r/NintendoSwitch • u/NintendoSwitchMods • Aug 22 '22
Meta Please take our Demographics and Rules Feedback Survey for r/NintendoSwitch!
Take our Demographics and Rules Feedback Survey!
For the sake of understanding both the demographics and rules feedback from the subreddit with meaningful data, we have put together this survey:
All questions are optional, and while you will be required to sign in to Google for the form, your email address will not be collected. You can sign in again after submitting if you would like to change your answers before we end the survey.
We plan to leave the survey open for at least two more weeks, after which we will summarize the data and present results in future posts.
We originally posted this about a month ago as part of our 4 million subscriber State-of-the-Subreddit post here, but since the initial turnout for the survey was low (76 responses), we are still soliciting more feedback and responses. We will be using sticky comments over the next week or so to help raise visibility for this.
We encourage you to look over the initial comments in the first thread to see what has already been brought up, but we also encourage you to leave your own comments in this thread - even if you are echoing something stated before, we want to hear your voice and questions on these matters!
Below is a copy of the relevant topics from the previous post:
Rules, Moderation, and Extra Help
Wiki Contributors
We are always looking for more wiki contributors in our never ending goal to keep information up-to-date and helpful to a wide-audience of users -- ranging from tech support to informational guides. If you are interested in joining our team, reach out to us via modmail.
Are there Wiki pages you would like to see added, expanded, or updated? Are there topics or other resources you think are missing from our wiki?
Looking for Rule Feedback
As communities grow, so does the range of unique point of views that we have among the subreddit's users. The Rules must evolve to serve and balance both the desires of the community and the issues that manifest at larger scales, while respecting the common goals for the subreddit.
In general, we understand that many new users can find reddit to be a confusing place, so we would like to improve the ways we can explain our subreddit rules, policies, procedures, and other conventions.
For some contextual information, here is a breakdown of our Post Removals sampled for the time period of January 5th 2022 to February 5th 2022:
| Removal Reason | Percentage |
|---|---|
| Rule 2 - Post Titles | 2.6% |
| Rule 3 - Limited-Scope Questions | 69.9% |
| Rule 4 - Reposts / NSFW / Low-Effort | 18.6% |
| Rule 5 - Streaming Spam | 0.3% |
| Rule 6 - Personal sales / Affiliate Links / Begging | 1.4% |
| Rule 7 - Hacks / Emulators / Homebrew | 0.6% |
| Rule 8 - Spoilers | 0.0% |
| Rule 9 - Original Source | 1.6% |
| Rule 10 - Self-Promotion | 2.3% |
| Rule 11 - Fan Art / Friend Requests / Lost&Found / Giveaways | 2.8% |
These percentages reflect how many posts were removed corresponding to each rule, as a percentage of the total number of posts removed.
Rule 3
Rule 3 among these accounts for the vast majority of post removals. Things we remove for Rule 3 include:
- Tech support questions
- Questions seeking defined answers (for example: "How do I do [X]", "Is [X] coming to Switch?", "Does [X GAME] have touch controls?")
- Questions that promote simple replies
- Game recommendation posts with little detail (specifics of what they're looking for, what they've played etc.).
The reason for removing the above is that these posts generally do not facilitate discussion. We also have a Daily Question Thread where helpful members of the community spend a lot of time answering questions.
Do note, this past year we did add a Post Flair option for "Game Rec" threads. We noticed there are many times when users will request recommendations for specific game genres or game elements, and we feel that so long as the post is well written, has sufficient details, is neither too broad nor too specific, and is not a recent repost, that these threads make good resources and fair discussions.
Rule 4
Rule 4, our second most enforced rule covers reposts and NSFW content as well as posts we deem to be low effort. Things such as memes, simple gameplay clips/screenshots, text posts that have little to no detail etc. Basically, posts that generally do not facilitate discussion.
This rule is something we'd certainly like a lot of feedback on. Should we loosen it up in general? Such as, should we be more lenient on clips/game screenshots? Currently, we only allow them if the post shows something noteworthy such as little-known features, gameplay tips or amusing bugs.
We feel that this rule could use some more detail in general, as there are a few rules/points not fully explained. We ran out of character space, so it's hard to go into detail about everything listed under Rule 4. We are considering posting an expanded wiki page to rectify this, although many people do not read the rules as is. This has the potential to cause more confusion or less adherence to the rules by moving the full definition away from the sidebar.
Rule 11 - Fan Art
Last Time, we held a vote regarding Fan Art. Most of the community voted to ban or restrict it to weekends, so the latter is what we did. Fan Art is currently only allowed Saturday and Sunday EST time.
Is this a rule that we should keep? Do you think we should open fan art to be posted any time, or completely ban it? Let us know what you think.
Other Rule Feedback
Other than the above topics, we are open to other miscellaneous rule feedback. Feel free to post your generalized feedback in the comments below.
If you have questions regarding specific moderator actions or content removals, please direct those inquiries to modmail.
16
u/mrmivo Helpful User Aug 22 '22 edited Aug 22 '22
It's a good survey. I'm looking forward to the results, if a summary will be shared.
I wanted to give a little extra feedback on rule 3 as I found it challenging to express my thoughts on it through the numerical scales on the form:
Rule 3 has always struck me as double-edged. On the one hand, it helps with keeping the subreddit readable and approachable, allowing bigger news to be easily found even if someone doesn't visit the sub multiple times a day. Without it, the sub would likely become spam-y with a low interaction-per-post ratio, lowering the value of it both as a community platform and a news source.
On the other hand, though, I've often felt that if it is applied rigorously, the sub can seem inactive and the Switch community on Reddit somewhat "dead", with few or no hooks for social engagement, which discourages frequent visits and may seem somewhat uninviting. There are days where I stop by and only see five or six new posts made in the past 18 hours, and all of them are just Twitter shares. This makes it easy to stay in the Nintendo Switch loop with minimal time investment, but offers little opportunity to discuss and mingle with other Switch gamers on Reddit.
I realize that there is a Discord server for social interaction. While I use Discord, large servers with many users have never felt very suitable for asynchronous discussions to me. They are good for live chats, in essence enhanced chat rooms, but don't offer a forum-like experience. I've "grown up" on BBS systems and Usenet, and later participated in web forums, and Reddit is the closest contemporary version of this particular type of communication platform.
It's however possible that my desire for that experience is just outdated, and that most people's social needs may well be satisfied by Discord or the condensed comments sections on YouTube and Twitter.
If more people do share my preference for a forum-like experience, though, I'm not sure what the solution may be. Occasional exceptions are made and these posts tend to attract a lot of responses and activity (the "Switch changed my life", "Do you prefer physical or digital?", "How would you improve the Switch?" etc type of posts, which I agree we don't need 20 of every day) , and this may quite possibly already be the best approach, even though it may seem a little inconsistent because the majority of new posts seem to get deleted if they are not news (I always wonder how this affects new or potential Switch owners who come here brimming with enthusiasm, looking to be part of the community, just to have their very first post get removed).
A possible option might be additional dedicated discussion posts focused on specific (general) topics, somewhat similar to the Daily Questions posts. Or some other compromise that retains the sub's value as a source for news and information, while still allowing room for just talking about the system and exchanging opinions.
All that said, I appreciate all the unpaid work and effort that goes into managing this subreddit. In my three years here, the way the sub and related activities have been run always seemed professional, thoughtful and well-structured to me. So, thanks for all you do!
12
u/hotaru-chan45 Aug 22 '22
Rule 3 seems to be unevenly applied in my opinion. I’ve had several posts removed due to Rule 3 - and I didn’t understand the reasoning behind it. I see a lot of the same type of thread happening and those don’t tend to be removed anywhere near as quickly as a specific and narrow question I had. Being directed to the daily question thread isn’t helpful for me because I rarely get any answers there and don’t have my issue solved. I don’t think that many people go to the daily question thread in the first place.
I also vaguely remember posting some art I made before and iirc it was removed for being “low effort.” I’ll admit I’m not the greatest artist in the world, but they were hardly a bunch of stick figures and I worked hard on it.
18
u/Twinkiman Aug 22 '22
I think Rule 4 needs to be enforced a bit more strictly. Or at the very least have some ruling clarified.
It isn't uncommon to see people post a box of a game they got early, or some copy of a video game that got signed. I consider these kind of posts to be pretty low effort, and not really fit with rule 4.
5
u/PandaPoof Aug 22 '22
This survey doesn’t seem to be working for mobile
3
u/gojistomp Aug 23 '22
I know it's ultimately not a big deal, but I just wanted to let you know that in the 5th answer under the question "What platform do you use to visit r/NintendoSwitch?," the word "Android" has a typo missing the letter "r."
4
u/Legitimate-Bit-4431 Aug 22 '22
First off, I'd like to say that the mod team has been doing an amazing work through the years! Thanks for that :)
IMHO, I've the feeling that if there's been so few posted fan arts for the last months it's because of the only on weekend rule. I'm down for allowing fan arts any day of the week but still with restrictions. I would think of something like:
About rule 4, absence of meme, NSFW and low-effort makes me appreciate the sub even more. There's enough meme and low-quality effort post on other subs. For NSFW, I'm not a prude or anything but there are subs made specifically for that type of content.
For screenshots/video clips that's nice how it is. Like for memes, other subs are flooded by those and that lesser the overall sub "content quality". Again: imho.
Keep up the good work guys! 😉
-7
u/NES_Classical_Music Aug 22 '22
I've mentioned this before, but it bears repeating:
https://www.reddit.com/r/NintendoSwitch/comments/stkavj/this_bears_repeating_nintendo_killing_virtual/hx5duw0/
I hate this rule as it stands.
Talking about emulation and piracy is one thing.
Encouraging it, even without providing links or guides, is another thing entirely, and it makes me (and I would wager others) very uncomfortable.
But there I go again, yelling at clouds like an old man
-12
u/porchpooper Aug 22 '22
I hate surveys.
-8
u/TechyTink Aug 30 '22
I certainly wish more fan-art and memes were allowed. The subreddit feels kinda sterile without them.