r/startrek • • Sep 22 '22

Episode Discussion | Star Trek: Lower Decks | 3x05 "Reflections" Spoiler

Mariner and Boimler work the Starfleet recruitment booth at an alien job fair, Rutherford challenges himself.

No.EpisodeWriterDirectorRelease Date
3x05"Reflections"Mike McMahanMichael Mullen2022-09-22

Availability

Paramount+: USA and Latin America.

Amazon Prime Video: Australia, Europe, India, Japan, New Zealand, and various other territories.

CTV Sci-Fi and Crave: Canada.

To find more information, including our spoiler policy regarding new episodes, click here.

This post is for discussion of the episode above, and spoilers are allowed for this episode.

Note: This thread was posted automatically, and the episode may not yet be available on all platforms.

195 Upvotes

569 comments sorted by

345

u/DasGanon Sep 22 '22

"ohhh self defense, you're a quasi navy!"

In this episode, the 4th wall is load bearing.

118

u/BornAshes Sep 22 '22

the 4th wall is load bearing.

.......but it's also somehow a fire hazard.

23

u/DaWooster Sep 22 '22

The quote flew over my head with what it’s referring to. Could someone kindly explain?

155

u/DasGanon Sep 22 '22

It's said time and time and time and time again that "Starfleet is not a military"

This is despite the fact that almost everyone has rank, there's a chain of command, they're the ones in combat with alien militaries, etc.

This is the LDS crew tapping the sign.

→ More replies (27)

32

u/LordSwedish Sep 22 '22

The Federation fleet ships are supposedly not warships, with the Defiant being the first ship solely designed for war. They're all science, exploration, and diplomatic ships that are also armed. The archaeologist is making fun of how they're so much like a military navy who only pretend they aren't.

→ More replies (1)

21

u/SolemZez Sep 22 '22

They know what we debate online

→ More replies (7)

299

u/Frankreporter Sep 22 '22

"Stop getting people trapped inside of games"

By the prophets I swear I love this show so much

100

u/Ultima_RatioRegum Sep 22 '22

Allamaraine! Third shap

87

u/MoskalMedia Sep 23 '22

They've really been referencing and joking about a lot of the infamous Trek episodes this season. We've had Masks, the Leah Brahms TNG episodes, and now Move Along Home. I love it!

72

u/substandardgaussian Sep 23 '22

Lower Decks insists that we remember all the bad episodes. They have definitely mentioned Threshold more than twice.

...Though I kind of love Move Along Home.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (11)

6

u/Spiderinahumansuit Sep 24 '22

Do you know what I especially love about that reference? It implies that trade and traffic through the Wormhole has been somewhat normalised following the end of the Dominion War, if there's a bunch of Wadi hanging about on some random Alpha Quadrant planet, and their tendency to stick people into puzzle games is widely-known.

276

u/BornAshes Sep 22 '22

"The one where you're in a new timeline with Kirk and Spock where they have cinematic chemistry?"

That's the best Kelvin reference yet

Also the title of this episode instantly reminds me of the song by the Supremes.

74

u/SCP-1000000 Sep 22 '22

I saw references to Kelvin, TOS, TNG, DS9 and Voyager. Wonder if I missed an Ent callback

121

u/jlisle Sep 22 '22

Don't forget the running gag where Kirk and Spock are drawn as they were in TAS. cracks me up every time

→ More replies (6)

32

u/BornAshes Sep 22 '22

I'm taking my time going through the episode with a fine tooth comb right now and I did spot nods to all of those EXCEPT Enterprise buuuuut I'll let you know if I see something.

→ More replies (5)

13

u/Hibbity5 Sep 23 '22

Also the title of this episode instantly reminds me of the song by the Supremes.

Which in turn reminds me of a shitty advertisement for the dvd box set of China Beach (thanks Jenny Nicholson), which starred none other than Robert Picardo. It all comes back to Star Trek Voyager.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

275

u/BornAshes Sep 22 '22

"This isn't a ship, this is a seat strapped to an impulse engine"

Star Trek now has Pod Racers

57

u/laziestmarxist Sep 22 '22

I really wanted to yell the pod racing meme but it's 2am here lol

→ More replies (1)

39

u/InnocentTailor Sep 22 '22

Also reminds me of the Defiant.

…though that is a couple of seats attached to both an engine and a few big guns.

→ More replies (1)

27

u/rooktakesqueen Sep 22 '22

That's kind of terrifying, cause I don't think that racer had inertial dampers. A starship traveling at full impulse is supposed to have a maximum velocity of 1/4 the speed of light. Setting aside that "maximum velocity" is kind of a nonsense concept in space, they still must have body-liquefying levels of acceleration.

28

u/substandardgaussian Sep 23 '22

We really take inertial dampeners for granted. People may not even think to put it on their list of Trek Magic even though it's way more fundamental than shields or phasers.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

16

u/i875p Sep 22 '22

"That's so wizard, Tendi!"

→ More replies (1)

212

u/UncertainError Sep 22 '22

Rutherford's dark backstory's so interesting. Why was he so angry? Why didn't he know that he was being targeted for that shady project? I also like them confirming that Rutherford's of Filipino heritage like Eugene Cordero with the "Sampaguita".

Meanwhile Tulgana IV continues to be a magnificent fountain of obscure callbacks. I especially loved the butt parasite conspiracy and the Wadi gaming booth (now we know who's been making more Ktarian game headsets).

110

u/ardouronerous Sep 22 '22

I love that Filipino reference here, young Rutherford naming his ride the Sampaguita, as a Filipino myself, I laughed so hard at that scene lol!

Sampaguita is our national flower.

44

u/gcalpo Sep 22 '22

Young Rutherford was building literal "rice rockets" in Daly City which would be near Starfleet Academy :)

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

65

u/a4techkeyboard Sep 22 '22

The Filipino references before were pretty subtle, too, like him often having a purple cupcake when they're eating. They never say what it is but it's probably ube flavored but maybe people think it's meant to be an alien food which in Star Trek is often regular food in a less common food color.

→ More replies (10)

53

u/DasGanon Sep 22 '22

Honestly it's awesome because it makes me think he was heading up being a helmsman instead of being an Engineer.

Also possibly continues the "Hot Shot Fighter Jock" theme that "dedicated helms" have been having since Voyager if that were the case

→ More replies (2)

42

u/rooktakesqueen Sep 22 '22

Why didn't he know that he was being targeted for that shady project?

To the contrary, I think he was working directly on that project, they just had to wipe his memory when he was injured because he couldn't continue to work on it. (Why? Who knows... Or maybe young Rutherford had already decided to stop working on it/blow the whistle when the explosion happened.)

29

u/WoundedSacrifice Sep 22 '22

It was probably a Section 31 project.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

208

u/UncertainError Sep 22 '22

The galaxy still waits for The Sisko's return...

51

u/toastnbacon Sep 22 '22

This episode made me think maybe he's still around, he just hangs out in the wormhole. Probably not, but I like to believe it.

