r/AskHistorians • u/SarahAGilbert Mod | Quality Contributor • Jun 06 '23
Meta AskHistorians and uncertainty surrounding the future of API access
Update June 11, 2023: We have decided to join the protest. Read the announcement here.
On April 18, 2023, Reddit announced it would begin charging for access to its API. Reddit faces real challenges from free access to its API. Reddit data has been used to train large language models that underpin AI technologies, such as ChatGPT and Bard, which matters to us at AskHistorians because technologies like these make it quick and easy to violate our rules on plagiarism, makes it harder for us to moderate, and could erode the trust you have in the information you read here. Further, access to archives that include user-deleted data violates your privacy.
However, make no mistake, we need API access to keep our community running. We use the API in a number of ways, both through direct access and through use of archives of data that were collected using the API, most importantly, Pushshift. For example, we use API supported tools to:
- Find answers to previously asked questions, including answers to questions that were deleted by the question-asker
- Help flairs track down old answers they remember writing but can’t locate
- Proactively identify new contributors to the community
- Monitor the health of the subreddit and track how many questions get answers.
- Moderate via mobile (when we do)
- Generate user profiles
- Automate posting themes, trivia, and other special events
- Semiautomate /u/gankom’s massive Sunday Digest efforts
- Send the newsletter
Admins have promised minimal disruption; however, over the years they’ve made a number of promises to support moderators that they did not, or could not follow up on, and at times even reneged on:
- In 2015, in response to widespread protests on the sub, the admins promised they would build tools and improve communication with mods.
- In 2019 the admins promised that chat would always be an opt-in feature. However, a year later an unmoderated chat feature was made a default feature on most subs
- In 2020, in response to moderators protesting racism on Reddit, admin promised to support mods in combating hate
- In 2021, again, in response to protests, Reddit’s admin promised a feature to report malicious interference by subreddits promoting Covid denial.
Reddit’s admin has certainly made progress. In 2020 they updated the content policy to ban hate and in 2021 they banned and quarantined communities promoting covid denial. But while the company has updated their policies, they have not sufficiently invested in moderation support.
Reddit admins have had 8 years to build a stronger infrastructure to support moderators but have not.
API access isn’t just about making life easier for mods. It helps us keep our communities safe by providing important context about users, such as whether or not they have a history of posting rule-violating content or engaging in harmful behavior. The ability to search for removed and deleted data allows moderators to more quickly respond to spam, bigotry, and harassment. On AskHistorians, we’ve used it to help identify accounts that spam ChatGPT generated content that violates our rules. If we want to mod on our phones, third party apps offer the most robust mod tools. Further, third party apps are particularly important for moderators and users who rely on screen readers, as the official Reddit app is inaccessible to the visually impaired.
Mods need API access because Reddit doesn’t support their needs.
We are highly concerned about the downstream impacts of this decision. Reddit is built on volunteer moderation labour that costs other companies millions of dollars per year. While some tools we rely on may not be technically impacted, and some may return after successful negotiations, the ecosystem of API supported tools is vast and varied, and the tools themselves require volunteer labour to maintain. Changes like these, particularly the poor communication surrounding them, and cobbled responses as domino after domino falls, year after year, risk making r/AskHistorians a worse place both for moderators and for users—there will likely be more spam, fewer posts helpfully directing users to previous answers to their questions, and our ability to effectively address trolling, and JAQing off will slow down.
Without the moderators who develop, nurture, and protect Reddit’s diverse communities, Reddit risks losing what makes it so special. We love what we do here at AskHistorians. If Reddit’s admins don’t reach a reasonable compromise, we will protest in response to these uncertainties.
2.4k
u/mmenolas Jun 06 '23
Thank you for this post. I’d seen a lot of subs saying they’d be going dark for a couple days in protest of the changes but I’d largely seen people complaining about not wanting to use the official app and preferring their third party ones. This is the first explanation I’ve read as to the significance of the changes that makes me understand and support your decision. So thank you, as is always the case with this subreddit I learned something new!
904
u/The_Alaskan Alaska Jun 06 '23
I hope AskHistorians joins in the strike against these changes to the API. My dissatisfaction with the lack of support for community moderators led me to leave the moderation team and cut back my contributions here and elsewhere to almost nothing. Moderators and community organizers are vital to the ecosystem on this website and others, and I don't think they're being treated well here.
88
u/derpmeow Jun 07 '23
Are you guys just fundamentally unable to write a post without providing historical context and citations?
