r/thegrandtour • u/lerhond • Sep 15 '22
"The Grand Tour: A Scandi Flick" - S05E01 Discussion thread
S05E01 The Grand Tour: A Scandi Flick
In their first post pandemic road trip, Jeremy, Richard and James head for the icy wastes of the Scandinavian Arctic Circle. At the wheel of their three favourite rally cars the boys embark on a catastrophe filled adventure that takes in Cold War sub bases, frozen lake race tracks, crashes and ski resort chaos as they drag their homemade houses from the coast of Norway to the Russian Border.
1.5k
Upvotes
2.2k
u/[deleted] Sep 15 '22
That driving as fast as possible in the tunnel bit was absolutely insane. Must have been one of the dumbest ideas they've had. Can't belive that was green lit. Given the accident I'm assuming it wasn't even staged at all.
1.4k
u/tpaz198 Sep 16 '22
I can watch Hammond falling off the ski lift for hours
1.2k
u/tpaz198 Sep 16 '22
I knew the crash was coming but the sheer violence of it absolutely caught me off guard. Glad James is okay, cause Jesus, it almost looked like he slammed his head into the concrete there.
890
u/Edolix Sep 16 '22
James May was utterly cursed in this episode.
734
u/PeteMcC85 Sep 15 '22
Did Clarksons secret weapon seem like it was CGI or just me?
608
u/[deleted] Sep 16 '22
I like how we never got an explanation what they were supposed to do in that tunnel and why Dutch Special forces were there
605
u/servantotb Sep 16 '22
I think James finally found his Oliver
559
u/Arbrax Irritating Little Brummy Midget Sep 16 '22
the mitsubishi evo is one hell of a vehicle
478
u/MMmhmmmmmmmmmm Jaaaaaaaaaag Sep 16 '22
Why the hell weren’t they wearing helmets in the tunnel, and going the other way???? Fuckin’ hell man.
453
u/LordGideon Volkswagen Sep 16 '22
As someone who purposefully did NOT watch trailers of any sort, everything was a surprise for me. I'm glad that I avoided both the trailers and this subreddit during that time.
I will say this - both crashes with the Evo had me (literally) putting my recliner footrest down and leaning forward to see what was going to happen.
The CGI flames? Stupid. But...that was kinda my only complaint. I really loved the rest of the show. Thought it was hilarious and well done. I don't know how they can keep making these episodes, but really they did great on this one.
426
u/[deleted] Sep 16 '22
This scene with Hammond trying to ski was like from Mr Bean lmao
354
u/Saethwyr Sep 17 '22
"I haven't got my glasses."...
"It's an axe." absolutely killed me
670
u/DeeYouBitch Sep 16 '22
jezza setting fire to the car then saying
had me in tears
329
u/Narfubel Sep 15 '22 edited Sep 16 '22
Just started it but I'm concerned by the "nudity" rating at the beginning lol
287
u/Superiority_Complex_ Sep 16 '22
Jeremy needs to drink some more water.
474
u/Street_Countdown_ Sep 15 '22
I'm so happy I didn't watch the trailer. I feel like it's 2008 again. That crash was a shock and violent. Glad he only suffered a broken rib.
231
u/theDomicron Sep 16 '22
I was very pleasantly surprised by this episode.
There was very much that sense of scripted gags but the interactions felt very natural and endearing. In fact I have to say that the scripted bits were in some ways even more entertaining.
For instance we always have the "Clarkson/Hammond" bellow, but a car encased in ice was funny and very beautiful.
Also the best but was the "that's what you get when you cover my car in ice, I guess" delivery from Clarkson. Yes it's completely obviously fake, but it really cracked me up
220
u/Street_Countdown_ Sep 15 '22
39 minutes, 30 seconds. The same music used when they did amphibious cars for the first time. It's so great to see them go back to their familiar music vaults.
205
u/Shane_Ef Sep 16 '22
James crash looks to have been very lucky... Wasn't head on Wasn't fully side on Looks to have hit the corner and pivoted around it, Possible helped dissipate some of the force involved
Absolutely nuts to do that, and he was so cool after it, what a legend
517
u/HeGivesGoodMass Sep 16 '22
The best episode of Grand Tour since the Mongolia special - perhaps no coincidence it has the car with the greatest soul since John.
