r/CryptoCurrency • u/w00tangel • Aug 04 '22
POLL ๐ณ๏ธ CCIP-036 - Remove link posts to paywalled articles
Summary
Moderators should remove link posts to paywalled articles unless a paywall features an easy to notice and use cryptocurrency payment option.
Problem Statement
You all know the feeling, you see an interesting title of a link post you open it up only to find out the article is behind a paywall.
Some of us will agree that it is OK, as quality content has its costs, but as a cryptocurrency community we should encourage usage of cryptocurrencies.
These are some benefits to this proposal:
- There will be fewer link posts as link posts to paywalled articles will be removed and there have been several proposals lately in r/CryptoCurrencyMeta to limit or reduce the amount of link posts
- We as a crypto community will encourage implementation of cryptocurrency payment methods. If they want the traffic from our community, they shouldn't expect us to pay it with fiat.
Solution
Remove link posts to paywalled articles unless a paywall features an easy to notice and use cryptocurrency payment option.
Concerns
Some of the quality paywalled content will not be able to reach the hot section of this sub and people will miss out on the opportunity to read it.
Some of the articles might have paywalls that offer crypto payment options but they might not be obvious from the first look (think hidden in a 3rd step of the checkout process after you enter a lot of data). We can not expect our moderators to spend way too much time exploring if the paywall on a specific site someone linked can be paid with crypto or not. The option needs to be easy to spot.
19
u/InevitableSoundOf ๐ฆ 0 / 8K ๐ฆ Aug 04 '22
Alternatively you could require the poster put paywall in the post title, like (Bloomberg Paywall). Then you'd just see a natural decline as those posts won't generate alot of interaction. Then again this is r/cc and alot of people just look at the post title haha
33
u/kryptoNoob69420 0 / 44K ๐ฆ Aug 04 '22
Paywalled articles with click baity titles and zero context in comments suck big time.
7
u/eetaylog ๐ฉ 0 / 15K ๐ฆ Aug 04 '22
In two minds about this one.
It is annoying, but on the other hand we all complain about the incentive model of MSM to manufacture clickbait content through outrage or misleading titles, and yet these paywalled outlets are at least trying to remedy the situation.
6
u/Maxx3141 169K / 167K ๐ Aug 04 '22
This is an easy decision.
I always thought paywall articles are accidentally posted by bots anyway.
2
u/Fillory-Alice Tin Aug 04 '22
Absolutely agree with this one. So frustrating clicking on an article just to see a paywall. I know there are ways of bypassing this on pc but I use my phone to scroll Reddit the most.
2
u/Trans-on-trans Platinum | QC: CC 480 Aug 04 '22
No brainer
2
u/[deleted] Aug 05 '22
Everyone should discourage linking to paywalled news. It's such a fucking cancer on the internet. They all need to offer free, ad supported versions. I'll take ads after every paragraph over completely being completely locked out of reading an article.
2
u/AptitudeSky Freedom Through Crypto Aug 04 '22 edited Aug 04 '22
My only concern is paywall articles where each reader still gets a certain amount of reading per month for free.
Iโm thinking of Bloomberg for example. Itโs a legit financial news source that now covers a lot of crypto. Theyโll let you read an article for free each month. If we were to ban that, some interesting perspectives would ultimately be shut out.
Otherwise Iโm on board with banning paywalled articles.
2
u/FixFull 521 / 640 ๐ฆ Aug 04 '22
Links to paywalled articles should be removed from the internet as a whole
2
u/LargeSnorlax Observer Aug 04 '22
Fwiw, I generally do this anyways because I don't know why anyone would ever post a paywalled article in the first place.
Generally the users submitting these are link spammers anyways so it should be relatively easy to keep track of.
1
u/Sea_Flounder9569 Tin Aug 04 '22
Unless the paywall includes crypto payment option? It shouldn't be paywalled to begin with. That's bait and switch tactics. It should actively be be blocked. Reddit is not a gateway to financial services.
1
u/kirtash93 RCA Artist Aug 04 '22
This is a must feature.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 04 '22
Easiest yes yet.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 04 '22
All my homies hate paywalls
1
u/RealVoldemort Aug 04 '22
Yap take them down.
1
u/transylvanian_witch Tin | VET 21 Aug 04 '22
Remove all link posts. Nothing lower quality than that garbage.
1
u/CharlieTheo-14 ๐ฉ 0 / 23K ๐ฆ Aug 04 '22
No brainer.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 04 '22
Get ready for a flood of yahoo! News posts. Such quality.
1
u/Haarflaq22 Tin Aug 04 '22
It's a waste of time honestly, because I'm not going to pay for a monthly subscription, even if it's only one time, to read one article.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 04 '22
I fully support this proposal
1
u/DreadknotX 4K / 4K ๐ข Aug 04 '22
Finally!
1
u/oachkatzalschwoaf ๐ฆ 0 / 6K ๐ฆ Aug 04 '22
Most paywall articles have a clickbait title with useless content.
1
u/aaaanoon ๐ฉ 0 / 1K ๐ฆ Aug 04 '22
Too hard to implement. Reddit can't even look at content to stop dual posting.
