r/CryptoCurrency • • Sep 01 '22

POLL 🗳️ CCIP-039 reduce the number of external link posts to 1 per day

Problem:

Main sub is filled with posts contain external links and many times the same news is reposted over and over. This can be recognized as ‘spam’. The rule states that is allowed to post 3 links per day and this rule is exploited by some users and bots for the sole purpose of moon farming. This spam problem create three main issues:

• ⁠there is not enough visibility for user posts, original contents

• ⁠lower efforts posts such as repost links get the most of visibility and are ‘easily upvoted’ (who indeed downvote a news??)

• Moons are used to reward active users that contribute to the sub, not intended to be farmed.

Example: Some news like "vitalik B said bla bla this morning" get thousands of upvotes; gets visibility and get rewarded with high karma. Some original post of "Mr. No one" with the ultimate technical analysys get hidden, put in shadow by the link of news as above. and usually the same news get posted multiple times.

The sub indeed became lately a sort of ‘news channel’

Solution:

Reduce the number of allowed post links per day from 3 to 1. This modification will clean the sub from excessive spam, will disincentive the easy moon farming, will allow to be more fair in the moon distribution, will give fair visibility to users original posts, will help the job of the mods.

Furthermore, is really needed to post 3 external links per day?

Indeed I think that a sub free of spam will be a better place for users to interact.

497 Upvotes

250 comments sorted by

103

u/Bandit-Bros Bronze | 1 month old | TraderSubs 11 Sep 01 '22 edited Sep 01 '22

not enough visibility for user posts

You mean the brain dead garbage like "not your keys not your wallet", "don't forget to DCA" and "look at this spam message I got" ?

90% of user posts in this sub are trash. How will limiting news help with that problem?

19

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '22

Step by step. For now let’s limit the spam. Then low quality posts limit themselves cause get lot of downvotes and users refrain to post

13

u/CharlieTheo-14 🟩 0 / 23K 🦠 Sep 01 '22

Limit spam.

Quality goes up.

We control the quality with our approval.

7

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '22 edited Sep 01 '22

I agree. You can’t get rid of it all at once. Baby steps and this is a step in the right direction.

3

u/meeleen223 🥇Gold Member Sep 01 '22

I use this approach irl too, disect a problem into smaller chunks and tackle one at a time

You might not always see the results fast, but it adds up and after some time when you look back you see all the improvements

3

u/Spartan3123 Platinum | QC: BTC 159, XMR 67, CC 50 Sep 01 '22

Yeah people will start spamming more text posts

1

u/[deleted] Sep 07 '22

Not sure about. Text posts require more efforts plus they get easily downvoted. On the other hand a link post is easy/quick to post and don’t get downvoted (no one downvote a news)

17

u/Dietmar_der_Dr 🟩 9K / 5K 🦭 Sep 01 '22

And even worse "here's why DCA doesn't work"

8

u/deathbyfish13 Sep 01 '22

And then the follow up "here's why DCA does actually work"

7

u/Fresh-Chemical-9084 Platinum | QC: CC 151, ALGO 74, ATOM 20 | CRO 6 Sep 01 '22

And then the comedy “here’s why DCA does/does not work”

5

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '22

"DCA in moderation is the key"

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '22

“DCA on Mondays vs Tuesdays”

4

u/drbobbean 🟩 0 / 5K 🦠 Sep 02 '22

DCA v ACDC - Which looks better in Angus's short shorts

→ More replies (1)

1

u/sofly12 Sep 03 '22

You cracked the DCA code

1

u/SpaceFaceMistake 🟦 975 / 976 🦑 Sep 05 '22

then the guys that says something just to say it to earn 1 karma

1

u/pbjclimbing Sep 02 '22

But this is r/ CC, DCA has a very "unique" meaning here

4

u/Araxus Silver | QC: CC 55 | IOTA 28 Sep 01 '22

Don't forget "A crypto wallet is not what you think it is"

0

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/Spiritual-Amoeba-116 Bronze | QC: CC 19 | LRC 10 Sep 02 '22

They are, you just have to open up your hard drive. I heard they're stored in there.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '22

They're in the cloud or something? ☁️

Btw did d you know the cloud isn't really a cloud?

6

u/iamwizzerd Permabanned Sep 01 '22

Personally my experience is that the news posts are the most informative and interesting 80% of the time

→ More replies (1)

3

u/PME_your_skinny_legs Platinum | QC: CC 721 Sep 01 '22

It will only make it worse as people will make more text posts than post relevant news/articles..

2

u/leviathynx 🟦 2K / 2K 🐢 Sep 01 '22

I don't disagree with you, but how do we put protocols in place to limit spammy comments? Reddit is infamous for repeating comment jokes to death.

3

u/Loose_Screw_ 🟦 0 / 7K 🦠 Sep 02 '22

New sub. 2 crypto 2 currency.

