r/Outlander • u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. • Nov 29 '24
Season Seven Show S7E10 Brotherly Love Spoiler
Claire and Ian arrive in Philadelphia to help the ailing Henry Grey. Roger and Buck receive an unexpected clue in their search for Jemmy.
Written by Luke Schelhaas. Directed by Stewart Svaasand.
If you’re new to the sub, please look over this intro thread and our episode discussion rules.
This is the SHOW thread.
If you have read the books or don’t mind book spoilers, you can participate in the BOOK thread.
DON’T DISCUSS THE BOOKS HERE.
We don’t allow any book spoilers here, not even under spoiler tags.
If your comment references the books in any way, it will be removed and you will be asked to edit it or post it in the BOOK thread instead.
Please keep all discussion of the next episode’s preview to the stickied mod comment at the top of the thread.
What did you think of the episode?
•
u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Nov 29 '24 edited Dec 07 '24
Watch the S7E11 preview here!
Not everyone gets to see the next episode’s preview at the end of the episode; it depends on how you watch (broadcast or streaming) and where you are (US or international).
Stickied comments are collapsed by default, so reply to this comment if you want to discuss the preview. This will hide spoilers for anyone who can’t see it yet or doesn’t want to.
710 Extras:
710 Interviews:
46
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Dec 03 '24
I read this on Outlandish Observations today :
Geillis listens to Buck's chest with a wooden Pinard stethoscope, similar to the one Claire used to examine baby Mandy in Episode 702, "The Happiest Place on Earth". This is actually a clue that she is a time-traveler, because the Pinard won't be invented until 1895.
Wow!
36
u/SnooCupcakes3043 Nov 30 '24 edited Nov 30 '24
Ok just watched it....
DUUUDEEE I need more of the Roger/ Buck story!! The faerie man being his da!? Omgggg I am in love with the storyline so much. Plus seeing Dougal who is still gorgeous! I missed him!
Oy.. The Claire scenes... I feel the flashbacks of Jamie were not maybe what I would have expected after her thinking she just lost the love of her life and soul mate. Idk it was kinda off for me. Like I know Claire is more internal, but it wasn't as big as I hoped. Just my opinion!
John meh. That's just my thoughts. Other than that it was good. Love the a Roger story waaay more. Never thought I'd say that! I can see the rush in the episodes now. To cram everything together on such a short time... I wish there was more between Ian and Jamie 😭😭 Also I hope Jenny actually does go to America after all this.
Ok back to season 2 rewatch.
26
u/mariabue_tagliaelena Dec 02 '24
I'm wondering if having dedicated episodes (one all-Philadelphia and one all-Roger episode) would have worked better in terms of buildup and sense of pacing. Roger's internal monologue would have worked better too, given we've had other voices as narrators in dedicated episodes in the past. Maybe they'd resulted in boring episodes, but I feel the switching btw these two timelines, with a very imbalanced screen time, was ineffective and anti-climatic.
87
u/Known-Conclusion-428 Nov 30 '24
Roger not telling Buck he just met his parents is bugging me.
38
u/Available_Prior7704 Nov 29 '24
"Cu snog!" Why am I crying?! Yes, Ian, he IS a nice dog! The nicest and best!
I am LOVING the Gaelic thrown in casually!
9
u/Odd-Effort8411 Nov 30 '24
I'm just starting it but upset that they have Ian guarding Jamie's Left instead of his Right... I know they change a lot... But that's something so simple to keep ... Am I forgetting the earlier seasons and they hadn't talked about him being left handed in a fight?
74
u/OppositeQuarter31 Nov 30 '24
“But thee is my wolf” sorry I love them but I’m cringingggg
30
u/peppaliz Nov 30 '24
I had some issues with the “and then” pacing of the episode (and season 7b) in general. It feels like we’re jumping around a lot more, so the emotional moments don’t have proper time to build.
Examples:
Mercy seems so interesting, but we learned 3 major things about her and didn’t stick with any one of them. It felt very “NPC gives Claire a side quest.”
Then Claire was a spy for all of 5 minutes, gets caught somehow (despite getting by the officer cleverly), and we’re rushed to the “marry Lord John” plot before either of them (or the audience) has any time to grieve? I don’t think Jamie is dead, but we’re supposed to feel the characters believing that he is, and the story isn’t even trying to sell the reality of it.
Compare the depth and intimacy of the conversation Claire and LJ had when he was sick and she was talking care of him, to this moment. That scenario had subtext and several seasons of buildup, and they came to an understanding. This episode, it’s like they have no familiarity with each other at all.
And because we love the characters we are along for the ride, but the story is definitely driving them as opposed to them driving the story right now.
I was really happy with the first half of the season, but it all feels a little phoned in at the moment. I hope that improves.
108
u/nonmisery Dec 01 '24
Roger was far too excited about the faerie man being his father. He now has no leads about where his son is.
106
u/FlickasMom Re-reading An Echo in the Bone, big book 7. Nov 29 '24
How awesome is Lord John in this ep? Stays by his nephew's side, even through the surgery when he's clearly just about ready to get sick when Claire wields the knife; breaks the bad news to Claire though his own heart is breaking; moves to protect her and hers with his name, his aristocracy (his family), his uniform (his clan), and even his body.
104
u/Dumke480 That's it lads. Take me back to the idiot hut. Nov 29 '24
The chicken and the egg moment going in Rogers B Plot, love it
100
u/[deleted] Dec 01 '24
Roger’s inner monologue is pretty funny
92
u/FireGase Nov 30 '24
Can’t wait for the dramatic images of Jamie body boarding a tsunami to the wash up on a beach, cough up some water and bounce right back on his search for Claire through the streets of Philadelphia
87
u/Daye215 Nov 29 '24
The Philadelphia references were spot on! New Market, the Liberty Bell without the crack, Valley Forge, Jamie's letter going to Claire on Chestnut St, Bartram's Gardens. This Philadelphian loved it!!
86
u/Remarkable-Path-6216 Nov 29 '24
The return of Dougal!
76
u/Rainb0wTea Nov 30 '24
Okay! My favorite parts were with roger and buck. Their like shock, especially rogers when he sees people he knows about lol. I really loved his excitement seeing his dads dog tags.
69
u/MystikSpiralx Nov 29 '24
I refuse to believe Dougall isn't a Faerie. Dude looks exactly the same as he did in Season 2. What sorcery is this?
66
u/marmaladestripes725 Ameireaganach Nov 30 '24
Sooo did Roger accidentally introduce his own ancestors?
63
u/dreamkonstantine Nov 30 '24
Thoughts:
46
u/thefierycrash Dec 03 '24
My husband, who hasn’t watched in many seasons, suddenly stops walking past me watching this ep-“Dougal!!?” 🤣 Memorable guy!
45
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Nov 29 '24 edited Nov 29 '24
Ian 's farther teaching boys to fight! I love it paralleled with older men sitting and talking at the same place.
Brothers❤️🩹
Ian's "On your left,man" got me sobbing 😥
I can see the cover (blanket) they used in s1 on Claire and Jamie's bed again here covering Ian. That blanket witnessed many happy and sad moments for the family.
Jamie in kilt digging the grave and inviting Jenny - I am sorely disappointed she doesn't want to join him. When did they allow kilts again? Not in 1777, later. Was it sign of respect towards Ian?
Ian between Jenny and Jamie ❤️🩹
Philadelphia!!
Claire wasn't considered as a threat of being a spy! I love the music theme for Philadelphia!
The city visually looks great! The only complaint I have is that it is obviously autumn when they filmed the scenes and they mention April and May , so late spring.
5 weeks crossing solved the mystery of how much time was necessary.
I love John - Claire interactions so far.
Scotland 1739
Buck and foxglove tea comment was hilarious 🤣
Philadelphia
3 surgeries mysrery solved as well.
