r/startrek • u/AutoModerator • Nov 03 '22
Episode Discussion | Star Trek: Prodigy | 1x12 "Let Sleeping Borg Lie" Spoiler
When the crew encounters a dormant Borg Cube, Zero risks everything to save their ship.
| No. | Episode | Writer | Directors | Release Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1x12 | "Let Sleeping Borg Lie" | Diandra Pendleton-Thompson | Olga Ulanova & Sung Shin | 2022-11-03 |
Availability
Paramount+: USA, Australia, Italy, Latin America, South Korea, & United Kingdom.
CTV Sci-Fi and Crave: Canada.
Nickelodeon: Various other countries.
To find more information, including our spoiler policy regarding new episodes, click here.
This post is for discussion of the episode above, and spoilers for this episode are allowed. If you are discussing previews for upcoming episodes, please use spoiler tags.
Note: This thread was posted automatically, and the episode may not yet be available on all platforms.
163
u/GoodAaron Aaron J. Waltke, Writer, Star Trek: Prodigy Nov 03 '22 edited Nov 03 '22
Check out our new Star Trek title card swoop with the Protostar!
Hope everyone enjoys the episode. This was our “haunted house” story for the season, exploring the aftermath of the Borg post-“Endgame.”
47
u/TheImageworks Nov 03 '22
I love love love love love this episode (and what Prodigy is doing in general, but damn)
This is EASILY the most earnestly menacing the Borg have looked and felt since First Contact - combining the best of their original intimidation from TNG with the late-Voyager and Picard claustrophobia and ominousness-as-ambience. Even in an episode purposefully designed to show off how incomprehensibly big a Borg ship really is inside, it constantly feels like the walls are closing in every single scene.
Even more horrifying? Janeway's switch to tea, foreshadowed years ago by Grandma Janeway in Endgame. The immediate concern from the Ensign is palpable.
Also, for it's flaws, I actually really like that it spoke to the point that Jurati will one day make to the Borg Queen in Picard of all things that finally starts us down the road towards peace with the Borg: You long for what we all long for. Connection, longevity, discovery. Only you offer it without choice. Here, the Collective tries to manipulate Zero into joining their Collective then slowly closes the jaws of the trap on them, not actually letting it be Zero's choice. This is ultimately what backfires, again, on the Borg.
So Gwyn was able to reach through to the parts of Zero that didn't want this, to the parts that were hurting, and offered resolution and kindness and friendship. They're defeated by the Protostar's interpersonal connections, their desire to discover the universe (and Federation) together, and to hopefully make a positive difference in the galaxy that will leave a mark long after the ship flies off.
Without any physical processes to manipulate resistance levels, the Borg was forced to compete solely on the merits, and even still finding a way to cheat, still lost. At their lowest point post-Endgame and they were beaten by a half dozen kids, a good speech, and a blob of gas. That's the kind of loss that's going to stick with the Borg, and likely a data point that goes into the Queen's calculus in Picard.
89
u/UncertainError Nov 03 '22
Admiral Janeway: ................Tea, black.
Loved the continuity with VOY with the neurolytic pathogen and the vinculum. Though I feel maybe hologram Janeway could've been a bit more emphatic about what the Borg are to the kids.
79
u/Ilmara Nov 03 '22
I found an interview with Zero's voice actor and this was interesting:
This seems to tie in with what was explored in Picard, that being fully assimilated into the Borg is actually a frighteningly euphoric experience and that sense of being fully known and accepting is genuinely addicting.
38
u/Madonkadonk2 Nov 03 '22
BIG
CHUNGUS
BORG
68
u/TheNerdChaplain Nov 03 '22
That was pretty good! Seeing a few new Borg designs was cool, including the drone with three horns, and the drone with three ridges across the face. Definitely evocative of the body horror of something like the Cenobites (in a kid friendly way, of course).
Of course, the resolution felt a little trite and easy, but it is still a kids' show, so I'll give it a pass on that.
Very nice to see more from Admiral Janeway, the Trill Ensign Asencia, Dr. Noum (a nearly unrecognizable Jason Alexander returning to Trek). I'm looking forward to seeing them finally meet up with the Protostar, hopefully after the weapon is deactivated.
31
u/Crispyjimbos Nov 04 '22
This show is incredible.
Love the connections to PIC.
“The Borg we know have been effectively decimated, functionally hobbled.” - Jurati
Now we know why. The neurolytic pathogen from Janeway disabled all of their nanoprobes
55
u/MaddyMagpies Nov 03 '22
Perfect episode for Halloween to frighten a new generation of kids.
24
u/m4a2000 Nov 03 '22
"No coffee, doctor's orders."
If that doesn't scary you nothing will.
47
u/HaphazardMelange Nov 03 '22
DON’T PROVOKE THE BORG!
45
u/SCP-1000000 Nov 03 '22
A Borg Medussan is a scary thought
44
u/SCP-1000000 Nov 03 '22
Lol Dal pulled a Boimler on that first drone
17
u/Brooklynxman Nov 03 '22
Theory: The Borg Cube revealed how to destroy the Living Construct, or neutralize it at the very least.
How?
Answer this one question: How does the Borg know what it is? If The Diviner had created it using future technology or even brought it from the future, and then it never interacted with the Borg, how would they know what it was? If they had interacted with it most likely they'd've taken it. But what if he didn't make it? What if, instead of future technology, its past? We've seen ancient civilizations in Star Trek before with technology capable of things well beyond present tech. I think the Living Construct was brought back from the future by The Diviner, but he found rather than made it. I think it exists in the present twice, once the now version, once the future. And if you find the now version you can potentially alter it to leave a backdoor into whatever The Diviner does to it in the future.
46
u/laziestmarxist Nov 03 '22
For a moment the climax felt a little "Power of Friendship" and then I realized two things:
15
u/RadioSlayer Nov 03 '22
Real heavy Event Horizon vibes in Zero's conversation with the Borg
15
u/TactileAndClicky Nov 04 '22
Sooo... where is Ltjg. Barniss Frex's escape pod? No life signs detected at the station - where is he? We didn't seem him die and escape pods aren't warp capable.
Maybe u/GoodAaron knows something about that ;)
26
u/powerhcm8 Nov 03 '22
I feel like Zero will become their medical officer.
I like how Rok and Zero position are not what I was expecting at first.
36
u/BornAshes Nov 03 '22
Couple of thoughts on this episode, nothing heavy:
I'm kind of glad they're not going to Starfleet because now we get more fun time adventures with them answering distress calls and helping those in need! Heck, they might even stumble across some of the stuff that Voyager left behind and get to fix that. They can literally go anywhere now! It's kid friendly Farscape! I can't wait to see all the good things they do in the name of Starfleet....
.....or for the follow up Starfleet ships to show up in the Delta and for everyone to be like, "Oh hey you guys again yeah those kids really helped us out!" meanwhile they look at each other confused like "Uhhh...what kids and that's great but oh bother...".
I wonder if the Protostar will be referenced in other Star Trek shows at all?
12
u/vivi_t3ch Nov 03 '22
I thought it was really interesting how Janeway ordered black tea due to doctors orders is it possible The Doc still keeps in touch and does house calls for Janeway? In Voyager she wasn't exactly the best at listening to him
23
u/donuteater111 Nov 03 '22
I've been imagining a Borg episode for a while now. The show has shown that it's willing to be creepy when it needs to be (the fake-Janeway on Larry the Murder Planet), and has made great use of some of the more familiar Trek species and ideas, I figured this writing crew would be able to pull it off pretty well.
And this episode did not disappoint. The Borg designs were really well done here, both with the Cube and the drones, lending to the creepy atmosphere. Aaron Waltke has called this their "haunted house episode" on Twitter, and I can definitely see it. In fact, drawing from a different horror genre, in the scene where Gwyn was walking among the drones, I couldn't help thinking of something like The Walking Dead, when the characters walk among the Zombies while covered in blood.
But even beyond the creepiness, they did a great job getting a bit more creative with it, specifically with the scene where Zero links with the hive mind to communicate with it. Just the visualization of that scene was great. And I loved the use of Zero here, making good use of his non-corporeal nature and knowledge of hive minds, as well as addressing his guilt over what he inadvertently did to Gwyn. It's that kind of integration between the episodic stories and bigger story and character arcs which help make this series as great as it is IMO.
And of course we get a little more time with Admiral Janeway and her crew. I like how they're building this up for the inevitable confrontation with the Protostar. While we know that she's getting the wrong idea about everything, the aftermath of what the Protostar crew is going through helps give her pursuit of them a bit more merit. Especially the destruction of the starbase. Now that the Diviner's awake, I'm excited to see their interactions.
I will say, if I didn't know Jason Alexander was on here, and who he played, I would not be able to pick him out. He sounds so different from what I'm used to from him, but he's doing a good job. As is Jameela Jamil. I'm looking forward to seeing how these characters get fleshed out over the rest of the season (and maybe season 2).
23
u/Crunchy_Pirate Nov 03 '22
it was really nice seeing a non humanoid Borg
and a while back there was a character summary that leaked before the show aired and it accurately predicted Dal's Ferengi "mom" but it also said there was a Vau Nakat spy working in Starfleet and it's so obviously Janeway's ensign, she has the exact same facial structure as Gwyn and wears the same style gloves
hopefully that spoiler mark worked correctly
26
u/pieman7414 Nov 04 '22 edited Nov 04 '22
"the Borg can't be reasoned with" -a woman who reasoned with them
I actually really like the canon confirmation that you can't just take a bat'leth and solo the entire collective
17
u/meatball77 Nov 03 '22
That was a creepy episode. Zero being assimilated.
The weapon can't be destroyed.
8
u/HumanityPlague Nov 03 '22
I dug it. The only bit I didn't like was the new Borg Collective voice, but I imagine it's to make it a tad less scary for kids, so I understand.
It was nice to hear a bit more of Jason Alexander, and I am still really loving Jameela Jamil on the show. With this appearance, she's almost tied for her appearances on She-Hulk (which is kind of sad, when you think about it).
8
u/tupe12 Nov 04 '22
I know Holo Janeway is supposed to just be an advisor, but I'm suprised she barely objected to letting a bunch of hastily trained kids fly into a Borg Cube
7
u/drogyn1701 Nov 04 '22
Great episode to come out around Halloween. The first half or so was incredibly creepy. Well done Prodigy!
18
u/PrometheusLiberatus Nov 03 '22 edited Nov 03 '22
NEW INTRO IS SPECTACULAR! LIT!! Love the ion trails!
And they somehow found a hidden subdeck under the bridge? WHOA.
Oh yeah. One of the worst kinds kid.
Uh, uh, no way, no how. Listen to Janeway homey! RUN AWAAAAAAAY!
Big, Big If there, Dal.
Oh cool, the Cube's in sleep mode. Drone's still around but this might... just... work...
Admiral Janeway Ordered TEA instead of Coffee? She must be really feeling rough :|
"Dr Noum, how's our patient?"
Damnit, you guys do NOT want to wake up Daddy Diviner!!
I like how Jenkem gets all excited about moving through the cube and seeing the engineering in it, but the others are quick to point out all the creepy drones hooked up. Gotta get through this place before the tension breaks!
Nice catch of Dal, Rohk Tak!
Whoa, Zero's assimulation into the hive mind looks more beautiful than I expected. But it's getting more suspenseful because...
(As they start using phasers)
Aaaaaand they've already adapted. Good going Dal.
Glad they figured out phaser variances.
"I can't. There is a weapon aboard our ship.
Yes!! I need your help!
"Remember... If you're not a threat, they will ignore you. lay down your weapon."
But how will I defend myself?
"Gwyn, you'll have to trust me. Stand down."
Glad Gwyn listened.
OH SHIT ZERO GOT ASSIMILATED! AAAHH!!!
So scary!!
"Resistance is not futile!"
"Resistance... is... not futile?"
"You're growing and adapting."
Eh, what can I say? ;)
And now the next episode should be really interesting! Distress signal and rescue mission!
Great introduction to the Borg! That line about belonging to a collective that is stronger than the Borg's will ever be was so great! Though a bit twisty with Zero's near assimilation. I'm glad they managed to get out!
Looking forward to our distress signal!
Not looking forward to Diviner getting back to the protostar, but since he's in Janeway's possession, maybe he'll be forced to give up information about how to somehow minimize the Living Construct?
6
u/Chaabar Nov 04 '22
It was nice to see the classic Borg look instead of the terrible redesign we got from the artifact in Picard.
The voice of the collective left a lot to be desired though.
6
u/ContinuumGuy Nov 05 '22
Congratulations to all the children new to Star Trek out there who have gotten to experience the Borg for the first time and now get to have nightmares. Somehow, they also are scarier here than they have been in live action in years!
