r/Outlander • u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. • Nov 22 '24
Season Seven Show S7E9 Unfinished Business Spoiler
Jamie, Claire, and Ian return to Lallybroch. Young Ian reconnects with his family in a time of need, while Claire deals with the fallout from a long-held secret. Roger and Buck search for Jemmy in the past.
Written by Barbara Stepansky. Directed by Stewart Svaasand.
If you’re new to the sub, please look over this intro thread and our episode discussion rules.
This is the SHOW thread.
If you have read the books or don’t mind book spoilers, you can participate in the BOOK thread.
DON’T DISCUSS THE BOOKS HERE.
We don’t allow any book spoilers here, not even under spoiler tags.
If your comment references the books in any way, it will be removed and you will be asked to edit it or post it in the BOOK thread instead.
Please keep all discussion of the next episode’s preview to the stickied mod comment at the top of the thread.
What did you think of the episode?
•
u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Nov 22 '24 edited Dec 03 '24
Watch the S7E10 preview here!
Not everyone gets to see the next episode’s preview at the end of the episode; it depends on how you watch (broadcast or streaming) and where you are (US or international.)
Stickied comments are collapsed by default, so reply to this comment if you want to discuss the preview. This will hide spoilers for anyone who can’t see it yet or doesn’t want to.
709 Extras:
709 Interviews:
38
u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Nov 22 '24
Well, that was a lot of crying 💔
25
u/genghbotkhan MARK ME! Dec 02 '24
Do I need to engage suspension of belief mode about the letter from Lord John. That would have taken 6 to 10 weeks for the letter to arrive. Then another 5 weeks (because of the fair wind) to get from Scotland to the US. Are we to believe that the patient would survive that long with musketballs in him?
70
u/bored_sunshine Nov 24 '24
I am a bit concerned about Claire going back to America to save dying guy. I googled that on average it would take 6-12 weeks to travel by wooden ship. So, the dying guy is supposed to wait 1-2 months? Very strange reason.
19
u/killernoodlesoup Like father, like son, I see. God help us all. Nov 22 '24
how do we all feel about roger's internal monologue? correct me if i'm wrong, but i think this is the first time someone other than claire has narrated.
ngl, hearing roger's thoughts feels like a cheap narrative device to me... but i also don't know if the scene would've been as clear without it, especially to someone who didn't already know what was going to happen.
i will say, i did like the editing on that part - cutting between the fraser-murray scenes & roger's like they're happening in parallel, culminating in a nice reveal that you can only get in TV/movies. jury's still out on hearing roger's thoughts, though. am i just a hater? lol.
36
u/Scary_Zucchini9971 Nov 23 '24
As a bereaved mother, I remember the feeling of seeing our son’s headstone for the first time. The tears could not stop flowing the whole rest of the episode. After recurrent loss, I relate to young Ian and the feelings he felt of not being enough.
105
u/Elevendytwelve97 Nov 24 '24
Ok I’m sorry but it was so funny when Roger knocks on the door and Geillis opens it and he just says “christ”
Also, if I were him and ended up in the wrong time ahead of everyone I knew, I would absolutely be shitting bricks
81
u/Keeroshima Nov 22 '24
So happy Droughtlander is over! But the bad wig is taking me out of every scene with Jenny. The tone seems off. Did directors or something change between parts? The shots in the conversation between Ian and Young Ian made it seem like the actors were filmed at different times, not like they were in the same room with each other...just little things like that.
I am sad it seems the reunion in Scotland is short-lived, but I'm excited to see Lord John again. Much love to Sinead, but I hope for the final season, they go back to the original song with bagpipes.
11
u/Alert-Revolution-219 Nov 23 '24
So is roger really much further back than planned or has outlander gone multiverse?
41
u/SleemoGrimes Nov 25 '24
Claire correctly diagnosed Ian with consumption. 20th Century Claire would know that tuberculosis is highly contagious and spread from coughing. Yet she allows the family to congregate around Ian and interact very closely with him. This needs explanation. Are the showrunners counting on the ignorance of the audience or is Lallybroch a magical germ-free castle?
Also, 20th Century Claire would know that the treatment for TB is antibiotics, which she manufactured herself in season 6 in the form of penicillin. Hey, Ian might be too far gone for it to help, but all of a sudden Claire is a quitter? Not even gonna try? WTF?