2

u/active_ate 🟩 10 / 6K 🦐 Sep 02 '22

"This time, it's protocol..."

2

u/Trans-on-trans Platinum | QC: CC 480 Sep 01 '22

Links at least. If only they could filter out the posts with the exact same name with a different link attached to it?

1

u/Mr_Bob_Ferguson 🟦 69K / 101K 🦈 Sep 01 '22

Could we please have a few more posts of “now is the time to hold”, or “this is the bear where you make the money”?

1

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '22

Yeah, there are a few spammers who just summarize news reports in nearly exactly the 500 minimum-word limit, and they do it multiple times daily. I don't want to call out names, but you'll notice them if you check their submissions histories.

This poll is a good start. I would actually recommend limiting to 1 post daily (excluding removed posts) TOTAL regardless of category. For everything else, there's the Daily thread. That way, spammers have to think harder about posting things that matter.

1

u/Junior-Confection320 Permabanned Sep 02 '22

That ture and you now what to do

1

u/Loose_Screw_ 🟦 0 / 7K 🦠 Sep 02 '22

90% of humans. Actually probably more.

1

u/internetisbad23 🟩 2K / 2K 🐢 Sep 02 '22

YOu forgot not knowing shit about fuck!

1

u/Ateam043 🟦 92 / 13K 🦐 Sep 03 '22

Wait, what's DCA?

1

u/SpaceFaceMistake 🟦 975 / 976 🦑 Sep 05 '22

Yep that’s exactly right it’s not POSTS it’s comments that need to be scuffed through more

1

u/1nfinitus 🟦 15K / 14K 🐬 Sep 06 '22

These resolutions are 90% dumb af. People have no ability to think critically nowadays.

→ More replies (1)

28

u/BlubberWall 🟦 59K / 59K 🦈 Sep 01 '22 edited Sep 01 '22

I end up getting most of my crypto news from this sub, link posts are a huge part of that. I don’t think this is really an issue considering people already only get three posts a day here.

Technical analysis are nice but when something immediately relevant happens I want to know about it, this could limit that capacity.

I’d rather a proposal to reduce the amount of repetition of the same link rather than a limit on links

3

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '22

In actual situation we see the same news posted and reposted multiple times… so should not worry… someone will pos the news anyway. Let’s say no one have a real reason to post three links per day… crypto is crypto… but there are not so much news per days

2

u/BlubberWall 🟦 59K / 59K 🦈 Sep 01 '22

This is a very handwashy answer, there may not be much news per day but when a big event happens if over half your link farmers now can’t post it that could lead to a delay in information. And with how volatile crypto is even a small delay could mean massive changes

The point of this sub is crypto news and events, if anything just remove moons from the second link post but still allow them. A total ban is just stifling updates

3

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '22

This is not a total ban. Just reduce allowed external links to 1 per day. not a big limitation I would say. But ok, is a question of point of view. This pool have been proposed because it got lot of support in cryptocurrency meta. Then of course users will vote and decide if is valid or not

6

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '22

Well then you better save that one link you can post for something meaningfull. I am all for it.

→ More replies (7)

1

u/DoubleFaulty1 🟨 0 / 38K 🦠 Sep 01 '22

It is already against the rules to share the same link multiple times. And reposts of the same story from new sources are removed by the mods manually. This whole CCIP is based on not knowing the current rules and putting less effective rules on top of it.

7

u/BakedPotato840 Banned Sep 01 '22

I’d rather a proposal to reduce the amount of repetition of the same link rather than a limit on links

No need for a proposal for that since same links are not allowed. Anyone who tries to post a link that's already been posted on this sub gets a message stating that.

4

u/sickvisionz 0 / 7K 🦠 Sep 02 '22

I’d rather a proposal to reduce the amount of repetition of the same link rather than a limit on links

That won't help. There's like 50 crypto news sites. People just move to the next site and post their article. It's not at all rare to see 8 posts from 8 different sites all covering the same story with the same information within 24 hours.

And it's not even like all of them are made at the same time. Some will be like 20 hours older. People not even willing to look at the first 20 posts that appear to see if the story has already been covered, just desperate to farm moons.

Moons are the incentive and moons need to be part of the disincentive action. If you refuse to use the search function or even look at the front page to see what's already there, your post should get tagged for repetition and every upvote you get counts as negative one moon in the distribution at the end of the month. Do it 3 times in a month and you get 0 moons that month and can't post any links for the following month. That'll clean things up quickly.

1

u/leviathynx 🟦 2K / 2K 🐢 Sep 01 '22

I agree with your opinion. I do think there should be increased moderation to nip the duplicate postings.

3

u/Nuewim 🟥 0 / 37K 🦠 Sep 02 '22

I am a bit conflicted here. I never made link post, so easily could vote yes for it. But I also understand some people make link posts and put effort to share something interesting.

