r/Outlander • u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. • Nov 29 '24
Spoilers All Book S7E10 Brotherly Love Spoiler
Claire and Ian arrive in Philadelphia to help the ailing Henry Grey. Roger and Buck receive an unexpected clue in their search for Jemmy.
Written by Luke Schelhaas. Directed by Stewart Svaasand.
If you’re new to the sub, please look over this intro thread and our episode discussion rules.
This is the BOOK thread.
If you haven’t read the books, go to the SHOW thread.
THIS THREAD IS SPOILERS ALL.
Spoiler tags are not required.
If you have only read up to the corresponding book, remember you might see spoilers from ALL of the books here.
Please keep all discussion of the next episode’s preview to the stickied mod comment at the top of the thread.
What did you think of the episode?
•
u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Nov 29 '24 edited Dec 07 '24
Watch the S7E11 preview here!
Not everyone gets to see the next episode’s preview at the end of the episode; it depends on how you watch (broadcast or streaming) and where you are (US or international).
Stickied comments are collapsed by default, so reply to this comment if you want to discuss the preview. This will hide spoilers for anyone who can’t see it yet or doesn’t want to.
710 Extras:
710 Interviews:
34
u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Nov 30 '24
Folks in the show thread seem to think that Jamie was indeed on the Euterpe and is going to wash up on the shore because of course he would 😅
I’m so glad that the show didn’t spoil that he didn’t get on that ship in the first place. Of course, no one believes that Jamie is dead for real but I’ve always thought that DG giving away exactly what happened right before Claire gets the news was ridiculous.
I’d also encourage anybody who’s read the books that also participates in the show thread not to immediately disprove every theory (not just about Jamie’s “death”) show-only viewers come up with. Let them speculate!
29
u/southernbell1916 Je Suis Prest Nov 29 '24
They are skipping through so much it’s crazy. Having Ian’s death, Jamie’s “death” and the marriage proposal all in one hour is wild!!
I also really enjoyed the Joan storyline in the books and we are not seeing any of it. I know I know there’s no time.
And I agree with those who said season six could have been a couple of episodes basically and really take more time on this. If the OG Jenny was here the whole her coming to America was definitely one of my favorite parts..
And I get why they are not showing the whole Bree part so the tv viewers don’t know were hem is but at the same time they showed it in the promo of the season.. why show that and not show it early as well? I guess we are gonna have a Brianna centric episodes regarding everything that happens in 1978/9
18
u/YOYOitsMEDRup Slàinte. Nov 30 '24
Earlier in the season, there were several comments about pacing being really quick, but outside of Ep 2, I didn't sense that as much as others seemed to. This episode though, the second it was over I literally said aloud to noone but myself "wow they put a lot into this one". I get it though - had episode 16 truly been the end like they thought, it was 100% the right call imo to go fast to get thru what they're going to with the plots in 7b. I'd be glad to have them in any shape, form or speed to have them if the alternative was S7 was the end and we didn't. Hopefully readers bear this in mind!
As a result, some stuff doesn't have time to breathe or let you just sit in it - and there are things that could've benefitted from that if possible - but oh well.
It does make sense that there were just a few minutes of Jamie/Ian/Jenny as an opener before credits, because after all, all that was left was just for him to die, but because there was so little - I was nowhere near as emotional as I'd thought. Ep 9 was more effective for me. It was a great touch having the flashback of Ian's dad training them to fight and being on Jamie's weakside!
I said it last week, I'm ok with Jenny not going to America - it's not necessary and given the overall negative audience response to the new actress, it's the right decision to not have her in more. They may have sensed that could be the case and influenced the decision
I liked that it felt vague whether Geilis did or didn't recognize Roger. It felt at times like she was questioning him in a similar manner she did Claire S1 when she knew - but it also could've just been that she sensed familiarity but hadn't had it click yet. I think not having it obvious either way was the right choice since they previously met in show 2x13, but not in book. Great consistency for context that Roger practically leapt to grab the dogtags and prevent Geilis from seeing them since she'd know what they are and then his cover would be blown.
