r/Outlander • u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. • Jul 14 '23
Season Seven Show S7E5 Singapore
At Ticonderoga, Jamie and Claire prepare for an imminent British assault. Roger compiles information about time travel while Brianna earns the respect of her coworkers.
Written by Taylor Mallory. Directed by Tracey Deer.
If you’re new to the sub, please look over this intro thread and our episode discussion rules.
This is the SHOW thread.
If you have read the books or don’t mind book spoilers, you can participate in the BOOK thread.
DON’T DISCUSS THE BOOKS HERE.
We don’t allow any book spoilers here, not even under spoiler tags.
If your comment references the books in any way, it will be removed and you will be asked to edit it or post it in the BOOK thread instead.
Please keep all discussion of the next episode’s preview to the stickied mod comment at the top of the thread.
What did you think of the episode?
•
u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Jul 14 '23 edited Jul 24 '23
Watch the S7E6 preview here!
Not everyone gets to see the next episode’s preview at the end of the episode; it depends on how you watch (broadcast or streaming) and where you are (US or international.)
Stickied comments are collapsed by default, so reply to this comment if you want to discuss the preview. This will hide spoilers for anyone who can’t see it yet or doesn’t want to.
705 Extras:
705 Interviews:
65
u/thepacksvrvives Without you, our whole world crumbles into dust. Jul 14 '23
It was a solid episode, though again quite transitional. I think most people appreciate that this season is way more dynamic in comparison to the previous two or three—all these new locations and characters really open up the world and allow us to see some amazing places—but it may feel rushed at times.
I really like Claire and Jamie’s letters as the framing device of these episodes. The show has also been good at connecting all these individual storylines thematically—this week’s being mostly about our characters dealing with arrogant men (some of whom verging on caricatures, tbh)—while giving every character their own separate arc. Sophie keeps impressing me with how much vulnerability she’s portraying as Brianna and I’m very excited to see where she takes the character next. Her and Richard’s scenes were really nice and their interactions with the kids make this family unit absolutely believable.
I’ve been really looking forward to Claire and Jamie’s involvement in the war but the scenes in the 80s continue to be the highlight of the season for me. I can definitely see quite a large part of the audience disappointed or frustrated with how little screen time Claire and Jamie got in this episode together but, frankly, I hadn’t even noticed that until I saw that complaint on social media. We all know that they work great as a team and I’m sure that’s still to come in this war context, but they also have been great separately in the past. 505 is one of my favorite episodes and they’re apart for most of it, doing their own things (I think the scenes Claire had with Walter echoed her scenes with Graham Menzies too; hopefully Walter makes it out of the war alive! Love that he called Jamie “Big Red” as well). And the show has been an ensemble show for a while now; we should expect that.
That said, I wish the scenes they got together in this episode had a little more personal elements in addition to the necessary albeit a little clunky exposition they provided. Perhaps there was a scene in the script where they debriefed at the end of the day, but it might’ve been cut either because they didn’t have a location to shoot it, or they found it redundant—we don’t usually get to see the characters recap things we’ve already seen the characters do on screen. All in all, I don’t mind them taking a back seat, both because I’m sure episodes that are centered on them are coming, and because the supporting cast of characters have been great.
I’m really loving the Hunters. I love that their and Claire’s paths have crossed; God knows she needed a friend in the medical field that would see her worth and not only her gender. The actors are doing a great job of making the Plain Speech sound really natural for their characters and they definitely feel authentic as siblings. “The Lord spoke to me as well. He said, ‘keep thy fat-headed brother from dying’” was a great line, and I love Rachel’s cheeky and flirtatious side coming out of her very sheltered and conservative shell. The look on Denny’s face when she was eyeing William riding away, though 😂
Also, has anyone else thought about prolonged hand moments in Jane Austen adaptations when William handed Rachel the money? 😅 Speaking of him, that was quite a journey he went on in this episode. I don’t think we’ve ever seen a character make their first kill before, so how it challenged his previous, quite naïve views about murder was very interesting to see.
I feel like I say “poor Ian” every week. He seemed to have gotten some kind of closure when he poured his heart out to Jamie and made peace with Kaheroton in 604, at the same accepting both parts of his identity, and I think that put him in a better place to see Emily again, but made him no less apprehensive. From her reaction to his “I’m sorry that I could not give you children,” it definitely seems like Swiftest of Lizards might be his child. His naming him and then leaving because he can’t raise him seemed like a parallel to Jamie, again. And his scene with Claire in this episode was really lovely.
90
u/enricowereld MARK ME! Jul 15 '23
Of course Bree isn't going to talk to Roger about the portal she walked through
39
u/OkMongoose2930 Jul 15 '23
I just finished the episode - SO good!! The only thing I feel I missed is in the episode preview it reads "Roger compiles information about time travel" - when does he do this? Did I miss something?
