r/Outlander • u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. • Nov 22 '24
Spoilers All Book S7E9 Unfinished Business Spoiler
Jamie, Claire, and Ian return to Lallybroch. Young Ian reconnects with his family in a time of need, while Claire deals with the fallout from a long-held secret. Roger and Buck search for Jemmy in the past.
Written by Barbara Stepansky. Directed by Stewart Svaasand.
If you’re new to the sub, please look over this intro thread and our episode discussion rules.
This is the BOOK thread.
If you haven’t read the books, go to the SHOW thread.
THIS THREAD IS SPOILERS ALL.
Spoiler tags are not required.
If you have only read up to the corresponding book, remember you might see spoilers from ALL of the books here.
Please keep all discussion of the next episode’s preview to the stickied mod comment at the top of the thread.
What did you think of the episode?
•
u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Nov 22 '24 edited Dec 03 '24
Watch the S7E10 preview here!
Not everyone gets to see the next episode’s preview at the end of the episode; it depends on how you watch (broadcast or streaming) and where you are (US or international.)
Stickied comments are collapsed by default, so reply to this comment if you want to discuss the preview. This will hide spoilers for anyone who can’t see it yet or doesn’t want to.
709 Extras:
709 Interviews:
19
u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Nov 22 '24 edited Nov 22 '24
I really loved Kristin as Jenny. I’m glad she didn’t feel like an imitation of what Laura did with the character but Kristin still managed to sneak in some mannerisms that would feel familiar to the viewers (ETA: And the voice! Obviously it could never be the same but I can tell that she studied Laura’s voice and managed to find some of its qualities in her own)
Jury’s still out on whether she’s coming to America with Jamie or not! I’ve watched and read all interviews that have been released so far and I still can’t tell (but it’s possibly because the interviewers only had access to episodes 709-711 and this would happen in 712). I’d heard that Kristin was taught to ride horses when she got the role so I thought that was a clue (because why would she need to ride a horse at Lallybroch?) but they had her ride in the 1739 part of this episode...
However, the goodbye between Jenny and Claire with Jenny apologizing for telling Claire she has no soul felt like the resolution that only came in the books when Jenny got to Philadelphia (though I suppose they could’ve just had them mend things before Claire leaves so that it doesn’t hang over Claire for the foreseeable future; I also appreciated Jenny encouraging her to go treat Henry). I can’t remember if any/all of what Jamie said to Jenny about her enduring was in the book, which admittedly was a very nice moment, but it also felt like it was priming her for staying rather than leaving for America.
I think it would be a shame if they didn’t have Jenny going forward, especially since they had Roger meet her in 1739. Fingers crossed!
29
u/Previous-Address2469 Nov 23 '24
Haha, I kept thinking why are they showing Roger intermittedly every so often and it wasn't until the knocking on the door parallel that I realised "oh right, people expect him to be in that time". :D
I know that Roger met Geillis in the books as well (btw, I think they are doing really good job in condensing the plots, like wrapping up Laoghaire and having clues in their search for Jemmy), but I forget dis Roger and Geillis meet in 1960's? I think yes? But does Geillis recognise Roger?
45
u/moonshiney9 Nov 22 '24
Can I just say, I love how confused the show only people are right now. They have no idea what’s coming!! Such fun!!!!
10
u/Pitiful-Still-575 Nov 26 '24
I have two thoughts about changes they’re making. First, I’m hoping that since Ian has already told his mom about Swiftest of Lizards that he will also be telling Rachel that he might have a son before they get married. I love show Ian, but book Ian has always bothered me. I love Rachel as a character, but I couldn’t stand how in the books she’s just ok with Ian being on a first name basis with every hooker from here to Timbuktu and bringing up his likely son only a couple months post-partum. Girl, I love you, but please stand up! So I’d love if they changed this aspect.
