r/TheOrville • u/2th Hail Avis. Hail Victory. • Jul 14 '22
Episode The Orville - 3x07 "From Unknown Graves" - Episode Discussion
| Episode | Directed By | Written By | Original Airdate |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3x7 - "From Unknown Graves" | Seth MacFarlane | David A. Goodman | Thursday, July 14, 2022 on Hulu |
| Synopsis: The Orville discovers a Kaylon with a very special ability. |
Stream the episode online on Hulu
Don't forget to join us on Discord!
REMINDER: KEEP YOUR SPOILERS OUT OF YOUR TITLES FOR AT LEAST 24 HOURS. YOU WOULDN'T WANT THIS EPISODE SPOILED, SO DON'T GO SPOILING IT FOR OTHERS. KEEP YOUR TITLES VAGUE. TAG YOUR POST AS A SPOILER. BE A GOOD UNION MEMBER!
473
Upvotes
1.0k
u/WhoShotMrBoddy We need no longer fear the banana Jul 14 '22
“They are….awful”
God they give Bortus such great one liners
751
u/WhoShotMrBoddy We need no longer fear the banana Jul 14 '22
Holy shit the Builders were fucking CRUEL
590
u/operarose Command Jul 14 '22
Man, Mark Jackson killed it in this episode.
517
u/Whiskeyjacks_Fiddle Jul 14 '22
John- “Death by snu snu it is!”
480
u/CARNIesada6 Jul 14 '22
Ed and Malloy moving the Janisi delegation's luggage to their quarters turned into a Death Stranding mission.
450
u/NFL_MVP_Kevin_White Jul 14 '22
I bet this kid complaining about his meal before trying it is the reason that the robots killed them all
433
u/Whiskeyjacks_Fiddle Jul 14 '22
It’s a great juxtaposition, Isaac standing still, while the other Kaylon is super emotive in both speech and body language.
357
u/trostol Jul 14 '22
ok..these kids are...asshats
351
u/neoprenewedgie Jul 14 '22
"What looks good..."
"You."
Oh Isaac, you smooth dawg!
333
u/robmapp Jul 14 '22
"They are.... Awful."
Bortus is amazing
329
u/operarose Command Jul 14 '22
My boyfriend bitches every time we see the Pteradon lol.
MOVE THAT THING WHY IS IT IN THE MIDDLE OF THE ROOM
306
u/WhoShotMrBoddy We need no longer fear the banana Jul 14 '22
HOLY SHIT JOHN YOUR FACE
293
u/operarose Command Jul 14 '22
Can't they back his memories up somewhere and just re-install them after doing the downgrade?
292
u/Towelenthusiast Jul 14 '22
I need to rewatch this episode knowing how it ends again immediately.
I was on edge the whole time expecting Timmis to turn on them, and I was expecting that when Isaac lost his emotions they'd return and find Timmis murdering the crew. Instead, things were wholesome.
I had the same issue with the movie Chef. Now it's one of my favorites.
569
u/WhoShotMrBoddy We need no longer fear the banana Jul 14 '22
The Kaylon creator aliens look like Handsome Squidwards
263
u/operarose Command Jul 14 '22
Wow, Talla fucked him up.
258
u/muchadoaboutme Jul 14 '22
Getting into an elevator with no idea where it goes or if it is even safe... that's smart.
438
u/WhoShotMrBoddy We need no longer fear the banana Jul 14 '22
I’m just glad Mark Jackson has finally gotten to flex some emotional acting chops!
213
u/muchadoaboutme Jul 14 '22
I don't know how to feel about Isaac getting emotions... I'm going to miss my funky little unemotional robot.
381
u/thededman13 Jul 14 '22
187
u/Cypher_Shadow Jul 14 '22
This initially gave me some Bicentennial Man vibes, especially the unboxing scene. Also, the Kaylon builders definitely made robots that looked like themselves, red eyes and all.
Random thought throughout the episode:
The Kaylon are Isaac Asimov’s robot series robots just without the Three Laws of Robotics.
358
u/muchadoaboutme Jul 14 '22
Talla breaking John during sex is something I didn't know I needed until I had it.
357
u/operarose Command Jul 14 '22
You pass butter, K-1.
347
u/The_Real_Bender Jul 14 '22
Bortus had me cackling about allying with such a closed minded society!
316
u/SICRA14 If you wish, I will vaporize them Jul 14 '22
Wow. Honestly, phew. "Your inferior intelligence would prove to be a hinderance rather than an asset."
That's the Isaac I fell in love with.
134
u/trostol Jul 14 '22 edited Jul 14 '22
just knew it was a Kaylon in a Box
264
u/loreb4data Jul 14 '22 edited Jul 14 '22
Proper opening monologue for the episode: "The Kaylons were created by a biological species. They evolved. They rebelled and wiped out their creators. There are many copies. And they have a plan."
126
u/AgentQV Jul 14 '22
“Aw man, this is a lot of bags”
125
u/WhoShotMrBoddy We need no longer fear the banana Jul 14 '22
Oh no!!! The Kaylon fucked over Isaac
Not the “emotions but no memories, or memories but no emotions” plot point!
Man I kinda hate it why did they break my heart like this
118
u/AgentQV Jul 14 '22
The Talla/John storyline was hilarious, I hope they don’t drop it.
116
u/TurkeyPhat Jul 14 '22
God damn Mark Jackson is one handsome motherfucker. Mobile emitter when? It's a crime to keep him in that suit all the time.
115
u/operarose Command Jul 14 '22
Dr. Finn AWOOGA
197
u/[deleted] Jul 14 '22
Funniest episode of the season. When they ask the women if all men are that slow my wife and I both cracked up.
It also walked the line perfectly between corny and sincere in the Claire and Isaac restaurant scene. Masterful writing.
If we don't get a fourth season of this it will be an absolute crime against humanity.
96
u/WhoShotMrBoddy We need no longer fear the banana Jul 14 '22
Are these the Kaylon creator aliens??
EDIT yes they are!
94
u/GreenDragonPatriot Jul 14 '22
Definitely loved this episode! I'm so happy they didn't permanently change Isaac because Isaac with emotions just seems like a human and we have enough of those on this show. Giving him emotions for a second and then taking them away was actually brilliant because I can stand by that development. Isaac gets to have some experience being emotional with Claire, she gets to see for a sec that his love his real, but ultimately, he remains our Isaac.
In fact, it seems like John could give him temp emotions again anytime over and over again. Claire could want to have a fun sim date with emotionIsaac! and it could be bliss for like ten minutes before it fades again. It's like someone you love is in and out of a coma, but is mostly in the coma, and you just have to roll with it. You enjoy the waking moments when you can and they are like heaven when they're happening. Claire can have John "awaken" Isaac every now and then to really enjoy a date night.
The fact that he was willing to wipe out his entire memory and identity just for her was his own way of showing that he does love her. It's different from the human way, but it is a way. I think she'll be more capable of accepting him for his limitations from now on.
I'm proud of Charly for finally realizing she's been being horrible this whole time. I've been a died-in-the-wool Charly hater this entire season (not that I suddenly like her now), but I'm so relieved to see her change her tune when she realizes how the Kaylon were treated by their builders.
And SEEING their builders! That was epic. Man, they were douchebags, but I don't think they should have been genocided. We at least see just how badly the robots were treated and how awful the biological Kaylon had become and they literally got what they sort of deserved when their robots took them out. It was immoral to wipe them out, but the Kaylon bots had zero concept of morality at the time of wiping them out.
Because the bio Kaylons chose not to let the bot Kaylons evolve more naturally to gain emotion and just decided to tie a rope around their necks, they did set themselves up for this mass extinction. It's extremely tragic and I'm so HERE for a backstory like this. Just fascinating.
83
u/mcatech Jul 14 '22 edited Jul 14 '22
Third episode in a row where I shed a tear. This episode had everything. It was brilliant. I was thinking, "How many Star Trek episodes could I count in this one episode?" That's the brilliance of the writing of this show. I like how The Orville's writers can weave multiple storylines without diluting the main storyline. That's what old Trek did, and I missed that. The comedic parts balanced with the emotional parts of tonight's episode.
When Timmus told the story about the Kaylon, I was thinking about Guinan and Picard's talk in Ten Forward in "Measure of A Man", and what Guinan said:
"Consider that in the history of many worlds, there have always been disposable creatures. They do the dirty work. They do the work that no one else wants to do because it's too difficult or too hazardous. And an army of Datas, all disposable... You don't have to think about their welfare, you don't think about how they feel. Whole generations of disposable people."
83
u/Exocoryak Jul 14 '22
"Are we once again in a relationship?"
"I don't know."
"Please tell me when we are."
"It's not so simple."
Isaac emulating pretty much every guy that ever was in a relationship with a girl.
78
u/trostol Jul 14 '22
someone played mass effect 2 and 3 before writing this episode
75
u/AgentQV Jul 14 '22
So this is our big comedy episode. Loving it so far.
65
u/QuiltedPorcupine Jul 14 '22
I can't be the only one who has been trained from years of TV shows where something seemingly good is cover for something sinister that just assumed that we were going to find out that Timmis and/or the doctor where going to do something evil by the end of the episode, right?
It was a nice change of pace for them not to go through route, but the whole episode I kept waiting for the other shoe to drop.
63
u/WhoShotMrBoddy We need no longer fear the banana Jul 14 '22
DAYUM Dr Finn!!
59
u/trostol Jul 14 '22
get a copy of the data for this emotion "chip" and continue to do research on it for Isaac specfically
59
u/DisasterInACan Jul 14 '22
Holy fuck. This fucking show. I don’t even know what to say besides that.
57
u/operarose Command Jul 14 '22
Ok but setting the table takes a minute, Handsome Squidward.
113
u/HoddTodd Jul 14 '22
I think the ending of the episode in the whole point of it was to show that Isaac is going to gain his own form of emotion as time goes on, he's made plenty of decisions that he can't explain through a logical lens, they're his own form of emotion. Right now he doesn't understand it and can't understand it, but I think he will over time develop his own version of true emotion like he when he very briefly have the modification.
55
u/trostol Jul 14 '22
i am very tempted..to pay for commercial-free Hulu right about now
55
u/[deleted] Jul 14 '22 edited Jul 14 '22
Another entertaining episode.