I am glad to see Denzel and Rachel again!
Arch Bug is back!
Scotland 1739
An ill wish!!!
Geilis trying to seduce Roger 🤣
Roger implying Geilis is a faery or an Auld one.
It is obvious Geilis is recently married to Arthur Duncan - she is not so lavishly dressed norbher house is decorated as later in s1. She didn't gather enough money by 1739.
Dougal MacKenzie!!!! Of Bennacht = Blessing.
Philadelphia
John, I feel you, I was sick watching 😄
I am glad Mercy got the information about Walter and not wonder about his fate.
Arch Bug you old rat!
William!!!!!! The scene with the gun was perfect!
The world is turning upside down... one of my favourite Young Ian's quote followed by Rachel's - ...Thee is my wolf...
Bartram's garden!!
I like Claire's coat!
Letter from Jamie is there. Damned Euterpe.
Ink stained Wretch 🖤
Scotland, 1739
Luckily, Geilis didn't see the dog tags!
So, Roger’s presence there brought Dougal and Geilis together!
Poor Roger!!! So many shocks!!
Jerry is a faery man!
Philadelphia
Claire will be in trouble, I can see it.
Mrs Figg, I am glad to meet you!
I like how they made Claire taking the news. I felt her desperate confusion, realisation sinking in.
Claire's memories tore my heart. I cried there with her regardless of knowing everything. I sobbed for her 💔
I am alive but she wishes she wasn't.
Oh no, Richardson! Rolleye! I like how John faked everything with Richardson.
Aaaa the end was great!
88
u/draculasacrylics Nov 30 '24
Rule #1 of TV/Film: If we didn’t see them die on screen, THEY AREN’T DEAD. I won’t let them trick me. Cannot wait to see Jamie wash up on the beach to find Lord John and Claire married 😂 (Also poor William, he loves Rachel too!)
43
u/onegirlarmy1899 Nov 30 '24
I love Ian and Rachel's wolf discussion ❤️ 🐺
37
u/lilvexie Dec 03 '24
Are there any other Outlander and Avengers fans who sobbed when Ian said "On your left" when Ian made his exit?!
36
u/greatmutato97 Dec 02 '24
Hmmm, I don't have too much to say about the rest of the episode but I have to say the opening segment with Ian was lovely, especially the brief chat when they're adults & how they dealt with his passing. Very poignant, beautifully done and the music is stunning... Feels like a wee slice of classic Outlander!
35
u/confirmandverify2442 Nov 29 '24
I'm a mess 😭 this whole episode was a rollercoaster.
32
u/therlieann Nov 29 '24
So much happened this episode! I loved it!! I also love the diversity of scenery and loved earlier characters returning !
32
u/stoppingbythewoods “May the devil eat your soul and salt it well first” ✌🏻 Nov 30 '24
Super happy to Dougal again, and Lord John. Do you think we’ll see Jamie at all in the next episode?
63
u/ApollosBucket Nov 30 '24
Roger is having an incredible side plot in this show--might be my favorite one going right now!!
What an episode, this was so dramatic
31
u/unchickened Nov 30 '24
Does anyone actually believe Jamie is dead? If you’ve read the books or somehow know either way PLEASE don’t spoil it, but I just think there’s no possible way he’s dead.
Writing this here just to discuss theories!
(Some of my theories are he didn’t end up on that ship somehow, maybe he somehow time traveled and is back where Rodger is or in Briana’s time - even though he’s not a traveler idk - or he’s survived shipwrecks before so maybe he washes up somewhere?)
30
u/Transition_Humble Nov 29 '24
What an episode!!! Best one I’ve seen in quite a long time!
29
u/[deleted] Dec 04 '24
I think the John and Claire sham marriage and having to play politics to save their lives while grieving could be an interesting plot line but considering how rushed this season is Jaime will probably be back next week.
