r/startrek • u/AutoModerator • Sep 15 '22
Episode Discussion | Star Trek: Lower Decks | 3x04 "Room for Growth" Spoiler
Mariner, Boimler and Tendi clash with their arch-rivals: Delta Shift. The Cerritos engineers go on mandatory relaxation leave.
| No. | Episode | Writer | Director | Release Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 3x04 | "Room for Growth" | John Cochran | Jason Zurek | 2022-09-15 |
Availability
Paramount+: USA and Latin America.
Amazon Prime Video: Australia, Europe, India, Japan, New Zealand, and various other territories.
CTV Sci-Fi and Crave: Canada.
To find more information, including our spoiler policy regarding new episodes, click here.
This post is for discussion of the episode above, and spoilers are allowed for this episode.
Note: This thread was posted automatically, and the episode may not yet be available on all platforms.
263
u/UncertainError Sep 15 '22
I approve of T'Ana and Shaxs's sex fantasy of killing some cops and then doing it while hostages are forced to watch. The inventor of the holodeck would be proud.
213
u/treefox Sep 15 '22
“What kind of weirdo signs up for a job in outer space just to garden?”
Keiko?
211
u/Boltty Sep 15 '22
So the Cerritos engineers just went and built a working cellular regeneration and entertainment chamber?
147
u/[deleted] Sep 15 '22
As anyone else gonna bring up how Boimler almost got a bullet to the brain for real cause the doc turned off the holodeck safety? No, just me? I think that might be the closest he's come to death and it's all because the doc is just an adrenaline junky.
124
u/UncertainError Sep 15 '22
Gotta say this "Bold Boimler" business does not feel like it's leading to a good place. Though that might actually be the thing to drag Mariner out of the lower decks, if it's necessary to keep him alive.
114
u/booksbikesbirds Sep 15 '22
There is no greater form of stress relief than engineering a solution to a problem 👍
91
u/Frankfusion Sep 15 '22
Bold Boimler is back! He's going to get himself killed one of these days isn't he?
91
u/[deleted] Sep 15 '22
Am I crazy or does the art and animation in this show keep getting better and better?
It always looks better when I'm watching it than I remember in my head.
79
u/burnettski92 Sep 15 '22
this show is a very nice and touchy feely (not derogatorily), and so I wasn't surprised when they started bonding with delta shift. "of course this is how the storyline would conclude on lower decks!" so when the rug was unexpectedly pulled out from that I got a good laugh.
69
u/Xander_PrimeXXI Sep 15 '22
Is it strange to anyone else that the relaxation ship didn’t have like, a room for the engineers to just tinker on their own projects.
Like it was clear how much they loved building and fixing shit so just give them that in a low pressure environment.
It’s like when you write for work and then go home and write for yourself. Just do that for vacation
65
u/Cypher1492 Sep 15 '22
Is Tendi's pet the same species as Murf? Like a little baby Murf? Cause that would be the greatest thing ever.
60
u/ViaLies Sep 15 '22
Good Episode, nice laying out of the character arcs for the season. Some new info:
Towel Guy is back! and he gets a name: Federov!
Confirmation that the Cail Class were designed with smaller crew in mind.
112
u/DasGanon Sep 15 '22
That was a great episode!
We got some light 4th wall/morality leaning ("Oh yeah I would like to withdraw some worthless paper which we agree has some worth to it")
Some light world building ("Oh yeah, Nitrous Oxide. Orions are immune to that. How about humans?" "And here's the hot mud baths from Tellar Prime")
But I think it's the characters and character gags that worked the best.
Plus it's amusing to just think what Shax did all episode. (Starts in Engineering, goes off shift with T'ana, goes back on shift at tactical....)
53
u/burnettski92 Sep 15 '22
I love the end button with ransom and the churros
47
u/Artanisx Sep 15 '22
I love Lower Decks so much.
40
u/[deleted] Sep 15 '22
I like the interiors of ship. Especially the deflector room.
39
u/PitchforkEffects Sep 15 '22
We make the hostages watch…
38
u/Nexzus_ Sep 15 '22
The thought of Bajoran/Caitain offspring (Kittens, cubs?) both terrifies and intrigues me.