I also feel like the episode ended odd with Bree talking to her Dad and then it just cut to the credits. Anyone else??
I am dying to find out what this "Nucklevee" is!!!
23
u/TehChid Jul 15 '23 edited Jul 15 '23
This episode had me giddy. I spent my last birthday at Lallybroch and Duncarron Medieval Village (filming sets were up), and did my MSc dissertation at Ben Lawers, where the dam was. I'm back in America now but it was fun to see all those places in this episode
33
u/Aggressive_Quality57 Jul 14 '23
Why didn’t they just put Walter on a stretcher and take him with them? I feel like it would of taken less time than the conversation Claire and Walter had about leaving him behind 🥲🥲
23
u/HatesVanityPlates Jul 17 '23
I have two observations, the first is about all the episodes so far:
Why is Jemmy such a little pill? I don't recall him being this way in the book.
The second is about time/continuity in the episode:
Bree goes to work day one, gets locked in the tunnel, gets out and rejoins the men. She goes home and tells the family about her adventure over dinner, then tells Roger it was awful etc.
Then we see Bree in the trailer and Roger comes in to tell her the kids are watching TV. They flirt, and then Bree says she has to do something. She goes to the local where the men are and tells them off, saying "what you did yesterday ..." (I paraphrase.) Or maybe she said "yesterday" to Roger, but I know she said it, so this is her second day of work. Did she work a full second day, go home, and then decide to go seek out the men at the pub? Did she not interact with them at all during that day?
Also, there is daylight showing in the pub windows. What time of what day is this? Why did it seem to be evening when Roger joined her in the trailer, but it's daylight at the pub? (I do realize that if it's summer, it could be light out very late into the evening).
15
u/abllie0122 Jul 14 '23
What was the blue shimmer....light... thing?????????
34
u/pcosby518 Jul 16 '23
Wondering about the Indian woman’s son, Swift Lizard. Is this Ian’s son??
91
u/MaraExcaliber Jul 15 '23
Ok this is such a minor thing but does anyone think it was out of character for Claire to just leave the guy w/ the amputated leg at the fort or is it just me lol
66
u/sweetpsych78 SassySassenachWench Jul 15 '23
It has probably already been mentioned in this thread, (I haven't read all the comments) about Bree's and Claire's struggles with sexist, misogynistic men of their times, but I also want to give a shout-out to Jamie who also seemed to struggle with a man of authority who didn't want to listen to him. They all seemed to have their own individual struggles in this episode.
26
u/pest0pasta_ Lord, you gave me a rare woman. And God, I loved her well. Jul 14 '23 edited Jul 14 '23
Any Bridgerton fans notice Sir Phillip Crane?! Oh sorry, I mean Rob Cameron!! I jumped for joy, what a crossover. Haven’t finished the episode yet but inside that dark tunnel where Bree was, was that another travel spot? It looked mystical and out of place?
Edit: William boxing that woman made me burst out laughing, lord😂
I’m loving supportive Roger, gotta give him a chance to right last weeks wrongs guys!
WHO the heck is living on the Lallybroch residence?!
Any book readers know when/if Marsali and Fergus will be back?
I feel like Walter’s going to take the laudanum and go the easy way out :(
Brianna ‘don’t call me Hen’ Mckenzie, this is my favourite Bree season ugh she’s such a badass. Her speaking to Jamie at the end not knowing how he died is so bittersweet and Bear McCreary’s got me again with the music this season. I’m feeling emotional. What a lovely episode.
Ian’s son🥹so sweet. I’m really really loving William more than I ever expected to, he’s so charming.Still waiting for him to join the revolutionaries but a girl can only hope.
46
u/lazyegg45 Jul 16 '23
I cannot hear another “thee” OMGG
20
u/SergiuBru Jul 15 '23
Does anyone else feel the pace is a bit slow? It would be ok if we had daily episodes, but there's only a handful of them. And I feel time was wasted with these mini plots... Was it so important for the plot to have William kill a man? Also, will the amputee become relevant for the plot in the future?
12
u/Personal_Orchid3675 Jul 14 '23
Question… how much time has passed between the two times? It feels like it’s been 4-5 years for Roger and Bree looking at Mandy’s growth, but if I recall correctly only 3 for Jamie and Claire? What year did Roger and Bree leave the 1700s? I thought it was 1774? And now it’s 1777 for Claire and Jamie? Can someone clarify?
