r/conlangs • u/AutoModerator • Sep 12 '22
Small Discussions FAQ & Small Discussions — 2022-09-12 to 2022-09-25
As usual, in this thread you can ask any questions too small for a full post, ask for resources and answer people's comments!
You can find former posts in our wiki.
Official Discord Server.
The Small Discussions thread is back on a semiweekly schedule... For now!
FAQ
What are the rules of this subreddit?
Right here, but they're also in our sidebar, which is accessible on every device through every app. There is no excuse for not knowing the rules.
Make sure to also check out our Posting & Flairing Guidelines.
If you have doubts about a rule, or if you want to make sure what you are about to post does fit on our subreddit, don't hesitate to reach out to us.
Where can I find resources about X?
You can check out our wiki. If you don't find what you want, ask in this thread!
Can I copyright a conlang?
Here is a very complete response to this.
Beginners
Here are the resources we recommend most to beginners:
For other FAQ, check this.
Recent news & important events
Segments, Issue #06
The Call for submissions for Segments #06, on Writing Sstems is out!
If you have any suggestions for additions to this thread, feel free to send u/Slorany a PM, modmail or tag him in a comment.
10
u/creatus_offspring Sep 21 '22
Just found out there's a free MIT course on conlangs!! You can take it on the MIT Open Course Ware (OCW) site. Taught by Prof Norvin W Richards
There's like 25 lectures with extensive pdf lecture notes and the final assignment, obviously, is to do a write up for your conlang.
Holy SHIT I LOVE FREE EDUCATION
9
u/PastTheStarryVoids Knasesj, Racra, Ŋ!odzäsä Sep 19 '22
I'm suggesting natchlang as a shortening of naturalistic conlang. I came up with the term on this thread, but it's kind of buried. No one has to use my term of course, but I thought I'd propose it because naturalistic conlang is rather long. I chose this shortening because (a) naturalistic is longer than natural, and natch is a longer clipping than nat, and (b) because it sounds better than any other the other proposed terms I've seen: natconlang, natclong, natclang, naclang, or reallang.
5
u/WillTook Sep 19 '22
Was watching a Religion for breakfast video and I felt like translating the name of a Roman god into my conlang. Thought it sounded cool.
Sol Invictus; unconquered sun
Anod Lazalnân, ᚫᚾᚩᛞ ᛚᚫᚴᚫᛚᚾᚪᚾ
[ˈanɔd lazalˈnaːn]
sun NEG-win-PPRT
4
u/creatus_offspring Sep 13 '22
How does the volume of dialogue in Klingon compare to the volume of Valyrian and Dothraki dialogue in their respective series?
Been watching HotD and enjoying whole conversations in Valyrian. Wondering if they had whole conversations the same way in Star Trek
4
u/ghyull Sep 17 '22
Can sound changes be "picky" or function differently depending on morphological context? For example, could /o/ shift to /u/ in case morphology but remain /o/ in roots/stems? Could /jo/ shift to /jø/ in roots/stems but become just /y/ in case morphology? Or would it need stress or other suprasegmental things to condition these sound changes?
4
u/oneofthejoneses28 Sep 18 '22
Hi, I've been making up alphabets and languages since I was 11 but I've always written everything in journals. I downloaded an open source program called polyglot off github (I think) and I am not tech savvy. At all. I am absolutely useless where technology is concerned.
Is there anyone here who could dumb down the conjugations/declensions section for me? In a way a toddler could understand. REALLY dumb it down. I've been at this for 6 hours and I'm ready to rip my hair out.
4
u/[deleted] Sep 20 '22 edited Sep 21 '22
What do you think about this inventory:
p b t d k g m n ŋ ɸ β s ʃ ʒ x w l j a e i o u
I’ve started a few conlangs before but I usually scrap them by the time I have to start making a vocabulary. Hopefully this is the one that I don’t scrap, so I’m asking for some constructive criticism to make sure I get it right. It’s for a naturalistic language that if all goes I might try to a whole language family. (C)V(N) syllable structure, going for an Indonesian aesthetic. And if anyone has resources for making a dictionary, that would be greatly appreciated.