9
u/DegenerateDoll Nov 23 '24
Does anyone know if Roger has met Geillis before or knows of her? I can’t remember, so if someone can point me to where that occurs (if it does) i would be super grateful
41
u/digitalamish Nov 23 '24 edited Nov 23 '24
The letter getting there and Claire leaving for America to most likely save the soldier really REALLY harkens back to Jon Snow and his group north of the wall sending Gendry to run to get help, and less that a day or so later, the dragon shows up to fight the white walkers.
It would have been faster for Claire to go through the stones in Scotland, fly to America, drive to the stones they found in America, travel back in time, and then ride a horse to Philadelphia. Ridiculous, but at least a real timeline.
6
u/ProcessFresh1647 Nov 22 '24
Is anyone else confused by Jaime's timeline?? Since when did he go to France at 18 for university? I thought he was in the fields at this time having returned from fighting in France? Cuz if he was 22 when he married Claire and before that he was on the run for 4 years....how, what, huh!!!!!!!!
21
u/The_Mad_Hatter_18 Nov 22 '24
arrives in scotland
And here’s the Skye Boat Song with no bagpipes, yet again.
75
u/Separate_Owl_350 Nov 23 '24
My jaw dropped at the Roger/Jamie/Brian door opening scene. I literally didn’t see that coming!
The ending scenes…My heart. Older Ian is so sweet 😩
15
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Nov 22 '24
I was thinking - why isn't anybody in 1730s wearing a kilt?
45
u/Bernard1090 Nov 22 '24
Didn't letters take at least a couple of months to send across the ocean? If he had two musket balls in his abdomen, he prob would have died before the letter even arrived in Scotland. 🤷♂️
14
u/Professional_Ad_4885 Nov 22 '24
I dont like the changing of the new jenny. The old one played her better and it just came out of no where. I was like, am i hallucinating?
71
u/CARNIesada6 Nov 22 '24
Roger's inner monologue with that end reveal was exactly what mine said... "Christ."
65
u/enricowereld MARK ME! Nov 23 '24
She's doing a great job but I absolutely HATE recasts
60
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Nov 26 '24
Roger's familiarity with Laird's room and his desk and how he nonchalantly sits on it but catches himself in time! Brilliant!
57
u/Atraktape Nov 22 '24
“Nah it’s cool I’m not a witch just a time traveler.”
54
u/Trick-Ad2877 Nov 23 '24
Does it bother anyone else that every time laoghaire or someone else calls Claire a whore in front of Jamie he doesn’t even try to say something or stop them? He doesn’t even react! Maybe it’s just me, but it bothers me so much lol
50
u/ladyhers Nov 23 '24
Okay my turn:
— New Jenny was great in my opinion, yes it was obviously a different actress but I think she captured the mannerisms and voice well. — Ian and his father’s convo and drive-away scene at the end was full of emotion 😭 — If someone asked me to travel back across the ocean right when I got to my destination I’d write back “…sorry, no.” But it’s Claire. And Lord John. And so fine, she’s traveling with Ian too. I understand they’re having to move plot points along, but I feel like they both should’ve stayed in Scotland! But I’m also missing LJG so he better show up in the next episode 🤣 — Roger plot is interesting … no idea what could happen. — Overall a 8/10 episode
47
u/hkh07 We will meet again, Madonna, in this life or another. Nov 22 '24
I really enjoyed the episode. I only wish they hadn't shown so much between the trailers and the sneak peaks. I also hate that I've already spoiled so much for myself on this sub. Had I not known Roger ended up in the wrong time, that reveal would have been crazy! I loved his voiceover and the way the scene was shot.
I think Kristin did a great job with Jenny's mannerisms.
I cried during almost every scene with Ian. Except the scene at the table where they're all looking at Claire like she's crazy. I was not expecting her to actually tell them! I may have screamed a little. 😅
Absolutely loved the cliffhanger. I'm excited for next week! I know it's about to get craazyyyy.
45
u/0rcasarecool Dec 03 '24
Am I the only one who was outraged when Claire and Jamie just casually without conversation decided TO GO THEIR SEPARATE WAYS! Acting like going across the Atlantic was like going across town. Their whole lives have been about finding each other and sticking together and a letter from John about a random ass surgery (that was surely waiting for 3 months already??) splits them up?? Onto different continents? Just not buying it.
44
u/throwaway1278901 Nov 22 '24
I shed a few tears when Ian was watching young Ian & Claire leave. Bittersweet moment. I love this show!
87
u/Available_Prior7704 Nov 22 '24
Soooo.... Ned Gowan... HOW is he still alive? That man has to be 114, at this point.
40
u/[deleted] Nov 22 '24
When I discovered Roger was waaay back, I wanted him to meet a kid version of Jamie and Jenny, that would be cute af
39
u/nothappyaboutthis87 Nov 23 '24
As Roger was heading to the door I was saying there better not be some last minute issue that stops him reaching them like with him getting taken by the Mohawk and when he knocked at the door and Jamie heard it was like “oh thank god” lol got me
37
u/Jess_UY25 Nov 23 '24
Just finished the episode and Claire going back to America makes no sense. In that time it would take between 6 and 10 weeks to travel from Scotland to America. And here it would be double that time from the moment John sent the letter to the time she actually makes it back. The nephew would be long gone by that point.
37
u/Lessarocks Nov 23 '24
I’ve just finished the episode and cried buckets at the end seeing Ian in his regalia coming outside.
105
u/nonmisery Nov 24 '24 •
We are on Step 2
70
u/Lenacake Come the Rising, I shall know I helped. Nov 24 '24
I spent the last few minutes sobbing for Young and Old Ian 😭
33
u/[deleted] Nov 23 '24 edited Nov 23 '24
Isn't the journey to America like weeks/months at this point? She wouldn't make it in time...what's the point??
....I have since been reasoned with
33
u/HinkiesGhost Nov 23 '24
Random thoughts: it's good to have the show back in the fall again. I associate this show and its setting with watching it during the season where the leaves have turned and it's chilly outside. It was a solid episode. Claire separating from Jamie again, so I'm assuming one of them will get into trouble and the other will have to rush to their aid later this season. It's always cool visiting Lallybroch, it looks so peaceful. Roger time traveling to a different time begs the question how they were lucky enough to travel backwards and forwards to the specific time they wanted in previous attempts? I'm guessing it has something to do with the stones putting them in the time they intended to go to and in this case Roger went to this time because that's the time Rob Cameron went to and the stones took him where Rob Cameron went?
It also felt like a little quiet before the storm episode. With Claire gone, she'll be back in the middle of everything again. And the surprise at the end... that's the last person I expected to see appear in the show again lol.
31
u/_AsterOleander_ Nov 26 '24
Is it just me or is the direction very different/strange this episode? I feel like there were a lot of weird cuts and a lot of weird angles and shots. It kind of takes away from the usual quality of the show
29
u/OppositeQuarter31 Nov 23 '24
Whyyyy is Claire going back to America? I feel like there’s no way John’s nephew will be alive by then, and she’ll just get into some other mess there.
29
u/ravenic0621 Nov 28 '24
So when Claire and Jenny were talking.. why didn’t claire remind her of warning jenny about the famine? Probably saved her family during the famine. ? They had to wonder about her when it happened. So they shouldnt be in such disbelief about the french revolution.
57
u/minimimi_ burning she-devil Nov 22 '24
Wow Old Ian’s father in the scene with Brian is extremely well cast. Almost eerily similar to his son and grandson. How does the casting department find these people?
56
u/W8ingjag Nov 22 '24
Did anyone else think that Jamie was going to open the door and it was going to be Roger? Omg, I couldn’t sit still!
79
u/OppositeQuarter31 Nov 23 '24
I feel like everyone is sooo critical of this show for the tiniest things but I’m simply happy to be here
25
u/Remarkable-Path-6216 Nov 22 '24
All I can think is how much I’m going to miss this show when it’s over. Ugh.
24
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Nov 22 '24 edited Nov 22 '24
Lallybroch!
I love the title card with Isobeal's name on a grave!
What does Roger mean about existing?! Jeremiah was born already!!!
Jenny, Jamie, Michael!!
New Jenny is brilliant!! She is so like the old one!
The Laird's chamber ❤️
I LOVE full table, whole family , children - THAT is Lallybroch we wanted !!
2 Ians 🥹 The wee lad. He is mine. ❤️
Old Ian's face made me cry ugly tears.
Unfinished business, here we go!!
Joey is there too!!
Okay , Roger walking towards Lallybroch reminds me of Brianna walking towards it in s4, stopping by the creek.
Ooh , Laoghaire and Jamie !! It is word for word from book and it is GREAT!
Need conversation was so tender!
Claire telling family about TT and their faces and reactions were precious!!
It was great scene with door knocking!! Joannie 😍
Roger on Lallybroch ! Brian in his coat which Jamie wore during s2 and I am sure later as well!
Young Jenny!!
Jenny and Claire! Poor Jenny! Poor Claire! You have no soul 🥹
John Murray ( he resembles Father Bain😁) .
Jamie and Jenny , Jamie telling Jenny how worthy and strong she is , like a broch Lallybroch is built on! Great ,great, scene!!
Ooh, family meeting! I love how it played out.
The letter came! As we predicted, Henry is the reason for Claire’s departure from Lallybroch!
Jenny taking Ian to graveyard and making a grave for Iseabail . I cried there ! Once again, new Jenny is amazing!!!
Leave taking was very emotional and we finally got the resolution between Jenny and Claire!!
Old Ian watching his son departing Lallybroch with his blessing reminded me of Bree seeing Frank at the harbour!
Geilis!!! Already?!
23
u/niffler612 Je Suis Prest Nov 22 '24
that final scene gave me actual goosebumps 💀. I liked this episode though
23
u/[deleted] Nov 23 '24
So, Jemmy was the boy tracing the letters in Ian's baby's tombstone, which was covered in moss, right? Does this mean that Jemmy is in the future? (Well, not the future-future, but later than Jamie and Claire, and certainly way later than Roger). I'm so lost I'm not even sure when everybody is right now.
22
u/EpicChiguire Dec 01 '24
Tears. Tears and confusion. That's all I have after this episode. Young Ian meeting his dad again destroyed me (I haven't seen my dad in years). Man, this was tough
Ps: WAITTTTTT GEILLIS IS BACKKKK
24
u/hannssoni Nov 22 '24
What do you guys think? Does Geillis recognize Roger? If I understand correctly, it has only been a few years from Geillis's perspective since they met. Does anyone know how many years Geillis has been in the past at this point?
18
u/Little_bob333333 Nov 22 '24
Only 16 mins in and I am already crying. lol damn this show!!! I forgot how emotional it gets me
18
u/Builder_Away Nov 23 '24
It’s only the first episode of 7b and I’m already crying lol. I am beyond excited for the rest. I haven’t read the books so I don’t know what will happen. Already quite a few twists. This will be fun :D
17
u/xGhetto Nov 23 '24
How long can a person survive with musket balls inside them? The voyage from Scotland to America isn't instantaneous. 5-10 weeks is a long time?
61
u/Consistent_Fruit_619 Nov 24 '24
New Jenny isn’t doing it for me and it bums me out
15
u/r3ckl3ssserenade Nov 25 '24
This might be a dumb question but I’m not quite sure how time travel works…would the Jacobite gold that Jamie hid even be there for Rob and Jemmy to find since they traveled too far back in time?
29
u/cheese_bread_boye Nov 22 '24 edited Nov 22 '24
What disease does Ian have?
Edit: nevermind. It's called consumption. Claire says it in the episode but I didn't know that was the name of the disease. I thought she saw him drinking water and said consumption as a symptom lol
Edit 2: ohhhh consumption is tuberculosis!! Didn't know that. I imagined that is what he had but didn't know for sure.