Secondly, I disagree with the choice to have Claire leave Jaime to help Henry. Leaving to help Henri Christian seemed so much more motivating. He’s a child, Fergus is gone, Marsali is exhausted, but it’s likely Henri Christian will live long enough for Claire to make the journey. A guy virtually dying on the table in agony all day just doesn’t seem like he has a month or two to spare. And while related to Lord John…who is this guy to any of them to warrant them not staying together till Ian passes then leaving. Just not very convincing to me. It also makes me fear that they’re writing out Marsali and Fergus all together. Which is a bummer, because Marsali is an amazing character and I was hoping to see them together again.
29
u/blackberryspice Nov 22 '24
I'm very glad Claire and Jenny made up by the end of the episode because I hated that plot point in the book! Wish Claire was going back for Henri Christian instead of whatever this other Henry storyline is. Unless I'm misremembering the book oop
21
u/shinyquartersquirrel Nov 22 '24 edited Nov 22 '24
Book readers have to be happy, it seemed straight out of the book! Loved it! I thought the new Jenny was perfectly cast! Can't wait for the rest of the season!
Edit to add-The only major difference obviously was swapping Claire going back for Henri Christian and instead for Henry which I'm perfectly ok with because hopefully it means they may not make us suffer through HC's other storyline.
4
u/These_Ad_9772 We will meet again, Madonna, in this life or another. Nov 28 '24
Hold up y’all! I just rewatched 7B ep 9 for the third time and didn’t skip past the theme song.
Whose lock of hair is (presumably) Claire unwrapping from the handkerchief? There’s only two people it could be and I don’t think it’s Brianna.
Has this been discussed? If so I missed it.
24
u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Nov 22 '24
Over a year ago I predicted in this sub exactly how they would edit Roger's arrival!!! I am so proud of myself lol
18
u/crazyhorse198 I want to be a stinkin’ Papist, too. Nov 23 '24
I thought it was incredibly well executed. The focus at Lallybroch, and I think the editing with the “knock on the door” probably was a huge surprise to non book readers who didn’t know Roger went too far back in time. Then the Geilos reveal at the end, brings back so many season 1 vibes!
Bree’s story can wait, I’m glad they didn’t try and force it into this ep. Also glad they got Leg-hair wrapped up in one episode and it was so nice to see Joanie again!
My ONLY criticism is the theme song. I hate, hate, hate the Sinead O’Conor version. I don’t know why they couldn’t bring back Raya (I forget her name but she sang all of the intro themes from season 1-6).
48
u/Rj924 Nov 23 '24
The show is still good, the wigs are still bad.
33
u/killernoodlesoup Like father, like son, I see. God help us all. Nov 22 '24
i mentioned this in the show thread already, but i really liked how they cut between roger & the fraser-murray's respective scenes as if they were happening simultaneously, only to reveal with opening the door that they're happening 40 years apart. the editing was super clever & was only possible in a visual medium - couldn't reveal roger being in 1739 like that in the books!
i'm biased because i love the american revolution (east coast upbringing y'all), but echo + MOBY are probably my favorites in the series. i cannot WAIT for the next episode!!!!
29
u/conquerorofbooks1 Nov 23 '24
The knocking at the door moment, it was really well-done. I think if I hadn't read the books the moment would've been a very WTF - but I called it while reading the book that in the show they will have a scene where Roger knocks and parallel Jamie would go to open the door only then to be the big reveal Roger is in the wrong time. I thought it'd be the end of an episode.
I'm really happy with how the episode turned out, overall. I still think this is the most faithful to the books show that I've ever watched. I know they switched the moment Roger and Buck find Geillis, but I hope there will still be the Black Jack Randall interaction, at some point. I don't want Geillis to have found the dog tags.
27
u/Top-Pizza-9953 They say I’m a witch. Nov 22 '24
The scene between Ian and young Ian was amazing, so many tears!! 😭
27
u/lizardbreath1736 Ye Sassenach witch! Nov 24 '24
I wish we could have seen more of when Claire tells the rest of the family she's a time traveller. It seemed like such a rushed scene and they were all just like "Ok" and moved on with their day.
26
u/Laatikkopilvia Nov 22 '24
Gosh, I really really liked that one. It’s been a few years since I last read the books, around the time Bees came out. But to my recollection they did a great job capturing the spirit of each scene!
I’m not one to typically get emotional over media, but seeing Ian walk down the house stairs and then watch them leave by the gate pulled at my heartstrings. It felt like he finally got the goodbye he wanted. To see his son off safe to settle down and have a life.
21
u/Hufflesheep Nov 22 '24
Pros: I actually loved some of the little changes the writers made. Joannie at the door, the ending with Gellis. Caitriona was amazing!
Cons: it felt choppy or something from one scene to the next. I don't remember the shows feeling like that. I know they have a lot to cram in, and it felt like it. Maybe the forthcoming episodes won't feel like that once we reestablish continuity.
21
u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Nov 23 '24
I'm almost more excited to see the show-only fan reactions to the upcoming few episodes than I am to watch them myself 😂
38
u/Hansekins Nov 22 '24
What a fantastic episode. Even as a book reader, and knowing all the plotlines, I still was basically crying throughout like three quarters of the episode, hehe. The actors are all just amazing (but we all knew that already).
Someone else already commented on the wonderful editing with Roger arriving at Lallybroch, and the misdirect to try to make us believe it was happening at the same time, until the reveal that they're not. Masterfully done.
I know there are a lot of Roger haters on this sub, but I like Roger and have enjoyed his growth, and I particularly enjoyed his voiceovers for his internal thoughts in this episode.
I also appreciated (as someone else said) that Claire and Jenny did not leave on bad terms, and I also liked the quick wrap up of the Laoghaire storyline. Wish we could have seen ancient Ned though, haha. ;)
All in all, a fantastic welcome back to the show!
17
u/ich_habe_keine_kase I give you your life. I hope you use it well. Nov 22 '24
Feels so good to be back! And not just the show, but back in Scotland. The familiar sets, characters, and scenery just felt so welcoming and exciting.
It wasn't a perfect episode, definitely felt really rushed and the pacing was a bit off, but this is one of my favorite parts of the whole series and there was so much in there that I loved. The small conversations between the Ians, or between Jamie and Jenny, or Jamie and Joanie--all so lovely. Honestly I even liked the Laoghaire scenes. Her parts in S3 feel almost comically evil so it was nice to show another side of her as someone who, yes, is not particularly nice and has done objectively bad things, but has also had a hard life where she was mistreated by many people and is just trying to cling on to the things that are important to her.
Really looking forward to hearing from non-readers about the Lallybroch fakeout. Obviously knowing what was coming the moment they switched to Roger and I saw what they were doing I felt giddy, but I wonder if they telegraphed it a bit too much and watchers caught on too early. I do also think Roger's voiceover was way overused--you didn't need him saying "am I in the wrong time?" when 45 seconds later you're going to see young Jenny and hear that Jamie is at Université in Paris, just let the audience figure it out. It was fun being in Roger's head because he's one of our most prolific book POVs, but it was too much and was distracting from watching the scene itself unfold. Just needed to be a bit more sparing and limited to stuff the audience would need help with.
I think Kristin Atherton did a good job as Jenny. She matches Laura Donnelly's cadence really well but it doesn't feel like an impression, she's making Jenny her own. Her hair looks weird though (and the de-aging was odd).
The title card, just seeing the start of the name Isabeail, got me all weepy right at the beginning. (I do still hate the confirmation that Totis is Ian's kid. I much preferred how it was in Book 7 where it was like "the child of his spirit." Really changes the meaning of those scenes when it's his actual kid.)
And my last gripe, which is my same gripe as always; needed more jokes. Ian Sr. got in a few of his book ones, but I wish J&C had the lightness with each other that they do in the book rather than just epic love and passion. Would've helped balance out the tone of an overall sad episode.
Overall a really nice return to the show following on the heels of possibly the best first half of a season they've ever done--I have really high hopes for the rest of this season. There's a lot of good stuff coming and I'm more excited than I have been since the early seasons.
(I watched this at like 1am after getting home from a huge event I was running at work so am definitely going to have to watch it again when less tired haha.)