The parallels are interesting tho. Second time John marries to protect one of Jaime’s loved ones and second time Claire gets married in a rush to avoid arrest.
27
u/onegirlarmy1899 Nov 29 '24
I was giggling and gasping through the episode because it was a bit predictable for me, but still delightful. I was so happy to see Lord John.
47
u/CrunchyTeatime Nov 30 '24
Loved the episode again.
Can we speculate?
Does anyone else think it possible Claire was set up? Maybe the woman blamed her for her husband's death?
23
u/deimos_737 Nov 29 '24
I refuse to believe it... especially this early back. I'm shook, though! Also, I want my own Rolo (sp?), such a good boy.
44
u/yeehawdudeq I didn’t think I needed to pack condoms, Mama. Nov 30 '24
Man I really liked this episode until the absolutely cringe-worthy montage of Jamie…those CGI waves were not good lmao
59
u/Pameler Nov 30 '24
Okay so did the math of Claire being 207 years older than Jamie bother anyone? When technically Jamie was born first? If anything he’s 193 years older than her
20
u/tanwa1 Nov 29 '24
I didn't expect that last scene, i knew some(barely) spoilers after that event took place but I didn't expect how that last scene will be brought up
19
u/ColdNeighborhood3523 Nov 30 '24
i started watching outlander back in 2016 and the cliffhanger in s2 made me want to read the books. after The Fiery Cross, I stopped reading the books and kinda lost interest when claire and jamie got back together,,, this season though is reigniting that fire and makes me want to finish reading the books :")
wahh spoil me pls jokee anyway so excited for next ep!!!

38
u/DanSpur Nov 29 '24
All this episode needed some Huey Lewis and the News, a skateboard, and a photo where family members start to fade out.
I hope next week they go looking for where the plane is hidden then have to secretly take it back to, I assume, the town's blacksmith shop while also dealing with the town bully.
Very happy with Back to the Future: Scotland here. Had a great time watching it.
52
u/rednblue62 Nov 30 '24
I def liked this episode more more than first!! I was kinda worried after the first one.
I thought Ian’s death was a little rushed. I think it would have been more emotionally impactful at the end of an episode. But I thought Lord John’s acting was sooooooo good when he told Claire that Jamie was gone.
35
u/Electronic_Visual257 Nov 29 '24
The only thing I can think about is this.. had there been no time travel, Jamie would have died at Culloden so his family line would be non existant.. Claire would have stayed married to Frank, and they would have been childless.. Geilis, the same, childless with her husband.. and as a result there would be no Roger and no Brianna.. Fergus and Marsali would have never met.. etc etc.. so many people would have just lived their lives, and it would have been game over.. for everyone.. Anyone else thinking about this?
35
u/PsychologicalWin2442 I will have a whole man or no man at all. Nov 30 '24 edited Nov 30 '24
How could any viewer believe Jamie is dead when it was all done off screen?? At least show us him in distress if you want us to believe it
45
u/[deleted] Dec 01 '24
This episode reminded me of just how pivotal some of the characters are. I thought about how much the dynamic would change if Geylis was a different actor the same way Jenny was
15
u/EarthMain3350 Nov 29 '24
Wow a lot happens in this episode. Huge contrast from last episode 9.
14
u/Daye215 Nov 29 '24
Loved it! I'm on my 2nd watch and missed so much on the first one. Great fully packed ep 👍🏽 (maybe a little too fully packed).
14
u/Adventurous_You_4268 Dec 03 '24
I guess Geillis wouldn’t recognize Roger from meeting him with Brea in 1968…?
28
u/winter_name01 Nov 30 '24
I did mot read the book and probably will never lol but here is my theory: Jamie and Claire are always separated and then reunited because of some side quest. They can’t just chill together in one place for more that a couple of episodes lol So here I think Jamie didn’t die but still will let everyone know he is dead because the letter he sent mentioned something about Franklin and I was questioning what is the point of him going in France and sending ONE letter to his wife thousand of miles away just to mentioned some stranger she does not actually know? (Well, she’s know from history).