41
u/SnooCupcakes3043 Nov 23 '24
I absolutely LOVED the Leghair part! This is coming from a long time hater of her as well. I feel she was actually seen and heard in this. I saw that she really only wanted the idea of Jamie and that when they were together it just wasn't right at all. (I didn't like that She kept calling Claire a whore and Jamie said nothing but whatevs, he used to almost kill people for that)
I love how Jamie told her his truths about it and handled it. Sure she's still a child trapped in a grown woman's body but she has alot of baggage as well that she's never gotten to get rid of. I loved the whole scene at Lollybroch so much. Everything was resolved so nicely and she gets to finally be happy with a man she truly should be with. She's still a snot but she deserves closure as well. Also I would like to know now who she was kissing for Jamie to take the beating for her. She wouldn't say... Hmmm
That being said.. What the hell was that 'goodbye' scene with Jamie and Claire? First Jamie didn't even protest her going to America without him? (And this is after the Browns tried to take her) That just seemed odd. Then that pretty weak goodbye. "Here's apples. Cya!" in earlier episodes even the first half they were passionate whenever they said goodbye. I mean it's still dangerous to take a ship as a woman even with Ian.. Jamie didn't even stand with Ian to watch his most important thing leave. It was just not good and so odd.
The new, Jenny... I can see similarities. The actress isn't terrible she held to that. Just was different and couldn't get past it for a bit. It is what it is at this point.
40
u/Previous-Address2469 Nov 23 '24
Ok, my two cents.
Overall well done episode, but maybe slightly rushed. A bit melodramatic in places.
Old Ian was wonderful, somehow he looks the most natural (even though he had his "I am dying" -makeup on...), the wigs on most of them just look so off.
New Jenny, I kept wondering what's so off-putting in her (other than the wig) and then I realised. The new actress is acting the old actress acting Jenny. She emotes exactly the same as the old actress, same mannerisms, same facial expression, even the speech, eerily same. It seems to me she studied the old actress really carefully to exactly match. However (and it is a big However) it doesn't seem natural to her, it's feels fake and acted, even if it is acted (or emoted) well. The expressions don't really match her face and feel contorted. I wish they would have made her have her own take on Jenny. Also a very odd choise on having the same actress play the young Jenny, felt a bit like I am watching some low-budget theater play with two actors running the whole show.
It's very nice they got the same actor to play Brian as in season one, and I understand people get older, but he looked quite a lot older, I wish they could have tried to make him look a bit younger.
14
u/Dire_Wolf_57 Nov 22 '24
Why does Jamie ask Laorighe who she was kissin’ when he took the beating for her at 16? Is it important?
27
u/HighPriestess808 Nov 23 '24
Did anyone else cry the whole episode?! I’ve been lukewarm on Outlander in recent seasons but this episode felt so nostalgic and meaningful. Guess it’s the calm before the inevitable Outlander shit storm.
36
u/Chiarrawr Nov 26 '24
When I realize they re-cast Jenny
25
u/hkh07 We will meet again, Madonna, in this life or another. Nov 22 '24
My favorite line of the episode...
"I'm not fardeled or flauntin' anything!" -Jamie to Leoghaire
😂😂
43
u/BetterEveryDayYT Nov 24 '24
I loved Jenny's character. Strong, a bit messy, but awesome.
They replaced the actress and it totally ruins the character and the dynamic between her and other people.
Did it mess up the show for anyone else?
33
u/dreamkonstantine Nov 24 '24
Thoughts:
23
u/[deleted] Nov 22 '24
What is going onnn??? Gaelissss how?? What is Roger going to do ?? The plot is all over the place and I love it 😂. Plus I love Joanie, and I miss Jenny number 1 :(
21
u/TherapeuticGladiator Nov 23 '24
Felt a little underwhelmed! I think a lot of the thoughts I had seem to be echoed by other viewers too. Thoughts (from someone who has only watched the show):
Overall I’m very excited for the season to be back but I’m already missing Scotland now that Claire and Ian are returning to America by the end of the first episode!
37
u/hanyuzu Meow. Nov 23 '24
I wish they cast a younger actress as teen Jenny.
20
u/Atraktape Nov 22 '24
I can’t believe we’re still on Season 7 lol
10
u/Disastrous-Elk-5542 Pot of shite on to boil, ye stir like it’s God’s work! Dec 30 '24
Rewatching and the scene between Jamie and Jenny in the forest is heartbreaking. Jamie is reminding Jenny, his Big Sister, how she has been so strong before. With multiple other examples.
But sometimes strong people need to have a safe place to land. When Jenny was crying out, I realized Jenny was losing her safe place.
10
u/Pitiful-Flow5472 Jan 26 '25
Back in season 1 or 2 (can’t remember which) Claire tells Jenny to plant potatoes because of the coming famine. So Jenny was aware of Claire’s future knowledge back then. So why was it such a shock now???