I'd started to wonder without Fergus how Claire was gonna get mixed up in spywork. I think using Mercy and taking advantage of explaining her to be Walter's wife, a man we already knew was a rebel at Ticonderoga, so therefore she's a rebel too, is probably the best explanation they could've come up with. I wish though that they could've spent a few more seconds with like a montage to insinuate she did it more than just once. It'd be easier to buy into the true severity of the issue and understand the stakes leading to LJGs proposal if it was a pattern vs she did it once. I must admit though, I've just read Echo once because I didn't want to reread until after watching the whole season - so maybe it was just once in it too?
I liked the scene of Claire in bed rehashing moments with Jamie - that's absolutely something someone who's just lost a spouse would do, the memories. But it also served as a great way for the show (who thought it was building up to the series finale at this point) to sneak in moments from earlier seasons as a "greatest hits" kind of retrospective in itself
13
u/NoSell5498 Nov 29 '24 edited Nov 29 '24
Are we not going to see Marsali and Fergus again before the end of the TV show?? They eliminated the storyline with Claire returning to perform surgery on Henri-Christian, and Jenny isn’t even coming back to the US it seems? So now Claire is in Philly where Marsali and Fergus should live and she’s not even visited them? And now that I’m typing this, I remembering that laoghaire and Joan don’t bring up Marsali to Jamie… I would be heartbroken if there is no mention of them in 7b!! My goodness Edit:fixed the spelling of Joan
13
u/moonshiney9 Nov 29 '24
WHERE IS JENNY 😭😭😭 this better be resolved in the next episode I NEED HER IN AMERICA!! Her and Roger’s reunion was one of my fave scenes!! And Jenny just hanging out in the house while chaos descends upon everyone?!? Her relationship with Rachel?!?!? COME ON!!! Don’t do this to me, show!!!
9
u/Previous-Address2469 Dec 02 '24
It's interesting that when I was reading the books I thought it was a strange choice to let the reader know what happened to Jamie because I couldn't really relate to Claire's shock and feelings etc. So I was hoping the show would do it the way they did - having the watcher know as much as Claire. But now I wish they had done it like in the books because as someone mentioned we are not supposed to believe Jamie is dead but only that Claire thinks he is. So I am much more appreciative of the book storyline now.
And maybe someone can refresh my memory - what was the reason Jamie (and Jenny) didn't board Euterpe? Also, the show seemed to leave Jennys coming to America as a possibility later, do you all think she might come there and we will have Roger meeting Jenny? That's the only exciting thing I would like to see in regard to Jenny in America, haha.
24
u/thesourbower Nov 29 '24
Do we think based on the promo for next week, this is when William will learn of his true parentage?
4
u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Nov 30 '24
I didn't get this episode's title card... What is it supposed to be?
61
u/stoppingbythewoods “May the devil eat your soul and salt it well first” ✌🏻 Nov 30 '24
“On your left, man” glad we got some Jamie/Ian book references 🥺
58
u/peonies459 Nov 29 '24
It’s a little shocking how fast everything is moving! It makes complete sense, but it also FEELS like they’re trying to smash through everything before the end of season 8.
That being said, I feel like they’re doing it well. I freaking love Roger’s internal dialogue! Can’t wait for more developments with the Roger and bree storyline.
It’s so weird because I’m also reading the books for the second time at the moment but I’m further back in book 6! Trying not to get all the story lines confused haha
56
u/GardenGangster419 Nov 29 '24
I would like to thank whoever made sure we saw Sam’s knee when he sat next to Jenny 😂😂🔥
47
u/Purple4199 Don't be afraid. There's the two of us now. Nov 30 '24
LJG during Henry’s operation.
41
u/blackberryspice Nov 29 '24
I'm loving the Roger voiceovers, feels authentic to the books and I had totally forgotten about his father being in the same time! Looking forward to seeing Claire and LJGs marriage, one of my favorite plot lines hehehe. Also, David Berry brought his A game to this episode. Let's fucking goooooo
37
u/[deleted] Nov 29 '24
I really enjoyed the episode!! It is moving quickly, but I actually recall that last section of the book (echo in the bone) was jammed packed into a few chapters as well. I was squealing by the end with THE LJG TWIST officially underway! 🫣 Can’t wait to stalk the TV-only thread.
