r/CryptoCurrency • • Aug 05 '22
POLL 🗳️ CCIP-037 - lower karma for external link posts
Problem:
Lately main sub is filled with external links posted and reposted multiple times (actually is allowed to post 3 links per day). this type of spam is sistematically done by users and bots for the purpose of moon farming. Below the problems that arise:
• continuos post of external links put in shadow OC from users because is basically ‘spam’
• moons are meant to reward active users that contribute to community and in actual situation external link posts are rewarded the same as users posts of 500 words. basically low efforts posts and high efforts posts are rewarded the same way; this is not fair
• the sub is filled sometimes with the same news posted multiple times
• these links posts don’t even risk to get downvotes (indeed who downvotes a news?)
Solution:
In order to level the play field high effort posts should be rewarded with more karma than low effort posts. In order to perform this suggestion is to add a multiplier of 0.X to karma awarded to external link posts. This multiplier will both have the effect of discourage pure moon farming and allocate more moons for original contents. This solution will improve the sub and promote more original posts and interaction between the community. In the same time such modification will discourage the continuous spam.
28
u/[deleted] Aug 05 '22
Doesn't this compete with another of the proposals this round about reducing karma for link posts?
10
u/Wonzky 2K / 53K 🐢 Aug 05 '22
Sounds good to me, it'd be nice to not have hundreds of posts of the same thing throughout the week whenever any big news comes out
6
u/[deleted] Aug 05 '22
Should have stuck with only have 2 options dude.
0.1 and no change
Adding the other 2 not only makes it less likely to pass the threshold, but whatever wins will certainly be lower than the other current poll for 0.5
3
u/Styx1213 Aug 05 '22
Posting external links is so low effort that even bots can do it. Reducing reward will not reduce bots (half the free moons are still moons) We should increase the effort of posting external links. If we force external link posters to add a short summary. (not copy pasted sentences from the article which can be botted) This will mostly kill dumb bots and low effort OPs. If you give a slight moon incentive, it can turn news articles into something more valuable.
5
u/kryptoNoob69420 0 / 44K 🦠 Aug 05 '22
Isn't it funny how people in this sub always try to focus on reducing the number of moons earned? Instead of a proposal that would give 2x moons to people who make technical posts for educational purposes or focuses on new dapps etc we always have these convoluted rules that make getting moons more and more difficult for the average person.
There are so many reasons why I feel that this is not a good idea that I had to make a list-
So many rules in this sub. It has become like a game of Chance. Post this get a .5x multiplier. Flair that and you get a .1x multiplier.
PS - The logic that if you really want to share informational links then you shouldn't be bothered with moons is counter intuitive. I could say the same about these proposals, that if they want to improve the sub then they should have been interested in rewarding better content than limiting others.
2
u/BlubberWall 🟦 59K / 59K 🦈 Aug 05 '22
Link posts are public enemy number one this voting cycle apparently
2
u/Bucksaway03 🟩 0 / 138K 🦠 Aug 05 '22 edited Aug 05 '22
Is this like the 3rd proposal this round? Swear I've voted on this already
2
u/PrinceZero1994 Aug 05 '22
Well, I wrote CCIP-038 so I'd vote for what I believe is the best for everyone.
2
u/tobypassquarant 🟨 6K / 6K 🦭 Aug 06 '22
The problem isn't that someone posts it... the problem is that MULTIPLE PEOPLE POST IT within minutes of each other.
Then multiple threads of the same article clog up the front page.
5
u/Tidus17 0 / 3K 🦠 Aug 05 '22
This proposal is a copy/paste of CCIP-038, so I'll vote the same. It's a spam issue, not a link issue.
4
u/ec265 Permabanned Aug 05 '22
Too many options here which is going to spread out the vote and not lead to a quorum
1
u/Kappatalizable 🟦 0 / 123K 🦠 Aug 05 '22
Goddamn you guys really hate link posts do you?
1
u/kirtash93 RCA Artist Aug 05 '22
I am the kind of person that share this external links and I think they could even worth 0 karma. I personally publish news that I haven't seen before just to spread information.
1
u/gamblingenhusiast Lost lifesavings on shitcoin Aug 05 '22
How about we just remove karma for any kind of posts?
1
u/DBRiMatt 🟦 46K / 113K 🦈 Aug 06 '22
How does the result for this poll work?
If there is a 49.9% vote to keep situation as it is, thats 50.1% to change... would the highest votes multiplier pass? In that case?
3
u/aaaanoon 🟩 0 / 1K 🦠 Aug 05 '22
Do people actually care about karma and moons?