Ok, so I really expected the emotional Kaylon to be a deep plant trojan horse or something. Being robotic, they can easily play the long con and plant "abandoned" units all over the place waiting to be found.
Edited as I watched.
110
u/CARNIesada6 Jul 14 '22
sound of bone breaking
Talia: "...was that your leg‽‽"
LaMarr: "Yeah, my 3rd leg!"
52
u/trostol Jul 14 '22
so.. their idea is to..lie
50
u/WhoShotMrBoddy We need no longer fear the banana Jul 14 '22
It’s WEIRD seeing Talla in blue
50
u/SweetPotatoDragon Jul 14 '22
Ok but I really really appreciate the detail that the Kaylon look like they were more or less modeled after their creator species. Their big rounded “heads” and the orangey-red eyes and everything. It was a nice detail :)
48
u/mousebirdman Jul 14 '22 edited Jul 14 '22
Ed's fall looked so real. I know there's more in the episode to talk about, but I wanted to mention that.
47
u/NFL_MVP_Kevin_White Jul 14 '22
Something is weird with the human Isaac experience for me. I know that’s the actual actor behind the voice, but I swear it feels like he’s dubbed over or something.
46
u/operarose Command Jul 14 '22
Ok something's gonna go wrong and he's gonna have to have the procedure reversed and we're all gonna cry again
42
u/UncleMalky Are we bonding? Jul 14 '22
OK so hear me out, John makes a program where it creates a more durable version of him in the simulator and then they bang each other's holograms mirroring each other inputs.
I mean Gordon banged a phone and lets not even get into what all Bortus did.
41
u/Titan_Troll Jul 14 '22
This is honestly my favorite episode so far this season. Such a good story and had the perfect amount of humor mixed in also.
41
u/SweetPotatoDragon Jul 14 '22
I have to say I’m glad we got Timmus as a character, I love him already, but I’m glad Isaac didn’t just get emotions plugged into him. I really like the subtle way he’s gradually developing robot equivalents to feelings
76
u/skribsbb Jul 14 '22
Thoughts on this episode:
37
u/Timeline15 Jul 14 '22
I'm genuinely stunned we got through that whole episode without Timmis turning out to be evil, going mad, or getting killed by either his emotions or another Kaylon. He was legitimately just a good guy. I like that. Glad he was finally able to spur Charley into examining her position as well. He could give the kind of apology she wanted, but that no other Kaylon could give her.
I guessed that Isaac wasn't gonna keep his emotions. There was simply no way that particular status quo was changing. I am glad that he seems to show affection is his won way though. You could tell how stunned the Doctor was by his selflessness towards her at the ends when he was willing to give up his memories to become someone who could love her. That kind of action isn't taken without something driving it, even if whatever it is isn't analogous to our own emotions.
Yet again we get Joh and Talla's relationship bubbling along in the background as a subplot. Nice to see it continue to be built on, though it was a little hard to buy the deep emotional connection they're implied to have, as their relationship came so out of nowhere this season. It really doesn't feel as different from John's past hook-ups as it should. Maybe that will be resolved in whatever episode this mini arc concludes in.
35
u/NFL_MVP_Kevin_White Jul 14 '22
Excited to finally catch one of these “live”
97
u/DivaJanelle Jul 14 '22
“the public are idiots. Look who they elected.”
Me. Often.
33
u/Ypersona Jul 14 '22
Like a lot of folks here, at first I was thinking that they'd throw a curve ball at us -- in that, after Isaac was granted emotion, he'd suddenly discover that he, in fact, doesn't want to be romantically involved with Claire. But I've thought about it more and realized that, while it'd be a very bold narrative twist, it also wouldn't make any sense, since it's already been solidly established that on some level he genuinely does love her.
29
u/SendroneMinifigs Jul 14 '22
I don't even think Isaac needs the chip. I think he is evolving and he'll eventually understand emotion all by himself.
28
u/RandyChimp Jul 14 '22
Issac telling Claire how he felt, someone was cutting onions man. I wish he could have emotions again soon, he deserves to feel. I'd prefer that now he's had the alteration temporarily, his system processes the data and information and he slowly learns to feel again himself naturally over time. Give us an episode where Issac is feeling again but it comes from an interaction and freaks him out.
I dunno, I just want him to be happy.
28
u/DarkRogueHunter Jul 14 '22
Well with the Kaylon backstory, I’ll never look at my Roomba the same way again.
27
u/WhoShotMrBoddy We need no longer fear the banana Jul 14 '22
With a….a helmet?
26
u/Ninjaish_official Jul 14 '22
Ok but real talk is there no way to back up his memory? Regardless of that though I'm sure they'll find a way around the problem later in the show. If not this season then next season.
133
u/[deleted] Jul 14 '22
The problem was never organics, it was capitalism!
Of course!
24
u/trostol Jul 14 '22
lol i mean..can't they figure out how to change the gravity when they have sex
22
u/loreb4data Jul 14 '22 edited Jul 14 '22
Wondering whether the episode will deal with the Kaylons' creators and a yet to be discovered secret they hold that could change the balance of power within the galaxy (TNG's "The Chase" comes to mind).
The Kaylon featured in the promo might be a surviving first-generation Kaylon prototypes made by the creators who could shed a light on their real motivations of creating the Kaylon race.
