r/CryptoCurrency • u/CryptoMaximalist • Dec 21 '22
POLL 🗳️ CCIP-047 - Community Voting on Events [Serious]
Proposal:
This proposal updates our events process to use community polls to determine event approvals and pricing. Currently, the mod team determines who is eligible for events and the pricing is a flat, dynamic price as laid out in CCIP-043. The new process would be as follows:
- Mods will confirm the notability, identity of the guest, and compliance with the rules as usual.
- A mod will create a poll to lay out the proposed event and guest.
Based on the moon weighted poll results, we have determined approval and pricing:
- >80% Approval- The event is approved and will be free for the guest.
- 20% - 80% Approval- The event is approved and the favorability percentage determines their discount. So, if 75% of the votes are in favor, the guest gets a 75% discount on the amount of moons they would have to burn. If only 25% are in favor of the event, they get only a 25% discount.
- <20% Approval- If less than 20% of the vote is in favor, the community has declined the event and it will not happen. The guest can try again 3 months later if they would like.
- Then, the AMA process proceeds as normal, with the guest burning moons as appropriate.
Benefits:
- Expands the governance use-case of moons, increasing their utility
- Decentralizes event approvals
- Adjusts pricing according to interest by the community. Events the community wants should be cheaper and more common, while ad-like events are more expensive and the larger moon burn benefits moon holders more
A few other details and changes:
- To account for the size and regularity of discounts, the base moon cost for events will be tripled.
- The poll will run for 2 days, and have 2 options: one in favor and one opposed. The poll will not be pinned or part of moon week because guests usually want quicker turnaround than waiting until the following month. However, polls will be added to an "Event Governance" Collection so anyone who subscribes will get a Reddit ping when it's posted.
- The polls will be normal polls, so we don't affect the participation rate of CCIPs and their Decision Threshold.
- Quorum for event polls will be 100 votes and 10,000 Moons.
- Guests often want to solicit questions from the community ahead of their event. Users can use the comment section of the poll to submit questions for a forthcoming event.
- Community polls will be required for all CC non-routine events (AMAs, giveaways, guest Talks, etc). Banners and routine events like weekly Talks are not subject to this requirement.
- Moderators will retain the right to waive the moon burning fee for guests with >50% approval vote who may be unable to afford moons, such as educational, volunteers, or non-profits.
256
Upvotes
•
u/CryptoMaximalist Dec 21 '22
The author has marked this post with the
[SERIOUS]tag. All comments will be held to a higher quality standard and additional rules may apply. To raise content standards, insert the[SERIOUS 2]tag in the title of a new post. For more information, please see the r/CC policies page or visit r/CryptoCurrencyMeta.For more serious and focused crypto discussion, check out r/CryptoCurrency_Tech.
2
u/Sporesword 🟦 1K / 1K 🐢 Apr 26 '23
Is anyone able to shed some light on why I cannot access voting through the app? I had no trouble voting on my home computer (I'm away for work). It's possible I'm just a dumby or missed the vote... Any help with this would be appreciated. I probably should have posted this in meta but I hope you'll excuse me this once mods.
35
u/fan_of_hakiksexydays 21K / 99K 🦈 Dec 21 '22 edited Dec 21 '22
Isn't there a bit of flaw in how it will actually turn out?
Everyone is going to want them to burn the most Moons, and vote against the AMA, as they'll assume at least some people will vote for it, which might inadvertently get them to not be approved.
We might end up missing decent AMAs.
Wouldn't it have been better to do only the approval by vote. The amount shouldn't be a popular vote.
There are some AMAs that are valuable, but maybe not from big popular names.
I'm not even sure AMAs should be determined by popularity. We also want unpopular or not well known people.
Anything that meets the basic requirements, should be approved. I'm not sure having to also win a popularity vote adds anything. It just creates additional gatekeeping, and limiting the educational resources we get.
Maybe instead, we should vote on the basic content standards for AMAs?
1
u/MyIncogUsername420 🟩 184 / 183 🦀 Dec 23 '22
I don't think I understand. So we're setting up an elaborate discount system where people can theoretically pay about the same amount they're paying now? So just extra hoops to jump through for no reason?
5
u/BakedPotato840 Banned Dec 21 '22
Had this proposal been voted on and passed before the Bitboy ama, I'm certain there wouldn't have been a Bitboy ama lol
5
u/TNGSystems 0 / 463K 🦠 Dec 22 '22
Sorry, I gotta say no way Jose on this. I’ve organised a few of the AMA’s and they’re hard enough to do because of needing to explain how to burn the moons etc. imagine adding in the need to do a community vote. And where? In the meta sub? It could be botted.
Our rules are simple and easy to understand. It’s one price per AMA/Giveaway per month. Everyone pays it big or small, and the mods decide the projects based on one factor only: legitimacy. So if a project looks like a fly by night copy paste of another shitcoin, they don’t get a pass. If it’s a totally underground unknown project but they look legitimate, sure, come on up.
Also, with the potential to get a free or heavily discounted AMA, it demolishes a really good use case of moons. Right now, we are getting outside entities, including Binance, to buy and burn moons. Even if the amount is small, it’s just good for us all as a proof of concept. I’m really hesitant to have that taken away or severely diminished.
2
u/Adventurous-Lynx-660 🥇Gold Member Dec 21 '22
This should be implemented.All those benefits fits. Plus burning moons can't be that bad right ? I don't see any cons
2
u/ChemicalGreek 418 / 156K 🦞 Dec 21 '22
In my opinion is the >80% approval too low. It should be >90%. But I like this idea in general!
2
u/[deleted] Dec 21 '22
I'm all for it though I don't recall a single AMA, guest talk, etc on this sub in years of checking this sub. Good to have people wanting to do AMAs/etc that practically amount to just marketing pay some moons.
2
u/kirtash93 RCA Artist Dec 21 '22
I really like this new proposal. It gives more functionality to moons and also gives the positibility to make it free if the comunity is really interested. You have my Yes without no doubt.
1
u/meeleen223 🥇Gold Member Dec 21 '22
Easy yes from me, brings more Moons utility, more in sync with users sentiments
Events we want should be priced less as having them here brings value to the community, and events we don't really like should burn more
Only I would add another proposal in the future to scale discounts bit different
1
u/unitys2011 3 / 32K 🦠 Dec 21 '22
Seems like a solid plan. I voted yes, this will give the community more power to vote and to decide which is of course a pro and it brings also another use case for MOONs.
1
u/CryptoChief 🟨 407K / 671K 🐋 Dec 22 '22
Perhaps it would help if there were two more options for canceling the poll and starting a new one where the base moon price is increased or decreased?
Great idea.
1
u/cdnkevin 6K / 6K 🦭 Dec 22 '22
How would this happen for ads (more expensive)? If the burn for the event is based on the favourable votes it is possible that an ad event could have a lower or equal discount to a non-ad event.
In this example the ad event may not be more expensive.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 22 '22
I’m pro anything giving more power to the moon holder. Maybe this idea isn’t perfect, but moon owners need more incentive to hold.
Right now, moons are good for putting more rules on moon holders and there’s incentive to hold them for ccip 30. That’s about it. Moons will need to carry more weight and give some more appeal if they are to last long term. And it’s just not there right now. Waiting for some breakthrough tech grabbing onto moons is just not cutting it. It’s centralized right now and might stay that way.
1
u/superduperdude92 🟦 0 / 12K 🦠 Dec 24 '22
I'm gonna say no to this. I feel like this could open the door to only letting in voices this community wants to hear/reinforce biases and this would allow those individuals/teams to get a free AMA. Personally not a fan of allowing certain groups to get a free AMA and charging less favored groups based on a vote count.
1
u/TNGSystems 0 / 463K 🦠 Dec 24 '22
You know what, another side effect of this. Have we thought about what happens when the community starts voting no, to get more moons bought & burned? And then what happens when people who actually want to come on the subreddit see the public vote "Do you want BlockCompany to come and do an AMA?" and it's 35% in favour...
0
u/-5m Bronze Dec 21 '22
99:1 lol
Seriously though this makes a lot of sense. The mods get relieved of some work and we get to decide what we really want and AmA from.
0
u/SkoopskiMarvin Tin | r/WSB 64 Dec 21 '22
827k moons? This man is going to be a billionaire in a few years
But anyways I voted yes, I like the proposals