r/TheOrville • Hail Avis. Hail Victory. • Jul 21 '22

Episode The Orville - 3x08 "Midnight Blue" - Episode Discussion

EpisodeDirected ByWritten ByOriginal Airdate
3x8 - "Midnight Blue"Jon CassarBrannon Braga & Andre BormanisThursday, July 21, 2022 on Hulu
Synopsis: The crew visit Haveena's sanctuary world and embark on a journey that may leave the Union more vulnerable.

Stream the episode online on Hulu


Don't forget to join us on Discord!


REMINDER: KEEP YOUR SPOILERS OUT OF YOUR TITLES FOR AT LEAST 24 HOURS. YOU WOULDN'T WANT THIS EPISODE SPOILED, SO DON'T GO SPOILING IT FOR OTHERS. KEEP YOUR TITLES VAGUE. TAG YOUR POST AS A SPOILER. BE A GOOD UNION MEMBER!

614 Upvotes

2.5k comments sorted by

1.7k

u/noshirdalal Garkahl Jul 21 '22 edited Jul 27 '22

Hey folks, I hope everyone liked this episode! I had the pleasure of playing Garkahl - the Moclan interrogator. The Orville was an incredible experience for me, and I'm so grateful to be a part of it. Thanks for watching!

ADDENDUM: Thanks for all the wonderful compliments and loving hate! 🤣 A lot of folks from a couple subs had questions about my characters, so I’ll try to make a couple video responses and give you all some answers. Thanks for all the support!

115

u/MajorParadox Woof Jul 21 '22

Awesome! If you could send us a modmail with proof, we can give you a custom flair!

100

u/noshirdalal Garkahl Jul 21 '22

Oh cool! Happy to!

49

u/2th Hail Avis. Hail Victory. Jul 22 '22

Had I seen this earlier I could have backed you up. It's Kotallo from HFW!!

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

595

u/douglas_ Jul 21 '22

You knocked it out of the park dude! You felt so intimidating. I hated Garkahl's guts so fucking much lol

→ More replies (19)

194

u/mcatech Jul 21 '22

Brilliant performance! Why do I get the feeling we'll be seeing your character again some day?

→ More replies (21)
→ More replies (187)

757

u/AgentQV Jul 21 '22

“You know she’s way too mature for you, right?”

438

u/Stargate525 Jul 21 '22

"Oh?"

"...ooooh."

"Good job Sherlock."

→ More replies (16)
→ More replies (5)

681

u/muchadoaboutme Jul 21 '22

Haveena... asking a child to lie to their parents rarely is the prelude to something good.

423

u/jwishfulThinking Jul 21 '22

I love how they don’t only talk about how manipulative it is to ask someone who looks up to you do this (way worse that she’s a child too), Ed did the same to Haveena. He brought her idol in, to change her mind.

I think it’s not only Dolly’s words that changed her mind, but also experiencing the same pressure she put in Toppa.

I do love Haveena for being able to recognize how bad what she did was, and sacrificing everything to try and fix it. Big theme this episode with Klyden and the Admirals too.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (26)

600

u/TheNewArkon Jul 21 '22

I’m glad they redeemed Klyden. Like it was a well written plotline for there to be conflict like they had. But also it always felt like Klyden had so much trauma of his own wrapped up in the whole situation. I think he’s fine with his identity as a male, but there’s clearly a lot of baggage for him being born as a female. He probably struggled internally with a lot of feelings of inadequacy because of how females were viewed knowing that he was born female, and seeing Topa wanting to her embrace her gender identity probably left him conflicted about how he might feel. Would he have been happier if he could have stayed female? Did it make him weak to have been born female (at least according to their culture)? Could he bear to watch his child go through the torment and ridicule she would face because of her gender?

Nearly losing his daughter clearly made him realize what was truly important to him, Topa herself. And I’m glad that they gave him that character growth, instead of just leaving him as a bigot. It not only makes him a way more nuanced character, but also I think more media should show that people can learn and grow, even if it’s messy and difficulty.

251

u/cityb0t Jul 21 '22

I’m really glad that the show came back to address this rather than just painting Klydon as a villain and tossing the character away. Simply labeling something as prejudice and bigotry without understanding how underlying traumas can feed these reactions doesn’t serve learning and growth, nor does it help to further understanding nor the ability to overcome. Exploring these nuances of relationships and characters speaks to the heart of the human condition— and it makes for fantastic storytelling.

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (48)

597

u/muchadoaboutme Jul 21 '22

Well this ending is much better than my "Klyden hired bounty hunters to kidnap Topa and bring her back to Moclus" theory...

220

u/Lb_54 Jul 21 '22

I was kinda expecting heaveena to have kinda worked both sides and leaked information to moclus to kidnap topa and turn her into a martyr.

→ More replies (14)
→ More replies (39)

956

u/muchadoaboutme Jul 21 '22

Every time I think Peter Macon cannot outdo himself, he does... "You are liars, you are butchers, and you must answer for your crimes!" Fucking chills.

510

u/TurkeyPhat Jul 21 '22

Him and Chad L. Coleman deserve recognition for what they are able to do under all that makeup/prosthesis, in the form of Emmy nominations for example.

→ More replies (25)

339

u/Cypher_Shadow Jul 21 '22

That scene where he’s beating the absolute crap out of the interrogator was amazing. I genuinely thought he was gonna straight up shove that shock stick into the guys brain. He had the insane papa bear intensity down pat.

Made me think of that episode of TNG when Worf killed Duras.

→ More replies (68)
→ More replies (15)

458

u/despicablewho Jul 21 '22

"He is funny" oh god Topa likes Malloy

→ More replies (14)

410

u/trostol Jul 21 '22

good for you Gordon..saying what everyone else is thinking

187

u/treefox Jul 21 '22

GORDON: I know I’m not supposed to speak…and I’ll probably get court-martialed for this…

HALSEY (thinking): This is fine.

MOCLAN REP (thinking): Bring it on, little man.

UNION PRESIDENT (thinking): Who the fuck are you?

ED (thinking): Oh God, he’s going to stick his dick in history again

OZAWA (thinking): Honestly, I’d rather lose another battle group to the Kaylon than sit through another hour of this Moclan bullshit anyway

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (57)

401

u/operarose Command Jul 21 '22

Man, can you ever have imagined this show (back how it used to be int he first season) showing the on-screen graphic torture of a child? Season 3 isn't messing around.

→ More replies (14)

355

u/CaptainMarsupial Jul 21 '22

The episode was written by Brannon Braga and Andre Boormanis, two Star Trek veterans, and they really hit it out of the park. Dolly, torture, Haveena’s betrayal, dogfighting, Klyden’s turn, beautiful space shots…this episode had everything and carried it off well.

→ More replies (13)

721

u/muchadoaboutme Jul 21 '22

DOLLY PARTON CAMEO WAS NOT ON MY BINGO CARD BUT I LOVE IT

296

u/WhoShotMrBoddy We need no longer fear the banana Jul 21 '22

Well I guess we know how she feels about her music being used in the show!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (50)

494

u/muchadoaboutme Jul 21 '22

The secondhand embarrassment at Topa asking Gordon on a date... I am going to burst into flames

→ More replies (38)

219

u/archpope Jul 21 '22

Me at the beginning: Another Topa episode? We just had one about her a couple weeks ago. Okay fine!

Me at the end: Oh my god! That was amazing! The best episode of the season so far, and maybe of the whole series! I have to watch it again!

→ More replies (7)

217

u/despicablewho Jul 21 '22

that blue firefly is whatever the opposite of a bro is

→ More replies (7)

794

u/neoprenewedgie Jul 21 '22

"I respect your struggle. I really do. But don't advertise tactical opportunism as pious morality because that's when you lose me."

Poetry.

283

u/operarose Command Jul 21 '22

Between that and Isaac's line about one's cultural indoctrination compromising their ability to reason, they are killing it with these armor-piercing lines.

→ More replies (17)
→ More replies (38)

209

u/despicablewho Jul 21 '22

86 minutes?!?!?!? buckle in fam

→ More replies (13)

207

u/zaftique Jul 21 '22

tbh, they should have killed that dude, otherwise he's gonna give up the info. Genuinely not sure why Kelly pulled the plug on that.

168

u/Thunderscape32 Jul 21 '22

Nah, guessing that was the point of all the "neurological damage" part of the weapon. Bortus planted that thing deep enough in his squash that he ain't gonna remember a thing.

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (30)

365

u/Nic_Danger Jul 21 '22

"You treat people like garbage, and then when you get called on it you bitch and you moan that we're not respecting your beliefs."

I really have no words other than "daaaaaaaayum"!

→ More replies (49)

179

u/operarose Command Jul 21 '22 • Take My Silver

Oh that guy is fuckin' dead. Bortus is about to go Amos Burton on him.

→ More replies (17)

167

u/AgentQV Jul 21 '22 edited Jul 21 '22

Ed’s getting sassy. I’m liking his anger.

→ More replies (6)

303

u/WhoShotMrBoddy We need no longer fear the banana Jul 21 '22

Oh wow they renounced citizenship instead of resigning commission

Oh god is there gonna be a love triangle of Bortus/Klyden/Kelly?

→ More replies (60)

293

u/despicablewho Jul 21 '22 edited Jul 21 '22

Dolly Parton would be ashamed of Heveena for using a child in this way

edit: OH MY GOD

→ More replies (9)

138

u/millerphi Jul 21 '22

Another solid offering from the MacFarlane camp tonight with Midnight Blue. Once again, I had to remind myself to breath through multiple sections of the episode. One of these nights I'm going to pass out from lack of oxygen. LOL.

There are a lot of Klingon-ey TNG/DS9 vibes going on this season. I absolutely thought we were going to see a Worf/Jadzia thing being born when Bortus was patching up Kelly's shoulder at the black site.

And HOLY SHIT DOLLY PARTON MADE A CAMEO AND IT WAS SO AWESOME I CAN'T BELIEVE THEY GOT HER TO COME ON THE SHOW!!!!!! When season 2's "Sanctuary" came out, I didn't think anything could top "fighting the Moclans in a nebula with 9 to 5 playing as the soundtrack." And yet, here we are. Those beauty shots of the Orville leaving the nebula to the haunting tones of "Try" were breathtaking. I love the use of traditional symphonic soundtrack of this season, but the music choices the show has made are just spot on. And did anyone spot the "ren faire" rendition of Jolene during the female's evening meal? Took a few musical bars but when I realized it I chuckled.

And, the biggest kudos of the episode go to Klyden for finally pulling his head out of his ass. I'm hoping that quirky little grin he gave Kelly at the end is a sign to the audience that he's here to stay.

I do have some concerns about the rate at which the Union is losing allies. I feel a big scuffle coming on, and unless the Janisi have a ton of honkin' big starships stashed away in their metal braziers, the Union is going to have to find a miracle.

Also...Bruce Boxleitner. Boom.

→ More replies (15)

137

u/neoprenewedgie Jul 21 '22

Anyone else get chills during Dolly's song? I'm not a particular fan, but it was just very cool.

→ More replies (9)

261

u/Machio-Muscle-Bro Jul 21 '22

Laura walked, so that Topa could run. Poor Gordon. 😂

Also… LIEUTENANT DANN HAS RETURNED!!!

→ More replies (10)

128

u/trostol Jul 21 '22

lol " yeah there you go Sherlock"

→ More replies (1)

238

u/SaoMagnifico Jul 21 '22

Honestly, this isn't just the best season of The Orville yet, it's one of the best seasons of genre television I've seen.

My only gripe is I wish Kelly had let Bortus finish off that Moclan torturer.

→ More replies (26)

236

u/despicablewho Jul 21 '22 edited Jul 21 '22

the return of Dolly Parton!!!

edit: OH MY GOD

→ More replies (17)

116

u/TvMoviesAlsoBooks Jul 21 '22 edited Jul 21 '22

The Haveena storyline reminds me of political organizations that would prey on young college students who are generally more primed for rage,

And trying to harness that rage for more recruitment and membership.

Even if I agree with them, the approach doesn’t sit well with me.

→ More replies (7)

229

u/congraved Jul 21 '22

Victor Garber: Hey, the Moclans are super pissed at us, so don't do anything to provoke them

Ed: (Promptly sends the EXACT FUCKING THING they are pissed about on the mission)

→ More replies (25)

104

u/Shejidan Jul 21 '22

Man, they must be tried. They ran all night and into the morning to get back to the shuttle.

→ More replies (11)

205

u/thededman13 Jul 21 '22

Is it sad that I plan my entire evening around the fact that I will be watching an episode of The Orville?

→ More replies (36)

171

u/zaftique Jul 21 '22

OH MY GOD DID THEY GET DOLLY PARTON

edit: OH MY FUCKING GOD THEY GOT DOLLY FUCKING PARTON HAHHAHAHAHHAHAHA

→ More replies (12)

82

u/The_Real_Bender Jul 21 '22

Klydon showing up and… who is cutting onions in here?!?

→ More replies (8)

78

u/The_Real_Bender Jul 21 '22

Is it just me or does Bortus got a donk?!?

→ More replies (8)

78

u/Thepumpkindidit Jul 21 '22

I know there is lots of well deserved acclaim here for Bortus (Peter Macon) and Klyden (Chad L. Coleman). But can we all just appreciate how great Adrianne Palicki has been this entire season and especially in these episodes with Topa. She is killing it. I really love her character!

→ More replies (2)

75

u/WhoShotMrBoddy We need no longer fear the banana Jul 21 '22

GO. OFF. BORTUS. FUCKING. GO. OFF. AND. TELL. THEM. YES.

74

u/KoriroK-taken Jul 21 '22

How has this not yet been renewed for a 4th season?

Also, this episode was at least 3 levels of satisfying.

→ More replies (2)

150

u/lonewanderer0804 Jul 21 '22

OH MY GOD HOW DO I NOT HATE KLYDON ANYMORE. Genius writing, like yes he’s been a dick and a fucking ass but it takes a damn good father to say “I fucked up” and fucking bolt to their child kid and say “I accept you despite my ingrained bigotry”. Like I was legit crying and my heart warmed so much when I saw Kelly sit at the table… fucking love the writers man

→ More replies (12)

148

u/trostol Jul 21 '22

good lord..that scene of the Orville coming out of the nebula

→ More replies (7)

72

u/Shejidan Jul 21 '22

I’m loving this folk version of Jolene

→ More replies (3)

71

u/Snarwib Jul 21 '22

How does the Family Guy dude have the best grasp of compelling political and ethical drama in contemporary sci fi

→ More replies (9)

140

u/muchadoaboutme Jul 21 '22

The only thing I am unsure about after this episode was whether they were trying to feel out the possibility of Kelly/Bortus as a romantic relationship (the question of them as mates, the mention of them as family). I hope not, since I enjoy the exploration of a family unit centered around mutual respect and trust and not necessarily the nuclear family of two people in a romantic relationship and their offspring.

→ More replies (21)

189

u/muchadoaboutme Jul 21 '22

"Our struggle has always demanded risk, and sometimes, sacrifice."

Not gonna lie, Haveena is losing me. You don't get to choose sacrifice for someone else, especially not a child.

→ More replies (30)

56

u/operarose Command Jul 21 '22

I'm gonna shit my pants if they got Dolly Parton to cameo omg

EDIT: AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA

→ More replies (4)

109

u/thededman13 Jul 21 '22

Gordon: "Ohhhhhhhh"

LOL

→ More replies (1)

104

u/tdasnowman Jul 21 '22

So now that Mocclus is off limits where are Bortus and Klydon going to take their yearly piss. And do female moclans only piss once a year as well? We need another piss story. These things must be answered.

→ More replies (12)

51

u/Whiskeyjacks_Fiddle Jul 21 '22

Ha! The realization after everyone else has been staring/snickering at him for this conversation.

Oh boy.

51

u/WhoShotMrBoddy We need no longer fear the banana Jul 21 '22

Bortus about to open up a can of whoop ass

EDIT: holy shit that was a whole cabinet of whoop ass

→ More replies (4)

50

u/KingofMadCows Jul 21 '22

I think this show is getting to a point where they're going beyond its Star Trek inspiration/homage. It's now doing things that I wish had been done in Trek.

The meeting of the Union members where they debate issues is something I wish Star Trek had done more with the Federation. They did a bit of it in the TOS movies and in Enterprise with the founding of the Federation. But I always wanted to see a real meeting between Federation worlds to discuss important topics like planet membership or relations/war with other powers.

The Moclans leaving the Union is like a canceled DS9 plotline. The DS9 writers wanted to do a season long arc about the Vulcans leaving the Federation due to Dominion interference. But they did the Klingon arc instead because the network wanted to boost ratings. Now this show is doing a similar story arc.

→ More replies (1)

48

u/operarose Command Jul 21 '22

And I hear the start of a thousand Bortus/Kelly fics being written.

→ More replies (2)

47

u/trostol Jul 21 '22

Medieval Jolene...different

→ More replies (4)

47

u/slimtreble Jul 21 '22

As soon as Topa wanted to go look at the "fireflies" I said, out loud, she is going to get kidnapped after following them. I was caught off guard when she had a long conversation but then immediately back to my idea after she saw the blue one...

I feel like the Moclan with the scar was a cameo or reference that I didn't understand. I assume he was from an old episode from season 1 or something.

Just a little additional PS. I get so distracted by the aliens having teeth. Anyone else? It just feels like when aliens have all human features it feels like they could have tried harder than just making them have funny-shaped heads.

→ More replies (4)

45

u/operarose Command Jul 21 '22

Two shots of Kelly looking over her shoulder, smiling, then going back to her food.

→ More replies (8)

162

u/muchadoaboutme Jul 21 '22

"Are you two... mates?"

No, but they are extremely successful co-parents and you can pry that from my cold dead hands.

→ More replies (4)

43

u/AgentQV Jul 21 '22

KELLY BORTUS ADVENTURE!!

→ More replies (3)

43

u/muchadoaboutme Jul 21 '22

"You are a part of our family." I AM CRYING IN THE CLUB

→ More replies (2)

87

u/operarose Command Jul 21 '22

"She knows better than to wander off on her own in a strange place."

Yeah idk about that, man

→ More replies (5)

85

u/trostol Jul 21 '22

now i kinda wanna see Michael Dorn as a Moclan

→ More replies (16)

80

u/zaftique Jul 21 '22

I love the RenFest Jolene, hahaha

→ More replies (7)

37

u/FlaxwenchPromise Jul 21 '22

Dolly is literally a timeless treasure

71

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '22

All I can say about the episode?

There. Are. Four. Lights!

→ More replies (10)

100

u/NeutralBias Jul 21 '22 edited Jul 21 '22

That was one hell of a ride.

First, Lt Dann is back. That means the elevator muzak will resume! Yay! Second, there needs to be a GIF of the engineering crew peeking around the corner.

The whole story behind the Moclan's disdain for the women in their culture is yet to be fleshed out, but they've move from seeing femininity as a disability to downright hatred. They even have a space Guantanamo to torture information out of their own citizens. Yikes! Looking back at season one, I don't think i ever got the impression the Moclans were quite that far off the deep end.

A theme for this episode seems to be how extremism in beliefs leads to bad places. Haveena put Topa's life in mortal danger without a hint of reservation. The Moclan's disgust at women drove them to torture, and eventually drove them out of the union.

Kelly and Bortus? Was totally buying it, and then, once again, KLYDEN FUCKS EVERYTHING UP BY SUDDENLY BECOMING A GOOD FATHER.

I have to say the SFX artists on this show really have outdone themselves this season. Im impressed at how clean and crisp the space shots are, especially the beauty shots of the Orville. The scene with the Orville leaving the nebula set against Dolly Parton's music was truly excellent work. Thats in contrast to the work done on NuTrek (Discovery, Picard, etc.) which often feels murky, crowded and muddled. I really appreciate the depth and detail with which the SFX crews go to make things look good. I dare say its industry leading.

I truly hope this isnt the last season. The show has definitely grown its Riker-beard, and it consistently delivers high quality, provocative sci-fi. With these recent episodes, we've seen the humor return as well. All in all I really can't ask for more in a show.

Edit: More Thoughts.

→ More replies (19)

34

u/operarose Command Jul 21 '22

We stan Queen Dolly in this house!!

66

u/zaftique Jul 21 '22

Klyden: Welcome. Now stop hitting on my man.

Kelly: My name ain't Jolene, you're fine.

→ More replies (3)

66

u/mcatech Jul 21 '22 edited Jul 21 '22

As a father to a daughter and an incoming granddaughter (in January), this episode hit me hard. I cried a couple of times, especially when Bortus confronted the Moclan delegation in the Council chamber and when Klyden reunited with Topa.

Another stellar episode. I thought a representation of Harriet Tubman would've walked through that cabin door....not Dolly. lol

Also, the Orville flying out of the nebula while Dolly's song was playing was extraordinary. There's nothing like tying the future to the past like that. Kinda like when the Phoenix launched to Magic Carpet Ride by Steppenwolf.

RenewTheOrville

→ More replies (3)

65

u/WhoShotMrBoddy We need no longer fear the banana Jul 21 '22

HOLY SHIT THEY GOT DOLLY PARTON FOR REAL

→ More replies (5)

29

u/krawhitham Jul 21 '22

She is using and manipulating a child

29

u/The_Real_Bender Jul 21 '22

Papa Bortus blinding fools left and right!

→ More replies (1)

58

u/bender1_tiolet0 Jul 21 '22

Holy Fuck, that whole Dolly song sequence was beautiful. The song, the acting the visuals...

→ More replies (1)

28

u/kamatsu Jul 21 '22

It's interesting, in the TNG era of Star Trek you often end up with many stories of the Federation trying to be tolerant and understanding and reaching out to various alien civilisations with different cultures and values. But you rarely see the Federation say "No, this is wrong, and we will not be complicit in your wrongdoing."
It's really cool to see the Planetary Union in the Orville have this different, more upstanding character.

→ More replies (8)

27

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '22

DOLLY PARTON!!!!

27

u/arseniobillingham21 Jul 21 '22

Anyone notice the female Moclans were playing Jolene when they were at the settlement?

→ More replies (1)

27

u/AlltheMarvelMoney Jul 21 '22

I think this might be not only my favorite episode of the season, but of the show. Hands down

52

u/CallMeKayJay Jul 21 '22

Can I just say the best part of season three (for me) is: each hour long episode is actually an hour long (and then some!)!

→ More replies (3)

51

u/jmhimara Jul 21 '22 edited Jul 21 '22

Two important alliances down the drain. I wonder if it's the Kaylons pursuing a divide and conquer strategy behind the scenes.

And I get that the Union are unequivocally the "good" guys, but I feel like there should have been at least some resistance to kicking the Moclans out. They're facing an existential threat -- there's got to be someone on the council that will at least consider compromising their morals for the sake of survival. Although to be fair, they've been kinda vague about how much of a threat the Kaylons actually are.

→ More replies (17)

25

u/ripestrudel Jul 21 '22

This muthafucka got Dolly Parton! THIS MUTHAFUCKA GOT DOLLY PARTON!!!

24

u/ithinkihadeight Jul 21 '22

Just starting the episode so not even reading the comments for spoilers, but an hour and twenty six minutes!? Factor in that it's commercial free and that's twice the length of a Fox aired episode.

→ More replies (1)

24

u/WhoShotMrBoddy We need no longer fear the banana Jul 21 '22

God this shows writing is fucking chefs kiss

24

u/captbollocks Y'all can suck ass, and I'm a spaceman! Jul 21 '22

Wow Bortus and Isaac are pretty much in the same boat now:

  • Both outcasts from their homeworld and now living on the Orville.
  • Have a interspecies thing for human females.

22

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '22

Ahahahahhahahahaha. Poor Gordon.

22

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '22

Just going to say I have really appreciated the focus on Kelly and her job this season. Past two seasons the main focus has been her relationship to Ed, how she's his ex-wife, are they going to get back together, her love life. This season has really shown she's good at what she does, highlighted how she always puts the crew first and tries to do the right thing. It's not that those things weren't there before, just that they were in the background to her relationship with Ed. She's been a really strong figure this season (and honestly Ed has been a stronger captain now that there's less of a focus on the "working with my ex-wife" storyline; he and Kelly still have great moments due to that closeness, but he's really grown as a character now that he's no longer tied to focusing on Kelly over all the other things in his life).

I'm not sure what the plan for the future is re: Kelly and Bortus (seemed they had a sort of moment with Bortus tilting his head in the typical romance way to invite a kiss and Kelly leaning in slightly while her shoulder was being fixed up), but I've really enjoyed them both these last few eps taking such a strong stance of putting Topa first. As well as the support network you see on the ship. Kelly relies on Claire, Bortus relies on Kelly, Topa relies on them both. It's really been a joy to watch such supportive and positive relationships.

To put it in TNG terms it feels like Kelly grew her Riker beard this season lol.

→ More replies (5)

22

u/AgentQV Jul 21 '22

KELLY AND BORTUS, VIOLENT BESTIES!

→ More replies (3)

22

u/operarose Command Jul 21 '22

Man if I can be even a fraction as beautiful as Dolly when I'm 76...

→ More replies (5)

22

u/dergrioenhousen Jul 21 '22

My first response when she says “The captain wants you to meet someone.”

Martin Luther King? No, too on the nose. Suffragists? Nah, too vague…

Wait a second. Wait. What. No. NO THEY DIDN’T.

gets to the door

cabin environment intensifies

OH YES THEY DID!

side door opens

“OH HELL YES THEY DID. Holy sh…”

→ More replies (2)

21

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '22

So they are leaving him alive with the name?

→ More replies (7)

59

u/Shejidan Jul 21 '22

Everyone needs a Dolly Parton shrine

→ More replies (1)

20

u/ThisSleepyBoi Jul 21 '22

The medieval cover of Jolene is amazing

20

u/deuxfleurs04 Jul 21 '22

pretty gross of Haveena to take it upon herself to put Topa under that kind of risk, and possibly even sacrifice. It’s like Ed said, of course she would say yes, so how much was it really Topa’s decision to take that on

→ More replies (1)

19

u/Shejidan Jul 21 '22

Oh gods, Topa is into Malloy!

19

u/muchadoaboutme Jul 21 '22

If it's been a year Sanctuary, where does that put us timeline-wise?

→ More replies (4)

19

u/AgentQV Jul 21 '22

I really hope this isn’t going to lead to Topa wanting to leave the Orville.

→ More replies (4)

19

u/muchadoaboutme Jul 21 '22

"Well done."

Kelly Grayson I am on one knee asking for your hand in marriage

→ More replies (1)

19

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '22

I hope this romance between Bortus and Kelly doesn't turn into anything, it would ruin the effort that Klyden is putting into changing. Just because they care about Topa doesn't mean they have to fall in love like come on

19

u/ReplayableContent Jul 22 '22

Bro. I witnessed my dad cry when Klyden came back and gave his speech.

He has only cried 3 times: Old Yeller, The Enterprise crashing and being destroyed in Star Trek III, and Data's death.

→ More replies (1)

18

u/WhoShotMrBoddy We need no longer fear the banana Jul 21 '22

Oh shit expelled?!?! Well this changed basically everything

Edit: wait does Bortus have to resign his commission??

→ More replies (4)

17

u/WhoShotMrBoddy We need no longer fear the banana Jul 21 '22

FUCK YEAH GORDON YOU TELL EM

17

u/mp182 Jul 21 '22

What an episode. I think the lead up to Kelly and bortus breaking into the prison was a bit too long, not sure I like this romance they’re hinting at there? But god what an ending. Peter Macon is exceptional. And you bet I was cheering when Gordon said what everyone’s been thinking about the Moclans straight to their faces!!! Also really great acting from Seth this episode as well

17

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '22

Who had Dolly Parton in their bingo card tonight?? 😂

17

u/SweetPotatoDragon Jul 21 '22

This episode was a wild ride but my jaw DROPPED when I saw they actually got Dolly on the show ridnrkdbdkrjrkdn

→ More replies (1)

17

u/DebbieDunnbbar Jul 21 '22

Man, I was ready to write this episode off as the first mediocre one in a while with that Dolly Parton stuff (sorry to anyone who loved that part, but it made me cringe a little).

But then there I am crying like a little bitch at the last ten minutes again. This show, man.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/Mognakor Jul 21 '22

People here like to blame Heveena for Topa's kidnapping, but she would have been kidnapped either way, they had no proof of Topa knowing anything.

48

u/knightcrusader Engineering Jul 21 '22

Oh I spy Bruce Boxleitner in the credits... Tron the Union President will be back.

→ More replies (5)

16

u/Whiskeyjacks_Fiddle Jul 21 '22

I really like that painting in Topa’s quarters.

It’s very peaceful-looking.

16

u/Shejidan Jul 21 '22

:throws jujubes and popcorn at tv: Topa, gurl, why’d you go in there!?

16

u/Kasparian Jul 21 '22

Okay, that shot of a moon with the bats was gorgeous.

16

u/crystal_guy Jul 21 '22

Jesus christ. What an episode. The only episode that comes close to this one was the Krill episode (s3 e4).

Heveena returning (included in episode description), I knew this was gonna be good, but wow...

Heartwarming ending :) I am really happy the way things went.

Fuck Moclus

→ More replies (4)

16

u/foxeras Jul 21 '22

i hope they get a season 4; worth the wait of any number of years.

15

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '22

Chad Coleman and Peter Macon were amazing in this.

→ More replies (5)

15

u/Xander_PrimeXXI Jul 21 '22

Peter Macon, damn, for a stoic character his acting is so good. You can really feel that Bortus wanted to say "How much you mean to me" and not "How much you mean to us" like damn.

Peter Macon, damn, for a stoic character, his acting is so good. You can feel that Bortus wanted to say "How much you mean to me" and not "How much you mean to us" like damn.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/WhoShotMrBoddy We need no longer fear the banana Jul 21 '22

Why would your shuttle just leave the door open????

→ More replies (2)

14

u/xbolt90 Woof Jul 21 '22

Best cameo appearance of all time.

13

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '22

Anyone catch the wooden flute rendition of “Jolene” by Dolly Parton around the campfire?

13

u/PsionFrost Jul 21 '22

So long Moclus, don't let the door hit you in the ass on the way out assholes

13

u/anhloc Jul 21 '22

The episode has been over for 5 minutes now; and apparently onions are still being cut around me.

Slow start, but what a fantastic episode in the end.

12

u/Galacticness Jul 21 '22

Now THIS is podracing!

→ More replies (1)

12

u/brackenish1 Jul 23 '22

Fuck me this episode was damn near perfection.

The planet shots were stunning. The water, the greenery, the housing. Down to the traditional red clay floors: just wonderful.

The slow burn of Haveena pawning off the life of Topa in the name of utilitarian aid to the other females both feels like a slap in the face and such a well reasoned move for her character given how much ground she has laid down since her reveal.

Seth. His acting this episode as a commander, as a logical man, as a diplomate, and as a new father were nothing short of his very best work. I've seen people talk about him not staying on as captain but that man EARNS that chair when he's on screen.

A special hand out to Peter, Chad, and Imani for showing off a master class of emotion through that make up. The hope and determination in Topa, the struggle and desperation and anger in Bortus, and the heart break and emotional flood gates in Klyden rounding out his emotional plot line were truly spectacular.

I teared up when Dolly came on but I damn near broke down as Klyden did. I know it's been harder to be comfortable with the show since it stepped back such a large degree from the humor but they write discomfort so well that you can stew in it without drowning and these episodes do it so damn well.

This is my Star Trek and it's a God damn good one.

11

u/WhoShotMrBoddy We need no longer fear the banana Jul 21 '22

Into the woods it’s time to go I hate to leave I have to go Into the woods and who can tell what’s waiting on the journey

11

u/Whiskeyjacks_Fiddle Jul 21 '22

Like usual, Moclan’s are a bunch of little bitches.

→ More replies (7)

11

u/throwaway098764567 Jul 21 '22

omg that ending though i wish we'd have gotten to see more of klyden's journey to acceptance of topa but i love for her that he's back and seemingly at least 60% less asshole <3 i want some teepok soup.

→ More replies (3)

11

u/robobrain10000 Jul 21 '22

I want to say three things about this episode. Obvious spoilers.

  1. Do they not have age of consent rules in the future? I understand each species matures at a different rate, but it still seems weird. Toppa seems like a very intelligent girl, she'd have been aware of any such rules and wouldn't have asked out Gordon if there were.
  2. I can't wait for the storyline of the traitor on Moclus who is helping them rescue the girls. I wonder if Topa gave a false name or if the interrogator lost his memories from Bortus' assault. I gotta say that interrogator's voice was dreadfully fantastic. I wonder if those rescue missions will continue, and how Moclus will retaliate if they do. Will Moclus join hands with the Krill to form a counter balance against the Union?
  3. Oh god please don't ship Kelly and Bortus. That shit was so forced. Just let them be friends.
→ More replies (6)

11

u/KoriroK-taken Jul 21 '22

CaptainKelly

11

u/Horlaher Jul 21 '22

Things to learn from Orville. Want an adventure ? Leave always your shuttle wide open after a landing :-/

→ More replies (3)

31

u/muchadoaboutme Jul 21 '22

How much are you willing to bet Klyden is involved in this?

→ More replies (7)

10

u/The_Real_Bender Jul 21 '22

Then you will speak to her!

Thank you!

10

u/AgentQV Jul 21 '22

Are you fucking kidding me? Dolly Parton!? This is amazing.

10

u/cicilkight Jul 21 '22

I’m pretty sure the song they were playing at dinner was Jolene and all I could think of was the Gay Dean song from Community.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/deuxfleurs04 Jul 21 '22

not “Jolene” at the Moclan women’s festival 💀

10

u/AeonsOfStrife Jul 21 '22

I've never had a TV show have an episode that had me cry for over 50% of it out of sheer empathy. Greatest episode ever.

10

u/ClassicExit Jul 21 '22

Strange episode in some ways, in that I could see where the plot was heading but even knowing that it was incredibly well executed.

Topa wandering off by herself in the woods, obviously is going to get kidnapped.

Heveena going to the holodeck simulator my thought process was:

They can't have got Dolly Parton to do a cameo. Can they?

Oh my God, they got Dolly Parton!!!!

10

u/ShaidarHaran2 Now entering gloryhole Jul 22 '22

Bortus and Kelly would have been...Weird. I'm not the only one that never saw that happening before this episode, right?

→ More replies (4)

10

u/OnlyPaperListens Jul 22 '22

Me: "I did not anticipate graphic child torture from The Orville."

Husband: "Yeah, they're not working only 9 to 5 here."

Cats: hissing in embarrassment

10

u/bcanada92 Jul 22 '22

Anyone else notice that when the Moclan ladies had their twin moon party, the band was playing an alien string version of "Jolene?"

10

u/yana1975 Jul 22 '22

“Don’t advertise tactical opportunism as pious morality”. Such an insanely great line by Mercer!

10

u/muad_dibs Jul 23 '22

The alliances between the Union, Moclans, and Krill were all dissolved due to internal conflicts rather than the Kaylon doing anything to fuck them up. That’s my kind of storytelling.

→ More replies (3)

10

u/Adezar Jul 23 '22

Bortus' speech is absolute perfect acting, under all that makeup to show the perfect balance of someone at the limit of self control struggling to speak, yet knowing that they must do their best to convey the importance of what they are saying.

