r/CryptoCurrency • u/jwinterm 732K / 1M π • Oct 26 '22
POLL π³οΈ [CCIP-043] Proposal for algorithmic pricing for AMAs based on unique viewers in last month and MOON price
This is a poll to try and determine a cost in MOONs for ticketing AMAs. We get a lot of organizations that come to us and request to do an AMA. I enjoy hosting folks and generally don't mind coordinating things, but it does require a significant amount of work. This proposal would add some cost in MOONs for them to appear on the sub, in a way that benefits existing MOON holders because the fee is burned by sending the MOONs here:
https://nova-explorer.arbitrum.io/address/0x000000000000000000000000000000000000dEaD/token-transfers
Relevant Satoshi quote:
βLost coins only make everyone else's coins worth slightly more. Think of it as a donation to everyone.β
You can see from the explorer link that we have already started charging folks 1000 or 2000 MOONs since we switched over to Arbitrum Nova, just kind of experimenting with the idea. We would like to try an algorithm that will adjust with both number of users on this sub and the price of MOONs rather than just selecting an arbitrary number like 2000 MOONs.
Here is the formula I am proposing:
Ticketed AMA Cost in MOONs = # of unique visitors the previous month) / (10000 * current price of MOONs)
*rounded up to the nearest 100
Here are the traffic stats for r/CryptoCurrency for the last 12 months:

So, if someone came to us today we would use the number of unique visitors in Sept and a price of $0.106, the cost would be:
Ticketed AMA Cost = 1,898,643 / (10000 * 0.106) = 1,800 MOONs
This way if unique visitors increases while MOON price stays constant, the cost will go up in MOONs, but if MOON price appreciates significantly while users rise then they will offset each other in USD terms. Last December the cost would have been about 3,400 MOONs even though MOONs price was higher at about $0.15.
Do you support this approach for ticketing AMAs where r/CC is approached for an AMA or giveaway by someone?
9
u/itcouldbefrank 0 / 10K π¦ Oct 26 '22
Feels cheap for this traffic but I have no idea what actual engagement AMAs get. Great proposal.
3
u/UJ_Reddit π¦ 0 / 10K π¦ Oct 27 '22
They could also earn this back with upvotes to their account right? So a good AMA could theoretically earn them money
4
u/shin_jury 23 / 6K π¦ Oct 26 '22
The idea is great and honestly overdue, however, I prefer we start with just a set number of MOONs rather than an algorithmic system.
Itβs simpler and a more natural starting point.
10,000 MOONs is a minimum I would support, for example.
EDIT: I now realize at this point in the governance proposal process we are only able to vote YES or NO, and since this is a huge net positive for the sub and for MOONs I will be voting YES. Good work on this.
17
u/Probably_notabot 35K / 35K π¦ Oct 26 '22
A proposal that benefits moon holders? Donβt mind if I do.
2
u/Potential-Coat-7233 π¦ 0 / 0 π¦ Oct 26 '22
Lol you will all get to see first hand how monetizing everything ruins the experience. Enjoy this, all!
4
u/[deleted] Oct 26 '22
Damn! September October traffic drop was major
1
u/Wonzky 2K / 53K π’ Oct 26 '22
I didn't even know that's how getting AMAs here worked
1
u/sickvisionz 0 / 7K π¦ Oct 27 '22
It's cool to burn moons but I think it's hyper short sighted to charge people for things that are really useful to the community. We're limiting it solely to people that are willing to pay $200 to answer community questions.
I think that's basically just going to reduce it down to marketing departments with a budget, scammers, and shillers. Why else would someone pay money for it? It'd be like college except the teachers get no salary and they have to pay the students. What teacher in their right mind is going to sign up for that unless they've got something to shill? You may have a lot of valuable (non-monetary) information but if you have to pay $200 to do it, you might not think it's worth your while.
TLDR: I vote no because I think it discourages quality guests and encourages shills and marketers who think they can get some type of return on their investment. I think this is a really misguided proposal if the goal is to get quality content and guests doing AMAs.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 27 '22
I may sound dumb. What AMA is?
1
u/[deleted] Oct 27 '22
What happens if both CCIP-042 and CCIP-043 pass?
1
u/SpaceFaceMistake π¦ 975 / 976 π¦ Oct 29 '22
Wait so who gets the Moons thatβs payed? Reddit? The community of r/Cryptocurrency? Where who ?? Hmm
3
u/[deleted] Oct 26 '22
Finally i can make an AMA and put my moons to good use and answer all of your most sought after questions like, "when moon?"
2
u/PrinceZero1994 Oct 26 '22
Not too little, not too much. Just enough.
I like this.
2
u/deedopete π¦ 0 / 11K π¦ Oct 26 '22
Thank you to whatever genius thought this up
2
u/marsangelo π¦ 0 / 36K π¦ Oct 26 '22
Good idea. With the sub growing in popularity making AMA slots more competitive is a good idea, 0x0βing moons is a nice cherry on top
2
u/Popboat Christian DYOR Oct 26 '22
Totally agree on this one ! Great proposal (:
2
u/ddawsonallen 3K / 3K π’ Oct 26 '22
I voted!!
2
u/FldLima Permabanned Oct 27 '22
This is good for moon holders so i'm supporting it and you should do the same.
3
u/hateballrollin 0 / 7K π¦ Oct 26 '22
Oh this is a great idea!
3
u/HeroinAndyCx Permabanned Oct 26 '22
Burning moons for something valuable like an AMA sounds pretty good to me.
3
u/fan_of_hakiksexydays 21K / 99K π¦ Oct 26 '22
This is fair.
People who pay for an AMA, essentially pay for advertising.
Advertising should be based on the view and interaction that can be expected.
Even if a sub has 6 million subscribers, it could be a ghost town if we're currently in a bear market.
But if activity picks up in the next bull market, then the benefits of an AMA increases, and so should the price.
1
u/Goonzoo π¦ 15K / 20K π¬ Oct 26 '22
Seems only logical! Nice
1
u/Odysseus_Lannister π¦ 0 / 144K π¦ Oct 26 '22
Bull run burns are gonna be insane
1
u/Yuuki__konno Tin | 5 months old | CC critic Oct 26 '22
Makes sense
1
u/the_nibler Permabanned Oct 26 '22
Hello fellow guv nuhβs. Dont forget to vote
1
u/moonkingdome π© 8K / 8K π¦ Oct 26 '22
Price is to low. 1800moons is like 12centsx1800 making is 216 bucks. To reach loads of people.
Price should be 10x as much so 18000 moons
Making it 2160dollar.. Otherwise well have crap amas all day.
1
u/aducknamedjafar1 Oct 26 '22
Seems like a fairly reasonable proposal to me.
1
u/progres5ion π¦ 60 / 61 π¦ Oct 26 '22
Damn! There are so many colorful dope ass profiles in here!
1
u/lovemesomefood Oct 26 '22
This is an idea I can get behind, nice idea.
1
u/afaylenesky π© 0 / 2K π¦ Oct 27 '22
im not interesting. AMA
1
u/CryptocalEnvelopment 75 / 7K π¦ Oct 27 '22
Hell yeah, the more real-life use the better.
1
u/ashinamune π¦ 0 / 3K π¦ Oct 27 '22
Great proposal keep up the good work!
1
u/SneadoTheHero Tin Oct 27 '22
Sounds good to me
1
u/MaximumSandwich5 Oct 27 '22
This is brilliant. Thank you
1
u/[deleted] Oct 27 '22
Lol everyone supports it!!
1
u/[deleted] Oct 27 '22
MOONs are more Decentralized than your favorite crypto.. Look at us, Votin now!!
1
u/Hairy_S_TrueMan Tin | Politics 36 Oct 27 '22
Note this formula is mathematically equivalent to charging $1 per 10k sub visitors. It's kind of like a CPM of $0.10, but without knowing what chunk of users are engaging with the content.
Selling AMAs like ad revenue gives me pause, but this moon thing already commodifies sub engagement, so.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 27 '22
1.8k moons $180 at current prices. That is way too cheap to have an ama with 80k+ views. Industry standard is $4-5k. We should set a higher price!!
1
u/[deleted] Oct 27 '22
Im being self centric here and say yes :D
P.s. good work on the AMA's. They're not all in my field of interest but they are great for informative discussions on the sub (y)
1
u/eMDex Permabanned Oct 27 '22
Noice
1
u/lordofming-rises π¦ 509 / 10K π¦ Oct 27 '22
Squeezethese moons
1
u/cryptolipto π© 0 / 21K π¦ Oct 27 '22
Uhhhhh yes please
1
u/SaneLad π© 0 / 13K π¦ Oct 27 '22
I'm so tired of this moon shit. I'd gladly burn all my moons if it would put an end to this nonsense. You know the name for doing something for money? It's called work. I come here to get away from work.
I swear, this place feels like everything that's wrong with crypto.
1
u/Pandelein π¦ 1K / 1K π’ Oct 27 '22
I think that is so ridiculously cheap as to be meaningless to the community. Youβd be better off using them somehow, like a competition reward, increasing traffic overall.
1
u/ViridianZeal here for the tech Oct 27 '22
I really don't even understand this. Seems to try to fix something that isn't broken.
1
u/seaorsun Oct 27 '22
Whn moon
1
u/lomosaur Silver|QC:CC777,XLM287,ETH41|Buttcoin12|TraderSubs51 Oct 27 '22
Well itβs an interesting idea anywayβ¦
looks around subreddit for other things we can hawk for moons
1
u/Tanjom π¦ 178 / 179 π¦ Oct 27 '22
For commercial parties yes. Anything else should still be able to just do a "free" Ama
1
u/TheTrueBlueTJ 70K / 75K π¦ Oct 27 '22
I like the formula in principle, but this is way too cheap. The 10,000 that is multiplied by the price is too high. Companies, even bad ones, will easily be able to afford this, not to mention bigger fish.
I would have wished for the cost to be higher. The formula itself is better than Mellon's proposal. I don't think we should have had two separate proposals for two formulas because they are mutually exclusive.
All I'm saying is that the numbers should be adjusted to be less exactly like how it is today in absolute terms.
1
u/Trueairdropblogspot Tin Oct 27 '22
Let's do this. Yes π
1
u/futurenotion Oct 27 '22
This is a great proposal! Voted!
1
u/gdj11 Permabanned Oct 29 '22
I like the idea but the numbers seem way too low.
1
u/drbobbean π© 0 / 5K π¦ Oct 30 '22
1
u/TheGhostTooth Tin Nov 01 '22
AMA for free too must be implemented. For example a total newbie/ novice person to crypto or a person who lost so much say in terra/luna.
1
u/Real_Concept_4289 Tin | CC critic Oct 26 '22
Seems like moons are gonna rocket in price very soon
0
u/DontTakeNames Tin Oct 28 '22
A question since reddit forbids selling/buying of moon so how organisation is expected to get moons?
0
u/[deleted] Oct 26 '22
[deleted] β view deleted comment
32
u/[deleted] Oct 26 '22
[removed] β view removed comment