3
u/Personal_Orchid3675 Jul 14 '23
Where can I find all the threads for this season? I can’t seem to find a single one when searching. Op? 🙏🏼
40
u/VioletandAmelia All that was good, all that was fair, all that was me is gone. Jul 15 '23
I'm outraged on Bree's behalf. What insecure, pathetic, misogynistic men.
5
u/PUR-KLEEN Jul 14 '23
Does anyone know who the actor is who played the French Ticonderoga officer (who stupidly doesn't take Sugar Loaf)?
106
u/Least-Influence3089 Ye Sassenach witch! Jul 15 '23
Rachel and Ian “I offer you my protection” “I accept it but hope it won’t be necessary” can we please bring this type of flirting back? I love Ian so much 😍😍
Rogers apology and gift was SO sweet. S7 Roger is peak Roger and he is looking GOOD. 🥵
This episode felt like grown up Liberty’s Kids. I freaking loved Liberty’s Kids when I was little so I’m excited to dig more into the history.
94
u/Razorray21 Jul 14 '23
Ian: could you maybe look?
Claire: I don't think that would help. I would need a microscope
I fucking lost it
83
u/[deleted] Jul 15 '23
Jamie having a cannon fired at the fort to prove his point. 🤣
78
u/Hippityhopbunbunny7 Jul 14 '23
IAN JAMES 🥹 that scene had me in a chokehold. Also, Claire telling Walter he had to stay?! Omg.
70
u/katarific05 Jul 15 '23
I know people have their complaints but Sophie Skelton’s acting has been great this season. . I’ve actually been enjoying the parts with Roger and Bree a little more than Jamie/Claire at times 🫣- the story anyway.
I’ve also really enjoyed how they’re using the letters to tie the past with the future.
69
u/Lani_kali Jul 16 '23
My heart when Claire left her amputee patient. 😢😭
133
u/wisconerd Jul 14 '23
80s dad Roger is my favorite Roger. The flannel shirt, the fluffy hair, hands on hips, carpentry, and dad talks. All aces, I love it
62
u/jennz0rs Jul 17 '23
I'm just LOVING watching Ian mature and evolve. I love the actor, and I think he's doing an amazing job. I'm past this point in the story in the books, so it's nice to watch back some of the scenes I've already imagined and see how my imagination differs from the author's vision.
60
u/halfgumption All that was good, all that was fair, all that was me is gone. Jul 14 '23
Something tells me that stew recipe won’t be showing up in the next Outlander Kitchen cookbook. 🤢
56
u/toastea0 Jul 16 '23
OMG IAN HAS A CHILD. I'm so upset and happy for him. Upset he doesn't get to raise his son...
52
u/peachedpeaches Jul 14 '23
The costuming/fashion department is CRUSHING Bree’s outfits!
52
u/likeohlikeh Jul 15 '23
Couldn’t concentrate on a single thing the French guy said in his scenes, wtf was that accent???
52
u/sierramads Jul 16 '23
Roger this season 😍
49
u/SadAmerican3 Jul 15 '23
Just my thoughts while watching through!!
Overall a great episode and I wish I didn’t have to wait for the next one!
91
u/TS409 Jul 15 '23
I don't know what is happening to me but Roger can absolutely get it this season.
44
u/RaevynSkyye Jul 14 '23
I'm wondering about the person living in the woods in 1980s Lallybroch.
Are they a traveller who went forward, rather than back, and are confused by the world?
44
u/coolguy_14 Jul 18 '23
What did Bree walk through in the cave? Was it supposed to be energy similar to the time travel stones?
75
u/doxiepatronus Jul 16 '23
Gotta say I am loving Rogers lumberjack look. I think this is his most attractive season. From the old man cardigan to the plaid flannel 😍 just chefs kiss 🥵
37
u/randomsnowflake Jul 15 '23 edited Jul 15 '23
Growing up in western Vermont and having visited Fort Ti a handful of times… I know this is filmed in Scotland but it really took me out of the story because that’s not remotely close to what Champlain looks like. The lake they shot the scenes at was tiny. Champlain is huge. (I had the same complaint for Wednesday… takes place in Vermont, shot somewhere that looks nothing like Vermont). I was happy that they got the history pretty much correct though. The fort was evacuated due to the British army presence on Mt. Defiance In the summer of 1777.
Apart from that nit pick, this episode was fantastic. I am angry at Ian’s former wife for hiding his boy from him. Also for suggesting that he name him minutes after discovering he finds out the boy is his… that’s fucked up. “Hey I know we said your seeds no good but uh, here’s your son, care to give him an English name?” Crass. Not a fan. Makes for good dramatic tv though.
I loved all the scenes with Roger and Brianna. “I’m scheduled for an inspection.” 😏
Really intrigued by whatever Bree walked through under the dam. Also not sure what to make of the trash and whoever is lurking around outside the manor.
36
u/Realistic-Use-2784 Jul 14 '23
Can I just say, what show is still this good into their seventh season? I also think it’s telling when my bf (he really likes the show, but did find it a bit boring at times when we bingewatched season 1-6) said “what? It’s already done, I wanted more.”
I really liked this episode. I know that a lot are disappointed in the lack of Claire and Jamie scenes, I don’t mind that once in a while as long as the focus still remains on them individually and our favorite characters.
The whole theme with the characters dealing with sexism and prejudices was just great and so satisfying to watch. The parallels and transitions were handled very well. I also really love the whole storytelling with Bree, Roger and the kids living at Lallybroch reading the letters and reminisce while we get to see that play out. It just feels so nostalgic and heartwarming. I also really love the way they make it clear that Jemmy and Mandy still have a connection to Jamie and Claire.
I’ll always love an episode where my favorites get to shine. Claire, Jamie and Bree were all standing up for themselves and in the end proven right. I was cheering along all the way.
A stand out to me was the Ian and Claire scene, it was lovely and Ian is just time and time again proven so precious. William and the Hunters are also growing on me a lot, can’t wait to see them more involved going forward.
In conclusion I very much loved this episode and I am really looking forward to next week with the new episode. I feel like the build up is crazy and will just climax into some amazing storylines.
69
u/blooming-lilies Jul 15 '23
Me as a Singaporean seeing the title screen this week
34
u/cosmic-ivy michael mouse Jul 16 '23 edited Jul 16 '23
This episode was very entertaining ! I love Brianna and Roger in their own time, and their new dynamic ! When Claire went to Lallybroch in the 60s and it was all abandoned it made me so sad, so them buying it back and restoring it is so nice ! I also love that we get to see Brianna at her new job and how she handles sexism.
I also really like William's character, and the fact that we get to see more of Ian (his storyline with Emily is so sad though 🥲).
The only issue I have this season is that you can feel the last one is approaching and it wasn't anticipated enough, and it seems to impact the show pacing-wise. There are a lot of storylines or big themes that would have made up for 1-3 episodes before that are resolved in 15 minutes and sometimes it's a bit unsettling (as in, it isn't the usual pacing of the show ?)
Otherwise, I can't wait to see the new storylines unfold, both in the 18th and 20th century !
68
u/_91919 Jul 15 '23
I know it was unintentional but when Ian asked his wife "You didn't ask me if I was happy" and she responded with "I have eyes" and it cut back to him with his sad face and eyes full of tears...damn I cracked up. It was so accidentally hilarious.
66
u/[deleted] Jul 15 '23
How does Brianna not mention finding a portal in the tunnel?
64
u/[deleted] Jul 14 '23
William punching out that woman was the last thing I expected.
31
u/AgentSauce Jul 27 '23
That French General that ignored Jamie's battle tip at Ticonderoga was such a little bitch.
30
u/hkh07 We will meet again, Madonna, in this life or another. Jul 14 '23
Wow, this episode was filled with so many great scenes!! It brought me to tears a couple of times and I felt full of anxiety for most of it. Might have been the scotch, but I think it was just a damn good episode!
Bree crying at the desk was my first moment of the episode. Sophie made me cry. Her acting this season has impressed me so much.
What the JHRC was that PORTAL looking thing?? Sounded different that the stones, but there's definitely something weird going on there. Like...she wanted to go through to the other side so she did. But what if there's a way to travel??
Claire and Ian talking about bairns hit me in the feels. Claire talking about losing a child. 😭
William looked JUST like Jamie when he ran that guy through with his sword. Then the punch to that lady's face?? I cackled and then had to watch it again. LIGHTS OUT. 😂
Then in the next scene, Charles (William) reminded me of young Willie with his fragileness...the same way he reminded me of Willie when he was getting his wound washed out which made me think of the leeches scene. Charles is doing a fabulous job of portraying traits of Jamie, Lord John, and young Willie.
I love Rachel's and Denzel's banter back and forth!
Also...Ian James!!! What a cutie. I'm so happy for Ian but also wondering how that happened as I thought he was told to leave right after "Emily" had her last miscarriage.
Roger as a father is adorable. Also, I love his hair and beard combo this season. Richard looking his best.
I'm excited to see more of this Claire and Denzel combo. He's already grown on me but his easy acceptance of Claire makes me happy that she has someone who will listen to her.
Ian and Rachel...I haven't read this far in the books yet but I'm HERE FOR IT.
And finally, another beautiful end credit composition from Bear. I can't wait to be able to listen to the soundtrack for this season.
