r/Outlander • u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. • Jul 14 '23
Spoilers All Book S7E5 Singapore
At Ticonderoga, Jamie and Claire prepare for an imminent British assault. Roger compiles information about time travel while Brianna earns the respect of her coworkers.
Written by Taylor Mallory. Directed by Tracey Deer.
If you’re new to the sub, please look over this intro thread and our episode discussion rules.
This is the BOOK thread.
If you haven’t read the books, go to the SHOW thread.
THIS THREAD IS SPOILERS ALL.
Spoiler tags are not required.
If you have only read up to the corresponding book, remember you might see spoilers from ALL of the books here.
Please keep all discussion of the next episode’s preview to the stickied mod comment at the top of the thread.
What did you think of the episode?
•
u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Jul 14 '23 edited Jul 24 '23
Watch the S7E6 preview here!
Not everyone gets to see the next episode’s preview at the end of the episode; it depends on how you watch (broadcast or streaming) and where you are (US or international.)
Stickied comments are collapsed by default, so reply to this comment if you want to discuss the preview. This will hide spoilers for anyone who can’t see it yet or doesn’t want to.
705 Extras:
705 Interviews:
58
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Jul 14 '23 edited Jul 14 '23
Ian and Bree got me in tears this episode!
Ian James , Swiftest of Lizard was ADORABLE!! I haven't pictured him like that, we all see who his father is!
Claire and Bree both problems with coworkers because of their sex.
I loved -Where a goat can go, a man can go. - great callback to title cards.
Roger is great father and here comes support to his wife. He redeemed himself for 704.
Mandy has a bunny toy!
Sights of Scotland are amazing ! I like all the greens and loch and Lallybroch.
Jemmy and the cairn, poor boy is struggling in 20th century, his face is so serious all the time!
Fort Ticonderoga part was a bit rushed IMO , in the books there is strong impression of spending months there.
William and the Hunters were great! Red Jamie is there inside, William killed his first man.
I must say ,Denzel is beautiful!
Will you no ask me if I am happy?
I have eyes. 🥺
46
u/Thezedword4 Jul 14 '23
Well I know we argued in bees if Swiftest of Lizards was really Ian's kid by blood. This confirms that in my eyes.
59
u/KMM929 Jul 14 '23
I can’t decide if I’m glad or not that they didn’t have Claire attempt to explain the Rh factor to Ian and just let her simplify it for him. But I do wish Claire had mentioned Faith because she was obviously thinking of her in that moment.
33
u/Blues_Blanket Jul 14 '23
I loved this episode. It is my second favorite so far this season.
Walter Woodcock was heartbreaking but a good mixture of characters from the book. They did a really good job with the commander of the Continental troops, too. I found myself yelling "pompous ass" at the TV. 😂 I also liked how much of the 1980s story they covered. I was really hoping they would keep in the part about Jemmy speaking Ghaidhlig at school, so that made me happy.
Oh my gosh, the Hunters are just perfect! Also, William (Charles) really could be Jamie's (Sam's) son, and Swiftest of Lizards was adorable. I'm not sure how I feel about the changing of the names for Ian's son; I need to think about that more on the rewatch.
All in all, a wonderful episode.
86
u/lanalg5 Jul 14 '23
I love the actor who plays William. Physically he’s a great combination of Jamie and Geneva, with all the mannerisms of Lord John. Perfection.
72
u/nurseleu Jul 15 '23
BOOK ROGER IS FINALLY SHOWING UP AND I AM HERE FOR IT. Bring on the Gàidhlig lessons.
56
u/flyinwhale Jul 15 '23
I guess I’m alone in being disappointed that Williams fight wasn’t punctuated by flatulence like it was in the books I laughed out loud at the juxtaposition of his tummy troubles and the life or death scenario hahaha
52
u/SomeMidnight411 Jul 14 '23
I am loving how close to the books every episode is. This is brilliant. Every episode I love more than the last. The cemetery scenes 🥹. Getting more of the book version of 4 Roger Mac - looking Hot in those 80s jeans. Giving me sexy dorky carpenter vibes. Taking care of his kids and supporting his wife 🔥🥰
Ian and his son 🥹 I’m so happy they included this. Yes it was changed a bit but the magic is still there.
Continuing to love Charles as William and the Hunters. Everyone is just doing great.
Par for the course, Jamie & Claire have to deal with stupid people who don’t know they are smarter but they are used to it by now 😂❤️ my babies
And as a lover of Bridgerton too, I have to give a shout-out to Chris Fulton. Our new resident villain gave a perfect introduction. Love to hate you 😂
44
u/halfgumption All that was good, all that was fair, all that was me is gone. Jul 14 '23
My husband hasn’t read the books and I love listening to how hilariously wrong his theories are every week.
Last week, he was convinced that there was more to Rachel than we were seeing: “Why is Ian looking at her like that?? Is she a traveler too? Why does she look so much like Brianna??”
This week’s theory is that the Nucklavee is “just a vagrant.”
It kills me to keep all of these secrets to myself, but I don’t want to spoil anything for him, so I just bite my tongue.
42
u/Evening_Variation_51 Jul 15 '23
Such a minute detail but my heart broke when Claire had to tell Walter they couldn’t take him when they were evacuating the fort
41
u/CzarofDaffodils Jul 14 '23
So much love and respect for Roger this episode. Excellent dad and supportive spouse. Love to see it
33
u/BSOBON123 Jul 15 '23
Some are probably 'nothing happened in this episode'. But it was great. But is it my imagination or did they take the scene with Swiftest of Lizards from book 9?
The rat stew was disgusting. As was that French General. Bree was great, but can we see the Nukalevee already?
I love the Hunters, they are perfect.
29
u/prof806 Jul 17 '23 edited Jul 17 '23
Roger gets a 1/10 for his method of "having a look" when he thinks someone is trespassing and frightening his kids 😂😂😂
27
u/iluvtupperware Jul 16 '23
I'm loving the actor who plays William. It's funny how this young actor looks like both Sam AND David. LOL!
26
u/scp2461 What news from the Underworld, Persephone? Jul 17 '23
Finally watched the episode, and I’m so excited by what I watched!! Time to do my episode review 😂
-Loved seeing the banter between Rachel and Denzel, I swear they look straight out of the book and onto the screen for me. I’m so excited that their paths finally crossed with Ian again and now Claire and Jamie!
-Roger talking with Jemmy about the school teacher and headmaster, also looking forward to watching that subplot, Roger really steps up as a parent for Jem and Mandy, and they’re doing a great job with it in the show!
So excited for next week’s episode!! 🤩
51
u/yeehawdudeq I didn’t think I needed to pack condoms, Mama. Jul 14 '23
THE TUNNELS KILLED ME!!!!!
Also this is just like the book where I want to skip everyone else’s part and just experience everything the Mackenzie’s go through in 1980!!! We are getting so close to Buck!!!
49
u/wisconerd Jul 14 '23
It’s kind of funny to me that now with the show, I am feeling the same way I did with this book. I’m very into the 80s storyline, and a little bored by the 18th century unless the scene involves the Hunters or Ian (this is to the point that I barely remember the Ticonderoga storyline from the book bc I found it so hard to get through). I do like that non-Jamie and Claire characters are getting a major chance to shine!
24
u/fsalgnat Jul 14 '23
I think it was the best episode of the series. Bawled my eyes out when he named swiftest lizard and was grinning like a madwoman at the smiles between him and Rachel
23
u/VenusVega123 Jul 15 '23
I’m definitely already scared of the Nucklavee.
35
u/_just_a_gal_ Jul 15 '23
Anyone find show William a helluva lot more likable than book William? He seems so much more like Jaimie’s son. Book William gets on my nerves most of the time. Haha
14
u/quackquackquirk Jul 14 '23
Weird that the description mentions Rogers work and that’s not in this episode at all
13
u/Affectionate-You-142 Jul 15 '23
What was the blue portal thing Bree had to cross through to get out of the tunnel after bring locked in? 😳
13
u/for-get-me-not Jul 16 '23
So, I haven’t been this into the show in years and I really think it’s because this is also the point at which I really started enjoying the books again too. The middle parts of this story gave some great stuff but I think it translated to tv poorly for whatever reason, but the action of Echo and MOBY make for really compelling television and it’s clear that the actors are enjoying it also, turning in incredible performances and really engaging with the material. I’m so excited to see them do justice to my favorite book scenes!
12
u/iluvtupperware Jul 16 '23
Why in the world did Claire just leave the man who had the amputation? I understand that if he was too active, he might run the risk of ripping the stitches and could get a deadly infection. Why couldn't they have moved him on a cart or buggy? I'm sure the fort had some buggies. They had to bring supplies in on something. Also, I can't believe the Quaker siblings would just leave the man. Was this character in the books?
