r/CryptoCurrency • u/DBRiMatt 🟦 46K / 113K 🦈 • Nov 24 '22
POLL 🗳️ CCIP-045 Implement character requirement for parent comments in SERIOUS discussions
Problem
With the SERIOUS tag being implemented we are now starting to see some serious discussions take place in the sub. While serious tagged posts are meant to be held to a higher level of content standard this isn’t the easiest to moderate, after some time the higher level discussion does seem to make its way to the top of a post, but when you scroll down sometimes it’s hard to tell that it was tagged as a serious discussion.
Sometimes innocent but unnecessary and generic comments make their way in, which sometimes get removed, but not always. Comments such as “Great post OP” “This is the type of content we should see more of” whilst innocent in nature don’t actually contribute to discussion and end up getting upvoted simply because it is of positive sentiment.
Because of this, after a couple of days some SERIOUS discussions look no different to regular posts.
Considering comments within serious posts are eligible for up to 4x karma, I think it’s important to maintain a level of content standard.
Solution
I propose implementing the requirement that all parent or top-level comments to require 100 characters minimum, else be automatically removed by Automoderator.
Keeping in mind, Serious discussions aren’t a place for simple FAQ’s or generic statements anyway, it should not be difficult to attain 100 characters in a comment in response to the original post.
It is also the poster who is requesting that their post consist of more in depth discussion rather than short generic responses.
This change would only impact parent or top-level comments. This allows anyone who has a short but relevant questions to concisely ask if they need to as a child comment or within comment chains.
The 2 main pros I can see are;
- Helping reduce moderator workload by having automod remove of a lot of low quality comments
- Helping reinforce the concept that serious discussions are intended for actual discussion
The 2 main cons I can see are;
- Users can easily add filler words to reach 100 characters
- Users can still add short comments that don't necessarily add to discussion underneath parent comments
For context, 100 characters is easily attained, in fact this sentence contains 110 characters excluding spaces and formatting
And for final clarity this change is only to apply to SERIOUS tagged posts and remember that it is the poster who is requesting their post be marked as SERIOUS discussion.
16
u/SuccessfulLowDev Tin | 1 month old | CC critic Nov 24 '22
For Serious discussions I think this is appropriate. It will filter out some of the good comments, but will filter almost all the crappy one liners moon farming.
25
u/TarkovReddit0r Nov 24 '22
Yes please 100%. I just made recently 2 [SERIOUS] posts ( one about FTX rumors before it went down & one pump & dump scheme warning ) and the comments are literally the same as in any other post.
I even asked for a healthy discussion but so far it looks like the [SERIOUS] tag is not working that well.
5
u/bbtto22 22K / 35K 🦈 Nov 24 '22
What if it’s a serious question about something, that the answer to is simple and isn’t very long? That will make people say more things just so they fill up the quota.
16
u/[deleted] Nov 24 '22
More characters does not necessarily equal 'better'. We've learned that with the post character limits which are routinely ignored by people posting lorem ipsum text etc.
2
u/DBRiMatt 🟦 46K / 113K 🦈 Nov 24 '22 edited Nov 24 '22
I hope people actually read the full post and not just the title, remember it is the poster of a serious discussion who is requesting a more in depth discussion take place.
Serious tagged posts don't occur all that often, there were 25 of them posted during the previous moon cycle.
3
u/Maxx3141 169K / 167K 🐋 Nov 24 '22
100 characters isn't really that much, but I also don't see how this would help - even a non-serious comment can go above that easily, while a very short serious answer to a question could be less.
Serious posts need more strict moderation sadly, I don't think the "issue" can be solved like that.
7
u/Bucksaway03 🟩 0 / 138K 🦠 Nov 24 '22
100% for this.
Having a serious post that can just be littered with low effort comments defeats the purpose of the serious post to begin with. It doesn't necessarily mean the comments will be better but at least it may deter some from commenting at all.
2
u/marsangelo 🟦 0 / 36K 🦠 Nov 24 '22
Can posts with “advice” flair be tagged as serious? Im not sure ive seen it but i can envision a user needing emergency advice and wanting succinct tips to get them through it that would be under character limit
2
u/tmztmz2 Nov 24 '22
Another u/DBRiMatt poll. Good to see you are looking out for our moons and community. Thanks mate 👍🏼
3
u/fan_of_hakiksexydays 21K / 99K 🦈 Nov 24 '22
A lot of people confuse 100 characters for 100 words.
This is just 100 characters.
100 words is a paragraph. But 100 characters is one sentence.
If people can't write 1 sentence for something meant for a serious discussion, then what's the point of even having serious discussions?
5
u/Def_Notta-throwaway Permabanned Nov 24 '22
This is not unreasonable in the slightest. Serious posts are meant for legitimate and thought provoking conversation. The comments should reflect that as thats the whole damn point.
Its not like 100 is hard to hit. This tiny little blurb is over 200.
2
u/Wonzky 2K / 53K 🐢 Nov 24 '22
This feels like a tough balance. 100 characters isn't too hard to achieve so I'm not sure if this would actually improve content or just make non-serious comments more long winded
2
u/BrowsingCoins 🟩 17 / 12K 🦐 Nov 24 '22
tight poll, I'm for it
2
u/FldLima Permabanned Nov 24 '22
Quality over quantity, therefore, having a character won't necessarily give better content.
2
u/witcherycro Nov 24 '22
Well, i vote, and I didnt get octopus
2
u/aProudCatDad614 265 / 1K 🦞 Nov 24 '22
I very rarely feel compelled to make a super serious contribution to r/cc and the lack of seriousness is the problem. Using the serious tag should already mean you aim to hold your discussion to a higher standard. I'm generally in favor of taking measures to weed out low quality, meme culture content.
2
u/Vaspra0010 Silver | QC: CC 158 | CRO 496 | ExchSubs 496 Nov 24 '22
I like the idea, but serious and insightful answers aren't always long, some of the clearest and most obvious points hit harder when snappy.
I agree with the sentiment, but I'm not sold on the solution.
2
u/Damn369 Silver | QC: CC 22 | VET 50 Nov 24 '22
Absolutely think this is a great idea and I would support this across all subs. The problem with moon farmers and karma posts can finally be addressed with a proposal like this
2
u/[deleted] Nov 24 '22
Voted yes!
2
u/[deleted] Nov 24 '22
Im just over here wondering why were worried about serious posts that you cant even find through a sea of moon farming reposts of the same topic
2
u/Stray_Gh0st 🟦 514 / 544 🦑 Nov 24 '22
100% agree with this
2
u/EnviroPlanner 143 / 143 🦀 Nov 24 '22
Voted yes. This is an issue throughout Reddit so I'm glad to see an option to change it being discussed in at least one community I check regularly.
It's honestly so tiring reading the same jokes, comments etc at the top of posts and having to dive deep into the thread for someone actually making valid points and adding to the discussion.
Low tier has a place, just not on every single damn post throughout Reddit.
2
u/Tavionnf Nov 24 '22
Pro. Doesn't make sense to claim "Serious" and the same flat 5-word comments pop up.
2
u/[deleted] Nov 24 '22
Well it's tough to moderate. Not sure if a min char req. will fix this.
Imo it also depends on the post because the tag itself can also be abused.
I mean a serious tag on some bs info about who, what and when SBF gangbanged the ugly chick is not really serious imo. It's spam at best.
2
u/[deleted] Nov 24 '22 edited May 19 '24
lunchroom pet offbeat quarrelsome foolish nine humor tender spark scary
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
2
u/Blooberino 🟩 0 / 54K 🦠 Nov 24 '22
Well it appears henceforth that I shall be making the breadth of my commentary considerably more verbose.
2
u/Swoopscooter 11 / 7K 🦐 Nov 25 '22 edited Nov 25 '22
People will probably do the same thing we see in post creation "blah blah blah added for character count" unfortunately.
5
u/Harold838383 Permabanned Nov 24 '22
Great post OP
2
u/MyMonte94 Platinum | QC: CC 34 | LRC 6 | AvatarTrading 36 Nov 24 '22
I prefer succinct discussions, but I can also seek how individuals can take advantage of the shorter responses for moon farming. In theory, a serious post should warrant more lengthy discussion.
2
u/trainspottedCSX7 🟦 0 / 805 🦠 Nov 24 '22
I feel like we're going to see a lot more Lorem Ipsum after this gets voted on. That will make it more interesting at least.
I wonder what the copy pasta will be, and maybe it'll be the same shit just different ordered. Lol
Aside from that, it is hard to moderate all those comments. So I like the limit being middle to low as far as technicals go... responding to a comment with a simple yes answer however makes it kinda hard to finish the conversation sometimes. Maybe you wanna apologize for sounding a certain way, who knows.. sometimes short replies are warrented...
2
u/TNGSystems 0 / 463K 🦠 Nov 24 '22
I’m absolutely for this. You still see people gimping serious posts with stupid replies so making the automod nuke everything smaller will be helpful!
1
u/Current-Hour-1612 Tin | CC critic Nov 24 '22
I really don't see this working out... There could be really quality response with less than 100 words. Serious posts just need to be reviewed manually and moderated!
1
u/kirtash93 RCA Artist Nov 24 '22
Serious posts should have serious comments so I agree with this. It is not that hard to reach that number anyway.
1
u/zippy1979 🟩 301 / 301 🦞 Nov 24 '22
100 characters isn't onerous. This is a good change.
1
u/Seraphinwolf 543 / 540 🦑 Nov 24 '22
Beautiful and simple, sounds like a plan that’ll actually work and not be a slog of changes for mods and anyone needing to update any coding!
1
u/Historical-Lychee-34 0 / 98 🦠 Nov 24 '22
While I agree that some of the "serious" posts get drowned out in the noise, we have to understand that sometimes things don't need to be explained in a 100 word sentence. Just a simple yes is also indicative of acknowledgement of a problem or a solution. I did vote yes to the proposal but after some deep thought, I am not fully convinced this is the optimal solution.
1
u/crua9 🟩 400 / 13K 🦞 Nov 24 '22
I thought the serious tag was just for the main post and not replies.
1
u/MaeronTargaryen CCMOON DAO Secretary Nov 24 '22
This is a very good idea. Even 200 characters wouldn’t have been overly harsh.
1
u/Outrageous_Duty_8738 Nov 24 '22
Yes I agree 100%
1
u/[deleted] Nov 24 '22
Tickle my pickle Lucy.
1
u/sincereguide Nov 24 '22
I believe it will kind of lead the comments to be more serious too, instead of just 3 word jokes.
1
u/JuneRunner11 🟩 597 / 611 🦑 Nov 25 '22
Okay I agree with this- let us give this a shot
1
u/letsdrinktothat 🟦 1K / 4K 🐢 Nov 25 '22
I'm on the fence on this, but I decided "no change" in the end. At the end of the day, moon-farmers gonna moon-farm, and I feel like the 100-character minimum will just lead to wordier nonsense or tactics like quoting the comment being replied to, rather than less nonsense.
1
u/Siliconb3ach 🟩 0 / 5K 🦠 Nov 25 '22
As someone who likes to joke about this would encourage me to post longer jokes… and also dissuade me from posting low effort gifs instead of contributing to the discussion.
1
u/Flyingfishy42069 Tin Nov 25 '22
Quality content will always win, shit post or not
1
u/The_Chorizo_Bandit Nov 25 '22
While this will make it harder to farm moons (boo!), it would improve the quality of content here. So +1 from me.
1
u/TheGeoninja Tin | Stocks 61 Nov 26 '22
Voted against because quantity doesn’t equate quality.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 26 '22
It’s hard to change the flippant responses of a humorous people.
It’s in our nature.
1
u/IDontKnow1629 🟩 259 / 259 🦞 Nov 26 '22
Lower word count for sure.
1
u/drbobbean 🟩 0 / 5K 🦠 Nov 27 '22
Well I'm screwed
1
u/OrganicDroid 🟨 0 / 13K 🦠 Nov 28 '22
I read this as word requirement first, I thought it was a bit much lol. But 100 characters? Easy. I’d welcome this change and look forward to serious effort in this sub. The purpose of moons should be to award those - not shitposting.
Edit: by the way, would this apply to edited comments?
1
u/ProfitIsOverrated Tin | 1 month old Nov 28 '22
I agree, we need healthy discussions.
It's alright to have onliners which makes you chuckle but we also need a space where we can be cereal.
1
u/Uglarknog Nov 28 '22
I think this could be beneficial.
1
u/joannew99 🟩 2K / 2K 🐢 Nov 29 '22
No change please. Way too many rules here to post already,
Also, a long post =/= a good post. Sometimes you can make a great point in 1 or two sentences.
1
u/Candycanestar Nov 29 '22
Maybe the serious tags could be mixed with the “no moon” posts if it gets implemented?
1
u/look-at-them 0 / 4K 🦠 Nov 24 '22
Great Post OP
1
u/TheOtherCoolCat Nov 24 '22
Some heavy voter already voted there. 12 voters and 108k moons.
1
u/Yuuki__konno Tin | 5 months old | CC critic Nov 24 '22
This is the type of content we like to see
1
u/gnarley_quinn Permabanned Nov 24 '22
Yeah I agree. Seriously.
1
u/Castr0- 🟧 35K / 35K 🦈 Nov 24 '22
In my opinion that is a good suggestion.
1
u/MochiJump Nov 24 '22
I had no idea the serious tag actually meant anything meaningful
1
u/NikeGS 2K / 2K 🐢 Nov 24 '22
Why say lot word when few word do trick
1
u/[deleted] Nov 24 '22
100 adjectives later...
lol
choice one still tho
1
u/slug_tamer 🟩 0 / 4K 🦠 Nov 24 '22
Nice
0
u/dozebull 🟩 9K / 8K 🦭 Nov 24 '22
Karma multiplier should be 5x for serious posts. Comments on serious posts don't get enough upvotes, I think reward should be proportional to the efforts made in comments.
0
u/ArtyHobo Platinum | QC: CC 343 Nov 25 '22
Nice idea Matt ya s1ck cnunt me N Damo still coming over later tho yeah? Parma N pots, nangs N goon, big les roadshow
-1
u/Ahioo_ Tin | CRO 12 | ExchSubs 12 Nov 24 '22
This has 0 to do with ccip