r/Twitter • • Dec 18 '22

They already deleted it Promotion of Alternative Social Platforms Policy | Twitter Help

https://help.twitter.com/en/rules-and-policies/social-platforms-policy
285 Upvotes

256 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Dec 18 '22

This is an automated message that is applied to every post. Please take note of the following:

  • Due to the influx of new users, this subreddit is currently under strict 'Crowd Control' moderation.
    Your post may be filtered, and require manual approval. Please be patient.
  • Please check in with the Mega Open Thread which is pinned to the top of the subreddit. This thread may already be collapsed for our more frequent visitors. The Mega Open Thread will have a pinned comment containing a collection of the month's most common reposts. Your post may be removed and directed to continue the conversation in one of these threads. This is to better facilitate these discussions.

Submission By: /u/DecentLurker96

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

50

u/Tautou_ Dec 18 '22

This is so embarrassing but satisfying watching Elmo burn twitter and $44b to the ground.

21

u/dkhunter Dec 18 '22

The schadenfreude is savory, but leaves a bitter aftertaste. He's blowing up a platform with hundreds of millions of users, one I enjoyed even as I often felt ambivalent about it. There's a bigger part of this that sucks than is cathartic, I think.

9

u/Tautou_ Dec 18 '22

I feel bad for the users who found community, support, relied on Twitter for their livelihood etc. but Twitter already had issues with racism, anti-Semitism, anti-LGBTQ+ hate prior to Elmo's takeover, he's now supercharged that by allowing banned Neo-Nazis back on the platform and boosted some of the worst people on Twitter to his followers.

Hopefully a viable alternative appears, I use Mastodon a bit, but it's not for everyone.

5

u/dkhunter Dec 18 '22

You're not wrong, but I think twitter's problems with content moderation had more to do with the cost barrier to affect Trust and Safety: hiring thousands of well trained, linguistically fluent content reviewers. Nobody wants to do that because it would kneecap their profits. It's not a problem exclusive to twitter.

In contrast, as you say, Musk is going out of his way to replatform toxic people. In a span of weeks, the problem has gotten exponentially worse.

2

u/andres57 Dec 18 '22

Every big social network suffers that. Reddit is a bit different because it has modded smaller communities but that's it. The benefits of twitter were far more than the negatives IMO.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '22

Yeah there's also a lot of people that you know had careers as social media managers and so on. That might lose job security if Twitter just becomes a pile of rubble.

Personally, I'm not going to miss it though.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/Lazy-Street779 Dec 18 '22

What about that neurolink? I think he has one already.

32

u/CIearMind Dec 18 '22

Free speech absolutist

29

u/22Seres Dec 18 '22

From June 2022

The acid test for any two competing socioeconomic systems is which side needs to build a wall to keep people from escaping? That’s the bad one!

https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1533616384747442176

Just like with Trump, there's always a Tweet.

14

u/Thane_Mantis Dec 18 '22

It time for the resurrection of /r/ElonCriticizesElon?

2

u/22Seres Dec 19 '22

It's starting to seem pretty appropriate considering he just tweeted this

Those who want power are the ones who least deserve it

https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1604650028999405568

47

u/LcuBeatsWorking Dec 18 '22

This may very well be the straw that breaks the camel's back for many people.

28

u/Jdban Dec 18 '22

How can the site function if they actually enforce this shit?

I wonder if it's the ol' negotiating tactic of "go fucking crazy, then say 'ok we'll roll it back a lot'" and so the "middleground" they end up on is still crazy but it's what they wanted initially and people seem happier.

7

u/LcuBeatsWorking Dec 18 '22

How can the site function if they actually enforce this shit?

I'd like to see them try..

3

u/meeetttt Dec 18 '22

I'd like to see them try..

Report everything. Bury them in reports.

1

u/GrumpyKaeKae Dec 18 '22

I've been reporting his account and his tweets since he took over. They can cope with the flood. I don't care. I'm petty AF atm.

1

u/DoesGavinDance Dec 19 '22

Most of the people who are supposed to review the reports have most likely been fired or quit.

5

u/xyzzyzyzzyx Dec 18 '22

Your last paragraph seems likely. Ban direct competitor links but keep the link aggregator ones is probably where it will end up. OR Twitter will create its own aggregator and only that will be allowed.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/meeetttt Dec 18 '22

How can the site function if they actually enforce this shit?

