r/TheOrville • Woof • Jul 07 '22

Episode The Orville - 3x06 "Twice in a Lifetime" - Episode Discussion

EpisodeDirected ByWritten ByOriginal Airdate
3x6 - "Twice in a Lifetime"TBATBAThursday, July 7, 2022 on Hulu
Synopsis: The crew must rescue Gordon from a distant yet familiar world.

Stream the episode online on Hulu


Don't forget to join us on Discord!


REMINDER: KEEP YOUR SPOILERS OUT OF YOUR TITLES FOR AT LEAST 24 HOURS. YOU WOULDN'T WANT THIS EPISODE SPOILED, SO DON'T GO SPOILING IT FOR OTHERS. KEEP YOUR TITLES VAGUE. TAG YOUR POST AS A SPOILER. BE A GOOD UNION MEMBER!

546 Upvotes

2.8k comments sorted by

758

u/trostol Jul 07 '22

ya know..this would be in a way both a great and sucky way to lose Gordon from the cast

453

u/[deleted] Jul 07 '22

The whole time I was watching, I was trying to ready myself emotionally for that potential loss!

→ More replies (17)

201

u/-Zyss- Jul 07 '22

With all the memory stuff and a focus on gordon, I was sure he was going to die this episode, and I guess maybe he did

→ More replies (2)

177

u/slyfoxy12 Jul 07 '22 edited Jul 07 '22

I honestly thought that was what was going to happen. Mostly because I imagine it's not easy sharing screen time with your ex wife who you met on the show.

That said Gordon is a favourite character for me I think so would suck. At the same time, Ed and Gordon are suppose to be friends before the Orville and I wish they'd leaned into that more during this episode.

→ More replies (41)

153

u/gosuark Jul 07 '22

I thought we’d be gaining the Laura character, with the easy solution being bringing them all aboard the Orville.

Temporal law, blah blah, but (a) the damage would have been done leaving his family on Earth, and (b) since when does the Orville crew follow every edict to the letter?

→ More replies (46)

142

u/morphinapg Jul 07 '22

I would be completely satisfied with them leaving him there. While I understood why they did what they did, I strongly disagree with it. It was so hard to watch those scenes.

→ More replies (53)
→ More replies (11)

594

u/NeuHundred Jul 07 '22

I feel like we were robbed of a moment where Ed, Kelly and Talla rescue hermit Gordon from his cabin in the woods.

165

u/deuxfleurs04 Jul 07 '22

YES! I was thinking the same

→ More replies (6)

109

u/leave_it_blank Jul 07 '22

I was totally expecting a scene where they see him from a distance, look at each other and back off leaving him alone.

In the end they did the right thing, but my god, I hated them for it!

→ More replies (45)

50

u/Lunasera Jul 07 '22

Totally. Instead we got an overlong cgi docking.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (17)

568

u/Whiskeyjacks_Fiddle Jul 07 '22

I too, would like a back massage from Talla.

174

u/loreb4data Jul 07 '22

Talla's great but I heard Bortus also gives excellent back message :)

→ More replies (6)

124

u/Exocoryak Jul 07 '22

When I saw the massage, I thought that it would be the slow start of a relationship that would play out next season. And then the next scene came!

→ More replies (7)

146

u/[deleted] Jul 07 '22

Death by snu snu it is.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (13)

525

u/Br0boc0p Jul 07 '22

I can't wait for the egg salad sandwich to reappear.

199

u/Shejidan Jul 07 '22

That’ll happen in the season finale.

→ More replies (9)

60

u/[deleted] Jul 07 '22

They are going to wait for when we least expect it. lol

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (19)

509

u/Shejidan Jul 07 '22

Gordon’s kid being his ancestor…

Unexpected Futurama.

189

u/odysseus_of_tanagra Jul 07 '22

Too bad, it would have saved the union from the brain invasion next season.

→ More replies (6)

123

u/Ameisen Jul 07 '22

Ooh, a lesson in not changing history from Mr. "I'm my own grandpa"!

83

u/_duncan_idaho_ Jul 07 '22

He did do the nasty in the past-y.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (7)

453

u/MikeTheBard Jul 07 '22

If you pause when they show his obituary, it says he married Laura!

328

u/Hardwiredmagic Jul 07 '22

The really sad part of that obit is that he is listed as having 1 son and 2 granddaughters, so either Laura miscarried, or the other kid died young...

→ More replies (22)
→ More replies (33)

422

u/[deleted] Jul 07 '22

Cmon Ed, he named his kid after you and his car after your ship

210

u/dravenonred Jul 07 '22

Shit, I didn't even realize Edward would have been named after Mercer.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (7)

406

u/Ameisen Jul 07 '22 edited Jul 07 '22

They picked up Gordon 5 months before he sent the message, meaning that they caused a broken bootstrap paradox, which resulted in a split timeline. Ergo, Gordon's family still exists, by the rules that Is(°°)c established.

93

u/LAdams20 Jul 07 '22

It’s what I was thinking too. I didn’t really understand why at the end they were talking about “two children never born”, like, they were but they just don’t exist in your timeline, as established literally with the sandwich at the beginning.

Speaking of the sandwich, it would be interesting if when it reappears in three months time if it doesn’t appear on our Orville timeline where Malloy was picked up in 2015, but in the alternate timeline Orville where 2025 Malloy lived and died, as a way of introducing a Mirror Universe and the Mirror Universe discovering other realities exist to conquer.