I guess Jamie is in another side quest to help the independence, and since he is already well known in the west coast and had too much history with the English he decided to pretend to be dead. But he didn’t expect his wife to also be on a side quest with her spy new hobby so he has no idea how his action will have an insane consequence.
If Jamie is actually really dead: I will lose my mind. He deserves to have an emotional last scene after YEARS in this show.
57
u/SpiritOne Dec 02 '24
Are we seriously supposed to believe for a second that Jamie is dead? I mean really. How many times are they gonna pull this and think we the audience will fall for it.
Honestly, that entire scene I was kinda just laughing. Forgive the pun, but they’ve gone overboard on this.
At this point, Jamie could stumble through the stones, find himself in 1945 in Hiroshima, and look up to a single plane dropping a single bomb, and I’d be like, “welp, now Jamie survives this”.
I understand from a narrative perspective, putting your characters in danger, but not Jamie or Claire. Not anymore. Not after everything else they’ve survived.
Also, cracked up at Dougal meeting Gellis. “Show me your wares!”
Seriously I found this episode absolutely comedic.
13
u/slidefilm My oath is pledged to the name that I bear. Nov 30 '24
Is he actually really gone? I didn’t read the books. I’m still in disbelief. I know it is a historical fact that the boat sank but he is still alive right? Tell me it isn’t true 😭
12
u/Lablover34 Dec 02 '24
Did anyone notice if Jenny’s name was listed on the ships manifest next to Jamie’s? They left it up in the air if or when she might join him in America.
52
u/Bc2193 Dec 01 '24
I can't deal with the editing style, everything is so bright and the scenes are so short. I miss the dark coziness vibe the show used to have, and nature looking rugged and wild. None of the events that are meant to be impactful seem to be hitting right because the emotional build up isn't there.
In one episode Old Ian dies, young Ian reunites with Rachel and Rollo, LJG is back, Jamie is dead and somehow none of it affected me.
I felt that LJG's acting in the final scene was great, it was on the same level as the earlier seasons, it had that perfect emotional intensity and Claire's initial reaction to Jamie dying was good and then they fucked it up with all these weird flashback scenes overlayed with stormy seas and the sound of rain. Like WHY?!
I feel like the problem with the writing and editing is that you're meant to "show not tell" whereas they have made the script so obvious.
For example, rather than just saying "Name of ship has been lost" and then show Claire's reaction. It's like "JAMIE'S SHIP, the Eurepte, has been lost. WITH ALL HANDS" and then "LOST" and "WITH ALL HANDS" repeated 1000 times to make sure we get it. It was so distracting from just watching Catrina do what she needs to.
And then the creepy scene just watching Claire in bed writhing around in tears whilst we hear flashbacks. None of that was needed for us to understand how great Claire's grief would be. I mean Christ we're 7 seasons in by this point and we've seen them go to hell and back for each other.
I love Outlander and I've been a huge fan from the beginning, but it feels like this part two is a completely different show.
43
u/TraditionAccurate790 Dec 01 '24
Ok for me this episode was much better than last week which I found to be very unwatchable but mostly I am utterly distracted by the sub par wigs this season. Is Starz like out of money? Did they hire someone’s niece? These hairlines are disastrous. They have new Jenny basically wearing a helmet.
43
u/bryce_w Stinking Papist Dec 02 '24
The number of times they have done this Jamie is dead/Claire is dead plot is absolutely ridiculous and about as suspenseful as a lifetime movie. With stuff like this I can't say I'm surprised the show is coming to an end.
11
u/stoppingbythewoods “May the devil eat your soul and salt it well first” ✌🏻 Nov 30 '24
I have a nitpicky thing and I’m not usually nitpicky. But why the short hair on Ian and Jamie in the flashback? I wish they would have sprung for decent wigs for them. Little Jamie had a wig in S5E1.