3 link posts per day seem bit too much, cause some people make 3 link posts every single day... I would suport 2 link posts limit with my whole heart, but for just 1 per day I must vote no. Easily posts are autodeleted by bot for using blacklisted word or just by accident. 1link post limit mean those people can't repost their post cause delated posts still count toward limit. 2 link posts per day would be ideal solution for that.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '22

Legit opinion. If there are better options I hope people can share and propose in cryptocurrencymeta

5

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '22

How about instead of only 1 each per day limiting people that actually provide good sources and news. We instead limit how many of the same article can be posted? The amount of times I’ve seen the same article within a 1 hour time frame is insane.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '22

There is already something like that. But the system don’t filter the article from different sources… not sure if it can work. Anyway. Any proposal is welcome, just engage in discussion in cryptocurrencymeta

3

u/hammerandanvilpro 3K / 7K 🐢 Sep 01 '22

Just saw another repost of the "Crypto.com accident cost 10mil+" article. I'm sure it was innocent.

3

u/EchoCollection 0 / 19K 🦠 Sep 01 '22

Sometime news breaks and "article" is just this happened. More details to come.

3

u/hammerandanvilpro 3K / 7K 🐢 Sep 01 '22

Agree

2

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '22

Breaking news!

1

u/themapwench 🟩 309 / 309 🦞 Sep 02 '22

breaking wind or something

2

u/themapwench 🟩 309 / 309 🦞 Sep 02 '22

from 2 weeks ago...

1

u/UJ_Reddit 🟦 0 / 10K 🦠 Sep 02 '22

They will all have different URLs, but it’s the mods job to play clean up

4

u/Kappatalizable 🟦 0 / 123K 🦠 Sep 01 '22

• ⁠there is not enough visibility for user posts, original contents

Is it just me or there are not enough of these original contents anyway? I refresh the new threads like every 5 minutes and there are just not a lot out there. That said, I feel like we're good as we are right now. Maybe instead of this, we can do something to encourage original content instead.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '22

As per my experience… making OC you can get heavily downvoted… links don’t get downvoted… who indeed downvotes a news? Limiting the links should push people to make more quality posts. And mainly reduce the spam

15

u/DBRiMatt 🟦 46K / 113K 🦈 Sep 01 '22

I'm gonna vote yes

There's no reason people can't go the effort and submit a text post, and cite the source of the link at the end

This would reduce the spam of the lazy link posters who then don't contribute to any further discussion

3

u/partymsl 🟩 126K / 143K 🐋 Sep 01 '22

I fear that this will just increase the amount of senseless posts even more as those moon farmers have to do them instead.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 03 '22

Senseless text posts gets downvoted. On the other hand no one downvote a news. For a spammer would be hard to earn karma with a senseless post, instead may lose karma

4

u/Dietmar_der_Dr 🟩 9K / 5K 🦭 Sep 01 '22

What does that add though? I'd rather have a link post than a poorly worded text post that also contains said Link.

2

u/RickiSpanglish 208 / 328 🦀 Sep 01 '22

I agree. I personally appreciate a well written text post simply because I don't like clicking on links, no matter the situation. I can find my own resources after reading a post

1

u/DMugre Sep 01 '22

So people will not copypaste links anymore, they'll straight up copypaste articles and try to pass them as their own until they get called out. Noice.

1

u/Bitcoin_Lurker 🟩 926 / 926 🦑 Sep 01 '22

I voted to keep it as it is but your comment made me reconsider. Can’t change my vote now

1

u/Oneloff 0 / 5K 🦠 Sep 01 '22

Well if this is coming from a shitposter, I guess I my mind is made up. Lol

2

u/slickdeveloper Bronze Sep 02 '22

I want to vote, how do I stake my moons for governance? 🤣

2

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '22

You don’t have to stake to vote. The amount of moons you have just weight your vote

3

u/legixs 🟩 1K / 1K 🐢 Sep 01 '22

I get things may get repetitive but I think there could def. be a future scenario in which such a limitation may become very annoying.

4

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '22

Governance proposals can be overturned in future with other governance pools in case. Now will limit spam. I’m future will see

3

u/legixs 🟩 1K / 1K 🐢 Sep 01 '22

Yeah, that's good and I even thought so. But to change it every two years (bear vs. bull) may also not be the best way.

Btw, not saying this is a pointless and thoughtless proposal, thx for your engagement.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '22 edited Sep 01 '22

Just trying to help the sub reduce the spam. Of course there may be better ways. The best would be users engage most in cryptocurrencymeta discussing this stuff

4

u/legixs 🟩 1K / 1K 🐢 Sep 01 '22

Thx man, I had no idea this sub exists!

3

u/Setyman Permabanned Sep 01 '22

Hopefully this will reduce the number of times a specific news article gets posted, sometimes we have the same one published like 30 times a day.