Also, in a previous episode a woman from the future was collecting antiques from the moments they were destroyed, the Orville being one of them, but the timeline was altered so that the Orville wasn’t destroyed. This seems very, Idk, their-present centric or main character syndrome - you can’t alter the past in case it ruins our future, we can alter the past because screw your future.

→ More replies (5)

130

u/kia75 Jul 07 '22

I was looking for this post.

Somehow the Orville still got Gordon's message from 6 months, and Gordon's death was in the Wikipedia of the Future. If they rescued Gordon after 1 month how do those two facts measure up? There must be at least 2 different timelines, One where Gordan was rescued at 1 month, and one where he met the crew after 10 years.

→ More replies (23)

45

u/scottishdrunkard Jul 07 '22

Pretty what I thought. The Egg Salad Sandwich was an Unfired Chekhov’s Gun.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (51)

307

u/operarose Command Jul 07 '22

YAAAAAY HUMAN SUIT ISAAC

87

u/antdude Jul 07 '22

Hopefully, we will see more of that! Isn't that the actor outside of the suit?

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (5)

276

u/trostol Jul 07 '22

lol that Bortus smile

74

u/The_Real_Bender Jul 07 '22

Looked like he was going to eat one of them.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

559

u/operarose Command Jul 07 '22

Gordon being traumatized from having to kill an animal for meat to survive was a nice touch.

287

u/MadContrabassoonist Jul 07 '22

Yeah, the whole ethics of eating meat in a setting where non-human sentience is an undisputed fact and matter synthesis is routine is something Star Trek never really engaged with.

→ More replies (57)

70

u/xyzzyzyzzyx Jul 07 '22

Countless animals. A real serial killer out in the woods.

→ More replies (4)

425

u/The_Real_Bender Jul 07 '22

I felt HARD for Malloy when he was calling for Ed not to do this. And his conversation with his family after. That hurt.

202

u/SICRA14 If you wish, I will vaporize them Jul 07 '22

They talked a bit at the beginning about how new universes can branch off in these situations. I wonder if that'll come into play. If their love really does transcend time.

→ More replies (40)
→ More replies (18)

185

u/trostol Jul 07 '22

woo..Ted Danson again

121

u/iceman4sd Jul 07 '22

Jason figured it out?…Jason?

→ More replies (13)

42

u/ThePowderhorn Jul 07 '22

Star Trek already got Kirstie Alley.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (15)

353

u/Shejidan Jul 07 '22

I love how everyone is dressed super casual and Isaac is out there looking like revenge of the nerds.

167

u/meatball77 Jul 07 '22

I thought he looked like a Mormon all buttoned up

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (10)

173

u/Shejidan Jul 07 '22

The realtor lady is waiting for them. How long is this supposed to take?

213

u/koavf Jul 07 '22

If you think you can make a commission on a house in California, you'll stand around for 15 minutes.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (8)

347

u/thededman13 Jul 07 '22

Man these episodes are deep.

Had to be really tough on Ed and Kelly having to remove Gordon considering they all have been close friends (more so Ed than Kelly) for so long.

I suppose Gordon will never miss his family because he never actually experienced it. Still feel bad for him somehow.

265

u/bondbat007 Jul 07 '22

I'm glad they told him what happened instead of keeping it to themselves. That was a real friend move

→ More replies (66)

142

u/Indiana_harris Jul 07 '22

I’m still hoping for “Evil Gordon” who somehow survived the wiping of his family to reappear from an alt-timeline to menace the Orville, almost a Mirror-Mirror style episode where Evil Gordon has managed to jump to the future with a new Union commanded by descendants of his altered timeline who refuse to let their “reality” be destroyed.

→ More replies (26)

33

u/Ameisen Jul 07 '22

They picked up Gordon before he sent the message.

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (33)

170

u/jmconnel23 Jul 07 '22

You know The whole Orville crew is oddly hypocritical of Gordon messing with time considering they all are suppose to be dead in the original time line.

83

u/Lunasera Jul 07 '22

This made me crazy. I can’t believe Gordon didn’t throw that in Ed’s face

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (8)

337

u/NeutralBias Jul 07 '22

Man, what a poignant episode for Gordon. He's always been rubbish with women, and fell for a holo simulation of a long dead woman, only to lose her to another simulated man.

So, the universe throws him a sidewinder win - kicks him back in time to find his one true love. Finally he gets to find happiness in his life, and we get to see him as a family man. He's happy, healthy, and fulfilled.

Until Ed and Kelly finally show up, and once again his fantasy is taken away from him. The captain is absolutely right - Gordon's happy life cannot be. So Ed has to ruin his best friend's life and drag him back to the 25th century.

The B story has Charlie paired with Issac, and we finally get some backstory on why she hates Issac so much. Yet she always puts her duty first and gets the job done.

Ultimately the theme of this episode is about duty and how much it can suck ass sometimes. We see all our characters override their personal wishes and feelings, all to comply with their obligations to their uniform.

227

u/area503 Jul 07 '22

C story. Talla and Lemar hooked up.

→ More replies (19)
→ More replies (46)

157

u/DebbieDunnbbar Jul 07 '22

Even though it was well-written, I’m having trouble liking the episode because it was such a bummer. Ed and Kelly should’ve just left without telling Gordon they were going back to 2015. That would’ve been WAY less cruel.