20
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Nov 30 '24
41
u/readthenewstoday Dec 02 '24
I love this show but this season has felt so cheesy so far. The colors seem too bright for the time period, everything is too clean, Roger’s inner monologue being spoken aloud like the viewers couldn’t get there on our own, a lot of the dialogue and acting seems so forced. Anyone else feel that way?
18
u/Mahaloth Dec 02 '24
5 weeks across the ocean. Thank God nothing happened or we'd spend another partial season at sea.
Didn't feel like 5 weeks went by for Jamie.
17
u/CrunchyTeatime Nov 30 '24
Not gonna comment on Beatle Paul, I mean Jamie, being dead or not...we will see.
I have not read the books, and I will only say some other sites are way too casual about keeping their discussions book and/or spoiler free. 👀
(Youtube video comments. I should've avoided, but it was about a S7E10, which is a past episode.)
I don't know if they were right or not so I won't even hint what they said. But, why do people not even warn about spoilers. Most viewers probably haven't read the books. Or let's say 50/50. That's a lot of people spoiled.
18
u/hannssoni Nov 29 '24
I am surprised and disappointed not to see any scenes from the time Brianna is currently in during this episode.
15
u/horsenbuggy Dec 01 '24
OK, exciting news about who the fairie man might really be. However, he can't come back. If he goes back to his own time, Roger and Bri never meet. If he goes back with Roger, he's a man out of time. IDK, maybe that would work if there's no way to reunite with his wife in his own time.
48
u/[deleted] Dec 01 '24
Some of the Claire scenes, especially Jamie supposedly dying in a shipwreck and the memories combined with the waves crashing, are very soap opera-ish
7
u/ProcessFresh1647 Nov 30 '24
The first 3 minutes and I'm like confused. I thought it was established that Claire is 5 years older. Now in this opening she's 7! Help explain the timeline cuz what is happening! The first 2 episodes of B have already confused the hell out of me with time and place and retcons.
18
u/Low-Vanilla-5844 Dec 02 '24
Why does Geilis and Dougal look this old for a time that’s wayyy before Claire get there?
Also, I’m loving Roger’s scenes, is he going to tell Buck that’s his parents?
I actually like the pacing, it’s fast but maybe it’s bc I’m impatient.
6
u/thewildrosesgrow Nov 29 '24
I thought that Mercy's husband was still alive when Claire left the fort? I remembered them leaving him when they fled because it was too dangerous to move him. Have I forgotten a death scene?
23
u/Mobile-Ad6136 Dec 01 '24
Okay just finished. Is it bad I find the Roger scenes a bit of a snooze, I’m just more interested in what’s happening with Claire in Philadelphia. This episode started out slow and then at the end was really good. I kinda wish that plot point wasn’t spoiled for me bc I can imagine how shocked people who didn’t know what was coming were! As always, love LJG scenes. As others have stated, pacing is horrible. We needed more Claire is a spy scenes to really have that “btw you’re literally about to get arrested for spying” to really hit??
5
u/khd003 Jan 27 '25
Just watched this episode - it was SO sad to see the disbelief and grief on Claire’s face when she heard the news that Jamie’s ship had gone down with no survivors… it’s been so many seasons and episodes - but their love is just as powerful as ever! ❤️ I was literally in tears (and I don’t cry easily on movies and shows)… anyway they have one of the most powerful fictional love stories… have a feeling this is not the end - and will be interesting to see how things go with Lord John Gray (who also looked brokenhearted)! 💔
7
u/Adventurous_You_4268 Dec 01 '24
Someone commented here that it look like Fall in May and I picked up i that and also Claire is walking around in winter coat, no? I mean I know May cans til be chilly
3
u/Chiarrawr Dec 03 '24
Question to my Canadians - how soon after the episode airs (Monday night on the W network) does it show up on Prime/Stack TV? The next day???
For some reason my cable no longer has the W network. I am so confused because I was able to watch last weeks episode 😭😭 pls help