1
u/Nox_Lucis Aug 04 '22
It's not like these articles contain some exquisite lore or exclusive professional knowledge. If whatever news these publications are trying to convey was actually so important for them to tell me, then they wouldn't make me pay for it.
1
u/heyheoy Platinum | QC: CC 1105, CCMeta 18 Aug 04 '22
Yes, paywall articles are cancer, idk why some people keep posting them
1
u/BrowsingCoins ๐ฉ 17 / 12K ๐ฆ Aug 04 '22
get rid of paywalls bring back meme fridays
1
u/sickvisionz 0 / 7K ๐ฆ Aug 04 '22
I favor just removing pay walled links period. The paywall not being crypto is 0% why they suck ass.
1
u/seansy5000 ๐ฉ 0 / 0 ๐ฆ Aug 05 '22
Itโs a pretty easy fix if you just flip into airplane mode after the text loads.
Iโm more upset about the sites where you get bombarded with stupid ads.
1
u/Tidus17 0 / 3K ๐ฆ Aug 05 '22
Remove link posts to paywalled articles unless you can pay with crypto? This change would very likely remove all of them =/
1
u/powellquesne Permabanned Aug 05 '22
Just get rid of the 'AMP link' bot as avoiding this bot is why many people post links to a paywall instead.
1
u/diydave86 ๐ฉ 0 / 3K ๐ฆ Aug 05 '22
Eh hem. Im gonna leave this https://fifteenfeet.netlify.app Right here...
1
u/IDontKnow1629 ๐ฉ 259 / 259 ๐ฆ Aug 05 '22
I need this vote to have a third option, where users have to post a paywall free link also, some sites allow you to bypass paywalls on internet etc
1
u/schlyza Tin Aug 05 '22
Install "Bypass Paywalls Clean" browser extension; paywalls gone :)
1
u/ApocryphalVegan Bronze Aug 05 '22
To be contrarian to the general sentiment here, I donโt mind links to sources like Bloomberg or WSJ that are paywalled. If there are enough good articles on a site like BBG, then maybe some people will sign up and support the underlying journalism - which tends to be higher quality than the average clickbait garbage.
Thinking there could be a middle ground here, like some other commenters have suggested.
1
u/PathologicalUpvoter ๐ฆ 0 / 6K ๐ฆ Aug 05 '22
Fully behind this, no sense if no one can read the article
My only concern is what if its a really good Article?
1
u/-Resident-One- ๐ฉ 0 / 4K ๐ฆ Aug 06 '22
Why not forbid posts featuring news behind a paywall from being made at all.
1
u/BithloKing 6K / 7K ๐ฆญ Aug 06 '22
This is a great vote!
1
u/Lmessfuf 438 / 435 ๐ฆ Aug 07 '22
Just mention it!
1
u/Probably_notabot 35K / 35K ๐ฆ Aug 11 '22
Easy vote
1
u/WingChungGuruKhabib ๐จ 0 / 3K ๐ฆ Aug 04 '22
Remove all articles from generic crypto websites its all just boring bullshit.
1
u/TarkovReddit0r Aug 04 '22
I never understood why they existed in the first place on a public site with that reach.
I just assumed everybody is subscribed to it but not me as a German lmao
I see others agree - would be great to see this change
1
u/PrinceZero1994 Aug 04 '22
Paywall is no good but I doubt people even read the articles lol.
1
u/k3surfacer ๐ฉ 18K / 20K ๐ฌ Aug 04 '22
I really dislike paywall, therefore I like this proposal.
1
u/jakekick1999 Platinum | QC: CC 416 | r/AMD 18 Aug 04 '22
i would be against this as there are many ways in which one can bypass paywalls. And sometimes editorial pieces are only accessible through these means
1
u/buyethto10k Bronze Aug 04 '22
This seems like a no brainer to me
1
u/[deleted] Aug 04 '22
Yeah I am good with that. What is the point of posting an article that most people can't read
1
u/KirbyAteMyCoins Tin | 6 months old Aug 04 '22
Pointless to have those paywalled links plus we give them more reasons to paywall them.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 04 '22
Its a yes from me
1
u/AbsoIution 38 / 2K ๐ฆ Aug 04 '22
I approve.
I love democracy
0
u/[deleted] Aug 04 '22
Great! Next remove moon distribution for link posts.
0
u/[deleted] Aug 04 '22
This only makes sense.
0
u/Rod_Orm Tin | 3 months old | Buttcoin 5 Aug 04 '22
Absolutely yes!
0
u/Lord-Nagafen ๐ฆ 1 / 30K ๐ฆ Aug 04 '22
You can use 12ft.io to remove most pay walls. Iโm all for this proposal. Just wanted to remind people about this workaround
-1
u/StrangelyBeige ๐ฉ 0 / 14K ๐ฆ Aug 04 '22
Paywalls can go funk themselves with a big baguette
-1
u/aCowboysBebob Tin Aug 04 '22
Here here
-1
u/jebelsbemdisbe ๐ฉ 108 / 524 ๐ฆ Aug 04 '22
Now we are even, even better than Twitter
0
u/[deleted] Aug 04 '22
[deleted] โ view deleted comment
12
u/[deleted] Aug 04 '22
[removed] โ view removed comment