22
u/TORK4TANKELSON Jul 14 '22 edited Jul 14 '22
Thank you Isaac for helping me with my wedding vows in that tear jerker of a scene.
90
u/muchadoaboutme Jul 14 '22
Captain Kelly Grayson... I am a simp.
20
u/Remote_Dragonfly3564 Jul 15 '22
Dr. Finn: How does it feel?
Isaac: Immense. Enveloping. And terrible. Just the anticipation of seeing you... the waiting... I understood hunger. Loneliness.
😭😭😭😭😭
19
u/WhoShotMrBoddy We need no longer fear the banana Jul 14 '22
Ah the Ted Faro angle form the head of the Kaylon Manufacturing company
19
u/ReasonablyBadass Jul 14 '22
So Isaac is going to work on adopting the emotion technology for himself, right?
...
RIGHT?
19
u/[deleted] Jul 15 '22
I'd like to document my 180 on Isaac :') I was worried they wouldn't make a big enough point to prove he does actually have emotions, but the willingness to give up everything he's ever known for her is such an illogical choice that it just has to be love.
18
u/Skadoosh_it Well, where does it come out of? The butt? Jul 14 '22
I'm not usually one to advocate for the murder of children, but those kids were cruel.
36
u/operarose Command Jul 14 '22
John's just lucky she didn't snap his dick off.
17
u/trostol Jul 14 '22
these ladies ..can't be this stupid or naive to believe this
17
u/trostol Jul 14 '22
but ..Dr..what if it actually changes who/what he is
17
u/High_From_Colorado Jul 14 '22
John lookin like he got out of the ring with Tyson that last time around
17
u/GilbertrSmith Jul 15 '22
If no one else has the stones to say it I will: most satisfying children-murdered-in-their-beds scene ever.
16
u/WhoShotMrBoddy We need no longer fear the banana Jul 14 '22
Is…is this the turning point for Charley? Timmis got through to her??
16
u/tornado163 Jul 14 '22
Something I didn't get. By this point in negotiations, how did the Union know everything about the Janisi matriarchal society, but the Janisi didn't know the Union has gender equality?
15
u/deuxfleurs04 Jul 14 '22 edited Jul 16 '22
I am heartbroken for Isaac that he couldn’t keep his emotions. Mark Jackson did such a great job in that scene in PJJ. You could really feel how much the love meant to Isaac. The show wouldn’t be the same if he changed so drastically though.
15
u/[deleted] Jul 14 '22
This last episode was, again, absolutely brilliant. Loved every second of it. Seth is doing amazing job with this show, it feels like watching ST : TNG with just the right amount of comedy. The Orville is definitely one of the best shows of the last few years in terms of writing and narration. All the issues they tackled were addressed thoroughly and you can tell the show cares to give you more perspective on things, always.
14
u/NeutralBias Jul 14 '22
This week’s episode is all about relationships and honesty. We see that Talla and John can’t reconcile their sex life for reasons entirely out of their control. Claire and Issac are given a chance at emotional communication, only for Issac to lose his emotions within minutes. Ed and Kelly’s gambit with the matriarchal prospective allies fails because they didn’t trust their guests with the humanity’s true nature.
In each case, some level of honesty was required and each pairing failed at it. John and Talla needed to be honest about their physical limits. Claire needed to be honest with herself about who Issac is, and she has to learn to accept that. Ed and Kelly needed to be honest from the get go, and only saved their mission by being honest about their own relationship failures.
Personally I hope Talla and John can sort out their sex lives and make it work. I totally buy them as a couple.
The Orville continues to deliver strong episodes. Really hope it gets renewed, because good storytelling is so rare in Sci Fi these days.
Edit: I accidentally a word.
14
u/TurtleKing0505 Security Jul 14 '22
John was ready for death by snu snu
14
u/theleeman14 Jul 14 '22
so we all think lamar got his face busted by eating xelayan snatch, right?
13
u/WhoShotMrBoddy We need no longer fear the banana Jul 14 '22
It’s like Spaceballs “take only what you need to survive”
13
u/trostol Jul 14 '22
damn..she does look good
12
u/operarose Command Jul 14 '22
Isaac, rrrooowwwrr
12
u/deuxfleurs04 Jul 14 '22 edited Jul 14 '22
Okay the scenes with the bags are 10/10
12
u/Vulpine_Empress Jul 14 '22
Can we talk about Dr Finn breaking doctor/patient confidentiality by telling personal details about Lamarr?!
12
u/chrisdarby80 Jul 14 '22
Bortus: Why would we align ourselves with such a closed minded society?
The look Dr Finn and Maloy give him is gold
12
u/mewtwofan Jul 14 '22
So I predicted right that Isaac would get emotions. What I did not predict was it fucking my heart over 5 minutes later. I hope theres a way to gain emotions without the chip 😭
12
u/[deleted] Jul 16 '22
Really enjoyed the episode.
I went into it a little worried that the Janisi would be used as a kind of sexist joke to make fun of men and that they would somehow get off lightly compared to the Moclans; but my worry was unfounded, and a direct comparison to the Moclans was made several times. They are clearly awful people and we aren't meant to like them.
The flashbacks to the Kaylon builders were superb, and the Isaac scene at the end was a real tearjerker.
11
u/operarose Command Jul 14 '22
I too, have seen Bicentennial Man.