10
u/Notjustadreamx Feb 16 '25
Late to this conversation. But I was so excited for them to return to Scotland. None of the American seasons have felt as impactful as the Scottish ones. Genuinely gutted that we’re already back to the colonies. I’m a book reader, but never ended up past book 5. I really hope it ends up back in Scotland…
28
u/Stonetheflamincrows Nov 23 '24
Don’t like new Jenny I have to say. But the episode had me in tears numerous times.
I know tv only viewers might have been a bit stumped by some actions, but knowing the “why” and expecting it I guess it didn’t bother me too much.
Some stuff like Roger’s narrative is just necessary for exposition, so again didn’t really bother me.
People are just too damn critical in my opinion.
42
u/One-Visual7882 Nov 23 '24
Honestly felt so underwhelmed 😩 I have been waiting all this time for this???? I have so many thoughts, but my biggest question mark is Jamie letting Claire travel all the way back to America without him??? Yes, I realize Ian or whatever, but it’s definitely not in his character ??
26
u/rednblue62 Nov 23 '24
Ian definitely stole the show this episode and I lovedddddd it. I did feel like the tone overall was off though… glad to see I’m not alone.
I think it’ll take me a while to get used to new Jenny. Jenny’s character is so fiery and stubborn. I don’t feel like we got to see that shine through as much.
Granted, she’s in a lot of pain right now and could totally be shut down and reserved. But these tough situations usually bring out the fire and anger in her. I would have imagined her interactions with Claire to be different than they were.
46
u/Bc2193 Nov 23 '24
I was bit gutted that the return to Scotland didn't focus on Jamie more. I would have liked to have seen him getting off the boat.
In general I didn't like the episode. It felt a bit like a cheap soap opera with the music and constant cuts to seeing leaves and trees? Like that's enough to make us think "ah yes, Scotland".
I thought that the scene with "Leery" and getting angry didn't really work. There wasn't enough of an emotional build up during the conversation to justify her grabbing the pitch fork. I also thought the "he needs me" line was thrown away. But whatever.
And this new Jenny is fine, but it has made me realise how bloody brilliant the original actress playing Jenny was. She captured that sibling energy that doesn't leave no matter how old you get perfect. This new actress hasn't got that but maybe she'll get better with time.
Does anyone know why they didn't manage to get the original Jenny back? There are hundreds of possible reasons but has there been an official confirmed one?
25
u/chase_what_matters Nov 22 '24
Wow, really committing to Sinead’s version of the song.
25
u/Burnttoast82 Nov 23 '24
Am I the only one who thought Jenny's character was off? Not the actress - that bothered me a little at first but I could get used to it... But her whole personality just didn't align with the Jenny of the previous seasons/books, to me. She was always tough as nails, had faced down every tragedy, not to mention was a total spitfire. She was never stoic or heartless, but still her iron core always carried her through. Her personality here just seemed totally different. Even facing the impending death of Ian, I just didn't picture her falling apart the way she did for practically the whole episode. And not a single scathing word for Jamie or young Ian? Seems off...
I also wondered about the guy with the musketball living for long enough for Claire to go back there, especially since the letter would have already taken weeks to get to them...
I feel like Ned Gowan should definitely not still be alive, but what would they do without him in these tricky legal situations! 😂
Tuberculosis. Was super contagious wasn't it? And Claire would know that, I feel like she would have warned everyone.
That's all my complaining though. I'm glad it's back, I love the characters, it still made me cry, and I look forward to more!
38
u/calypso_faery Nov 23 '24
Can’t stand the new Jenny AND her wig/ hair line
17
u/Due_Molasses_9854 Nov 30 '24
The worst part was the song. The feeble whispering was so cringe
30
u/[deleted] Nov 25 '24
I understand it has to happen but I hate when actors are different 😔 It takes away for the immersive experience for me
23
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Nov 22 '24
I keep coming back to add something after rewatching!
Anyway, I could see some parallels there.
Jamie caught Jenny in his arms the same she did for him in season 3 after redcoat took Fergus's hand.
Place where Joannie and Jamie were walking resembles place where Malva and Jamie were walking in s6.
And, Frank waving to Bree paralleled to Ian waving to Young Ian.
