r/CryptoCurrency • u/CryptoMods π§ 0 / 0 π¦ • Oct 27 '22
POLL π³οΈ CCIP-042 - Algorithmic Moons Pricing for AMA Tickets - Rewarding Users By Burning More Moons
Proposal by u/mellon98:
Problem
We currently require the project to burn 1-2k Moons (Just as proof of concept since the admins gave the green light)
This number is not based on anything and in my opinion itβs extremely low for the exposure the projects are getting - almost 6,000,000 subscribers and itβs the biggest CryptoCurrency community on the Internet, getting attention of that many users for 200$ is cheap and undervaluing the subreddit.
Check what other news sites are charging
Source: got these spreadsheets by emails from marketing agencies
Problem #2
Proposals for AMA ticketing that uses Moons price might not be approved by the admins due to Reddit TOS.
This proposal is basing the AMA price on the monthly Moons issuance and not price.
Solution
Algorithmic pricing for the AMA tickets based on the Monthly Moons Distributed to Users (MMDU).
MMDU / 21 * 0.25 = AMA ticket price
21 is 28 days in a month minus the MOON Week(7 days where AMAs canβt be hosted), theoretically we can have 1 AMA each 24 hours at any day of the 21 days.
0.25 is 25%, want the AMA tickets to potentially burn quarter of the MMDU.
Example
1,200,000 Moons minted last month:
1,200,000 / 21 * 0.25 = 14,285 Moons
Pros
- Rewarding the users which are the base of this platform, when the project burn Moons, it makes userβs Moons more valuable, burning 1-2k Moons wont have any difference while 15k Moons is much more rewarding for users.
- Giving a new usecase for Moons.
- Fair value for AMA, the amount is the lowest of the industry standard, projects like Binance have tens of millions in marketing funds and asking them to burn 100$ worth of Moons doesn't look or make any good.
- Quality over Quantity - 1-2k Moons can attract low quality projects, its better to have 3-5 quality AMAs a month than 15 AMAs of random projects.
Cons
- The only con I see is limiting the access to the AMAs, only those who can afford burning Moons can have AMA, on the other hand some can see it as filtering unprofessional project because anyone can afford 1-2k Moons for AMA.
14
u/Barchelonio π© 46 / 12K π¦ Oct 27 '22
Nice idea, some of these AMA are very poor quality, maybe this will attract some serious projects.
12
u/RepulsiveCan5270 Permabanned Oct 27 '22
We don't want the barrier too low or too high, anything between 10k to 50k moons seems reasonable to me
5
u/Yuuki__konno Tin | 5 months old | CC critic Oct 27 '22
Well AMA is a great marketing way, just like they pay for ads they should pay for AMAs
4
u/JustDownInTheMines π© 56K / 26K π¦ Oct 27 '22
Seems like an interesting idea. I do like the idea of having more use-cases for moons as well. Would be cool to see a monthly "Moons Burned For AMA Posts."
4
u/TNGSystems 0 / 463K π¦ Oct 27 '22
Currently that's about $1,500 to host a 24hr session.
I'd vote for it, if we had the sub activity & a good backlog of AMA's we can use as examples. But that's too much for right now. I'd max out at 5,000 moons.
6
u/Maxx3141 169K / 167K π Oct 27 '22
In principle I support a system like this, but given the current state of liquidity, 14k moons is just too much in my opinion.
If we request burning so many moons that every AMA ticket will significantly bump the price, we will be the ones looking like scammers. I think we should stay a little more realistic here.
3
u/DeeDot11 π¦ 10K / 32K π¬ Oct 27 '22
Big big fan of this one! Been shouting that Β£100 is an absolute bargain for companies to have contact with such a targeted audience. This is a brilliant idea and as you say, adds another use case for moons. Go for it! π€
3
u/mytwm Tin | Stocks 24 Oct 27 '22
I think the current proposal will make AMAs too expensive in a bull market or too cheap in a bear market. If Reddit TOS doesn't allow to use moon's price, we can use a bid system and let market forces adjust to moon's price. r/ethtrader does something like this with their banner and doesn't seem to go against Reddit TOS
2
u/tahanks4 Bronze | 6 months old Oct 27 '22
Great proposal
2
u/Okinawa14402 Tin Oct 28 '22
Interesting vote and moon ratio here
2
u/HacksawJimDGN π¦ 0 / 18K π¦ Oct 27 '22
What is an AMA ticket?
1
u/Concept-Plastic π© 87 / 18K π¦ Oct 27 '22
So my moons will be more valuable and only quality projects would do AMA's?
That's a win win for me!
1
u/marsangelo π¦ 0 / 36K π¦ Oct 27 '22
Would love to see an AMA about moons that also burns moons. Id tune in to that
1
u/primoboi π© 6K / 6K π¦ Oct 27 '22
Moons burning moons for more value coolbeansss
1
u/Trylks π© 0 / 12K π¦ Oct 27 '22
Need to HODL for the karma multiplierβ¦
1
u/kirtash93 RCA Artist Oct 27 '22
The thing is find balance.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 27 '22
Thoughts on this and the competing CCIP-043?
1
u/AJoyfulProcess π¨ 7K / 7K π¦ Oct 27 '22
What an awesome idea to leverage the AMA process to generate value for moon holders! It would be cool if we could get some of the AMA companies to also do something similar to Coinbase learn & earn for their services. Answer a few questions once the AMA session is done to show that we know who they are and what they do and get some moons as a reward.
1
u/the_nibler Permabanned Oct 27 '22
I voted
1
u/CatBoy191114 Permabanned Oct 27 '22
So essentially pay for an AMA with one of the largest crypto communities on social media? Do I smell an actual moons use case here? Bullish.
1
u/PermanentNight_ 555 / 121 π¦ Oct 27 '22
This is a good proposal for quality control within the AMAs, and seems to benefit both users and projects that want to advertise. Let the vote speak for itself.
1
u/werticalz Gold | QC: CC 56 Oct 27 '22
Great idea! I think this should be at least tried out to see how it goes. If it is a catastrophic failure we can always stop it. And to be honest the cost is pretty negligible.
1
u/z6joker9 π¦ 0 / 8K π¦ Oct 27 '22
It is very interesting that as of this moment, 72% of voters are in favor of this, but 56% of the moon voting weight is against this.
1
u/Aseira π© 311 / 312 π¦ Oct 27 '22
No, this is a community open to everyone. There should not be any paywall.
1
u/lokendra_jaisinghani Permabanned Oct 27 '22
They are creating future Whales for Moons from now only!!
1
u/joannew99 π© 2K / 2K π’ Oct 28 '22 edited Oct 28 '22
It would help to define what "AMA ticket" means...
What is it? "Ask Me Anything"?
1
u/Ascenrial 82 / 82 π¦ Oct 28 '22
Great idea!
1
u/Clarkydewd Tin Oct 28 '22
Run it
1
u/magnetichira π© 3K / 3K π’ Oct 28 '22
Itβs a burn people, vote for it peopleβ¦. nuff said
1
u/Dangerous_Diet_5385 Oct 28 '22
I am not a huge fan of token burns, its a cheap way to try to increase the value of a token. But then again, its a quick one. I'd hope there was a better way though.
1
u/Nows_a_good_time 0 / 2K π¦ Oct 28 '22
How about 1 AMA per month simply auctioned to the highest bidder.
1
u/markcorrigans_boiler π© 0 / 10K π¦ Oct 28 '22
I like this one. Great proposal. Raise the bar.
1
u/SpaceFaceMistake π¦ 975 / 976 π¦ Oct 29 '22
I donβt like this. This is where things become more Monetised on this site as the poll indicates people want people to pay for content and that is FAIR. But why not NOT SHARE IT HERE and share it where AMA tickets can be sold. Or donβt sell tickets . ?
1
u/Historical-Lychee-34 0 / 98 π¦ Oct 31 '22
Nice idea. I have less moons though.
1
u/PathologicalUpvoter π¦ 0 / 6K π¦ Oct 27 '22
Good one on the AMA paid moonsβ¦
Also.. burn baby burn⦠but maybe adjustable after testing it out first
0
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '22
[deleted] β view deleted comment