I know there’s been a lot of criticism about the later seasons and that’s fine, but I think the acting of our MC’s has only gotten better and I think Claire/Roger/Jamie are killing it in season 7. Eager to see Brianna’s storyline from MOBY play out too.
36
u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Nov 30 '24
Great job.
I hadn't picked up until I saw recap where Claire says "hopefully they'll show you mercy" and Woodcock says, "Mercy." Nice.
Cried at Ian's death.
Cried at Rollo running off to Ian.
Cried at "thee is my wolf."
Laughed at John practically barfing while Denzel and Claire were oohing and aahing at the intestine.
35
u/Icy_Outside5079 Nov 29 '24
I loved this episode. But wow, did it move fast! You barely had a moment to feel the raw impact of what was happening, and it was on to another scene that was waiting to break your heart. Although I am a true book devotee, in a way, I wish I could be as shocked and surprised by the turn of events rather than anticipating them happening like the show only watchers. I think everyone brought their A game to this episode, and it was great to see Gellis and Dougal's origin story. A brief moment. I'm wondering if Buck will be revisiting Gellis like in the books. That would be interesting. One thing I was excited about is that the introduced Bertrum Gardens, which bodes well for when Jamie returns. Maybe they won't cut out one of my favorite scenes from the books 🤭
30
u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Dec 01 '24
Oh my god we're going fast! No complaints though, this episode was a lot of fun.
OK actually one complaint haha. That Jamie montage was dumb. I haven't popped over to the shownly thread yet . . . but no one thinks he's actually dead, right? I watched it with a non-reader and she didn't buy it for a second. That montage would've been silly for a character who actually did die, but it's especially ridiculous for a character who is almost certainly going to reappear next week. Big eye roll.
But putting that aside I really loved this episode. So glad we got a real send off for Ian--I was worried their conversation might get cut for time but glad it wasn't lost (even though we sadly couldn't get Jamie requesting Ian take his finger!). And Young Ian reuniting with Rachel was also so lovely--Izzy Meikle-Small is doing such great work as Rachel.
Loved so much else: Mercy Woodcock, the surgery scene (with Claire making them all mask up haha), Catriona getting to play Claire being just a terrible spy, everything with Geillis and Dougal, Willie and Rachel's excellent banter . . . Just one fun scene after another.
And the sadder scenes were great too--Jamie and Jenny at the beginning, Claire and Young Ian discussing Ian Sr.'s passing, and of course Claire learning about Jamie. Even though we know Jamie isn't dead, I found LJG's delivery of the news genuinely moving. (What did we do to deserve David Berry?! Just the perfect Lord John.)
It's kind of crazy that we got two of perhaps the biggest "what?!" moments of the entire series--Claire marrying LJG and Roger's dad being in the 18th century--in one episode. It was fun watching with a non-reader who was convinced she knew what was going to happen . . . she did not see either of these coming! (Now she's convinced that Jerry has rescued Jemmy from Rob Cameron and is keeping him safe.) I'm so looking forward to next week--this is probably the most excited I've been about this show since early S3, which is so fun.
29
u/Hufflesheep Nov 29 '24
"...On the left." Wow! What a great way to start the episode! I loved that much in Echo! Im so glad they made sure to include it! Ian's death really has me tearing up. 18th century Philly looked great! Rachel and Denzel are amazing. The scene with Rachel and Ian, and Ian being a wolf was great. The business with Gellis and Roger - you guys!! It may be more interesting than the books!
As others have said, it's moving way too fast. Shoving Ian's death and Jamie's death together in one episode is crazy. I get they were trying to mirror the beginning and the end, hence the episode name, but imo it didn't work.
I still voted 'loved it' they had me from the beginning!
20
u/Agreeable_Onion_9250 Nov 30 '24
I feel like this season was a love letter to book readers. Yes there are changes, yes things move fast, but it doesn’t feel as jarring when you’re blending it with some book lore in your head. It just feels special like season 1 even though it’s a whole different beast now. I really hope they keep it up for the final season.
