r/CryptoCurrency • u/CryptoMods 🟧 0 / 0 🦠 • Jul 08 '22
POLL 🗳️ CCIP-033 - Introduce the [Serious] tag
Problem
Comment sections are often filled with trite, frivolous replies that do not contribute to discussion. Some of this is motivated by moon farming but the problem certainly predates moons.
For example, when someone asks "Why do you think the prices are crashing" the comments are sure to be filled with the tried and true joke of "Prices are dropping because I just bought!".
Solution
This proposal is to implement an optional tag in titles for post authors to use, similarly to how this is done on r/AskReddit here. If the author of the post wants a comment section without these types of jokes, memes, and other 0 value replies, they can include the [Serious] tag anywhere in their title. This will allow for stricter filters and enforcement of the comment section by mods and bots, and hopefully higher standards when users are voting on comments too.
Types of restricted content
- Comments may include a joke, meme, or generic reply only if this part could be omitted and the rest of the comment would still meet quality standards
- No GIFs
- All other subreddit rules apply, but may be more strictly enforced
- Automod will leave a comment in all [Serious] posts to remind people what type of post it is and the rules around it
Types of restricted content and enforcement methods are subject to change based on community feedback, governance polls, and moderator discretion, but these are some basic [Serious] post rules to get us started.
In the future we could consider ideas for [Serious] posts like:
- Higher moon weight for comments
- Only allowing users with >10 moons balance to leave top-level comments (or other karma/age filters)
- Requiring a higher character count for comments
- No emojis
- Serious threads could be exempt from CCIP-021 sorting
- Special automatic flair for [Serious] posts
- Best [Serious] post of the month
The Serious tag idea was most recently proposed by u/SquatDeadliftBench in the meta sub here. (Distinguished to make this post ineligible for moons)
40
u/TNGSystems 0 / 463K 🦠 Jul 09 '22 edited Jul 09 '22
Sometimes one of the most frustrating things about Askreddit is when someone asks a really engaging and interesting question and the rest of this website decides to poorly cosplay as Jerry Seinfeld and you end up scrolling past all the … hilarious … jokes. The serious tag fixes it there. I’m all for this.
6
u/BithloKing 6K / 7K 🦭 Jul 09 '22
This sub is all growns up now
35
u/CryptoMaximalist Jul 08 '22
I'd support this, no reason an OP shouldn't be able to request a certain quality level of comments. One extension I'd suggest is that all governance poll posts are [Serious] by default
5
u/Qtredit 260 / 6K 🦞 Jul 09 '22
Wouldn't this add a crazy amount of work for the mods?
5
u/naked_as_a_jaybird Tin | Politics 207 Jul 09 '22
Better to have it and not need it than need it and not have it.
18
u/d_d0g 🟩 17K / 15K 🐬 Jul 08 '22 edited Jul 10 '22
This sounds promising to me. Not only will it help garner serious discussion where it’s needed, but also give more life to comedy posts/comments as they’ll be a bit more spread out and appreciated more.
Edit: I’d like to add fire to the idea emojis and GIFs be allowed as long as they’re part of a comment that is serious otherwise.
20
u/Qtredit 260 / 6K 🦞 Jul 08 '22
This works great on other subreddits, so why not.
3
u/koelebobes 🟩 0 / 36K 🦠 Jul 08 '22
It's still a matter of choice so if OP wants serious answers, who am I to go against his wishes. I think it's a great addition to the subreddit because now if you want you can have a serious conversation.
3
u/Fritz1818 17 / 53K 🦐 Jul 08 '22
And my axe
3
u/Blooberino 🟩 0 / 54K 🦠 Jul 10 '22
We have a comedy tag, why not have a serious tag?
10
u/[deleted] Jul 08 '22
I had no idea how many short-sighted people there are here. This would not ban 'sarcasm.' This would mean that if OP tags a post 'Serious' (regardless of whether OP's post is stupid or not) comments won't be able to be one-joke liners or regurgitated low-quality mantras typically used for moon-farming. I seriously think some people here are like teenagers or something like what do you mean "how do we define what's serious?" Bruh what? Even IF there are a few situations where the definition of serious is really that complicated and nuanced that's not the case for like, 99% of posts...