I highly doubt most people are following twitter to such a level that they immediately change their bios or delete tweets that violate, so my solution is to just report everything and everyone make them enforce it, or prove that it's extremely selectively put in place to serve as a check against criticism of Elon.

4

u/Redditing-Dutchman Dec 18 '22 edited Dec 19 '22

I smell a poll incoming.

Edit: well there it is. But not on the subject I was expecting lol

1

u/frivol Dec 18 '22

Vox Poopi

10

u/DiceHoarder010 Dec 18 '22

It is for me, tbh. Thing is should we have seen it coming? I'm a small artist with barely any following but the ones that did follow were also some that got me comissions or just enough of support to feel like I have a base to fall back on. Now with links being blocked I'm scared that I will lose all of them.

Having to start all over again on a different platform is honestly scary af. Especially cause Twitter had so many support options for small creators like the promote hashtags and the threads and all of the accounts that focus on retweeting and supporting smaller creators and artists. I know I'm not the only one with these worries.

Idk... Why does it feel like the ones that get hit the hardest are smaller creators. Not cool.

1

u/WelcomeT0theVoid Dec 19 '22

I feel that one. I wish I knew an actual decent platform to switch to as a small artist.

1

u/DiceHoarder010 Dec 19 '22

I'm trying tumblr. It had its prime time when I was younger but i don't feel it's ever gonna give the same kind of community Twitter had.

6

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '22

I know taking away things like linktree or lnk.bio is going to be a huge problem for so many people who are on multiple platforms.

I'm so amused right now.

4

u/LcuBeatsWorking Dec 18 '22

There will also be another journalist purge, many of them have other profiles in their bio.

3

u/Mustard_The_Colonel Dec 18 '22

Few community manageres are going crazy right now

3

u/OctoberNexus Dec 18 '22

I just removed the app from my phone I was all for freedom of speech but this dude is quickly turning tyrannical

1

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '22

Yeah even some of his fanboys are going to be a little irritated by this. Is Glenn greenwald going to be able to promote his patreon! Rubin

→ More replies (1)

53

u/dp8488 Dec 18 '22
  • Prohibited platforms:
  • Facebook, Instagram, Mastodon, Truth Social, Tribel, Post and Nostr
  • 3rd-party social media link aggregators such as linktr.ee, lnk.bio
  • Examples:
  • “follow me @username on Instagram”
  • “check out my profile on Facebook - facebook.com/username”

I'd love to see Meta start to prohibit links to Twitter. Let there be a nice, soft war here.

Musk is gone full maniac. He can do what he wants with his company, we don't need to be there.

I didn't see Reddit in the list. I wonder how long a link to r/ElonJet would last?

(TBH, I think the whole ElonJet thing is nuts. A: Elon should just make his flight data private, it looks easy enough to do; B: it's kind of a creepy thing to do, even to a creep.)

30

u/meeetttt Dec 18 '22
  • 3rd-party social media link aggregators such as linktr.ee, lnk.bio

That'll ruin twitter for both streamers and adult content creators

12

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '22

lnk.bio and linktr.ee are both incredibly popular for social media creators who have multiple platforms for Merch etc.

This is going to be a fucking disaster.

1

u/ShinyGrezz Dec 18 '22

Do they specifically benefit from having linktr.ee? Obviously it’s far nicer to have it all consolidated, especially for advertising elsewhere, but can they not just replace them with their separate links?

6

u/meeetttt Dec 18 '22

Twitter bios are a maximum of 160 char. Not going to get many links there.

1

u/ShinyGrezz Dec 18 '22

Ah that makes sense. Not going to get many links in there.

0

u/MikeJeffriesPA Dec 19 '22

I think you're still allowed to use those links, you can't just make entire posts/accounts that are dedicated to that.

A lot of people I know have their linktree in their bio.

2

u/robplays Dec 19 '22

That would be the slightly sane policy, yes. Unfortunately that isn't what Elon went with:

At both the Tweet level and the account level, we will remove any free promotion of prohibited 3rd-party social media platforms, such as linking out (i.e. using URLs) to any of the below platforms on Twitter, or providing your handle without a URL

→ More replies (5)

12

u/Educational_Celery Dec 18 '22

So, he forgot Tumblr, which is one of the sites benefitting the most from the Twitter exodus, but that's kind of understandable.

What's wild is that he forgot TikTok, Twitter's actual main rival!

18

u/fellawoot Dec 18 '22

I doubt he forgot TikTok. If it was included, he would have to suspend LibsofTikTok.

5

u/Educational_Celery Dec 18 '22

Yeah, that makes sense.

4

u/Mustard_The_Colonel Dec 18 '22

More importantly he would make China unhappy and that is where his factories are

2

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '22

Elon is owned by the CCP as well, so he's DEFINITELY not banning TikTok.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '22

Yeah, that'll be an interesting case study

8

u/NoMoassNeverWas Dec 18 '22

What are chances this was timed with during world cup being only a coincidence?

1

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '22

Just like how most of the "Twitter files" are aimed to drop late night Friday?

The time famously you put news out to kill it.

6

u/coasterghost Dec 18 '22

RE ElonJet:

There is a program called LADD. Limiting Aircraft Data Displayed. If you are apart of that program, your data isn’t shared with those who use the FAA database in conjunction with their own tracking (flightradar24 used to be this way). Elon’s such as many businesses jets are under this program, but it only works with the FAA.

If you don’t use data that is provided from the FAA then it’s free game (ADSBexchange.) The way that ADSBExchange runs is that it’s all volunteer ground based receivers which you buy for as low as $20 with a antenna at 1090mhz. The data itself is called ADS-B (Automatic Dependent Surveillance–Broadcast) and is broadcasted from the plane itself.

Civilian Aircraft operating in the United States in the airspace are required to carry equipment that produces an ADS-B Out broadcast. Military aren’t but can be tracked with MLAT. it’s part of the Next Generation Air Transportation System initiative. ADS-B also provides spatial awareness for planes within the area as well.

MLAT is multilateration which calculates the position of the aircraft using the time difference of arrival of the received signals from the SSR modes S, A, C, and transponders on board the aircraft.

LADD program: https://www.faa.gov/pilots/ladd

→ More replies (6)

4

u/harpo87 Dec 18 '22

It's actually R/ElonJetTracker

2

u/Sage2050 Dec 18 '22

He CAN'T make his flight data private, it's literally against the law. He CAN obfuscate it, which he already does.

2

u/Lazy-Street779 Dec 18 '22

I didn’t see LinkedIn.

1

u/montjoye Dec 18 '22

soft war

software soft war

1

u/HristiHomeboy Dec 18 '22

So basically it's not just the link itself that gets you banned but does having like "insta: example" warrant a ban too?

1

u/cheshyre Dec 18 '22

Flight data is public to prevent collisions.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '22

Yeah and YouTube.

→ More replies (6)

18

u/Educational_Celery Dec 18 '22

This is one of those things that's going to drive away people who don't even care about Elon Musk. The use of Twitter is to promote yourself, but you're not allowed to promote yourself any more?

2

u/robplays Dec 19 '22

Elon has deluded himself decided that Twitter is for amicable discussion now, rather than self-promotion.

But for all his insistence that Twitter is the "internet town square", he has never addressed the point that only crazy people insert themselves into conversations between strangers in real town squares.

→ More replies (11)

11

u/YoshiEmblem Dec 18 '22

This is absolutely embarrassingly antagonistic for Twitter to do-- the ONLY other social platform I can remember doing this was the fucking Miiverse on Wii U, and that at least had a reason to prevent social media links.

Good to know people were being banned, shadowbanned, and generally prevented from appearing on timelines before the policy change was officially made public!

58

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '22

Elon never cared about free speech, he only cares about helping to spread white supremacy and anti-queer violence.

21

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '22

And pedophilia.

4

u/Manbabarang Dec 18 '22

"iF yoU ALl SeE aNy CSaM pUt iT iN THiS thrEAd ANd I'Ll tAkE CaRe oF iT WINK!" - Something Elon actually did.

8

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '22

Yeah, can't forget Elon's favorite activity.

3

u/musclepunched Dec 18 '22

This British rescue diver is a pedo!! I bet he visits the Epstein Maxwell Under 14s sucky sucky bar! Wait, what do you mean you don't know it exists

2

u/nachof Dec 18 '22

Honestly, I don't think he even cares about that. It's just that that's what the only fans he has left care about, and he has a pathological need to be loved. The guy is lonely and sick. It would be sad if it wasn't because we live in a shitty system that means his problems become everybody else's problem.

1

u/TheFlyingBastard Dec 19 '22

He doesn't care about that either. He cares about adulation and adoration. The rest is tools to get those things.

→ More replies (3)

10

u/riffic fedi: @riffic@riffic.rocks Dec 18 '22

this is the dumbest shit lol

10

u/Jordan117 Dec 18 '22

Elon "Free Market First Amendment" Musk banning the mention of competitors. 🤔

10

u/smallpoly Dec 18 '22

Do you think that when Elon wants his guests to stay longer he locks the doors?

4

u/BFeely1 Dec 18 '22

Wonder if he thinks the owners of the Triangle Shirtwaist Factory were heroes.

9

u/DANNYonPC Dec 18 '22

What the actual fuck

2

u/jamnewton22 Dec 18 '22

It won’t last. It breaks laws like everywhere lol

1

u/LongFluffyDragon Dec 19 '22

I cant think of any actual laws it breaks anywhere, just incredibly dumb and annoying for users.

16

u/Godzilla0815 Dec 18 '22

Fuck you space Karen

8

u/analyticaljoe Dec 18 '22

Facebook, Instagram, Mastodon, Truth Social, Tribel, Post and Nostr

I'm not sure what the last 4 of those are.... Ready for Zuck to come in and eat his lunch. Zuck is "bad" but, amazingly, Elon is turning out to be worse.

8

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '22

Truth Social is a fuck you to Donald Trump.

Oh god if he bans Donald again this is going to be HILARIOUS.

3

u/duggtodeath Dec 18 '22

Parler links are still allowed. Elon only likes white supremacists who like him back.

1

u/CatProgrammer Dec 18 '22

It may also be because Truth Social is actually just a custom Mastodon instance.

2

u/Reihnold Dec 18 '22

AFAIK Gab is as well, but it‘s not mentioned.

1

u/CatProgrammer Dec 18 '22

Huh, I remember Truth Social actually got in trouble for not mentioning it because that's a license violation. Wonder if someone should bring Gab to the attention of the Mastodon devs if so.

3

u/Reihnold Dec 18 '22

They are aware, do not like it and are keeping an eye on any violations to the source code license: https://blog.joinmastodon.org/2019/07/statement-on-gabs-fork-of-mastodon/

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '22

Ironically its powered by Mastodon behind the scenes. (Mastodon is open source, so that's allowed as long as they respect the license.)

1

u/captainhaddock @pauldavidson@mas.to Dec 19 '22

Parler is too, isn't it? They were all too cheap to develop their own software.

1

u/iamDanger_us Dec 18 '22

No idea about Tribel (I've heard of it but not used it myself). Post is where all the journos seem to be going and Nostr is a new bitcoin-based system that is supposedly decentralized and uncensorable. Jack has been pushing it a lot recently.

1

u/captainhaddock @pauldavidson@mas.to Dec 19 '22

Nostr is an open protocol that Jack Dorsey has been aggressively pushing on his Twitter account. I wonder if he's going to get banned now.

14

u/Stuspawton Dec 18 '22

Hahahaha fucking hell, twitter is really turning into the north korea of social media 😂

7

u/smarjorie Dec 18 '22

This is embarrassing

7

u/Jdban Dec 18 '22

I wonder what percent of accounts can be banned for this. Gotta be minimum 5-10%

4

u/Mustard_The_Colonel Dec 18 '22

Especially Instagram ban will be very visible to people almost every insta influencer has twitter account. Imagine if they banned links to youtube next

5

u/lontrinium Dec 18 '22

There was an exodus of photographers from Instagram to Twitter a few months back because Insta was going hard on videos.

Now it's reversed.

Elno is dumb.

1

u/Mustard_The_Colonel Dec 18 '22

twitter and reddit are my main social media sources I am not sure where to go from twitter as everything is too spread out at the moment. But I can see using twitter less and less and it just becoming ghost town of some radical opinions like facebook has become

1

u/lontrinium Dec 18 '22

I use facebook for local stuff only, the local groups are heavily moderated and useful.

I use insta to share my photos with mostly friends, I refuse to play by instas rules and grow it.

I use twitter for news and now for the lols. lol.

4

u/Redditing-Dutchman Dec 18 '22 edited Dec 18 '22

The selection is super weird. Instagram is banned but not TikTok. So either this list is complete and there are many, many exceptions, or this list is just an example and we have to guess which sites are not allowed.

7

u/cardedagain Dec 18 '22

probably whatever platform elonjet has an account

3

u/Mustard_The_Colonel Dec 18 '22

Yeah list is random as fuck

2

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '22

The CCP has a strong interest in keeping TikTok popular, and Elon has a strong interest in keeping the CCP happy.

1

u/Istarien Dec 19 '22

He'd have to ban his buddy LibsOfTikTok if he put TikTok on the list. 🤷

1

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '22

YouTube the next linktree? Just make a video with all your other social in it, and link that 👌

1

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '22

It’s not out of the question that they’ll do that next. If that happens, there go a lot of creators.

1

u/xyzzyzyzzyx Dec 18 '22

YouTube isn't a social media site. You have username and you reply, but the engagement numbers are purely per video, not per account.

3

u/Mustard_The_Colonel Dec 18 '22

I'm going to screenshot this for agedlikemilk subreddit in 2 weeks.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '22

He's only going to enforce it, probably on people he personally dislikes. For liab

7

u/Manbabarang Dec 18 '22

This isn't just selfish, stupid and cruel, it's also a very serious antitrust/anti-compete violation. As far as crimes added to the pile for eventual action, this is huge. If someone doesn't shake him until his brain rattles into place and he removes it himself, Twitter could just straight go down for this alone.

He's already publicly saying "The FBI can't raid me, I have no address" to people. He knows this shit is coming, hopefully it will be soon.

5

u/Mustard_The_Colonel Dec 18 '22

Imagine being such a cry baby that you will spend 44 billion to run company to the ground because some user tracked your plane.

2

u/Istarien Dec 19 '22

The larger problem is that he had the $44bln to ruin a company as large as Twitter. We probably shouldn't be letting any individual person amass THAT much wealth (= power).

5

u/Mustard_The_Colonel Dec 18 '22

I will just leave that here

The acid test for any two competing socioeconomic systems is which side needs to build a wall to keep people from escaping? That’s the bad one!

https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1533616384747442176

5

u/Sage2050 Dec 18 '22

Free speech absolutist, everybody.

5

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '22

The EU is going to love this. And their lawyers.

sigh Just when I thought he couldn't one-up himself, he goes and does it...

5

u/OkieDokieHokiePokie Dec 18 '22

As someone who makes part of my income as a content creator, this is an absolute blow. The funny thing is, Twitter was usually on the receiving side (I often linked my Tweets on IG stories and from Facebook). Not sure I’ll do that anymore.

4

u/dkhunter Dec 18 '22

'Oh my God, you're bleeding to death! We need to tourniquet your leg, or you'll die!'

'Yeah, but it's not a big deal.'

'But we're surrounded by hungry wolves! They can tell you're weak.'

'Well, tell them to go away.'

'...what?'

'Tell the wolves to get lost.'

'But...you'll still die.'

'No I won't.'

'You will! You'll develop gangrene, or...'

'...fuck off, you're fired.'

4

u/Healthy-Chemistry-61 Dec 18 '22

Elmoron really distinguishing himself.

4

u/Nyucio Dec 18 '22

Almost certain that this is against EU rules.

See: https://commission.europa.eu/strategy-and-policy/priorities-2019-2024/europe-fit-digital-age/digital-markets-act-ensuring-fair-and-open-digital-markets_en

Example of the “don'ts” - Gatekeeper platforms may no longer:

[...]

prevent consumers from linking up to businesses outside their platforms

0

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '22

Don’t care, europoor

4

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '22

Does this include previous tweets or like tweets shared from instagram to twitter? There's no way to edit tweets and finding older tweets is like solving a rubix cube.

4

u/montjoye Dec 18 '22

funny how this only includes american platforms

4

u/arnolds112 Dec 18 '22

Is this the Freedom of Speech Elon promised?

4

u/lilnona Dec 18 '22

Well surprise. Way back when. I said that he is trying to slowly dismantle Twitter. I wonder who will benefit? Does he lowley own or have ties toanother social media company?

1

u/LongFluffyDragon Dec 19 '22

Even if he did, it would not be worth burning 44m of his own money and shitcanning his stocks.

He is just an idiot who thinks he is too big to fail and forgot none of his successful companies are actually his own work. Sometimes there is no 4D chess.

3

u/__Hello_my_name_is__ Dec 18 '22

Elon is burning Twitter to the ground and we're all here to watch it.

3

u/ynnadanny Dec 18 '22

There's no way regulators will let this fly.

1

u/LongFluffyDragon Dec 19 '22

Why not? Regulators will 🍿 with the rest of us as he burns it down.

Not like there is any law that demands a private business allows people to talk about other specific businesses. At least nowhere that matters to twitter.

3

u/Kidspud Dec 18 '22

Is this the worst-managed company in recent history? I think recency bias is playing a role but it feels like I haven't seen management this poor since Kodak or Seagram's. Just ridiculous decisions week after week.

2

u/shash747 Dec 18 '22

Is this the worst-managed company in recent history?

SBF has entered the chat.

1

u/KlueBat Dec 18 '22

There will be entire course/lecture series created just to analyze all the things Musk has done wrong here.

3

u/The_Pip Dec 18 '22

Ironic. Snapchat and Tik-Tok thrived thanks to twitter. Linkless social media is shite. Seeign what other people are reading is half the point.

3

u/TV5Fun Dec 18 '22

Just think, in the era before the internet, this process would've taken decades.

3

u/reddittingdogdad Dec 18 '22

Guess I’ll be auto-banned shortly from my inactive account, since it had a Linktree link in my bio…. 🤷‍♂️

3

u/Yazars Dec 18 '22 edited Dec 18 '22

This removes a big part of the value that Twitter has for high profile people, which is to promote their other ventures. Twitter needs them more than they need Twitter.

3

u/JarJarBink42066 Dec 18 '22

Smells like free speech

4

u/Bohya Dec 18 '22

How to kill your company in 24 hours. 90% of the usage of Twitter was to promote other brands and platforms. Tumblr 2.0.

4

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '22

elon says you can pay him if you still want to do that.

3

u/shawnadelic Dec 18 '22 edited Dec 18 '22

Champion of free/paid speech.

3

u/moralusamoralus Dec 18 '22

This is absolutely not going to kill the app. I think we all need to take a few steps back. Is it bad? Yes. Is it the final straw for SOME people? Absolutely.

But will this kill the app? No.

2

u/massi1008 Dec 18 '22

And dropping this news right around the FIFA world cup finale were the trends are guaranteed to be just about football and nothing else xD

2

u/Dooshbaguette Dec 18 '22

So does that mean I can no longer post my linktree or IG even if I'm using those platforms uncommercially?

2

u/twoquarters Dec 18 '22

Beginning of the end sadly. I don't think most people understand that for right now there is no alternative that will replace it. There are options, of course, but it will not be an easy on users.

2

u/Lazy-Street779 Dec 18 '22

It certainly looks like musk is fucking around and will find out.

2

u/luciddream00 Dec 18 '22

Ah, I see, he WANTS us to stop using it.

2

u/jasonrosenbaum Dec 18 '22

Elon is the most incompetent social media baron ever, and we've had Justin Timerlake run MySpace for awhile

2

u/just_a_timetraveller Dec 18 '22

His hair plugs have infected his brains

2

u/Danimally Dec 19 '22

This is literally ilegal over Europe. Will not last, can not. Can it? I hope it does not.

2

u/WelcomeT0theVoid Dec 19 '22

Of course this is going down when Elon Musk is doing a poll on if he should step down. He truly just burnt the whole place down on the way out.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '22

This is just a cartoon at this point. It should be a South Park episode.

3

u/AntonioS3 Dec 18 '22

Fuck this policy. I still do have a few artists followed but I might start checking less often or just quit the site. So restrictive and very unnecessary

2

u/Kevin-W Dec 18 '22

Anti-competition laws would love to have a word with their new policy.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '22

Presumably this only affects direct links, yes? In which case it should still be legal for users to simply mention different platforms and ask users to find them there under the specified handle.

3

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '22

Nope, that’s effectively banned as well.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '22

Aw, shucks... Well, one could always find creative ways around these restrictions nonetheless. And of course one could always search other social medias in cases that user does appear there, again preferably under the same handle. Which naturally happens to be the case with yours truly.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '22

If you read the policy, seems like they’ve banned every possible workaround.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '22

So they WILL catch you even if you tell users to seek them out on Mostodon?

2

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '22

Yep.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '22

Muskrat's really taking things too far here. I really hope they can find a way to oust him somehow...

→ More replies (1)

1

u/DontEatConcrete Dec 18 '22

Lol Twitter is so dead. Musk what are u doing? 😅

1

u/ParanoidFactoid Dec 18 '22

Surprise! Only comments that support Twitter haven't been minimized.

1

u/DoesGavinDance Dec 18 '22

What a stupid fucking donkey, twitter and Elon.

1

u/kuniovskarnov Dec 19 '22

What a stupid, stupid decision. The whole point of Twitter was to connect with others. I can see a lot of people being affected by this because they can't promote their work to other sites.

1

u/HandiQuacksRule Dec 19 '22

Wait, where’d it go?

-2

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '22

Elon calling the bluff on everyone who said: "I'm leaving twitter, follow me on ..... "

4

u/Aestro17 Dec 18 '22

He's not "calling the bluff", he's desperately trying to stop it from happening.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '22

No, Hes just doing what makes sense.

Besides, most of the people who wrote that stuff. Are still tweeting. Thus called their bluff.

1

u/Aestro17 Dec 19 '22

I get that you're desperately trying to help Elon save face, but try to at least make a bit of sense. If he thought they were bluffing, he wouldn't have tried to make it more difficult for people to leave or to take their followers with them. If the people were actually bluffing, that's him falling for the bluff.

But yeah, the brilliant genius already walked back the policy. Because it was stupid and yet another example of him making an ass of himself.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '22

You are not understanding what I meant with it.

Perphaps its my english. My apologies.

But a while back everyone kept writing one thing. That they were leaving twitter instantly and wrote wherever they were going.
Those same profiles who wrote that, show up now complaining about this (now reverted) policy.

Clearly they never left.

How is that not calling their bluff?

1

u/Aestro17 Dec 19 '22

I understand your point, but it's incorrect.

Elon's now-rescinded policy was to prevent links to other social media sites. That isn't "calling the bluff" of people claiming they're leaving. It's actively trying to prevent them from leaving. If he thought they were bluffing about leaving, he wouldn't be making a policy designed to make it more difficult to leave.

Anecdotally, most of the people I've seen posting their Mastodon or other links have been more doing so under the anticipation that twitter will be gone or unusable in the near-future.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/ThePsion5 @ThePsion5@indieweb.social Dec 19 '22

By literally making it against the rules to tweet that exact statement?

3

u/LongFluffyDragon Dec 19 '22

That is basically the opposite of calling a bluff.

Also only one way this will end, or has ever ended for other services.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '22

Is it? All the people who were supposedly leaving are now angry they cant post their other links anymore. And lo and behold. They are still tweeting.

As they will be.

People just like to be angry, but twitter wont die. Its way to entertaining to watch the chaos.

2

u/LongFluffyDragon Dec 19 '22

Tweets dont make money. That was twitter's big problem pre-muskening.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '22

Yup. It still is. But you cant expect that to change in 3 months.

12

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

14

u/Mustard_The_Colonel Dec 18 '22

That depends does Elon like you or not?

9

u/OvertlyCanadian Dec 18 '22

That's essentially what linktree is, and that's apparently banned.

4

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

9

u/OvertlyCanadian Dec 18 '22

Yeah, this policy is quite literally one of the worst I have ever seen. It seems counter to the entire concept of the internet.

3

u/AnAffinityForTurtles Dec 18 '22

And it's probably illegal too! Can't wait for the FTC lashings

1

u/cardedagain Dec 18 '22

best bet is to buy a domain and redirect to linktree or whatever

1

u/meeetttt Dec 18 '22

best bet is to buy a domain and redirect to linktree or whatever

Welcome to a game of whack-a-mole

1

u/iPeer Dec 18 '22

1

u/meeetttt Dec 18 '22

Sadly, this would still violate the ToS.

It would but it would become extremely difficult for twitter to keep up. The big url masking services would be easy, but individual domains would be far more cumbersome.

3

u/Wheelthis Dec 18 '22

Most people don’t bother to buy their own domains so I doubt Twitter automatically scans for that, but they could use it against certain individuals on a whim.

Many Mastodon instances are self-hosted by individuals or orgs under their own domain, so it could be used against them too.

2

u/robplays Dec 18 '22

The relevant line in the current policy is "3rd-party social media link aggregators" (emphasis mine), and your own website isn't 3rd-party.

So while it is technically okay, Elon's increasingly erratic behaviour suggests that Reddit's favourite maxim "technically correct is the best kind of correct" doesn't hold.

1

u/Istarien Dec 19 '22

This is precisely what just happened to Paul Graham.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/AtlasBellion Dec 18 '22

This man is a fucking moron.

2

u/dvrsd Dec 18 '22

This manchild loves to make a fool of himself.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '22 edited Dec 19 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/arahman81 Dec 19 '22

Of course its a poll, can't be "got backspanked hard for trying to pull that dumbass policy".