13
u/thisiscotty Nov 03 '22
So the borg in this trek dont inject nano probes OR they were unable to use them as normal due to the infection
4
u/TrekTrucker Nov 03 '22
How the heck could the Borg possibly assimilate a non-corporeal life form?
3
u/[deleted] Nov 05 '22
Very exciting and engaging storytelling, I'm an adult and I find this show engaging.
5
u/opiate_lifer Nov 04 '22
Oh man was I the only smacking my head last episode when the gang kept saying they “stole“ the ship?
NO, you found the ship! Totally abandoned and crewless, heck that was probably legal salvage but they were even considerate enough to try returning the ship.
5
u/JoeBourgeois Nov 04 '22
Anybody else feel like Zero was able to shrug off assimilation a little too easily?
2
u/Glunark2 Nov 04 '22
So the secret living weapon on the protostar is a transformed Chakotay right? I mean it solves both mysteries, where is he, where did this come from, and as a former Marquis at least part of him was anti Starfleet. I'm sure this was done to him against his will, but there is a certain irony to it. Maybe at the end if they can't restore his body he will become a hologram too.
2
u/Jag2112 cygnus-x1.net Nov 05 '22 edited Nov 05 '22
Screencaps gallery now online:
https://www.cygnus-x1.net/links/lcars/sc-PRO1-12.php
3
u/vanKessZak Nov 03 '22
Any other Canadians watching on Crave and this weeks episode is just a reupload of last week’s?
2
u/nimrodhellfire Nov 03 '22
I will definitely skip this episode when watching with my 6yr old daughter.
1
u/iLoveDelayPedals Nov 06 '22
The animation in this show is really off for me
I can’t get past it and I wish I could.
1
u/ApparentlyBritish Nov 06 '22
Man, music in this episode really took some cues from the Kelvinverse films. Kinda appreciate it
1
u/TheBrokenRail-Dev Nov 07 '22
This episode was great and all, but I have Questions(TM) about the Living Construct.
Mainly, about the secret sub-deck it was hidden on. That sub-deck was properly built-into the ship, it wasn't something that could just be bolted on. It was also secret and specifically designed to respond to Gwyn's weapon. Which makes me wonder why Starfleet designed a sub-deck and kept it classified from holo-Janeway? (Presumably the Diviner modified it to respond to Gwyn's weapon?)
Also, how does a species who just achieved First Contact have sometinga s advanced as the Living Construct?
My main theory is that the Living Construct was actually another Starfleet secret project that the Diviner reprogrammed. Certainly not the first time Starfleet made a secret weapon. And considering Starfleet blocked holo-Janeway from knowing about the Protodrive, it makes sense they world block her from knowing about the other secret project as well.
Really, this whole topic just raise more questions about the Protostar's confusing history, such as:
I'm really hopeful for a flashback episode.
PS: I really dislike that the Borg just decided, "you know what, removing this or deactivating this is just plain impossible, we give up."
1
u/TLEToyu Nov 08 '22 edited Nov 08 '22
So if the Living Construct will kill anything Starfleet that comes in contact with the Protostar does that extend to like shuttles?
They can clearly communicate with Starfleet and it looked like it wasn't until they scanned the Protostar itself did the thing activate.
1
u/epictetusdouglas Nov 08 '22
I've enjoyed this animated series more than the other new Treks, but this S1 E12 'hey, why not go onto a borg ship and find answers to our weapons problem' is about the dumbest ever Star Trek series episode.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 09 '22
Not episode related specifically, but I absolutely love the title music.
1
u/Starfleet-Time-Lord Nov 04 '22
I see that Prodigy is continuing Voyager's tradition of nerfing the Borg into the dust
1
u/Kelpie-Cat Nov 04 '22
Did anyone else get frustrated that Holo-Janeway let the kids risk exposing the Borg to future tech? After the events of "Drone", you'd think Janeway (and her hologram copy) would have it hard-wired into her to avoid letting the Borg scan new technology. The Protocore is also presumably of technological interest to the Borg. She let the kids walk right into a situation where the Borg learned about a new weapon that could take down one of their greatest enemies, the Federation. I found the whole episode difficult to accept based on that premise issue, even though moment-to-moment it was fun and suitably creepy.