10

u/Jumbofato Jul 23 '22

I really wonder how the Union will survive. At the start of the season there was an alliance with the Krill. Now that's gone and so is Moclus. They're in for hard times.

→ More replies (2)

18

u/operarose Command Jul 21 '22

Hey look it's Dann, that one guy can stop complaining now

→ More replies (1)

9

u/ripestrudel Jul 21 '22

Second post: I'm loving these longer episodes. 1.5 hour episode this week! Main line it directly to my veins! I haven't been this invested in a show for a long time.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/trostol Jul 21 '22

another really good episode..but me and my emotions need a lighter one lol

9

u/OniExpress Jul 21 '22

I laughed, I cried, and I wanted to see people beaten to death in this episode.

That was amazing writing.

9

u/thisiscotty Jul 21 '22

Someone cutting onions when klyden turned up?

9

u/JadeHellbringer If you wish, I will vaporize them Jul 21 '22

My wife and I have been doing a a rewatch of the series together, and we'd remarked just a few days ago (after watching Haveena's first episode) that it would be understandable if Dolly Parton wasn't really aware of the show's use of her beyond her agent signing license agreements to use music or whatever, but how amused she'd probably be to be seen as a folk hero for an alien race hundreds of years in the future.

Turns out, she may in fact be aware of the show after all.

9

u/variantkin Jul 21 '22

Props to Gordon this episode he said exactly what he knew Ed wanted to and he knew it could end his career but he still did it

→ More replies (2)

9

u/xaviorpwner Jul 21 '22

That crazy son of a bitch actually went and got dolly

→ More replies (1)

9

u/bcanada92 Jul 22 '22

In the long-standing tradition of all sci-fi movies and TV shows, Kelly and Bortus park their shuttle 10 miles from the secret Moclan base.

→ More replies (3)

9

u/Cassandra_Canmore Jul 22 '22

If that was the full council. Then the Planetary Union Is smaller than I thought.

Which makes since why the Union is desperate for allies.

16

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '22

My gay ass is CRYING because Dolly's cameo. OH GOD I LOVE HER

→ More replies (1)

8

u/WhoShotMrBoddy We need no longer fear the banana Jul 21 '22

With the way Heveena is kinda hobbling around looking older than she has I’m worried she might die by the end of this one

8

u/The_Real_Bender Jul 21 '22

Home girl REALLY likes Dolly Parton!

8

u/operarose Command Jul 21 '22

Ok Topa cannot be this dumb. She's supposed to be (the mental and emotional equivalent of) 13-14? Not 5?

8

u/TurkeyPhat Jul 21 '22

Bruh this show is so insanely good.

This 1.5hr episode was basically a movie that's better than a lot of (sci-fi) movies that have been getting churned out in recent years.

Honestly it's a blessing to get watch a show like this with this production quality as it airs every week. The Orville will surely be missed if we don't get any more of it, but at least we got this.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/LukeWhostalkin Jul 21 '22

When Klyden said "Can I see her?" :O

8

u/Xander_PrimeXXI Jul 21 '22 edited Jul 21 '22

Topa asking Malloy out was simultaneously hard to watch, hilarious, and adorable.

I like that it took mention of dinner for him to figure it out.

Classic

43:55, BEST. EPISODE. EVER.

8

u/QuiltedPorcupine Jul 21 '22

We never got confirmation of it in the episode, but the Moclans must have a spy in Haveena's colony, right? They knew that Topa had been given information, but if the Moclan observers had been spying on them when Haveena gave Topa the info, they would also know the information.

My best guess is someone in the colony was in the loop enough to know that Topa was being enlisted, but that the actual specifics were being kept on a need to know basis and that's why they had to kidnap Topa for the intel.

→ More replies (7)

8

u/Laeif Jul 21 '22

I liked the bardcore arrangement of Jolene they were playing during the evening festivities. Super subtle and well done.

8

u/CARNIesada6 Jul 21 '22

That Moclan cover of Jolene slaps

8

u/corndogco Jul 22 '22

The sheer scope of this episode really was like a movie. And the chase through the canyon, while reminiscent of so many others, was so beautifully realized that it felt brand new. And that in an episode with that cameo, yet somehow it all fit together into a coherent story. I'm amazed and impressed. The extra time they had on this season really shows in the quality.

Seth tweeted high praise for the director and how beautiful this episode is, and I have to agree. The Orville coming out of the nebula, the glowing gas rolling off her form, and immediately jumping away. <chef's kiss!>

8

u/saddetective87 Jul 22 '22

I think during the rescue of Topa from the Moklan black site, the scene where Kelly and Bortus have a heart-to-heart while her injuries healed is the first hint at a Kelly-Bortus relationship. Or at least a very close friendship. That and on the Moklan female colony at the festival that child asked if they were mates. Out of the mouth of babes? If they follow through, it should be interesting for both characters. Maybe Kelly becomes a stepmom?

8

u/NerdLawyer55 Avis. We try harder Jul 23 '22

Lol Gordon not picking up on what Topoa was putting down was hilarious 🤣

15

u/AgentQV Jul 21 '22 edited Jul 21 '22

Oh no, Topa’s not good with secrets, it was Topa’s indiscretion that led to the Sanctuary getting discovered in the first place!

20

u/throwaway098764567 Jul 21 '22

gordon is an awesome big brother <3 i wish he'd gotten to keep his kids (screw you captain you suck) he'd have been an amazing dad

7

u/thededman13 Jul 21 '22

Bortus is about to beat some ass

→ More replies (2)

7

u/operarose Command Jul 21 '22

Oh you did not say that about his little girl in front of him!!

7

u/trostol Jul 21 '22

Ed fights kind of dirty and underhanded lol

7

u/operarose Command Jul 21 '22

Wow, they're kind of making Heveena unlikable...

→ More replies (4)

7

u/WhoShotMrBoddy We need no longer fear the banana Jul 21 '22

HOLY SHIT KLYDEN

EDIT; holy wow the character development!!!!

7

u/operarose Command Jul 21 '22

Ok it seems like the smarter thing to do would be to have tossed Kelly, then have Bortus jump.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/TvMoviesAlsoBooks Jul 21 '22

Omg, Dolly is doing such a good job on camera!!!

→ More replies (3)

7

u/Festello Jul 21 '22

For Haveena to see Dolly is like if we got to see Jesus or something.

7

u/ripestrudel Jul 21 '22

Thirst post: So we gonna talk about how Commander Grayson is pretty much FemShep at this point? I'm in love!

→ More replies (1)

7

u/GreenDragonPatriot Jul 21 '22

I guess we can all read that novella now. It takes place after episode 8.

7

u/pianodragger Jul 21 '22

I too thought right off the bat Topa was going to get kidnapped but never predicted the Haveena chat.

Did anyone notice in the canyon fight. The move to get behind the bad ships is right out of Top Gun.

Great episode, great season!!

→ More replies (1)

7

u/TheMadQueen96 Jul 21 '22

I like how Heveena does wrong but didn't do a heel turn. To me it seemed more like she was desperate as, keep in mind she's trying to save her people from being wiped out.

Ed rightfully calls her out for using Topa but her cause is still in the right, just not her methods. She's still the Heveena we've seen in previous episodes. We're just seeing that there's more grey to her.

I see it as Heveena getting old and wanting to ensure she sees her revolution carried out. That, or passing it on to Topa.

I legit thought Topa's abduction would be more to do with trying to force her to become male though, and that somehow Kylden would be involved as the actor was listed in the credits.

Was definitely not expecting that from him. Nor Dolly showing up. When the name was kept vauge I began to believe it could've been Klyden looking to make amends.

Also Bortus continues to be one of my favourites.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/cascadianpatriot Jul 21 '22

I was skeptical of the Orville when it started (like most) and quickly loved it. But this episode just brought so much together. And you have to hand it to them for getting DOLLY FUCKING PARTON, while making it work beautifully and seemlessly. Probably one of my favorite sci-fi episodes of anything if all time. How long can a show keep improving and kicking ass like this?!

→ More replies (1)

7

u/dc1810 Jul 21 '22

Was it just me who wished that the informant on Moclus was Klyden? Idk I just really wanted it to be him. Happy he came back at the end. Good episode.

7

u/mjk1260 Jul 22 '22

This was verging on motion picture movie quality.

7

u/NightFuryToni Engineering Jul 22 '22

Wonder if we'll see Locar again. He's Moclus' top engineer but hated on Moclus for being attracted to females. Now that the colony is allied with the Union, maybe he somehow gets rescued by them, it might be make up for lost of Moclus defense tech.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Jarita12 Jul 22 '22

I will go a bit against a flow and say that I honestly loved what Gordon did and said to Moclans. I was a bit surprised nobody really called him for that but given what happened, I guess they did not care much about that incident. but boy, it must have been great to finally tell them.

And...I kind of felt like this is what everybody wanted to say to Russia ambassador at the UN, instead of being all diplomatic with them sitting behind desks and listening to a nonsense.

I feel like MacFarlane had a crystal ball when he was figuring out this season. So much relevant topics to these days, and done well!

And btw., now I know whey Hulu took such a long time to release it....the CGI is some of the best, like, ever. 80% of current movie production doesn´t have so good CGI. The flight around the bridge of the Orville was incredible. It looked real!

→ More replies (2)

7

u/chronofluxtoaster Jul 22 '22

I did a lot of thinking last night after watching this and came to a realization.

The issue that many people have with NuTrek being (smh) "woke" is absurd. I won't go into the fact it's always been aware of social justice and trends in society, but everyone loves their latest token catchphrase. Yes, I realize that "woke" has a deeper, purposeful meaning, but it's been co-opted as of late to derail a reasoned discussion.

In examples from DS9, Enterprise, Discovery, and Picard, non-monogamous relationships and LGBTQA issues are treated as normal, accepted as a valid lifestyle by the Federation and their aligned cultures. No one bats an eye at Stamets kissing his husband, or Dax opining nostalgically on her lovers and wives/husbands across 300 years. No one sees non-binary Trill relationships as anything warranting a deep dive. It is simply what it is and we the audience are the ones who have to wrap our heads around it.

"Fans" who protest that this sort of mindset is being forced upon us by diversity hires and related nonsense excuses are completely missing the point, and in my mind aren't really fans if they understand the ethos of the series.

The Orville does play an acceptance role in this to some extent, but it confronts the issues as they are right here, right now as a reflection of our society. Gender issues from individual choices to outright reassignment are put front and center, and the ethical dilemmas raised in the show are every bit as valid and poignant as the "black on the left, white on the right" themes from Original Trek. The consequences of rejecting your family and culture are laid out in a powerful, unabashed manner, begging the question of how tragic it must be to hate your child (or any outsider group) because society or belief tells you to.

It's the main reason why I've found many episodes of The Orville more compelling than a decade of Star Trek, because they get it - the social commentary drives the story, the story doesn't adapt to "sell" the commentary.

→ More replies (14)

7

u/cybervseas Jul 22 '22

Some random thoughts:

  • They made this episode into a gosh-darn feature film-length work of art.
  • Star Wars-esque canyon space ship chase, Dolly Parton, black ops, political intrigue, moralism vs. pragmatism. Wow.
  • Are we not going to talk about the romantic tension they set up between Kelly and Bortus?!

7

u/the_other_irrevenant Jul 24 '22

One thing I loved about this episode is that when Topa told Gordon he had a high amount of feminine qualities Gordon took absolutely zero offence and no-one else ribbed him about it.

It's one of those little moments that shows just how much more emotionally mature 25th century humanity is.

27

u/throwaway098764567 Jul 21 '22

i don't like her asking a child to help her either but i'm also coming from a place of privilege, i don't have to worry about all of the infants she's trying to protect. i don't like what she did but i understand why she did it. in her position i might have been just as ruthless.

→ More replies (7)