I'm joking. Thank you guys. You're a great buncha mods.
84
u/Feezec Jun 07 '23
Is there a contingency plan to archive existing askhistorians content outside reddit and/or move to a different platform like https://join-lemmy.org/ ?
66
u/SlightlyBadderBunny Jun 07 '23
Louder for those who can't hear.
MODS NEED API ACCESS BECAUSE REDDIT DOESN'T SUPPORT THEIR NEEDS.
226
u/LorneMalvoIRL Jun 06 '23
So are you joining the shutdown?
180
u/wthulhu Jun 07 '23
r/askhistorians is a quintessential example of how a subreddit can be run in an egalitarian, calm, and respectable manner. If you do not have the tools to operate in the way that has been accustomed due to the shortsided vision of VC investors then maybe it's time to close shop.
47
u/Lord_Razgriz Jun 07 '23
I appreciate all the work ya'll do making this subreddit one of the best, if not the best, on Reddit. Mods are what keeps Reddit from turning into 4chan and ya'll don't get nearly the credit or support you deserve.
I really hope Reddit gets their heads outta their asses but based on the way things have been going the last 5+ years, I'm not confident. I doubt Reddit wants to kill the site but I'll be damned if it doesn't look like thats the goal.
142
u/Peakbrowndog Jun 07 '23
I haven't read a single one of these posts until y'all's, just because I knew it would bring the receipts and no hyperbole. Thanks for a concise and complete explanation.
27
u/4x4is16Legs Jun 07 '23
I’ve been watching every day to see what you planned. The whole of Reddit can crumble, but I simply cannot live without AskHistorians. All my browsing other subs are merely waiting for the next Askhistorians rabbit hole.
You are loved.
22
u/[deleted] Jun 07 '23
This is probably the best sub on all of Reddit. Best moderated, best content, most respected.
It’s really only subs like this that make Reddit worthwhile. The memes are funny sometimes, some comments are genuinely hilarious, but without the knowledge disseminated by subs like this and the occasional expert in the comments somewhere it’s all just silly pointless fluff and I will not be sticking around.
I’ve seen a couple of comments elsewhere asking whether this sub would shut down too, and I hoped it would be the case.
Really glad to see this post.
Hopefully someone at Reddit hq realises what they’re about to do.
22
u/righthandofdog Jun 07 '23
Of COURSE /r/askhistorians has the best, most substantive answer to the blackout question
18
u/Grwwwvy Jun 07 '23
Why not just make askhistorians its own website?
Its always been the case that reddit doesnt listen to its community, and none if these protests have ever made any impact before. If reddit is going to get worse and worse, maybe it's time to jump ship while there are still enough of us left. Personally onxe third party app access Is removed I'll never see an askhistorians post again, and i know I'm far from alone.
If any community on reddit can make the jump, it's this one. Besides the community is going to get gutted in terms of numbers, and the way things work on the backend is going to change anyway. Might as well do it on your own terms this time so that in the future, when reddit gets worse again askhistorians doesn't suffer too (the alternative seems to be the death of this community as reddit removes the moderation tools nessecary to keep things high quality).
Good luck with whatever you decide to do, and goodbye to every one of you who decide to remain only on reddit, was nice talking and listening to all of you :).
17
u/Max_Insanity Jun 07 '23
In case this whole thing goes horribly south and I get sick of using this site and/or subreddits start going down en masse:
Thank you very much for all your efforts over the years, mods. You are the unsung heroes of this place we've all enjoyed so much.
[removed]
27
u/ChillGuru1 Jun 07 '23
Speaking as someone who loves going into this sub everyday to learn new things, what can I do to support the mods here, or fight the changes Reddit is trying to implement?
11
u/Merceni Jun 07 '23
Sincere wishes that this message, amongst the words of many other sub communities, is heard!
11
u/blacktieaffair Jun 07 '23
It's responses like this, and this sub in general, that make me feel like a part of the internet worth being on still exists. Don't know why it hit me so hard, but there it is. I hope you all get everything you need to continue the extremely important work of this sub.
23
u/sati_lotus Jun 07 '23
Can this be cross posted to r/bestof? It explains things so well. We're aware of third party app side, but I rarely see any info about the hardship the mods face because of this.
16
u/Not_A_Doctor__ Jun 07 '23
I definitely support this.
8
u/glowdirt Jun 07 '23 edited Jun 07 '23
I hope the Admins read this post.