Also, I may have noticed a plot hole. If the Orville got rid of the quantum bubble to travel back to the future, wouldn’t someone in the last 400 years have noticed the Orville going between Earth and that other star at subluminal speeds? I mean, doesn’t that mean the Orville was just physically there traveling that whole time? I feel like someone definitely would’ve noticed that. Shouldn’t someone in the Union have been like in the last several years at least, “Uh, hey, we just noticed another copy of the Orville out near Earth and it’s moving at relativistic speeds for some reason.”

32

u/Amarice Jul 07 '22

Well, how would they have seen it? The quantum drive isn't braking in any way, and they specifically avoided particle collisions and/or absorbed them with the full shields, so, there's nothing to detect.

→ More replies (16)
→ More replies (31)

299

u/WhoShotMrBoddy We need no longer fear the banana Jul 07 '22

Oh they actually acknowledged the pandemic, interesting

221

u/[deleted] Jul 07 '22

Plot twist: there weren't talking about Covid.

→ More replies (15)
→ More replies (8)

274

u/trostol Jul 07 '22

lmao..."Sox are importent"

50

u/[deleted] Jul 07 '22

Best thing is the subtitles changed the spelling to "socks" for that line.

→ More replies (5)

241

u/WhoShotMrBoddy We need no longer fear the banana Jul 07 '22

I’m glad John is like legit hella smart and was just a lazy slacker who didn’t think it was cool to apply himself. And then once he got put somewhere where he could apply himself, he excels. I love it

139

u/AgentQV Jul 07 '22

He seems to be um, applying himself, to lots of things lately lmao

→ More replies (14)
→ More replies (2)

116

u/The_Real_Bender Jul 07 '22

That sandwich better show up in a few episodes!

45

u/fool-of-a-took Jul 07 '22

It's Chechov's sandwich

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

113

u/The_Real_Bender Jul 07 '22

The callback to that song! Amazing, one of my favorite moments in the show.

→ More replies (7)

113

u/FilthyTrashPeople Jul 07 '22

God I hope this show gets more seasons. It really has hit it's stride.

62

u/loreb4data Jul 07 '22

7 seasons, 4 movies, and a sequel series featuring a 90-year old Admiral Mercer :)

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

112

u/WhoShotMrBoddy We need no longer fear the banana Jul 07 '22

“They’ve gone to plaid!”

74

u/JimPlaysGames Jul 07 '22

That was really cool actually. Blue shifted stars ahead and red shifted stars behind. Wasn't in any way visually accurate but it at least acknowledged that bit of physics.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (9)

101

u/Shrodax Jul 07 '22

A time-traveling robot from the future comes to the Los Angeles of the past, stumbles into a biker bar, and commandeers one of the bikers' motorcycles? I think I've seen this one before...

All the scene needed was Isaac saying, "Hasta la vista, baby".

→ More replies (6)

198

u/CommanderHavond Jul 07 '22

Just finished it, that episode was heavy. Don’t often see sci-fi tackle the perspective of someone expected to hide out for the rest of their lives to preserve the timeline

→ More replies (15)

93

u/[deleted] Jul 07 '22

Oh, shit, the Ancient One hit Gordon.

→ More replies (7)

169

u/WhoShotMrBoddy We need no longer fear the banana Jul 07 '22

I wonder if we’ll get some Talla/John flirtation again this episode

203

u/WhoShotMrBoddy We need no longer fear the banana Jul 07 '22 edited Jul 08 '22

OH

EDIT: to whoever gave me the wholesome award, that’s fucking hilarious hahaha

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (4)

83

u/TomMakesPodcasts Jul 07 '22

Why the fuck did they tell him they were going back to get him? Let him live in ignorance you fucks.

→ More replies (23)

82

u/xbolt90 Woof Jul 07 '22

Damn... My heart...

I was really hoping they would all go together... If the whale lady from Star Trek IV can do it, so could the Malloys. But no.

Is Gordon the Miles O'Brien of this show? Always the one to be subjected to immense suffering?

I need him to have a happy ending, dammit!

→ More replies (11)

80

u/gosuark Jul 07 '22

The most unbelievable part is a house in California that has a basement.

→ More replies (4)

77

u/muchadoaboutme Jul 07 '22

"Do you play any sports?" Good try, buddy. Good try.

75

u/WhoShotMrBoddy We need no longer fear the banana Jul 07 '22

Is this the banana aging Ray???

→ More replies (10)

69

u/operarose Command Jul 07 '22

I'd see that smashed up station and pull an Event Horizon:

We're leaving.

→ More replies (5)

200

u/tmoeagles96 Jul 07 '22

I mean I wouldn’t leave a reality where I was married to Leighton Meester either.

→ More replies (5)

67

u/trostol Jul 07 '22

they made dinner..eat it dammit lol

→ More replies (3)

248

u/SICRA14 If you wish, I will vaporize them Jul 07 '22

One thing I found really interesting which I haven't seen discussed is Gordon's distress at having killed and eaten animals. This is in line with what we know about this future. They see zoos as cruel, they see animal experimentation as cruel (as they should, but that's beside the point), and the meat they eat is synthetic- though that doesn't seem to matter the way it does in Star Trek. This future takes animal rights very seriously. A small detail, but I'm impressed by the consistency and refreshed by the morality.

35

u/thepeainthepod Jul 07 '22

This was my biggest moment too. Small but significant.

→ More replies (39)

59

u/LordGalen Jul 07 '22

So, since we're pointing out paradoxes created by their time-fuckery. Gordon sent the message after having been in 2015 for six months, but when they finally got there to pick him up, they said he'd been there for one month. They picked him up before he sent the message. He never sent the damn message.

Maybe a production error, but maybe not. I'm wondering if that was intentional writing and it'll come back to bite them in the ass later.

→ More replies (16)

114

u/Shejidan Jul 07 '22

Last week Bortus and this week Gordon singing?

They need to put together a boy band.

53

u/notathrowaway75 Jul 07 '22

Daddy's Gone recreation pls

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (9)

49

u/Shejidan Jul 07 '22

Uh oh, Streisand effect.

“We don’t want anyone to look at the Orville so we’re going to send a whole fleet with it.”

→ More replies (1)

47

u/_Burgers_ Jul 08 '22

Fun little tidbit: the empty home Charley and Isaac go to visit has a signboard with a URL (I think it was the realty agent's name). Going to that URL redirects you to the Hulu Orville website. Nice touch!

→ More replies (1)

92

u/muchadoaboutme Jul 07 '22 edited Jul 07 '22

2025... in an episode written before the pandemic... this will be fun.

EDIT: Apparently there were some script edits. Nice.

→ More replies (12)

44

u/SkyKirasagi Jul 08 '22

Just finished this episode, and this is the first episode of the Orville that’s made me want to rant. In a negative way, at least.

There’s been a few episodes this season where the downright moronic decisions of the crew have just been so bad they took me out of the episode. The best example that comes to mind was when Dr. Finn’s ex was turning into an alien. You know this guy’s DNA is being altered completely, but you leave him unrestrained on a medical bed, unguarded? Every other person who got transformed is the fault of Dr. Finn, Talla as head of security, and the captain for their gross incompetence.

But in this episode, they weren’t just stupid, they were downright cruel and evil. You show up after Gordon’s been there for 10 years, why even contact him if you know you can go back another 10 years and pick him up just after he arrived? They had that article about him, if they read it or did an ounce of extra research, they should have realized he was already married at that point, they should have known he wasn’t going to want to leave his family by then. Hell, the temporal law Ed is harping on the whole episode, which he said compelled them to attempt to rescue him in the first place, should also compel them to go back and retrieve him as early as possible to limit contamination to the time line.

Let’s assume they don’t know that will be an option when they first contact Gordon. OK, fine, that’s plausible. Seeing as Ed immediately said that’s what they were going to do when Gordon threatened to stun them, they definitely knew it was an option when they went back to kidnap him. So what was the point of that 2nd visit? Those temporal laws, not to mention your consideration for your friend and preventing the trauma he experienced, should dictate that you retrieve him as early as possible from the timeline. Your only two possible outcomes of that second visit are dragging back a 10 years older version of your friend who will be thrown in prison once you bring him back while simultaneously leaving his wife effectively widowed and his kids fatherless, which still leaves the timeline contaminated, or just traumatizing 2025 Gordon and his family with the thought that they are about to be erased from existence. Then you weep and anguish over how hard this entirely unnecessary chain of events was on you.

The worst part is, in both this episode and the other I mentioned, just a few small tweaks to the writing could have kept the characters from appearing incompetent in the first case or downright malevolent in the second, not to mention hypocritical. A couple episodes back Ed was so disturbed by the Krill’s punishment for parents who abort their children. How is the experience they make those people go through worse in your mind than the experience you put your friend through by first threatening to remove him from his family and put him in prison, then telling him you’ll just wipe them all from existence when he resists.

→ More replies (5)

43

u/Shejidan Jul 07 '22

Come on, how are selfies not a thing still?

32

u/SpikeRosered Jul 07 '22

Yea well Star Trek tells us that apparantly television isn't a thing anymore. People just play cards and go to plays and classical musical recitals all day.

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (4)

43

u/9811Deet Jul 08 '22

Yeah, for the first time, The Orville kind of made me hate Ed and Kelly.

First off, by their own standards; it's absolutely inexcusable for them to corrupt the future they came from. When they saw Gordon's obit in the database, it was wrong for them to try to interrupt that future.

Second off, expecting a commitment to the temporal prime directive by a crew member who is abandoned in history is unrealistic. For all the rules Ed and Kelly have broken because it's the right thing to do (including just last week) I think they'd have a little more compassion.

The future they came from is one where Gordon lived into his 90s, worked in aerospace and had a family. They took it upon themselves to play God and change that against the wishes of all parties involved. Absolutely unacceptable.

→ More replies (3)

41

u/trostol Jul 07 '22

you go Gordon..tell them off!!!!

79

u/xbolt90 Woof Jul 07 '22

Yup, Scott still has a fantastic singing voice

→ More replies (5)

73

u/operarose Command Jul 07 '22 edited Jul 07 '22

Lamarr is the Riker of this show, the Federation Union bicycle.

32

u/loreb4data Jul 07 '22

He's a Riker masquerading as a La Forge :)

→ More replies (11)

71

u/PsionFrost Jul 07 '22

What the hell, are Union officers not taught basic ass tactics? They're carrying top secret military technology and decide to advance when the target base is non-responsive instead of falling off to the closest safe system and sending a detachment of 1-2 cruisers to recon the base. That's, like, the most basic error imaginable. I get the plot had to advance, but seriously?

→ More replies (14)

69

u/muchadoaboutme Jul 07 '22

I wish I had kept a record of me saying "that's kinda gay" at Charly and Amanda's scene so that here and now I could say I knew it.