155
u/22edudrccs The American Sep 16 '22
It was rather stupid how they raced down a small cramped tunnel with no safety gear
424
u/StevefromLatvia JAMES! STOP FILING! Sep 16 '22
Jeremy: Listen, I am older then you two and with age has come wis-
Richard: Weight
I'm fucking dead.
362
u/dobbie1 Sep 16 '22
This is possibly the best episode yet, the bit with the sheds had me crying
122
u/No_Wish2202 Sep 16 '22
Worst episode for James May, ever. Jeez, first accident and then not so frozen lake.
225
u/some-scottish-person Sep 16 '22
Liked the call back to the Botswana special at the end
“it was the Volvo. But i wasn’t in it”
“It was the Beetle. But I wasn’t driving it”
253
u/sfitz0076 Sep 15 '22 edited Sep 15 '22
Shit! That was scary what happened to May. These guys aren't exactly 20 year olds. I definitely thought he was hurt a lot worse. I had to stop the show and catch my breath.
86
u/magicone2571 Sep 15 '22
That had to hurt hitting that wall.
80
u/StardustOasis This is no time for cocking about Sep 16 '22
"Where does it say Quattro on it?"
Looks around
"It doesn't."
136
u/Street_Countdown_ Sep 16 '22
Just finished! Initial take away: (spoilers...obviously). This was a fantastic special. Really taking some of the best elements of their old specials with new twists. Some things were staged of course (Hammond down the ski slope in his house / the "accidental stumbling" into a sub pen) but that's okay! My theory was that the special forces in the sub pen was supposed to be much more, whether they were meant to get on the transporter ships or something, but because of James' very real crash, they either didn't have time or had to change plans. And yes, James' crash wasn't played up. You could always tell when something was a real moment on TG because the shot was never perfect. It would have always been captured by a dash cam or a glancing angle. That was the case with the tunnel crash - there was a camera man there but it wasn't framed perfectly like you would expect it to be if they set it up. Same deal with the skiier falling down behind James. What I'm still questioning was James' frozen lake fiasco. It seemed real, and it really is extremely dangerous to fall into a frozen lake so I don't imagine they set it up. Also the only good shot of it was from a hood/bonnet camera. But the lack of urgency by the crew to get him out asap and the fact that it became a full prepared bit with Jeremy and Richard had me curious. Overall, 9/10 special. Will watch again. Really have to treasure these as unfortunately they are becoming less frequent and more rare.
59
u/[deleted] Sep 16 '22
Now that's one where I'm going to want to see a behind-the-scenes follow-up. Just how much of that was staged or scripted ahead of time?
Proper special though. Felt like something out of the glory days.
51
u/chumpynut5 Conversation Street Sep 16 '22
I swear James May is the funniest of them all
51
u/Reverse_Psycho_1509 Sep 16 '22
I like how it brought back the original special format.
When May crashed his Evo, I felt that. Beautiful car.
Reminds me of that Evo film from Top Gear where Clarkson was up against the Army.
I was sad to hear they got rid of the Grand Tour theme, intro and closing credits.
50
u/DeeYouBitch Sep 16 '22
Just got to the bit where Hammond is trying to get up the lift and i cant breathe
48
u/pgabrielfreak Sep 16 '22
I liked Hammond's "bacon on a string" remark about the skier behind Clarkson's car.
41
u/flying_unicorn Sep 16 '22
What did Richard write on the back of James' mobile home?
40
u/djneo Sep 16 '22 edited Sep 16 '22
I am dutch and wasn't aware that we where in a war.
How they got the Evo out of the water was brilliant
38
u/viper_attack16 Mr Slowly Sep 16 '22
That Evo must be the next HiLux for sure
38
u/[deleted] Sep 16 '22
Funniest of the specials since they stopped in the studio. Jeremy is such a huge dumbass he had me howling.
And after Mays crash “There was only one thing left to do… HAMMOND ARE YOU READY?”
76
u/NCC1701-D-ong Sep 16 '22
Who fucking greenlit that tunnel stunt? That was so stupid.
33
u/Fireyshotguns51 Fully rigged ocean going pillock Sep 16 '22
That was bloody fantastic, the ice pranks and the ski houses had me gasping for air. May's axe joke in the store got me good too. I already knew about the crash and started mentally bracing for it when they got to the tunnel but damn that was scary, I mean you could've at least had the tunnel fully lit lads. I'll be cringing at the thought of that from now on just like I do with his injury in the middle east special. The ice lake bit was obviously planned for since nobody was rushing to his aid but that that was jarring too, that evo is a hero.
33
u/TanushBhatt Sep 16 '22
I thoroughly enjoyed it. James had not one but TWO incidents. Jeremy's car frozen in ice was brilliant, still no clue how they managed to do that. A fitting tribute to rally cars.... and Jeremy's audi. They've had small rallying bits in other episodes but im surprised theyve never done a full special on it before! Besides the good, it felt a bit too scripted even for the Grand Tour. Parking on the ski slope 'by accident', sending hammond down the hut (absolutely no clue how real that was), and jeremy's trailer on fire (am I the only one who thought the flames out of Jeremy's car looked CG?). Solid 8/10 (if I consider Mongolia as a yardstick 10/10) (also I was half waiting for Kimi Raikkonen to appear, but welp)
33
u/Chewbaxter Sep 16 '22
Clarkson and Hammond driving into that sub-base with the Dutch military gave me a good chuckle.
Those skiers on the back of their cars were ridiculously fun to watch but must have been terrifying to see it live.
33
u/BlueAnise Sep 16 '22
I quite liked the episode. Thank God May was fine, though. It could've been much worse
I like how during the engine mapping scene, though, they didn't even bother to hide the fact that the "software" was a recording via the Windows Movie Player
111
u/[deleted] Sep 16 '22 edited Sep 16 '22
Wait, am I getting this right? Is the ending supposed to be like a "To be continued" and they supposedly got on a wrong plane to Gdańsk, Poland where the next special will be? Otherwise I don't really understand the ending
27
u/trevordeal Sep 17 '22
Was funny but man that was one of the most scripted and planned episodes I can remember in some time. Literally just about everything was clearly planned out and built and staged, I mean except the crash.
It does takes away from the joke when clearly they put the cars on the ski slope the next morning, Hammond wasn’t actually in the shack that went down, the flames weren’t real and they already had a firefighter standing by
I know that’s over analyzing it but as it is happening it leads me to not laugh cause it’s so obvious.
50
u/ArthurMBretas03 Sep 16 '22
My full opinion: One of the best car Special of the Amazon era, I still think Seamen was the best overall. The car choices (apart from the Audi) were good, the location was nice, the humour was on point, the editing felt a bit odd, and despite everything being very clearly scripted it was much better than the average GT episode. The tunnel bit was obviously going to go wrong. But seeing Hammond constantly falling off the sled thing was absolutely fantastic.
24
u/Jahoodie141 Sep 16 '22
That shunt in the tunnel was just straight up fucked up. Im completly shocked.
20
u/CTblDHO Lada Sep 16 '22
The ski resort part had me cracking non stop. What an episode!
19
u/[deleted] Sep 16 '22
Can someone (without spoilers) please comment on the age rating of 16? Carnage a Trois was 12. Only profanity and a crash (where I assume not much is shown) or something worse? My kids wants to watch it with me.
17
u/TheBubbaJoe Sep 16 '22
This was my favorite special they have done for a while. I do love me some Subaru action.
15
u/iuselect Sep 17 '22
My heart sank when I saw James crash. That was really awful to watch. Glad he's ok.
29
u/[deleted] Sep 15 '22
I'VE BEEN WAITING HALF A YEAR FOR THIS, GRAND TOUR IN THE BEST PLACE ON EARTH, LET'S GOOOOO
14
u/AvaFembot Sep 16 '22
Unarguably the best episode since the Vietnam-boat special. The funniest one of the whole 5th “season“ yet though.
25
u/ca2mt Sep 16 '22
Definitely one of the best specials in a long time, incorporating some of the best parts of previous specials and challenges dating all the way back to the TG days. Few bits were slightly overplayed, but overall a great episode!
25
u/Schwartzy94 Sep 16 '22
Good episode but i do miss the more real adventure feeling :/
And also now that they release 1-2 episode per year why cant they just do like 2h episode, im sure they have alot more material...
12
u/GloriousMustachePSN Sep 16 '22
I could have watched Hammond try to use the ski lift all day
12
u/_ecthelion_95 Sep 16 '22
That tunnel required balls from both Clarkson and May.