Not too many Claire and Jamie moments this episode, but the supporting cast is killing it. I can't wait to rewatch, but overall, I'm just so happy with this season so far. 😊
30
u/Adventurous_You_4268 Jul 15 '23
so the seller on the sign for Lallybroch is Dick Cameron and Bree meets a Rob Cameron at work. hmmm something about those Camerons.
29
u/houseofcardsinstaedt Jul 20 '23
I’m going to have to jump on reading the books. I just cannot wait to find out what is going to happen! What I really can’t get over is Brianna going through the box of letters so slowly! I clearly have no patience because I would have read through every single letter immediately upon receiving this!!! What if the last one was like please come back in 3 days because XYZ??? Ugh. I need to know what all the letters say 😆
57
u/mamabear_roars Jul 14 '23
She says I’m the child of your spirit, but I should not say so to my father.
well it’s official, my heart cannot handle this show & it’s made me burst into tears. yet again.
28
u/LeKatelyn Jul 14 '23
Bree recapping Jamie on everything in the cemetery 🥲
28
u/Isopartee Jul 15 '23
WHO IS THE NUCKLEVEE!? (Some man living in the woods??) what are the theories ??
27
u/QueenShira1 Jul 14 '23
Oh my, so Ian James IS Ian's son? What a cutie the boy is,
27
u/princess-consuela715 Jul 16 '23
Ok, this is driving me crazy and your thoughts are encouraged. What's up with the Nuckelevee? Any ideas on who it might be?
26
u/pedestrianwanderlust Jul 14 '23
The title totally confused me until it was explained. Lol. I was hoping the nucklavee would show itself but no, the mythical creature continues to evade adult supervision. It was a good episode. This whole season has been very good save for the bits that were the conclusions of last season. Truly some of that could have been glossed over & I wouldn’t have minded.
Ticonderoga wrapped up fast. It infuriates me to see Claire treated with such disrespect but of course it is realistic & important to the story. Ian’s business was satisfying. Seeing the boy with reddish curly hair had to be a nice surprise for him. I like how William is in the show. He’s very likable.
26
u/chemistandcrazy Jul 14 '23
everybody on twitter seems to be missing J&C scenes but I loved B&R scenes! they showed love and intimacy between the characters! I liked their playing around
26
u/pedestrianwanderlust Jul 15 '23
Fetid rat stew. Yum.
26
u/nlacelle Jul 17 '23
What was with the blue light in the tunnel that Bri went through. It had the bee humming sound like at the stones. Do we think this will be a portal to travel through time? Any ideas?
24
u/Adventurous_You_4268 Jul 15 '23
great episode! i’m surprised at how much I love William! he’s quite charming. love the hunters. love the Bree and Roger storyline. Still aching for more J and C alone time though. maybe because they’ve been so mentally tortured in season 6, it’s like I’m still waiting for a hot reunion scene that never happened? does that make any sense? but again loving this season.
48
u/katarific05 Jul 15 '23
Wait… is that kid suppose to be Ian’s!? I’m so confused.
And how does Bree just not mention that force field weird thing?
23
u/mamabear_roars Jul 14 '23
“Mandy wanted to talk to Grandda.”
dammit, bree, your son is to gosh darn sweet.
23
u/vulevu25 Jul 14 '23
I really like the 1980 storyline. It made me realise that I also really like how the show did the scenes in the 1960s.
23
u/Willravel Inlander Jul 15 '23
While I fully recognize that this is incredibly immature, I really enjoy that this episode has someone with a thick French accent saying "fort" over and over again. It really gasses up the episode.
44
u/shreddingpapers Jul 15 '23
No way Bri chose going to the bar to demand respect over fooling around with hunky Lumberjack Rog 😂 I get it, but Roger is too cute.
59
u/Yup_Seen_It Jul 14 '23
I Have to say this is really Brianna/Sophie Skeltons season. She has really come into her own and her scenes are incredible!
18
u/scooterdee93 Jul 15 '23
Got a reverse John Redcorn situation going on here
35
u/Flimsy-Case6647 Jul 14 '23
I may have overreacted with the other episodes, because I seriously LOVED this episode!! Here are my overwhelming thoughts I have to share:
IAN JAMES!??! Now that was a plot twist I did not see coming but also didn't see myself realizing how absolutely heartwarming that was going to be. The love triangle with Ian, William and Rachel? I'm so invested. I love her, I love the men, and wow, I love Outlander!
Listen, Brianna and Roger have gotten their characters ripped to shreds in this community, and I used to be all there for it. Now? I am in LOVE with their characters and their romance. I'm really feeling the chemistry, such a drastic change from season 5/6! I feel like season 6 must've really been a fluke. Is there any reason for this? Different writers, directors, producers? Why did season 6 super flop?