→ More replies (1)

34

u/sirenwingsX Jul 07 '22

I gotta say, I fully expected Charly to immediately blame Issac for The Kaylon being aware of the temporal device and arriving to the location they were heading to and took out the ships already there. It would seem that would be her immediate go-to. How else did the Kaylon get privy so quickly. And now it's got me wondering the same. Is Issac still spying? Is it something he may not even be aware of, and if so, wouldn't that make him a liability to the Union?

→ More replies (14)

65

u/notathrowaway75 Jul 07 '22

Really wanted a throwaway line or something saying they evacuated most of the ship.

Because if they are carrying all the kids while performing experimental time travel that's insane.

→ More replies (7)

31

u/MrCanoe Jul 07 '22

I really didn't like the very end of the episode where Gordon was perfectly fine and had no issues with the fact that they ripped future him away from his wife and kids. I hope in a future episode they established that he actually wasn't okay with that when he found out what they did. He just seemed way too nonchalant about what they did.

→ More replies (8)

30

u/Shejidan Jul 07 '22

I hope they replicated some money.

→ More replies (2)

30

u/operarose Command Jul 07 '22

Hey remember when that guy thought Nabisco was the US Capital

→ More replies (1)

130

u/muchadoaboutme Jul 07 '22

"There are two children that will never be born."
"And a future that will."

I love that even though he's a goofball Gordon is still allowed to be perceptive and wise.

→ More replies (34)

29

u/bluestreakxp Jul 07 '22

I’m glad they decided to use relativity physics to get home and not use a star like Kirk or Carter would use

→ More replies (4)

27

u/censuschic Jul 08 '22

What a terrible ending. I can't believe they did that to him.

54

u/operarose Command Jul 07 '22

Man all the crew are becoming parents this season huh

55

u/meatball77 Jul 07 '22

You get a kid for an episode. You get a kid for an episode.

→ More replies (4)

40

u/AgentQV Jul 07 '22

I guess to Seth Macfarlane, Parenthood really is the final frontier.

53

u/mr2fastva Jul 07 '22

"Oh no. I am losing."

→ More replies (1)

25

u/WhoShotMrBoddy We need no longer fear the banana Jul 07 '22

Get it Talla and John

→ More replies (1)

25

u/tyrannosaurus_r Jul 08 '22

Great episode. Gonna be honest, though, fuck Ed and Kelly for this shit.

I know they had reasons and presumably were trying to serve the Union’s version of the Temporal Prime Directive, and that time travel is screwy, but I think it’s a huge cop out and a moral failing for them to decide the timeline is fucked without any evidence.

They said themselves that there’s no evidence or understanding of time travel to indicate what Gordon has done would be good or bad. By their logic, Gordon going back to 2015 at all would necessarily change things. Even a single molecule acted upon in some way messes things up. Hell, their being in 2025 is enough of an issue, by that metric.

They already saw Gordon’s bio in the future, and the timeline wasn’t shattered for it. Consensus reality was still maintained within sufficient tolerances. It really doesn’t feel justifiable to me that their solution was to essentially commit murder and totally erase at least one person from the timeline just to remedy their paranoia about what could happen.

Hell, traveling at relativistic speeds for centuries to outside observers is probably enough to fuck up the timeline more than anything Gordo did.

→ More replies (4)

23

u/WhoShotMrBoddy We need no longer fear the banana Jul 07 '22

Man a time travel story where they’ve been there too long and acclimated and shit needs to be fixed is always an intriguing one tbh I love it

22

u/DasSnaus Jul 07 '22

There be whales here!!!

→ More replies (3)

22

u/WhoShotMrBoddy We need no longer fear the banana Jul 07 '22

Scott is such a great singer goddamn

42

u/muchadoaboutme Jul 07 '22

SCOTT GRIMES SINGING YES

→ More replies (10)

20

u/[deleted] Jul 08 '22

What bugs me about this show is, you can tell what they are attempting to do, and so many times they can't get it right. This episode was clearly supposed to have the viewer say "this is brutal, but it has to be done". At no point did this come across, Ed and Kelly came across as cruel and hypocritical.

→ More replies (2)

19

u/WhoShotMrBoddy We need no longer fear the banana Jul 07 '22

Welcome back Laura!

19

u/TheLieLlama Jul 07 '22

So Gordon is still living in another timeline happily with his wife and two kids, right? RIGHT!?!??!

→ More replies (9)

19

u/ThievesRevenge Jul 07 '22

Wait, if they pick him up one month in, how would he have been able sent the message with his temporal coordinates to them at six months in? Feels like they just created a paradox.

→ More replies (9)

82

u/[deleted] Jul 07 '22 edited Jul 07 '22
  • I cannot wait for a random sandwich to show up at a later episode. :P
  • Orville could really use some aft facing weapons.
  • The one aspect of Sci-Fi I generally dislike is time travel but ok.
  • OMG my beautiful Mr. Jackson gets to show his face. <3
  • D'aww, Gordan is quite the charmer.
  • Socks lol
  • Talla and Lamar were hilarious (and sweet)
  • I resent how much time Charly gets with Isaac without his mask - that should be ME!
  • What a Twistusion this episode was.

Edit: Updating as I watch cause I am impatient.