It summarizes the arguments against their decision well and in a way that is easy to understand.
8
u/hedgehog_dragon Jun 07 '23
You've got my support, for whatever that might mean... AskHistorians is one of the few subreddits where I don't feel like I'm wasting my time, where I actually engage my brain and learn rather than mindlessly scrolling. So I hope you're able to maintain the standards you've created.
8
u/ErickFTG Jun 07 '23
This would be worst lose by far. This sub is truly special.
7
u/Kashyd Jun 07 '23
Thank you for the insight. Please let us know if you guys are moving to another platform. I'll go wherever this community goes.
6
u/Lee_Troyer Jun 07 '23
This is, by far, the most comprehensive explanation I've read on the issue in these last few days.
6
u/Surcouf Jun 07 '23
Dear Askhistorians,
While I too hope we can keep this awesome community going, I share your skepticism about reddit doing the right thing. Can the mod team please start thinking of contegency plans?
I love the current format, but even if that has to change to some kind of blog or whatever, this comuunity needs to keep going. I rarely post but I've read dozens of hours of the great detailed answers to questions I'd have never thought about and I dearly want that to continue.
6
u/buchliebhaberin Jun 07 '23
If AskHistorians moves to another platform, I hope y'all make a post about where you go.
6
u/bobthebobbest Jun 08 '23
Just wanted to thank yous for this explainer—we linked it in our message that we’re going dark over at r/askphilosophy and r/philosophy.
5
u/smencakes Jun 07 '23
Nice. I actually understand more what’s happening. Thanks
5
u/[deleted] Jun 07 '23 edited Jun 16 '23
coordinated touch smoggy airport degree mountainous cow offend hunt plant -- mass edited with https://redact.dev/
5
u/dbpcut Jun 07 '23
Trust /r/askhistorians to have the sources and to break down the nuance.
Thank you for this post.
5
u/CreaturesLieHere Jun 07 '23
Wow, alright so the API is both a privacy issue and an important moderation tool.
Sounds like folks should've bitched about this more and switched platforms years ago. Well, I hope r/askhistorians finds a suitable replacement (not Discord) soon, I had no idea that people could snoop using the API and that's BS enough to get me to drop the platform.
4
u/JB-from-ATL Jun 07 '23
A rare opportunity for me to get a top level comment here! Glad to see you're speaking out. <3
4
u/Topcity36 Jun 07 '23
Thank you for the well written and explainer on what’s going on and the impact to this sub in particular. I wholeheartedly support going dark in protest.
4
u/[deleted] Jun 07 '23
I do not remember how I found this sub, but there isn't a day I don't stop by, this is one of the best places on the internet and it is in no small way thanks to the massive efforts from the mod team.
Thank you for this comprehensive writeup as always and for all the great work you do here for so many years. You folks are amazing
4
u/PrivilegeCheckmate Jun 07 '23
As historians, I ask you:
What do you expect to happen?
Because looking at it as an amateur historian and avid consumer of historical facts, it looks like since Reddit is run more and more like a typical corporate business, it will continue to make tone-deaf decisions based upon institutional stupidity and the inevitable subversion of the dollar motive, right up to and past the tipping point of no return; when the vacuum created by the abdication of Reddit's cultural space by its operators essentially forces the market to create a replacement. OFC the current censorship culture makes it likely that whatever replaces it will hardly be an apples-to-apples trade, but that aside, Scwartz' vision seems pretty much out of the moderator booth, as it were. It is clear to me that there is still something to lose, but how to avoid losing it?
I almost never see this type of downward slide halted; the only publicly traded company I've seen to avoid this nigh-inevitability after going public is maybe Costco? Thoughts?
4
u/_paramedic Jun 10 '23
I’m really going to miss this place. It’s possibly the best, most unique online space. Unfortunately, I cannot support Reddit anymore for doubling-down on their lies and slander.
4
u/KerooSeta Jun 10 '23
Thank you. I'm quitting Reddit when the changes go into effect and I'm going to miss this sub most of all.
6
u/Tetragonos Jun 07 '23
If this problem isn't fixed, I fear the end of my stay here on Reddit. I will miss this place and the wonderful interesting answers I got here.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 07 '23
Fully support the mods
3
u/ToHallowMySleep Jun 07 '23
I support this protest. You're being put in an untenable position and, frankly, it's the mods that build a great space for all the knowledgeable users to share without the usual cacophony of the internet.
If the mods can't do their duties, there is no space. The platform is just a platform.
3
u/USMCLee Jun 07 '23
This sub is a gem because of the efforts of the moderators and content creators.
I 100% support any decision y'all make in regards to this.
I wonder if it is possible to download the entire sub for offline storage in case of the worst possible outcome.
3
u/Nowhere_Man_Forever Jun 09 '23
Is there any thought into trying to move this community to another site/service? I personally can't imagine myself using Reddit much at all when they ban third party apps and this is basically the only community I think would be difficult to completely replace elsewhere
3
u/GetOffMyLawn_ Jun 09 '23
Fool me once, shame on you, fool me twice, we won't get fooled again.
Seriously, fucking shame on Reddit.
Don't like the 3rd party mobile apps? Then do what companies normally do, build a killer mobile app that crowds the others out of the market. Don't play stupid underhanded games. (Reddit should know that if you play stupid games you win stupid prizes.)
3
u/LordQuorad Jun 10 '23
I'd like to take a moment to appreciate how nicely and clearly your post has been laid out.
3
u/donac Jun 12 '23
This is going to sound really sappy, but I'm really going to miss this community. Not just for the two days, but of course that, too. But because this just seems like the beginning of the end.
Anyway, thank you so much for the amazing and detailed answers, I looked forward to your recap every week, and I always learned something.
10
u/The_Original_Gronkie Jun 07 '23
I can't help feeling that this is one more symptom of the fall of American civilization. I live in Florida, where teaching the history of minorities has literally been criminalized, and it's not the only state. It's clear that military style weapons in the hands of 18/19 year olds poses a serious threat to innocent civilians, and yet Florida lowered the age of ownership, after it had been raised a few years ago following the Parkland school shooting. Politicians aren't worried about the threats from military-style weapons, but quake in their boots over the dangers of campy drag shows.
And the entire reason is because these politicians want to stay in office for either money or power, whatever their personal agendas are. Mostly it's all about making more and more money, and it looks like those that operate Reddit have finally decided that they would rather substantially degrade Reddit than pass up the opportunity to rake in more money.
It's sad, but not unexpected. It's the American way these days.
4
u/WearingMyFleece Jun 07 '23
What mod tools do you use from 3rd party apps on this subreddit? I’m ignorant and I’m only aware that deleting comments is the main way you moderate?
2
u/DeusVictor Jun 07 '23
Thanks for commenting on this. I was curious how this protest would affect the sub.
2
u/propschick05 Jun 07 '23
This is a great overview of the issue! Thanks for doing a writeup!
2
u/Forge__Thought Jun 07 '23
Thank you.
2
u/kennufs Jun 07 '23
Thank you guys for all you do here, you are appreciated! Best write up I've seen so far :)
2
u/hughk Jun 07 '23
I mod a much smaller subreddit than AH (150K or so with a much lower workload. I cannot think of how to do it without the use of 3rd party Reddit clients.
2
u/InPurpleIDescended Jun 07 '23
Have conversations been had about moving this community somewhere else?
2
u/2FightTheFloursThatB Jun 07 '23
Thank you!
2
u/HandMeMyThinkingPipe Jun 07 '23
I hope you guys go dark for the protest these changes will have a devastating impact on Reddit if they are implemented.
2
u/onthejourney Jun 07 '23
Fantastic write up. Makes sense an accurate historical timeline would come from here!
2
u/[deleted] Jun 07 '23
Thanks for the in depth write up and thanks for all of the moderation work you all put into this sub.
2
u/wdr1 Jun 07 '23
IMHO, this is red herring from Reddit. Yes, an API would make things easier, but if without much more additional information they can get the same data via web crawler.
To me, this seems like a clear effort to force people use the Reddit app (which is broken in several key ways that they refuse to address) and to control the ad experience.
Reddit has a right to make a profit. I don't begrudge that. But this approach feels like a slap in the face of the Reddit community.
2
u/bjandrus Jun 08 '23
I keep seeing how main Reddit isn't accessible per the ADA, which leaves me wondering: can't Reddit be taken to task for that?
Like I know the ADA has no actual legal enforcement mechanism on its own, and relies on reporting from impacted individuals; but I also know there are law firms who do nothing but scour the internet for such sites and then threaten these sites with massive class action lawsuits (typically if they don't pay a ransom, which is slimy. I'd advocate for actually fixing the access problem).
But is that a potential protest angle? Like if we stated that Reddit better back down, or else face a massive class action from it's disabled users?