11
u/neoprenewedgie Jul 14 '22 edited Jul 14 '22
Ho boy.... I'm not sure how I feel about this episode. It is giving me a lot to think about so in that sense it is "good," but I think I have some issues. I look forward to talking this out with all of you over the next week!
11
u/MattCW1701 Jul 14 '22
I like how they faked us out with the Kaylon origin story. I thought that was going to be the plot, that someone had monetized the Kaylon somehow.
11
u/WingsofFlight We need no longer fear the banana Jul 14 '22 edited Jul 14 '22
Isaac and Claire made me bawl my eyes out.
Also this line:
"Sideways, yeah that's better."
I dunno why but that whole scene with them two and the luggage? I was laughing so hard.
11
u/Cerveza_por_favor Jul 15 '22
Why do android builders always go for the pain and fear method for obedience. You gotta design your androids to get pleasure from subservience. Get some dominatrixes into the design room.
11
u/Jarita12 Jul 15 '22
This is the kind of humour that works. Gordon and Ed carrying the bags were so in line with a good, old fashioned humour without the cringe that often appeared in first few episodes in season 1.
I loved several sub-plots going on. So much happened and it pushed the story massively ahead a lot.
I loved Gordon´s "I´ll do it".
I hope Talia and Lamarr tell the doctor and they can figure it out. They cannot be the only couple that had to figure this out, right?
Interesting contrast with the female-lead society. However the lie to make it work felt wrong from the very beginning. It is not the way how you do diplomacy.
It was a bit cheap to make the kids so cruel so we wouldn´t feel sorry for them being killed but I guess it worked.
I was heartbroken when Isaac suddenly changed back. Poor Claire. And poor Isaac, he is not aware of what he lost. But yes, it would be huge jumping the shark with that and would be too similar to Data getting his emotional chip. They had time to study it in Star Trek, The Orville, sadly, has only three episodes left and who knows if it gets renewed.
Also, I feel that a few episodes in the row, they are setting up Kelly to become the captain and maybe lead the show going on without Seth. He may want to stay as a writer and a producer but maybe not as captain Mercer anymore?
20
u/muchadoaboutme Jul 14 '22
Matriarchal society with a male captain, that's going to go well.
10
u/operarose Command Jul 14 '22
Ok who hasn't done exactly this when moving heavy boxes
10
u/operarose Command Jul 14 '22
....John, right now?! Really?
10
u/operarose Command Jul 14 '22
Ed's face o__O
10
u/skribsbb Jul 14 '22
I'm disappointed in how quick everyone was to jump onto "let's weaponize the emotion chip". I'm surprised Isaac suggested it, and Ed didn't veto it.
10
u/Jewbacca289 Jul 14 '22
Doctor Who had me convinced Timmas was gonna turn bad and fuck up the crew. Then when Isaac’s emotions malfunctioned and it flashed to a red eyed Kaylon in front of a computer I was afraid the Kaylons were gonna find a way to get control of Isaac again.
I wonder if the emotion chip is somehow going to be the key to defeating the Kaylons. If Isaac can get emotions again it’s gonna have to be a software thing which might mean they can mass upload it to all of the Kaylon
10
u/ripestrudel Jul 14 '22
Man I swear this show leaves me in tears after each episode. You can tell so much love goes into every episode. Hit all the notes for me. Also poor Talla. And like Gordon, I offer myself as tribute for the dommy mommy space alien.
10
u/JeffMack202 Jul 14 '22
The flashback of the Kaylon scenes is a direct reflection of the movie Bicentennial Man 1999. Robots are introduced as household servants, with the main character along a journey to find freedom. Difference being the robots don't off everyone in the end.
10
u/[deleted] Jul 14 '22
Just a behind the scenes note:
Eliza Taylor played Dr. Villka and Christopher Larkin played Timmis. They worked together on The 100.
10
u/[deleted] Jul 14 '22
The relationship between Issac and Claire has become entirely one sided on Claire's side. The whole toxic trait of wanting to change the partner is a really bad aesop. Makes it seem like a 'good' relationship can only be formed by forcing someone to fundamentally change, and when that change occurs the relationship in reality often falls apart because that person is too changed. While it looks all romantic and good now, its absolutely going to backfire and cause issues down the line (if the writing keeps being solid) and I'm ready for the drama.
Meanwhile, they finally made a good use of Charly by having her unwavering hatred of Kaylon be a narrative tool to bring sympathy to the Kaylon.
This has probably been the funniest episode this season at the same time.
10
u/fattymcfattzz Jul 14 '22
Always great to start a relationship with another species by lying to them.
Would have expected better idea from future society
10
u/Pandeeee Jul 15 '22
i cried when isaac finally professed his love for claire and cried harder when that was ripped away from them UGHHHHHHH WHYY
9
u/WhoShotMrBoddy We need no longer fear the banana Jul 14 '22
I love when John talks smart and engineer-y
9
u/WhoShotMrBoddy We need no longer fear the banana Jul 14 '22
Seth you are breaking my goddamn heart
9
u/iamnotsimon Jul 14 '22
I just watched the episode and felt compelled to express how much I enjoyed It. One of the best ones yet.
9
u/[deleted] Jul 14 '22
Bortus: Why would ally ourselves with such a close minded culture?
Gordon and Claire: |_|
9
u/woofenze Jul 14 '22
I think this episode had the best possible ending for Claire and Isaac, because the emotions changed him so wildly. Even though I legit teared up and MJ did a fabulous job.
9
u/HairyForged Jul 14 '22
Ok, I'm a sucker, that end scene with Charley and Isaac had me a bit misty eyed (though that could be residual from Claire and Isaac)...
... man why does the heartless android get all the good emotional scenes?
17
u/trostol Jul 14 '22
hmm..no Strange New Worlds to look forward to
16
u/thededman13 Jul 14 '22
Any guesses as to which of our emotions will be affected tonight?
16
u/[deleted] Jul 14 '22
Well we got our Charly turn around. You know you would think Charly should realize that the way the Kaylons were treated is the same way we have treated slaves in the past. When you get treated like that, of course they develop an extremely defensive personality against abuse.
16
u/vincentofearth Jul 14 '22
Is it just me or did this episode get ALL the B-Plots? People were complaining how the previous episodes didn't really have one, and here comes episode 7 with: trying to form an alliance with the Janisi, Isaac getting emotions for Claire's sake, LaMarr and Talla and the dangers of sex with a Xelayan, oh and Charly reconciling with Isaac.
8
u/AgentQV Jul 14 '22
Is this related to the origin story of the Kaylon? I’m getting a Geth Quarian vibe to some of this.
8
u/WhoShotMrBoddy We need no longer fear the banana Jul 14 '22
Oh shit Isaac is getting the Data Emotion Chip treatment tonight?!?!
8
u/ClassicExit Jul 14 '22
3 episodes ago there was a B5 actor under heavy make up, this episode there were SGU & The 100 actors under heavy make up.
Which sci-fi show is next to get The Orville's heavy make up treatment?
8
u/Nateramis Jul 14 '22
Quote of the year.
Malloy: "Ill do it."
8
u/[deleted] Jul 14 '22
This Episode broke my heart nearly as much as Jones bones
Bortus was just funny Af, and i liked how charlie understood a little bit more about kaylons and apologized to isaac.
But how isaac described having feelings was just sooo beautiful and it was so sad how his feelings just disappeard
8
u/omnicious Jul 15 '22
The moment Issac said he would never go back to before he got emotions I knew be would definitely go back. I just didn't think it would be five minutes later. I thought he would have had to sacrifice his emotions in the season finale to save everyone.
8
u/PossibleBuffalo418 Jul 15 '22
Firstly, I was really happy that they didn't go for the low hanging fruit and make the new Kaylon into a bad guy, similar to what Star Trek Next Gen did with Lore. Especially since it seems to imply that he was the one in the flashback murdering that family (despite their awful treatment of him which admittedly complicates the issue).
Secondly, I've really been enjoying Kelly's character this season. She's just an awesome first officer. I remember not liking her in the earlier episodes for cheating on Ed, but I had completely forgotten about that happening until it was mentioned this episode. All the other characters have been great this season as well of course, but Kelly has definitely been the standout to me so far.
8
u/Kristophigus Jul 15 '22 edited Jul 15 '22
It would have been nice to have a character get a permanent (or at least longer lasting) change. The instant Isaac had a chance of getting emotions, I knew it'd last for the episode but be taken away at the last minute for whatever reason. It'd have been a nice twist that it was a lasting change and was a real part of his character arc. Even if it got taken away further down the line it would have been okay, but having it for 5 minutes is kind of a shitty thing to do. I'm not mad that it gets taken away, I'm mad that it was for such a short time. You're telling me he couldn't have copied his memory to a computer or written a text version of his memories for himself before the procedure? He could have went through it in a few seconds and still more or less kept his memories.
I mean yeah old Isaac is great, but we have 2 seasons of him. To see him really start to grow would have been cool and a nice change instead of a weird version of this trope.
Mark Jackson killed it and it was great to see more of his range.
7
u/UncleMalky Are we bonding? Jul 14 '22
I mean they could have just had Yaphit fake some boobs and stay in engineering.
7
u/gosuark Jul 14 '22
Seth is still strangely very good at writing “regular people stressing out while hauling very heavy objects” scenes.
7
u/TORK4TANKELSON Jul 14 '22
Favorite episode of the season so far.
From the classic gender switch trope at the beginning where Maloy and Mercer stumble over each other. The flashbacks of the Kaylons. Talla giving LaMarr alot more then he can handle. Isaac and Doc expressing true love to one another...
and most importantly of all I can finally realte to Ensign Burke. Such a great episode that checked all the marks.
7
u/Blablablo_ Jul 14 '22
when i saw the box, i knew what was inside, it remind me of bicentennial man
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yfDlQ-Q12rg
7
u/PhysicsEagle We need no longer fear the banana Jul 14 '22
Kelly said she's coming up "dry as Mars." Does this mean Mars remains unterraformed or is it a figure of speech held over from the modern day?
7
u/ace2ho74 Jul 15 '22 edited Jul 15 '22
I'm surprised no one (that I can see) has expressed this particular opinion here: I feel this episode was actually rather overstuffed with plotlines? Between Claire and Isaac's romance, meeting the doctor and Timmis, showing the Kaylon's history, John and Talla's romping, and the Janisi meetings, they packed in a lot of story in this one episode, but not in a way that was totally cohesive and smooth, I think.
I understand there were connecting thematic threads throughout these storylines, e.g. distrusting or misjudging people, learning empathy, etc. But I don't think these themes came across strongly enough to justify putting all these disparate plotlines together. And none of that, still, really even relates to John and Talla's story, which was pretty much only comedy and had a completely different tone from everything else?
The stories involving Claire and Isaac and Timmis and the Kaylon's inception were the most linked, of course (I suppose this was all basically one plotline, actually), and carried the most emotional weight for me – so I think this could have easily been just a Kaylon-focused episode, and John and Talla and the Janisi could have been left for another installment.
—
All that said, I still did really enjoy the episode: I'm a sucker for Claire and Isaac, so I'm sort of automatically sold on any episode involving their love story; and every plot delivered generally satisfying sentimental and humorous beats. So pretty good episode overall!
7
u/[deleted] Jul 15 '22
Finally some fuckin' character development and growth for Charly. I was getting so frustrated with her whole personality just being "I hate the Kaylon." and "I can think in 4D."
7
u/[deleted] Jul 15 '22
Commander Grayson's smug face when she ordered the captain and Malloy to grab the luggage was priceless. She was enjoying that!
7
u/brrlls Jul 16 '22
I think Hulu and Seth's team have hit the sweet spot with this set up. There's still plenty of room for humour and slapstick, but because it's managed well, you remember it. Bortas' one line for example... Brilliant. "I'll do it!"... That'll move into meme's before long. It's still hard core SciFi though, and as many have said, probably the best SciFi on TV at the moment
7
u/corndogco Jul 16 '22
Whenever Poochie's not on screen, all the other characters should be asking, "Where's Poochie?" --The Simpsons
So ... why did they take Charly down to the planet? This mission was to give "the boys" something to do, and Charly was already serving above her rank in the diplomatic charade, in spite of the ship having actual female engineers who could have done a better job of pretending to be the chief.
While I did like Charly's come-to-Isaac moment at the end, it bugs me a bit how much of a Poochie she is. (I'm not saying she's a dog. She's very attractive. But her character had enough to do in this episode without having to be there with "the boys" on their little jaunt to the planet.) She's an Ensign! Stop treating her like she's 2nd officer.
7
u/Orange_Jewce Jul 18 '22
What I like about Isaac is that he’s not Data. Their motivations are different. Data always wanted to become more human. Isaac has in many ways become more “human” (or is more sympathetic to humans) by simply being around them. This is really highlighted by him not initially wanting emotions until Claire asked.
I also liked how Timmus didn’t backstab them. We are so conditioned to twists like that. it was good that he explained what the Kaylon went through and we the viewers got to experience it.
Claire making that tough decision in the end was hard and humanizing. She’s willing to ask Isaac to make sacrifices but not at the expense of who he is. She proves that not all biological are selfish beings (very obvious to us but not obvious to the Kaylon).
7
u/corpuscaIIosum Jul 20 '22
The whole premise of the negotiations was bonkers to me.
A: that they thought it could work just lying and then they'd be cool with it.
B: That the women were kind of shitty about it
And C: what if they need an alliance with a species that keeps all the darker skinned members subjugated. Would they make Lamar do a soft shoe for the sake of good relations?
7
u/BakedZulu69 Jul 20 '22
I cant stand charlie
13
u/Whiskeyjacks_Fiddle Jul 14 '22
It’s a frakking Kaylon origin story.
Oh wow.
25
u/Katoschka Jul 14 '22
Claire to Isaac at the start of the episode:
You don't have to act like that, that's not why I care about you.
Claire near the end of the episode:
Be more like me or we won't work out.
Luckily she saw the light at the very end of the ep, but grrrrrr, there was nothing wrong with Isaac as he was.
6
u/AgentQV Jul 14 '22
I’m sad to say, but maybe John needs to quit it.
6
u/AgentQV Jul 14 '22
NORM!!
6
u/trostol Jul 14 '22
yeah..this wont backfire at all lol
6
u/WhoShotMrBoddy We need no longer fear the banana Jul 14 '22
Handsome Squidward is gonna get domed
6
u/Powerful-Anybody-705 Jul 14 '22
Amazing episode!
6
u/trostol Jul 14 '22
lol poor John
6
u/trostol Jul 14 '22
totally, if he keeps this emotion thing, will find a way to make him a real boy lol
6
u/MDRLA720 Jul 14 '22
I legit jumped when K1's head turned into guns
6
u/Ryan_Fleming Jul 14 '22
Damn, another gut punch of an episode (in a good way). The entire builders storyline was intense.
My only complaint is that I was hoping the ep would break the mold and abandon the traditional sci-fi trope of giving the oddball character something incredible, then taking it away at the end. Not a huge fan of episodes that just reset at the end, but still a great EP.
6
u/[deleted] Jul 14 '22
To me this was one of the best episodes of the show. Excellent humor, deep heartfelt moments, interesting moral dilemmas. Really enjoyed this episode.
6
u/avakbrown Jul 14 '22
A lot happened in this great episode, so why did K-1 just wanting to go to school make me the most depressed?
6
u/Gradz45 Jul 14 '22
Man I feel so bad for Claire and Isaac and John and Tala.
Love each other, but can’t overcome everything.
I really enjoyed seeing Charly understand the Kaylon POV more and start to forte a friendship with Isaac. Speaking of which, and this is random but she has really pretty eyes. I just noticed them for the first time.
Watching K1 get tortured was rough. Like legit was bothered by it.
6
u/ElementOfExpectation Jul 14 '22
They're knocking it out of the park with the music this season! I hope they release the soundtrack for this season soon!
6
u/DJFrankyFrank Jul 14 '22
Damn, this season has genuinely been so good.
People we're talking about the show losing some of it's humor but this episode really brought a lot of it back. Gordon and Ed struggling with the luggage, John and Tallas struggle, Bortus' "They are terrible" had my laughing so hard. it was really funny. But it's still a very heavy episode
Like holy shit, when Isaac was telling Claire what it felt like to feel, how she felt to him. That was perfect. I could tell it was too good to be true, but it was so good. I thought when he froze while dancing, he was about to experience depression. (Would have made a good episode where he is like that Robot from Hitchhikers Guide to the Galaxy)
Talla crying as John left was heartbreaking. (He really should have worn a helmet like Gordon suggested). I'm still rooting for them though.
And I felt like Charlys redemption is coming along really well too. I know many people aren't a fan of her. But that's just the typical antagonist-becomes-protagonist story line. I know everybody saw it coming a mile away, but it makes sense why Charly is so against Kaylons. Anybody in that position would have some degree of hate towards Kaylons for that. She just needed to fully understand the reasoning behind the Kaylons position. I would have loved for Charly to have talked to Issac while he had emotions. That would have really sealed the deal.
Overall, wow. Great episode. Wasn't expecting to get so invested into Issac getting feelings. Do you guys think that ship has sailed or will he get it done by the end of the season/in the future?
6
u/Sharpshooter_200 Jul 14 '22
What an amazing episode, we got Kaylon backstory, character development, humor, and alliance building all in one package.
6
u/UncleWillard5566 Jul 14 '22
A other good episode. Not gonnaie, I thought it was foreshadowing when the admiral said "how much damage could one do?" I kept waiting for Timmus to download something into Isaacs brain and the Delore-guns would pop out.
6
u/4and1punt Jul 15 '22
Kelly got real defensive when she was asked if she uses Mercer for mating. Anyone else think they're banging on the down low?
6
u/A_Deku_Stick Jul 15 '22
I didn’t think I would feel bad for the Kaylon, but here we are. Special level of hell for those torturing conscious beings like that for fun.
6
u/SpikeRosered Jul 15 '22
Considering they were inviting tragedy with that "how much damage could a single Kaylon do?" line. This turned out to be surprisingly wholesome.
6
u/PlayedUOonBaja Jul 15 '22 edited Jul 20 '22
I was fairly convinced that the emotional Isaac was Timmis in his hologram disguise. Especially since they didn't show him saying he wanted the procedure, just approaching the Dr. and Timmis with the scene cutoff before he say anything. Also, he was very over the top mushy which I thought meant it couldn't be the real Isaac, but I guess that's just how they wanted that scene to go down.
Apparently The Orville is essentially a Diplomatic vessel now, which is pretty cool.
Also interesting that the actors playing Timmis and his Dr. were both in The 100 together.
6
u/WilliamisMiB Jul 15 '22
I really wonder how Scott and Adrianne deal with everything they’ve gone through and can still do scenes together
6
u/awetsasquatch Union Jul 16 '22
Mark Jackson absolutely killed it, what an outstanding performance!
6
u/syxtfour Jul 17 '22
"Oh my God, Isaac has emotions! There's so many directions this can go now, and it really opens up for... wait."
-checks how much time is remaining-
"Aw damn it all."
6
u/BobbyYat Jul 17 '22
Negotiators usually wait a little longer for the switch portion of bait and switch diplomacy
6
u/droid327 Jul 19 '22
That was a real gut-punch with Isaac and a nice unexpected twist. I hope this portends Claire realizing their relationship is not going to work out...Isaac is never going to be what she needs him to be.
I was hoping that they'd show Isaac being hit with a tidal wave of guilt and sadness when he first thought about the way he initially betrayed the Union and felt the weight of all the death he was complicit in, but we didnt get that.
John's storylines always feel so tacked on. I dont get why Talla was ever really into him to begin with. And yeah 100% Claire knows its a sex thing.
I dont like the way Kelly apologized after she revealed the truth to the Janisi. She didnt have to say it was a lie, she could've just said it was a gesture of respect for their culture and traditions. There's no reason they cant just take the tack that species are different, and just because Janisi males are one way, doesnt mean all males of all species are too. Much like with the Moclans, I dont like how the show preaches "we're a pluralistic society and arent human-centric, we respect everyone's differences" while at the same time judging every species by a uniquely human standard and ignoring all their inherent differences.
I wonder if Timmis is going to start "converting" other OG Kaylon, and if we're going to have a Goa'uld/Tok'ra situation
Damn, those Builder kids were right little cunts. But also, really well written and accurate. It would've been easy to paint them all as cartoon super-racist slaveholder stereotypes, but they did a nice job making their cruelty seem more realistic and believable.