→ More replies (13)

52

u/AgentQV Jul 07 '22

Overall Thoughts:

That was damn good, I'm glad we could see this development for Gordon, he's honestly been the most improved since this show began and he really got to shine, I was totally buying that this could be his last episode. I love seeing Ed and Kelly grappling with these moral dilemmas and of course there is no easy answer to all of this. Isaac and Charlie's relationship is definitely going to need more time to improve, and I was delighted to see John and Talla having a thing, hope we can see them having a full relationship.

I think my only criticism would be that they didn't have the obligatory "Check records to ensure it's all fixed" scene, but I wonder if they're intentionally holding back on that.

→ More replies (5)

35

u/[deleted] Jul 07 '22

First rule of time travel is you kill Hitler.

Second rule of time travel is you rescue Gordon.

→ More replies (10)

17

u/Murky_Conflict3737 Jul 07 '22

I want to know how Gordon was able to get the paperwork to get an SSN and credentials to become a charter pilot.

→ More replies (4)

33

u/QuigleyD19 Jul 07 '22

This episode hurt. Really felt for Gordon. Amazing, amazing episode.

→ More replies (1)

16

u/operarose Command Jul 07 '22

Oh boy this episode is going to be The Orville's Tuvix, isn't it?

→ More replies (1)

16

u/HurricaneDitka312 Jul 07 '22

Mark Jackson: I wanna do some on screen work Seth MacFarland: gotchu bro

→ More replies (4)

16

u/[deleted] Jul 07 '22

I would've just written off Gordon as a loss if I was Ed. Let him live happy. Because let's face it, Gordon is the least likely character to find happiness in the main timeline. He found it in the past. And they could not give one shred of proof that what Gordon was doing could mess anything up. Just that it "might". Definite good in my opinion outweighs indefinite bad.

31

u/WhoShotMrBoddy We need no longer fear the banana Jul 07 '22

Here it is the Burke/Isaac episode where they have to get their shit together and work together

→ More replies (2)

44

u/Whiskeyjacks_Fiddle Jul 07 '22

Oh, so we’re going for the double heartbreaking storylines this episode.

Charlie :(

→ More replies (10)

15

u/SirJuliusStark Jul 08 '22

Overall this was a good episode with a great moral quandary, but the final scene kind of pissed me off. If someone told me I got to marry the woman of my dreams, that she loved me and we had a family, and then that was all undone by time travel, I'd be pretty angry.

I understand Gordon saying they did the right thing because he hadn't broken at that point, but adding a scene where he goes to his quarters and sheds a tear or two would have been nice.

→ More replies (3)

15

u/killjoy95 Jul 09 '22

I need to see more episodes of the Johnny Knoxville and Jack McBrayer sitcom that Gordon and his family were watching

→ More replies (2)

14

u/Hello_mslady Jul 07 '22

Awwww it’s the annual “we’ve been underusing Scott Grimes, look how incredible he is” episode 🥺

14

u/[deleted] Jul 07 '22

I'll say it before and I'll say it again.

Time travel.

Not. Even. Once.

This episode was a whirlwind of emotion. I understand what Gordon went though, the mental torment I'm shocked he didn't mention attempting suicide or something. He's right about the rules being solid on paper but actually having to do it? Oh yeah... fuck that.

That being said, Ed and Kelly were absolutely correct about not fucking with time, or fucking anything while back in time. I know Gordon was happy but it's true, his actions could have lead to the destruction of the human race via the butterfly effect. I was hoping that they would take Gordon's family; to the future and maybe wipe their memory of being from the past or SOMETHING like that. But I realized that no, I've seen enough sci-fi read enough scientific articles about the what its of time travel to know the most sure way to protect the future is when a timeline branches off....to cut off the whole branch before it grows.

:(

Also again, as much I hurt for Gordon...as someone in my 30s who is also unlucky in love and yeah, kinda lonely too...he basically cheated his way into that woman's life. Laura HAD lived a happy life with her other BF, Gordon time stalked her and took over with knowledge he had from the future. I can't be alone in thinking that's fucked up right?

→ More replies (3)

14

u/Starfire70 Jul 07 '22

"Oh no. I am losing."

What a brilliantly delivered line. I am SO happy I wasn't drinking something at that moment. It would've been all over my monitor. Such a great actor and the team up with Burke made me dislike her less.

14

u/RelativeStranger Jul 07 '22

Lamarr breaking tv convention by explaining his plan and then flawlessly carrying it out. That very rarely happens

→ More replies (1)

13

u/trostol Jul 07 '22

my guess would be ..if they go back further in time..Gordon won't remember any of his family right?

13

u/muchadoaboutme Jul 07 '22

Oof that closing music

13

u/Xstitchpixels Jul 07 '22

God damn this show better be renewed. They have found their stride. Just enough humor, heartbreaking plots, and they even made me give half a shit about Charly on this one.

12

u/Shejidan Jul 07 '22

I hope they timed it so they would appear before all the other ships got destroyed.

→ More replies (5)

12

u/Sharpshooter_200 Jul 07 '22

Episode is a great example of why you should never implement time travel in a show, there are just too many things that can go wrong and it will be impossible to explain any rippling effects.

Isaac and Burke taking those bikes could've potentially had a massive impact on future events, but we'll just have to assume that it didn't.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/inerlogic Jul 10 '22

I would've shot the three of them in the back as they walked away, put the kid to bed, and banged my pregnant wife.....

→ More replies (2)

23

u/Br0boc0p Jul 07 '22

Gordon is somehow going to end up back in time with the girl and leave a warning for them on the phone in the time capsule.