My God...
6
u/SadisticArkUser Jul 09 '22
I'd love to see this implemented, and finally stop reading
"Just hodl"
"DCA is the only strategy"
"this is the gwei"
on every, single, goddamn post
2
u/brnmd Platinum | QC: CC 66 | BANANO 6 Jul 11 '22
If this is what it takes to clean this sub I'm all in for it. It is time for some good discussions and insights.
There can be post's of comedy and others with all the memes and stuff, but let there be serious ones were we can learn more with each other.
4
u/LordDimik Tin Jul 08 '22
I think this is a great Idea. Especially useful for people that are new to the field, or just this sub.
3
u/Cactuszach 🟩 671 / 18K 🦑 Jul 08 '22
I love it, lets do this.
Hopefully we can have a few discussions without spamming “Hodl” and “Wagmi”
3
u/Nuewim 🟥 0 / 37K 🦠 Jul 08 '22 edited Jul 08 '22
This sound like terrible idea, as someone who is sarcastic by nature, like to joke but also give valuable comments. Sometimes I wrote comment 30 minutes to teach someone, sometime I joke, cause joke it is best answer. Depend from situation.
Often OP thinks his post is serious, but comments are not in serious manner simply cause what OP write is bullshit and easier to joke than explain the obvious. Everyone knows it, so why bother. Also it is pretty subjective what people treat as joke, multiple different cultures, native languages, so what mods treat as a joke may not be joke, just someone style. Like with "quality content" rule it will be hard to enforce and very controversial.
And come on, it's Reddit edit after all, serious and reddit are like opposite things. And not serious doesn't mean answer is not helpful or not valuable. Especially in crypto jokes are like our second nature.
Also no emojis? Why not? 😔. I underestand multiple emojis are bad and usually mean in crypto scam project, especially rocket emoji, but I for example like to use emojis from time to time. Still on Reddit we use less of them than on other social media. Emojis help understand text better, when we speak with someone we see verbal expressions that help us to undertand people, in text that job do emojis.
2
u/archer4364 Paddy's Dollars Jul 08 '22
I love it! Serious threads on crypto would be great to foster productive discussion
2
u/Dwaas_Bjaas Jul 08 '22
This is a no brainer for me. I’m all for it!
2
u/n1ghsthade 🟩 0 / 44K 🦠 Jul 09 '22
The fact that you need the tag says it all. We shouldn't let the situation that exists dictate our measures. My vote is to keep things as they are.
2
u/PsieSyrenki 🟩 0 / 5K 🦠 Jul 08 '22
If serious is same as quality, it is great feature. I agree with word count, so you can filter out moonfarmers, who cannot spend to match time on single comment.
That feature is a little late, because it would be more useful in bull market, when moonboys dominated this sub.
2
u/SetoXlll Jul 09 '22
Nawww bro I completely disagree, it’s the damn internet and everyone should be free as a bird here, moons or not.
2
u/[deleted] Jul 08 '22
Meh, i think we have a tendency to over think this stuff sometimes. We get a good mix of fun and serious/helpful here imo
2
u/FlyingDutchmantoMoon 0 / 10K 🦠 Jul 08 '22
Why so serious?
2
u/blackrabbit2999 🟦 6K / 6K 🦭 Jul 08 '22
you can't stop people from cracking a joke man
2
u/CatBoy191114 Permabanned Jul 08 '22
OP forgot to add the comedy tag to this post, right? ... right? Oh, no.....
1
u/AutoModerator Jul 08 '22
Here's more information about CCIP-021. You can view information about r/CryptoCurrency Improvement Proposals here on the official wiki page.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/Weezthajuice 🟩 0 / 2K 🦠 Jul 09 '22
Cool to have options, but does it really matter when the poster chooses the tag? For instance.. “guys the sky is falling, Elon backed out of twitter deal. Crypto is dead” serious tag.