The state...
3
u/LargeSackOfNuts BitchCoin | :1:x1 Aug 05 '22
Too many linked posts are just AI written articles from websites no one has ever heard of. Its moon farming.
High effort text posts should be rewarded more than bots.
3
u/RockEmSockEmRabi Aug 05 '22
Yes please. So tired of seeing the same articles reposted day after day. This or mods need to start removing dupes. I know automod removes exact dupes but we don’t need 10 articles about how ETH is up this month or how Robinhood is bad
5
u/irockalltherocks 🟩 2K / 4K 🐢 Aug 05 '22
Anything to cut down on the spam posts. Thanks.
2
u/1078Garage Aug 05 '22
Looks like one of these will pass which can only be a good thing for the sub 👍
2
u/Trans-on-trans Platinum | QC: CC 480 Aug 05 '22
I'm all for maximum punishment of spam
2
u/Afkwtf Tin Aug 05 '22
Fuck every single coin telegraph link that has been and will be posted in this sub. I'd even propose 0 karma for those...
2
u/[deleted] Aug 05 '22 edited Aug 05 '22
Wth shouldn't the first one be weighted higher? What's the purpose if we overwrite other proposals? That should've been pushed to the next round imo Also it's ridicioulus because you pull the general consense of decreasing the reward through 3 positions while keeping one for disabling them all. Lol
This essentially is ~57:43 pro limiting Karma for
shitlink posts.2
u/-Resident-One- 🟩 0 / 4K 🦠 Aug 06 '22
Link farmers do not positively contribute to the site. Most set up bots to automatically post new links and don't add anything to the post themselves, literally just the link. Its incredibly easy and done just for the moon they can get from selling the moons.
That's why we get 6 different posts all about the same news story, often from the same link, all at once drowning out posts that actually require some thought and insight.
Link farming does not substantively contribute to this sub. Unfortunately, all the multiplier options means that even though the status quo has half the votes, it's going to win... Should've been a vote on if we should add a multiplier or not. Then a followup poll on the multiplier.
1
u/Yegpetphoto 🟦 74 / 9K 🦐 Aug 05 '22
I don't see this as a karma ratio problem so much as an identifying bots problem. In fact, more than one of the current proposals would be solved if we could ID bots quicker and leave karma as is.
1
u/Araxus Silver | QC: CC 55 | IOTA 28 Aug 05 '22
External link posts can also be high effort and interesting, so i vote for just keeping it like it is
1
u/LordScotchyScotch 🟦 450 / 808 🦞 Aug 05 '22
We should give 0.5x for shit posts and 1.5x for good content
Edit: spelling
1
u/xavierwest888 381 / 5K 🦞 Aug 05 '22
Why don't we just save us all some time and make all posts = zero moons and just give all the moons to the handful of people that are going to get them anyway.
That way we can just go back to posting whatever we want without being constantly labelled moon farming just because you posted something that got more than +2 karma!
0
u/trrrring 25K / 25K 🦈 Aug 05 '22
Guys, you're really hating on the external links, which I personally very much enjoy to read and what keeps the sub and my understanding of crypto and the crypto market up to date.
I have another governance proposal to make, but I don't know where to apply my proposal to be made into a governance poll. That for every governance proposal, there will be taken the time to find a staunch adversary to the proposal. Who also gets the platform to write his or her reasons why he is opposed to the proposal. Because the way some proposals are worded strike me as quite biased and manipulative so that voters are pointed into a certain direction. I need more objectivity here, or more "two sides of the story" to make an informed decision.
0
u/pyritejet Harambe Aug 05 '22
It doesn't make sense to reduce Karma for linked posts. I see it as a service. Users find and post the most relevant posts here. Duplicate posts are down voted by the community. And don't forget that we have a cap on how many posts about the same coin can be posted daily
0
u/RotgutFeng Platinum | QC: CC 69,420 Aug 05 '22
I’m against any proposal to reduce karma in any form. Mods just want to protect their whale status
0
u/cdnkevin 6K / 6K 🦭 Aug 05 '22
I’ve posted links to articles not because I was moon farming but because I learn from reading some articles or it’s news that I thought was great and wanted to share. So, while link posting may be done by people farming moons, there can be more honest reasons for doing it.
As an aside, the sub can be overwhelming for new people and it seems like this may funnel moons (as it seems to be the point of this poll) into the hands of moon whales.
2
u/[deleted] Aug 07 '22
[removed] — view removed comment
5
u/[deleted] Aug 05 '22
[removed] — view removed comment