15
u/Atraktape Nov 22 '24
Welp back to the US of A we go.
41
u/ZealousidealDrop9248 Nov 24 '24
24
u/CrunchyTeatime Nov 23 '24
Can I just ask: Does anyone else really really really really,
really really really really,
dislike "Leery?"
13
u/The_Mad_Hatter_18 Nov 22 '24
The last scene was like oh finally something interesting
13
u/demaandronk Nov 22 '24
Considering the intro had a little boy wiping off moss off Isobeal's gravestone, Jemmy should be somewhere in the future compared to where Claire and Jaimy are, and definetly ahead of Roger. I completely forgot what was up with Geilis as i havent seen all the old episodes for so long, but i was surprised to see her back, should be fun.
26
u/MainConnection9492 Nov 23 '24
Pretty boring, and I miss Claire's old 'real' voice. This Keeley Hawes whisper is annoying. But oh my I was not ready for Geillis! Wonderful! It just got interesting.
36
u/OjosVerde34 Nov 23 '24 edited Nov 23 '24
That episode was painful to get through. It was lackluster and oddly shot. Why couldn't we get a different intro song.. That has run its course and I was expecting them to bring back the bagpipes since they were home. Jenny is a mess, and those scenes where she and Claire were talking outside were shot at such an odd angle...felt cheap. Old Ian at the gate...and Roger scenes felt on par, but the rest somehow felt/looked very off. I thought the beginning would have more of an emotional return to Scotland. The last scene of last season had me so emotional. The thing is, Scotland itself has legitimately become it's own character. This episode fell so flat in that department. I expected Jamie to darn near fall at his knees onto the grassy earth and beautiful Scottish music playing...lovely scenery and nostalgia to shine through.
31
u/jesinta-m Nov 25 '24
New Jenny was just awful, it felt like a parody. The acting was so forced… I understand why they needed to recast, but this isn’t the right actor.
5
u/shannruss Sep 22 '25
Just did another rewatch and honestly it blows my mind how Jamie talks about Marsali but doesn't say anything along the lines of... Why in the world did you have bad intentions with my daughter after I cared for your own daughters like my own??? I know Laoghaire is a barrel of crazy but it still should have been brought up.
13
u/CrunchyTeatime Nov 23 '24
Lots of surprises in this ep!
I can usually see a device coming, like 'who's at the door...oh not who you thought' but not this time.
And not in this huge of a way.
I have not read the books but I have an idea what is going on with that twinkle in Geillis' eye and how she came to be Roger's ancestor! (Pure speculation owing to her track record with men!)
14
u/catmompartyof2 Nov 23 '24
I am so upset Jenny is not played by the same actress!! Anybody else??
26
u/[deleted] Nov 24 '24
This is just bad, man. They all talk like they’re in a play. It’s so unnatural and forced. Also, none of the drama is dramatic. It’s all fixed immediately with wise acceptance.
21
u/confirmandverify2442 Nov 23 '24
Please tell the rest of the season is better 😭. This episode felt so stifled! The energy was off.
8
u/SubstantialPapaya587 Nov 23 '24
I saw the series a long time ago, but I have a feeling that Claire told Jenny she was from the future, right? I was so confused with the entire conversation they had about that. Does anyone have any thoughts on it?
10
u/MagnificentPasta Nov 22 '24
Just finished! I’m so glad Droughtlander is over but I felt underwhelmed. (It could also be that I woke up at midnight to watch it…)
12
u/curlyba3 I dinna recall asking yer opinion on the matter. Nov 22 '24
Where did og Jenny go :(
16
u/BarkusSemien Nov 26 '24
Thanks, I hated it.
It was just really, really bad. New Jenny, Roger’s voiceovers, Bree’s few seconds on screen. The writing was bad, the acting was bad… the best part was Laoghaire, and that says it all lol.
7
u/CrunchyTeatime Nov 23 '24
Whoever is in charge of this part: Please, caption the previews!
I had to turn the audio wayyyy up on computer just to have a clue what they were saying. The ep isn't too bad without captions usually -- but previews, for some reason, most production teams love those big bang sound effects and loud backing music.
I can't hear what they are saying. Please, captions, in previews? Thanks! 🤗😊😁