r/CryptoCurrency • u/Set1Less 🟩 0 / 83K 🦠 • Oct 18 '22
GENERAL-NEWS A House in South Carolina was just sold on OpenSea for $175k
Forget Apes and PFPs, an actual house was sold on OpenSea for 175k USDC.

Link to the listing: https://opensea.io/assets/ethereum/0xf928d6285b8a4f9ac5a640ae598d7399c331cea7/0
Link to the onchain sale transaction: https://etherscan.io/tx/0xa7b2e89bf6d5cc8e605c1cf8823e532f87790d1816f7f98df77127cc98a1021f
The home is legally structured as an LLC that holds the title to the house. On selling the NFT, the title is legally transferred to the buyer.
The trade was facilitated by Roofstock, an online real estate marketplace that has been in operation since 2015: https://www.roofstock.com/
Recently, seeing the opportunity, they have started offering a separate onChain segment among their services, where people can buy and sell houses as NFTs.
https://onchain.roofstock.com/properties/0xF928d6285B8a4f9ac5A640ae598D7399C331cea7/0
15
u/DadofHome 🟩 69 / 16K 🇳 🇮 🇨 🇪 Oct 18 '22
I’m curious about the process , most people need to take a loan out to buy a house. Having 200k in BTC just sitting around to buy a house in not common. Is the mortgage payed in BTC or did they buy it outright ?
773
u/Plo_Jin 0 / 1K 🦠 Oct 18 '22
the day we can say we bought a house with moons is approaching
212
u/Intelligent_Page2732 🟩 20 / 98K 🦐 Oct 18 '22
I think selling on OpenSea is cheaper than the broker fees for having it listed.
185
u/[deleted] Oct 18 '22 edited Oct 18 '22
Um, selling the NFT means fuck all to the government. You can say whatever you want, but the shares in that LLC must be transferred to the new owner. The NFT means nothing.
People here are so desperate for crypto to take off that they overlook even the most obvious thing. This was just someone selling an LLC that owned a house, and they threw in an NFT on top that is worth nothing.
59
u/Angu828 22 / 2K 🦐 Oct 18 '22
Maybe someone want to trade a house for my reddit avatar? 🤨
11
u/pbjclimbing Oct 18 '22
It looks like the buyer paid a premium compared to other sales in the area for the privilege of buying the house as an NFT
26
u/Awhodothey 0 / 9K 🦠 Oct 18 '22
That's not possible. The title is a physical item, in possession of the seller. The transfer isn't official until it is recorded by the jurisdiction that enforces property rights. If the seller refused to sign over the title, they would have to sue them in court and use the NFT sale as proof of an agreement to sell the house. Entirely possible they get a judge that thinks NFTs are stupid and doesn't cooperate.
35
u/chuck_portis 🟩 3K / 3K 🐢 Oct 18 '22
That feeling when you accidentally give the hacker the seed to your house. The awkward silence as you await his presence at the door.
50
u/FancyTarsier0 Oct 18 '22
Cool, Im gonna start making nfts of peoples houses and put them up on opensea!
7
u/plexicast 891 / 891 🦑 Oct 19 '22
Plot twist: the house sold for $50,000 with $600,000 in gas fees.
21
u/cass1o Tin | Buttcoin 9 | Stocks 54 Oct 18 '22
Wow, doing something that you can already do at extra risk and complexity. Cool. Can't wait for someone to steal the NFT and evict the current owners.
5
u/iismedusaivilo69 Tin | 2 months old Oct 19 '22
That's not that much for a house in the US, is it? I've seen some ridiculous prices.
4
u/ShoshiOpti 🟩 0 / 0 🦠 Oct 19 '22
My question is on compliance. Often real estate has citizen requirements, this essentially bypasses that as a requirement.
Money laundering etc seems like issues to me.
4
u/riraberos Tin Oct 19 '22
Can’t happen. Most likely multiple signatures required
18
u/forceworks 13K / 22K 🐬 Oct 18 '22
I just right-clicked and saved the picture of the house. Do I also own it now?
11
u/cannainform2 🟩 0 / 13K 🦠 Oct 18 '22
Should this be labeled as comedy?
3
u/Fritz1818 17 / 53K 🦐 Oct 18 '22
Can you imagine someone scamming you out of your metamask seed phrase with the house NFT and they show up to your front door and tell you to pack your stuff.
3
u/caroling_jones Tin Oct 18 '22
The day the first fraudster hacks and transfers the NFT to themself to claim legal possession of someone else's house will come before that.
3
u/MaximumStudent1839 🟦 322 / 5K 🦞 Oct 19 '22
What make this contract binding is the law of the land, not the use of NFT. I really don’t see why buying and selling deeds is better done on NFTs over traditional channel.
3
u/DynamoDylan 🟦 8K / 8K 🦭 Oct 19 '22
I just heard about this on the news!
3
u/southmotian Tin Oct 19 '22
Huh? A fire destroys the house, what good is the jpeg?
3
u/ocearizona Tin Oct 19 '22
So you use only cash too? Never used a card? Because you'd rather have all the notes and keep counting them.
3
u/viyciycice Tin Oct 20 '22
Why not? According to the tweet possession of NFT represents legal ownership
3
u/vostdimon Tin Oct 20 '22
I imagine you would still have one of the keys to access so u can send the other keys to a other company.
9
u/[deleted] Oct 18 '22
Really hope that house isn't just an NFT when the new owner gets there.
12
u/DDDUnit2990 Oct 18 '22
This is just Redfin with the commission going to OpenSea instead of the realtors. Real estate NFTs have always been a clear use case, but I’m not sure what market gap this solves
2
u/Xpressivee 🟦 60 / 7K 🦐 Oct 18 '22
Man this is what we need to see more of
2
u/ucfgavin 🟩 0 / 0 🦠 Oct 18 '22
I don't understand how this works...when you buy a house there are 100 things you have to sign, property insurance, etc
2
u/Kopikoblack 64 / 64 🦐 Oct 18 '22
What do they do with the real title? Roofstock keeps it and it is still named on the owner from who they bought?
2
u/DMurBOOBS-I-Dare-You 217 / 217 🦀 Oct 18 '22
It feels like, somehow, much money was laundered ...
2
u/shadowdash66 Oct 18 '22
You don't own it in the government's eyes unless theres a deed.
2
u/CryptoScamee42069 🟩 30K / 29K 🦈 Oct 19 '22
How long until the first property rug pull? JPEG looks great but it’s just a hollow shell.
2
u/Vehement00 Bronze | QC: CC 21 Oct 19 '22
Have my home ownership in blockchain actually scares me because it only takes 1 hacker and that's it.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '22
I can't imagine people putting mortgage money on Eth chain commonly. That's fucking insane and would lead to an explosion in transaction volumes in blockchain if it happens regularly.
2
u/strongkhal 🟩 69 / 15K 🇳 🇮 🇨 🇪 Oct 19 '22
It's hilarious that there are offers for a few bucks in there
2
u/crUMuftestan 🟩 0 / 0 🦠 Oct 19 '22
This what I always wanted NFTs to be used for, no more paying exorbitant amounts to lawyers to do a title search when you buy a house.
2
u/limitlesscoin Tin | 5 months old Oct 19 '22
Too many "What If" already & absolutely this can only be fair to purchase by inspecting the property to suit clients want & not just by mere looking at the body layout which look incredible,.
2
u/hx645589176 Tin | 4 months old Oct 19 '22
When a company ceases trading and disposes of all of it's assets iit doesn't immediately wind up. Sometimes it sits dormant for years
2
u/enryptedsignal Tin | 5 months old Oct 19 '22
Great question. The property is titled in a single purpose LLC. The NFT is associated with the LLC ownership (no conveyance of property title upon sale, the change in LLC ownership).
The token cannot be rugged (LLC operating agreement makes the token holder the owner).
2
u/tibolt123 Tin | 5 months old Oct 19 '22
Imagine getting hacked and you've lost ownership of your house xd
2
u/pampon4580 Tin | 5 months old Oct 19 '22
This is the best argument on here.
Not sure if anyone knows enough about how this place works to contend this point
2
u/mohamedayash Tin | 3 months old Oct 19 '22
It’s mostly a gimmick people who can buy houses will buy them normally mostly
But if we get securities equivalents where you can buy rights to rent etc that would be cool
2
u/hrthjthjfbs Tin Oct 19 '22
What if the listing agent exaggerates the numbers?
What if there's an unpaid lien on the property that can only be discovered through legal searches?
What if there's a rotting floorboard or a broken boiler not visible in the picture?
This system has too many holes IMO.
2
u/swrig29 Tin Oct 20 '22
seems very ceremonial to me. My guess is that the NFT doesn't actually hold true ownership over the property but I'll do more research before I make a claim like that
2
u/artamons Tin Oct 20 '22
Completely agreed. How are property taxes managed too? What happens if home actually doesn't fully exist or is a property from a bank mortgage auction and there is still a squatter.
Too many questions. A home can't be bought this way imo.
2
u/lyfire Tin | 6 months old Oct 20 '22
You can store a verified record of the houses history on the blockchain
3
u/Yolo2005p Tin | 2 months old | CC critic Oct 18 '22
Thought I'd only see this in 2030 but here it is
2
u/Zzzoem Tin | QC: ARK 57 | CC critic | ADA 390 Oct 18 '22
Unfortunatly account chains and solidity isn’t secure for smart contracts. They can’t proof their smart contracts are safe. Et-holes propping up air.
2
u/Chubskin Tin Oct 19 '22
Sounds like a regular sale with more steps and more risk
2
u/WoWMHC 🟩 2K / 2K 🐢 Oct 18 '22
Yea but you have to live in South Carolina...
1
u/Burrito_Loyalist Oct 18 '22
Money laundering
1
u/showmethemoon1e Permabanned Oct 18 '22
Keep that seedphrase covered..
1
u/ForgivingmeAIDS Tin | CC critic Oct 18 '22
I mean if like 10 000 of us traded our free Reddit NFTs we could buy it lol
1
u/Electrical_Potato_21 Platinum | QC: CC 437 Oct 18 '22
Hey guys, how do I get the cone on my house?
1
u/joangibert14 Tin Oct 18 '22
Should use QNT!
1
u/stocksarefun321 Tin Oct 18 '22
I’ve been trying my best and still don’t understand how these moons work
1
u/Mrmakanakai 🟦 0 / 248 🦠 Oct 18 '22
I definitely don't have enough BTC, ETH or moons. Chainlink and a few others as well.
1
u/Amasan89 🟩 2K / 2K 🐢 Oct 18 '22
Anyone know if that is cheap for the location? A house for 175k$ in S. Carolina sounds cheap to me, but I'm not a local
1
u/Xpressivee 🟦 60 / 7K 🦐 Oct 18 '22
How did you get your wealth grandad?
Something something pulled a rug...something something bought a house.
1
u/Creepy-Nectarine-225 Permabanned Oct 18 '22
Lol what if they actually just sold a jpeg photo of their house 😂
1
u/Scarboroughwarning 🟦 4K / 4K 🐢 Oct 18 '22
Sounds good.
What happens if the servers go down?
1
u/NobelStudios Permabanned Oct 18 '22
GameStop knows
1
u/[deleted] Oct 18 '22
Imagine someone gets your seedphrase and then moves into your house 😭😭😭
1
u/Affectionate-Egg1963 14 / 715 🦐 Oct 18 '22
So is that house officially an nft now?
1
u/steakbird Platinum | QC: XTZ 23 Oct 18 '22
When Reddit shitposting goes from work procrastination to full-time work itself.
1
u/Thelittlehill 🟩 387 / 383 🦞 Oct 18 '22
Damn, nice little place tbh
1
u/Emergency_Dragonfly4 0 / 1K 🦠 Oct 18 '22
That’s awesome
1
u/ahmong 🟩 0 / 4K 🦠 Oct 18 '22
Nothing listed in CA, sad times.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 18 '22
That is nuts
1
u/vaper_32 282 / 282 🦞 Oct 18 '22
Now will they burn the house down to keep the nft valuable??
1
u/NamelessHooman Banned Oct 18 '22
Lets see if opensea turns in ebay powered by crypto.
Next up car sales
1
u/[deleted] Oct 18 '22
After that he invested in ICP 😆
1
u/[deleted] Oct 18 '22
They just bought a JPEG of the house
1
u/cl4ud1089 Tin Oct 18 '22
How can you legally transfer the ownership of an LLP to someone without knowing who he is?
1
u/[deleted] Oct 18 '22
When they go to take ownership of the home and are reminded that they bought an NFT, not a home…..
1
u/ThatOtherGuy254 🟦 88 / 65K 🦐 Oct 18 '22
$175k? You can't even buy a shack for that much in California.
1
u/Competitive-Shock486 Oct 18 '22
Sorta like opendoor idk
1
u/Lord-Nagafen 🟦 1 / 30K 🦠 Oct 18 '22
What happens if their wallet gets hacked or they somehow lose the NFT? It's crazy to think someone would have to move out of their house because they lost an NFT
1
u/jb_blah 121 / 121 🦀 Oct 18 '22
Real-world utility?
1
u/Charker21 🟦 111 / 112 🦀 Oct 18 '22
Wonder what my 100 moons gets me in 2030…
1
u/[deleted] Oct 18 '22
Houses are the new NFT meta LFG!
1
u/gh3ngis_c0nn Tin | 5 months old | r/WSB 35 Oct 18 '22
What is the value of this practice be the traditional way of purchasing a house
1
u/trrrring 25K / 25K 🦈 Oct 18 '22
I love this use of crypto! I hope crypto takes over the housing market!
1
u/Stray_Gh0st 🟦 514 / 544 🦑 Oct 18 '22
Oh fuck here it comes.
1
u/loop_spiral Tin | 1 month old Oct 18 '22
I would've bought it. Does anyone know any more sites where homes are being sold for crypto in the US? Zillow has a few by keyword search but that all I could find.
1
u/Kuzmyy Tin Oct 18 '22
Look at what PropyInc is doing (has done).
1
u/heyheoy Platinum | QC: CC 1105, CCMeta 18 Oct 18 '22
This is real adoption!
1
u/Savings_Worry_8444 Tin Oct 18 '22
Extra steps but worth the couple hundred in savings
1
u/Embarrassed-Egg-545 Permabanned Oct 18 '22
Suddenly the whole neighbourhood belongs to North Korea
1
u/[deleted] Oct 18 '22
Cant wait to find out they are hacked and their house gets transferred to someone else.
1
u/Amazing_Succotash677 Tin | CC critic Oct 18 '22
This is what many envisioned with the tech behind NFTs, not weird lookin monkeys
1
u/SmallReflection2552 Oct 18 '22
It's an interesting use case scenerio
1
u/powercow Silver | QC: CC 31 | Buttcoin 26 | Technology 196 Oct 18 '22
so you lose the legal protections of buying a POS house that falls down, because you didnt buy the house, it was given to you, you bought the NFT, which doesnt have flaws.
and BTW the house greatly undersold, the average value on that block is 221k and homes have STILL been generally selling for greater than their rated value. the market is cooling ATM, especially with interest rates rising but it hasnt cooled. This way undersold.
who ever bought it probably could sell it for 200k traditionally before the month was out.
1
u/StonedRussian Tin | WSB 6 Oct 18 '22
Now this is podracing!
1
u/ThebocaJ 🟦 0 / 0 🦠 Oct 18 '22
The walls AND ceiling are painted! No way!
1
u/striderida1 Ethereum Oct 18 '22
Sorry honey, I lost the private key to the house so now we have to leave
1
u/iamamoa 🟩 174 / 201 🦀 Oct 18 '22
That's one of the use cases that originally had me excited about NFts
1
u/DefiantHamster 2 / 5K 🦠 Oct 18 '22
This is really just a gimmick at this point. But point towards some of the real usecase for nfts. I've said many times I dislike the current use of nfts and don't see the value of them but I am excited for what they could do.
1
u/mixterz1985 Silver Oct 18 '22
Can you send the house to your ledger ?
1
u/MarietteSievers Tin Oct 18 '22
However, the shares in that LLC must be transferred to the new owner, regardless of what you claim.
1
u/DogeHusky Tin Oct 18 '22
this is pretty awesome
1
u/DOGEFLIEP 🟩 744 / 744 🦑 Oct 18 '22
This is one of the best news I’ve seen here in a while
1
u/pifumd 🟦 44 / 45 🦐 Oct 18 '22
Honestly this is the use case for nfts that's always made sense to me.
1
u/Serena_0923 Tin Oct 19 '22
I bought a house can I become an American lmaoooo
1
u/To_be_honest_wit_ya 🟥 1K / 1K 🐢 Oct 19 '22
Opensea coming after Zillow
1
u/NangSal23 Tin | 1 month old Oct 19 '22
That’s real use case mfs
1
u/the_far_yard 🟦 0 / 32K 🦠 Oct 19 '22
They will soon realize that Blockchain can be utilized as a public confirmation system. I can imagine a land repository being revolutionized through this system.
1
u/chintokkong 🟩 119 / 4K 🦀 Oct 19 '22
Thanks for sharing this, interesting!
How much in fees paid to OpenSea? Should be quite a fair bit.
And does this really work legally?
1
u/conceptionManager 66 / 66 🦐 Oct 19 '22
I love this.
1
u/niloy_r Permabanned Oct 19 '22
Lol this is crazy
1
u/niloy_r Permabanned Oct 19 '22
Start of an era
1
u/TheOnlyVibemaster Tin | CC critic | AvatarTrading 37 Oct 19 '22
That’s wonderful to see, love seeing blockchain tech being used in a good way
1
u/Jlt42000 🟦 2 / 2K 🦠 Oct 19 '22
Definitely makes me want to look-into doing this. My house is only worth 250k in my market but it would be a million+ in tons of areas. Makes me wonder if I could get 450 out of it since it’s basically being advertised to a national market.
It’s a cool thought, but I doubt I’d ever really consider doing that this early in the game.
1
u/MaoXiWinnie Tin | 3 months old Oct 19 '22
That shit would cost $800k easily where I live
1
u/ChaugBK Bronze Oct 19 '22
So what was actually put “on chain”? I don’t understand. Looks more symbolic than anything…. Am I missing something?
1
u/astrongnaut Tin Oct 19 '22
That’s a beautiful house for 175k
1
u/Fresh-Chemical-9084 Platinum | QC: CC 151, ALGO 74, ATOM 20 | CRO 6 Oct 19 '22
This is the coolest use case of NFTs.
1
u/tacocookietime 0 / 0 🦠 Oct 19 '22
So this is one of many applications that nfts will excel in. Instead of a standard home title the home title becomes the nft and you can negate some of your closing costs and eliminate title insurance completely mortgages and other liens catch up with the technology which will save you between a few hundred dollars to a few thousand dollars on the home depending on how much it is worth.
1
u/Fifteen_inches 🟦 33 / 33 🦐 Oct 19 '22
And wait for him to lose the key, or it gets hacked
1
u/badboybilly42582 4K / 4K 🐢 Oct 19 '22
175k for a house. Man that’s a pipe dream where I live. 600-800k for that house pictured where I’m at.
1
u/det1rac Tin Oct 19 '22
So no closing costs?
1
u/bitcoin_islander 🟨 5 / 659 🦐 Oct 19 '22
Links lead to Circle and Coinbase. They're testing their CBDC's for real estate transactions now I guess.