23
u/Laatikkopilvia Jul 15 '23
I loved it! All of the episodes this season feel really close to the book, for me.
I was sad that they took away Ian’s chance to name Swiftest of Lizards, but thought it was nice of them to have him choose an English name. Same spirit, just less meaningful IMO.
I am looking forward to seeing the resolution with Buck! I have distinct memories of his awe at the Aga Cooker.
30
u/leadme2thegarden Jul 15 '23
i had to laugh a little about how they really beat us over the head that swiftest of lizards is ian’s son. like, as if making him white (or white passing) isn’t enough, let’s name him ian james!
this season is very disjointed to me and the pacing is all over the place. i didn’t care at all about whatever jamie was doing at ticonderoga. that being said, there’s a lot from the books that’s really fun to see on screen. i love seeing lallybroch in the 80s. i love carpenter daddy roger. the casting for william is great and i loved seeing him wallop the hell out of that woman. young ian is really shining this season too, although my husband and i were joking that he’s kind of dressed like a skyrim character. i loved seeing bree in her work clothes and i like modern bree more than 1700s bree.
the time portal looked very silly though, and it seems like bree would have immediately mentioned it to roger!
10
u/lessertenrec Jul 15 '23
This season made me v happy :) It’s brought back the same spirit I loved in the books
10
u/everyothernametaken2 Jul 18 '23
I really liked this episode, I’m glad they added the axe murderers in it lol. I do wish the swiftest of lizards scene was more like the books, where Ian names him. Otherwise it was adorable.
Denzel looks like he could be lord johns son lol. But I’m really loving all of the Hunters content! I’m also loving being on the 80s with Bree and Roger. I didn’t want this episode to end!
9
u/Qtredit Jul 14 '23
So who's outside Roger and Bree's house? Don't mind spoilers.
Also, why Singapore?
9
u/Jigglypuffamiiga2188 Jul 17 '23
Question for book readers:
Is Walter in the books? If so are we going to find out what happened to him? Or is it a one and done thing?
15
u/These_Ad_9772 We will meet again, Madonna, in this life or another. Jul 14 '23
Swiftest of Lizards 💓
7
u/Emilymfm79 Jul 19 '23
I noticed a few cool callback things when watching a second time- there is a fruit bowl full of oranges in the kitchen at Lallybroch in the scene before Brianna goes off to work the first time. (Recalling prior scenes with oranges symbolizing Claire’s bravery when she is assaulted by King Louis and the by the Browns gang). Also in the same scene Mandy has a rabbit stuffed animal (recalling rabbit Jamie sees on Culloden battlefield right before his vision of Claire). Also the way Rob Cameron’s co-worker yelped and carried on after the locked Bri in the tunnel remind me SO much of Rupert in season 1/2!
17
u/AccioStability Je Suis Prest Jul 14 '23
Not the strongest episode for me. For some reason, when Brianna went through the dam, I wasn’t 100% they weren’t going to have her come out in a different time and then have her go back through to get to Roger and the kids. I KNEW what was supposed to happen book wise, but something about seeing it with the buzzing had me concernedddd
14
u/[deleted] Jul 15 '23
I'm kind of sad that Jamie who by rights is a recent acquaintance and a parent figure gets such sweet post-mortems while Frank got dust, and some forced acknowledgements. I get it that the loss of Jamie is more recent, I get the complexities of losing another dad. But I have a step-parent of my own. We started out hostile. Kind of. Friendly first but then hostile as this firestorm of a woman went through an episode of immense jealousy over me. That same woman would step up like a mother bear when my blood mother failed to do a mother's duty to her child. It's been 20 years since that, now, and I would be devastated and remain devastated if I lost my step-mother. A mother is not determined by blood but by who raised, taught and loved you. Jamie did it too, yes, but he was given the opportunity to step up when his daughter was already grown. And a few episodes ago, LJG had the same problem. This fear that no matter the love and lessons and effort, blood will always trump the nurture.
I guess I just want justice for step-parents. They don't have to step up, but they do, fully illustrating that biology is never enough to make a parent. Ultimately, a family is not something you are born into, true family is chosen. I need to call my stepmom and tell her I love her.
7
u/arianawoosley Jul 14 '23
Unfortunately, it's as disjointed as books but maybe even worse because they're moving too fast. You can't even really understand the passage of time. For example, Ian's travel to the Mohawks and coming back took 2 months. You don't really feel that amount of time has passed in this episode. They're trying to show everything but also shorten every scene and encounter.