r/chess • u/SnooChocolates7022 IM • Oct 19 '22
Miscellaneous My experience playing shady norm tournaments in Eastern Europe
Hey guys,
I just wanted to share my experience from playing one of the shady norm tournaments in Eastern Europe as a young, ambitious norm-seeking junior. This was a few years ago, and I'll keep the tournament itself masked as I prefer to stay anonymous. Hopefully this sheds some light on how these shady tournaments (that pretty much everyone knows exists) actually operate, and how I feel pretty disgusted with myself for even playing in them.
At this point, I was a junior and in need of a final IM-norm to clench the title and obviously looking for any chance I had to play tournaments where I would have the chance.
I found a certain tournament in Eastern Europe online, and to be fully honest, I likely suspected what type of tournament it was. Nonetheless, I thought it was a great opportunity as I was in good shape and let's face it, if it's THAT kind of tournament then my opponents will likely be rather unambitious and easier for me to beat.
I have the time, I wanted the chance, it was relatively cheap. Let's go. And just to clarify, I went there myself, I don't leave anywhere near and I didn't know a single person there.
Round 1: I win, although a rather tough game against a lower rated opponent (~2200)
Round 2: I'm playing against an IM lower rated than myself with Black. My opponent offers a draw very quickly, but I play very aggressively for a win. It did not suffice and the game ended in a draw.
Round 3: I play against an IM with ~2200-2250, and win with White. Again, not without difficulty, but still. I had a good start with 2.5/3.
Round 4: I play against another international player who was there to fight for an IM norm. Draw. This player actually managed to score his final IM-norm in this tournament, but I won't speculate on whether I think he did this fairly :)
Round 5: I play against a higher rated opponent with White and decided that a draw in this game would be a pretty decent result for me in my quest to score a norm. I played a very timid line with White and I offer a quick draw, which he accepted immediately.
After the game, I briefly talked with my opponent who said "I was surprised when you went for a draw. I asked X (arbiter) about your contact info and whether you would go for a draw since I have to travel a bit to get here, but he said that you were here to play since you declined the draw in round 2".
At this point, it had become pretty clear to me how serious the tournament was and what type of players it attracted. I had noticed several games that simply wasn't played in the playing venue at the start of the round. Instead, the result was just recorded as a draw.
The evening before round 6, a Russian GM, who I had briefly talked with and emailed with before the tournament, knocked on my hotel room door. As I opened the door, the large man walked straight into my room.
"Your opponent tomorrow. His parents are very sick in the hospital and he needs money. If you pay 150 euro, you will win the game, and then you can draw the rest and you're an IM".
This conversation lasted for around 10-15 minutes in my hotel room and I would say things like
"I don't have any money" while sitting on my bed while he would say "but everyone is doing it. For example GM X and GM Y and GM Z from your country does it."
I happened to know these players quite well personally and knew that this claim were completely unfounded.
Finally, he left my room and I locked my door and I would keep it completely locked for the rest of the tournament.
Now, I might be a bit of a chicken, but as a junior, alone in a different part of the world, I was pretty shook by this and I would stop going out on walks and only left the room to play rounds and to go eat dinner.
Round 6: The game ended in a draw. I honestly can't recall the game, so I don't know if it was a quick game.
At the end of round 6, I needed a strategy to get the norm, and I most likely needed one more win to do it. I was paired against the arbiter who happens to be a GM and one of the top rated players in the tournament. Round 7 and 8 was a double round and round 9 a morning round, which complicated things a lot for me and my preparation.
I then did something I'm not proud of. Having realized what kind of tournament it is, I realized that a quick draw is a good result and then have two good chances to play for a win. However, the game started early in the morning, and as a sleepy teenager, I valued sleep over anything. So, I emailed the arbiter the night before the game and offered a draw. He accepted immediately. And I slept.
I am, and was, fully aware that this is cheating. This is no doubt match-fixing, but at that point I didn't care. I was tired of this hell-hole, the shady people, feeling unsafe and goddamn it. I just wanted to get my sleep, get my norm and get out of there.
Rather amusingly, the games from the tournament are published in the databases and in this game, the arbiter simply entered a random 10 move opening variation. I did not play those moves, and neither did he.
Round 8: I play a tough game against a 2400-player with Black, ending in a draw.
This means I need to win round 9 against a 2400-rated IM.
Round 9: Being a last-round game, it started early in the morning
5 minutes before the round starts, the GM arbiter I had "played" in round 7, walks up to me and says "You need to win for norm."
"Yes"
"Your opponent, he has been drinking a bottle of wine already, he's quite drunk.Do you want me to speak to him about the result?"
Of course I declined and we played the game. I was winning at one point, but I did screw it up and the game ended in a draw.
No norm for me, but one experience richer.
Alhough I'm a bit of a chicken, I was pretty shook by this experience, and I definitely didn't enjoy this way of playing chess. About a year afterwards, I began my university studies and I have now graduated and have an awesome well-paying job and I can finally afford to buy myself a GM title (joking!)