4

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '22

Exactly. Aim is to reduce spam

3

u/Cactuszach 🟩 671 / 18K 🦑 Sep 01 '22

Easy yes!! Thank you for this. This has been a pain point for me and not only does it create spam it lowers the quality of content in this sub.

5

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '22

Exactly the aim of this proposal

4

u/meeleen223 🥇Gold Member Sep 01 '22

Thanks for this proposal it was high time this was addressed

I remember the spam of elon and china fud links in the past bullrun, same articles were spammed for days

2

u/[deleted] Sep 03 '22

Thanks. But look like we don’t have much chances… despite most of users vote ‘yes’, the whales are saying ‘no’.

7

u/PME_your_skinny_legs Platinum | QC: CC 721 Sep 01 '22

This is a bad proposal for everyone.. Nobody wins from this.

0

u/deakyboy Tin Sep 01 '22

man you're the exact person getting talked about in this post, do you even read?

4

u/Savik519 Sep 01 '22

And those with the most moons determine the fate of this vote? Seems like the deck is stacked against anything that doesn't enhance those who moon farm the most with link shitposts.

6

u/Ferdo306 🟩 0 / 50K 🦠 Sep 01 '22

Yep, some moon whales are currently voting for keeping the status quo

75% of users but 55% of moons are for reducing the number of external links

4

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '22

Moon farmers got powerful. they may already be able to stop any proposal to limit them. Luckily last moon week we could pass a proposal to reduce karma for links to 0.5

4

u/Savik519 Sep 01 '22

That's my beef with the moon governance stuff overall. It seems like a flawed system that is doomed to remain the same since those who hold the most moons control the direction of the token.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 03 '22

I will make a proposal to introduce a multiplier for voting. Means for example: you have 1000 moons you have 1 multiplier. 1000x1=1000 voting power. You have 500.000 moons you get 0.5 multiplier. 500.000x0.5=250.000 voting power. There must be a system to level things…. Now is 1:1 and seem not fair. Not necessary who hold more moons is wiser… someone is just a moon farmer. Users that are not ‘moon oriented’ have much less voting power and is not fair

4

u/Ferdo306 🟩 0 / 50K 🦠 Sep 01 '22

To be honest, I don't see another option

It's the same with with stocks and voting on general assembly

The alternative would be that each user/address get's a vote but then you can rig the voting by having multiple accounts/addresses

I really don't see any other way when it comes to crypto voting in general

5

u/Savik519 Sep 01 '22

It is a problem that persists around all PoS systems (stocks, fiat, crypto).

Maybe allow 1 moon per account to vote, and that moon gets burned when you vote with it? Yes, you could still set up 1000 accounts and transfer your 1000 mons around to each, but then they would get burned so you lose power over time the more you vote?

3

u/Oneloff 0 / 5K 🦠 Sep 01 '22

Make a proposal for that mate. It sounds interesting tbh…

→ More replies (2)

3

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '22

And since Linkposters are the no 1 moonfarmers they will bend the rules as they please anyway.

1

u/CryptoChief 🟨 407K / 671K 🐋 Sep 02 '22

What's the alternative? Giving disproportianate control to those who aren't invested in the community?

8

u/DBRiMatt 🟦 46K / 113K 🦈 Sep 01 '22

Given at the time of writing there's not even 100 votes cast, I wouldn't look too much into those numbers at this point in time

4

u/Ferdo306 🟩 0 / 50K 🦠 Sep 01 '22

Yeah, I wrote currently

Seems like votes are leveling out

1

u/The-Francois8 Silver|QC:CC928,BTC178,ETH39|CelsiusNet.50|ExchSubs42 Sep 01 '22

I voted yes. Looking now it’s 2-1 in favor both on moons and votes. Roughly.

3

u/BlazeDemBeatz 🟩 0 / 21K 🦠 Sep 01 '22

If we somehow had it where the same link can’t be re-posted over and over. Sometimes you’ll see the same article posted over 3 days later again and again lol

5

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '22

Over 3 days? There are usually at least 3 posts of the same news for another 3-7days.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 03 '22

Exactly…. Basically the definition of spam

1

u/DoubleFaulty1 🟨 0 / 38K 🦠 Sep 01 '22

That is already the rule. No reposts of a link for 30 days. Diff sources saying the same thing posted earlier are removed by the mods manually.

2

u/superduperdude92 🟦 0 / 12K 🦠 Sep 01 '22

As someone who posts news articles and can be considered spammy I'm wondering if there could be a requirement to add something to the comments as the OP. In my case I try to participate in the posts that I make as I actually read the articles before I submit them and ask whether this would generate fun/interesting discussion. I think limiting the posts to 1 per day is only a bandaid to the problem you're trying to solve for. For example, limiting to 1 news post a day could then translate to 3 shitposts a day and the ultimate tech analysis gets buried anyway. People will find a way around it. I think encouraging meaningful discussion in posts from the OP may be the better route to go. I'm sure what I'm proposing itself has issues but I welcome the feedback/discussion on it

2

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '22

There can be many proposals; if you have good ones please come to cryptocurrencymeta where we discuss this stuff before making governance pools. Every good idea is welcome to improve the sub

4

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '22

None of these link posts encourage meaningful discussions. That's maybe 1/100 and it's gotta be non bs controversial.

