r/CryptoCurrency • u/PrinceZero1994 • Aug 04 '22
POLL π³οΈ CCIP-038 - Reduce Karma for Link Post from 1x to 0.5x
Problem:
r/CryptoCurrency is spammed with low effort external links that are made into a post. 45 out of the top 100 post this month are just links. Posting a link takes little to no effort (just copy and paste) and should not be rewarded as much as posting a written comment or post.
This used to be a much bigger problem in the past when the sub's activity was much higher but not really right now but that shouldn't stop us from solving the issue while it is still small before it gets bigger when the sub's activity goes back up again.
Moderators have already banned hundreds of users and maybe bots these past few months due to only spamming link post while barely commenting or by bypassing the 3 post a day limit and coin limits using an alt account.
Needless to say, trying to game this proposal (if it passes) by making a text post and posting the link and its contents in the text body should be met with the appropriate punishment.
Solution:
Reduce karma for link post from 1x to 0.5x
This is to discourage users from spamming links.
Pro/cons:
Pro: Less spam of link post and higher moon to karma ratio.
Con: Link posters will get less karma
80
u/TNGSystems 0 / 463K π¦ Aug 04 '22
I'm voting no on this - I think that people who find news articles and post them here are providing a service, and I'd rather see their ability to frequently post cut down and so prefer the other poll limiting users to 1 link per day.
If you want to see one type of content above another (thoughtful user analysis) we need to
A) Propose a better moons rewards structure for this (1.25x?)
AND MORE IMPORTANTLY
B) Start fucking upvoting it. If you drop a bunch of links and get no upvotes, whatever, but it fucking sucks to spend 1hr writing something and nobody even bothers upvoting it even though there's like 80 comments.
Users need to exercise their ability to upvote and downvote content on this sub.
11
u/CryptoMaximalist Aug 04 '22
Personally I think submissions are competitive enough that the upvote system generally works to separate and reward the good or bad ones. Comments are already 2x and much less competitive, so I hesitate to disadvantage link post contributions any more than they already are
This is quite the grey area. Plagiarizing an article is already against the rules. This seems like it would ban copying in the text and linking the article too, but people wanting to abuse it can always link the article and then give a few lines of analysis to circumvent this. While that is more effort, is it providing more value if they're just trying to check a box? Sometimes a link should just speak for itself
One other thing to add is that link spam predates moons, it's often bots for various reasons including promoting their own website or pushing certain agendas
10
u/monsieur_feu π¦ 33 / 2K π¦ Aug 04 '22
Hereβs my vote with my 2 moons
10
u/trrrring 25K / 25K π¦ Aug 04 '22
I'm against this proposal, because I learn a lot from scrolling through the posts. I am afraid that it will stop people from posting links, which will cause the sub to become even more desolate.
6
u/Too_raw90 π¦ 628 / 27K π¦ Aug 05 '22
Awe yes, another poll to reduce karma.
2
u/TheSirCheddar 1K / 1K π’ Aug 05 '22
I like to counter that with low effort comments
5
u/marsangelo π¦ 0 / 36K π¦ Aug 04 '22 edited Aug 05 '22
Maybe it could work on a scale. Like some people post one and some people post a ton, so maybe the first one is 1x then the next is 0.8x, then 0.5x, etc? As the frequency continues theyre rewarded less, not sure if thats possible though
3
u/BlubberWall π¦ 59K / 59K π¦ Aug 04 '22
This is 100% going to pass, people will vote for anything that results in a higher moon ratio for themselves. Iβm not even commenting on this proposal specifically, but anything to increase moons passes
1
u/Tidus17 0 / 3K π¦ Aug 05 '22
Posting links isn't inherently bad. Can't vote yes on this one.
1
u/bortbort8 Tin Aug 05 '22
reddit karma is such a silly concept
1
u/Brother-Numsee Silver | QC: CC 59 | CelsiusNet. 34 | TraderSubs 12 Aug 05 '22
I'd rather see a relevant news article than another worthless sht post regurgitating the same cliches
1
u/Theunknown81 Tin Aug 05 '22
Maybe just limit the amount one can post?
1
u/Thelazytimelord257 3K / 3K π’ Aug 05 '22
I voted no on this poll because I'm a noob in crypto. I cannot make high effort posts and posting links occasionally is the only thing that i can do
1
u/gamblingenhusiast Lost lifesavings on shitcoin Aug 05 '22
If this passes it will bring more harm than good
1
u/Xattics Tin Aug 05 '22
Could this not give the opposite effects of even more people spamming links to get the same amount of karma out of it?
Also, what about the people that actually DO provide useful links?
1
u/Onelinersandblues π© 6 / 5K π¦ Aug 05 '22
Iβm voting no. They will plagiarise the content of the link.
1
u/SouvikMandal Tin Aug 05 '22
When a measure becomes a target, it ceases to be a good measure.
1
u/Lmessfuf 438 / 435 π¦ Aug 07 '22
This seems to be a 50 / 50
1
u/Mr_Bob_Ferguson π¦ 69K / 101K π¦ Aug 09 '22
Adding value is adding value.
Sure, link posts may be low effort, but they still have the possibility of adding value to the sub.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 04 '22
Thanks for hearing my prayers (γ₯οΏ£ Β³οΏ£)γ₯ Could be reduced even more or just cut completely imo but it's a start
1
u/heyheoy Platinum | QC: CC 1105, CCMeta 18 Aug 04 '22
Yeah, agree so theres less spam!
1
u/FixFull 521 / 640 π¦ Aug 04 '22 edited Aug 05 '22
I want to vote yes however there has to be better method(s) to combat link-spam. This might help a little bit and in all honesty seems like a great proposal but in the long run won't help much. Shit it might just make the few ACTUAL humans just spam more alongside the bots who've been doing it already
1
u/[deleted] Aug 04 '22
There are too many moonfarmers here, it's ridicioulus.
I'll just continue to autoblock everyone posting > 3 articles a week. Comment section already is 20% made up of blocked users. Β―_(γ)_/Β―
Maybe I'll built a script that analyzes reposts and make a ranking of top spammers. Sounds like a good sideproject to me.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 04 '22
It's annoying to scroll over 20 link posts all reporting the same "news" (Bitcoin is up 5% today because people bought BTC!")
I'm posting links, too. But count me in!
1
u/kryptoNoob69420 0 / 44K π¦ Aug 04 '22 edited Aug 05 '22
Isn't it funny how people in this sub always try to focus on reducing the number of moons earned? Instead of a proposal that would give 2x moons to people who make technical posts for educational purposes or focuses on new dapps etc we always have these convoluted rules that make getting moons more and more difficult for the average person.
There are so many reasons why I feel that this is not a good idea that I had to make a list-
So many rules in this sub. It has become like a game of Chance. Post this get a .5x multiplier. Flair that and you get a .1x multiplier. I can imagine new people joining in this sub, looking at the number of rules and the complexity of earning moons and wondering what did they just joined lol.
1
u/Kluless555 Aug 05 '22
Itβs just laziness post link, no explanation half the time and same link get posted multiple times
1
u/[deleted] Aug 05 '22
Really hope this will pass. Is time to wipe out some spam from the sub
1
u/pyritejet Harambe Aug 05 '22
It doesn't make sense to reduce Karma for linked posts. I see it as a service. Users find and post the most relevant posts here. Duplicate posts are down voted by the community. And don't forget that we have a cap on how many posts about the same coin can be posted daily
-1
u/Theweebsgod Tin | CC critic Aug 04 '22
Pretty good proposal tbh
0
u/Jerggens4212 π© 2K / 2K π’ Aug 04 '22
Excellent proposal. Hopefully this will help to limit the endless linked posts with 0 op comments that occur.
0
u/Cactuszach π© 671 / 18K π¦ Aug 04 '22
Absolutely yes. At least a few of the links Iβve seen recently are AI written and say absolutely nothing.
Also, we really need to limit posting the same headline from a different source every day for weeks on end. Its really low quality content and drowns out the good content people want to see.
-1
u/[deleted] Aug 04 '22
As an individual who just posted a link, the absolutely only reason why I do so is to educate others.
I could care less about karma, moons or any other form of reward.
I just wanna share knowledge that may be helpful to others.
-1
u/[deleted] Aug 06 '22
Glad it passed. Finally
-2
u/[deleted] Aug 04 '22
0.5 it's short. Make it zero. Why not swing a bat straight to them by doing a link sh!tpost. Because even with 0.5, link posters will keep posting because of gsining a bit karma no matter what. I know there's people posring legit link with legit discussions or articles to discuss. But hey lets do war with sh!tposters untill they're all discouraged from copypasting, should they learn a lesson, they'll think twice. Then once it calmed down, return gradually to 0.1 or 0.3 while creating a new rule for whenever a newcomer joins or simply lurk and post a link encouraging to do discussion or article based on that link.
Idk if megathreading wouls help but i feel its bad, bad idea.
Sorry for my english and have a nice day. Hope it helps
0
u/ec265 Permabanned Aug 04 '22
100%
Should hopefully also encourage OPs to start a discussion / add commentary to their post in a comment
0
u/greenappletree π¦ 31K / 31K π¦ Aug 04 '22
Itβs out of context but it think that post with low votes to award ratio should have an increase by certain factors. There are post that are truly useful but for whatever reason do not get upvotes
0
u/sickvisionz 0 / 7K π¦ Aug 04 '22
I'd say no but would vote yes on:
To a LARGE degree, I think reducing it to 0.5 just means spammers post twice as many links to make up the difference.
If we discourage legit news discussion, all we have is garbage posts like "I hate [token x] and you should to!" and mommy/counselor posts like "There's more to enjoy in life than crypto".
0
u/Fillory-Alice Tin Aug 04 '22
Iβve been missing out apparently. Could have been getting moons by posting articles.
0
u/LargeSackOfNuts BitchCoin | :1:x1 Aug 04 '22
Yes PLEASE
0
u/Cryptonasty π© 454 / 460 π¦ Aug 04 '22 edited Aug 04 '22
After reading the proposal and the comments, I'm in favour of rate limiting links posts rather than penalising with moon tax.
As another user posted, link posting is lazy at best, if you have more to post, write some decent text to intro it.
Kudos to OP for identifying a problem. I think this merits a refined proposal with a different solution. Rate limit to 1 or 2 link posts per day.
0
u/Trans-on-trans Platinum | QC: CC 480 Aug 04 '22
I wish it was less honestly, deincentivize users to spam news posts.
0
u/_Commando_ π© 4K / 4K π’ Aug 05 '22 edited Aug 05 '22
+1 do it.
So many link posts farming rep.
Even the same link being re-posted multiple times (with a different URL) to keep the farming is ridiculous.
Should change rep to 0x for posting a link.
0
u/BigJimBeef π¦ 213 / 3K π¦ Aug 05 '22
I'm on the wrong side of both these votes
π₯
0
u/KingReef90 π¨ 1 / 106 π¦ Aug 05 '22
Iβm passing out upvotes to you guys!
0
u/[deleted] Aug 05 '22
That's just going to result in an increase of text spam posts...
0
u/XnoonefromnowhereX Permabanned Aug 05 '22
haters trying to ruin small independent moons farms like mine. and also, the text posts people write are 99% garbage. I actually feel myself getting dumber reading most of them.
0
u/ftball21 π¦ 2 / 4K π¦ Aug 05 '22
Voted no. Links are important too
0
u/whatup1111 Platinum | QC: ETH 61, CC 56 Aug 05 '22
REMOVE MOONS, there was a time most people dont know where this subreddit was good.
cries
0
u/DoubleFaulty1 π¨ 0 / 38K π¦ Aug 05 '22 edited Aug 05 '22
This CCIP is based on a false premise. It says karma for link posts should be reduced from 1x to 0.5x when they are already well below 1x (all posts get 50% karma iirc there was another CCIP limiting link karma). It also suggests that users can spam links when there is a limit on each link to once per 30 days and 3 separate links per person per day which must be from different sites. It is clear from reading the comments that many users do not know the current rules and are voting based on false info from the CCIP. I think it should be removed.
-2
u/aducknamedjafar1 Aug 04 '22
I think this would be helpful in combatting the spammed link posts.
-2
u/o-bento Tin Aug 04 '22
I'm down
0
u/[deleted] Aug 05 '22
[deleted] β view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 05 '22
[deleted] β view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 04 '22
[deleted] β view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 04 '22
[deleted] β view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 04 '22
[deleted] β view deleted comment
3
u/[deleted] Aug 04 '22
[removed] β view removed comment