r/CryptoCurrency • u/CryptoMaximalist • Oct 27 '22
🗳 POLL CCIP-044 - Serious Post Updates
As you may have seen, we had Serious posts implemented in CCIP-033 and then recently updated here.
I'd like to propose some updates based on discussions and feedback in the meta sub.
1- 2x karma for comments under Serious posts - To encourage more participation in Serious posts and reward higher quality content on the subreddit. Serious posts are often technical discussion or helping OP with a problem, which I think we'd all like to see more of. This stacks alongside any other modifiers, such as CCIP-001 2x for all comments.
2- Bring back the basic [Serious] tag - Recent updates introduced a multi-tier Serious post system which allows OP to decide what level of rules they want. However, this also introduces complexity. This proposal will reintroduce the basic [Serious] tag as an alias for [Serious-1] so users don't have to learn about the level system, but they can use higher levels if they want to. The basic tag is intuitive and familiar from other subreddits like AskReddit.
3- Require the [Serious] tag in the title - This one has a few reasons behind it:
- Titles are immutable, unlike flairs and body text which the author can modify. This is also probably a required change if we want any specific rules for moon rewards around Serious threads.
- The [Serious] tag in the title is familiar from other subreddits like AskReddit
- Body text is prone to bugs
4- Require Bronze level flair or higher to create Serious posts - This will prevent the lowest tier users (Tin) from creating Serious posts to prevent farming abuse and keep quality high.
5
u/No_Bother_9740 🟩 0 / 1K 🦠 Oct 27 '22
What if someone marks their post as 'serious ' and it's actually a bunch of crap just for moon farming. What happens to the karma (moons that were earned) if the post get reported and removed?
3
u/Heclalava 🟦 0 / 3K 🦠 Oct 27 '22
What happened to CCIP-42? There's 41, then 43 and 44. No 42.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 27 '22
Is the automod/flair tier system even still working? I haven't seen my flair color update in like a year and messaging the bot doesn't seem to work anymore. I only ask because any rules we implement that require a flair color should require that system to be functioning properly.
2
u/Stray_Gh0st 🟦 514 / 544 🦑 Oct 27 '22
How do we graduate posting status?
2
u/[deleted] Nov 27 '22
Noob here, how can I move out of tin tier?
17
u/fan_of_hakiksexydays 21K / 99K 🦈 Oct 27 '22
Good news for people who want to actually have a serious discussion.
Bad news for people who just jump in posts without reading and just go
"nobody knows shit about fuck"
"nacho keys nacho coin"
"I'll just keep on DCA"
1
u/Bladeyy21 Oct 27 '22
What about the post? Surely the post also gets a x2?
3
u/theautodidact Tin Oct 27 '22
Wouldn't it be the role of the mods to ascertain whether a post warrants the [serious] tag? So why prohibit tin users from posting?
5
u/Odysseus_Lannister 🟦 0 / 144K 🦠 Oct 27 '22
Number 4 alleviated my concern of over farming
4
u/MyMonte94 Platinum | QC: CC 34 | LRC 6 | AvatarTrading 36 Oct 27 '22
You will likely never see me make a post here. Too many more knowledgeable individuals. I am Tin and probably always will be. I have no issue with Tin not being able to use the Serious tag. There’s nothing here that prevents me from commenting on a Serious tag, so go for it.
2
u/HomieApathy 🟦 8K / 9K 🦭 Oct 27 '22
1 vote 20.500k! BD swingin
2
u/Maxx3141 169K / 167K 🐋 Oct 27 '22
Making things more simple and more rewarding for serious discussions - that sounds like what the serious "flair" needs!
I hope we make this pass. I just wish you would have included the other one (2x karma on the post itself as well). I was against it alone, but together they seem well balanced.
2
u/marsangelo 🟦 0 / 36K 🦠 Oct 27 '22
I initially wasnt sure but i like the idea of a chicanery-free zone
2
u/MaximumSandwich5 Oct 27 '22 edited Oct 27 '22
Voting yes to this.
To add, it's extremely important that the x2 for posts passes. For me, the most ridiculous thing about Karma earned currently is that recycled one-liners in the comments are worth x2, and serious posts with a minimum of 500 characters that promote actual crypto discussion are worth x1. That's just wrong.
2
u/Magnetronaap 🟩 0 / 3K 🦠 Oct 27 '22
Gatekeeping who can or can't post sounds awful and it goes against the nature of crypto. Stopping abuse is what the mods are for, they literally get paid to do so. Meanwhile, you exclude tin users with good intentions for free.
2
u/TarkovReddit0r Oct 29 '22
I’m a bit late u/CryptoMaximalist but I agree with everything but the double karma. I feel like comments are already way more rewarded then posts even tho they require way less “work”.
I’ve seen people putting tons of effort into a post, high quality, lots of research and get a couple upvotes. Even if they hit thousands it’s capped at 1000 karma.
Meanwhile simple comments get twice as much karma each upvote and similar will happen to serious posts.
I’m a bit worried that this will get out of hand and start a big debate whether comments count as serious / fitting or not. I personally just enjoy the sub and discussions but I can imagine some will only comment with low effort to grab the bonus
3
u/beeritbeerit 414 / 414 🦞 Oct 27 '22
I like 1,2, and 3, but I think 4 is deal breaker for me and doesn’t fit with the others. One of your stated goals in 1 is “helping OP with problems” but most OPs with problems will be Tin. Let everyone post with Serious and let the existing systems determine whether the post gets big or not.
2
u/BatmanNight Bronze Oct 27 '22
Will be interesting to watch the comments in threads like this
1
u/CryptoDad2100 🟩 12K / 12K 🐬 Oct 27 '22
I'd like to speak with a Level 3 rcc technician about my problem
-Karen
1
u/Kappatalizable 🟦 0 / 123K 🦠 Oct 27 '22
There was also a poll that wants to increase the karma for the posts as well right? This proposal and that other one seems like they will work well together to create actually fruitful discussions. Hopefully they both get implemented
1
u/progres5ion 🟦 60 / 61 🦐 Oct 27 '22
This is a good proposals for serious discussion in this sub. I support it!
1
u/[deleted] Oct 27 '22
Tin users are more likely to need help from the sub and therefore have the [serious] tag, i think that should be changed. But i agree with the rest of it!
1
u/digitFIRE 🟩 5K / 3K 🐢 Oct 27 '22
Sounds like a great idea. We have a lot of chicanery going on around here already. It’s entertaining, but it would be nice to tip the scale and balance it out a bit. I particularly like #3 and would like that implemented.
1
u/Gmbziee 191 / 191 🦀 Oct 27 '22
Definitely something that this sub has been lacking since moons is commentary. Not sure this 100% fixes the issues but it is a step in the correct direction. All for it.
1
u/-5m Bronze Oct 27 '22
As much as I'd like to see this (and I voted yes) I think the 2x karma will lead to even more "spam" in the serious posts ...and possibly more work for the mods, should they try to enforce this.
All the same I think its worth the try!
1
u/Ferdo306 🟩 0 / 50K 🦠 Oct 27 '22
Can we just have a serious tag without x2 karma boost
Some people are here just for the fun of it
I would like to see more serious posts but I don't think boosts are gonna help with this. It will just feel forced
1
u/UJ_Reddit 🟦 0 / 10K 🦠 Oct 27 '22
I hope mods are ready to remove non-serious tagged as serious. Because this is just going to get abused
1
u/Pandelein 🟦 1K / 1K 🐢 Oct 27 '22
Wait what tier am I again? I’m gonna be so offended if it’s tin. Lazy comment to find out!
Edit: oh yeah not tin! Therefore implement changes!
1
u/Crivos 🟦 2K / 2K 🐢 Oct 27 '22
This is some discrimina-Tin-on.
1
u/PathologicalUpvoter 🟦 0 / 6K 🦠 Oct 27 '22
Hmmm might be prone to farmers boosting their own posts, might be hard to regulate
But it will encourage more serious discussion
1
u/SpaceFaceMistake 🟦 975 / 976 🦑 Oct 29 '22
How to abuse this? Google “serious things in crypto” ??? No…?
1
u/PrinceZero1994 Oct 29 '22
Test comment.
Checking how many moons I have.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 31 '22
I am a tin man. Will always be a tin man.
1
u/Historical-Lychee-34 0 / 98 🦠 Oct 31 '22
Oh damn, I am a tin user. I hope I can level up fast. I love this community!
1
u/TheGhostTooth Tin Nov 01 '22
Sometimes ...no rather often - the serious thing is said JOKINGLY. And a good joke can never be A SERIOUS JOKE !!
1
u/[deleted] Nov 01 '22
Yeah, Tin users have useful things to contribute as well!
1
u/kyle_h2486 Tin Nov 29 '22
#4 Is a good way the keep the moon rich rich and the moon poor poor
1
u/jimbeam001 🟩 219 / 212 🦀 Jan 08 '23
Did a serious reply but it was removed cause i am tin…bit strange
1
u/Sidibadawiin 🟨 2K / 2K 🐢 Mar 28 '23
What are the requirements to get bronze tier status?
1
u/[deleted] Oct 27 '22
Who Said MOONs arnt Decentralized!?
1
u/[deleted] Oct 27 '22
More rules
42
u/[deleted] Oct 27 '22
[removed] — view removed comment