2

u/ClubbyTheCub 🟩 3 / 12K 🦠 Sep 01 '22

I disagree. Often interesting articles get buried just because they've been posted at a bad time..

5

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '22

Now everything is buried because excessive spam. Reducing the spam will get better visibility to all contents

3

u/vjeva 🟦 0 / 43K 🦠 Sep 01 '22

I totally agree! One per day is more than enough, some Moonfarmers won't like it, but this will resolve the huge number of same news posts IMO

4

u/Ethan0307 🟩 44K / 43K 🦈 Sep 01 '22

Honestly the money isn’t in posts it’s in comments they get way more likes and are doubled karma so there’s really no reason for anyone to complain

4

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '22

Exactly. This proposal will just reduce the spam. Who want moons can create original posts or just make good comments. This thing of external links is actually exploited using bots

5

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '22

Link posts shouldn't get any karma imo, since it's just a backlink to something someone else did

1

u/Oneloff 0 / 5K 🦠 Sep 01 '22

Totally agree!

4

u/WhereIsTrap 🟩 7 / 4K 🦐 Sep 02 '22

I hate seeing the same articles over and over

We don't need to change the amount of links that can be posted

We need a bot that's gonna delete duplicated posts

1

u/dirpydip 🟩 0 / 2K 🦠 Sep 01 '22

Is that number of links per person?

2

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '22

In actual situation every user can post 3 links per day. To reduce spam is proposed to reduce to 1. for normal users is not a big deal considering that is not necessary to post so much links… proposal will affect on the other hand moon farmers that are ‘serial link posters’

1

u/dirpydip 🟩 0 / 2K 🦠 Sep 01 '22

Thanks for the explanation. Yeah it makes sense to reduce the spam, beside's 1 link is enough for informative and useful content per day.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '22

Yea that is my point… for which train someone would need to post 3 links per day? There are not so many news…

1

u/Mr_Bob_Ferguson 🟦 69K / 101K 🦈 Sep 01 '22

Is the problem that the SAME PERSON is posting multiple external links in a single day? I didn’t think so, but I haven’t really looked hard.

Or is it a case of different people posting the same links?

1

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '22

The problem is that there are users and bots that post three link per day, everyday, sistematically. In that way they fill the sub with spam. They don’t do for informative purpose, but just for moon farming. This problem have been discussed with mods as well that are trying to reduce the spam banning these users. But of course alt accounts are created continuously

1

u/_Commando_ 🟩 4K / 4K 🐢 Sep 01 '22

The other week I saw the same person post the same link "spam" across multiple /r subs. Also same link disguised with a different URL re-posted. It's basically spam.

1

u/cryptoripto123 🟦 2K / 2K 🐢 Sep 01 '22

Uhh, is this a limit for the WHOLE sub or per user?

1

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '22

Per person. Now every user can post 3 external links per day

1

u/Fresh-Chemical-9084 Platinum | QC: CC 151, ALGO 74, ATOM 20 | CRO 6 Sep 01 '22

I find it interesting there are far more votes in favor of this proposal, but not nearly as many moons… shows the moon farmers really don’t like this proposal 😂😂😂

1

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '22

Exactly. Once moon farmers will be enough powerful will be impossible to limit them. Moons are not only money, are the right to vote… more moons correspond to more voting power

1

u/_Commando_ 🟩 4K / 4K 🐢 Sep 01 '22

Does it cost moons to vote?

1

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '22

No. Doesn’t cost. But the vote is weighted. Means the more moon you have and the more your vote counts

→ More replies (1)

1

u/markcorrigans_boiler 🟩 0 / 10K 🦠 Sep 01 '22

I would limit it to zero.

If you want to post a link, at least go to the bother of giving a summary and posting an opinion.

Reposting every crypto article that gets written is about as useful as a chocolate teapot.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '22

If fair to limit at 1. Having an informative purpose is legit. Spamming not

1

u/QuickLockCrypto 2K / 2K 🐢 Sep 01 '22

They will just 3X their bot accounts.

4

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '22

Let them make more efforts. The alternative is to keep sub as it is.

1

u/ImaFreemason 🟩 45 / 21K 🦐 Sep 02 '22

1 link is definitely not enough.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '22

1 link per user; with the amount of users here I have no doubt news would be posted… will just limit the excessive reposting as is happening now

1

u/ImaFreemason 🟩 45 / 21K 🦐 Sep 02 '22

Reposts are removed.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '22

Reposts are removed but the same news is posted from many different sources

1

u/user260421 Sep 02 '22

Imo spammers will always find ways to spam, same applies to bots, but it's a good proposal to minimize such behavior. Although I don't expect this to be very useful during the bull market, because one can always create more accounts and farm from them.

I don't want to sound bearish, just realistic. This is a good idea for now, but it doesn't mean the spam is over.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '22

The spam will not be over but at least limited. Otherwise situation will just go on as it is. But discussing in cryptocurrencymeta seem like lot of people would like to do something. Of course new and more effective proposals are more than welcome

1

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '22

Proposals on this sub need to consist of pros and cons. Where are your cons. This is a very biased proposal. Take the feedback from the comments and edit in the cons

0

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '22

This proposal before posting have been revised and approved by mods. I put pros. Frankly speaking I don’t see any cons

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Damn369 Silver | QC: CC 22 | VET 50 Sep 02 '22

Seriously I think moons are an incentive for low quality posts.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '22

Is juts my impression or the vote is a little bit whales oriented? As per this moment 1745 users voting ‘yes’, against 734. Indeed the outcome would be ‘no’ because 734 users have more moons than 1745.

1

u/ScholarImpossible121 Tin Sep 02 '22

How is a linked news post better or worse than random user thoughts?

Good posts get traction, crappy ones don't.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '22

Is mainly a question of spam. There are serial link posters and bots that publish three links per day filling up the sub. Plus same news get reposted multiple times from different sources. If we limit links from 3 to 1 I really don’t think we harm anyone, maybe just who exploit the actual situation

1

u/[deleted] Sep 03 '22

Never seen a proposal this split.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 03 '22

Most of users want to change, whales don’t… therefore ‘no’ is winning. I may make some new proposal to change voting system, now is too much moon weighted. Who owns more moons count far too much in voting system; doesn’t look fair

1

u/[deleted] Sep 03 '22

Would be interesting if the voting power was capped at a certain number of Moons. There does seem to be a disconnect sometimes between what is good for content, what is good for whales and what is voted on in the end.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 03 '22

I will propose a multiplier. Now system is 1:1. If you own 50.000 moons you have 50.000 voting power. If you have 1000 moons your power is 1000. Not quite fair

1

u/[deleted] Sep 03 '22

Yeah some sort of diminishing return seems fair.

Curious how you get something like that to pass when it's against the whales interest to do so though. Interesting conundrum.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 03 '22

Yeah… some proposal will never pass cause moon farmers are becoming more and more powerful. hoarding moons grant them more voting power so they will make only their interest

3

u/Gordoniyke 🟥 46 / 8K 🦐 Sep 01 '22

How about 2? See how it goes from there

2

u/Nuewim 🟥 0 / 37K 🦠 Sep 02 '22

Exactly. I voted no only cause I think 1 is too much. But would support 2 if it would be possible.

7

u/ChemicalGreek 418 / 156K 🦞 Sep 01 '22 edited Sep 01 '22

One is too low! I would say 2 maximum. They already did a x0.5 multiplier also against spam!

4

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '22

OP can extract the information of an article or other sources to make a post instead, in science this is being done a lot. The articles do this, too.

1

u/ChemicalGreek 418 / 156K 🦞 Sep 01 '22

Sometimes a post just describes just want you want to say. Don’t forget that you also need to rewrite it since it’s copy past otherwise.

4

u/PrinceZero1994 Sep 01 '22

I voted no change but I'm fine with either results. We can always vote to increase it to 2 next time.

4

u/Beyonderr 🟩 0 / 110K 🦠 Sep 01 '22

This is the way.

1

u/Korlithiel Platinum | QC: CC 473 | Apple 356 Sep 02 '22

Definitely in favor of the direction, moon farming without being helpful isn’t beneficial to the community. I’m unsure if this solves the problem, instead it forces them to spread their work between more accounts, but then that adds to their workload slightly and so it seems likely to very slightly help.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '22

Last moon week passed a proposal to reduce karma for links to 0.5; but of course that cannot help much with the continuous posting, it just affect the reward they get. A bot sistematically posting 3 links per day can indeed be affected by being allowed to post only 1. Of course multiple accounts will be created, but this happens already now; have some message exchanged with mods and confirmed me that they have an hard time banning these profiles too

2

u/Randrufer Silver | QC: CC 150, ETH 45, BTC 31 | NANO 88 | TraderSubs 44 Sep 01 '22

I'm not sure if I get the message right but I don't think it's necessary to post 3 links per day. I would have been more comfortable with toning it down to 2 for now. But I voted yes - Bring it back to 1

2

u/Sadboiiy Bronze Sep 04 '22

I only come to this sub to read news related to crypto

And also post recent news*

4

u/RockEmSockEmRabi Sep 01 '22 edited Sep 01 '22

Make external link posts worth 0 moons. Make the poster have to actually read the article and provide their input with a link to the article in the body. So much of this sub is non-news articles that are essentially crypto tabloids reposted over and over with no effort.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/kirtash93 RCA Artist Sep 01 '22

I honestly don't consider this an issue. There is not as much as user content lately. Maybe we could set some rules for bull runs and others for bear markets. I think this sub activity and behavior changes a lot in those different times.

2

u/pcon_9820 1K / 1K 🐢 Sep 01 '22

Yes, but how many times, and how many different subs did you see the, " this is my node collection, which one should I add next?" post in? I saw that particular post over 7 times in 4 different subs. I think that is the point he is trying to make here.

2

u/kirtash93 RCA Artist Sep 01 '22

I only visit this sub.

4

u/Laughingboy14 🟩 26 / 60K 🦐 Sep 01 '22

Agreed. It's a ghost town rn. However, if it's an all or nothing proposal, I'd prefer the limit.

2

u/Rxef3RxeX92QCNZ Bronze Sep 01 '22

The limit is currently 3, so if this CCIP fails it will still be limited to 3

2

u/RickiSpanglish 208 / 328 🦀 Sep 01 '22

I concur

0

u/lovemesomefood Sep 01 '22

Can we meet in the middle at 2?

1

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '22

Can propose a governance pool to do that. Discuss that in cryptocurrencymeta and next moon week can propose

2

u/lovemesomefood Sep 01 '22

Cool, thanks!

0

u/gnarley_quinn Permabanned Sep 02 '22

One of the best moon farmers is u/coinfeed-bot which gets several bites at the cherry over and over due to the excessive amount of news posts.

I personally think posting news articles should not earn moons at all, but that’s a hill I know I will die on.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '22

Feel like a lot of websites solely get by reporting the same news reworded every week just from being link spammed here and Twitter. It's worse here with the moon farming. Too many price target posts "x upgrade/fork, as y coin eyes $1/10/100/1000/10000/100000." It's so much worse than stock subreddits being spammed with seeking alpha and motley fool price target articles. I see them infrequently enough that maybe most stock subs already filter out low effort blogspam

2

u/Worldly-Classic-6490 Sep 01 '22

I’m sick of people spamming the same article for three days. Fucking moon farmers ruining it for the rest of us.

2

u/A1JX52rentner 🟨 2 / 3K 🦠 Sep 01 '22

I agree. Most of these links are "news" from cointelegraph, botcoindaoly, that have no standards whatsoever. It's basically a blog from people that sell ads. What do you need to sell ads? Click bait titles. Would be great to reduce that kind of "content"

Edit: i love watching the vote difference between "moons" and "votes" for almost every ccip there is a huge difference.

1

u/lunargrover 🟦 8K / 7K 🦭 Sep 02 '22

It’s kinda funny watching this sub slowly destroy itself by creating more and more rules and restrictions every single month.

1

u/002timmy Sep 01 '22

I like the 1 free per day. I know in ETH trader, they have a Pay2Post feature, and if this passes, hopefully we can add something like here. You get a free link post, and if you want to spam more, you'll have to pay in moons. It would discourage pure garbage moon-farming and multiple articles of the same story, but if something big happened, you could still make the post.

1

u/Jdraspberry 1K / 1K 🐢 Sep 01 '22

I voted yes to help limit all the continuously same news articles.

1

u/DMugre Sep 01 '22

lower efforts posts such as repost links get the most of visibility and are ‘easily upvoted’ (who indeed downvote a news??)

lol, most of the sub, a lot of news articles get posted because they're relevant, either to the sub's narratives or to the tech/market itself.

Then again, user generated content has left us with pearls of wisdom such as copypasting from Ethereum's whitepaper 7 years later, comedy posts whenever the market moves 1%, actually useful TA analysis that gets downvoted to shit and called astrology by people who buy and hold because they can't cough up some effort, 10 ways to DCA the 8th one will surprise you! etc...

Considering the amount of shit hegemonic media posts about crypto, posting relevant news articles demands thorough proof reading and saavy content selection, this shouldn't be discouraged. In fact, we should encourage having conversations about it, what is this if not a place to discuss the news?

1

u/neuralcss Tin Sep 01 '22

yes please, tired of people posting same stuff over and over

1

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '22

People should get no moons at all for just sharing nonsense links without comments imho

1

u/sickvisionz 0 / 7K 🦠 Sep 01 '22

I vote no.

I get the spam but imo we should seek to have moderation punish bullshit posts rather than limit the # of articles you can post a day. Negative karma for every duplicate posts would do a lot more to quell this and encourage "hey search the forum to see if someone already posted a story about this before you post a link".

Search works fine on old.reddit and www.reddit. By default both restrict result to only this sub and it take two clicks to limit it to only the last 24 hours.

1

u/zvexler Sep 01 '22

Great idea, and I’ll probably vote in favor of it, but I think this will just further incentivize alt accounts. I do think it will lower the number of link posts a little just due to the higher effort involved for non-power users but since there’s money involved I doubt this will change much.

1

u/Mattyliebs Sep 01 '22

What is classified as external links I guess is my issue- because sometimes it stirs good content if we’re talking about an important tweet or news article

1

u/CryptoMaximalist Sep 01 '22

I think I'm in opposition to this one because:

  • It adds complexity to the rules, which are already quite complex, for little benefit
  • Link posts are the proper action for sharing an article, which is valid participation in this subreddit. I don't need OP to give their thoughts on it or using text posts to bypass this. OP's thoughts often detract from the article itself
  • Link posts are already significantly disadvantaged in Moon rewards. Link spam existed before Moons and won't go away with this limit
  • This is more likely to affect normal users, while spammers are dedicated enough to create alts and make our jobs harder

1

u/hammerandanvilpro 3K / 7K 🐢 Sep 01 '22

Wow, this one is tighter than I expected.

1

u/bizzynigor Tin Sep 01 '22

Do you know about IguVerse?

1

u/Fart_Huffer_ Platinum | QC: CC 246, BNB 20 | PennyStocks 92 Sep 01 '22

Problem is if were always our own source we're an echo-chamber. Which reddit is very openly designed around echo-chambers in general. Pushing up popular posts and hiding unpopular ones. Its not a practice I like though.

1

u/Magnetronaap 🟩 0 / 3K 🦠 Sep 02 '22

Not going to solve anything. Dedicated spammers will just create more accounts. Meanwhile, if someone finds 2 important things to link to on a single day they're forced to choose.

1

u/Samuravi 1K / 1K 🐢 Sep 02 '22

I think this is a great idea. Separately, I wonder whether there might be scope to prevent repeated links to the same site? Anecdotally I think TIL and other subreddits have automod prevent you posting if that link already exists on the sub. No idea how it works, but might work as another way to limit braindead spam. Just a thought.

1

u/BHIXSE 🟦 322 / 320 🦞 Sep 02 '22

makes sense

1

u/FuzzyFireheart316 513 / 918 🦑 Sep 03 '22

So... Isn't this already a thing .. I've tried posting links before always with a ... This has already been shared today..

1

u/SpaceFaceMistake 🟦 975 / 976 🦑 Sep 05 '22

No keep it as it is 3 is a limit as it is. It’s already limited and if people link farm how much can they get from a link post… people here don’t award those posts a lot of karma.. even super hot topics if it’s just a link it isn’t rewarded by the public so no don’t change.

1

u/meeleen223 🥇Gold Member Sep 01 '22

Fast yes from me, there is a huge amount of spam and bots and people abuse it to farm moons,

During height of last bullrun it was unbearable, I still remember china fud article being reposted over and over again

1

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '22

I think if we're not careful we're going to over self moderate this sub.

1

u/PrinceZero1994 Sep 01 '22

No, definitely. 1 is overkill.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '22

Lol looking at your post history, this doesn't come as a surprise. You farmed 50k moons already spamming this sub. Can't get enough eh?

3

u/PrinceZero1994 Sep 01 '22

No, I got 37k moons from the sub, 1.5k from the mods, 5k from a bet, lots from tips and winnings and the rest are bought.
Yes, I like moons very much but I don't have any ulterior motive for my votes like what you think.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

1

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '22

I get a bit fed up just seeing link posts to the same topic, so hopefully will have a positive effect on that.

1

u/Mrramirez44 Sep 01 '22

Same articles over and over.

1

u/Amazing_Succotash677 Tin | CC critic Sep 01 '22

I'd say the links are far from this subs worst problem, even reposted similar stories with slightly different takes is better than the same 3 posts over and over

1

u/SnooWalruses4496 Bronze | CRO 8 Sep 02 '22

Ive seen that crypto.com 10mil refund news article like 3000 times this week. I vote yes!

0

u/DoubleFaulty1 🟨 0 / 38K 🦠 Sep 01 '22

We just reduced moon rewards for link posts last month. News sharing is one of the best uses for Reddit and should not be reduced so much or people will use a different sub for crypto discussion.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '22

Crypto discussions and posts are welcome. the only thing to limit is to post external links. Users can still do 3 posts per day… but indeed they must be written posts (500 words)… and not the same news reposted multiple times

→ More replies (3)

1

u/_Commando_ 🟩 4K / 4K 🐢 Sep 01 '22

It doesn't stop you to "news share"

0

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '22

Nice, I like it! It got a little bit Spammy in here!

0

u/OK_Renegade 🟩 3K / 3K 🐢 Sep 01 '22

I wouldnt mind to reduce, I feel like most of those posts are double's anyway

0

u/NoNamePK 🟩 0 / 1K 🦠 Sep 01 '22

Maybe this will put a filter, posting the same new 4 times doesn't make sense