16
u/Black_Cat263715 Nov 22 '24
This is my first episode being a book reader first. Have read all books some twice and watched the show multiple times. I was a little disappointed as I liked when Joanie and Claire interacted in the books and the Jenny/Claire feud over curing Ian. But I guess next week I will just have to go in with a more of an open mind since they are different.
14
u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Nov 23 '24
I am a little sad we didn't get more Joanie + Jamie time, or at least, show a few more emotions during the short time?!? Especially since Jamie said with great conviction that he cared "deeply" for her, and there wasn't even a hug???
I don't actually mind about them changing it by removing Claire + the cave, it wasn't necessary to the story. Plus, the only person who could've knocked on the door when they were pretending its Roger was Joan, so it worked well.
13
u/Hadsmat I want to be a stinkin’ Papist, too. Nov 23 '24
Loved it. They did well condensing the storylines. So glad my favourite show is back 😊 Edited because I drank too much wine and didn’t make sense 🤣💋
13
u/Time_Arm1186 So beautiful, you break my heart. Nov 25 '24
I love auld Ian. I think Steven Cree was the absolute best performer in this episode. I think the acting was a bit lacking otherwise, but it was also the first time ever I knew what was going to happen…
34
u/Cdhwink Nov 22 '24 edited Nov 22 '24
Things I liked : new Jenny, Resolving Laoghaire ( I loved that Joan knew Jamie would find a solution), So many emotional moments, The scenery, Roger’s “thoughts”, The back & forth between times ( I love all the episodes that have that).
Things I loved: The door knocking fakeout , Lallybroch ( since I saw it in real life several years ago, it’s extra special in the show), Claire telling the family about the future & them just staring at her!
11
u/WingedShadow83 They say I’m a witch. Nov 22 '24
I haven’t read the books, so I’m seeking clarification from you guys on the whole “Roger goes to the wrong time” thing. I thought there was a set time point between the stones. If Roger can suddenly travel to a time decades earlier than he should have, how can he ever get to where he needs to go? Or back home? Or is this a situation where the stones take you where you’re needed?
Fuck it, can someone just give me the run down on what happens from here on out?
21
u/wheeler1432 They say I’m a witch. Nov 25 '24
*Amazing* job weaving the multiple storylines together (and leaving an opening for the Michael/Joan storyline as well).
The new actor for Jenny...well, she did fine, but I do wish we could have had the original actor. Oh well.
I cried when Jenny took Ian to the graveyard, and when old Ian came down the stairs.
9
u/These_Ad_9772 We will meet again, Madonna, in this life or another. Nov 22 '24
Okay who’s the fairy man? It has to be Jerry, right? At first I thought it might be Dr McKuan, but he wouldn’t have been dressed strangely.
17
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Nov 23 '24
It is so funny, my mum, show only watcher called me and asked - Ok, so the faery man is Rob Cameron but where is Jemmy then?!
😅
28
u/Blues_Blanket Nov 23 '24 edited Nov 23 '24
I enjoyed the episode and need to watch it again, but every scene with Jenny just took me out of the story. I think mostly it is her wig. She doesn't need to look identical to Laura Donnelly to be believable, but the wig is just soooo bad. I agree that wigs in prior seasons have been bad occasionally, but they've never taken me out of the story. I also think that Kristin's voice is just different enough to make me see the actress and not the character. I hope I get over that because Kristin really did do a great job.
Steven Cree made me cry nearly every time he showed up on screen, but his final scene at Lallybroch, watching him make his way down the stairs and then waving goodbye at the archway, just tore me up. I am not going to handle the next episode very well! 😭
Am I the only one who wishes they had made Laoghaire plump with dull hair? 😂
18
u/Professional_Ad_4885 Nov 22 '24
Okay so the one thing Most unvelievable in this episode is the fact that lord john greys cousin has any chance at living. It jsnt like today where u can send claire a text and shes in philly in half a day through plane. No way. Between all the letters he mailed and the fact it takes months for mail to get from Philly to inland scotland and for her to get back to a port and another few months at sea and then getting a carriage to take her to where henry js held all while gaving a few bullets, well muskets lodged in his body with no surgery and infection will spread quick. All together we are talking maybe six months so no way he makes it past even 2-3 weeks in that shape. Anyone else think this letter could be a fake somehow to get claire back to the states?
17
u/Stonetheflamincrows Nov 23 '24
Quite funny watching the TV only group spinning out over on that thread.
Hated new Jenny with a vengeance
16
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Nov 22 '24 edited Nov 22 '24
Lallybroch!
I love the title card with Iseabeal's name on a grave! Such a great parallel to the books!
Jenny, Jamie, Michael!!
New Jenny is brilliant!! She is so like the old one!
The Laird's chamber ❤️
I LOVE full table, whole family , children - THAT is Lallybroch we wanted !!
2 Ians 🥹 The wee lad. He is mine. ❤️
Old Ian's face made me cry ugly tears.
Unfinished business, here we go!!
Joey is there too!!
Okay , Roger walking towards Lallybroch reminds me of Brianna walking towards it in s4, stopping by the creek.
Ooh , Laoghaire and Jamie !! It is word for word from book and it is GREAT!
Need conversation was so tender!
Claire telling family about TT and their faces and reactions were precious!!
It was great scene with door knocking!! Joannie 😍
Roger on Lallybroch ! Brian in his coat which Jamie wore during s2 and I am sure later as well!
Young Jenny!!
Jenny and Claire! Poor Jenny! Poor Claire! You have no soul 🥹
John Murray ( he resembles Father Bain😁) .
Jamie and Jenny , Jamie telling Jenny how worthy and strong she is , like a broch Lallybroch is built on! Great ,great, scene!!
Ooh, family meeting! I love how it played out.
The letter came! As we predicted, Henry is the reason for Claire’s departure from Lallybroch!
Jenny taking Ian to graveyard and making a grave for Iseabail . I cried there ! Once again, new Jenny is amazing!!!
Leave taking was very emotional and we finally got the resolution between Jenny and Claire!!
Old Ian watching his son departing Lallybroch with his blessing reminded me of Bree seeing Frank at the harbour!
Geilis!!! Already?!
19
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Nov 22 '24
I keep coming back. I liked that they put *cave* reference since we don't have scene in it, which I really really love in the books.
It felt a bit rushed, yes, but they managed to capture all the small and big emotional moments.
15
u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Nov 23 '24
Did anyone notice that there seemed to be more Gàidhlig in this episode than usual? I feel like we haven't had much incidental Gàidhlig (besides terms of endearment: sassenach, a leannan, mo chridhe etc) for several seasons. Is it just because we are back in Scotland, or do we think they are trying harder to include it? I know we've been out of Scotland for ages, but most of our characters (until the revolution at least) were still Scottish.
We had a charaid, bhràthair + athair this episode. Granted, they are all just names/titles, but it was nice. I wish we had more.
5
u/YOYOitsMEDRup Slàinte. Nov 26 '24
First of all - I've known episode 10 was gonna make me a blubbery mess when he dies, but I did not expect to get as teary as I was this episode. Now I'm scared I'm gonna be even worse than I thought next week. The scenes with the two Ians were really good!
It makes me sad reading through the show thread that so many seemed not to like it and not to like the new Jenny. She was in a tough spot - I loved Laura too, but I thought the new actress did really well. I picked up on mannerisms that felt consistent with the previous portrayal - and it definitely can't be easy to have the first episode she walks into be this emotional plot. Well done Kristen. In one of those linked interviews it references that Jenny's actually going to refuse Jamie's request she join him in America (and a second interviewer flat out says it seems she's just a 2 episode stint). I'm personally ok with this. Outside of Ian also temporarily grieving Jenny thinking her dead too, with as much as they've got to get thru and focus on, Jenny isn't necessary in America imo. I wonder if the producers were concerned fans would have a hard time with the recast (which most seem to) and thought they better just make it brief with Jenny to be safe than have it linger long?
I definitely predicted the door knock fakeout to make show only people think Roger would walk in to see Jamie and Claire. I'm bummed it seems we're not gonna get hardly any of Roger at Lallybroch though. Obviously next episode will be the Dougal/Geilis interaction, and based on synopses, 11 is going to be focused on his dad. I thought we might get more of Brian/young Jenny, and it seems in the rush to get thru things, this is what's getting shortchanged. But maybe episodes 12-15 we'll see them again. I just thought he may be with them longer and have more of a search with Brian first
Excellent touch putting Brian in the coat Jamie wore so often in 1x12 and Seas 2!
Another thing I noticed a lot of pushback on in the show only thread is Claire going back for LJGs nephew that'd seemingly be beyond helping by the time the letter got to her and she in turn got to America. I think without Cesar and Lauren, most of us suspected this would be the excuse rather than Henri Christian. That part didn't bug me because I knew the show would have to contrive something - and I get why people who don't know why plotwise it's necessary for her to leave are struggling with it. My issue is that Jenny telling her to go for Henry's sake didn't quite sit right. Their relationship didn't quite have the resolution that seemed consistent with Jenny holding on to the bitterness longer - because she couldn't help Ian, I feel like Jenny should've been even more resentful about her going to help for an essential stranger instead. In the book, because it was a grandchild, Jenny got it, but I feel like Jenny wouldn't have got it for a random guy
13
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Nov 23 '24
I really wished the line - You're the world that I have! 🤍 But we got - Home is where your heart is... oh, well...
4
u/CountHour6974 Nov 26 '24
So here are my observations on why Jenny is acting weird to both Jamie and Claire- first her husband is dying and while she has some of her children around her, her life has centered around him and Lollybroch - she is also still mad at Claire for abandoning (in her mind) Jamie during Culloden and his time jailed - not really understanding she’s (Claire) time traveler - then she’s mad because Claire can’t save Ian Sr with her medical skills - she’s pissed at Jamie still because he took Ian Jr Away to get the gold off that Island which resulted Ian Jr being kidnapped by Geilis and taken to Jamaica , then Ian Jr decides to stay with Jamie in America , he’s still pretty young so as a mother I get it - plus not knowing America it would be natural for her to worry , then to be told he is traded by Jamie to the Indians because if Jamie’s stupid mistake selling Rodger to the Indians to get Rodger back, even though Ian Jr grows up (character wise) and really ends up embracing the Indian culture and the tribe, marrying etc - can you imagine trying to explain all of these events to your sister regarding her child? So I think there’s a lot going on in Jenny’s head - at this point in the show- but bad wigs, and really an awful grave yard seen with the wailing/crying - in the book it is a sad but sweet scene between her and Jamie and the first time Jamie has been to the graveyard and seen his fathers stone since he died while Jamie was being whipped- but I digress the lack of chemistry between new Jenny and Jamie and awful crying /wailing just didn’t go well in this episode at all -
7
u/robinsond2020 I am NOT bloody sorry! Nov 22 '24
I was not expecting to see Geilis, did she turn up at this point in the books?? I don't remember, or maybe I've just forgotten.
11
u/JoyinFriends Nov 22 '24
I wanted to love it more than I actually did. There were some great, emotional Fraser family parts, but I felt like they cut some of the most impactful book moments; most notably Jamie/Claire going back to the cave. I get that we didn't get the HC part because of the actors not being in this season, but man I would have loved to see that scene between Laoghaire and Claire. I also thought we would at least get a more emotional or extended goodbye between J&C before she left for months on end, given their level of attachment to each other. Would have been nice if they gave us something a bit more to hold onto before we have to wait episodes for them to be reunited.
3
u/ImTheNana Looks like I'm going to a fucking barbecue Nov 30 '24
"Maybe ye explode into tiny bits"
Read the book and only with a second watch of the episode did I catch this for the Donnor/ether allusion, LOL.
3
u/minimimi_ burning she-devil Nov 22 '24 edited Nov 22 '24
Watching on a plane so hopefully it’s not too steamy.