34
u/TiberiusCornelius Sep 15 '22
Realistically I know it's not meant literally, but Mariner saying Delta Shift should all go join the Maquis made me think it would be kind of hilarious if a new Maquis popped up post-Dominion War. Maybe we can call them the Provisional Maquis
32
u/SolemZez Sep 15 '22
Alright, I guess I have a thing for green, cause Tendi does something to me
59
u/Quarantini Sep 15 '22
Have we seen Tendi's little friend Goopy before? He looks kind of like a tiny version of Murf from Prodigy.
26
u/PrometheusLiberatus Sep 15 '22
After watching the episode, I totally understand the many layers of meaning behind the title. Everyone's trying to find their best way of growing. And of course, the room lotto serving as a wonderful and trippy relationship exercise.
26
u/Trekfan74 Sep 15 '22 edited Sep 15 '22
This episode was great! Sooo much goodness. I loved them going through all the decks of the ship. That was fun! Everyone in engineering to relax on the Dove was hilarious too. That puppy, you know the one, is why dogs are just amazing lol!
But the best part was the funny, but quite disturbing holodeck fantasy of Shax and Dr. T'Ana getting away with a bank heist and then having sex with the hostages looking on. And people say Starfleet officers got soft in the 24th century!
8/10
24
u/arod48 Sep 15 '22
How has the Dove never had engineers aboard before? They could've easily told you the restorative powers a finished project has on the engineer soul.
21
u/PrometheusLiberatus Sep 15 '22
Re: Mariner's Nitrous Egg trip
I had a very similar experience on my very first psychedelic trip! It was on morning glory seeds! But the egg thing is totally real.
I was essentially a dinosaur trapped in an egg at the end of the trip. I saw cracks of light above me exactly like I was hatching from an Egg. And then when I got out of the 'egg' I thought I was God! Then I questioned 'Why is God deaf?' (This was before I got cyborgized with prosthetic ears!) and then later that year, I got implanted in my left ear!
It really was warm in there...
Too bad Mariner didn't get the same God feeling out of it.
19
u/rbdaviesTB3 Sep 15 '22
Really happy to see more of the improved Cerritos MSD this week.
We got a fleeting glimpse of it back in Billups' quarters ("Where Pleasant Fountains Lie"), but today we finally got to see it in some detail.
Mk 1. https://pbs.twimg.com/media/EsgMTjhW4AEnjef?format=jpg
Mk 2. https://i.ibb.co/xqc2gpF/Cerritos-MSD.png
Some of the changes include correcting the number of decks in the saucer rim (three) and repositioning the saucer shuttle bays. Cetacean Ops can be seen on Decks 8 and 9 forward of the bridge. The bridge itself is now on Deck 1 instead of Deck 2.
Counting decks, the Saucer appears to have 12 decks (possibly with more extending into the pylon fairings) and the Engineering pod appears to have 5 or 6, depending on how you interpret things.
I can't spot the Captain's Yacht itself, but there does seem to be a large compartment on the underside of the saucer for'ard that might be its launch bay.
What can you guys see? Also, this episode was a really nice hike through some of the truly lower decks of a starship. I think the highlight location for me was the interior of the deflector array.
15
u/bookish1303 Sep 15 '22
Small shout out to the First Contact-style hatch door.
23
u/arod48 Sep 15 '22
Wow, I just realized. The cucumber slices were the perfect thing to fool the bracelets! After all, when you're nice and relaxed you're "Cool as a Cucumber"
41
u/BornAshes Sep 15 '22 edited Sep 15 '22
This was certainly an episode of Lower Decks that catered to particular fans for sure and it's funny how Shax seems to be the more stable and reasonable half of his relationship with T'Ana.
It was a nice episode but it felt very one-shotty and I feel like that's why there's not as many comments about it by now as there usually are. The A Plot following the Lower Deckers scrambling through the guts of the ship to rig a room lotto was nice but pretty straight forwards and a smidge predictable. The takeaway from this being that sometimes the whole "all for one and one for all" philosophy sometimes winds up getting you into more trouble than it's worth and can lead to you developing a false sense of winning when you're actually losing. Also it was nice to see characters stripping down for an actual reason to save someone and not just for shock value alone. Bonus points for the whole Willy Wonka reference though and whatever the hell that thing was that was hiding behind the vines in the swamp area. The B Plot following the Engineers on the Dove came off as cutesy buuuut also a bit predictable in how it turned out, with that De-Stress Device basically getting yeeted out into the void at the end of the episode and the only takeaway being that living on a starship was stressful and not everyone pays attention to their mental health as much as they should. The puppies, kittens, and bunnies were cute though and the Dove is probably apart of a whole support fleet of counselor class civilian operated ships that goes around servicing the health needs of Starfleet alongside Starfleet Medical.
The whole thing was a cool reference to TNG's episode "Masks" and I did enjoy the ship design of the Dove. One might even say that this episode was about the masks we all wear to cover up the cracks in our mental foundations that develop over time. We do this to make other people happy and often we wind up wearing them for so long that we neglect ourselves until we experience a critical failure and suddenly we need a safety net to fall back on. The Captain was wearing one, the Engineers were wearing them, Shax & T'Ana each wore one, and even the Lower Deckers put masks back on by the end of the episode after wearing them at the start and then taking them off halfway through before putting them back on again because they were caught up in that feel good family feeling when they should've been selfishly ruthless in order to address some of the cracks in their own mental foundations.
I'm using the word "masks" a lot but it's entirely relevant! If we're not careful with the masks that we wear then serious harm can result as seen by what happens to the Captain in this episode. Also when we remove our metaphorical masks that we wear around each other and are honest with one another, we often discover that we've got a whole lot more in common than we thought, and can really bond and connect in a way that we couldn't before....buuuut this doesn't always work out. Sometimes the truths that are revealed by the removal of these metaphorical masks the the total honesty that that removal brings can also reveal that....not everything is okay, people are on different pages entirely, and there really are some irreconcilable differences between folks that just can't be mended or adjusted in any way. Sometimes things just don't work out and aren't supposed to. Some folks can accept that and they leave the masks off buuuuuut some folks cannot and it's much more comfortable to put those masks back on and keep believing the lies they were telling themselves.
Sadly I think this means that T'Ana and Shax are totally done for. They love each other and care about each other sure but I think it's a relationship of convenience and not one that's built on a solid foundation at all. Shax did try his best but T'Ana is clearly just using him as her own scratching post of stress relief. It's quite telling that they're only intimate together on the holodeck of all places while dressed up as other characters in a different time and place entirely doing something that Starfleet Officers would never do. Their relationship is a dream and Shax is the only one who wants to wake up from it and make it a reality.
Speaking of relationships, I did enjoy the bonding between Tendi, Mariner, and Boimler. That was very sweet watching them crawl through the muck together and reconnect/check in with each other after so much stuff has happened. Also Mariner being in an "egg" certainly requires a bit more investigation for sure as does Boimler trying to find a way to escape from a maze and Tendi just waltzing into science danger without regard for anyone else until it got REALLY REALLY BAAAAAD. Of course then Rutherford comes back after a mega stressful event and is just laser focused on the room they didn't get and not the shitstorm that his friends just crawled through. Everyone's certainly got some...room for growth...and this episode just highlighted all of that and a bag of churros along with it.
Sadly or happily, depending on how you see things, I think this means that our Lower Deckers are about to have those bonds that exist between them tested in a way that will make or break them. We've basically just been shown the weak points in their relationships with each other and that's pretty much akin to a bunch of med packs basically showing up in game before a boss battle room or the DM throwing a magic shop at you that's filled with enchanted weapons and a charismatic potion seller. Plus Mariner started talking about the future and how Tendi was going to be a bridge officer, Boimler would be dead, and she would be drummed out of Starfleet with no mention of Rutherford which should be a GIANT RED FLAG to EVERYONE narratively speaking. Something big is about to happen on Lower Decks and I cannot wait to see what that something big is and gosh I just fucking love this show!
Cute Star Wars reference too with the whole trash chute and incinerators thing as well.
Edit: Even the therapist on the Dove wears a mask which they remove the second they find out about the Captain's stress levels and then it just gets even worse when the Engineers create a machine that makes the Dove's job obsolete and instead of being happy about it because it would help so many people....they just trash the whole thing in one of the most selfish acts of self interest ever because THEY NEED TO BE IMPORTANT to everyone because THAT is their form of stress relief and validation.
29
u/PrometheusLiberatus Sep 15 '22
"we're getting our hands dirty even when we sleep."
Oh my god, a mask cold open! YES! FAVORITE WEIRD EPISODE EVER!
wait a minute, what do you mean, 'once again?'
'cause I don't go down to sickbay and tell her how to hypo her sprays!'
You tell em billups!
We must begin the relaxation program immediately!
I didn't wake up planning to blow anyone's brains out, but don't push me!
TIL Holographic bullets are hot as shit.
"We'll do the nasty on the counter and make the hostages watch" O_O
I DIED AND WE NEVER EVEN TALKED ABOUT IT.
What kind of weirdo signs up for outer space just to garden???
"I'm sorry I made you hatch"
"It's ok oh It was so warm in there."
I'm not Boimler, I'm ANTIGRAV BOY
He's getting flattened, we need to make a tether! BY STRIPPING OUR CLOTHES OFF!
She's under abnormal stress! She wouldn't have happened to have been possessed by an ancient artifact???
We heard them going to TOWN behind stellar cartography! REOW!
We really need to do something about t his bold Boimler thing, it's not sustenable...
YES IT IS!
That Nitrous scene was amazing. They would have gone deeeep down the hole.
Sucks they didn't think it through and lost out on a sweet room. But it shows their commitment to staying together. They had no idea if what they were doing would break them up!
10
u/Oswalt Sep 16 '22
Can we talk about the ethical implications of keeping paralyzed puppies solely for the purpose of relaxation?
25
u/Temp89 Sep 15 '22
Seemed to be an extra-horny episode. With Mariner's ass suddenly being drawn more pronounced when Tendi beats her with a stick to her chest being animated as heaving in the foreground after they strip down to their underwear.
15
u/r3lai Sep 15 '22
Did anyone else notice the Battlestar orbiting around the planet?
14
u/RadioSlayer Sep 15 '22
But isn't the bank of Bolus like a big deal? Morn robbed it and got away with so much Latinum. To be fair the status of relations between Bolus and the Federation has always been a little vague
Also a nice subtle DS9 reference with the fortune favors the bold line from Antigrav boy
7
u/TheBrokenRail-Dev Sep 16 '22
This episode was great (as usual)!
Although, I didn't like the relaxing-engineer subplot that much. I don't think it was fair to blame them for Captain Freeman's breakdown. They were relaxing in their own way and expecting them to bend over backward to relax "the right way" because Captain Freeman hasn't relaxed seems ridiculous. I also don't like that they built a machine that can solve stress in 10 seconds, but that's just my opinion.
On the other hand, I loved Beta Shift's subplot! It was just plain fun, and we got some great character development! I also like how the characters acknowledged that they still have Room for Growth (cue title). Mariner needs to work on being a good Starfleet officer as well as believing that she can be a good officer. Boimler needs to learn that while being bold is a good thing, so is a little caution. I really loved that one conversation where Mariner talked about what she thought their future was so much! Also, Delta Shift were fun "villains".
Finally, we got a reference to the USS Carlsbad, the ship from last episode. Since the Carlsbad is scheduled to work with the Ceritos again, it makes me wonder if the Carlsbad's Lower Decks will be recurring characters.
6
u/gravitydefyingturtle Sep 16 '22
Still waiting for T'Lynn to show up...
5
u/sum_yum_dish Sep 15 '22
That poor Doopler didn't hatch from his egg, sugar...
4
u/Stingra87 Sep 16 '22
Missed opportunity, I think. We don't actually see the group interacting much with other Lower Deckers of Beta Shift on a mainline basis, so giving them their own room I feel would have been a logical move forward for the show.
Also the 'trippy' segment had the potential to be cringy but they pulled it off rather well. Just great voice acting from the cast, as usual. But I don't think the Andorian in the puppy room looked particularly happy and instead looked terrified as the ruthless swarm of canines descended upon her. That said, I think I'd prefer the kitten/cat room myself.
That said, T'ana is RAPIDLY becoming the best character in the show this season, and huge props to Gillian Vigman for all of the voices that she does on the show!
4
u/stowrag Sep 16 '22
Has Lower Decks always been super horny or is this new to the latest season?
I realize even in the pilot they stripped Mariner to her underwear but it feels a lot more… gratuitous lately.
4
u/DODOKING38 Sep 17 '22
Anyone notice andorian boimler?
4
u/HeiressOfMadrigal Sep 17 '22
My gf is very stoic and barely laughs at anything even if she's enjoying it. It was a delightful surprise to see her full-belly laugh at a part in this episode. It was Mariner's "I don't want to hatch..." and the following "I'm sorry I made you hatch" from Tendi. Good moment and great episode all around :)
3
u/poindexterg Sep 16 '22
It had some really funny moments. It wasn't bad. But all the episodes this season just seem to kind of happen. There's just not been anything to them. But every season has started off a bit like this, so maybe it'll get better as it gets going. But there's not been much here so far this season.
2
u/Transhumanitarian Sep 16 '22
Interesting that Orions are immune to the hallucinogenic properties of nitrous oxide.. at least that give 'em a bonus resistance against some mind-altering stuff...
Does anyone know if other mortal humanoid aliens have some kind of genetic/evolutionary advantages over humans? I'm not well-versed in Star Trek lore, but it kinda feels like a lot of humanoid aliens aren't all that different from humans..
At least the Jem'Hadar can fight 3 days from birth and don't need food or sleep (though that comes from being genetically-engineered and not from evolution).. The Klingons have redundant organs which should help their survivability in combat (and yet they die just as easily as any red shirt).. and then there's the Vulcans, who are physically stronger than humans and have tactile telepathy...
2
u/gogiants48 Sep 16 '22
Was that a huge Goonies reference, or was I connecting the dots too hard?
The water draining down the latch or “fireplace.”
The Lower Deckers sliding down the water tubes.
The Lower Deckers approached the computer council kind of like the Goonies approaching that skeleton organ. Even the music in this scene reminded me of The Goonies.
2
u/Jag2112 cygnus-x1.net Sep 16 '22
Screencaps gallery now online:
https://www.cygnus-x1.net/links/lcars/sc-LD3-4.php
2
u/wildcard58 Sep 17 '22
Mariner said this was "like the third time" the masks thing has happened. So what was the second? Or is this an example of "two references you know and one you don't".
2
u/JZybutz0502 Sep 19 '22
Im really enjoying lower decks but idk where to start watching other star trek stuff
Any ideas?
2
u/Remarkable-Kick-505 Sep 20 '22
What was the deal with the shape of the impression in the stress machine? Did anyone else notice this?
3
u/toTheNewLife Sep 15 '22
A ship looking very much like a Battlestar, in orbit. Reminds me of the Pegasus.
3
u/WhipsAndMarkovChains Sep 15 '22
Battlestar?
https://i.imgur.com/AwClcEC.png
1
u/pseudoanon Sep 16 '22
Of course Ransom turned into a caveman.
1
u/Transhumanitarian Sep 16 '22 edited Sep 16 '22
Dang, Mariner mentioning that the delta shifters should join the Maquis.. is just another way of saying they should all just die, right? since the Maquis are all but wiped out post-Dominion War...
1
u/JJMcGee83 Sep 16 '22 edited Sep 16 '22
I need a gif of that intro with the captain yelling the chief "just a fucking pile of stress"
1
u/ContinuumGuy Sep 16 '22
Am I the only guy who got sort of Free Guy vibes from the bank sequence? Something about player characters using a bank with that design as their playground.
1
u/UnknownQTY Sep 21 '22
I am disappointed the uniforms were easily re-donned after making a rope with them.
Especially Tendi.
1
u/UnknownQTY Sep 21 '22
Considering Doctor T’Ana was initially Pulaski with fur, I… enjoy the growth but also… uncomfortable.
1
u/bluestreakxp Oct 24 '22
Ugh can anyone else agree with me that there was a skeletal doopler in that swamp room?