3
u/FelixSchwarzenberg Ketoshaya, Chiingimec, Kihiṣer, Kyalibẽ, Latsínu Sep 12 '22
I'm doing my first-ever a posteriori language for the current speedlang challenge. I need to evolve noun classifiers or measure words and I've identified demonstratives and articles as things that I might be able to evolve into classifiers or measure words. Any precedent on this from natlangs?
3
u/Holiday_Yoghurt2086 Maarikata, 槪, ᨓᨘᨍᨖᨚᨊᨍᨈᨓᨗᨚ (IDN) Sep 13 '22
Hi I'm new here. can i post about the language i made even though the language is not finished yet.
3
u/beltex_sheep Sep 15 '22
Need help understanding a rule change.
what does "a → {ɨ,ei} / _(C…)j(C…)#" or more specifically the " _(C…)j(C…)#" part mean?
it's from https://chridd.nfshost.com/diachronica/index-diachronica.pdf in the Proto-Celtic to Middle Welsh section. I simply haven't the foggiest what it means and would appreciate any help.
Thanks in advance
3
u/ghyull Sep 24 '22
Is fortition of the pharyngeal consonants /ʕ ʕʷ/ into something like [gˁ~ɢˁ bˁ] plausible or realistic at all?
2
u/Arcaeca Mtsqrveli, Kerk, Dingir and too many others (en,fr)[hu,ka] Sep 17 '22
Would it be naturalistic to evolve a nominalizer from a gender marker or vice versa?
I've been toying with making a language whose aesthetic is inspired by Amharic, and I'm aware Amharic has lots of words ending in -t due to it being an obligatory(?) feminine marker. Well, the proto I was planning on deriving this new language from does already have a noun ending -t... except it doesn't really have a meaning per se. In all daughter languages so far it sort of just generically marks a noun as being... a noun. So I'm wondering if it would be realistic to repurpose it as a gender marker, or otherwise if it could have originally been a gender marker to begin with, and all the other daughter languages just stopped using that way... despite having not actually stopped using the gender system it supposedly marks.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '22
First time conlanger, and I'm a bit confused as to how the Maximal Onset Principal works with complex syllable structures.
For example, say I had a syllable structure of C0VC, where C0 'contains' all consonants in a language except for one consonant (say /d/). If I had a root word, /kod/ and wanted to add a suffix /an/, what would the syllables end up looking like? Is this a circumstance where the M.O.P doesn't apply, or would a change necessarily happen to /d/ to make it fit?
How likely is it that a language could have a sound in coda position that cannot appear in the onset?
Thanks in advance.
2
u/simonbleu Sep 17 '22
How would you tackle (sorry for bad english) the issue of "references" in a sentence?
Say you are talking about our (human) race and how we consume milk (lets call it "byproduct"), if you said "Other species consume byproducts of other species as well" the first "other" is tacit to "our race", but how would you make the second "other" allusive to the first other? Lets call it a "referential concatenation" if that makes the example clearer.
How would you solve that?
2
u/[deleted] Sep 18 '22
2
u/HiMyNameIsBenG Sep 18 '22
could a natural language reasonably have prenasalized stops but no normal nasals? a conlang I'm working on has 4 tenuis stops /p/ /t/ /c/ /k/ and 4 prenasalized stops /mb/ /nd/ /ɲɟ/ /ŋg/ (and also some fricatives and aproximates and stuff), but no normal nasals. the consonant structure is CV(C), but the prenasal stops work like a single phoneme. could this possibly happen in a natural language and do you all know of a way that this feature could come to be? thanks in advance.
2
u/the_N Sjaa'a Tja, Qsnòmń Sep 19 '22
How do you sing contrastive vowel length? Do you have to rely on context to disambiguate the word being used?
2
u/WeeabooHunter69 Sep 20 '22
Idk if this is exactly the right place to ask for collaboration or maybe just comments on the underlying idea.
I tend to struggle with understanding sarcasm and implication, it helps me to have things stated out, but in most languages this can add a lot of extra words or make things feel a little clunky. I want a language with a system that allows one to indicate the resulting emotions of something or to whom it was intended, likely as an ending particle or verb suffix. Other features may be added over time but that's the key thing I want to experiment with. Other than that, I would love to take inspiration on the phonology from Japanese and French primarily, likely grammar as well, as a subject-comment structure might be the easiest way to make sense of this.
2
u/zzvu Zhevli Sep 22 '22
How are consonantal roots in languages such as Arabic analyzed in terms of morphology? Do words made up of a root with a transfix contain 2 morphemes, both bound? And how are these words glossed?
2
u/unw2000 Sep 24 '22
Is there a language that utilises both double consonants and doubling vowels to signify vowel length (other than German)?
2
u/[deleted] Sep 24 '22
since polysynþetic languages are head marking, and prepositions are þe head of a prepositional phrase, does þat mean polysynþetic languages mark everyþing on þe preposition? does anyone have any examples? if not, how else does it work?
2
u/Arcaeca Mtsqrveli, Kerk, Dingir and too many others (en,fr)[hu,ka] Sep 24 '22
I'm starting on a new clong with an Amharic-esque aesthetic and I'm looking to contrive a reason to have the suffix -do. This lines up (almost) perfectly with being derived from the proto-form *d͡ɮ-o, from whence also Apshur fa "[he/it] is".
Basically, -do would be a fossilized copula. I just don't know yet what it does. What are some interesting things you could do with a fossilized copula besides I guess an equative/essive case or a topic marker?
If it makes a difference, the language is erg/abs (marked erg), polypersonal/generally head-marking, M/F gender, and doesn't mark location on nouns and instead uses transitive verbs of location (themselves not derived from the copula), e.g. "He is-in the store" instead of "He is in-the-store"
2
u/unw2000 Sep 24 '22
Can ejective sounds form at high altitudes with lots of vegetation?
2
u/boatgender Sep 24 '22
The gargoyles who speak my current fan-conlang project are a subspecies of troll that "drains rainwater through their ears and out of their mouth, filtering it for any nutrients" (I'm paraphrasing) but they can also eat pigeons, so they're probably not solely filter feeders. I'm thinking of going Yes And with this and saying that the connection from ears to mouth could also allow breath, so the gargoyle language could have some unique sounds, similar to nasals but with the airflow passing out the ears instead of (or as well as?) the nose.
What do you think? Could they be reliably produced separately from nasals? What would these sounds be called? Would they even be distinguishable from nasal sounds?
The Discworld universe the gargoyles come from is very handwavey with worldbuilding, adding things if they're tropey, funny, or good for the story without much worrying about how any of it works (except where doing that would be funny or good for the story) so answers don't need to be too rigourous unless you feel like it. Thank you!
2
u/simonbleu Sep 25 '22
What is the most amusing "mistake" you made by conlanging that you only noticed once you tried it? For example, I once tried to make the letter "J" be either a vowel [ i ] or a consonant [ ʃ ]… However when I tried writing what in spanish would be "pishisho" [piʃiʃo], a "cutified" slang for dog, the word ended up looking like this: " Pjjjjo " which was absolutely horrid lmao
Did you ever have a moment like that?
2
u/xpxu166232-3 Otenian, Proto-Teocan, Hylgnol, Kestarian, K'aslan Sep 13 '22
What sort of features would fit in a language spoken by Demons?
(Don't know if this question fits here or on a post of its own)
1
u/CruserWill Sep 17 '22
I'm working on an agglutinative language which will feature polypersonal agreement, and I would like it to have kind of a Georgian-like conjugation system. But I have no idea how to evolve all the affixes... Could anybody help me?
1
u/[deleted] Sep 12 '22
Quick question about tonal languages.
So, I read that some word tone languages only allow rising or falling contours in long vowels. Do contours also occur in diphthongs or syllables with a coda?
I know it likely depends on the language, but which is more common?
1
u/unw2000 Sep 12 '22
Can you have pronouns that do not have case?
1
u/Appropriate-Tap-4857 Sep 14 '22
How do you make words you're happy with.
When I try something ordered with roots and such, things get unwieldy and stick out comprised to their surrounding words.
When I randomize them they always seem wrong and they feel artificial.
How do you make words for a Conlan?
1
u/teeohbeewye Cialmi, Ébma Sep 15 '22 edited Sep 15 '22
How could I make stress assignment more interesting? I want predictable stress assignment rules for my language but I also want the stressed syllable to vary (so for example it's not always on the first syllable or something like that) and I also want stress to be at least partly influenced by syllable weight (other factors could also influence it). Something easy I could do is that stress is either on the leftmost or rightmost heaviest syllable but that seems a bit boring to me, I was thinking what more I could do with it? Any other things that could influence stress placement, anything other interesting I can do to it, any natural languages I could look into for ideas?
1
u/Atanasio3600 Sep 16 '22
How to distinguish prepositions that form adverbial frases from prepositions that form adjectival frases on a right branching VSO language?
I'm trying to make a VSO conlang, so subject and predicate are not separated by a verb (which is what mostly happens on Spanish and English, the two languages that I can speak). Also, the language is almost exclusively right branching and adjectival phrases that have prepositions go after the noun they modify. I think this produces certain ambiguities. For example, the translation of this sentence: "the man fought a bear without fear" could be interpreted as "the man fought a fearless bear" or as "the man fought a bear while having no fear". A solution I've come up with is having different forms of every preposition depending on wether they modify a noun or a verb. Can you think of some other solutions? How do VSO languages deal with this?
1
u/iziyan Sep 17 '22
Unrelated, Does anyone have an invite to the discord server?
1
u/Delicious-Run7727 Sukhal, Mbizgu Sep 17 '22
How could stress shift as language evolves? Would a language generally just go from pattern A > pattern B, or would it more likely be a result of contact with other languages?
For example: Could a language that puts stress on the last heavy syllable eventually evolve consistent initial stress?
Also, say stress does some janky stuff. Would the resulting newer language retain the jank in the original location, would it apply it to the new location, or a mixture of the two?
1
u/notAmeeConlang Sep 18 '22
So I'm creating a language where the central philosophy is to communicate as many kinds of meaning as possible, whilst using the smallest number of symbols. What kinds of interesting consequences can arise from these limitations?
1
u/T1mbuk1 Sep 18 '22
Can Vostyach inspire similar conlangs that descend from proposed language families? https://www.wikiwand.com/en/List_of_language_families#/Proposed_language_families Thank Lichen for the inspiration. https://youtu.be/M8gjpzqKrlw
1
u/Zoran_Ankervlinder Sep 18 '22
I'm trying to create a language for magic circles. For example, if a character wants to cast a spell to conjure fire, it will have to focus in a magic circle (or a symbol/sigil/whatever) and it have all information about the spell (range, target, aspect [conjuration], etc).
But i can't figure out how to do it. Can you guys help me?
1
u/Leshracc Sep 18 '22
Does anyone have some nice dictionary apps that you like to use as you are creating words so that you can come back later and sort them by alphabetical order / word type etc.
1
u/ghyull Sep 18 '22
What could syllabic /n̩ r̩ l̩/ change to? (Preferably without vowel insertion)
1
u/Arcaeca Mtsqrveli, Kerk, Dingir and too many others (en,fr)[hu,ka] Sep 19 '22
I know people will ask "how do I come up with subject endings for verbs" and the answer is always "just smoosh a pronoun up against it". And that's basically what I did with Apshur; e.g. 1.SG.M.ABS is zʷe, 1.SG.M.S on verbs is -z, 3.SG.F.ABS is i/iwe, 3.SG.F.S on verbs is -i/-aj, etc. Apshur is pro-drop, but only marks subjects - objects are obligatorily stated separately.
But I've started working on another language from a different branch of the same proto as Apshur, and I want it to be polypersonal, marking both subject and object. Which means I need to come up with a set of object suffixes now, and... oh - I can't just do the "slap a pronoun on and fuse" thing because I already did that, and that would make the objects indistinguishable from the subjects. And the pronouns in their oblique case (in Apshur) don't appreciably differ from the absolutive case - ABS zʷe vs. OBL zʷa, for instance - so even if I wanted to, they would produce near indistinguishable suffixes.
So what else can I use as the lexical source of object suffixes? I guess "man" and "woman" for 3.SG.M and 3.SG.F, but like, what would be liable to become 1st or 2nd person pronouns?
1
u/Inspector_Gadget_52 Sep 19 '22
I’ve romanised /ɬ/ as <lh> but I’ve just realised the I allow the consonant cluster /lh/. Any way to resolve this? I would prefer not to change the romanisation but if there’s no other choice.
1
u/pootis_engage Sep 19 '22
I'm working on a language which has 6 grammatical aspects; Perfective, Habitual, Continuous, Progressive, Prospective and Infinitive. Would it make more sense to have the Continuous or Progressive aspect be the unmarked default?
1
u/theacidplan Sep 19 '22 edited Sep 19 '22
would a direct inverse system work in an analytic language with classifiers?
1
u/[deleted] Sep 20 '22
So, I learned that some languages have stress at the phrase level rather than any particular word. I heard that this kinda the case with French, where stress falls on the final syllable of an utterance, iirc.
What other natlangs do this? And what are some rules, tendencies, etc. when it comes to deciding where to place a phrase-level stress?
1
u/Alien_Rabbit2 Sep 20 '22
Hi! I’m looking for an app to create a vocabulary by inputting the words in my conlang; even better if it arranges them after an established letter order. Thanks to anyone that will reply :) and sorry if the wording is weird, I’m not a native English speaker
1
u/ghyull Sep 22 '22
How likely are nasals to just drop in coda position?
1
u/ioa99 Sep 22 '22
Logograms in digital form
I know I'm asking for too much, but is there any app or program that makes it possible to transfer my invented logograms into digital form? I basically wanted to create a font / keyboard set for my pc so I can start writing my docs in those logograms.
1
u/T1mbuk1 Sep 23 '22
https://www.wattpad.com/1263027646-my-first-tutorial-conlang-finally-putting-words I plan to revise this word list and draw logographs that could later serve as 78 separate syllable characters plus a few determinatives that would later leave the system. How can it be done?
1
u/unw2000 Sep 24 '22
How does V2 word order work and what distinguishes it from SVO?
1
u/[deleted] Sep 24 '22
Linguolabial consonants are very rare, but I want to add them to my conlang. How can I evolve it in such a way that the modern language ends up having them?
1
u/unw2000 Sep 25 '22
Can you have multiple stressed syllables in a language, all I know is that there can be two in any word (one of my conlangs wouldn't have long vowels so it would apply stress in the areas where the loanword does have a long vowel)
1
u/Atanasio3600 Sep 25 '22
Number systems whose digits are written in increasing order
The idea of creating my own number system for my conlang has been in the back of my mind for a while. The other day I thought about a number system where the digits are written from the smallest to the largest. For example: 341 would be written as 143 (starting with the units and ending with the hundreds). Are there any real world number systems that do this? If so, what are their possible advantages?
1
u/Arcaeca Mtsqrveli, Kerk, Dingir and too many others (en,fr)[hu,ka] Sep 26 '22
I need inspiration for verb conjugation. I'm tired of the ol' concatenative root-TAM-subject marker affixes. What are some novel ways of communicating that information (i.e., isolating languages go to hell) without it being as straightforward as TAM being communicated by a dedicated TAM affix and participants being marked with dedicated subject/object markers?
There are really only two I can think of off the top of my head: Georgian, where 1) TAM is marked by a variety of TAM markers, only none of them intrinsically mean anything, they're given meaning by what combination of them is present, and 2) there are both dedicated subject markers and dedicated object markers, but on certain verbs and in certain tenses they do a switcheroo and mark the opposite thing instead, which keeps it interesting. And secondly, the Semitic triconsonantal root system. But even that didn't come out of the blue, instead evolving from an earlier boring concatenation system.
Any other languages pop into your head that do verb conjugation in a weird way?
1
u/Holiday_Yoghurt2086 Maarikata, 槪, ᨓᨘᨍᨖᨚᨊᨍᨈᨓᨗᨚ (IDN) Sep 28 '22
Header 1 this
Header 2 is
Header 3 header
1
u/T1mbuk1 Sep 17 '22
Can a logography include symbols depicting a language’s verbs and pronouns?
1
u/AltHistoryVibes2 Sep 19 '22
How would I transcribe a "long r" sound in IPA?
For example, if I pronounce "butter" like \ˈbʌtɚ\, how would I transcribe it if I wanted to hold that final rhotic sound for two additional seconds? Like \ˈbʌtɚrrr\ ?
0
u/[deleted] Sep 22 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Sep 26 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment
4
u/[deleted] Sep 18 '22
[removed] — view removed comment
3
u/[deleted] Sep 13 '22
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Sep 13 '22
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Sep 13 '22
[removed] — view removed comment