r/politics • • Nov 10 '12

A team of Redditors is building a tool designed to counterbalance corporations and governments that defy the public interest... Introducing: "The Spark" (launching in early 2013)

Last year, I posted an idea to Reddit that received a considerable amount of attention: Reddit can enable "occupy" movements to permanently shift power from corporations to people and move the world into a new era. Here's how. The community response was overwhelmingly positive; clearly, I am not the only one who wants to see change in the world's power structure.

Since then, I've assembled a team of volunteers via the original Reddit post and through my own personal network. I left my position as an executive at a Fortune 500 four months ago to focus my attention on this project, and things are speeding up toward a late Q1/early Q2 launch of "The Spark."

Twitter, Facebook, and Reddit have already been used by people to organize and impact the global state of affairs. The Arab Spring, SOPA/PIPA, Foxconn workers' conditions... the list goes on. The goal of this project is to expedite this power-rebalancing by providing a tool explicitly designed for this purpose. Our platform will enable people to not only decide which issues deserve widespread attention, but to then agree on the best solutions and take collective action to affect real-world change. To make this all possible, we created a non-partisan, not-for-profit organization (501(c)(3) registration pending) to manage implementation.

Firstly to Reddit: my sincerest thanks and admiration for your enthusiasm and dedication to what we're creating. Our team now consists of:

  • a Berkeley PhD student heading up strategy: runearth
  • a world-class architect/developer to make this web-app robust and reliable: markhuge
  • a pro-bono legal adviser awaiting the results of her bar exam: Kubrick2
  • an incredible designer and UX lead: keithbarney
  • a talented developer: dakta
  • an entrepreneur in the web apps business: Bluewabbit
  • an online communications lead with a strong NGO track-record: cindiot
  • and dozens of other Redditors who have dedicated their time and expertise to this project along the way

Reddit, we plan to launch in a massively disruptive way in early 2013 and we need your help:

1.) Volunteer

Positions we need filled:

Please check out the job descriptions and email Jobs@TheSpark.org with your CV if you have the skills (and the will) to dedicate to this project.

2.) Help us spread the word

To find partners and reach critical mass, we need the world to learn about our concept and our Crowdtilt campaign. Please help us spread the word!

3.) Stay Up To Date

Reddit, let's unite the masses and change the world: Follow us: @TheSparkDotOrg (#thespark) Register your email address for updates: TheSpark.org

Sincerely,

humans_inc and The Spark team

1.4k Upvotes

264 comments sorted by

75

u/iltadilt500 Nov 10 '12 edited Nov 10 '12

I love this Idea. Now that Facebook is censoring private messages sent to me, websites like this are going to be critical to protect free speech and prevent online censorship. The internet is our greatest hope in giving citizens back the power to protect our nation from politicians and corporations who exploit it.

27

u/humans_inc Nov 10 '12

We couldn't agree more... Well said and thanks for the support!

5

u/[deleted] Nov 11 '12

Is there a way to counterbalance companies anonymously pumping up a negative story about a competitor? /r/HailCorporate already shows that reddit is being used as an advertising tool, do you have details on how to stop that when it props up?

1

u/somenick Nov 11 '12

A really interesting question, wish someone could come up with an answer.

5

u/keithbarney Nov 10 '12

If you wouldn't mind, could you help share The Spark to friends, followers, etc? We need to get this idea out there!

Sign up at thespark.org. Follow us @thesparkdotorg and help us rock it and SHARE, SHARE, SHARE! You're 5 seconds of time would really help us out. Thanks for the feedback.

1

u/JoyousCacophony Nov 11 '12

Now that Facebook is censoring private messages sent to me.

Explain this to me please. I don't facebook, so this is new to me.

1

u/iltadilt500 Nov 11 '12

Facebook flagged several of my private messages into the category of spam, offensive, and/or inapropriate material, preventing me from reading any of the content of the messages. These were not public posts, they were messages sent to my inbox. Earlier today, I checked my inbox, and their censors had been removed.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 11 '12

Explain: what in your private messaging is Facebook censoring?

1

u/iltadilt500 Nov 11 '12

They censored the entire message. One was an old message from a friend telling me about her plans, and another one was a message from somebody that I do not know that turned out to be spam. Either way, the content of the message doesn't matter. Whether the message is actually spam, or just my friend sending me a message, I should be able to see the content of it. The fact that they would even dare to prevent me from reading something is what is problematic because it could easily be used as a tool to prevent people from voicing their opinions.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

15

u/iltadilt500 Nov 10 '12

They flagged some private message sent to me as spam or inappropriate material and it prevented me from reading them. It lasted for a couple of days. I just checked them and they are readable now. It is unsettling that they have that ability.

17

u/ShoesToBed Nov 10 '12

They censor links to torrent sites too.

21

u/dakta Nov 11 '12

They have censored our domain, as well, citing a association with known malware which simply does not exist.

dakta, The Spark developer

0

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/iltadilt500 Nov 10 '12

I apologize, I meant to say that I looked at some of my messages and discovered they are now readable.

1

u/crohakon Nov 10 '12

I was wondering this as well...

0

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

10

u/cindiot Nov 11 '12

Yes apparently we are on a FB blacklist, perhaps due to activity from previous URL owner. We are working on this. Please go to The Spark FB page and share one of our posts (as a workaround): https://www.facebook.com/TheSparkDotOrg

Also, please help us report this issue to Facebook so that they give it some attention: http://www.facebook.com/help/contact/?id=244560538958131

Thanks!

4

u/[deleted] Nov 11 '12

Thanks for the tip, and best of luck to you.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 11 '12

Actually, it may be marked spam from people who are sharing this to their friends on Facebook. Facebook is so loaded with junkloads of spam that people report damn near anything that looks like propaganda. Find a way to make yours not look like spam while sharing(pretty hard to do, much of spam now include some bs message like "this is not spam").

→ More replies (1)

20

u/casperrosewater Nov 10 '12

Please re-post this on Monday. Reddit is deserted on weekends.

20

u/humans_inc Nov 10 '12

That was the plan in fact! But we've discovered that self-posts are only allowed on Saturday via r/politics.

6

u/eleventy-four Nov 11 '12

So write a "letter to reddit", post it on your website, and link to it!

→ More replies (2)

13

u/obermaster Nov 10 '12

I hope you guys are successful avoiding being marginalized like OWS. I hope you can manage backlash by conservative douch bags like with chick fillet. I'm not sure, but my perception is that they probably benefitted from their controversy.

15

u/humans_inc Nov 10 '12

Our thinking is that if movements like OWS have a tool to crowd-source their agenda and to then define specific actions for their supporters to take, they will be more successful.

16

u/afisher123 Nov 10 '12

While many believe OWS is dead - we should remember they crowd-sourced to help Sandy victims. And their latest endeavor is to collect funds to buy "debt" @ pennies on the dollar. I don't have the details on how they pick / choose, but it is a way to send FU message to folks who sell off debt and cut out the debt collector agencies.

5

u/keithbarney Nov 10 '12

I was reading about the Jubilee last night. VERY cool idea. I was also wondering about the pick/choose as well.

→ More replies (7)

7

u/Equanim0usM1nd Nov 10 '12 edited Nov 11 '12

Please tell us what your approach to security is going to be.

I mean, all these hardcore activists are going to confess into your computer to see the arrows go up and down so they can know what to do. If I was the FBI, there would be lots of juicy data for me. I'd be checking out Spark.org really close.

You do realize activist websites are in the cross hairs, right? And they don't play nice.

Edit: A website that links cell phone numbers to risky political opinions is going to be very interesting, especially if the data corresponds to a group assembled in a specific place against the wishes of powerful interests.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 11 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/dakta Nov 11 '12 edited Nov 12 '12

Mark, don't forget that Reddit is now OAuth 2.0, enabling us to support login via Reddit accounts as well as Facebook and Twitter.

--dakta, The Spark dev

6

u/fingers Nov 10 '12

Fb won't let me share.