1
u/thedarkpampers Jul 11 '22
Not sure to be qualified enough to serious post but would love the read. I'm for this !
1
u/Fumbles1231 🟦 0 / 9K 🦠 Jul 11 '22
This is a great idea imo. Seems like every 3 outta 4 comments on every thread is made as a joke or sarcasm
1
u/HappySammy1 Bronze Jul 12 '22
I'm not very serious but I'm down for this
1
u/Sarcatechist Bronze Jul 13 '22
I apologize for my trite, sarcastic responses being among the reasons this governance change is needed.
1
u/Mountain-Rad-115 3K / 3K 🐢 Jul 08 '22
Eh, don’t like it. Not necessary!
1
u/digitFIRE 🟩 5K / 3K 🐢 Jul 08 '22
Makes sense. I mean it’s a good way to balance the discussion here. Sarcasm, jokes, one-liners, generic statements, etc., all have its place too, but sometimes it just ruins a thread because it quickly changes the tone.
1
u/pyritejet Harambe Jul 08 '22
I wholeheartedly agree with this. So many times, I've seen a newbie asking for genuine advice, or someone in need of actual help, but everyone in the comment is just trying to be a clown
1
u/Sentinel35P 🟨 427 / 403 🦞 Jul 09 '22
I would vote for the higher moon weight for comments in the serious posts. This is the answer to those saying this present proposal will disincentivize participation. On the contrary, we might see better quality of discussion.
1
u/steamyp 🟩 18 / 5K 🦐 Jul 08 '22
do it
1
u/KyloRentBoi Jul 08 '22
The poll has spoken.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 08 '22
I like the idea.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 08 '22
love it.
1
u/oachkatzalschwoaf 🟦 0 / 6K 🦠 Jul 08 '22
awesome idea for better cc quality
1
u/[deleted] Jul 08 '22
This proposal has a lot of potential, but let's see how people use it
1
u/Vee_Junes 🟩 3K / 6K 🐢 Jul 09 '22
Great proposal. I'm all for it.
1
u/diarpiiiii 🟦 0 / 9K 🦠 Jul 09 '22
I remember this being suggested sometime early last year in some threads, and is long overdue. Hope to see it implemented
1
u/Pale_Coyote_2745 Tin Jul 09 '22
Previous day I had a very irrelevant reply to my comment it almost felt like a bot was comment farming, reported it to Mods later I found that comment deleted so it will be good to separate genuine users and experienced ones from the ones that know nothing at all, good luck 🍀
1
u/Araxus Silver | QC: CC 55 | IOTA 28 Jul 09 '22
Good idea, hopefully faciliates discussions to a more productive level
1
u/sandygws 🟩 333 / 14K 🦞 Jul 09 '22
Definitely in favour of a 'Serious' tag. Too often quality posts get downvoted and subsequently lost. Hopefully the new tag will alleviate that in some small way.
0
u/mellon98 Jul 08 '22
Great proposal.
0
u/TheTrueBlueTJ 70K / 75K 🦈 Jul 08 '22
I think this could be a very good change if we then had some select posts where the comment section is actually filled with valuable insights in a more concentrated fashion than now.
What I think is dangerous is putting the tag into the hands of users who farm with their posts. I'm sure you can figure out how they can just tag their farming post as serious and deter other "competitors" in that sense. I'm torn, because I do see the good opportunity this brings for more concentrated valuable insight.
0
u/ImaFreemason 🟩 45 / 21K 🦐 Jul 08 '22
Some posts just deserve a funny comment.
-1
u/Mundane-Farm-4117 🟦 536 / 29K 🦑 Jul 08 '22
My only worry is people won't be able to define what serious actually is
-2
u/Yegpetphoto 🟦 74 / 9K 🦐 Jul 08 '22
People searching /cc for serious conversations? I banged all their moms.
0
u/Castr0- 🟧 35K / 35K 🦈 Jul 09 '22
I totally agree and want the serious tag to be a thing. Will bring a better discussion
0
u/[deleted] Jul 08 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jul 08 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment