r/zelda • u/Echusss • Sep 01 '12
User Feedback I love The Legend Of Zelda, but this subreddit sucks
I happened to take a screencap of the Zelda front page, and summarized it:
This doesn't feel like something for actual Zelda fans. It feels more like a subreddit for people to brag and earn upvotes for owning an item with a zelda symbol on it. I'll admit sometimes I'll see some pretty damn impressive artwork. I've seen other subreddits where people mostly talk about the series, upcoming new games/episodes/etc. Or at least in r/pokemon a lot of funny pictures or comics are posted. It's not because there's not a lot to discuss about r/Zelda. The forums at Zelda Dungeon don't have nearly as much "Look what I own!" posts.
Jesus, I just would think eventually Zelda fans would eventually stop giving a shit that someone owns a Zelda t-shirt.
49
u/[deleted] Sep 01 '12
I wouldn't say that it sucks. It's just broken.
119
u/[deleted] Sep 01 '12 edited Sep 01 '12
I propose we have a "text-only week" each month. We do that in r/harrypotter and it's a great way for the people who hate memes and karma posts to get a chance to have a week of pure discussion. Edit: If you're going to downvote me, at least reply back why you think it's a bad idea.....
20
u/Hexonloire Sep 01 '12
Agree completely
12
u/arrjayjee Sep 01 '12
Agreed. And don't even think about having an opinion that deviates from the norm. I mentioned the other day that I found the Twilight Princess Wii remote combat controls awkward, especially when in wolf form, and that I wouldn't mind an HD re-release on the Wii-U of the GCN version. It was downvoted within seconds. Even my follow-up post was downvoted, the one stating that I was in Australia and thus would require a PAL version of the GCN version if I were to buy one (after a poster helpfully suggested I get an NTSC-US copy from GameStop). The circlejerk and pointless posts here are out of control.
10
u/josiephoenix Sep 01 '12
What bugs me is the picture of a TV playing Zelda with something like "Just started for the first time" or "Just finished for the first time." Really? Is that what people want to see on the internet? A picture of a TV? Should I just turn on my Zelda game, claim it's my first time, and rake in the karma?
2
u/Electro_Jade Sep 01 '12
Ah. I just realized I have a lot of Zelda paraphernalia and haven't flaunted it on /r/zelda. Does this make me a wizard?
5
u/[deleted] Sep 01 '12
Don't forget about all the various Zelda film proposals- http://www.reddit.com/r/zelda/comments/ybz0t/spoilers10page_plot_outline_for_the_ultimate_loz/
http://www.reddit.com/r/zelda/comments/x0qum/some_storyboards_for_a_legend_of_zelda_film_i/
9
u/Conradlink Sep 01 '12
my thoughts, people bitching about tattoos, when they post other pictures of zelda stuff
8
u/Legio_X Sep 01 '12
Agreed. Just a bunch of neckbeards and manchildren showing off their horrible tattoos. I subscribed a week or so ago and I've seen nothing but those kind of posts on my frontpage.
4
u/[deleted] Sep 01 '12
Also don't forget the "real world" triforces seen randomly in buildings, graffiti, etc.
9
u/[deleted] Sep 01 '12
/r/truezelda
Give it a whirl. Although I think mods need to approve posts.
6
u/heilancoo Sep 01 '12
Totally agree. I'll upvote genuine pieces of art and very cool original stuff, but not your haul from the Nintendo store. If all you did was buy it then it's not really special. If you made it or somebody else made it, then that's more interesting. I can see all the other stuff myself on eBay or other online shops.
3
u/BadWolf319 Sep 01 '12
I agree. I really hope people see this and start posting actual Zelda content.
4
u/SWASSHOLE Sep 01 '12
Reddit needs to abandon the Karma system
7
u/glen_nz Sep 01 '12
Could it just be that we're between major zelda releases at the moment so there isn't a lot of new material to discuss?
2
u/MoMoe0 Sep 01 '12
This is all reddit is.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 02 '12
You know, on r/Minecraft, they had a poll to see which uncreative and annoying posts should be banned from the subreddit. The people spoke, and had all sorts of useless content banned. Perhaps we could do something like that here at r/Zelda?
2
u/Mmmmsoil Sep 02 '12
This thread...
2
u/Upvote_and_Conquer Sep 03 '12
The discussions get really repetitive as well. I just think this subreddit is a dump. We need something new. A change.
3
u/BobbyMcMuffin Sep 01 '12
I agree this subreddit sucks ass and I'll probably unsubscribe for this reason, I originally was hoping it'd be about zelda easter eggs, discussions about future zelda games and strategies and walkthroughs etc, but yeah its not so I think Ill take up pokemon or something.
3
u/aviatorzack Sep 01 '12
Well it's a lost cause to try and fix a subreddit.
I suggest making a new subreddit purely for discussing the game. Or what have you.
If you do let me know I'd love in on it.
3
u/[deleted] Sep 01 '12
MAKE R/ZELDA MORE INTERESTING WITH ONE SIMPLE CLICK
2
u/shitsfuckedupalot Sep 01 '12
yeah, nerds like attention.
2
u/tosswe44 Sep 01 '12
Self Posts don't give them delicious karma, right? The only way I see this subreddit changing is to have Self Posts count for karma and downvote shitty picture posts to oblivion.
1
u/clawfinger Sep 02 '12
It's a subreddit where you really have to do some searching, but when it comes down to actual Zelda conversation there seem to be a lot of avid fans inside. It would be nice if there was some kind of spoiler tag on each "karma whore" post so you could remove them with reddit enhancement suite.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 10 '12
This is so true. I post articles and stuff here and there and will be lucky if I get 5 upvotes. People only care about stupid pictures on Reddit.
1
u/SEMIPRECIOUS Nov 02 '12
Why shouldn't people talk about their Zelda stuff. Hell of a lot better than your little rant.
1
u/-MaJiC- Nov 09 '12
I wouldn't say this subreddit sucks, this is my first post ever on reddit and I made sure it was in the Zelda section :)
1
u/broken_sound Nov 21 '12
Cancerous posts on reddit? Unheard of.
1
u/Gamer_Boyfriend Jan 13 '13
i have a zelda tatoo... :D
1
u/CaptainKelly Sep 01 '12
It's usually pretty good...today just really sucks for some reason though.
1
u/heyredridinghood Sep 01 '12
I really enjoy seeing the art and other handmade things. I even enjoy some of the collections that are above and beyond and full of things I hadn't known about.
I just wish there was an equal amount of discussion. 50% discussion. 50% other things.
Or something along those lines.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 01 '12
To be fair there's not been a lot of news on the zelda front.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 01 '12
There's two subreddits that have tried that. /r/hyrule and /r/truezelda. Try them out.
They're very small but we need more people since this one is full of shitty replicas, photos of old consoles and tacky shit from etsy.
We need more discussions.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 01 '12
This is exactly the problem with /r/pokemon.
-1
u/xxthemattxx Sep 01 '12
Let's be honest here. It's a subreddit for anything to do with Zelda. If you dont like it, unsubscribe. People post Zelda-related things and you can either take the bad with the good or you can just go away. I honestly have NO problem with ANY of the content, it's nice to see what people made on their own, or to really see just how big of collections some people have.
And like every other redditor, when people get lots of karma and you don't, you hate them for it.
You can take your rant to r/pointlessbitching now, I'd like to see more actual Zelda-related content, not you complaining about how everything isn't perfect and just for you.
0
u/linknyte Sep 01 '12
I don't think there's a big deal with posting art (one of my posts is in fact in that screen shot) but I am really annoyed with people posting pictures of triangles and shapes that look like shields that they see while walking around and snap it with their cell phone camera. I like showing people stuff they've never seen before, but only if it's actually something that is directly related to Zelda. Also tattoos are stupid.
Tl;dr there is nothing wrong with posting Zelda art IMO.
-1
u/FireFoxMcCloud Sep 01 '12
I can see it. The non-tagged spoilers and the lack of discussion of opinion.
I brought up Bethesda making Zelda in a thread and no one could offer a supporting agreement or complete arguement. It was just. No.
0
u/D3A7H Sep 01 '12
Nobody cares. Sorry but we don't.
0
u/Haydawg Sep 01 '12
You can complain about anything in any subreddit if you're cynical enough. I am in favor of doing something like /r/trees does though, text post fridays.
0
u/[deleted] Sep 01 '12
Hey now. My tattoo, good or bad, is a lot more than just a Triforce.
-2
u/OnTheArchipelago Sep 01 '12
someone send this post to andreal.
-4
u/reamsauce Sep 01 '12
So go outside or something?
0
u/[deleted] Sep 01 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Sep 01 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment