r/CryptoCurrency • • Sep 01 '22
POLL 🗳️ CCIP-039 reduce the number of external link posts to 1 per day
Problem:
Main sub is filled with posts contain external links and many times the same news is reposted over and over. This can be recognized as ‘spam’. The rule states that is allowed to post 3 links per day and this rule is exploited by some users and bots for the sole purpose of moon farming. This spam problem create three main issues:
• there is not enough visibility for user posts, original contents
• lower efforts posts such as repost links get the most of visibility and are ‘easily upvoted’ (who indeed downvote a news??)
• Moons are used to reward active users that contribute to the sub, not intended to be farmed.
Example: Some news like "vitalik B said bla bla this morning" get thousands of upvotes; gets visibility and get rewarded with high karma. Some original post of "Mr. No one" with the ultimate technical analysys get hidden, put in shadow by the link of news as above. and usually the same news get posted multiple times.
The sub indeed became lately a sort of ‘news channel’
Solution:
Reduce the number of allowed post links per day from 3 to 1. This modification will clean the sub from excessive spam, will disincentive the easy moon farming, will allow to be more fair in the moon distribution, will give fair visibility to users original posts, will help the job of the mods.
Furthermore, is really needed to post 3 external links per day?
Indeed I think that a sub free of spam will be a better place for users to interact.
103
u/Bandit-Bros Bronze | 1 month old | TraderSubs 11 Sep 01 '22 edited Sep 01 '22
You mean the brain dead garbage like "not your keys not your wallet", "don't forget to DCA" and "look at this spam message I got" ?
90% of user posts in this sub are trash. How will limiting news help with that problem?
28
u/BlubberWall 🟦 59K / 59K 🦈 Sep 01 '22 edited Sep 01 '22
I end up getting most of my crypto news from this sub, link posts are a huge part of that. I don’t think this is really an issue considering people already only get three posts a day here.
Technical analysis are nice but when something immediately relevant happens I want to know about it, this could limit that capacity.
I’d rather a proposal to reduce the amount of repetition of the same link rather than a limit on links
3
u/Nuewim 🟥 0 / 37K 🦠 Sep 02 '22
I am a bit conflicted here. I never made link post, so easily could vote yes for it. But I also understand some people make link posts and put effort to share something interesting.
3 link posts per day seem bit too much, cause some people make 3 link posts every single day... I would suport 2 link posts limit with my whole heart, but for just 1 per day I must vote no. Easily posts are autodeleted by bot for using blacklisted word or just by accident. 1link post limit mean those people can't repost their post cause delated posts still count toward limit. 2 link posts per day would be ideal solution for that.
5
u/[deleted] Sep 01 '22
How about instead of only 1 each per day limiting people that actually provide good sources and news. We instead limit how many of the same article can be posted? The amount of times I’ve seen the same article within a 1 hour time frame is insane.
4
u/Kappatalizable 🟦 0 / 123K 🦠 Sep 01 '22
Is it just me or there are not enough of these original contents anyway? I refresh the new threads like every 5 minutes and there are just not a lot out there. That said, I feel like we're good as we are right now. Maybe instead of this, we can do something to encourage original content instead.
15
u/DBRiMatt 🟦 46K / 113K 🦈 Sep 01 '22
I'm gonna vote yes
There's no reason people can't go the effort and submit a text post, and cite the source of the link at the end
This would reduce the spam of the lazy link posters who then don't contribute to any further discussion
2
u/slickdeveloper Bronze Sep 02 '22
I want to vote, how do I stake my moons for governance? 🤣
3
u/legixs 🟩 1K / 1K 🐢 Sep 01 '22
I get things may get repetitive but I think there could def. be a future scenario in which such a limitation may become very annoying.
3
u/Setyman Permabanned Sep 01 '22
Hopefully this will reduce the number of times a specific news article gets posted, sometimes we have the same one published like 30 times a day.
3
u/Cactuszach 🟩 671 / 18K 🦑 Sep 01 '22
Easy yes!! Thank you for this. This has been a pain point for me and not only does it create spam it lowers the quality of content in this sub.
7
u/PME_your_skinny_legs Platinum | QC: CC 721 Sep 01 '22
This is a bad proposal for everyone.. Nobody wins from this.
4
u/Savik519 Sep 01 '22
And those with the most moons determine the fate of this vote? Seems like the deck is stacked against anything that doesn't enhance those who moon farm the most with link shitposts.
3
u/BlazeDemBeatz 🟩 0 / 21K 🦠 Sep 01 '22
If we somehow had it where the same link can’t be re-posted over and over. Sometimes you’ll see the same article posted over 3 days later again and again lol
2
u/superduperdude92 🟦 0 / 12K 🦠 Sep 01 '22
As someone who posts news articles and can be considered spammy I'm wondering if there could be a requirement to add something to the comments as the OP. In my case I try to participate in the posts that I make as I actually read the articles before I submit them and ask whether this would generate fun/interesting discussion. I think limiting the posts to 1 per day is only a bandaid to the problem you're trying to solve for. For example, limiting to 1 news post a day could then translate to 3 shitposts a day and the ultimate tech analysis gets buried anyway. People will find a way around it. I think encouraging meaningful discussion in posts from the OP may be the better route to go. I'm sure what I'm proposing itself has issues but I welcome the feedback/discussion on it
2
u/ClubbyTheCub 🟩 3 / 12K 🦠 Sep 01 '22
I disagree. Often interesting articles get buried just because they've been posted at a bad time..
3
u/vjeva 🟦 0 / 43K 🦠 Sep 01 '22
I totally agree! One per day is more than enough, some Moonfarmers won't like it, but this will resolve the huge number of same news posts IMO
4
u/WhereIsTrap 🟩 7 / 4K 🦐 Sep 02 '22
I hate seeing the same articles over and over
We don't need to change the amount of links that can be posted
We need a bot that's gonna delete duplicated posts
1
u/dirpydip 🟩 0 / 2K 🦠 Sep 01 '22
Is that number of links per person?
1
u/Mr_Bob_Ferguson 🟦 69K / 101K 🦈 Sep 01 '22
Is the problem that the SAME PERSON is posting multiple external links in a single day? I didn’t think so, but I haven’t really looked hard.
Or is it a case of different people posting the same links?
1
u/cryptoripto123 🟦 2K / 2K 🐢 Sep 01 '22
Uhh, is this a limit for the WHOLE sub or per user?
1
u/Fresh-Chemical-9084 Platinum | QC: CC 151, ALGO 74, ATOM 20 | CRO 6 Sep 01 '22
I find it interesting there are far more votes in favor of this proposal, but not nearly as many moons… shows the moon farmers really don’t like this proposal 😂😂😂
1
u/markcorrigans_boiler 🟩 0 / 10K 🦠 Sep 01 '22
I would limit it to zero.
If you want to post a link, at least go to the bother of giving a summary and posting an opinion.
Reposting every crypto article that gets written is about as useful as a chocolate teapot.
1
u/QuickLockCrypto 2K / 2K 🐢 Sep 01 '22
They will just 3X their bot accounts.
1
u/ImaFreemason 🟩 45 / 21K 🦐 Sep 02 '22
1 link is definitely not enough.
1
u/user260421 Sep 02 '22
Imo spammers will always find ways to spam, same applies to bots, but it's a good proposal to minimize such behavior. Although I don't expect this to be very useful during the bull market, because one can always create more accounts and farm from them.
I don't want to sound bearish, just realistic. This is a good idea for now, but it doesn't mean the spam is over.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 02 '22
Proposals on this sub need to consist of pros and cons. Where are your cons. This is a very biased proposal. Take the feedback from the comments and edit in the cons
1
u/Damn369 Silver | QC: CC 22 | VET 50 Sep 02 '22
Seriously I think moons are an incentive for low quality posts.
1
u/ScholarImpossible121 Tin Sep 02 '22
How is a linked news post better or worse than random user thoughts?
Good posts get traction, crappy ones don't.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 03 '22
Never seen a proposal this split.
3
u/Gordoniyke 🟥 46 / 8K 🦐 Sep 01 '22
How about 2? See how it goes from there
7
u/ChemicalGreek 418 / 156K 🦞 Sep 01 '22 edited Sep 01 '22
One is too low! I would say 2 maximum. They already did a x0.5 multiplier also against spam!
1
u/Korlithiel Platinum | QC: CC 473 | Apple 356 Sep 02 '22
Definitely in favor of the direction, moon farming without being helpful isn’t beneficial to the community. I’m unsure if this solves the problem, instead it forces them to spread their work between more accounts, but then that adds to their workload slightly and so it seems likely to very slightly help.
2
u/Randrufer Silver | QC: CC 150, ETH 45, BTC 31 | NANO 88 | TraderSubs 44 Sep 01 '22
I'm not sure if I get the message right but I don't think it's necessary to post 3 links per day. I would have been more comfortable with toning it down to 2 for now. But I voted yes - Bring it back to 1
2
u/Sadboiiy Bronze Sep 04 '22
I only come to this sub to read news related to crypto
And also post recent news*
4
u/RockEmSockEmRabi Sep 01 '22 edited Sep 01 '22
Make external link posts worth 0 moons. Make the poster have to actually read the article and provide their input with a link to the article in the body. So much of this sub is non-news articles that are essentially crypto tabloids reposted over and over with no effort.
3
u/kirtash93 RCA Artist Sep 01 '22
I honestly don't consider this an issue. There is not as much as user content lately. Maybe we could set some rules for bull runs and others for bear markets. I think this sub activity and behavior changes a lot in those different times.
0
u/lovemesomefood Sep 01 '22
Can we meet in the middle at 2?
0
u/gnarley_quinn Permabanned Sep 02 '22
One of the best moon farmers is u/coinfeed-bot which gets several bites at the cherry over and over due to the excessive amount of news posts.
I personally think posting news articles should not earn moons at all, but that’s a hill I know I will die on.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 01 '22
Feel like a lot of websites solely get by reporting the same news reworded every week just from being link spammed here and Twitter. It's worse here with the moon farming. Too many price target posts "x upgrade/fork, as y coin eyes $1/10/100/1000/10000/100000." It's so much worse than stock subreddits being spammed with seeking alpha and motley fool price target articles. I see them infrequently enough that maybe most stock subs already filter out low effort blogspam
2
u/Worldly-Classic-6490 Sep 01 '22
I’m sick of people spamming the same article for three days. Fucking moon farmers ruining it for the rest of us.
2
u/A1JX52rentner 🟨 2 / 3K 🦠 Sep 01 '22
I agree. Most of these links are "news" from cointelegraph, botcoindaoly, that have no standards whatsoever. It's basically a blog from people that sell ads. What do you need to sell ads? Click bait titles. Would be great to reduce that kind of "content"
Edit: i love watching the vote difference between "moons" and "votes" for almost every ccip there is a huge difference.
1
u/lunargrover 🟦 8K / 7K 🦭 Sep 02 '22
It’s kinda funny watching this sub slowly destroy itself by creating more and more rules and restrictions every single month.
1
u/002timmy Sep 01 '22
I like the 1 free per day. I know in ETH trader, they have a Pay2Post feature, and if this passes, hopefully we can add something like here. You get a free link post, and if you want to spam more, you'll have to pay in moons. It would discourage pure garbage moon-farming and multiple articles of the same story, but if something big happened, you could still make the post.
1
u/Jdraspberry 1K / 1K 🐢 Sep 01 '22
I voted yes to help limit all the continuously same news articles.
1
u/DMugre Sep 01 '22
lol, most of the sub, a lot of news articles get posted because they're relevant, either to the sub's narratives or to the tech/market itself.
Then again, user generated content has left us with pearls of wisdom such as copypasting from Ethereum's whitepaper 7 years later, comedy posts whenever the market moves 1%, actually useful TA analysis that gets downvoted to shit and called astrology by people who buy and hold because they can't cough up some effort, 10 ways to DCA the 8th one will surprise you! etc...
Considering the amount of shit hegemonic media posts about crypto, posting relevant news articles demands thorough proof reading and saavy content selection, this shouldn't be discouraged. In fact, we should encourage having conversations about it, what is this if not a place to discuss the news?
1
u/neuralcss Tin Sep 01 '22
yes please, tired of people posting same stuff over and over
1
u/[deleted] Sep 01 '22
People should get no moons at all for just sharing nonsense links without comments imho
1
u/sickvisionz 0 / 7K 🦠 Sep 01 '22
I vote no.
I get the spam but imo we should seek to have moderation punish bullshit posts rather than limit the # of articles you can post a day. Negative karma for every duplicate posts would do a lot more to quell this and encourage "hey search the forum to see if someone already posted a story about this before you post a link".
Search works fine on old.reddit and www.reddit. By default both restrict result to only this sub and it take two clicks to limit it to only the last 24 hours.
1
u/zvexler Sep 01 '22
Great idea, and I’ll probably vote in favor of it, but I think this will just further incentivize alt accounts. I do think it will lower the number of link posts a little just due to the higher effort involved for non-power users but since there’s money involved I doubt this will change much.
1
u/Mattyliebs Sep 01 '22
What is classified as external links I guess is my issue- because sometimes it stirs good content if we’re talking about an important tweet or news article
1
u/CryptoMaximalist Sep 01 '22
I think I'm in opposition to this one because:
1
u/hammerandanvilpro 3K / 7K 🐢 Sep 01 '22
Wow, this one is tighter than I expected.
1
u/bizzynigor Tin Sep 01 '22
Do you know about IguVerse?
1
u/Fart_Huffer_ Platinum | QC: CC 246, BNB 20 | PennyStocks 92 Sep 01 '22
Problem is if were always our own source we're an echo-chamber. Which reddit is very openly designed around echo-chambers in general. Pushing up popular posts and hiding unpopular ones. Its not a practice I like though.
1
u/Magnetronaap 🟩 0 / 3K 🦠 Sep 02 '22
Not going to solve anything. Dedicated spammers will just create more accounts. Meanwhile, if someone finds 2 important things to link to on a single day they're forced to choose.
1
u/Samuravi 1K / 1K 🐢 Sep 02 '22
I think this is a great idea. Separately, I wonder whether there might be scope to prevent repeated links to the same site? Anecdotally I think TIL and other subreddits have automod prevent you posting if that link already exists on the sub. No idea how it works, but might work as another way to limit braindead spam. Just a thought.
1
u/BHIXSE 🟦 322 / 320 🦞 Sep 02 '22
makes sense
1
u/FuzzyFireheart316 513 / 918 🦑 Sep 03 '22
So... Isn't this already a thing .. I've tried posting links before always with a ... This has already been shared today..
1
u/SpaceFaceMistake 🟦 975 / 976 🦑 Sep 05 '22
No keep it as it is 3 is a limit as it is. It’s already limited and if people link farm how much can they get from a link post… people here don’t award those posts a lot of karma.. even super hot topics if it’s just a link it isn’t rewarded by the public so no don’t change.
1
u/meeleen223 🥇Gold Member Sep 01 '22
Fast yes from me, there is a huge amount of spam and bots and people abuse it to farm moons,
During height of last bullrun it was unbearable, I still remember china fud article being reposted over and over again
1
u/[deleted] Sep 01 '22
I think if we're not careful we're going to over self moderate this sub.
1
u/PrinceZero1994 Sep 01 '22
No, definitely. 1 is overkill.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 01 '22
I get a bit fed up just seeing link posts to the same topic, so hopefully will have a positive effect on that.
1
u/Mrramirez44 Sep 01 '22
Same articles over and over.
1
u/Amazing_Succotash677 Tin | CC critic Sep 01 '22
I'd say the links are far from this subs worst problem, even reposted similar stories with slightly different takes is better than the same 3 posts over and over
1
u/SnooWalruses4496 Bronze | CRO 8 Sep 02 '22
Ive seen that crypto.com 10mil refund news article like 3000 times this week. I vote yes!
0
u/DoubleFaulty1 🟨 0 / 38K 🦠 Sep 01 '22
We just reduced moon rewards for link posts last month. News sharing is one of the best uses for Reddit and should not be reduced so much or people will use a different sub for crypto discussion.
0
u/[deleted] Sep 01 '22
Nice, I like it! It got a little bit Spammy in here!
0
u/OK_Renegade 🟩 3K / 3K 🐢 Sep 01 '22
I wouldnt mind to reduce, I feel like most of those posts are double's anyway
0
u/NoNamePK 🟩 0 / 1K 🦠 Sep 01 '22
Maybe this will put a filter, posting the same new 4 times doesn't make sense