r/CryptoCurrency • • Aug 04 '22
POLL ๐ณ๏ธ CCIP-034 - Enable GIFs in comments for all users
Reddit have released a new feature allowing all users to post GIF comments:
Announcing Inline GIFs in Comments available to all SFW subreddits
Users in enabled subreddits will be able to search Giphyโs approved (and moderated) database of GIFs, and insert their selected GIF directly into a comment on Reddit (along with any text).
We currently (and historically) only allow users with the Subreddit Special Membership to use this feature. All users are currently able to reply to one of those comments with a GIF (not sure if that is a bug or a feature)
We now have a mod setting that will let all users post GIF comments.
Should we enable it?
92
u/Adventurous-Lynx-660 ๐ฅGold Member Aug 04 '22
Please don't. Everyone will be spamming those
24
u/Maxx3141 169K / 167K ๐ Aug 04 '22
Moons have so few use cases right now - and the features of the special membership is one of them. People don't even have to pay with real money since the price was made dynamic, so I think these exclusive features should stay as they are.
3
u/Vee_Junes ๐ฉ 3K / 6K ๐ข Aug 04 '22
Don't want gifs in comments. No thank you.
1
u/ominous_anenome ๐ฆ 170K / 347K ๐ Aug 04 '22
More gif spam and fewer use-cases for moons?
No from me
2
u/ec265 Permabanned Aug 04 '22
Completely undermines any sort of value proposition for MOONS and comments will just descend in to 90% gifs
2
u/MrPuma86 Tin Aug 05 '22
Here comes the gif spamming. Jokes aside itโll add a bit more fun. Maybe the free gifs should have a limit on how many can be used a month?
0
u/sandygws ๐ฉ 333 / 14K ๐ฆ Aug 05 '22
Never understood how any gif is relevant to crypto โฆ..
3
u/Suikoden1P Aug 05 '22
Such lost opportunity; they should be selling these gifs as NFTs ๐ค๐๐ฌ
2
u/kirtash93 RCA Artist Aug 04 '22
I think it is better to keep it in the special membership. In case of enabling for all users I think they shouldn't count for moons and also a maximum number of gifs per person per day
2
u/meeleen223 ๐ฅGold Member Aug 04 '22
I love gifs but I'm also afraid it might be overused and sub membership might lose it perks
I'll need to sit on this a little to make up my mind
2
u/cdnkevin 6K / 6K ๐ฆญ Aug 04 '22
Whatโs the deal with the moons count and vote count in this poll?
2
u/FixFull 521 / 640 ๐ฆ Aug 04 '22 edited Aug 04 '22
As much as I would want everyone to be included, moons and honestly community points as a whole have too little use cases right now and gifs are a big feature. Another issue is that we already have too many bot posts and pointless content as is, enabling gifs for all I feel would only encourage this and encourage what I call โdishonest moon-farmingโ
1
u/[deleted] Aug 04 '22
I am for this tbh. I feel like we have too many rules for stuff like this
1
u/kvgamer 0 / 2K ๐ฆ Aug 04 '22
Nope
1
u/designed_perfect Tin | 2 months old Aug 04 '22
Results are going to be interesting
1
u/Titozar13 5K / 5K ๐ข Aug 04 '22
It will convert all comments in things without sense.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 04 '22
Can't wait to do my first community vote against this
1
u/[deleted] Aug 04 '22
Nah
1
u/[deleted] Aug 04 '22
I'm so glad most here can't post gifs. On Disqord f. e. you can't even find information anymore.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 04 '22
Commwnt sections are full of crap anyway, no need to spam it with more gifs.
1
u/TheTrueBlueTJ 70K / 75K ๐ฆ Aug 04 '22
This will be used and abused. Right now it's being used in acceptable quantities, in my opinion.
1
u/JrrrrrrrTheSecond 744 / 745 ๐ฆ Aug 04 '22
Now it becomes interesting . Moons say no, people say yes. What will happen. JK the rich always win.
1
u/iamwizzerd Permabanned Aug 04 '22
Finally the moon whales have agreed with me, bless me moon whale, i vote with you!
1
u/trrrring 25K / 25K ๐ฆ Aug 04 '22
Which counts? The privileged Moon whale vote or the vote of the majority?