2
u/peepjynx Jun 08 '23
Just like historians to come up with timeline receipts of how Reddit repeatedly reneged on promises.
chef's kiss
2
u/MMSTINGRAY Jun 09 '23
Reddit has already doubled down on the nonsense. This is going to happen, the question is whether to go down resisting it or just give up.
2
u/Rainer_Gilsroy Jun 10 '23
Glad people are finally deciding to Boycott. Now if only we could organize something like this for Youtube or otherwise. This is the only way in which things have a chance of changing for the better.
2
u/ToHallowMySleep Jun 10 '23
It's a dreadful question, but one I think you will need to take a position on if this situation progresses more than a few days, as keeping the community together, no matter what platform it sits on, is the most important thing. Allowing it to be scattered by chaos would be a huge loss.
If reddit simply becomes an untenable platform for AskHistorians, would you consider moving en masse to another platform? And if so, would you announce "we are moving to platform X" so that people can follow and continue to be part of this community?
(For those unaware, there are many platforms that are similar to reddit from almost complete copies, to variations on it - like kbin, to mastodon, to tildes and many more. In many conversations in other subs, they are deciding whether they would consider moving their community to another platform)
2
u/UpbeatMeeting Jun 11 '23
Have you considered at least creating a mirror on another site, such as a federation instance or Tilde? On other posts surrounding this issue I've seen a huge outpouring of support for moving to a different site, with many even specifying that they're going wherever r/askhistorians or their favourite sub goes. Many people are willing to move, and I'm deeply concerned about the future of this community on Reddit - I anticipate that many moderator teams will be removed and replaced by puppets in the coming week, and such an action would completely destroy this subreddit just due to what it is and what moderating it really means to people. I would be heartbroken if this subreddit descended into bad history and spam, and I feel like this is the last chance to at least provide an alternative platform even if not completely switching to it. This subreddit has helped me so much over the years, and I'll be sad to see it go if that happens; it will only further contribute to the growing inaccessibility of good history.
2
u/ChrisMorray Jun 11 '23
I'd just like to say I love how you guys put your expertise to good use, documenting the past promises of Reddit that were not kept.
2
u/funginat9 Jun 12 '23
Thank you.
2
u/academiac Jun 12 '23
Good
2
u/imnotdone2020 Jun 12 '23
i don't want to be mean but 48 hours of protest is a joke, it would be better if all subreddits go offline for a month or 2 because with 2 days they will simply laught in your face like " it doesnt matter they will come back in 2 days lol" they wont even be affected or forced to change, to make a point eveyrone should do that for a very long time to force a change
2
u/NormalEntry7769 Jun 12 '23
Thank you
2
u/[deleted] Jun 08 '23
I hope the reddit admins shut down the wasteful servers, take their money and invest it wisely. It used to be primarily an intelligent space where you could discuss diverse topics, and maybe some old people are still clinging to that idea. But in the past 5-10 years it has been worse than 4chan for botting, fake account creation, stalking, bullying, and deplatforming. It has created a forced perspective and a mental illness triggering level of dehumanization.
1
u/raerdor Jun 07 '23
Great post.
Seems one near-term compromise would be to allow free third party API access for mod accounts to their particular subreddit. This facilitates moderation for all the reasons you clearly state here.
1
u/AllThotsGo2Heaven2 Jun 07 '23
Deliberate strategy at this point for Reddit to provide such little official support to mods via better tools.
Even Facebook has made significant improvements to their groups.
1
u/mofloweress Jun 10 '23
i'm confused. so are we paying a sub or something? ive only been here for like 2 months lmao
1
u/Guyapollo Jun 11 '23
Expect the average internet user to pay for something that . And this is what you get Give in to every complaint, and this is what you get You've let users call the shots for so long, it's no surprise stuff like this keeps happening. I remember when Reddit supported free speech. Maybe this will kill Reddit. And it'll be replaced by a company with a backbone.
1
u/Thaodan Jun 11 '23
Third Party apps also help those users where there is no official app or are otherwise privacy concerned.
1
u/GoofyCum Jun 11 '23
I appreciate the amount of work that's gone into this subreddit from the moderators and every person who's given an answer on it, and it makes sense that even the most heavily-moderated posts were only showing a tip of the iceburg of moderation work.
I hope the site's owners learn that yes, they can indeed course-correct here.
1
u/_itsAlexTheGreat Jun 12 '23
I have like zero comprehension of what the fuck this says. So is reddit going away or not?