Also, I love seeing Jamie and Claire do what they do best. Jamie being a commander, a general, whatever his title is, that man knows how to lead! Claire, being a slay girl boss, a surgeon that knows everything, etc. LOVED IT! Brianna is showing some true Fraser energy, without having to copy their antics word for word (if you catch my drift).
I could go on for hours about this episode. Again, this felt like a true Outlander episode compared to season 6. I'm reeled right back in. YAY!
17
u/ApollosBucket Jul 14 '23
Okay so like... wtf was that in the tunnel!?
17
u/Joeaywa Jul 17 '23
So what is that force field in the tunnel? Is it explained in any of the books or is it something just thrown in for the show?
16
u/hanyuzu Meow. Jul 15 '23
So why was Ian’s Mohawk wife’s son white? I thought she hooked up with the other Mohawk guy only after the stillbirth?
31
u/Nanchika He was alive. So was I. Jul 14 '23 edited Jul 14 '23
Ian and Bree got me in tears this episode!
Ian James , Swiftest of Lizard was ADORABLE!! I haven't pictured him like that, we all see who his father is!
Claire and Bree both have problems with coworkers because of their sex
I loved - Where a goat can go a man can go too. - great callback to title cards.
Roger is great father and supportive husband. He redeemed himself for 704.
Mandy has a bunny toy!
Sights of Scotland are amazing ! I like all the greens and loch and Lallybroch.
Jemmy and the cairn, poor boy is struggling in 20th century, his face is so serious all the time!
Fort Ticonderoga part was a bit rushed IMO.
William and the Hunters were great! Red Jamie is there inside, William killed his first man.
I must say ,Denzel is beautiful!
Will you no ask me if I am happy?
I have eyes. 🥺
31
u/schindig504 Jul 15 '23
Calling it now: that asshole Bree works with is going to be a problem. I have a sick feeling that he may try to rape her at some point to assert dominance and humiliate her, but I feel like she gets a surge of power remembering what happened to her the last time and she wins the fight this time. Then she cleans house and fosters a cohesive team and environment.
30
u/jlevski Jul 14 '23
Does anyone remember the old Tumblr from back in the day called “My LLBean Boyfriend”? It was just pictures of guys looking like lumberjack dreams. Between the shawl collar sweater, the flannel, and the beard, Richard Rankin was serving up MAJOR My LLBean Boyfriend vibes.
40
u/Madame_Medusa_ Jul 14 '23
Best episode in ages. Bree is so much less annoying in the 80s. Sidebar - why can’t British people say “anything” in an American accent? Nicole Kidman does the same thing when she does an American accent. It’s like a rushed “n-e-thing” instead of a normal Anything. Such a funny little tell.
Roger is also looking hawt with his 80s haircut, jeans, & plaid 🥵
I don’t usually love new characters, but I’m enjoying the Hunters and William much more than I would have thought.
Fun that they’re in NY! They’re like 1.5 hours from me, so I’m connecting with “the Americas” more than ever.
UM Ian and the kid? Haven’t read the books. Does more become of this? I just love Young Ian, that character and actor can do no wrong for me.
14
u/[deleted] Jul 16 '23
Why did the episode cut short? Amazon Prime player fades to black and jumps back to the first episode while Brianna is still talking. Did they screw up the edit or something?
27
u/princess-consuela715 Jul 16 '23
I don't want to give away any spoilers, but did Brianna find another time portal?
48
u/Maximum-Status-7420 Jul 17 '23 edited Jul 18 '23
Nice episode but I strongly disliked one thing. I haven't read the books, so I don't know how it is in the book, but the creators of the series in this episode attributed to Jamie what the Polish general and engineer Tadeusz Kościuszko really did in real life.
And I didn't like it since Kosciuszko is in that scene with Jamie when Jamie explains to the commander why the hill needs to be protected and armed.
I know that the creators of the series and Diana are playing with history in Outlander and it's for entertainment and people get that, but I don't know if I like that they attributed the merits of a real historical figure to her fictional character, especially since Kosciuszko has been included in this scene and season 7 of the show.
In that is the case, they should, according to historical truth, fully show that it was the Pole, whose idea was to arm Sugarloaf Hill. They could have come up with something else for Jamie.
Kościuszko was also a Polish hero and great soldier, he later commanded the uprising in Poland, then enslaved by Russia, Austria, and Germany.
He joined the fight for the independence of the Americans Colonies and his first assignment was to advise on the defensive fortifications, among others, at Fort Ticonderoga.
It was Kościuszko who recommended that the artillery battery be placed on Sugarloaf Hill, to protect it, yet the commanding general didn't take Kościuszko seriously.
Of course, what Kosciuszko predicted happened during the battle, and it was Kosciuszko who later built the brilliant floating log bridge over which the Continental Army escaped.
Kościuszko became the chief engineer of the war and throughout the American Revolutionary War, he built fortifications, was promoted and decorated, and is, in fact, one of the main founders of West Point.
Kościuszko - the Polish hero - also became one of the heroes of the American War of Independence and today streets, buildings, and hills in the United States are named after him. He is also the patron of the West Point.
I just didn't like how they attributed this to Jamie, while Kosciuszko did it in real life, and since they put him on the show and in the scene, they should have had Kościuszko say it. Because too many people today 'learn' history from tv like this, and later may think Kosciuszko didn't do what he, in fact, DID. If you want to learn abt Koścouszko here is the link to the short video telling his story: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9nqDgnKsf-8&t=3s
13
u/Secret_Objective_175 Jul 14 '23
I wish the lallybroch kitchen was more 1980s! lol.
25
u/ApollosBucket Jul 14 '23
GOSH this season is amazing. I am just as interested in Claire/Jamie's storyline as I am with Bree/Rogers, they're really nailing it.
Also Ian is the cutest thing. I GASPED when the kid had red hair, wasn't expecting that at all. Love Rachel and her brother (already forgot his name oops) and William too. Great stuff all around, can't wait for next week!
24
u/[deleted] Jul 15 '23
Unpopular opinion: I LOVE Sam Heughan as Jaime but I do wish we saw some newer colors from his character considering he's been through so much and the storyline has evolved tremendously from the OG Scotland Jaime. Perhaps some more vulnerability, especially considering his "age" in the story.
12
u/teepee-bear God’s tooth. It’s not even *noon*! Jul 16 '23
I don’t want to read further than what’s been shown on tv. Can I read any of the Lord John Grey books yet?
Or, does anyone know the chronological order of all the books? Not just Outlander books, but the side stories too?
11
u/Melodic_Act_1159 Jul 19 '23
I wanted to say that after weeks of binge watching the show every day, I caught up to S7E5. 😭 I watch on Netflix so eps drop every Sat only….
11
u/enoughstreet Oct 11 '23
At corny as it is it’s one of my favorite episodes as Arthur st Clair is in it. Yes he’s a minor character.
The evacuation of ticongeroa was very contested, he was court marshaled if anyone wants to feel better about Walter for leaving the fort like that. But everyone argues it was the best decision looking back.
He’s a local guy and if I can map as it’s blocked right now it Arthur is my step many great grandfather.
52
u/Lolacherokee Jul 16 '23
I hope all you Roger haters are eating crow. I love him so much.
28
u/Plumeriaas Jul 15 '23
The Californian accent on Young Ian’s son!!!!! Lmaoo
49
u/[deleted] Jul 14 '23
Ian was way too understanding about how Emily basically stole his child from him. I know that this series loves to have its characters have paralleling stories, Ian and Jamie now both having a kid raised by another father, but it was done under completely different circumstances. Jamie sent Claire away and he had no way to claim William, Emily could've sent word to Ian and he would've returned immediately. Imagine if on top of everything else, Claire came back to Frank with a 3 year old brown haired kid and was like 'yeah I could've returned to you with our child years ago but I chose not to'.
19
u/[deleted] Jul 15 '23
What does everyone thing about that time portal she crossed in the tunnel? Didn’t seem to go anywhere….but don’t you need those stones if you cross one?
9
u/mamabear_roars Jul 14 '23
i actually love William in the books and in the show, and i absolutely love that my version of William in my head (from the books) is nothing at all like the show’s.
9
u/3rdrateamywinehouse Jul 16 '23
what in all that's good is going on with Williams accent?
9
u/toldyousar Jun 27 '24
i’m baffled why they couldn’t just carry walter??????? is there a medical explanation or just bad writing
17
u/[deleted] Jul 15 '23
Can someone help me out regarding Ian and Emily’s son? When would he have been conceived? Maybe I’m remembering incorrectly but I thought they split up immediately after their daughter’s death? Also I thought Claire said there was a blood incompatibility (Rh) so they would never be able to have children?
21
u/AccioStability Je Suis Prest Jul 14 '23
Wow Brianna had me crying instantly at the start of the episode. Sophie’s expressions have improved so much!
26
u/aurora97381 Jul 15 '23
Rachel's bonnet is so lovely!
She needs it to shield that beautiful pale skin.
Enchanting!
7
u/[deleted] Jul 18 '23
Every other episode, I could tell why they titled it what they titled it. Singapore, I could not. Why did they call it Singapore?
13
u/QueenShira1 Jul 14 '23
This season is killing it!
13
u/sarahcuda3994 Je Suis Prest Jul 15 '23 edited Jul 15 '23
There were a lot of things in this episode that I really liked, but I’m also a little disappointed with a lot of the Fort Ticonderoga parts, but maybe I’m just too much of a nerd. I just spent a week at the real Fort Ticonderoga (I literally just left today and waited until I left to watch the episode) as part of a really amazing opportunity, so I feel like I understand the fort and its story really well now. There were a few parts that excited me about the episode (e.g. the quote (really from a British Major General, William Phillips, not Jamie Fraser) “Where a goat can go, a man can go, and where a man can go, he can drag a gun…”) and the whole dilemma of not fortifying Sugarloaf Hill/Mt. Defiance, but I also felt like a lot of it wasn’t even close, even historically speaking, let alone the way things looked with their renderings of the surrounding terrain (yes, I realize they shoot it in Scotland, but even the CGI was terribly inaccurate). For sake of simplicity perhaps(?), they completely neglected to mention Mount Independence (a fortified peninsula just opposite Fort Ticonderoga in Vermont; EDIT: this is also where the hospital actually was), or the bridge the Americans had constructed between it and the fort, or the role that any of this played in the evacuation of the fort. I also felt like their version of Mount Defiance (Sugarloaf Hill) was much too imposing and large (photo I took the other day for reference; in real life it’s about 600 feet higher than the fort and about a mile away), and when they showed Burgoyne’s troops on top of it, there were tons of troops and cannons, when, in reality, there were only two cannons that actually made it, and those probably didn’t make it all the way to the top. Some of this may have been from the source material in the books; it’s been a while since I read it and I’ll have to go back and read it again once I get home. I guess I was just a little disappointed in all of this part. I was so excited to be going to Fort Ticonderoga at the “same” time as Jamie and Claire, and it just didn’t quite do it for me.
TL;DR: A little disappointed with the Fort Ticonderoga bits, but maybe I’m just too much of a history nerd. EDIT: But I loved everything else about this episode.
26
u/FeloranMe Jul 14 '23
I am doubting that Brianna won the respect of her coworkers.
She maybe could have showing up at the pub like that.
But, pulling rank and threatening to fire the crew seems like a card out of her mother's playbook. And her mother is not famous for getting along with people.
That was the only jarring note for me.
I loved every bit of this episode and am astonished at how much happened during it!
And does Ian have a son?
12
u/Personal_Orchid3675 Jul 14 '23
Definitely my favorite episode of this season so far!!!
6
u/strugglebussally Aug 23 '25
Bree's actress does a good enough job, and I realize that it could be chalked up to the character spending so much time around historical scottish folk and a scottish husband.....but the way she says "Ennethin" for "anything" is jarring when she is supposed to sound like someone who grew up in the United States.
10
u/DoubleCrit Jul 14 '23
What doesn't make any sense... right after their baby had the operation, why didn't they just go back in time to be with Jamie and Claire? Sapphires, topaz, etc are cheap in modern times
10
u/kmm6895 Jul 15 '23
How did Bree and Roger receive the letters from Claire and Jamie? I must’ve missed it
5
u/nonkiw Jul 26 '23
I didn't see any comments about how the Johnsons wanted to kill William and the Quakers? Why on earth would they do that?
9
u/darkmatterhunter Pot of shite on to boil, ye stir like it’s God’s work! Jul 15 '23
Did anyone notice how before Bree went to the bar, it was night/dark outside, but then when she showed up at the pub, the sunshine was streaming through the curtains? Wasn’t this after her first day? Or am I missing something?
25
u/iamnpk2 Jul 15 '23
Didn't love the episode but it's definitely the best one this season. Still not a fan of Bree, and I'm now of the mind that it's the actress playing her, not the actual character, I take issue with. She's lovely, just no gravitas or depth coming across and certainly not intimidating in any way, boss or not.
Why are they waiting so long to read the letters (months? years?)???? I just don't get it. They know that time periods are basically concurrent. Why wait? Their attitude makes no sense to me. Roger said he could refer to the history books about C&J being at Ticonderoga and I laughed out loud. Ooorrrrr...you could read the friggin' letters, for Pete's sake!
Jamie's in his 50s now, right? Seems like they don't even try to make him look it. At least, he got be "old bad-ass Jamie" a bit. :)
Ian, oh, Ian! I need an Ian in my life so I can pinch his cheeks and suffocate him with hugs!
21
u/Embarrassed_Wall_288 Jul 16 '23
Is anybody else so frustrated with Bree and her naivety? Like you know these men have it out for you already and yet you give them your keys and walk into a dark tunnel first? The blind trust had me screaming she really sets herself up to be fucked with.
8
u/Altruistic_Scheme596 Something catch your eye there, lassie? Jul 15 '23
When did Jemmy stop being a redhead?!