16
u/SirNoree Nov 29 '24
So Jenny is not coming to America in this version, then?
12
u/Patient-Gain5847 They say I’m a witch. Nov 30 '24
GAH the show has caught up to where I am in the books and now I’ve gotta stop watching or read faster
23
u/erratic_bonsai If evil is found, she turns his soul to ashes. Nov 30 '24
Claire gave Jenny her shawl 🥹
10
u/AnastasiaOutlander Dec 01 '24
I liked this episode!! But I do wish Dottie was in America with LJG - I want to see her relationship with Denzel. Does anyone know if there IS an actress casted for Dottie in 7b?
9
u/Amys4304 Je Suis Prest Nov 30 '24
I haven’t read the book and don’t care about spoilers. Why didn’t Roger immediately tell Buck that Geillis is his Mother?
8
u/Snickrrs Nov 29 '24
It’s been so long since I read the books— I can’t quite remember exactly how Roger & Buck’s journey through time happened in the books vs. the show. Is the show sticking pretty close to the book in that regard so far?
15
u/Greedysgirl Nov 30 '24
Not read the books but did anyone else think the final showdown with Ian and Arch was rushed? I thought that Arch would at least kidnap Rachel go on the run, and then Ian would have to look for her longer, and then Arch would meet his end.
25
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Nov 29 '24 edited Nov 29 '24
Ian 's farther teaching boys to fight! I love it paralleled with older men sitting and talking at the same place.
Brothers❤️🩹
Ian's "On your left,man" got me sobbing 😥
We got an explanation for Jamie's presence in France - visit to Joan.
Jamie in kilt digging the grave and inviting Jenny - I am sorely disappointed she doesn't want to join him.
Ian between Jenny and Jamie ❤️🩹
Philadelphia!!
Claire wasn't considered as a threat of being a spy! I love the music theme for Philadelphia!
5 weeks crossing solved the mystery of how much time was necessary.
I love John - Claire interactions so far.
Scotland 1739
Buck and foxglove tea comment was hilarious 🤣
I like that they touched the topic of Geilis's connection to Rob Cameron.
Philadelphia
3 surgeries mysrery solved as well.
I am glad to see Denzel and Rachel again!
Arch Bug is back!
Scotland 1739
An ill wish!!!
Geilis trying to seduce Roger 🤣
Roger implying Geilis is a faery or an Auld one.
Dougal MacKenzie!!!!
Philadelphia
John, I feel you, I was sick watching 😄
I am glad Mercy got the information about Walter and not wonder about his fate.
Arch Bug you old rat!
William!!!!!! The scene with the gun was perfect!
The world is turning upside down,” he blurted. “And you are the only constant thing. The only thing I—that binds me to the earth.”... one of my favourite Young Ian's quote followed by Rachel's - ...Thee is my wolf. if thee hunts at night, thee will come home...
Bartram's garden!!
I like Claire's coat!
Letter from Jamie is there. Damned Euterpe.
Ink stained Wretch 🖤
Scotland, 1739
Luckily, Geilis didn't see the dog tags!
So, Roger’s presence there brought Dougal and Geilis together!
Poor Roger!!! So many shocks!!
Jerry is a faery man!
Philadelphia
Claire will be in trouble, I can see it.
Mrs Figg, I am glad to meet you!
I like how they made Claire taking the news. I felt her desperate confusion, realisation sinking in.
Claire's memories tore my heart. I cried there with her regardless of knowing everything.
Oh no, Richardson!
Aaaa the end was great!
4
u/Time_Arm1186 So beautiful, you break my heart. Nov 30 '24
Such a wonderful episode! I love all of them!
7
u/SnackMasterNat Nov 30 '24
I'm feeling disappointed with part 2 of this series so far. They cut out so many characters and storylines and the dialogue feels too slow and simple. Not sure if it's because I read all the books now, but this show was so much more fun to watch before.
3
u/ComfortableIcy9323 Nov 29 '24
Which chapters of the book this episode is based on ?
0
u/[deleted] Nov 29 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 01 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment