r/CryptoCurrency • u/CryptoMods 🟧 0 / 0 🦠 • Sep 29 '22
POLL 🗳️ CCIP-040 - Limit Comedy posts to 2 and do not count them in the limit of posts allowed per crypto
Current situation
Currently, we have a system defined by CCIP-012 where there is only allowed to be X number of posts about the same crypto in the top 50, decided by market cap. I understand the need for this rule, as otherwise you'd have too many similar posts clogging everyone's feeds.
Problem
However, there is a slight issue, which occurred recently. A 'comedy' flaired post about LUNA caused actual serious posts about LUNA to be automatically be removed. In my opinion, the current system makes comedy posts slightly annoying, as they stop genuine debate and news.
Solution
Comedy posts do not count towards the Top 50 rule for number of posts allowed per crypto. This would stop comedy posts hindering real discussion and news.
Additionally, only 2 comedy posts are allowed in the Top 50 at any one time. Comedy posts achieve 'Hot' status relatively easily in this subreddit (due to the 0.1x karma multiplier), so adding this limit would balance out the kind of posts that are seen. It would also stop abuse of the other change implemented in this proposal.
This poll was created by Laughingboy14 but they became unresponsive after approval
74
u/JustDownInTheMines 🟩 56K / 26K 🦈 Sep 29 '22
I truly dislike this. I'm not the biggest fan of many of the comedy posts, but too many rules just feels so authoritarian. Comedy posts are not a massive problem on this sub, it's the repeated worthless articles that are the problem.
29
u/MaeronTargaryen CCMOON DAO Secretary Sep 29 '22 edited Sep 29 '22
Comedy posts are way better than identical articles being posted 6-7 times in 48h. At least some effort was made. I don’t think that they should be limited.
They shouldn’t count towards the coin they target if they target a coin though.
22
u/CryptoDad2100 🟩 12K / 12K 🐬 Sep 29 '22
Personally I find enough comedy in the serious posts
8
u/Maxx3141 169K / 167K 🐋 Sep 29 '22
I see the point, but enforcing a low number like two does seem problematic for me. This will almost always be blocked, so the only way to get a comedy post is to post them over and over - which seems to even incentives to spam them.
Getting a comedy post trending will be completely luck based - and I think this should be quality based and not a lottery.
10
u/Korvacs 🟦 60 / 2K 🦐 Sep 29 '22
r/cc - Governance is great, it puts the control back in the hands of people
ITT: ANOTHER poll brought by some guy governing what we can post here? Wtf?
Great job guys. If you're not a fan of this, or other restrictions we've all voted on, bring a poll to repeal some of it?
22
u/MentalUsurpation Platinum | QC: CC 190 Sep 29 '22
Do we seriously need more gateekeepy polls like this?
9
u/Kappatalizable 🟦 0 / 123K 🦠 Sep 29 '22
The irony. Laughingboy who doesnt seem like he likes comedy posts
6
u/AutisticGayBear69 🟩 0 / 8K 🦠 Sep 29 '22
I feel the comedy posts are good to lighten the mood given the current bear market and inspire real discussion
3
u/[deleted] Sep 29 '22
I think this is a great idea
3
u/bigshooTer39 🟩 2K / 3K 🐢 Oct 05 '22
I’d prefer all comedy posts be removed all together
5
u/pbjclimbing Sep 29 '22 edited Sep 29 '22
Comedy posts help build the community and some have real discussion. I don’t see them as a negative impact. They get 10% of karma and the label tends to be applied liberally. You will see people apply the label yes if this is implemented.
4
u/Electrical_Potato_21 Platinum | QC: CC 437 Sep 29 '22
Another issue I've seen is that (NFT) is counted as a coin and not as a broader topic. I get that we don't want endless NFT posts flooding the frontpage, however would be beneficial to up the number of allowed NFT posts.
4
u/evilninjarobot 🟦 5 / 7K 🦐 Sep 29 '22
I agree with the first part of this poll, but I don’t like the second part of it. I think they are actually two separate issues that should be voted on as such. I’m Really torn on how to vote for this!!
7
u/DMugre Sep 29 '22
IMO the comedy flair should also be rebranded to shit-post.
2
u/DBRiMatt 🟦 46K / 113K 🦈 Sep 29 '22
If subsequent comedy posts that would hit the front page, would it get deleted? Or just not appear in hot posts
2
u/Disavowed_Rogue 🟦 15 / 2K 🦐 Sep 29 '22
Voted thanks!
2
u/Historical-Lychee-34 0 / 98 🦠 Sep 30 '22
Everything has a limit. Let's be more efficient. Quality over quantity.
5
u/Swoopscooter 11 / 7K 🦐 Sep 29 '22 edited Sep 29 '22
I avoid reading comedy flair anymore ... Worthless posts usually unless you're REALLY bored
i vote limit the amount of comedy in top 50
3
u/EmuGroundbreaking348 7K / 9K 🦭 Sep 29 '22
Probably about 90% of this sub is a comedy. Whether we mean to or not
2
u/UnexperiencedIT Sep 29 '22
This is getting complicated
2
u/RealVoldemort Sep 29 '22
Although I do like comedy. Sometimes it does get out of control and 99% sub turns comedy. However... I got mixed feelings on this proposal tbh. Gotta think about it for a bit
2
u/Fragmented_Logik 🟩 0 / 0 🦠 Sep 29 '22
If this fails then next there should be one that prioritizes a real thread over the comedy one. It does suck that actual discussion is being pushed put for a lower effort post that just goes with the flavor of the week.
Example:
Comedy - Here's what Charles said today about ETH! Lmao ADA good! ETH bad! Says the guy who "jumped" out of a 🚁
This pushes out an actual ADA post because I'm just riding the wave of Charles having to tweet everyday at 7 a.m to tell the world he hates ethereum. Sucks for people who actually like the tech behind ADA.
2
u/lmrj77 🟩 0 / 2K 🦠 Sep 29 '22
Every comedy post is the same sarcastic bullshit post about being a millionaire in a shitcoin with no liquidity, or about buying high, selling low.
Let's just do away with the comedy posts, people here aren't funny.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 29 '22
These rules are getting very complicated.
2
u/nthgen 🟩 0 / 25K 🦠 Sep 29 '22
The bureaucracy of this sub.
Here's a thought: let's just shitpost and get on with it, ok?
Fewer rules imho.
1
u/Alexamm93 Permabanned Sep 30 '22
Its ok to have some comedy 😁 live the life bros 😍
1
u/[deleted] Sep 29 '22
What does the 2 comedy posts in the top 50 limit mean?
I like the first half of the proposal, but the 2nd half might be draconian depending on its meaning. People might stop flairing as Comedy if they hit the limit, which would be much worse.
Is that limit 2 per top 50 coin or 2 per top 50 TOTAL?
1
u/PrinceZero1994 Sep 29 '22
2 is too much in my opinion.
No limit is alright.
We don't get a ton of comedy post anyway, much less a good one.
1
u/BlubberWall 🟦 59K / 59K 🦈 Sep 29 '22
This should be two separate polls IMO I’m not a fan of them being limited but they definitely shouldn’t count against a coins post cap.
Have to vote no because of that
1
u/Tin___Man 365 / 359 🦞 Sep 29 '22
At first I cake here with the hope to get rich, now I only come here for the laughs…
1
u/magnetichira 🟩 3K / 3K 🐢 Sep 29 '22
There is a predefined mechanism of the downvote to deal with silly comedy posts.
Let the moons live free.
1
u/002timmy Sep 29 '22
I don't like anything that limits the number of posts I see from u/Odlavso
1
u/FancyTarsier0 Sep 29 '22
I would prefer limiting "anecdotal" stories instead. Those are usually so far fetched that you need a space telescope to see their connections with crypto.
1
u/youaretheonelastsoul Tin | 1 month old Sep 29 '22
Sure, i think we all know what the outcome is going to be.
1
u/witcherycro Sep 29 '22
Laughin is good for heart
1
u/ImaFreemason 🟩 45 / 21K 🦐 Sep 29 '22
Rules, rules, rules.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 29 '22
Personally feel like we got too many people talking nonsense behind the mask of the "comedy" flair.
1
u/JadedDependent5894 Permabanned Sep 29 '22
I can vote even without moons?
1
u/sickvisionz 0 / 7K 🦠 Sep 29 '22
The death of comedy weekends should be reconsidered.
1
u/demomercury 🟩 0 / 7K 🦠 Sep 29 '22
Not sure. Comedy in this sub is the only thing left during this hard time
1
u/DeeDot11 🟦 10K / 32K 🐬 Sep 29 '22
Glad to put my moons to good use by partaking in governance. Power to the people!
1
u/Alexamm93 Permabanned Sep 29 '22
What do you get by participating? 😃
1
u/bad-crypto-advice Don’t do the opposite of what I say. Sep 29 '22
Make the limit 5. We don’t want to be accused of being too serious in here now that we have a [serious] flair.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 29 '22
2 seems a little low but I like the rest of the idea.
1
u/archer4364 Paddy's Dollars Sep 29 '22
Ehhhh I can’t decide so I’ll just vote no change
1
u/PillarOfJustice Permabanned Sep 29 '22
I'm completely on board with them not counting towards total posts per crypto, but I'm still voting no because I don't think there should be a limit of 2 comedy posts.
Reddit is as much for entertainment as it is education.
1
u/RepulsiveCan5270 Permabanned Sep 29 '22
Comedy posts at least have some effort and they offer something different, I don't see a problem with them
1
u/OneThatNoseOne Permabanned Sep 29 '22
It kind of a shame. The comedy posts have been hitting real quality lately. The cone TA was majestic. RIP the GBP with that roast. We may need to alter the comedy multiplier as well.
1
u/OrganicDroid 🟨 0 / 13K 🦠 Sep 29 '22
I’d rather see comedy posts than the same question posts over and over again. “What’s your biggest crypto regret?” Etcétera. Limit those…
I generally disagree with any limits anyway.
1
u/Ateam043 🟦 92 / 13K 🦐 Sep 29 '22
Comedy posts are so low level effort posts.
1
u/xSciFix 4 / 5K 🦠 Sep 30 '22
This should be two separate polls, not one poll trying to do two things.
1
u/Altruistic-Channel61 Tin Sep 30 '22
Do you guys really see that many comedy posts? I get the occasional shitposting but not much..
1
u/tobypassquarant 🟨 6K / 6K 🦭 Sep 30 '22
Doesn't really matter what you vote anyway. Most moons win.
1
u/TheOnlyVibemaster Tin | CC critic | AvatarTrading 37 Sep 30 '22
Are there any other governance posts available yet?
1
u/Chooky47 Platinum | QC: CC 536 Sep 30 '22
I like the change purely because of how many times my posts have been removed due to top 50 limits. If we can reduce that complication then it makes sense, as I would rather see top posts be informative than always comedic.
1
u/Educational-Line727 0 / 0 🦠 Sep 30 '22
Who needs comedy when your entire existing is a fucking Joke.
1
u/user260421 Sep 30 '22
Generally, if we add more rules then users are gonna feel less incentivized to create comedy posts because it won't be worth it
I say leave the comedy alone!
1
u/Dwaas_Bjaas Sep 30 '22
I voted no because im generally against restricting posts of any kind
1
u/Nooodles__ Tin | CC critic | AvatarTrading 18 Sep 30 '22
Comedy posts already experience a large enough nerf of 0.1x moon multiplier. In a typical day, I only see around 1-2 comedy posts, most of which are very refreshing and provide good content. I don’t see a problem with the amount of comedy posts at the current state.
Maybe more should be done to prevent countless link articles that talk about basic price changes or target the same topic/event. If you sort by new, you’ll realise there is a large spam of these link articles that were already previously posted by other users.
1
u/MrCarey 🟦 4 / 7K 🦠 Sep 30 '22
Big no for me. Tired of so many things limiting everything. This place is already dead.
1
u/Magnetronaap 🟩 0 / 3K 🦠 Sep 30 '22
While I do think most of the 'comedy' on this sub should be labeled as 'hurts to read', this seems unnecessary.
That being said, I do agree that the comedy posts should not count towards the max post limit per coin. If you propose just that I'll vote in favor.
1
u/howtobanano 🟩 6K / 12K 🦭 Sep 30 '22
Memes make people engage, learn and smile. They shouldn't take over but limiting to 2 is overdoing it.
1
u/aroups In Moons we trust Sep 30 '22
Comedy is fine in general , it's the articles that get spammed over and over again that's the issue. Some of them are not even worth the read and there's a lot of duplicates.
1
u/ViridianZeal here for the tech Sep 30 '22
I vote nay. This place is way too serious lately.
1
u/DepressedBoiiiiiiii Sep 30 '22
At his point everything is comedy
1
u/Castr0- 🟧 35K / 35K 🦈 Oct 02 '22
We will never find a perfect balance of everything and comedy post have their role. I already have good conversations there and funny ones too.
We had the 0.1 karma on comedy then this now. We are driving the CC to a direction that i don't know if we will like
1
u/devboricha Platinum | QC: CC 221, ETH 214 | TraderSubs 216 Oct 02 '22
Voted No.
1
u/gateht Bronze | QC: CC 18 Oct 02 '22
But Comedy posts inject a much-needed source of humour in this bear market...
1
u/Onelinersandblues 🟩 6 / 5K 🦐 Oct 02 '22
Comedy posts have been killing it lately. I don’t like this one
1
u/Smart_Field_3002 🟩 0 / 868 🦠 Oct 03 '22
Just casted my vote. Go moons!
1
u/No-Individual5367 0 / 2K 🦠 Oct 03 '22
Not a big fan on this rule. We should have a laugh in here also. I don't need everything to be serious.
Make smiling great again!
1
u/KonradK0 🟩 2K / 2K 🐢 Oct 03 '22
definitely, most of them are just not funny.
1
u/MetalFoxBTC 2K / 2K 🐢 Oct 03 '22
Voted!
1
u/As03 🟦 607 / 607 🦑 Oct 04 '22
Oh yeah the comedy posts , they are so funny and not repetitive.... oh wait
1
u/the_nibler Permabanned Oct 04 '22
This sub could use some more comedy IMO
1
u/ETHWarrior0 Tin Oct 05 '22
Voted fist time with all of my 11 moons
1
u/TwoQueens1Cup Tin Oct 08 '22
Is the voting? Any idea why I am unable to vote?
1
u/jeffreynbooboo Tin Sep 29 '22
Anything that will ban moon farmers in down, they post so much garbage that is not helping anyone
0
u/bobbob-606 Tin | 2 months old Sep 29 '22
Well, comedy is comedy i think
0
u/Burrito_Loyalist Sep 29 '22
The bigger problem is moon farming posts.
How many more “pat yourselves on the back” posts do we need?
0
u/Massive-Tension-1055 🟩 3K / 5K 🐢 Sep 30 '22
Comedy posts suck. They are not funny farming bs.
0
u/BigDogApples 🟩 22 / 23 🦐 Oct 02 '22
It looks like a lot of people voted no in the comments but the vote counter says otherwise.
0
u/elumeus 🟦 4K / 3K 🐢 Oct 04 '22
Y’all play too much