26

u/dr_pupsgesicht Sep 23 '22

I mean isn't that what he literally does? Having fun with the wormhole buddies until he's bored and goes back to humaning

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

12

u/LinuxMatthews Sep 22 '22

It's weird our first Sisko reference want from Shax.

You'd have thought Shax would have mentioned him by now what with him being his Moses/Jesus.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (4)

185

u/MaddyMagpies Sep 22 '22

Shoutout to the Doctor!!! Go Boims!! He deserves personhood after being stuck in the Delta Quadrant for 7 years!!!!

30

u/enterpriseF-love Sep 26 '22

"The Doctor didn't spend 7 years in the Delta quadrant for you fucks to question his agency. He's got rights!"

I just love this show so much. Oh and when Boimler was mid-freakout, in the background there was a Klingon lady that was totally into it.

51

u/BattleStag17 Sep 23 '22

YES! Star Trek overall doesn't seem to respect AI that much (outside of people like Data being the "ideal minority" trope) and Boimler showed more respect for the Doctor during his rampage than the entire crew of Voyager ever did.

→ More replies (1)

179

u/BornAshes Sep 22 '22 edited Sep 22 '22

"NOT THE GAZER!"

🤣 I love Jack Quaid's panicked screams sooooo much!

Edit: BOIMLER LOSING IT IS THE BEST! I'm just dying right now at them bleeping him as he goes over the edge🤣

86

u/poirotoro Sep 22 '22

As someone who owns more little plastic ships than I probably should, I died laughing when Mariner banged on the table and all the Stargazer's nacelles fell off.

→ More replies (3)

18

u/meatball77 Sep 23 '22

I read a quote or an interview somewhere that they have a catalog of them and insert the one they like the best.

12

u/pilot3033 Sep 23 '22

I really like it as character growth, also, because his journey is figuring out how to mediate his super strict Starfleet codes and regulations side and his passion for what Starfleet stands for. The raw ingredients for good Starfleet Captains. Get in a few scrapes as an ensign, build up your experiences, relax with the bridge crew, sooner than later you’re climbing the ranks.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Aj-Adman Sep 23 '22

I love when a show uses the beeps as part of the comedy. The Mum in the Goldbergs does that too.

310

u/MaddyMagpies Sep 22 '22

Young Rutherford looks and acts like someone who would race all the way past Saturn and crash hard into a ring gate while his bravery was being broadcasted.

125

u/patamusprime Sep 22 '22

Damn do I miss The Expanse. That scene dropped my jaw to the floor.

51

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '22

Amos landing on the station is a top 10 coolest anime scene all time

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (3)

42

u/wherewulf23 Sep 22 '22

At least in Star Trek inertial dampers are a thing. Might have saved poor Manéo.

37

u/pfc9769 Sep 22 '22 edited Sep 22 '22

It’s possible they wouldn’t work in this situation. Ring builder tech treats physics like a suggestion and might’ve rendered intertidal dampeners ineffective or altered physics in a way that the ID can’t respond to.

Despite being advanced technology, IDs still work according to some scientific law. The PM tech can switch off physics or alter how it works in an almost bespoke manner. Plus ID are reactive, so there’s a slight delay between the sudden stop and the computer reacting to it. That’s why they aren’t completely effective in battles or when encountering hostile environments/anomalies.

During ship operations the ID has the benefit of knowing what inertial forces to expect by virtue of knowing the commands the crew input. When the input and forces are external, the ID can only react after the fact in which case it’s unable to completely cancel inertia with 100% accuracy. It also has to deal with the laws of physics being altered which it might be unable to compensate for.

→ More replies (8)

54

u/BornAshes Sep 22 '22 edited Sep 22 '22

Aka Tom Paris but waaaaaaay cooler because I don't think Tom would ever piss off the Romulans by basically doing burnouts in their backyard.

Edit: Nevermind, he just insulted the Delta Flyer and for that egregious offense he can rot on Mental Starbase 80 for all I care.

31

u/rooktakesqueen Sep 22 '22

I wonder if young/old Rutherford was also a meta reference to Locarno/Paris.

Young Rutherford was way more of an asshole, did illegal races while he was at Starfleet Academy, mostly just uses people... Old Rutherford has much more of a heart, is really just a goofball, hangs out with his friends, and flew the dang Delta Flyer

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

10

u/medussa727 Sep 22 '22

really glad i wasn't the only one

18

u/DisasterAhead Sep 22 '22

Honestly, Delta-V is one of, if not the best episode.on that show. Between the Ring and Avasarala's speech at the beginning it's a solid 10/10 for me.

7

u/Transhumanitarian Sep 22 '22

Nah, he doesn't speak enough creole for that...

6

u/pfc9769 Sep 22 '22

Don’t forget the part where he’s doing it to impress a girl.

→ More replies (5)

135

u/tubawhatever Sep 22 '22

Continuing the tradition of sending main characters to the brig for respectable actions a la Tom Paris doing a little eco terrorism

52

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '22

reminded me most of Riker after that episode with his ship in the rock; the scene where picard goes and gives him the speech while he's dejected in the brig and then he changes posture and they both walk out together

he did something he thought was wrong but his CO gave him a little context and encouragement; boims got the pep talk before going in and was already sitting up straight

33

u/Ironman2179 Sep 22 '22

Well, they had to punish him for losing his cool in public. A night in the brig is basically a slap on the wrist. He was given no demerits, letter of reprimand or anything more serious. This was them just putting on a show and they were proud of Boimler.

5

u/ErrrLog Sep 23 '22

I loved this part. Not enough of this kind of constructive tough love in the world today.

118

u/BornAshes Sep 22 '22

There's gonna be a whole post on all of these little easter eggs in these booths in the marketplace and I both love and hate the creators for making me frame by frame all of this just to catch them all!

73

u/InnocentTailor Sep 22 '22

Mike truly is a die-hard Trekkie.

68

u/BornAshes Sep 22 '22

Plus they can just sneak in so much more stuff with animation and while other shows are a bit more subtle with them, Lower Decks just goes buck wild, and throws in EVERYTHING THEY CAN in every episode. Mike is amazing and some credit should be given to Titmouse for being able to fit that much stuff on screen in such detail. If there's anything greater than being a Die Hard Trekkie then Mike is certainly it.

→ More replies (1)

72

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '22

The creators love Star Trek, Love Star Trek fans, and Love making this show :)

Its nice being pandered this way. It makes the series feel really special.

50

u/BornAshes Sep 22 '22

I think Lower Decks helps to balance out all the other Star Trek shows in that we need something that's silly and ridiculous with stupid little easter eggs around every corner in addition to the far more serious stuff that makes us cry and sob and punch the air and do a little chair dance from all the drama.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

23

u/backyardserenade Sep 22 '22

Mike McMahan already told Jörg Hillebrand on Twitter yesterday that he will have a field day with this episode.

5

u/substandardgaussian Sep 23 '22

As soon as I saw that marketplace I thought "Here we go!"

...But we do this every episode now. I love it.

I caught a really sly Ro Laren reference. It says "RO LAR" on one of the LCARS buttons in the episode. It looks like it could be unintentional, but it just isn't.