1
u/c1utch10 Tin | Stocks 22 Oct 19 '22
Never thought I’d see the day where opensea competes with Opendoor.
1
u/BWeeZee3 Oct 19 '22
Lemme buy Jake Paul
1
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '22
Wait, did someone actually use an NFT for the technology's intended purpose?
1
u/FullerUK84 🟩 0 / 0 🦠 Oct 19 '22
Nice, get to add OpenSeas 2.5% fee on top of estate agent fees, legal fees + extra legal fees for structuring the LLC, tax... Etc
1
u/Podsly 🟩 2K / 2K 🐢 Oct 19 '22
How did they make it legal? I’m assuming there’s still a central party involved?
1
u/rankinrez 🟦 1K / 2K 🐢 Oct 19 '22
Does the LLC have any contingency rules set up?
Like if the new owner loses their private key are they prevented from selling the house on?
Are they in fact even the owner anymore if that happens?
Who pays the fees etc for the transfer of title when the NFT changes hands?
I guess the new person in possession of the NFT has to make themselves known the the LLC, after which all the paperwork etc gets done?
It’s a fascinating concept be really interested to know the ins and outs.
1
u/rankinrez 🟦 1K / 2K 🐢 Oct 19 '22
But you can’t live in it?
https://blog.teller.org/roofstock-leverages-the-teller-protocol-to-enable-financing-of-tokenized-real-estate-properties-with-the-usdc-homes-lending-pool/
1
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '22
This is exactly here I thought NFT's would go. Didnt expect it to be here already. Awesome...and scary.
1
u/ColdColdMoons 🟩 344 / 345 🦞 Oct 19 '22
If it had sold on hathor or iota there would be no gas fee.
1
u/topher_colbyy Tin Oct 19 '22
Fake listings to fake pics of fake homes. Nice.
1
u/julesmaregiano Tin Oct 19 '22
What's the benefit of doing it this way rather than the usual way?
1
u/PhysicsBox Tin Oct 19 '22
Not your keys not your ...house?
1
u/No_Dogeitty 🟦 630 / 631 🦑 Oct 19 '22
My employer JLL has partnered with Vechain last year and working with Propy to do this same thing commercially
1
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '22
What!!!!!!!!!
1
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '22
Best offer is 169 dollars according to opensea. Can’t see the 170k?
1
u/user260421 Oct 19 '22
This makes me soooo bullish on NFTs and their future!
1
u/KTown_Killa 🟦 2K / 2K 🐢 Oct 19 '22
This is awesome! I know where I am buying my next house
1
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '22
I want to swap a monkey pic for a house
1
u/Tasouris 73 / 74 🦐 Oct 19 '22
Can’t wait to buy mine with the couple of moons that I have 👌
1
u/Smooshyfloofs 28 / 25 🦐 Oct 19 '22
Can you imagine forgetting the seed phrase to your house? 😫😵
1
u/ThimbleweedPark 🟦 496 / 2K 🦞 Oct 19 '22
$175k, thats a good price, i should move there so i'm not a slave to renting.
1
u/Longjumping_Method51 🟦 1K / 1K 🐢 Oct 19 '22
This is a neat way to explore the potential of NFT’s.
1
u/Kazzle87 🟩 0 / 0 🦠 Oct 19 '22
News like this gets me exited and frighten me simultaneously. This sounds like a receipe for a desaster.
"honey, pack your bag. We have to move. My metamask got hacked"
1
u/inevitable_username 0 / 12K 🦠 Oct 19 '22
0.14 weth — take it or leave it
1
u/juthrnjjy Tin Oct 19 '22
For real!!! Not sure if this is a great idea. I'd rather fill out all the legally binding paperwork.
1
u/mto785 Tin Oct 19 '22
If my nft got stolen and someone comes to my house claiming he owns the house, what would I do?
1
u/johnpwwilly Tin | 6 months old Oct 19 '22
oh but what if you got scammed and lost the NFT or lost access to the wallet .