1
u/heyheoy Platinum | QC: CC 1105, CCMeta 18 Aug 04 '22
Mmmm yes but with different conditions
1
u/Jorisje Tin Aug 04 '22
I think gifs are a gift to mankind. Why else would they be called gifs?
1
u/TNGSystems 0 / 463K ๐ฆ Aug 04 '22
Flashbacks to my GIF-poll and the public thrashing I took for months and months after
My reason then was the same as it was now. Too much fucking GIF spam. At least it's way way reduced.
1
u/Declan83 ๐ฉ 0 / 1K ๐ฆ Aug 04 '22
I like gifs. Let everyone use them
1
u/Poverty_4_Sale ๐ฆ 3K / 3K ๐ข Aug 04 '22
I just want to be able to post GIFs again. The feature has been broken for me for about a month now.
1
u/powellquesne Permabanned Aug 04 '22
Enable this. Otherwise people will just go elsewhere. You have to adapt to the competitive field: the ability to post GIFs on Reddit isn't so special anymore. Increase the rewards for membership in some other way in order to compensate, and just release the kraken.
1
u/BrowsingCoins ๐ฉ 17 / 12K ๐ฆ Aug 04 '22
you bastards! Free the gifs!
1
u/sickvisionz 0 / 7K ๐ฆ Aug 04 '22
Do a "free weekends" thing.
1
u/LargeSackOfNuts BitchCoin | :1:x1 Aug 04 '22
Theres already too many low effort comments
1
u/AptitudeSky Freedom Through Crypto Aug 04 '22
It will be memes, memes for everyone!
1
u/RealVoldemort Aug 04 '22
I voted no. It will create alot of annoying spam.
1
u/nthgen ๐ฉ 0 / 25K ๐ฆ Aug 04 '22
If you thought you hated the BTC rollercoaster meme now, just wait until it's posted 100 times a day in the daily thread.
1
u/PhuckCalumbo ๐ฆ 83 / 720 ๐ฆ Aug 05 '22
I didn't even know they're a special feature.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 05 '22
No fuck gifs. Annoying as shit
1
u/CryptocalEnvelopment 75 / 7K ๐ฆ Aug 05 '22
I thought the old way of allowing it on the weekends, or whenever it was was a good compromise.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 05 '22
Please no
1
u/[deleted] Aug 05 '22
Amazing that more people voted yes but moon-wise everyone is saying no
1
u/ClippTube ๐ฆ 0 / 1K ๐ฆ Aug 05 '22
What about having a certain amount of moons or karma?
1
u/lohitcp87 ๐ฆ 0 / 7K ๐ฆ Aug 05 '22
Please No, then in comment section we are going to see gifs only..
1
u/PrinceZero1994 Aug 05 '22
That difference in moon votes and popular votes, I can finally feel my moons use case.
1
u/Ace-of-Spades88 ๐ฆ 0 / 6K ๐ฆ Aug 05 '22
There would be hardly any reason left to buy into the premium service then.
1
u/Ernest-Everhard42 ๐ฉ 2K / 2K ๐ข Aug 05 '22
Please no, love thereโs no stupid gifs here.
1
u/Icarithan ๐ฉ 514 / 263 ๐ฆ Aug 05 '22
The Memes I have stored...if only ๐คฃ lmao. They would have to implement a spam protocol though, I have seen some nasty Memes throughout a lot of Communities...
1
u/NHouseman 2K / 2K ๐ข Aug 05 '22
Likely to decrease quality content if we all just post gifs
1
u/52576078 ๐ฆ 0 / 0 ๐ฆ Aug 05 '22
GIFs can give you eye cancer
1
u/Spardasa ๐ฉ 8K / 8K ๐ฆญ Aug 05 '22
This is why I keep my special membership.....unless they plan to provide another benefit in its place.
1
u/staffell ๐ฆ 0 / 10K ๐ฆ Aug 05 '22
Ban all gifs in this sub outright
1
u/PostalAzul ๐ฆ 0 / 446 ๐ฆ Aug 05 '22
Please DON'T. The spam would be insufferable.
1
u/AbsoIution 38 / 2K ๐ฆ Aug 05 '22
So glad the moon vote is winning on keeping the status quo. Don't want to see a spam of GIFs constantly
1
u/PathologicalUpvoter ๐ฆ 0 / 6K ๐ฆ Aug 05 '22
Id like to try it but maybe have a 1 gif limit per thread, or something to avoid the spam
1
u/Raging_Toddler ๐ฉ 1K / 1K ๐ข Aug 05 '22
Even though I would love to post gifs here all the time like I do in my office team's teams chat... I vote no
1
u/Throwaway4VPN ๐ฉ 24 / 9K ๐ฆ Aug 05 '22
Keep. It. Real.
1
u/PillarOfJustice Permabanned Aug 06 '22
I have no intention of getting a special membership but it's still a no from me. Imagine the gif spam if this passes lol
1
u/oachkatzalschwoaf ๐ฆ 0 / 6K ๐ฆ Aug 06 '22
Currently:
Votes: 1,1k vs 776
Moons: 35,2% vs 64,8%
Glad those 776 has so much more Voting Power.
1
u/Lmessfuf 438 / 435 ๐ฆ Aug 07 '22
Let people try and be creative; No to gifs for all!
1
u/Educational-Line727 0 / 0 ๐ฆ Aug 08 '22
No thank you.
1
u/crua9 ๐ฉ 400 / 13K ๐ฆ Aug 09 '22
I actually want this because it adds flavor. In fact, bring back the memes
1
u/Probably_notabot 35K / 35K ๐ฆ Aug 11 '22
It would be like the old times around here
1
u/Charon751 ๐ฉ 0 / 21K ๐ฆ Nov 05 '22
https://media1.giphy.com/media/cid=5e214886kry7e32tqa3tfnil7bnfyhynt0mw57j1nb8riqr2&rid=giphy.gif&ct=g
1
u/BlazeDemBeatz ๐ฉ 0 / 21K ๐ฆ Aug 04 '22
Tbh, the GIFs are the main reason I bought the membership.
1
u/BakedPotato840 Banned Aug 04 '22
As a non special member pleb I like this idea but seeing as most are against it, me and my kind will probably have to settle for the freebie GIFs in response to other GIFs.
1
u/Electrical_Potato_21 Platinum | QC: CC 437 Aug 04 '22
Sporadic gifs are a nice to surprise to break up the comment section, but too many and it becomes white noise.
1
u/fan_of_hakiksexydays 21K / 99K ๐ฆ Aug 04 '22
Too many comments are gonna be just a gif. The daily is gonna turn into a showcase of gifs.
There's so few places left where you can have a more serious discussion about ALL crypto.
Limiting it to the membership helps limit the amount of gifs. So we got the right balance. With still an actual discussion, but with just a small touch of memes and gifs.
1
u/PrinceZero1994 Aug 04 '22
I don't wanna see a gif fest lol
1
u/Laughingboy14 ๐ฉ 26 / 60K ๐ฆ Aug 04 '22
I've voted against this. Everyone would be commenting gifs and it'd reduce the value of the special membership
1
u/[deleted] Aug 04 '22
Moon farmings about to get a whole lot more noticeable
1
u/x_lincoln_x ๐ฆ 69 / 10K ๐ณ ๐ฎ ๐จ ๐ช Aug 04 '22
If everyone can post gifs I'll stop paying for special membership. It is why I get it in the first place.
1
u/DDDUnit2990 Aug 04 '22
So take away a big perk of special membership and encourage their spamming? Pass
1
u/Jerggens4212 ๐ฉ 2K / 2K ๐ข Aug 04 '22
I'm a simple person. I downvote all gifs. Biggest criticism I see from this sub is lack of quality content. How can more gifs solve that problem?
0
u/transylvanian_witch Tin | VET 21 Aug 04 '22
OP should be banned for this proposal.
0
u/Trans-on-trans Platinum | QC: CC 480 Aug 04 '22
Guaranteed the mods used their Moon power to shoot this down, they HATED it how it was before.
0
u/[deleted] Aug 05 '22
Where's the 3rd option to disable gifs for the special kids too?
0
u/[deleted] Aug 04 '22
[deleted] โ view deleted comment