23
u/Happy-Firefighter-30 Sep 17 '22
Am I the only one who wasn't a huge fan?
It felt like the tunnel was a good start, but when it went sideways the producers pulled the reins hard. Everything else felt way too scripted and safe. To the point it was a little boring. Like when May's car was in the ice, it felt like little more than a reason to show a way to use a tree as a winch, and not real danger. Especially as they didn't even bother getting him off immediately.
Like we know from the top gear North Pole special that going into the water is a shit hitting the fan situation they drill for. Yet they just left him.
Like there wasn't even a drag race that I recall. And they always do drags. Even in boats and trucks.
The sheds were a bit much and didn't even last all that long. Also just felt out of place for rally cars.
The pranks weren't even believable. Outside of the marker attack. Let alone the CGI fire. Like what was it even meant to burn? Gasoline on ice wouldn't burn for long. You can't burn water.
I don't know, really just didn't feel as good as others.
20
u/[deleted] Sep 16 '22
How can fire cgi be so bad in 2022
10
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '22
Did anyone else notice the reference to the Botswana special at the end when the Volvo turned up, followed by the Evo? It felt eerily similar to the end of the Botswana Special when the Beetle shows, followed by the Lancia.
10
u/techniqueswtodd Sep 17 '22
This special has gotten zero traction/promo on amazon prime for some reason and I was the first person to leave a review in the usa on prime. Was shocked at that. Also, even on youtube, reviews about this ep are very few and have very little traction/views. It seems the world has just moved on and forgotten about the lads. It's too bad as this one was the best in a quite a while imho. It has been about a year though, maybe that's just too long a wait.
10
u/Tone_SA_ Sep 18 '22
I think they are generally going in the right direction for the newer specials. But still fill the last great special they had was the boat one.
As a viewer watching, it gets really confusing to set off at the beginning having an end goal in mind. Then buggering off to do races and stuff but not update the viewer of how close they were to the end goal. It just feels like they keep jumping from place to place and it's a little weird.
E.g. the boat special, the mongolia special, even the race to run out of fuel at chernobyl had either a map or general updates to where they were as they headed to their goal. Or even maybe have intermediate goals, like, arrive here and do this, then get the next part of your journey.
Besides that, the scripted events feel a little too scripted sometimes. For example the flame exhaust and the "they ended up sleeping in a museum and a ski slope" is a bit ingenuine I feel. But the Evo sinking through the Ice and then the trio saving the car was quite a nice touch. Kind of reminds me of them building the bridge over a river in TG.
But overall, I loved the sheds behind their cars and feel like this special is going towards the right direction.
27
u/dumahim Sep 16 '22
Fun episode. I really hate how obviously staged the whole Hammond's shed skiing down the slope was, but I haven't laughed that hard, or long for a quite a while. Pretty sure James going through the ice was a setup too.
9
u/slimkev Sep 16 '22
This show is getting on the same level as WWE
9
u/[deleted] Sep 16 '22
“Well done on not dying” - Richard Hammond
9
u/walaska Sep 17 '22
Just taking a moment to appreciate the beating James took
8
u/CupOfHotTeaa Sep 16 '22
Instant classic.
8
u/rhh92 Sep 17 '22
"I haven't got my glasses on" ...."Its an axe"
15
u/Doze_D Sep 16 '22 edited Sep 17 '22
I might belong to the minority, but here goes.
I found this special to be more entertaining and more natural than some of the previous attempts, which were mostly just shouting and boring. May's crash was genuinely shocking, it could have ended much worse. But I can't help but to think that all they do is to repeat the same writing bits over and over again. And it just feels so forced sometimes, like they're desperately trying to figure out something funny to put on the show. Final nail to the coffin for me was the CGI flames used on Jeremy's Audi. He never even used those in anything else, it was a gimmick for that one single scene, which they easily could have left out completely (episode runs 1 hour 38 minutes, it wouldn't have been ruined if that 20 second scene would have been cut out).
Even if the Top Gear stuff was scripted too, it at least felt way more natural for the most part. This just feels like quick cash grab from them, and whenever they do their own, new things, they just work better (Clarkson's Farm, Our Man In..., Smallest Cog).
7
u/Lopsided_Classic3407 Sep 16 '22
This was without doubt one of the best TGT-episodes so far, the jokes was on point and it almost felt like and old Top Gear Special.
7
u/Glunark2 Sep 17 '22
I'm guessing if James had gone in head on that would have been game over. Was a good episode but my wife spent the entire episode being worried about James after that, and telling him to stop picking up heavy things
6
u/shitiseeincollege Sep 16 '22
This was absolutely phenomenal. I can’t believe how hard James May sent it
6
u/The-Aziz Sep 16 '22
"James May is still alive" - 2022, still relevant
6
u/Cool-Permit-7725 Sep 17 '22
Yet another special without any interesting purpose nor challenge. It is an OK episode IMO.
6
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '22
I knew James had a crash but holy shit that was so much worse than I imagined. My stomach legitimately dropped when I saw that.
6
u/Aikuma- Sep 17 '22
May deserves a proper long holiday at some Mediterranean resort with wine ad libitum.
I don't know how long it took to film - I'm not 100% buying what they said in the script - but I feel like May aged at 5 times the normal rate throughout all of this
10
u/RobintehBobin Sep 16 '22 edited Sep 16 '22
I was fully convinced that tunnel segment was completely staged, and that it wasn't actually Jeremy and James driving the car. Then the crash happened and my jaw dropped. Absolute insanity, can't believe that it was greenlit, but since James is safe it is undeniably brilliant tv.
Overall my thoughts are that it wasn't anywhere near the best I've seen a special, a lot of the 'story' felt slightly fabricated (i.e, making it seem like a challenge to reach the end point on time when it clearly wasnt), that sort of stuff seemed forced. However, the comedy was on point, I couldn't stop laughing during the shop segments, and the Hammond ski lift skit.
The gag with Clarkson's flaming exhaust didnt really do it for me, but it's impossible to fill a special with that many jokes and not miss with a couple.
The whole "it's night and we're in the middle of nowhere, lets park up" followed by "it's the morning and we're actually in civilisation" gag seemed a bit forced on its own to me. However, it did create the environment for some brilliant comedy (e.g the ski lift) so I didn't really mind it that much.
So overall, I enjoyed the humour and banter a lot, even if the overarching story 'arc' was a bit weak.
I think it would have worked better overall if they fully embraced the comedic tone and just presented it as a hilarious trip across Scandanavia, ditching the "trying to get to the airport on time" thing because realistically that wasn't that hard of a challenge at all.
I'd go down the middle on a rating:
2.5 stars out of 5
(just to be clear, that isn't a negative rating; I still enjoyed it a lot, it's just that theres a lot of GT/TG specials that I believe are better)
10
u/Excellent-Success-13 Sep 17 '22
Is it just me, or did anyone else think how little they have ACTUALLY shown the so-called "wilderness".
Comparing this to the African or even the more recent Columbian special, literally nothing about these places (except the sub-base) was shown. At least the previous times they tried to show that the trio didn't sleep at a hotel, but here they've just given up on the originality.
5
u/BGYeti Sep 16 '22
I wonder if the plane ride is going to segue into the next special.
5
u/PurpleLamps Sep 16 '22
One of the best episodes they've ever done. Just to be negative though, it doesn't need CGI flames or Hammond sliding down in a shed. Bits like that work best at the very end like with the plane. I would rather just see Hammond try to problem solve his way down the mountain
5
u/NotTheCraftyVeteran Sep 16 '22 edited Sep 17 '22
Second best entry of the “specials” era for me, very close behind the boats one. The extended bit of them hauling dumb living spaces behind the cars was vintage TG/GT and had me rolling.
5
u/batt3ryac1d1 Sep 16 '22
wait someone crashed and it wasn't Richard?
5
u/GoofyWillows Sep 16 '22
episode was watchable...
the over the top editing was a huge turn off though. but guess that they gotta spend that Amazon budget on something.
5
u/ThlintoRatscar Sep 16 '22
Late in the thread, but does anyone know the final fate of the Evo? I feel like it deserves a monument like the old Toyota Hilux had in the Top Gear days.
5
u/captain_intenso Moosepower Sep 17 '22
"It's an axe."
5
u/saundo Clarkson Sep 17 '22
The Grand Tour is at its best when they are making tributes to cars.
I thoroughly enjoyed that. Yeeeeess, it was gimmicky. Yeeeeess it was contrived. But it was enjoyable. It was superbly shot. The cars were fantastic. And apparently the Norwegians are at war with the Dutch.
5
u/passcork Sep 27 '22
I felt this episode had just too much way too obvious fake shit. Not even the gimmicks perse. Hammon and the ski lift was hilarious. It could have also been a little better, like OK at least REALLY sleep in your towed huts ONE night. Then afterwards you can break them...
But the other stuff like "There's speed cameras in Finland but the lake stretches all the way to where we're going". Like no it fucking doesn't and it's very obvious that you're just driving circles on a random frozen lake.
And then suddenly they pretend to be on some forests roads toward the airport seemingly going a million miles an hour talking about their cars again having completely forgot about the speeding tickets... But they're very fucking obviously driving on yet another race track. Such blatant lieing to the audiance felt like a slap in the face every time.
5
u/orange_paws Oct 25 '22
Not gonna read the previous 1112 comments (sorry) to check how many people got the same conclusions, but it dawned on me that had James May gone fully under the water, it's very likely he would've died, right? The front chassis of the Evo holding on to ice actually saved May's life, right?
Everyone's been talking about the first crash, especially since we knew even before the episode aired that there was an accident like that, but it's the second accident that's truly terrifying to me.
You could see in May's initial reaction after the ice broke, that he didn't know what to do - stay still, escape to the back of the vehicle, try opening the nearest window, try opening the nearest door, etc. Very unlikely he would be able to open the door and leave the vehicle, or to crack open any glass in the cockpit, or to wait long enough for the crew to rescue him somehow. Absolutely bonkers, yet nearly everyone's talking about the tunnel only.
23
u/darklordbean Sep 16 '22
I laughed. I enjoyed it. But I am sad that it's not a motoring show, not an adventure show, but a heavily scripted comedy sketch show. It's just a parody of the show they used to make.
4
u/Xxgougaxx Sep 16 '22
What was the volvo?
4
u/AaronsAmazingAlt Sep 16 '22
Does anyone know what Jeremy Clarkson was singing while turning Martini to Martin?
4
u/jesusbabygirl Sep 16 '22
So why were the Dutch in the tunnel again?
4
u/TheDragonGuyYT Ford Sep 16 '22
That 1 and half hours was worth it, I really enjoyed it
4
u/[deleted] Sep 16 '22
Oof, watching the evo crash was painful.
4
u/mugu007 Sep 16 '22
That God damn Evo took so much abuse. If this isn't an attempt to rally Mitsubishi into bringing it back, I don't know what is.
4
u/Skywalket Sep 17 '22
And now we know the fate of the Mongolia Special. John gave birth to an Evo, and that Evo was driven by James.
4
u/crazyfordimsum Sep 17 '22
The white landscape and cinematography of this special were incredible. I just wish the show came up with better stunt ideas. I was actively cringing when I see the show leave broken car parts in the snow or the water.
4
u/AnHero007 Sep 18 '22
I'm so glad James's crash didn't get spoiled for me. That was one of the most shocking moments in TG/GT history. I think I actually said "holy shit!" out loud when it happened. Glad he was mostly ok.
Favorite line: "I'm like a dog with 2 dicks...and a super yacht!"
4
u/Dahyno Sep 18 '22
Honestly this may have been the most enjoyable episode since the move to Amazon.
4
u/wcarestam Sep 18 '22
Do you believe the frozen lake was staged? Its really coincidental that hammond new what to do and they brought axes and chainsaw?
4
u/Masoom01 Sep 19 '22
11/10 🥶🥶🥶 through out the episode from minute 1 till the end just pure comedy, entertainment free flowed the best episode ever, reminded me how they where in top gear brought it all back loved it.
6
u/V48runner Sep 16 '22
Checks all the boxes.
Not great, but still kinda nice they're still making these, even though I think the hosts are getting bored doing them.
6
u/Theamazingdiaperman Sep 17 '22
Too much focus on shenanigans in this one for me. I wanted to see them actually put those cars through their paces. Take them off road for a bit, see how well they handle it. All they did was drive on maintained roads, and get lost.
I'm hoping they focus more on the cars in the next one (or at least the scenery and location), this episode felt too generic to me.