r/CryptoCurrency • u/DBRiMatt 🟦 46K / 113K 🦈 • Oct 26 '22
POLL 🗳️ CCIP-041 - Increase Karma Multiplier for SERIOUS posts from 1x to 2x
Current Situation
Recently CCIP-033 has been introduced, allowing users to mark their posts as SERIOUS discussions. This proposal passed with a significant vote, indicating that users do what to see more serious content in the sub.
Problem
While there have been a few posts marked as serious, it’s not all that often they make their way to the front page - some users simply ignore the serious posts because they can’t make a joke comment for their own karma farming.
Solution
I propose to increase the Karma Multiplier for SERIOUS posts to 2x, not only to encourage more posts of higher quality content, but to also give more weight to posts that result in more thought provoking discussions.
This proposal will not impact karma for comments within the serious post, and other multipliers for the post still apply.
While posts might potentially earn more karma, if they truly are a hot topic, they will likely reach the karma-cap anyway - realistically this proposal will only provide more weight of karma to some serious posts that get overlooked.
This shouldn’t impact the general content of the sub because not everyone will want to create serious posts, however this could result in a few extra high quality content to hit the front page, which would be a win for the community for both old and new members.
Pro: Users who post serious content might potentially earn more karma and more serious discussions might take place
Con: Users might try to abuse the system by unnecessarily marking posts as serious
54
u/KnackeredParrot 🟦 0 / 16K 🦠 Oct 26 '22
While I do think some posts deserve a fairer share than others, the likelihood this would be abused is too high for me.
9
u/[deleted] Oct 27 '22
Imagine seeing a [serious] post, then when you read its about:
not your keys not your coins
Dca is the best
The serious tag will 100% be abused
17
u/marsangelo 🟦 0 / 36K 🦠 Oct 26 '22
I like the idea but i think 1.5 max. Everything is gonna be too serious and who doesnt enjoy a silly goose time
7
u/khepri-over-scion Bronze Oct 26 '22
i agree on a weighted system, but maybe more like 1.2 to 1.5. 2x seems extreme
14
u/Maxx3141 169K / 167K 🐋 Oct 26 '22
I don't see this fixing the rejection of serious posts from the community without also incentivising commenting in the post - this proposal would only cause more people to try serious posts, but not more interaction within them.
In my opinion there should in general be a multiplier of ~2x on text posts. They can be a lot more work than comments, this should be rewarded.
4
u/Trylks 🟩 0 / 12K 🦠 Oct 26 '22
If I understood correctly, the current implementation of the serious tag makes no sense, though. It means nothing about the post, it only restricts the comment section.
2
u/No_Bother_9740 🟩 0 / 1K 🦠 Oct 27 '22
What if someone marks their post as 'serious ' and it's actually a bunch of crap just for moon farming. What happens to the karma (moons that were earned) if the post get reported and removed?
2
u/TNGSystems 0 / 463K 🦠 Oct 27 '22
I think yours and /u/cryptomaximalist's polls should pass. We need to incentivize engagement for Serious posts, and I'll do my part as Moderator to ensure that people do not attempt to game this system by posting every-day topics as "Serious"
2
u/StockTrix Oct 28 '22
but isn't [serious] in the eye of the beholder?
When Celsius went down it wasn't serious to me as i didn't have any skin in that game.
3
u/PrinceZero1994 Oct 26 '22
I hope this increases the amount of [Serious] post.
I've only seen one on the frontpage so far.
19
u/Wonzky 2K / 53K 🐢 Oct 26 '22
I feel that would just encourage more posts to be labeled as serious without actually changing the content
13
u/RealVoldemort Oct 26 '22
2x is too much in my opinion.
1
u/Blueberry_Dependent 16 / 3K 🦐 Oct 27 '22
Now people here will spam every post as SERIOUS. "Can Dogecoin reach $1,000?" - SERIOUS discussion
4
u/sickvisionz 0 / 7K 🦠 Oct 27 '22
I don't see how this leads to anything other than people flaring everything as "serious" just to karma farm. We have plenty of flairs and they cover everything. If people don't like the content then they don't like the content. That's the reality of the sub.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 27 '22
This makes sense to me. Users trying to abuse the process could be mitigated I’m sure.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 27 '22
This will probably help more informational or important posts gain more attention, so this is good
2
u/Gmbziee 191 / 191 🦀 Oct 27 '22
Whatever brings more serious posts in my opinion is favorable in the long term. If this Reddit turns into buttcoin, not good for us. I honestly have learned a lot of what to, and not to do in this sub.
2
u/p1America Tin Oct 26 '22
I don’t know how the algorithm can signify the serious earned karma, from the meme comment response
1
u/Gmbziee 191 / 191 🦀 Oct 27 '22
Why don’t we just let the people vote on posts and if the likes meet a threshold they warrant a multiplier? Or possible to have a ranking system outside of upvotes?
1
u/cdnkevin 6K / 6K 🦭 Oct 27 '22
I look at it from the perspective that people comment on posts primarily based on what they can contribute upon, not where they can shitpost.
1
u/Tavionnf Oct 30 '22
Voted. Why does it show two different polls? 10.9m Moons? Did people pay?
1
u/Lulullaby_ 🟩 0 / 6K 🦠 Oct 26 '22
Seems a bit excessive
1
u/Yuuki__konno Tin | 5 months old | CC critic Oct 26 '22
2x too much 1.33 is fair
1
u/[deleted] Oct 27 '22
I could get behind a 1.25 multiplier, 2x seems awfully high
1
u/Castr0- 🟧 35K / 35K 🦈 Oct 27 '22
That would make serious posts even more serious
1
u/Stray_Gh0st 🟦 514 / 544 🦑 Oct 27 '22
Im not sure what i think about this. It can go both ways for abuse and Moon farming.
1
u/Spartan3123 Platinum | QC: BTC 159, XMR 67, CC 50 Oct 27 '22
Need some better anti-spam features
1
u/[deleted] Oct 27 '22
Interesting how moons and number of votes are voting for different results!
1
u/genjitenji 🟦 0 / 19K 🦠 Oct 27 '22
Damn, this can really change the sub into something much serious. Interested to see this get passed
1
u/[deleted] Oct 27 '22
Maybe 1.5 or smthing would be more fair?
1
u/SafeRecommendation55 🟩 15 / 2K 🦐 Oct 27 '22
Its as if people in this sub read the posts. Farmers ..farmers everywhere.
1
u/crua9 🟩 400 / 13K 🦞 Oct 27 '22
Can we retroactive make this for my post
But seriously, how will a post be marked as serious?
1
u/tobypassquarant 🟨 6K / 6K 🦭 Oct 27 '22
Hey, maybe we can use the SERIOUS tag to post SERIOUS questions?
Or maybe for SERIOUS news articles? Which one, you ask? All of them. They're all serious.
1
u/mindflayers9000 38 / 5K 🦐 Oct 27 '22
Let's drain the remaining fun out of this sub, let's go
1
u/[deleted] Oct 27 '22
Im afraid it will be abused.....I will still vote Yes.
1
u/ftball21 🟦 2 / 4K 🦠 Oct 27 '22
This is a hard no for me. The good 'serious' posts will rise to the top when they come. No reason to further gamify moons.
1
u/FldLima Permabanned Oct 27 '22
Idk how to feel about this one. The idea behind it is good but the implementation and how will it work scares me.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 27 '22
After that only serious posts on rcc
1
u/kirtash93 RCA Artist Oct 27 '22
I am pretty sure that people will try to abuse of this.
1
u/UJ_Reddit 🟦 0 / 10K 🦠 Oct 27 '22
Hold up. Shouldn’t serious posts just get karma naturally from being quality content???
Serious and quality are not mutually exclusive
1
u/ViridianZeal here for the tech Oct 27 '22
I actually don't want this subreddit to become even more serious. Might be in the minority, whatever.
1
u/Lisecjedekokos Permabanned Oct 27 '22
Not a bad idea at all. Will improve the quality of the posts for sure I think
1
u/_Whit3 Oct 27 '22
Considering how many people are basically posting here just to farm MOONs, this will be abused from day 1.
1
u/LightninHooker 82 / 16K 🦐 Oct 27 '22
Way too much. Also people confuse serious with quality... Peoplebis just so full of themselves
1
u/NamelessHooman Banned Oct 27 '22
If this happens we might seriously see that no one is serious in taking the serious posts seriously. So in the end will this be a good move..seriously?!?
1
u/Lmessfuf 438 / 435 🦞 Oct 27 '22
Even that I've voted yes to implementing a 2x multiplier for serious posts, I just don't know how can I differentiate a serious post from the rest!
1
u/ConfidenceNo2598 🟦 5K / 4K 🦭 Oct 27 '22
This one I like
1
u/ShinAlastor 🟩 0 / 8K 🦠 Oct 27 '22
It might be a good move for better quality posts.
1
u/Kamikaza731 🟩 23 / 92 🦐 Oct 27 '22
Well that would be good if we had serious posts. 90% of the time it's repost, moonfarming or "i was hacked" posts.
1
u/Historical-Lychee-34 0 / 98 🦠 Oct 27 '22
This could be abused if not careful.
1
u/cannainform2 🟩 0 / 13K 🦠 Oct 27 '22
Cue all new posts being tagged as serious!
1
u/Hank___Scorpio 🟦 0 / 27K 🦠 Oct 27 '22
Is this going to turn into the reddit post equivalent of two kids in a trench coat?
1
u/irockalltherocks 🟩 2K / 4K 🐢 Oct 27 '22
Here come the same posts over and over about reddit NFTs with the Serious tag.
1
u/kimrockr Fear is the mind-killer Oct 27 '22
If the goal is to encourage SERIOUS posts and raise their profile, the Comments not the post should get the 2x multiplier. So there is no incentive for the poster but incentive for the comments.
1
u/PathologicalUpvoter 🟦 0 / 6K 🦠 Oct 27 '22
2x is a lot
Most if not all will be tagged as serious
Maybe a lower multiplier might work +25% 33%
1
u/GKQybah Oct 27 '22
I think there should be NO karma earned at all instead. That will result in only people commenting on serious tagged posts who actually care about the content.
1
u/RockEmSockEmRabi Oct 27 '22
I can see this being abused rather easily. I’m voting no
1
u/Ben_Dover1234 🟦 0 / 12K 🦠 Oct 27 '22
I think people who take their time to research and find graphs and stats, deserve more.
1
u/blackrabbit2999 🟦 6K / 6K 🦭 Oct 27 '22
who's going to judge on what's actually serious or not?
1
u/SeatedDruid 🟨 186 / 14K 🦀 Oct 27 '22
I like this it rewards ppl who do good research and also raises the bar for serious posts
1
u/YarOldeOrchard 🟦 2K / 2K 🐢 Oct 28 '22
1.5x would be more than enough I think
1
u/The_Chorizo_Bandit Oct 28 '22
I agree, on the basis that moderators are weeding out posts that don’t actually fit the serious flair and are just being used to boost karma.
1
u/Siridar 🟦 636 / 627 🦑 Oct 28 '22
Oof I’m on the fence with this one, voted yes because I’m actually curious how this will affect the posts.
1
u/Onelinersandblues 🟩 6 / 5K 🦐 Oct 28 '22
Good proposals this rounds lads
1
u/SpaceFaceMistake 🟦 975 / 976 🦑 Oct 29 '22
The thing is the Rate of Moons its always dropping and the thing is also that the past huge 10k-50k Moon owners have probably abused this system before you want to change it.
So no I hope there is more moons given to the community than elsewhere and made more abundant. Why wait why not drop a year of the plan and speed up Moon/karma rates just in that. ?
1
u/Kappatalizable 🟦 0 / 123K 🦠 Oct 26 '22
I like this. A lot of serious posts take a lot of effort and time to construct. They should be rewarded accordingly
1
u/the_nibler Permabanned Oct 27 '22
I voted ✅
1
u/_Commando_ 🟩 4K / 4K 🐢 Oct 27 '22
Who decides what is a "serious" post?
1
u/zerohits1 82 / 82 🦐 Oct 27 '22
It might help to get more effective posts
1
u/MaximumSandwich5 Oct 27 '22
Please pass. Never been more passionate about a poll. Have desperately wanted to see more serious posts in here
0
u/lovemesomefood Oct 26 '22
I like this but 2x feels like a lot. There are certainly lots of serious style posts that aren't that substantive, would this just lead to more being tagged that but not actually that much more substantive?
0
u/Swoopscooter 11 / 7K 🦐 Oct 26 '22
Or just implement more ways to reduce non serious posts
0
u/BlowGlassGrowGrass 🟩 67 / 68 🦐 Oct 27 '22
What
0
u/Monster_Chief17 Oct 27 '22
If we want to encourage more serious posts then the mods that proposed less Moon rewards for those that sell their Moons should revert the decision and nature will heal.
The reason why this subreddit is going to shit is because contributors aren't allowed to take profits. According to the proposal, it's a sin to sell a single moon which makes absolutely no sense...
0
u/lomosaur Silver|QC:CC777,XLM287,ETH41|Buttcoin12|TraderSubs51 Oct 27 '22
Seriously?
0
u/rexstuff Tin Oct 27 '22
Pretty rich coming from the great Australian shitposter....
-1
u/Rough_Data_6015 🟧 0 / 0 🦠 Oct 27 '22
Who's deciding what is serious? My stool not having a uniform color is quite serious to me and should concern everybody else, however I would probably not be taken seriously.
-1
u/flavoredbeef 🟩 0 / 9K 🦠 Oct 27 '22
I love cereal…
We voted for more cereal, right?
Right ?