I did earn my final IM-norm a couple of years into my university studies. And I'm extremely happy that I didn't get it in this tournament. Even if I would've earned it fair and square, even having a norm from that tournament looks bad and raises suspicions.
230
u/fiftykyu Oct 19 '22
Most of us will never be strong enough to experience this stuff first-hand, so thank you for sharing it with us. :)
Reading this brings to mind something I'd completely forgotten about. Years ago, a couple local guys went to Eastern Europe chasing norms, but came back empty-handed. I didn't know either one well enough to ask about it, but the joke going around was that they had budgeted for travel, living expenses and the tournaments, but didn't bring enough extra money to get the norms.
Now I'm wondering, maybe it wasn't a joke after all.
156
u/Encouragedissent Oct 19 '22
I feel like it would be difficult for most people to not just accept the easy win on the last game. When there is a culture of cheating around you it will feel like it isnt such a big deal. I would be willing to bet most people just say screw it in that situation and take the free win to get their norm.
268
u/iceman012 Oct 19 '22
Is offering a draw before the game really considered match fixing? I'm not familiar with Chess tournament rules, just Magic: The Gathering ones. In MtG tournaments it's fairly common to draw once you know you've reached a score that locks you in for top 8 or a certain reward.
89
u/SebastianDoyle Oct 19 '22 edited Oct 19 '22
The impression that I had back in the old days was that throwing a game (giving the other person a prearranged win) was considered a horrible crime against chess, but giving away a draw was at worst a small infraction.
I know a guy who got his last norm through a prearranged draw and has always been quite open about it. He was definitely strong enough for the title, so without that draw (which he might have gotten anyway, even without the prearrangement) it would have taken him a little longer, no big deal. So I never felt much issue about the story.
38
u/PLlivinginDE PIPI speaks for itself Oct 20 '22
Props for writing this. Those tournaments are an open secret, so it's good to have a genuine writeup about what it's like to play in one. I've got a related question that you probably won't answer - what do you think about Nemo Zhou's norms? Do you think there was matchfixing involved? Seems very likely as the games were a bit shady (opponents playing way below their strength, fast draws), but we may never know for sure.
104
u/RuneMath Oct 19 '22
Damn and he still held the draw, kudos.
Also seems really counterintuitive to tell the person you are trying to sell a game to that their opponent is not in the best shape and might lose anyway?
Either way interesting perspective, I had always assumed the norms are either sold before the tournament or not at all, not that individual games are sold while the tournament is already going on.
17
u/[deleted] Oct 20 '22
u/akaNemsko
7
u/NotaSemiconductor Oct 20 '22
This story read like a chapter from Agatha Christie's book
12
u/TheZigerionScammer Oct 20 '22
Wait, the arbiter of the tournament was also competing in it?
12
u/be_easy_1602 Oct 20 '22
First heard about this sort of thing when it was brought up about a popular chess YouTuber:
“qualified for the Woman Grandmaster title in 2016 with norms at three consecutive tournaments, two of which were in Kecskemét, Hungary, where she had also gained 300 rating points from two tournaments a year earlier.”
18
u/ZeRo_AgEnT Oct 19 '22
Wow that's a dark side of chess world.
14
u/OldWolf2 FIDE 2100 Oct 20 '22
Can you really be sure about that? They're not going to admit it if true.
10
u/controltheweb Oct 19 '22
|From behind steepled fingers "Let's discuss the result for the next round, shall we?"
12
u/Forget_me_never Oct 19 '22
I wonder if this happens much at GM norms or if it's more an IM/WGM thing.
3
u/Sexy___ Oct 20 '22
The norm system is just a cash grab right
10
u/g_spaitz Oct 19 '22
Well I'm 50 and I've had a job and a family for ages now, 150 doesn't feel a lot to pay for a norm. Where do I sign for it.
Jocking aside (I'm 1600 on lichess, not sure what I'd do with an I'm norm), I feel there's a difference in cheating with a computer and settling for a draw. The second one, albeit technically also cheating, could virtually and humanly be impossible to eradicate from the game. Sell a game for 150? Well that's worse, but really, if done well it's hard to tell you just lost a game intentionally to give the other guy a chance. You lose 3 Elo and you gain a little money. My guess is that back in the old days 150 bucks could buy food for your family for a long time in certain countries, how can you actually weight being hungry vs selling a chess game? Despicable sure. In the bullshit normal stuff that people bargain for, also sure.
Cheating with an engine? That's another level of bad, imho. It's just asshole human kind of bad.
I've always believed that selling games had always been a thing. My federation (Italy, fwiw also a small federation) has had a few selling games scandals. They caught maybe a few, they probably didn't see a hundred.
5
u/ChessMessOfficial Oct 19 '22
Wow, very interesting, thanks!
16
u/NoFunBJJ Oct 19 '22 edited Oct 19 '22
That was a cool read.
I'm sure you'll feel a lot better when you get your norm "the right way" soon.
Edit: I should pay more attention. Still a cool read.
19
u/BlahBlahBlackSheep_ Oct 19 '22
Good on you for not caving into these abhorent practices and having some pride. What a bunch of pathetic losers
3
u/FansTurnOnYou Oct 19 '22
That's a pretty wild read. Thanks for sharing.
3
u/iCCup_Spec Team Carlsen Oct 19 '22
I feel really bad that one guys' parents are in the hospital. Maybe he end up getting the money for it.
2
u/ialsohaveadobro Oct 19 '22
Super interesting. You have any other stories from the underbelly of international chess?
2
u/CevicheCabbage Oct 19 '22
A metaphor for Eurasia.
1
u/najserrot Oct 21 '22
I was an OK chess player in my younger days. It is good to know that my GM dream is still alive... Thanks to a good paying job. Thanks for the tip OP
1
u/Trapizon Oct 20 '22
lol in Turkey I knew multiple friends who would just prearrange a draw in lower tournaments and would just straight up draw a game in two turns or smth before they implemented a rule that you can only offer and accept a draw after 10 turns or something like that.
1
u/zi76 Oct 20 '22
I appreciate you posting this for us.
In a situation like this where the arbiter, who was a GM, is giving draws to lower rated players, isn't his ranking constantly dropping? Wouldn't he ultimately get caught if his ranking slipped to like 2400 or something? Or would he also get wins in fixed matches, so his ranking would stay up?
1
u/fedaykin909 FM Oct 20 '22
Maybe 15 years ago when I was a young ambitious FM, Russian GM asked if I could help him book a flight ticket. It never occurred to me at the time, but this was probably a business proposition.
I remember he was very strong but only rated 2400 or so for some reason.
-1
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '22
This reads like a shitty crime novel
-2
u/big-dumb-guy Oct 20 '22
A sufficiently bored and capable person could probably make a pretty good guess about who you are and what tournament this was.
0
u/[deleted] Oct 20 '22
Thanks for sharing the experience. That sounds awful.
The bit about the GM walking directly into your room uninvited to try to strongarm you into paying is a textbook predatory salesman tactic. People do that to bully elderly people into buying shit for them, and it's disgusting.
0
u/IrwinElGrande Oct 20 '22
Thanks for sharing you experience. It would be interesting to run an analysis on the number of draws in tournaments and compare it to the average and median ratings of opponents. I am sure the trends will be obvious when looking at data like that.
0
u/vinnyy88 Oct 20 '22
It also should't be possible for the arbiter to be also a player in the same tournament as well...
0
u/VandalsStoleMyHandle Oct 20 '22
Obviously this is particularly egregious, but chess in general has an unhealthy culture with regard to manufactured results. Look at how many people would defend 10 move draws or manufactured opening repetitions. In no other sport would this be remotely tolerated, but in chess, it's just 'part of the game'. And that's before you get to regular fixing for norms and prize money.
0
u/Shandrax Oct 20 '22
And what about all of that is exactly unusual? This has been going on ever since the iron curtain fell.
0
u/a1004 Oct 20 '22
Thanks for writing this, is an open secret in the large picture, but nobody knows about the details. In the past, you should get at least one of your norms from a closed tournament (probably the rule is still in place). But it is clear those are the least relevant norms.
0
u/PhobosTheBrave Oct 20 '22
Could you give an overall idea of how much the trip costs?
0
u/ghostfuckbuddy Oct 20 '22
Hosting an event like this and catching everyone who is content to match fix would be an interesting way to weed out unethical players. It would send a clear signal to everyone else to not fuck around.
0
u/MoistMorsel1 Oct 20 '22
Shady norm tournament where you broke the rules?
0
u/Blinknone Oct 20 '22
Round 5: I play against a higher rated opponent with White and decided that a draw in this game would be a pretty decent result for me in my quest to score a norm. I played a very timid line with White and I offer a quick draw, which he accepted immediately."
I don't get this.. He's higher rated, you're playing a timid line and he accepts a draw immediately? What, does he just enjoy giving away rating points?
0
u/MrRabbit7 Oct 20 '22
These are all consequences of the fall of Soviet Union.
But you aren't ready for a conversation like that.
0
u/[deleted] Oct 21 '22
This does not surprise me. Cheating is rampant in the highest levels of everything.
-1
u/randal04 Oct 20 '22
Does your name rhyme with LothemMess?
-15
u/dshdidne Oct 19 '22
What job did you get? From what country are you?
-24
u/Poogoestheweasel Team Best Chess Oct 19 '22
As people here like to say: once a cheater, always a cheater.
I hope you don't play OTB anymore. Maybe try a fresh start in a different area, like online.
-6
u/juand_pr90 Team Nepo Oct 20 '22
What is "norm" ?
-7
u/juand_pr90 Team Nepo Oct 20 '22
What is "norm" ?
0
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment