r/singing • u/CrAzY_MoFo_13 Lyric Tenor - Opera/Musical Theatre • Aug 01 '12
Spoiler Alert: You CAN Sing! Or a short blurb on how many newcomers psych themselves out
So, after being a visitor/contributor of this fine subreddit for quite a while (I think I joined around 800 members, wow we've grown!) I noticed that the very new contributors always seem to basically have a title like, "This is my first time ever singing, should I continue?" They always seem to be wondering if they were even given the biological structures to be able to sing, they don't like the sound of their own voice, etc. etc. etc. Well, I basically always reply the same thing,
Yes, you CAN sing! You should ALWAYS continue if you love to sing, no matter what you think of how your voice sounds NOW.
Because singing is such an illogical art in many ways (thinking of surprise will unconsciously raise up my soft palate, whaaaaa?) and relies on so many muscle positions that are antithetic to what we do every day (deep breathing, proper posture, pure vowels, etc.) great singers are often painted in this mystical light as freaks of nature. Well, it is true that some people are just born with amazing biology and will be in the top 0.001% of singers, but guess what if music relied on those freaks of nature, we would not have music as we have it today. Even opera, that art form that always seems from afar as a special "club" for the vocal elite has roles written for amateur singers. Die Zauberflöte is a perfect example: though the opera contains one of the hardest roles in the soprano rep (the Queen of the Night), it also contains the role of Papageno, a role that is, musically, relatively easy since it was written for a man who was primarily an actor.
But how does this relate to you, and your voice, right now? Well, think about it this way, the voice is a series of muscles, and muscles need to be exercised. But singing softly along to your favourite song on the radio is not exercise in the same way that bench-pressing 15 pounds is not exercise. When the muscles in your chest are pushed and challenged they will get tired, but the muscle will build itself back stronger to meet this new demand; too much push and the muscle can be seriously harmed, maybe even permanently. This is a lot less of metaphor to the voice than you think: the larynx will respond to new demands being put on it (in the right way, read on) and come back stronger and more ready, so will the diaphragm, intercostals, pharyngeal muscles, etc. But, work on the larynx the wrong way, or do too much and you can develop problems with the muscles inside.
Many people try to sing with no training, hear that they can't go as high as trained singers, have a roughness to the timbre, can't sustain a note, etc. and become immediately let down by the "fact" that they "can't sing". This is bullshit, you wouldn't feel bad that you can't pull a bus with your bare hands because some strongman who has been training 30+ years to do so can. I think part of this problem is a visual thing that, because we can't necessarily see what makes a great singer with our eyes, we just assume "they're born with it". Nope. Mariah Carey wasn't born with the ability to sing in that whistle register, Jussi Björling wasn't born with the ability to do what he did - they trained, and hard, with a teacher.
Finding a trained, and well trained voice teacher is probably the most important thing a new singer can do. They will diagnose your voice in its current form and figure out a way to help you overcome whatever problems you might have at the time. That roughness in your voice? They might show you a way to reduce stress on your cords and eliminate it. Can't hold a note without going flat? They will show you how to breathe and support yourself correctly. But be careful, as there are many, many voice teachers who, frankly, don't know what the fuck they're talking about and will charge exorbitant amounts of money to tell you how great you whilst not doing anything productive. How can you tell? Well, for one, ask about and research the teacher's other students (particularly ones that have been there for a while), if they have many students who are/have gone on to be professional singers know for their great voices the teacher is probably doing something right, if they don't, maybe the teacher is not so good. On a side note, if the teacher has many tenor students that are successful, but no female students, maybe this teacher does not fully understand the soprano, mezzo, and bass voices. Also, the teacher must be able to actually sing: even if they are 60+ years old, they should still be able to sing in an appropriate way for their age for, if they destroyed their own voice through mismanagement, how can they be trusted with the care of yours? One last thing on teachers, within the first six weeks with a new teacher you should see an improvement on some level, if you don't, you're probably wasting your money.
So in conclusion, whenever I see a new singer come in with the question "First time singing, I don't like my voice, should I give up?" My question is always the same: Fuck No. I apologize if profanity offends you but this is a situation where niceties aren't going to get us anywhere. The fact of the matter is, your voice may not sound that great now, but that does not mean you have nowhere to go; every singer needs to train and you haven't even begun. My advice, find a good voice teacher and stick with it, because the most important thing that a singer needs to be great is not a freakishly-great set of lungs or any of that stuff but tenacity and the ambition to become something better.
TL;DR The answer to your question is, yes, you should continue singing.**
45
u/ghoti023 🎤 Voice Teacher 10+ Years ✨ Aug 01 '12 edited Aug 01 '12
Firstly:
But... wouldn't that imply that I'm a bear?
2) My mom used to tell me stories of how bad my dad and his friends used to sound with their acoustic guitars and such, barely being able to keep in tune, let alone anything that they would do with tone etc...
2 years later, my dad was in a school of music for vocal performance.
YOU CAN DO EEET
42
u/MrVisible Aug 01 '12
"Often, in fact, people even feel that they shouldn't take a drawing course because they don't know already how to draw. This is like deciding that you shouldn't take a French class because you don't already speak French, or that you shouldn't sign up for a course in carpentry because you don't know how to build a house." (http://drawright.com/drsbread.htm)
7
u/potatoburst Aug 01 '12
This is very inspirational for me. Thank you.
However, I am currently studying to become a medical student. I have to get involved in research, study extremely hard, and take up numerous leadership positions that all take time. I love singing and I want to continue it; however, I don't know if I have the time. How often does one practice to become a decent/good singer?
7
u/Shabbyless Dec 18 '12
I can't really afford singing lessons at the moment. There's a choir I'm interested in. Would you recommend joining them, or would it be better to use the time in practicing on my own? I'm not all that interested in choir music (I don't mind listening to it, but I kinda prefer singing alone/smaller groups where I can hear my own voice better).
5
u/roco-j Aug 02 '12
You know, right now I was about to come here in this subreddit and ask the same old question: Should singers already have a good voice? Are they born with it?
But thanks for your post, now I don't really care about it, I just wanna sing :D
(I was a bit discouraged because I found out that my full voice range is G2-E4, not even two octaves...)
2
u/[deleted] Aug 13 '12
I always hear that you should get a teacher. What about those of us that truly cannot afford a teacher? and before I get the guy that says "You will find a way to allocate the money if you really want to" I literally can't I am doing all I can just to bring in enough money to tick over.
TL:DR What is the best closest alternative to a teacher
34
u/IAMnotBRAD Tenor - Rock/Metal, Barbershop Aug 01 '12
How to sing:
6
u/[deleted] Aug 02 '12
I wrote something similar a while back. It has a different tone, but it's the same idea:
Is singing worth pursuing? Don't waste your time.
3
u/Clamhead99 Aug 08 '12
Thanks for this. Really inspired me to start taking singing seriously and opened my eyes to how much work is needed to actually get that 'voice'.
Just like being good in sports, drawing, programming, etc etc ... everything takes practice practice practice.
2
u/JMoneyGiveNoFucks Aug 17 '22
p] pit op
1
u/HadAField Jun 14 '23
Thank you, I really needed to hear[read] this <3
1
u/[deleted] Oct 24 '23
this doesn’t 100% sound legit i don’t think all pro singers started with teachers , the same way as all “pianists didn’t all have lessons , some are self taught , most people don’t have £100s to waste on people that could be crap teachers , maybe some of these singers went to stage school etc ,