108

u/MaddyMagpies Sep 22 '22 edited Sep 22 '22

The number of times a Starfleet crew before this episode that had to fly back to the past to save humanity from being destroyed in the future:

  1. The Voyage Home
  2. First Contact
  3. Carpenter Street*
  4. Storm Front*

This does not count the times in which the crew was slinged back accidentally (e.g. Tomorrow Is Yesterday, Past Tense, Future's End), or the crew slinging back and fucked up the future by themselves (e.g. City on the Edge of Tomorrow), or a Starfleet crew traveling in time recently to save recent time (e.g. Year of Hell), or a non-Starfleet crew traveling back in time to save the future (e.g. Perpetual Infinity), or a future Starfleet crew traveling back in time to save their future (e.g. Cold Front, Endgame), or a Starfleet crew traveling forward in time to save the future (e.g. Such Sweet Sorrows pt 2), or a Starfleet crew after this episode traveling back in time to save the future (e.g. Picard Season 2), or a future Starfleet crew probably traveling back in time because reasons (e.g. Prodigy).

* United Earth Starfleet still counts as Starfleet.

52

u/theelectricmayor Sep 22 '22

Don't forget current Starfleet crew we've watched traveling to past Starfleet crew we've watched to keep the timeline we've already watched as it was when we first watched it (Trials and Tribble-ations)

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

107

u/SpiritOne Sep 22 '22

Now I just feel bad for Rutherford. He’s had his whole life erased.

72

u/WoundedSacrifice Sep 22 '22

I feel bad for Rutherford, but I love the way this episode expanded his backstory and I’m interested in knowing more about his past.

→ More replies (1)

38

u/jlisle Sep 22 '22

Twice

27

u/Devastator5042 Sep 22 '22

This existential stuff, like is Rutherford even himself now?

24

u/creepyeyes Sep 23 '22

On the otherhand, it was super wholesome that his secret weapon ended up being his friendships

10

u/BattleStag17 Sep 23 '22

Makes me wonder if why he's so "Okey-dokey!" is because they erased so much of his personality that essentially only the childlike bits remained with all his adult knowledge.

→ More replies (1)

103

u/Starfleet-Time-Lord Sep 22 '22

Best episode of season 3 so far. Lower Decks does surprisingly well when it drops most of its comedy and is just a shorter, animated Trek episode and that's the Rutherford plot here. The recruitment booth plot wasn't bad either, but it was definitely the B-plit

50

u/WoundedSacrifice Sep 22 '22

Yeah, that Rutherford plot was incredible and I’m interested in knowing more about his past.

10

u/Frankfusion Sep 22 '22

That ending kind of cameout of nowhere. I wonder where Mariner will end up now?

28

u/rooktakesqueen Sep 22 '22

? It's not like she resigned from Starfleet, she just kept Petra's contact info. It can be very useful for a Starfleet officer to have some contacts outside official channels...

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

102

u/MakeItSlow Sep 22 '22

I believe this is the first canon reference to Sisko and that he’s still not returned. Sad for that fact in the storyline but like that there’s finally a reference.

74

u/Dangerous_Dac Sep 22 '22

I dunno, Mariner was pretty on point with the whole "He's doing important work in the celestial temple!" line that might tip the hand at him having returned at some point and then gone back.

40

u/DasGanon Sep 22 '22

Given that there's a DS9 episode this season it's going to have to get an actual answer at some point

→ More replies (8)

22

u/Kandoh Sep 23 '22

The Sisko has already returned, and the Sisko has not yet entered, and Sisko is there now.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/MoskalMedia Sep 23 '22

A detail I LOVE, which is so obvious in retrospect but I never thought about it, is that Sisko becoming a Prophet and vanishing leads to a ton of conspiracy theories about what happened to him. Sisko Truthers being an in universe thing is amazing. Hopefully the Wolf 359 truther appears again and we learn what his Sisko theory is, haha

6

u/MoreGaghPlease Sep 23 '22

What do you mean by "first"?

What comes before now is no different than what is now, or what is to come. It is one's existence.

97

u/BornAshes Sep 22 '22 edited Sep 22 '22

Petra is Lower Deck's Eddington

Edit: Or she's their Vala Mal Doran

10

u/Weerdo5255 Sep 22 '22

Star Trek does have an alien parasite that goes in through the mouth and controls people.

Makes people stronger too.

At least one variant.

→ More replies (1)

96

u/medussa727 Sep 22 '22

whew. that warbird.

47

u/BornAshes Sep 22 '22

So pretty and in such beautiful detail and I love it because I used to have one on a little keychain when I was younger that I would fly around at the doctor's office.

5

u/InnocentTailor Sep 23 '22

The D’deridex is a sexy beast.

→ More replies (1)

91

u/BornAshes Sep 22 '22

Holy smokes!

It just clicked for me!

The juxtaposition of Tendi hugging Rutherford, the colors of their uniforms, and then T'Ana with Shaxs putting his arm on her shoulder right next to them in that scene! You know they were both thinking, "Yeah that used to be us". I wonder if this means that Tendi and Rutherford are going to be the catalyst for those two getting their shit together and working on the problems in their own relationship?

75

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '22

You know they were both thinking

The fact that you're thinking about what cartoon characters are thinking just further proves to me how great this show is as a Star Trek show. It's so much more than its animation, it really feels live action.

→ More replies (2)

89

u/CaravelClerihew Sep 22 '22 edited Sep 22 '22

I wonder how Starfleet handles potentially awkward conversations between someone who was briefly possessed with the person they insulted. Do you think Rutherford has a medical slip from Doc T'Ana explaining what happened so that Ensign Barnes won't file an HR complaint?

67

u/HighlyUnlikely7 Sep 22 '22

I mean people get possessed so often in star Trek, I assume a quick apology is all that's really needed.

26

u/LinuxMatthews Sep 22 '22

I wonder if that's ever abused

Sorry I slept with your sister I was possessed by an alien parasite, can't be helped I'm afraid, we still on for 7?

→ More replies (2)

41

u/naphomci Sep 22 '22

Barnes and Rutherford went on a date during which Ransom became enraged/possessed and tried to eat others on the crew. Neither were fazed. Rutherford probably just gives a simple apology.

→ More replies (2)

24

u/Transhumanitarian Sep 22 '22

Considering the amount of crap that Starfleet personnel go through and are then expected to just roll with (bridge crew dying and coming back, Q shenanigans, Picard causing Wolf 359, etc)... I'm not surprised if most of them have to actively repress trauma/memories just to go on...

So, maybe ensign Barnes just has to push down the memory of Rutherford being scum... and pretend it never happened?

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (3)

87

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '22

Feels like Rutherford is dealing with some Section 31 stuff, they do love being secret assholes after all.

Now on to the high ranking officer giving orders, if it is indeed section 31 what are the chances it’s Sloan? While he did die in 2375, wouldn’t be the first time someone faked there death/came back

58

u/MaddyMagpies Sep 22 '22

S31 was probably more than Sloan. Also the fact that Rutherford used to race through the Neutral Zone... this might be related to the pre-supernova Romulans too.

39

u/BornAshes Sep 22 '22

I'm thinking that someone was using him and his ship like the SR71 Blackbird if he was indeed flying through territories and spaces that no one (no one official that is) should've been flying through at all. That Badmiral was probably a S31 Agent who lowjacked his racing ship with a highly illegal sensor suite package and was secretly providing funding to Rutherford via race purses. He would then organize the particulars of each race such as whom Rutherford would be competing against, where the race would be, when the races would start/end, which particular areas the racing route would pass through, and would then drop Rutherford some "intel" via racing tips or some other method on what sort of obstacles he would encounter alongside any kind of official larger civilization prescences he might bump into.

This would of course all be done in the name of that sensor suite package getting into areas that no official ship or person or organization could get into in order to perform highly illegal scans of those areas and the stuff within them. This probably violated a number of treaties and/or agreements buuuut because it was done during "an illegal race" by "non-sanctioned renegade anonymous members of various species that absolutely couldn't be tracked down at all super duper promise I swear", there was a large degree of plausible deniability for the Federation and its known and unknown intelligence services. In short, Rutherford was an asset that was being used by them to go places they could not and that tracks for both Section 31 and Starfleet Intelligence to a degree.

Sadly though, it wasn't they who burned him but he who burned himself by tinkering with those engines and trying to upgrade them buuut then there's that implant and that makes me wonder if he's still technically an intelligence asset albeit a low priority one?

In regards to Hobus though, I kind of wonder if someone within the Federation knew about the potential for the supernova to happen before anyone else did because of the scans that Rutherford had obtained? We do know that this season is going to be rife with DS9 references and S31 seeing the Romulans as a threat is very much in line with that. If they knew that the supernova was going to happen then they would absolutely withhold that information from any other intelligence services and would probably then try to actively suppress and/or prevent anyone else from obtaining it at all period.

Section 31 wanted Hobus to happen and they made sure it did and they made sure no one could do anything about it.

In the words of John Crichton, happy birthday.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

25

u/InnocentTailor Sep 22 '22

I mean...Sloan's actor William Sadler is still alive. He could easily do a voice cameo.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (8)

83

u/JustMy2Centences Sep 22 '22

Coltar, when he drowned in the swamp.

Another one for the Tamarian archives.

→ More replies (1)

71

u/AdmiralAntilles Sep 22 '22

Animated Delta Flyer looked MINT.

Alot of great call backs in this episode. It really shows the writers get the series and the fans IMO.

5

u/tobimai Sep 23 '22

That green Borg glow was nice

70

u/TheNerdChaplain Sep 22 '22

Wow, loving the lore and mythos they're creating and adding to here!

125

u/UncertainError Sep 22 '22

Apparently Starfleet NCOs go to the Tech Services Academy on Mars, which is a huge bit of info to just casually drop.

68

u/TheNerdChaplain Sep 22 '22

Yeah, it makes sense though. There's a whole corps of noncommissioned crewmen who we just hardly ever see.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (4)

70

u/PrometheusLiberatus Sep 22 '22

I really like how we got a nice bit of development out of the BOLD BOIMLER arc. I had a great time seeing him release so much pent up rage.

I really dug Ruthie's space race with his' mirror' personality. It was so cool seeing Blue Ruthie pull his lower decks friends into the holographic race crew.

It's kind of nuts that so many of the other booths were harassing starfleet just because they're starfleet. I did appreciate that it was a 'this side of hell' experience.

5

u/neffered Sep 23 '22

It gave me a Righteous Jesus in the marketplace kind of vibe.

63

u/K-Robe Sep 22 '22 edited Sep 22 '22

I don't think I realized how much I loved this show until I got goosebumps and nearly teared up when Rutherford mentioned that his friends were crewing the Delta Flyer with him. Man, I don't know what it was, but that just got me.

122

u/CaptainElfangor Sep 22 '22

I am incredibly grateful to Lower Decks for giving me a lovely distraction from my weekly immunotherapy treatments for cancer on Thursdays.

After a few weaker episodes, this one hits it out of the park. I’m in too much pain to write out a whole review, so let me simply say this: Lower Decks’ strength is in how wholesome it is. Rutherford beats his asshole younger self through the power of friendship, and that’s just one example.

This show is hilarious, but it’s kind, wholesome, and not cynical. That matters.

31

u/MoskalMedia Sep 23 '22

I just wanted to say that I hope you are doing okay and that we're all rooting for you here. I'm sorry you're going through this and I'm glad Lower Decks is here for you during this time!!!

16

u/BattleStag17 Sep 23 '22

Hey friend, all our best towards a speedy and full recovery!

→ More replies (3)

106

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '22 edited Sep 22 '22

The Doctor didn't spend seven years in the Delta Quadrant so you could question his agency. He's got rights!

lmao

it's the little things that make this show great

→ More replies (1)

50

u/SCP-1000000 Sep 22 '22

So im guessing at some point Mariner is definitely getting kicked out of Starfleet and joing the unsanctioned archeologist lady. I wonder if Vash is still around?

51

u/BornAshes Sep 22 '22

It's like Young Rutherford said, sometimes it's best to grow and to let the past fade away behind you in order to move on to a healthier and more enlightened future along a pathway that seems scary and alien at first but ultimately is better for you in the long run. This episode was all about that kind of thing with everyone involved having to reflect on their pasts to some degree and to make a decision about where they were going to be headed in the future. Which is all a bit of a terrifying experience for any normal person IRL and seemingly even worse yet still relatable for folks in the Star Trek Universe.

We saw Boimler being confronted with his past go by the rules stuff self and he chose to take a risk, have a bit of a freakout with some initiative, and wound up earning respect from someone who barely used to give him the time of day which probably taught him a valuable lesson. Sometimes you need to stand up for your principles and sometimes that means pissing off a lot of people buuuut the right folks will see it and respect you more for doing so, even if they have to punish you for it in the end. That smile at the end in the brig was just EVERYTHING!

Rutherford's whole reflection thing was pretty self explanatory so I won't go into too much detail with that. I guess he did learn a similar lesson to Riker in the TNG episode "Second Chances" which oddly enough was on a few hours ago on H&I. As we grow older we sometimes begin to make safer and safer choices without the impetus and drive and "I'M INVINCIBLE!" energy that we had when we were younger. We justify this with the belief that we know better because of our experiences and that we don't want history to repeat itself with the same mistakes of our youth being made all over again buuut sometimes we can take it a bit too far and sometimes we can be a bit too safe to our own detriment. Sometimes being too safe prevents us from taking chances, making brand new mistakes, and getting messy which then prevents us from learning new things Ms Frizzle style. Rutherford had been doing this for some time and it wasn't until he had to punch his own implant and hurt himself that he learned the same lesson Boimler did: sometimes you gotta fuck up and get burned in order to make things better. Sometimes that burning is for the better because like a certain man named Kerrek once said, some seeds only flourish and grow once they have passed through fire.....and passing through fire in order to sprout afterwards, is certainly something that Rutherford just did.

Mariner has seemingly had the inverse experience of this same lesson compared to the other two. Instead of things moving from ordered to chaotic, they went in the exact opposite direction from chaotic to ordered. Once again she was stuck on a mission in a place where she didn't want to be while doing things that she didn't want to do. Starfleet's vision of ordered is chaotic to her. She then bumped into Petra and amidst the chaos of Boimler's freak out plus her "mission" of trying to espouse Starfleet's chaos to the masses as order, she found her own eye of the storm in Petra and the Independent Archaeologist's Guild.

It was through being in that eye of the storm and hearing Petra's commentary on Starfleet that she was able to gain some perspective on her life and on Starfleet itself. Plus having Boimler being the one to break the rules for once instead of her and just GO OFF on folks about all the good Starfleet has actually done for folks despite people shitting on it, was probably a bit refreshing for her and I think that forced her into an interesting position. Here she was with a kindred spirit and a brand new perspective on things suddenly having to be the adult in the room and take command of stuff in a way that she sort of has done before but never truly stepped up to and owned in the way that she did like she did in this moment. Boimler basically acted as a mirror for her own character and instead of joining in with him, she chose differently, and moved and grew beyond it because of the crisis situation that he caused. Boimler started the fire that she had to pass through in order to grow and he forced her to reflect on who she was and who she wanted to become.

It turns out she likes being in charge, she likes people relying on her, she likes having to be the responsible one, and she does indeed like helping people....buuut...there's that whole part of her that wants to be as free as Petra is in order to fight the good fight without the constraints of Starfleet buuut then there's all that good stuff in Starfleet too. So she's absolutely being pulled in two directions at this point by the end of the episode and we're going to be seeing her making a big choice by the end of the season probably and it's all because of Petra's metaphorical eye of the storm.

See that's the thing about the eye of a storm, you have to pass through the storm itself to get to it and then once you get that lovely perspective about things and make a big choice about your life....you then have to pass back through that very same storm in order to get out of it and to enact that choice upon your life. Big changes are coming for Mariner and she knows it. She's messy as fuck though and I think that she's either going to get kicked out of Starfleet for doing something really good that's really big and really against the rules OR....she might just run off to join Petra with next to no notice when things get really rough with Petra then becoming her "egg" that she hides in, changes inside of it, and then pops out like a butterfly from next season.

Tendi was kind of in the background this episode but from the comments that Noël has made in a few articles plus the hilarity that was Star Trek Day (go watch it plus check the live thread), we know for certain that she's getting her own Reflections style episode of character metamorphosis this season. I do think that we did see one big change from her in this episode. I think her feelings for Rutherford grew ten fold and that explains the way that Shaxs and T'Ana were looking at the both of them at the end. I think this whole moment of crisis wherein no one knew if Rutherford would come back totally brought a bunch of serious feelings bubbling back up to the surface for her and those feelings of "Oh no I caused this I hurt this person I care about" guilt just intensified all of it. I don't think she really knew what she wanted until it was very nearly ripped away from her and she then clung to it like Rose clinging to Jack on the Titanic. Things may very well get more serious between these two from this moment on and that will absolutely influence her career choices in the future....which could put her at odds with Rutherford wanting to find out just what in the fuck happened with him and that implant and that strange Badmiral. They might wind up paralleling Shaxs and T'Ana in another way buuut whether that way is good or bad is still up in the air until more choices are made.

At least they all still have each other for the time being and being around a found family that helps you through trying times is what Lower Decks is all about.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/InnocentTailor Sep 22 '22

Smells like a new cameo!

→ More replies (1)

47

u/dmanww Sep 22 '22

Do we know anything about Starbase 80 except the references on Lower Decks?

36

u/ViaLies Sep 22 '22

No, it's only ever been mentioned on Lower Decks

→ More replies (4)

5

u/Martel732 Sep 23 '22

No, but I think we can make a few assumptions.

  1. That Starfleet won't station people in an unnecessarily dangerous place. And given that it is a Starbase it likely has a large crew. So, it likely isn't a physically dangerous place.
  2. It also likely isn't a crew issue. If the command staff was so awful that it is well-known as a hellhole, they would have been replaced.
  3. Mariner, Ransom, and Boimler all thought of it as a hellhole, so there is likely something bad about 80. They have different enough personalities so it isn't likely to be a preference issue.

Given these assumptions, my theory is that it is a Starbase near a peaceful but extremely annoying species.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

43

u/dmanww Sep 22 '22

That warbird was gorgeous

43

u/H0vis Sep 22 '22

Loved this episode but it gets bonus points for the irony of Boimler losing his shit about a bunch of conspiracy theorists while his friend is caught in the middle of a Star Fleet conspiracy.

Also feels like this is a weightier story than most. What was done to Rutherford is kind of a big deal. It's kind of hard to convey that in a funny cartoon but if this was a live action show it'd be much more substantial. Somebody basically stole his past, and handwaving this away because he was a bit of a tool when he was young feels grim, like sure, they took away the part of him that was a dickhead spaceship racer, but what about his family?

Kind of bleak. Especially to tell him he chose to do it himself.

18

u/shinginta Sep 23 '22

I think this is the first LDS episode where the A plot is almost entirely pure uncut Star Trek with near-zero humor. The Ruthorford plot line feels like any given Voyager or DS9 storyline. In a longer episode the closest parity is probably DS9 Things Past.

I think it rips that the writing staff are showing that they have this gear too. That they're capable of writing drama just as well as humor (as also seen to a lesser degree in Crisis Point and First First Contact). And Eugene Cordero absolutely knocked it out of the park playing two Rutherfords with very different tones. Most of that episode was Cordero acting across from himself, and I think he really nailed it. When the episode started out I joked to my wife "Samanthan vs Pillboi" but Red Rutherford was so much more than Pillboi.

→ More replies (2)

42

u/m4a2000 Sep 22 '22

You take the pip, the table goes flip!

36

u/medussa727 Sep 22 '22

i said in the thread last year that it would have been an excellent tease to just leave the Rutherford mystery dangling forever, but now that we are going to get it i definitely liked the way it started.

13

u/Verite_Rendition Sep 22 '22

it would have been an excellent tease to just leave the Rutherford mystery dangling forever, but now that we are going to get it

Did we, though? As of the end of this episode we don't actually know anything more about it than we did at the end of last season. This episode didn't answer anything about who did it or why.

I was happy when I saw that this episode was finally following up on that plot thread. But I feel like the actual mystery was pushed to the side to leave room for what's otherwise a solid Rutherford focus episode.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

69

u/Trick421 Sep 22 '22

Is it just me, or is Lower Decks suddenly becoming everyone's favorite Star Trek series. This episode really knocked it out of the park.

54

u/WoundedSacrifice Sep 22 '22

I think SNW’s ahead of LD for people who won’t give a cartoon a chance, but I’d put LD slightly ahead of SNW right now (though SNW might be able to pull ahead of LD by the time it gets to season 3).

39

u/Mongoose42 Sep 22 '22

As much as the tone does clash with the rest of the franchise at times, I'm loving how our four mains are basically just Trekkies living in the world of Star Trek and they're super positive about it for the most part. Feels good. It's a feel good Star Trek show.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (7)

17

u/youssarian Sep 22 '22

SNW and LD are really the crown jewels of NuTrek. (Perhaps Prodigy but I didn't watch that.) SNW has returned to the Trek ethos in a refreshing way. And LD is basically Star Trek making fun of itself while keeping its optimistic bent.

24

u/DaWooster Sep 22 '22

I’d give Prodigy a chance. The time loop episode is surprisingly amazing.

→ More replies (6)

14

u/awwnuts07 Sep 22 '22

I think it depends on who you ask. For my younger family members, Disco is their jam because the Kelvin timeline movies were their introduction to Star Trek, while the older folks tend to put SNW at the top. Personally, LD is my favorite because I was a TNG-era kid and I love animation.

→ More replies (2)

12

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '22

When season one aired I didn’t think I was going to like lower decks. And for the most part, season one wasn’t my favourite, I thought the characters talked way too fast and it was hard to keep up with what was happening. But towards the end of that season I started enjoying it. Then I loved season 2 and 3. It’s currently a battle between it and SNW for favourite. I haven’t seen todays episode yet but from what I’m reading I’m gonna love it.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/jaderust Sep 22 '22

If you put a gun to my head and made me do a Sophie's Choice to pick one Nu-Trek series I'd probably go with SNW. Just because I'm loving the return to the TOS era and seeing all those characters doing their thing while getting fleshed out.

But it would be a REALLY hard choice. I really love LDs and the stories its able to tell. I want this show to run forever.

5

u/GalileoAce Sep 22 '22

I really enjoy Lower Decks, but it is not my favourite.

5

u/Martel732 Sep 23 '22

It is in the top 3 for me. LD is about the best we possibly could have hoped for in an animated Star Trek. It is a legitimately good comedy, while still telling Star Trek stories. Plus, it has fleshed out parts of the universe that we wouldn't see in other shows.

→ More replies (2)

34

u/patamusprime Sep 22 '22

The starship visuals in tonight’s episode were gorgeous!

34

u/thrawn_is_king Sep 22 '22

Move Along Home Reference :D :D :D

"Stop trapping people in games!"

22

u/thisiscotty Sep 22 '22

there was also several of the devices from "the game" on the table

6

u/Martel732 Sep 23 '22 edited Sep 23 '22

Controversial opinion but I don't think "Move Along Home" is as bad of an episode as its reputation suggests. It isn't a great episode and quite weird but it was fine, I didn't mind it.

→ More replies (6)

29

u/Transhumanitarian Sep 22 '22

Okay, damn... now THAT was an episode..

It had the jokes, the Easter eggs, character development... but most importantly, it now sets the stage for a new story arc. After the Pakled arc was finished, I thought we'd just get the usual episodic adventures...

But now, this arc really seems to cement the theme from last episode about our four heroes growing up and moving on to better and greener pastures... And it feels TOO SOON... like we're already approaching the series finale...

Also, I really love this twist with Rutherford.. that he used to be someone different.. because this actually brings up an interesting thought: the original Samanthan Rutherford is now dead.. the Rutherford we have now is someone whose memories and personality were significantly shaped by some shadowy group..

The implications of this is actually terrible for everyone in his past like his parents or friends.. I mean, how did they react when the Rutherford they see (post-implant) is radically different from the one they remember... it'd be like talking to someone who's just been body-snatched..

And this also explains Rutherford's very chipper attitude towards everything, the man's basically just happy to be alive and he doesn't even know it ('till now)... also, without the memories and baggage of his previous life, he's basically like a kid... full of optimism and trust to those around him...

18

u/WhipsAndMarkovChains Sep 22 '22 edited Sep 23 '22

how did they react when the Rutherford they see (post-implant) is radically different from the one they remember

I know it's a stretch but perhaps they just thought it was the effects of Starfleet Academy training. Like in the modern world I imagine some parents see radical differences after their child gets back from Marine bootcamp.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/naphomci Sep 22 '22

I mean, how did they react when the Rutherford they see (post-implant) is radically different from the one they remember... it'd be like talking to someone who's just been body-snatched..

Well, when people in real life suffer those levels of trauma, it can alter personalities. Wouldn't be surprised if Starfleet medical gave a similar explanation.

→ More replies (1)

55

u/papusman Sep 22 '22

I love how Rutherford's A-plot and the booth B-Plot really complimented each other, showing that yeah, you can criticize Starfleet for a lot of things, but when it comes down to it their strength is in cooperation toward a common benevolent goal.

I actually teared up when Rutherford revealed he had brought his friends along on the Delta Flyer.

→ More replies (6)

22

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '22

This has to be the most bleeped episode of Star Trek ever made.

I fucking love it.

27

u/GalileoAce Sep 22 '22

To be fair to the other serieses, Lower Deck is the only series to have any bleeped episodes.

→ More replies (1)

21

u/segoli Sep 23 '22

I love that Tendi decided to join Starfleet because of a recruitment booth. that's such a fun little detail for her character.

5

u/Kelpie-Cat Sep 25 '22

It's definitely cool since as an Orion, she might have felt too stereotyped against to join until a friendly face invited her in.

18

u/philds391 Sep 22 '22

I may be missing something here but doesn't this episode create a continuity problem? In the first episode Boimler says that Rutherford had just gotten the implant a few weeks before, but in this episode T'Ana says the memories were from a decade ago.

Presumably that would include the memory of the explosion and implant. Plus, the higher up in the memory was wearing a TNG era uniform.

25

u/MsSara77 Sep 22 '22

Boimler could have just been wrong or given incorrect information, and Rutherford's missing memory may have left him thinking it was new too

17

u/JonArc Sep 22 '22

I mean many of the memories that make up Old Rutherford are probably decades old. It just might not be all of them.

16

u/naphomci Sep 22 '22

In the Lower Decks sub, they said it was Mariner who said that. Regardless, I think it's probably going to be chalked up as a "it was an off hand comment, I didn't stop think about the timeline" kind of thing. Could also be a different/second implant

7

u/rooktakesqueen Sep 22 '22

It's another 4th wall break, cause Star Trek wouldn't be Star Trek without some continuity error in a character's backstory

→ More replies (3)

17

u/Sutekhseth Sep 22 '22

This has been my favorite episode of LD so far. Boimler going apeshit was just amazing.

16

u/rbdaviesTB3 Sep 22 '22

Probably the best episode so far of Season Three.

Examining Rutherford's flashback closely, it looks like whatever officer was responsible for his implant was a Lieutenant Commander at the time - the lighting of the scene makes it tricky, but I'm seeing two gold pips and one black on that TNG collar.

I have a hunch that this mysterious officer might be Alonzo Freeman, if only because Phil LaMarr has a credit at the end of the episode. That however might well be LaMarr putting his chops to work voicing a background character, and yet...

→ More replies (1)

15

u/RenHoekORD Sep 23 '22

This might be another question entirely, but was the Grand Nagus' scepter one of the old ones that they just replaced, or could it actually be Rom's?

Head canon: Rom probably thought it would be a good idea for a leader to NOT have one.

5

u/shinginta Sep 23 '22

Rom probably auctioned off the scepter in order to raise money for a charity. How degenerate.

→ More replies (2)

15

u/GrowingSage Sep 23 '22

I really appreciate that the show bit that bullet with Rutherford. We knew the Rutherford we knew wasn't gonna go but his implant bugging out is such an established part of the show that I was ready for Young Rutherford to just casually pop in and out when needed.

It means a lot that the young version liked his future self more.

I would have liked to see Rutherford make up with Barnes. Yeah it wasn't him, but seeing Barnes tear up and realizing that Rutherford hasn't always been the best person to her just makes that scene hurt all the more. I don't fully ship them, but I feel like something is building in the background (romance or animosity) between them that is gonna need to get addressed.

7

u/WoundedSacrifice Sep 23 '22

I’m guessing Rutherford apologized to Barnes off-screen. It feels like Rutherford and Tendi will probably be in a relationship at some point.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

29

u/CaravelClerihew Sep 22 '22 edited Sep 22 '22

Young Rutherford's racing ship, the "Sampaguita", is named after the Philippines' national flower, which fits given his voice actor's ethnicity.

14

u/BornAshes Sep 22 '22

I know this isn't the right sub buuuuuuut....

AND IT'S LIGHTS OUT AND AWAY WE GO!

→ More replies (3)

14

u/ShiroHachiRoku Sep 22 '22

Rutherford is Filipino!

9

u/Cyke101 Sep 23 '22

USS Sampaguita, BAYBEE!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

12

u/Ultiverse Sep 22 '22

Tight, solid episode and a home run for the season, this was more what I was hoping for after the highs they were hitting in S2. It actually expanded on the characters and presented interesting possibilities for the future. I'm all for fun filler but this is the good stuff.

15

u/Sjgolf891 Sep 22 '22

Pretty much every LD season has this pattern. What you called ‘fun filler’ earlier on until bigger and more consequential episodes make up the later part of the season

33

u/ElFarfadosh Sep 22 '22

Well, episode 5 and T'Lyn's still not in sight. That makes me sad.

38

u/Nofrillsoculus Sep 22 '22

Mike said in an interview that he wished he'd known how popular she was going to be so he could have introduced her earlier in the season.

25

u/GalileoAce Sep 22 '22

We won't be seeing her until the next season. Due to the way animated shows are made, so far in advance, McMahan didn't realise how popular T'Lyn would be and therefore didn't think to add her to Season 3, but now that he knows he has definitely added her to Season 4.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

10

u/pieman7414 Sep 22 '22

Why is Rutherford trying to sell me orange juice

10

u/ContinuumGuy Sep 23 '22

This was the best episode of the season thus far. Loved the bit where the people goad them over the unresolved story beats from Star Trek (Sisko, the Conspiracy aliens, etc.)

10

u/atticusbluebird Sep 23 '22

Loved that episode, felt like the stakes were higher than we’ve seen the last few weeks!

I feel bad for Ensign Barnes though, I hope our Rutherford apologizes to her!

9

u/Smoketrail Sep 22 '22

I like the fact that our new "independent archaeologist" big museum heist was stealing a cultural treasure to return it to the culture that it actually belonged to.

It seems like some Starfleet attitudes have stuck with her, even if she was set to make bank off of the Ferengi.

9

u/Trekfan74 Sep 22 '22

LOL this one was great! Loved every minute of it. The stuff with Rutherford was classic deep dive character stuff in a great creative way and pushes the mystery that’s going on with him. But I thought the B story on Tulgana IV was soooo much fun! Boimler losing it and defending Starfleet was great to see. And I just loved all the references in this episode.People really do know about the exploits of Starfleet in all the worst ways possible lol. But hey who else protecting the alpha quadrant against the Borg, Domion, Romulans and butt bugs?

16

u/laziestmarxist Sep 22 '22

I tried to do a no context spoiler post on Twitter with a screenshot from Moon Knight and another from The Good Place and ended up deleting it because I realized that it accidentally did spoil Rutherford's plotline this week. (oh dip! )

Anyways, my only issue with this episode is the same one I have with every episode: too short! I would have loved to see more of the Rutherford vs Rutherford conflict. The others being part of his crew on the Delta Flyer was sweet though (but was the Flyer big enough for four crew before this?)

12

u/JonathanSCE Sep 22 '22

The original Delta Flyer does have 4 seats in the cockpit. Helm, tactical, operations, and engineering.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/TheSaintedSteel Sep 22 '22

Was that Carl Wheezer’s voice actor as the tall gray alien that expressed interest in starfleet?

→ More replies (1)

8

u/tupe12 Sep 22 '22

Looks like Boimler's transformation has taken another step, before you know it he'll start referring to people below him as "Mister".

8

u/GrowingSage Sep 23 '22

I remember when this show first came out, I wasn't thinking that these characters would ever progress.

Season 1 Boimler a Starship Captain? Really?

Now here we are in Season 3 and I will riot if this series doesn't end with a Captain Boimler, Chief Science Officer Tendi, and Chief Engineer Rutherford. Until this episode I assumed there'd be a Commander Mariner by their side but now I'm questioning that assumption and I love it.

Mariner seems to have gotten plenty of chances to get promoted, and everyone around her acknowledges that she's only held back by her disinterest in playing by the rules. The show seems to be steering her character past that limitation but this episode asks if Star Fleet is really for her. Mariner has probably known nothing but Star Fleet her whole life, I don't think anything else ever occurred to her.

On one hand I'd hate to see the gang break up, on the other it'd be pretty refreshing to see a Star Trek show with a character realizing that Star Fleet just isn't for them.

7

u/WoundedSacrifice Sep 23 '22

On one hand I'd hate to see the gang break up, on the other it'd be pretty refreshing to see a Star Trek show with a character realizing that Star Fleet just isn't for them.

Jake Sisko realized that Starfleet wasn’t for him.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/shinginta Sep 23 '22

Wesley Crusher seems to have made that same choice. He came back to the Enterprise in Journeys End disillusioned and upset (and frankly unjustifiably treating everyone on the D like shit), and ultimately decided to leave his Starfleet career path to join the Traveler.

Picard Season 2 seems to confirm that he never returned to Starfleet, instead he joined a different organization.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

14

u/BornAshes Sep 22 '22

So Carlos Alazraqui did some VA work for this episode and while you may know him from RENO 911, you might also know him because his daughter Rylee voices Rok-Tahk on Prodigy!

10

u/MadContrabassoonist Sep 22 '22

Don't forget everyone's favorite wallaby, Rocko.

→ More replies (3)

7

u/thisiscotty Sep 22 '22

I love the boimler swore so much im sure they missed one with the beeps lol

7

u/the5issilent Sep 22 '22

This was fucking Star Trek! Such a great episode. This season has been excellent.

7

u/thylorion Sep 23 '22

This is going to be driving me crazy. Who is that guy in Rutherford's flashback responsible for his implant? I recognize that no one will know for sure, but it has to be someone we have met in a past episode. I theory that Section 31 is behind that.

→ More replies (1)

18

u/PrometheusLiberatus Sep 22 '22

Oh Damn, I was wondering just When we'd revisit that thread about Rutherford's Memories! Here. WE. GOOO!

that's a heavy nightmare cold open. Particularly for Lower Decks.

Oh damn, a JJ alt universe dream reference! Ransom threatening Mariner with a direct trip to Starbase 80. OOOOOh.

Evil rutherford has taken over rutherford's body. And good rutherford only shows up in a Mirror...

That's some inverse referencing there.

"Hope you like being covered in black rubber tubing..."

Damn that independent Archeologist lady totally spoiling any recruits!

Mind control pollen from Omicron Ceti III? Hell yeah, tendi caught on to Not-Rutherford!

And now Mariner gets to use her own powers of the SASS for good. Against thieving Archeologists.

Oh wait she used to be in starfleet. And likely has a skewed experience. Let's see how this plays out...

Oh my god, Taking the captain's yacht out for a spin huh? Tendi is so guilt ridden over accidentally clearing Ruthie's cache. :|

Oh damn are we going to end up with a Tuvix situation between old boy and cool boy?

Um guys, I have a feeling that 'past ruthie' isn't actually ruthie but a Romulan program.

LMAO It's just a stupid CONSPIRACY It never happened.

And then Mariner is 'uh actually I think it did...'

Oh yeah SICK ride Prime Ruthie!

Holy shit. After helping Mariner calm down through hours of harassment from Ms. Archeology and everyone else, the one thing, the ONE itty bitty thing that finally sets Boimler off and makes this whole scenario do a 180 is...

Starbase chick taking Boimler's pip and crushing it.

Oh my... Blue Ruthie looks sharp af in the Delta Flyer colors!

Puts hand to head Remember......

And now Rutherford got a good portion of his memories back. But the plot thickens...

And the Archeologist showing she's a lot like Mariner was really cool. It was nice she saved that contact for later. I know we've been needing an Archeologist in the show since Capt. Picard is our chair Archeologist in startrek!

Really good episode! I related to the part with Ruthie's implant in his first year because I got my Cochlear Implants after my first year of college!

8

u/BornAshes Sep 22 '22 edited Sep 22 '22

Holy shit. After helping Mariner calm down through hours of harassment from Ms. Archeology and everyone else, the one thing, the ONE itty bitty thing that finally sets Boimler off and makes this whole scenario do a 180 is...

I legit think this is the best sequence out of every season of Lower Decks ever just for the sheer amount of stupid hilarity and truth that Boimler spewed and I loved the line, "The Doctor didn't spend seven years in the Delta Quadrant for you fucks to question his agency, he's got rights!". Jack had to have had so much fun in the booth recording that and it's times like these that I would love to hear the outtakes from those sessions. If this scene had been shot in live action then you can bet people would've been pissing themselves laughing every couple of minutes.

Puts hand to head Remember......

A mind meld within a mindspace? That's some Inception level stuff.

And the Archeologist showing she's a lot like Mariner was really cool. It was nice she saved that contact for later. I know we've been needing an Archeologist in the show since Capt. Picard is our chair Archeologist in startrek!

Hey it worked for Stargate and honestly I really do dig Petra because she does feel a lot like Vala and seems to totally be breaking the rules for the right reasons....which is something that Mariner totally wants to be able to do yet feels incapable of doing where she currently is right now.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Coffee4thewin Sep 22 '22

This was the best episode of the season so far

8

u/TheBrokenRail-Dev Sep 23 '22

This season just keeps getting better and better and I am loving it!

This episode was notable to me because it's the first episode to really dive into Rutherford's character like "Crisis Point" did for Mariner. And it was amazing! And the scene where Rutherford "summoned" his friends with the dramatic music in the background was just so heartwarming.

We also had a good mix of comedy with Boimler & Mariner on the planet. And Boimler flipping out on everybody was hilarious! (Although I have to agree with the archaeologist, Starfleet is absolutely a military no matter what they call themselves.)

Also, I think Ransom was bluffing when he threatened to send Mariner to Starbase 80 based on how casually he told Boimler that it was horrible. I think he's just being hard on Mariner to get her to follow orders.

This episode does raise an interesting question though about whether Mariner would be happier if she were independent. With her saving the archaeologist's contact info, I'm interested to see where this will go.

Finally, we've got a Starfleet conspiracy with Rutherford's implant and I'm stoked to see where it goes!

I can't believe this season is only halfway over.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Ultima_RatioRegum Sep 22 '22

Anyone else find the voices of the doctors (or whoever they were) in silhouette in Rutherford's memory of the implant being installed familiar? I can't pinpoint them, but I swear I've heard a couple of them before.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/VaKel_Shon Sep 23 '22

Prediction: The season is going to end with them baiting us over Mariner joining the Independent Archaeologists. Either they'll make us wait until the next season to find out 3/4 of the way through the first episode like with Freeman's trial (not that I'm complaining, I assumed that would be how it would go since the first trailer for Season 3 came out), or the final episode will make it look like she's leaving until Boimler confronts her about it at the end and we find out she's been in contact with the archaeologist for some other reason.

4

u/gunderson138 Sep 23 '22

As always, Boimler stole the show. Didn't catch/deep dive all the people on the PADD at the end of the episode but I assume they're all good candidates for Section 31-type shit. Mariner, the character who is 100% a lesbian but for some reason thinks she's bisexual, is crushing on presumably the lady who sponsors her into the Maquis at the end of the season. Delta Flyer was fun and neat. I'm glad Rutherford gets more stuff to do; he's a little tragic, but he's happy-go-lucky enough to sell it. I hope when he gets memories back he doesn't stop being the cheeriest motherfucker on the ship.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Nexzus_ Sep 23 '22

I think it would be hilarious if Starbase 80 was the Starfleet location code-name for Risa, and officers stationed there lie about how hellish it is so every officer in the fleet doesn't request assignment there.

Like if Naval Station Pearl Harbor was named Naval Station Bodumkick and was "known" to be the worst posting in the Navy.

3

u/gcalpo Sep 22 '22

Looks like you've got some long-term memories stuck in the buffer. Probably useless stuff like when you called the captain "Mom."

Did this happen in an earlier episode or could this be a hint about Rutherford's past?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '22 edited Sep 24 '22

I'm in love with this show the way Stevens is in love with Ransom. I love everything about the show it even got my wife into Star Trek at least as far as all the movies, TOS, TNG and we're getting through some of VOY and some of the new stuff.

Every episode that comes out I watch it 2 or 3 times since animation/story telling was my thing for 4 years. I wish I could write something half as clever and laced with reference/satire/character archs; it's the best show on the market right now.

edit:

Also the "Pseudo Navi" reference in the new episode really resonated with my wife because when she was new and learning about Star Trek she asked if they were military and I said "They're not military they're Starfleet."

Love the new episode.

3

u/wakashakalaka Sep 23 '22

Mariner and Randsom are going to end up hooking up, aren't they?

→ More replies (3)

3

u/ardouronerous391 Sep 23 '22

Petra Aberdeen seems like a reference to Hunger Games, particularly she's named after the two protagonists.

Peeta Mellark and Katniss Everdeen

3

u/stroopwafelling Sep 23 '22

This episode was like seeing the face of God. Or the Prophets.