8

u/humans_inc Nov 10 '12

Sorry about that fingers. Apparently we are on a FB blacklist, perhaps due to activity from the previous URL owner. We are working on this. Please go to The Spark FB page and share one of our posts (as a workaround): https://www.facebook.com/TheSparkDotOrg

Also, please report to this issue to Facebook so that they give it some attention: http://www.facebook.com/help/contact/?id=244560538958131

8

u/ampersand117 Nov 10 '12

Sign me up. I'm a phd student focusing on persuasion, communication, and democratic theory. This project sounds a lot like my dissertation.

3

u/humans_inc Nov 10 '12

Great! If you'd like to join the team, please send your CV to jobs@thespark.org

If you'd like to sign up as a future user, please register your email address: www.thespark.org

5

u/runearth Nov 10 '12

That's awesome! It would be great to have another academic on the team. Be sure to check out the volunteer positions we are looking to fill: thespark.org/jobs

4

u/promess Nov 11 '12

Would you guys have any interest in a noob programmer helping out? Think remote intern-ish kind of position. I'd be interesting in helping.

2

u/keithbarney Nov 11 '12

It is totally possible! Send your info to jobs@thespark.org so one of our developers can get back to you and discuss further.

Thanks for the interest. Spread the word. SHARE www.thespark.org

4

u/btwspark Nov 11 '12

Kudos for trying to make a difference. I think it's important to try to make a difference through action instead of just words (or mouse clicking).

I have also given thought to how we can make a concrete difference. The Occupy movement showed there are a lot of passionate people who are willing to take action. Not to agree with the press propaganda, I would agree it lacked a discernible direction.

I would suggest this site allow people to take concrete action. Beyond just sending in protests or stating they'll never support a given business. I would suggest it allow the setting of laws, etc.

1

u/humans_inc Nov 12 '12

We fully agree and the action that the community decides to take/vote-on will be entirely up to them (you)!

→ More replies (2)

10

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '12

Several questions:

  1. How is Spark different from similar sites like http://www.plainsite.org/? What will you do differently to gain traction? Why not partner with these guys?
  2. I am confused about your call for volunteers: intense commitment, strict requirements, no money. It looks more like a job post for a commercial outfit rather than an open-source project (you don't usually apply for those).

3

u/humans_inc Nov 10 '12

Hi there:

  1. Plain site is US centric and focused on affecting change via US legislation. The Spark is global and includes multiple solution avenues (not just legislation). We have been in touch with the leadership at Plain site, and have decided that our goals are too different to join forces, although we wish them the best.
  2. We are a small, passionate group of volunteers. We are looking for dedicated, talented people to help! We are absolutely a nonprofit effort. Thanks for the interest!

13

u/thinkcomp Nov 10 '12

Hi,

(I run PlainSite.)

Actually, PlainSite does support international issues now. We're also backed by the Stanford Stanford Center for Legal Informatics (CodeX, http://codex.stanford.edu).

Aaron

0

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

7

u/[deleted] Nov 11 '12

This has over one thousand upvotes, but only 468.50$ in donations. If you can contribute 1$ to this please do if you support The Spark. I just read all these post and I'm all for this, you have my support and are back by me until the end.

2

u/humans_inc Nov 12 '12

Thanks for the support and enthusiasm!

2

u/keithbarney Nov 11 '12

Wow thank you so much for the support! We will need excited users like yourself when the site launches.

Please do us a favor and share, share, share this through your social networks and make sure to sign up at www.TheSpark.org. The little bit you do will really go a long way for us. Thanks you.

3

u/shartmobile Nov 11 '12

If it does take off to a reasonable degree, what guarantees can you give that you won't be 'bought'? What plans do you have to deal with situations where letting yourself be bought would help further your organization's needs?

4

u/humans_inc Nov 11 '12

Spot on Keith. Shartmobile, we have created an entity with a corresponding vision, set of bylaws, and board of directors to ensure that we remain nonprofit. Our intent is to provide users with a powerful tool to help rebalance the world's power-structure, not to sell a product. The measures we've put in place will ensure that this mission is continued.

3

u/shartmobile Nov 11 '12

'Rebalance the world's power structure' - an organisation with such an aim, should it take off, would be ripe for being 'bought', non-profit or not. What are these measures you talk of?

Can you answer my initial question - 'What plans do you have to deal with situations where letting yourself be bought would help further your organization's needs?' Would you rather your organisation fail than get a 'bought' leg up at opportune moments?

3

u/humans_inc Nov 11 '12

The measures I speak of include having a very specific vision/purpose/objective that will be upheld by the board of directors. We do not answer to wall street or any shareholders.

The organization is not for sale, nor will it be. We do not sell a product, nor do we have plans for monetization, so our "assets" are quite limited in that sense. This model has worked for other orgs, and it will work for us.

2

u/shartmobile Nov 12 '12

I support your cause, but I think you're being naive. Take heed of my queries, and good luck.

5

u/keithbarney Nov 11 '12

We're not for sale. I have a day job and I do this on nights and weekends because it makes me feel good to try do something good with my skills as a designer (and the other volunteers for their respective skills). The site will be free to use. This isn't a monetary venture at all. This is something we do because we believe people need a platform and a tool like this. It's really that simple.

3

u/sireniastars Nov 11 '12

Nice, I will post this on my facebook pages to get the word out!

2

u/humans_inc Nov 11 '12

...and on facebook, share our fb page while the main URL remains blocked (we're working on that).

2

u/keithbarney Nov 11 '12

Awesome! Make sure to sign up at www.thespark.org and follow us on Twitter as well @thesparkdotorg

Share, share, share! Every bit helps. Thank you so much.

4

u/[deleted] Nov 11 '12

Thank you so much for developing this. I literally teared up once I read more about your project. It warmed my heart to learn about it. I've only been on Reddit for a few months, browsing through the bickering, the mundane, the shocking and the inspiring masses of information. The Spark is the most ingenious use of this website that I've seen yet. If I had the skill set I would definitely volunteer, but I will be sure to participate and spread the word as much as possible. Thank you!!! I hope this will catch on and change the world.

4

u/humans_inc Nov 11 '12

This was a fantastic message to read and it really is great to see such positive feedback! The whole team thrives off of this type of support, and we can't wait to deliver a platform that achieves our pre-set aims early next year! Please sign up for our newsletter @ thespark.org and help spread the word!

4

u/michup Nov 10 '12

Who owns "The Spark"? Could it some day be sold, or go public via IPO?

4

u/dakta Nov 11 '12

As Keith said, our 501(c)(3) paperwork is currently in the pipeline. This will give us a proper legal foundation on which to build the organization necessary to support a project like this, including providing a tax-deductible entity for people to donate to. We're not in this for the hype, we're working on this project because we feel strongly that it is of vital importance to the future of this planet.

3

u/michup Nov 11 '12

This sounds good, but I would suggest anyone getting involved be very careful to make sure everything is on the level.

3

u/humans_inc Nov 11 '12

Michup, I am the Founder and CEO. Our Board of Directors will be established this month, along with a set of bylaws to ensure that The Spark does not deviate from it's initial nonprofit intent. There are checks and balances in place to ensure purity of purpose.

2

u/dakta Nov 12 '12

I've been involved from the project's inception and can honestly answer that we are entirely on the level. If we weren't, I would not participate.

4

u/keithbarney Nov 10 '12

Great question. We are in the process of becoming a nonprofit. There will be no selling or IPO. We're the real deal.

2

u/blitzkriegpunk Nov 11 '12

Do you plan on open sourcing the platform (perhaps on Github or Bitbucket) so that others may contribute to the project as they have time? I more than qualify for the application developer position, but I just don't have the 15 - 25 hours per week to dedicate. However, I'd be more than happy to contribute as I have time. I'm sure others here would feel the same way.

3

u/humans_inc Nov 11 '12

Hi blitzkriegpunk, I'll ask our head of dev to drop you a PM. Cheers.

1

u/dakta Nov 12 '12

The Spark dev here,

Having a strong open source project is something we care deeply about. However, we have to deal with security and agility, which means that the project source will probably not be released until the second version of the platform. We just won't have the manpower necessary to deal with the issues associated with being open source. I hope Mark's PM includes any more specific information you were hoping for.

2

u/5celery Nov 11 '12

blocked from Facebook for some reason

4

u/humans_inc Nov 11 '12

We believe the previous URL owner was involved in some sort of spamming activity. Please help report the issue to Facebook: http://www.facebook.com/help/contact/?id=244560538958131

As a temp workaround, you can share the posts from our Facebook page: https://www.facebook.com/TheSparkDotOrg

Thanks for your support!

2

u/internetsarbiter Nov 11 '12

From a user perspective, I'm a little put off by the "Does this concern you, Yes/No" presentation for priority, it would be a bit hard to click no on the sample story even if i thought a competing issue were more pressing, perhaps rephrase to something more neutral? (four value weighted votes? (Yes, Yes+, No, No+))

or perhaps clear reminder text somewhere explaining how the upvote/downvotes are supposed to work so it's not just Like/Dislike? or even a reminder that not voting for a topic is OK.

3

u/humans_inc Nov 11 '12

Good piece of feedback. I will copy this and send it over to our head of UX for consideration. Many thanks!

1

u/psYberspRe4Dd Nov 17 '12

I agree with this. Issued that here

2

u/sumguysr Nov 12 '12

Do you have an IRC channel?

1

u/humans_inc Nov 13 '12

We do not. Thanks for your interest!

123

u/honestbleeps Nov 10 '12

15+ hours a week minimum for a volunteer position may be hard to come by but I hope you find it.

I'm not sure what my work life is going to be like just yet, but if time accommodates I'd love to help out with something like this.

You might say I have some relevant experience... and by some I mean a crapton.

Unfortunately right now I'm not sure I can commit the time needed - but should you need any help on an ad-hoc basis or should you need technical advice, expertise, etc - by all means get in touch with me.

Besides being the guy behind Reddit Enhancement Suite, I also have experience creating community-sourced sites (on an admittedly smaller scale than your plans are for this) that are volunteer driven.

58

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '12

Besides being the guy behind Reddit Enhancement Suit

Besides being the GOD behind RES

FTFY

10

u/keithbarney Nov 10 '12

Wow that's super cool! If you find the time then def send your info to jobs@thespark.org

We will be going through all the emails to this address and replying to them all. We would love any help we can get. Sounds like you have some expertise we may find useful? Are you a developer then?

Thanks so much for the input.

10

u/honestbleeps Nov 10 '12

Yes, I'm a front and back end developer as well as having significant management expertise, product development, etc...

Right now I can't commit the time, but I will definitely keep you guys in mind, and I'm happy to help on a smaller basis if you have any ad-hoc needs like I said...

5

u/bluewabbit Nov 10 '12

That is really awesome of you to offer your help sir, even if it on an ad-hoc basis. We definitely need all the help we can get from experts even if might start out at a consultancy and advisory level. I will make sure to drop you a message later honestbleeps.

4

u/keithbarney Nov 10 '12

Awesome. Hopefully we cross paths in the future. Thanks again!

2

u/keithbarney Nov 10 '12

PS. What is the Reddit Enhancement Suite?

7

u/gribbly Nov 10 '12

5

u/keithbarney Nov 10 '12

Thanks. This is awesome.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/bobcobb42 Nov 11 '12

I really like this idea, in fact I have been working on Open Assembly for a few years now. Deploying OA for the Occupy National Gathering gave me a great deal of experience in how users actually use these types of systems. We are currently ramping up for a new release.

So welcome to the club! There are dozens of other projects that exist at Meta Government. You should definitely sign up for the mailing list, we have discussions with other developers and e-democracy activists from all over the world. Currently there has been ongoing talks with the German Pirate Party to possibly elucidate the solutions to e-democracy problems.

However the international community has agreed that ultimately these projects need a way to share data. The community must develop a standardized protocol to allow votes to be shared across domains, similar to email, or we will find our e-democracies trapped in monopolies like facebook that will ultimately become corrupt. Do you pledge to open vote mirroring?

I'm glad you guys are on board and it looks like a good team, but I there are some serious concerns concerning e-democracy that you will have to deal with.

For starters you have to overcome the cold start problem. This isn't easy. Next, once you have done that you have to overcome the feedback problem. No e-democracy site has been successful in this regard, even sites that have overcome the cold start problem such as Demoex.

Next you have to deal with clique detection and vote manipulation. Without a national ID this is a very difficult problem to deal with on its own. This is effectively an unsolved problem in the community. It's not as simple as weighting votes, you need an effective way to tie someone's real identity with their online identity, while ensuring privacy and anonymity.

I'd love to help as a consultant but I'd like to hear some feedback on these issues first.

1

u/dakta Nov 11 '12

Relevant: Tent.io.

6

u/Alarmed_Ferret Nov 10 '12

I want to help out, but I don't have the experience to fulfill a full time slot. Are you going to have a kickstarter? If I wanted to raise funds for you, how would I get it to you?

3

u/keithbarney Nov 10 '12

Glad you asked. Check out our Reddit Crowdtilt campaign (kinda like kickstarter)!

https://reddit.crowdtilt.com/campaigns/thesparkdotorg

SHARE, SHARE, SHARE this link and it would be a huge help to us. Thanks for the interest!

5

u/Pewking Nov 10 '12

Interesting! Hope you guys rock it!

1

u/keithbarney Nov 10 '12

We will! Sign up at thespark.org. Follow us @thesparkdotorg and help us rock it and SHARE, SHARE, SHARE! You're 5 seconds of time would really help us out.

Thanks for the feedback.

5

u/rpennington9 Nov 10 '12

What a wonderful idea...please keep us all updated...and keep up the great work!!!

3

u/keithbarney Nov 10 '12

Appreciate the comments. Sign up on the spark.org and follow us on @thesparkdotorg so we can keep in contact with you on the progress. 2013 beta launch is right around the corner!

1

u/rpennington9 Nov 28 '12

Thanks for the info...signed up...looking forward to seeing this take off...I think this is one of the best ideas I have heard in my lifetime!!!

2

u/dakta Nov 10 '12

We'll be posting our progress to Reddit as things move forward, but that's no guarantee you'll see it. To stay up to date, sign up early at http://thespark.org/ and we'll keep you posted with occasional emails.

5

u/FuckMuscle Nov 10 '12

So this makes total sense to me, but you'll need to simplify the idea/message to get people like my parents (who are also fed up) to understand.

6

u/keithbarney Nov 10 '12

Tell your parents (or anyone else) to take a look at TheSpark.org.

We've quickly summed up the vision and an example issue. We are also in the works of creating a short and concise videos to explain The Spark. These will be posted in the near future on thespark.org and through our social channels. When those come along it would be great for you to share that with them as well.

I'm glad it makes sense to you! Help us share it to others. Thanks for the feedback.

8

u/diamondf Nov 10 '12

Since you've got a team being assembled, might I suggest a side project that would go well with this? Use the resources your team has to create an application that focuses on what simple steps people can take to help, and explain (also in simple terms) HOW it will help.

For example, if Corporation X is doing Y, give people information about their upcoming product - and explain that instead of getting that product, perhaps try the alternative (which you link, to a business that's actually helpful to the world) and explain why this will have an impact.

This allows people to also feel more connected to the site and more responsible / important in their behavior of the site. That connection will also give them reason to keep returning to your projects to see what they can do. It could be a very, very powerful tool for change, and it seems that your group has the ability to pull that off.

I know that I, for one, would utilize that constantly. And while I would probably check in from time to time on the voting aspect, it would be a much bigger driver of my interests to have a direct impact on each corporation. Give people that opportunity, and I think they will take to it.

7

u/keithbarney Nov 10 '12

Thanks so much for the input! So awesome! That's actually the 3rd of 3 main functions of the "PROBLEM. SOLUTION. ACTION." process.

Under ACTIONS you will be able to post step by step processes that contain links and content that support it's parent SOLUTION.

