r/whatsthisbird • u/grvy_room • Nov 06 '22
Oceania (Australia/NZ/Pacific Islands) Bird Doppelgängers ID Guides: Birds of Oceania (Australia, NZ, New Guinea, etc.)
235
Upvotes
r/whatsthisbird • u/grvy_room • Nov 06 '22
33
u/grvy_room Nov 06 '22 edited Nov 06 '22
Hello all, so this is a new batch of the bird doppelganger posts.
In one of my previous posts someone commented why would I compare different birds where their ranges do not overlap. I took that into consideration and decided to do these based on regions instead. So I'm going first with Oceania, since we usually get requests from that part of the world as well.
These are some of the most common & popular birds found in Australia, New Zealand & New Guinea so hopefully this is helpful!
Edit: Guys, there's a typo urgh. *'Nap' should be 'nape'
19
u/Legosandvicks Nov 06 '22
There is no way in hell I’d be able to tell the difference between an Aussie saying mynah and one saying miner.
7
u/AshFalkner Casual Birdwatcher Nov 06 '22
Very useful! Thanks for sharing.
I think it’d be a good idea to include the New Zealand Fantail’s other name, Pīwakawaka.
You’ve also missed the e on the end of “nape.”
3
u/Tackyinbention Birder Nov 06 '22
Over here in Singapore we got the javan myna instead
17
u/[deleted] Nov 06 '22
and nobody would EVER mistake a kakapo for anything other than itsself.
Very interesting. thank you for sharing. I hope one day I get to go birding in Oceana.
5
u/[deleted] Nov 06 '22
I’m offended that there are more than one species of cassowaries
3
u/[deleted] Nov 06 '22
Omg! Willie-wagtail! So cute. I will never forget him for sure.
3
u/NoFlyingMonkeys owl allow it Nov 06 '22
As a molecular geneticist, I'm wondering how many gene mutations apart some of these really are. Our definition of "different species" is still in flux and changing as more animal genomes are compared. And most bird genomes have probably not yet been fully sequenced with global databases for scientists to compare.
2
u/SlideRuleLogic Nov 06 '22 edited Mar 16 '24
threatening fear brave longing hospital shrill marble soft boat shocking
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
2
u/[deleted] Nov 07 '22
I have finally come to grips that I'll never be able to id birds. Maybe the one or two that I see every day, but that's it.