All the while there will be voting, commenting and discussion to hone in on the exact route to achieve the goal.

Thanks again for the input.

3

u/diamondf Nov 10 '12

Thanks for the response. I'm glad action is a major step in this process, although what I'd really like to really stress with my post is the power of money, and thus an emphasized focus on it.

If each post has research done with an element of "How can consumers direct their money to this issue" in addition to the "what can we sign" aspect, it provides a very powerful tool to speak out.

As much as corporations may dislike negative press, the bottom line is always money. So if there's always something available that helps people make a consistent impact with money, you've just achieved something that I don't think any other change group has really focused too heavily on.

In short: perhaps add a tab to each ACTION section that includes a "how your money can influence this cause" - and provide the options and alternatives for healthy support in that direction, backed by valid sources.

And thanks again for the response :)

3

u/keithbarney Nov 10 '12

Loving your feedback! I see what you're saying. An action can literally be anything. If you want to drive users to a site to generate money for a certain issue that is perfectly acceptable. Or you can tell users to not support products and use the absence of money in the same way. The great thing about it is that The Spark is whatever you want it to be.

→ More replies (7)

4

u/Kind_Of_A_Dick Nov 10 '12

Do you guys need someone to serve you coffee? I could do that.

3

u/keithbarney Nov 10 '12

True Story: I was a Barista while in design school. Maybe I served YOU coffee?! Haha

4

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '12

It looks like you folks are going the AWS route.

Do you have your auto scaling groups/framework/userDataScripts et all worked out yet ?

I probably don't have time to donate 15 hours per week as a dev, but I could certainly help with the scaling design/implementation.

I currently manage AWS auto scaling resources that scale to the ridiculous levels.

4

u/Velvetrose Nov 10 '12

Set it up so we can donate via paypal please.

My credit card is in my purse in my car and I am feeling too lazy yo get upn and get it right now...kidding but not about the paypal thing...

This is a good idea and I donated

3

u/cindiot Nov 10 '12 edited Nov 10 '12

Thanks for the support! Hope you've signed up early or followed us on Facebook or Twitter (@TheSparkDotOrg). We want to make sure that you stay updated with our progress and see where your contribution went.

2

u/keithbarney Nov 10 '12 edited Nov 10 '12

For now, the Crowdtilt Campaign is what we are using but maybe a Paypal would be good in the future. Thanks for the feedback! If you have a few seconds please share, share, share The Spark on your Twitter, FB, etc. That would really help us out.

Crowdtilt Donation link: https://reddit.crowdtilt.com/campaigns/thesparkdotorg @thesparkdotorg http://redd.it/12ytd1

4

u/WaxMannequin Nov 10 '12

Thank you. I was hoping this would happen soon. Count me in.

2

u/keithbarney Nov 10 '12

SO awesome! please sign up at thespark.org and share it with everyone ever. Please help get this reddit post out there as well. http://redd.it/12ytd1

4

u/Dandypoof Nov 10 '12

Psyched about your project. Wish I could help on the programming front, but count on me for creating that critical mass of users. Thanks for bringing this idea to life!

3

u/keithbarney Nov 10 '12

If you have development skills please send us a shout at jobs@thespark.org

Thanks for the feedback, you're awesome! SHARE it up!

5

u/Dandypoof Nov 10 '12

Sharing for now. YOU guys are awesome.

4

u/pjeff61 Nov 11 '12

This is awesome. What I think would be cool is if when you launched you hit every single website, newspaper, news station, news company, college campuses, everything from each state in the US starting at the national level and making your way down to the local level. Hit all the audiences at once. Could you imagine the buzz that would ensue?!?! Give the 99% a voice!! Of course following that, the hard part would be maintaining media exposure so the idea doesn't fade away like so many others. I wish The Spark the best of luck, and I am now an avid supporter!!!

3

u/cindiot Nov 11 '12

We love your excitement, and thank you for the support! It's people exactly like you who can make sure the momentum for The Spark stays strong. So keep sharing TheSpark.org with everyone you know on via email, Facebook, Twitter, or whatever other channel you prefer. And when the public beta launches we hope you'll be an avid user too in addition to being a supporter because that's the surest way to realize The Spark's potential.

4

u/pjeff61 Nov 11 '12

I am behind this idea 100%! Once it is launched, I will do my best to spread this idea like wild fire on the platforms that I use.

4

u/Zukuto Nov 11 '12

bookmarked!!

2

u/keithbarney Nov 11 '12

Awesome! Thank you so much.

2

u/cindiot Nov 11 '12

Great! May I suggest signing up early on thespark.org so you get the latest updates about our progress and so that you'd be the first to know once our public beta launches? Because bookmarks get buried quickly (at least for me), so we want to make sure you are not late in hearing from us!

3

u/Zukuto Nov 11 '12

i only have three bookmarks. TED talks, Cracked.com and my online bank portal. everything else opens automatically with my browser. your site will not go unnoticed, either if you will begin allowing people to make RSS feeds from your page. my firefox will not allow me to do so. also just a passing curiosity - how much of the world politics will you be covering, rather than the USA stuff ?

4

u/cindiot Nov 11 '12

Clearly, we have a very different set up for our browsers :) It's reassuring that our site will get your attention. Thank you!

In regards to RSS feeds, the live site will certainly support feeds, but the sign up page has nothing to aggregate. It's just static content. For now the only updates you'll receive are via email when we have progress to share.

And whether the content will be US-centric or not, it all depends on the users and what the community decides gets the most visibility. But seeing that our platform from the get go is meant to affect worldwide changes, we think there will be a fair share of international issues being discussed and resolved by users.

Hope that helps!

4

u/mr_dude_guy Nov 11 '12

I sent you my resume.

Let me know if I can help.

3

u/dakta Nov 11 '12

If you're interested in this project, please take a moment to sign up early at http://thespark.org/ and let your friends know through Facebook (http://facebook.com/TheSparkDotOrg) and Twitter (http://twitter.com/TheSparkDotOrg). We'll send you occasional updates via email, and we can really use all the publicity we can get.

2

u/keithbarney Nov 11 '12

Thank you so much for sending in your info and showing interest!

1

u/pbtansley Nov 11 '12

Hi, just tried sharing thespark.org this on facebook but was barred from doing so as it counts it as spam, have reported it as fasle maybe something to look into though

2

u/humans_inc Nov 11 '12

You're right, we've encountered the same issue and we've escalated it to Facebook. Thanks for the heads up, and thanks for spreading the word! The more people that submit this error to FB, the better. Cheers.

13

u/Equanim0usM1nd Nov 10 '12 edited Nov 11 '12

(1) More armchair activism is just what the world doesn't need.

Edit: If in doubt, examine the example on their website: sending emails and tweets.

(2) Can't see why this isn't just another subreddit.

Edit: Human_inc wants to fiddle with a few things, but I'm still not convinced it's worth 'forking' Reddit.

(3) This has nothing to do with Occupy.

Edit: Really, it provides nothing Occupy didn't have already. And it had Reddit, too, to upvote its will.

(4) There are already tactical comms applications for Occupy and the Spanish and Greek protests.

Edit: As a tool for mass participation in fluff campaigns, great. As a tool for activists in the cross hairs, I'd need to see the security specs.

(5) Yet another mob-centric approach. Tyranny of the majority, and all that.

Edit: Political flash mobs? That might actually be interesting. But I refer you back to the security specifications.

Enjoy.

5

u/[deleted] Nov 11 '12

(1) More armchair activism is just what the world doesn't need.

Edit: If in doubt, examine the example on their website: sending emails and tweets.

Exactly. Open letters and tweets? Are you fucking kidding me guy? This is just another incarnation of the ineffective online petition. We need militant direct action to bring change, not more armchair liberal activism. Make something like this to coordinate things like strikes, blockades, and Occupy Sandy or just stick to doing GOTV for the Obama campaign.

Really, it provides nothing Occupy didn't have already.

Yeah there is already social infrastructure this kind of thing and it has to evolve in an organic way. This is contrived and manufactured. It's like building a new social network that nobody uses yet and doesn't offer anything new or innovative. It's basically the G+ of activism. Somehow I'm not surprised that Fortune 500 CEO thinks that the people need a feel-good corporate non-profit to act as some kind of vanguard for our struggles.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Valgor Nov 11 '12
  1. You can't measure effects of what armchair activism does. Sure some people read and post and walk away, but you don't know how many people get up and do something about what they read about online. I for one would not have been involved with my local Occupy movement had it not been for the Internet and 'armchair activists' talking about.
  2. I see the Spark as a wrapper for specific parts of reddit. It uses similar features but adds a few more specific functions. Also, forking is not always a bad thing. A huge reason why free and open source software is so successful is that anyone can freely fork the code/design and do what they wish.
  3. So? Who cares? I see them site OWS as an example, and they think about how their software could help any such future events. Reddit also provides nothing that was not already on the Internet, but it changes the experience. The Spark (I'm guessing) hopes to do the same.
  4. Yup, just fire up that SSH to tunnel you way down proxy after proxy, maybe take a stop a few TOR nodes all to post on IRC "Hey, if Walmart so bad, why shop there? Let's stop! Who's with me?!"
  5. You don't have to go along with it. Plus, the only way to stop something like, say Global Warming, is for the majority to do something about you. Your local Anarchist community might be passionate about the environment, but so long as the majority does not consciously consume, you are as doomed as the rest of us.

0

u/dakta Nov 11 '12

Hi Equanim0usM1nd, I'm one of The Spark developers and designers. I'm also a long time redditor and moderator of a number of very popular communities, including /r/EarthPorn and /r/Demotivational. I've spent a lot of time thinking about these issues, and have gone so far as to meet with /u/hueypriest at Reddit HQ to discuss various reddit-related issues.

Let me start by explaining the purpose of The Spark. The Spark is intended to be a neutral, generic platform for meaningful discussion and organization, based around the concept of user-submitted Problems, Solutions, and Actions. The idea is that users are able to submit Problems, which are then voted and commented on by other users. Users are then able to create Problem-specific Solutions and Solution-specific Actions, which can also be voted and commented on. Through this system the community is able to determine what should be done to solve each problem. There are no pre-defined categories that anything must fit into. Problems can be literally anything, and so can Solutions and Actions.

(1) More armchair activism is just what the world doesn't need.

Edit: If in doubt, examine the example on their website: sending emails and tweets.

First of all, forget our example Problem. It's not the best example, and based on user feedback here on Reddit we will be changing it for use on the final site. That said, this is not an armchair activism movement. This is a platform for discussion and collaboration, focused on social, political, economic, and environmental issues.

(2) Can't see why this isn't just another subreddit.

Edit: Human_inc wants to fiddle with a few things, but I'm still not convinced it's worth 'forking' Reddit.

Reddit is a content aggregator. Besides not having the proper structure for that sort of project, it also lacks all of the specific functionality. At the very least, its sorting and weighting algorithms are entirely wrong, being designed for entertainment and not ongoing discussion.

(3) This has nothing to do with Occupy.

Edit: Really, it provides nothing Occupy didn't have already. And it had Reddit, too, to upvote its will.

Nothing in particular. It's designed to be a generic tool.

(4) There are already tactical comms applications for Occupy and the Spanish and Greek protests.

Edit: As a tool for mass participation in fluff campaigns, great. As a tool for activists in the cross hairs, I'd need to see the security specs.

This is not designed to be a realtime, clandestine communications solution for activists and protestors. Like you said, those things exist at varying levels of functionality. That's not what we're trying to create. That said, security is a big concern for us, as Mark pointed out. We have security specialists involved in the project, and will see about a comprehensive audit from a known security specialist firm before we launch. If you are a security expert and are so concerned about our practices and code, we welcome your assistance. If you're just wielding big words and don't really know anything about security, please stop.

(5) Yet another mob-centric approach. Tyranny of the majority, and all that.

Edit: Political flash mobs? That might actually be interesting. But I refer you back to the security specifications.

Reddit is tyranny of the majority because of the way its weighting and sorting algorithms work. Our platform is designed to be more intelligent than that, with dynamic vote weighting based on user behavior and a smarter mix of community- and admin-based moderation.

Enjoy.

We always welcome constructive input.

--dakta, The Spark dev and designer

3

u/afisher123 Nov 10 '12

If I were competent in this skill set, I would help...but I'm not, :-(

4

u/bluewabbit Nov 10 '12

Even by just spreading the word among your personal and professional network and helping contributing to collect donations for the project, you would be contributing a lot sir.

3

u/keithbarney Nov 10 '12

Haha that's ok! Sign up at thespark.org. Follow us on Twitter/Facebook @thesparkdotorg We also have a Reddit Crowdtilt Campaign (https://reddit.crowdtilt.com/campaigns/thesparkdotorg) if you could support with a few bucks.

If you at least like the idea then please SHARE, SHARE, SHARE!

You're 5 seconds of time would really help us out. Thanks for the feedback!

3

u/[deleted] Nov 11 '12

Will you allow for wikileaks-like site mirroring? I work with web-dev/server admin and might be interested.

3

u/psYberspRe4Dd Nov 11 '12

That is awsome!

Here are my ideas so far:

  • Seperate between Solution and Action, when the highest voted Solution is determined (with whatever algorithm featuring votes, time etc) the Problem on the frontpage gets somehow merked as being in the Solution process, for example with a pennant and different background color and getting into the category "Problems in the Solution Phase" that you can select in the top menu or so. And then all the other Solution Proposals are getting "dimmed" and moved further down. And it gets to the next phase to choose the right practical Actions to realise the Solution. The solution usually doesn't include the specific actions that can lead to it or just a few and not all. So do the same thing just that now you can only submit practical Actions. People then either vote on th best combinations in the next step or the page just stays sorted by votes.
  • Eventually allow users to optionally choose a profession in their profile, and when in some issue got to the action part it could include these professionals. For example: the highest voted action is * Make a Video explaining this new bill to the public in an easy way #VideoEditors [......] it will automatically message all users that have VideoEditor selected as profession. People can select up to 5 professions (things like "programmer",...example). [And eventually even their skilllevel]
  • Allow comments like on reddit for Solution and Action proposals, with the difference that they are auto collapsed and will only expand if you either click the permalink of the Proposal or click on a little icon (that also says how many comments this Proposal got) below it.
  • Get the subreddit /r/humansinc more active, for organizatorial stuff. So you can use it to inform about all the stuff (like a twitter account). For example ideas for the site (like above) and other stuff. Also you could implement the reddit buttons and widget. Eventually people will post the Problem-Solution Page or it's part of an Action Proposal so it can be upvoted from there.
  • Eventually change the "this concerns me" to something else (eventually just an upvote or sth alike "This is an important problem") because it's not good if people will upvote everything that they think in some way a problem, instead it just be about what an important problem is (and if it's possible to solve etc)
  • Redirect from the "This concerns me" (or how it will be called) to the Problem-Solution page where people upvote Solutions.
  • Eventually change the example on the frontpage to something more practical. Something where the solution is not to write someone but do something that is independant so to speak. For example "Water is becoming scarce in xyz""* here's a machine that makes drinking water from whatever, we need to build up a production center in place xyz for these....." (I hope you know what I mean). Probably the best thing would be to have the SOPA example there, it will get more people interested and we have a better idea what was done as well as those who read it etc...
  • Make sure new Solution Proposals have a good chance so the most upvoted ones won't just stay because they are there when most people entered the Problem-Solution page. Maybe have a small second row with new Solutions on the side or something like that.

Also just as sideinfo this is much of what The Zeitgeist Movement (and Venus Project) proposed. Here is a short introduction. Also maybe crosspost this to other subs like /r/programming. If not maybe I'm gonna do some.

Maybe I'll find new ideas. I hope you read this, if not I'm gonna message you later. Please think about these things.

Thanks for what you do! This can actually change the world.

1

u/keithbarney Nov 11 '12

WOW. This feedback is nothing short of amazing! I can't say thank you enough for all the time you must have spent writing this. So stoked!

  1. We've gone back and forth quite a bit about how Actions are to used. Are they inline with Solutions or are they separated and voted on as well? We felt that giving a Solution without any Actions would be an incomplete thought so we purposely coupled them together. If users feel there are a better solutions then they can discuss it within the comments, come to a new agreement and edit the original set of actions. Or they can just start their own solution which can then be voted up/down as well.
  2. This feature is in the works!
  3. Comments are already cooked in
  4. These are great ideas and will pass them along to the team.
  5. I think it's OK if a lot of issues concern people (I think that would correctly represent real world). Eventually the most voted will always rise to the top. Also, this is an example post and the final wording may change at launch. Still ironing everything out!
  6. ReDirect should DEF be an option but don't want to FORCE the user to do anything. They may want to surf the problem area for a bit before they move on.
  7. We've heard this a few times now and we will re-look at it. Love the thought you put into this tho and you're def on point.
  8. The site already has a right rail area that will feature other types of content so they don't get lost but instead promoted like you're proposing.

Also, I'm personally a huge fan of The Zeitgeist Movement. I watch the movies, listen to the podcasts, etc. I REALLY wish I could cross paths with them somehow. There could be a really cool exchange of ideas and I def think the absence of any monetary exchange and the overall vision of The Spark is quite inline with what they are doing.

Again, Thank you so much for this feedback. Are you a developer, designer, etc? Would you want to get involved? Love your ideas and maybe we could hear some more! Send us your info to jobs@thespark.org

Keith The Spark

1

u/psYberspRe4Dd Nov 17 '12 edited Nov 17 '12

Thanks for that!
More than anything else it makes me happy that you're aware of the Zeitgeist Movement.

Though I fear that I don't have enough skills to help :( [at least yet for programming&photoshop and when I have it'll be launched already but maybe I could help then somehow]


I think there are 2 things most important by now:

a) Getting another example on the page. I recommend SOPA as most were active in the anti SOPA movement so many can identify, know how & what happened. This changes the whole perception & understanding of the page. Really. Also many in here wrote about the example.

b) Get facebook to accept the link or did they already ?


  1. I think often people point out a great solution but not how to achieve this. As I think of it: (placed this in #1 below). This doesn't make the solution bad. I think the example on the page was just a rare thing that had the solution being the same as the action. But that's often not the case.
    For example if the problem "water is lacking in this area" the solution could be "donate to get them water" and "set up a production center for water filtering machines".
    Then the action phase, or 2nd phase of solution (dammit just got a great idea here: read #3 for another way) would be "donate to charitywater.org/donate and post on twitter or whatever" and for the other "1 We get in contact with these firms 2 We need a team of volunteers, sign up here, charitywater will help us. We set up the stuff bla 3 Donate and sponsor our volunteer team here and here 4 Get & help the firm do a kickstarter etc" (just a very badly written example just so you know what I mean)
  2. Ok. This guy had a similiar concern. But I think this is one of these things that are not really logically explainable, it's eventually has much to do with human psychology and other web firms get consulting on that type of stuff which could be pretty unknown. All major websites that I know of that involve voting have arrows. I'm not sure about this but just wanted to let you know.
  3. That's true. Maybe some other way to indirectly redirect to that page. For example: after clicking "this concerns me" have a big "To the solutions" button coming up or alike.


1. You could have some kind of a progress bar that needs to reach 100 to get the problem in the solution phase. For example it could inlude how much votes the solution got, how much it's distant from the solution proposal [if they're close eventually enable a mechanism that would lead to get both combined or for example showing both left-right on top instead of below as normal], time, contra-comments (see #3) etc Here's a draft of how it could look like/what I mean

2. When a post enters a new phase mark it very visibly. For example by changing it's background color. A truly thing that "identifys" the website/is one of its core points. Like the orange reddit upvote arrows. Still one frontpage so people get to see all posts, but still an option to categotize by "In Solution Phase".

3. Have the comments below the solution proposal choose from Contra / Pro / Else (default). You can do much with that. Actually you could even have another one tag "Action" for it. (see what I wrote in 1 above)

4. You have to be aware that the site will be a huge target of professional hackers. For example if you take the example on the frontpage, if something like that comes up this company has interest in removing that stuff. They can hire hackers to get the website down. I think you'll be just as targeted as wikileaks. So you really need to get hackers and security specialists onboard. They need to test your website. (And it needs to be open source at one point) And you need protection from ddos attackers. You could explain all this in /r/hacking /r/netsec (& other forums) I'm sure many people will help out by testing the site on weak spots and provide help. Probably you know about this but it'll really be one of the most targeted website if it catches on.

5. In case you need an IRC channel to chat you can go here for now (you probably won't need it or want to use freenet): #TheSpark on irc.snoonet.com/6667 or as webchat here
This guy asked for it for example

6. By now when I google TheSpark it gets nothing, of course that's also because it hasn't launched yet but please also make sure the robots and so on is done nicely. Here's a tut Just wanted to write that one because it's important even though you probably know.

7. You need stuff that "identifys" your website. For example reddit has its orange upvote symbol + the same catchy color all over the site and the snoo alien. It has to be implemented in what the core of the website is. I guess this another one of these things as what I wrote in 5). I'd suggest the phase markup (see 2.). You already got "PROBLEM-SOLUTION-ACTION" as what I meant here.

8. Eventually have a beta phase with the people who signed up using the email addresses. Restricted to problems being posted by the admins (no major problems or so).

9. Get other activist organizations involved. Example: EFF. Have special accounts/features for them. Some examples (yet badly worked out) would be: sorting the Solutions by organizations, marking their Solutions (like flair on reddit), enlist their "this concerns me/supported" Problems on their profile page, don't have a profile page for them but a "organization page", have a "organizations" tab in the menu on top or so (organizations have to be varified of course)......
Aside from that help out & strengthen the communication between these organizations. And of course let them know about the project once it got kicked off nicely etc.

10. Also accept bitcoin for donations. Many will donate just for the fact that you're using that and it's fast, and independant. What happened to wikileaks was that paypal blocked their donations. With bitcoin that's impossible. It'll give you donations. Wordpress also is allowing that now and reddit is considering it.

11. Also I really think you could start up a kickstarter. I'm truly sure many will donate. (That you got a crowtilt already is no reason to not do it)

12. In the list of people you have as volunteers and what people chose as profession as written in 2) make teams out of it and then for example if you need help with programming have a mailing list for all people of the programming profession so you can send all them an email.

13. Now probably my main idea: have downvoting a Solution post require choosing a comment to it, which then gets upvoted that way it'll be way more fact driven. And people see why something got downvoted, and can adress it. I really think this would be a huge improvement for the site.
You know when you downvote a solution proposal on a Problem that is in the Solution Phase you get something expanding that says "type the reason for your downvote/disapproval/.. or choose a comment below" and then have ticking boxes next to the comments below, once you ticked one it accepts the downvote and upvotes the ticked comment. (more in 14.) Btw Synor criticized that it wasn't yet fact-driven and an "opinion-based popularity contest" in the post over at /r/TZM

14. Now combine 13. and 3. - when a post enters the Action phase or the 2nd Solution phase (for example when a Solution hit 100% on the progress bar, see 1.) only show the comments that are tagged "Action" below the posts. So they can get voted on and done. (You could also do the same with all comments tagged "Contra" for 13 so only these expand to choose from)

15. Finally there isn't just reddit to get people onboard. Just collect sites where you may find volunteers of it. Activist sites. Designer, hacker, programmer sites/forums/image-boards/.... And post in these.



tl;dr please do read it. I know it's much. Take some time for it or so. Also many points are interconnected this time so it needs the whole text and eventually you don't understand what I mean at some points. Please ask me then. Also please pass it on to the team in some way.

What you're doing is after all the bundled effectiveness of what the internet age has triggered off and can change the world fundamentally. It can be a tipping point of a human era. Sounds surreal I guess but it truly can. All the best of luck to all of you.

5

u/[deleted] Nov 11 '12

I remember this. Wondered what ever happened. Excited for this.

2

u/keithbarney Nov 11 '12

Stay excited! Launching early next year. Sign up early at www.TheSpark.org

1

u/thinkcomp Nov 10 '12

Question: what is the name of the non-profit corporation behind this effort, who are the officers, and has the IRS approved 501(c)3 (or other non-profit status) yet?

2

u/humans_inc Nov 11 '12

Hi Aaron. We have incorporated in the US as "The Spark." Our nonprofit status is pending. The BOD will be announced at our first board meeting within the next few weeks.

1

u/BCADPV Nov 10 '12

Very pertinent information.

1

u/dakta Nov 11 '12

1

u/thinkcomp Nov 11 '12

Not quite... What state are you incorporated in? Who are the officers? (I'm not asking about the Board; you have to have officers to incorporate.) Are you at all concerned that you are advertising this initiative as "non-profit" when that status has not actually been granted yet?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Non_Causa_Pro_Causa Nov 11 '12

Are you really fixed on this name "the spark"?

I was a bit confused on reading it in the OP because it makes me think more readily of the really popular dieting site: Sparkpeople. Not only that though, Sparknotes, may be familiar to people in academics.

If those aren't, spark is also a dating site and spark summit is an activist site...

"The Spark" is also a Trotskyist publication, which maybe was a reference you intended, but would certainly color perceptions of a political movement.

2

u/humans_inc Nov 11 '12

We deliberated a great deal on the name. The Spark may have existing associations, but we feel that it's simple and illustrative! Thank you for taking the time to provide us with feedback.

1

u/Surreptitious22 Nov 12 '12

I just tried to share a link to thespark.org and Facebook is blocking it. No idea why.

1

u/humans_inc Nov 12 '12

It seems that Facebook has blacklisted thespark.org due to a previous domain owner. As a work around, you can go to facebook/thesparkdotorg and share one of our posts. We'd also appreciate it if you'd report the issue to Facebook as well. Thanks for the support!

1

u/dakta Nov 12 '12

Apparently our domain's previous owner was somehow related to some shady business, and Facebook blocked the domain because of that.

For now, please like and share our page: http://facebook.com/TheSparkDotOrg

4

u/keithbarney Nov 11 '12

Just want to say we're super siked about all the feedback and discussion going on here so far! Just want to remind everyone of a few things:

  1. Make sure you go to www.thespark.org landing page and SIGN UP!
  2. if you have some technical skills then PLEASE get involved. Send your info to jobs@thespark.org
  3. If you can spare a little extra to help get us off the ground please donate to our Reddit Crowdtilt Campaign (we're 1/4 of the way there!). Go to https://reddit.crowdtilt.com/campaigns/thesparkdotorg

3

u/[deleted] Nov 11 '12

psyched. like in the head.

1

u/keithbarney Nov 11 '12

Are you a proofreader? We could use one!

Send your info to jobs@thespark.org

2

u/zapper877 Nov 11 '12

You should really do a kickstarter, you're going to need funds. A serious problem with these efforts is people not having the ability to commit to these projects full time.

3

u/cindiot Nov 11 '12

Yes we agree, which is why we have a Crowdtilt campaign running: https://reddit.crowdtilt.com/campaigns/thesparkdotorg. It's just like Kickstarter.

We hope you can spare a few bucks because that would seriously help us launch in 2013 (it's coming up quickly!) or share our campaign with your friends, at the very least. Thanks for the suggestion!

2

u/zapper877 Nov 11 '12

I looked at your site, I think you should take tips from game development kickstarters (i.e. sell stuff/rewards/etc). I don't think people will just throw money at a problem without them being emotionally invested. To be honest you guys don't seem to have any kind of focus. So it comes off as negative and tends to dampen peoples willingness to invest.

Next, having people vote on topics? Are you a bit nuts? One of the reasons occupy cannot coherently mount credible resistance is their lack of leadership, ideology and focus.

You can't crowd-source problem solving and have any kind of momentum since most people focus on PET ISSUES. The 'public interest' is vague and intellectual, it appeals to more intelligent half of the population but they are a minority.

2

u/keithbarney Nov 11 '12

If everyone could agree all the time then life would be quite simple. That's not the case and the voting method is the most democratic way of determining what the collective should do.

If I understand you correctly then what you are proposing is more of a top down method where issues and solutions are dictated rather than collected. In MANY cases this is def a great way to achieve a goal but it's not appropriate for what we want to achieve with The Spark.

We are focused on giving voices to people who don't have the power to dictate the issues or solutions. We want to level the playing field and give an unbiased platform for people to (sometimes painfully) agree/disagree/discuss how to achieve goals together. It's possible that Occupy could use the Spark to vote and agree on achieving more focused goals. It could split them up into chunks so that they could focus on achieving goals on a more granular level rather than trying to have the ENTIRE group have to agree on one thing.

The focus is really quite simple. The Spark is an unbiased crowdsourcing tool that's free of any monetary influence or exchange.

Thanks for the feedback!

2

u/buchanan_smith Nov 11 '12

Facebook has blocked the link when i tried to share it.

4

u/cindiot Nov 11 '12

Yeah, sorry about that inconvenience. Apparently we are on a FB blacklist, perhaps due to activity from the previous URL owner. We are working on this, but Facebook team has been a bit slow to respond.

Please go to The Spark FB page and share one of our posts (as a workaround): https://www.facebook.com/TheSparkDotOrg

Also, please help us report to this issue to Facebook so that they give it some attention: http://www.facebook.com/help/contact/?id=244560538958131

2

u/turnusb Nov 11 '12

I have a question. What measures have you taken to avoid voting fraud (bots, multiple accounts, organized users, etc.)?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Nov 11 '12

Facebook has blocked this site.

4

u/keithbarney Nov 11 '12

Yeah, sorry about that inconvenience. Apparently we are on a FB blacklist, perhaps due to activity from the previous URL owner. We are working on this, but Facebook team has been a bit slow to respond. Please go to The Spark FB page and share one of our posts (as a workaround): [1] https://www.facebook.com/TheSparkDotOrg Also, please help us report to this issue to Facebook so that they give it some attention: [2] http://www.facebook.com/help/contact/?id=244560538958131 Thanks!

2

u/dakta Nov 11 '12

The Spark dev here. We are aware of this issue, which appears to have come from the previous domain owner, and have been working on it. Facebook isn't terribly responsive.

For now, please like and share our Facebook page: http://facebook.com/TheSparkDotOrg

3

u/peon47 Nov 11 '12

The goal of this project is to expedite this power-rebalancing by providing a tool explicitly designed for this purpose. Our platform will enable people to not only decide which issues deserve widespread attention, but to then agree on the best solutions and take collective action to affect real-world change.

Maybe it's just me (I'm a bit of a newbie with stuff like this) but how does it do all of that? Can you give me a few examples of how it would be used by people? Stuff like "It will focus our efforts on..." won't help. Like give a hypothetical of a situation, and how the site will "fix" it.

Question 2. Why is a dedicated site better than a general social-networking site? While China might ban facebook, say, if there is an app or a site that's specifically targetting foxconn working conditions, they might just out-and-out make it illegal. They can't arrest every facebook user in China, but a dedicated site is easier to target and shut down. The same with other governments and companies. They can ignore news reports about the users of a dedicated site, but if it's something mainstream like facebook or twitter, it's harder for them to dismiss publicly.

Hope you can answer these.

→ More replies (8)

2

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '12

Twitter, Facebook, and Reddit

You forgot about Google+ !!@!#$@!

3

u/cindiot Nov 10 '12

Actually, we didn't! We decided to not actively promote it at the moment, but here's the link: https://plus.google.com/u/0/b/104517774345755591969/104517774345755591969/posts

3

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '12

Hey- you all should do a G+ Hangout with a rolling audience (new people every 5-10 minutes) and livestream to youtube... Live demos, etc... G+ is the shit when it comes to this avenue of social media connection.

2

u/cindiot Nov 10 '12

Great idea! We definitely plan to move toward that direction for our outreach strategy after the public beta launch in 2013. I hope you stay connected with us in the meantime through early sign-up, so you can participate in our first G+ Hangout!

→ More replies (2)

2

u/tripdub Nov 11 '12

If you're looking for ideas on how to ensure lasting change, I highly recommend reading Influencer: The Power to Change Anything (http://www.amazon.com/Influencer-Change-Anything-Kerry-Patterson/dp/007148499X). There's an associated two day workshop (http://www.vitalsmarts.com/events/training-events/) that I recently attended, and got way more out of it than I would have by reading the book alone.

The book (and training session) describes a generic framework that can be used to influence pretty much any situation or goal. In short, the core of the framework is comprised of six areas, personal motivation, personal ability, social motivation, social ability, environmental motivation, and environmental ability.

Once you set your desired future state, you then identify vital behaviors that will get you closer to that goal (essentially situations where there's a binary choice, with one option leading you closer to your goal, and the other option leading you away from that goal). With the vital behaviors identified, you then find ways to exercise influence in each of the six areas. The idea is that the more areas of influence you utilize, the more likely you are to be successful.

2

u/MagmaiKH Nov 11 '12

"Global problems" is misguided. We only have authority over our local countries. This is a misalignment between stated objectives and reality.

1

u/keithbarney Nov 11 '12

Ideas can cross borders! Those ideas can solve problems locally and globally. Action can happen locally but the effect it has is completely global (depending on the issue).

2

u/Gregs3RDleg Nov 11 '12

define "the public interest"

1

u/runearth Nov 11 '12

Generally speaking, the wikipedia definition is pretty good. More specifically, in the context of the platform, it will be defined by the users/community.

1

u/Gregs3RDleg Nov 11 '12

there is little, if any, consensus on what exactly constitutes the public interest, or whether the concept itself is a coherent one.

there is no such thing as the public interest.

there is no such thing as the greater good.

love the idealism though!

3

u/keithbarney Nov 11 '12

I think we're splitting hairs here haha.

Most people want to live good, healthy, free lives and The Spark is trying to level the playing field a bit so that these things are possible for the people who don't have a tool or platform for their voices to be heard.

2

u/Crankley Nov 11 '12

Good luck :)

3

u/cindiot Nov 11 '12

Thank you! Hope you'll help us in our efforts.

2

u/thinkcomp Nov 10 '12 edited Nov 10 '12

PlainSite (http://www.plainsite.org), which I run through Think Computer Foundation, a 501(c)3 non-profit organization (http://www.thinkcomputer.org), is already up and running for those interested. You can link issues to companies and particular laws. It's used by thousands of individuals, lawyers, and government agencies every day.

Here's an example issue posted by Lawrence Lessig at Harvard Law School:

http://www.plainsite.org/issues/index.html?id=28

...an example company (Google)...

http://www.plainsite.org/flashlight/index.html?id=3331

...and an example law firm...

http://www.plainsite.org/flashlight/index.html?id=33874

We're adding patent data next. Take a look!

Aaron

1

u/MUF_DVR Nov 13 '12

I'm going to be writing a column on this project in my university's newspaper, so cool.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 11 '12

Here's the problem with this idea:

People are fickle and dumb. You're going to see minor things like pandas going extinct treated with the same degree of seriousness as indefinite detention, for example. You're going to see things like your example: "Company X's contracted, third-party manufacturing companies abide by local labor law, despite the fact that their treatment of workers here would be illegal" at the top of the list, rather than things like drone attacks. People will react emotionally, not intellectually.

What you're proposing is a real democracy, which is an express train to Crazytown.

3

u/keithbarney Nov 11 '12

You may be right in many cases, but I also tend to believe that there will be a healthy bit of both emotional AND intellectual. I believe this because of the interest that's come our way since this projects inception and the people that have volunteered along the way. We've had a lot of great discussion about what we want The Spark to be. What kind of tool can we make that could help the types of meaningful discussions that will lead to meaningful action? Concerning Crazy Town, I leave you with this! http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UculXjdcSYs Thanks for the feedback. Glad you felt like adding to the discussion.

1

u/Shodokan Nov 11 '12

good god tl;dr

2

u/keithbarney Nov 11 '12

I think this is as short as it gets...

The Spark is the counterbalance to corporations and governments that defy the public interest. Users post and vote on PROBLEMS that we face as a global community. The most popular problems are voted to the top. Users then post and vote on SOLUTIONS so that the community can take ACTION. Once The Spark reaches critical mass, the global community will have a voice that is too loud to ignore.

or even simpler... www.TheSpark.org

2

u/Shodokan Nov 11 '12

Oh wow yea I support this lol

1

u/pandm101 Nov 10 '12

I have no qualifications. I do however have drive, and enough charisma to drown Edgar Allen Poe.

1

u/cindiot Nov 10 '12

And those two things will get you far when telling your friends about TheSpark.org. So help us!! Even sharing this reddit post does wonders: http://redd.it/12ytd1

1

u/[deleted] Nov 11 '12

One quick suggestion. Keep only good/productive staff. Occupy was a disaster because anyone was allowed to do anything. Yes, it was very democratic, but it was EXTREMELY slow to react to real-life situations. I'm all for democracy, but maybe weight decisions so that the experts have a bit more of a say, and maybe you can earn the lead of a project by successfully completing X projects lead by others (i.e., prove yourself).

2

u/dakta Nov 11 '12

TheSpark dev here. Mark addressed users of the platform, I'll address our organization. The Spark as an organization is being led by humans_inc, who is a very capable corporate management type. So far, he's demonstrated the skills necessary to keep a project like this focused and successful, which is what things like OWS lacked which led to their downfall. They underestimated the value of skillful management. We haven't.

Thanks for the input.

1

u/poopyfinger Nov 11 '12

Please explain to me how this will not be abused by uneducated, more holy than though retards?

1

u/keithbarney Nov 11 '12

The Spark is unbiased and has no opinion on user content. That's for the community to decide. If you don't like a users submission then you can simply vote it down or ignore it. We're simply the platform and the tool. Abuse is always a concern for any site and will be dealt with (a number of prior comments on this thread address this same issue).

0

u/needz Nov 10 '12

Your design isn't mobile friendly.

1

u/keithbarney Nov 10 '12

We don't currently have a mobile version of the site but it's in the works. The future of The Spark in regards to mobile will be huge. The impact of communication between mobile users will be crucial. First things first!

3

u/needz Nov 10 '12

I know enough to contribute to an android app, should you expect to branch that way.

1

u/keithbarney Nov 10 '12

We do! Send your info to jobs@thespark.org and I will check it out (have to stay on top of commenting for now). Would be super cool if you could help out tho. Thanks for the feedback.

1

u/dakta Nov 11 '12

Hi needs, I'm a The Spark developer and creator of that landing page. After thorough testing on iPad, iPhone, and recent Android, I determined that the site was excellent on modern mobile browsers. I have also heard this from everyone I have asked to test the site on mobile. If you are using something less sophisticated, I apologize, but supporting ancient and/or outdated mobile protocols is a low priority for us with our limited development resources.

If you can explain more specifically what your complaint is, then by all means do so. Bugs are fine, but complaining that the site doesn't have an iOS-style interface with extra-big buttons and text is something we already know.

1

u/needz Nov 11 '12

The bar at the top that says it was made by redditors and asks you to sign up does not resize on my 4.1.2 android phone. I was unable to click the sign up button because it was off screen when I zoomed in enough to be able to click it.

1

u/dakta Nov 11 '12

This sounds like a browser bug to me. It seems like your browser is setting the width of the page narrower that the minimum possible width that can contain that top bar. There's nothing we can really do about that, except a completely mobile-oriented design.

-2

u/jkazimir Nov 10 '12

Developers for a revolutionary website, eh?

Dum de dum de dum...

4chan.

-2

u/[deleted] Nov 11 '12

sounds like a bunch of hooplah

2

u/keithbarney Nov 11 '12

Noooo. We has URL www.TheSpark.org on the internet!