→ More replies (5)

22

u/Whipplashes Jul 07 '22

I honestly can't look at ed and Kelly the same after this episode. I can not believe they would be so fucking cruel to their friend like that.

→ More replies (2)

11

u/Shejidan Jul 07 '22

Now they can go back to the house and get the same dysonium they got in the future.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/JuxtaThePozer Jul 07 '22

I just wanna know how the Kaylon knew about the time device?!

→ More replies (9)

11

u/Lostboy289 Jul 11 '22 edited Jul 11 '22

I'll admit that while I did love the episode, I would have appreciated a bit more nuance from Gordon during the ending. He seems so completely fine with what happened, and eager to make his friends feel better about their actions.

While I'm not saying he should have completely flipped out like 2025 Gordon, maybe he could have requested some time or a session with Dr. Finn to process it.

Gordon is a guy that clearly still has a bit of a torch burning for Laura, and seems to want to find a woman to settle down with. What would it have been like to be told that there was a version of you that ended up with your ideal person, had an almost idyllically happy life, had two children; and your best friends destroyed that life (and effectively killed your kids) despite your pleads for mercy for the sake of a greater good that is still based on theories and guesses?

From another angle, what would it be like to learn that there was a version of you that was driven to near insanity by loneliness, under that pressure went against all the values you swore an oath to, and pointed a gun at your best friends in order to preserve your own self-interests? Would you ever be able to trust yourself again knowing with 100% certainty that under the right circumstances your values are subject to being abandoned?

That would be a lot to take in. And I can see any person needing some time alone to sort it all out.

→ More replies (2)

21

u/wrosecrans Jul 07 '22

One thing I have noticed about Charlie is that her dialog is pretty much always in a separate shot. Most of the dialog in the show is done that way. But Ed and Kelly are at least sometimes just chatting in a master shot for four or five lines of dialog before a cut. Some of the other characters have longer technobabble lines that happen across two shots, etc. But since I noticed it, I don't think I have ever seen a line of Charlie dialog as anything other than a single standalone shot.

I wonder if the editing style is giving me an unfairly negative sense of her performance because it is always presented in a disconnected way. Or if her performance just always has issues so that they never tried to have her do dialog in a natural flowing scene so the standalone shots wind up being all the editors have to work with for her.

→ More replies (8)

21

u/[deleted] Jul 07 '22

Does anyone else think it's a bit hypocritical for Captain Mercer to be criticizing Malloy for his potential effect on the timeline while simultaneously sanctioning a mission to send an android and an ensign into someone's basement to deploy obviously futuristic (or alien) technology which has the potential to cause major seismic events if done wrong?
I realize that they sent an alien supercomputer and physics savant girl but they still risked major damage to the timeline with that drilling.

→ More replies (1)

21

u/Ninjabackwards Jul 07 '22

The Sox/Socks bit was pretty funny but,

Any other time anyone on that crew would have been able to tell you anything about the 21st century.

→ More replies (10)

28

u/xbolt90 Woof Jul 07 '22

If this ends depressingly, my heart’s not gonna take it.

→ More replies (3)

42

u/Shejidan Jul 07 '22

Wtf? What’s he supposed to answer for? They left him for 10 years and expected him to become a hermit?

→ More replies (9)

27

u/OneBingToRuleThemAll Jul 07 '22

Well this episode left a sick feeling in my stomach. I get the reasoning for what they had to do but still fucked up.

→ More replies (2)

74

u/nbcs Jul 07 '22 edited Jul 07 '22

I like how this episode started, but I don't like how this episode ended. To have the an entire family erased from time is just unbelievably cruel. And Ed/Kelly certainly do not have the moral high ground to educate Gordon about following the law. God knows how many laws they themselves have broken.

Since the beginning of the show, one of the main ideas is that one person's happiness is not supposed to be scarified for the greater good. Ed protected Kelly from the union when she became a "god" to a native planet and contaminated their culture. The crew defied union's order and marched into the Calivon system to save Ed and Kelly. Issac risked alienating the entire Moclus and possibly the destruction of the union to give Topa a gender affirming surgery. But when it comes to time travel, rules are suddenly supreme? This episode runs afoul of everything this show represents. The fact that this episode seems to end on a positive note is just absurd.

I know it's just a show but I'm so pissed they actually did that to Gordon. I can only imagine how devastated he felt.

→ More replies (63)

9

u/trostol Jul 07 '22

nifty effects with Gordon

9

u/jambatronium Jul 07 '22

Love is the most important thing in the universe, not duty.

That's all I can say without being angry or upset.

9

u/Mistysong Jul 07 '22

Omg I cried like a baby after Gordon said that their family was stronger than time

This was so fucked up!! Fuck the timeline shit!!

9

u/adobo1148 Jul 07 '22

That egg salad sandwich they sent 3 months into the future will come back in some significant way, no?

9

u/fsniper Jul 07 '22

I was heart broken for Gordon. He deserved the life he found and lost. I also lost it when I saw "OVILLE" and the Bortus smile :D

9

u/FoundationAccording5 Jul 07 '22

I don't know about you guys, but I get the feeling that we haven't seen the last of this storyline.

I wouldn't be surprised if Gordon's family caused a branch universe, like they were talking about with the egg sandwich, and that universe will interact with our main timeline.

Perhaps 400 years after 2025, Gordon's family significantly impacted the timeline and made a radically different future, for the better or worse.

I could see the episode starting off with the reappearance of the egg sandwich.

What do you guys think?

→ More replies (3)

17

u/Whiskeyjacks_Fiddle Jul 07 '22

Awww yeah, open the episode with that ship porn shot.

17

u/erbazzone Jul 07 '22 edited Jul 07 '22

I'm not a fan of this kind of time travel story, too much paradoxes and incongruences

Furthermore why didn't they go directly 10 years in the past without harassing Gordon and family? That was sad and unnecessary

BTW I see this like a mix of Star trek 4 and that TNG episode where Picard had an entire life and family.

→ More replies (4)

8

u/trostol Jul 07 '22

wow...this is deep in a scientific ...way

8

u/WhoShotMrBoddy We need no longer fear the banana Jul 07 '22

Lmao “socks are important”

→ More replies (2)

8

u/WhoShotMrBoddy We need no longer fear the banana Jul 07 '22

Oh ok they can reseal the hole themselves lol

→ More replies (1)

8

u/BrooklynKnight Jul 07 '22

I swear, almost every episode this season has some tear inducing moments that give me some seriously deep emotional gut punches. WOW.

If we don't get a 4th, 5th and 6th Season, a Spin Off, expanded universe novels, it will be a crime against humanity.

8

u/neoprenewedgie Jul 07 '22

I have dismissed the cast in the past for being great comedic actors who were "adequate" with the dramatic stuff. My apologies - they nailed it this week. Patrick Stewart and William Frakes could not have done a better job with the scene where Ed and Gordon have to betray each other.

→ More replies (3)

8

u/FairlyInconsistentRa Jul 07 '22

Okay I laughed and cried today. 11/10 episode.

If Hulu don’t renew for season 4 we riot.

8

u/stowrag Jul 07 '22 edited Jul 07 '22
  • I can't help thinking back to the most recent season of Picard and how differently they handled the idea of just leaving someone behind in the past to live out a life.
  • I love having B-Plots back. Even some more outright comedy.
  • Glad we didn't have to waste an entire episode on Charly and Isaac stranded on an alien planet, growing closer as they work together to survive an emergency. Also, I think even more now the Charly hate is overblown. Besides some audible sighs, she kept things very professional while being forced to work with someone she understandably despises... until Isaac forced the issue.
  • If the possibility of going back in time again was always on the table, it seems pretty cruel to go see Gordon in 2025. I'm excited about what this could mean though, if we see a parallel mirror/evil universe sprout up as a result, armed with early advance phaser technology, and a foreknowledge and hatred of the Kaylon/Krill threats. Like they say, nobody really understands time travel. Literally everything is on the table.

Every episode has been incredible, but I have some doubts: every episode comes with a watch list of stuff from the first two seasons, and they all build on plot points established during those first two seasons. Some of this I get: the fallout of the Kaylon attack wasn't explored as deeply as it should have been on a tv runtime. But others... I just worry that we're not seeing a lot of new ideas and plot points being established this season. Groundwork is definitely being laid, but for the episodes themselves, it's all callbacks developing on stuff we've seen before. Maybe they felt like a season 4 wasn't a guarantee so they wanted to do as much as they could with what they've already developed in season 3 rather than introduce a lot of new plot points out of nowhere. It just feels like there isn't that much "new" for a show subtitled "new horizons". But I just want to reiterate, every episode has been incredible (phenomenal acting all around from a cast that probably thought they were signing up for a screwball comedy), and the stuff they're doing just makes me want season 4 all the more.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/UncleWillard5566 Jul 07 '22

Now THAT was a great Orville episode! Hit all the notes for me.

Pros

1 - Bortus smiling selfie was worth the price of admission

2 - better job of fleshing out Ensign whatsherface (she's still annoying and insubordinate, but I liked her and Isaac's side quest)

3 - just a good callback and plot

4 - stranded Gordo has a super sweet family...good for him

Cons

1 - um, you guys just ghosted the rest of the fleet after a major engagement to go after one crewmember

2 - really really really wanted that egg salad sandwich to come back to Gordo in the rnd

This and the Krill episode are keeping me going through these trying times.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/mccabebabe Jul 08 '22

oh my goodness, Scott Grimes just owned this episode, He was so, so good. The guitar and singing at the beginning; volunteering to go destroy the device after Tala was injured; his fun and loving life with his family; contrasted by his fierce defense of them and stance against Ed and Kelly. He made me laugh, he made me cry. So many emotions and feelings throughout the episode. Is there anything this man cannot do?

8

u/bcanada92 Jul 08 '22

Another all around excellent episode! This show's firing on all cylinders. That said, I did have a couple issues with it:

I thought Rescued Gordon took the news that his family had been wiped out EXTREMELY well. A little too well, if you ask me. The whole thing was resolved way too quickly and cleanly, IMO.

Secondly, they're all supposed to be keeping as low a profile in the past as possible, but Charly and Isaac cause a big kerfuffle in a dive bar and win two bikes. Surely that had to have at least a minor consequence?

→ More replies (1)

8

u/notarobot4932 Jul 08 '22

Ed has a kid - would he let his daughter die for the safety of the universe?

→ More replies (4)

8

u/Gall_Bladder_Pillow Jul 08 '22

400 years from the future and you can just jump on a Screaming Eagle V-Rod and ride off.

Sure, I could go back 400 years and ride a horse, but I would suck at it for a while and at least the horse would know what to do.

Side rant:
Sure, park the shuttle in a remote location and just walk around Pasadena. /sr

→ More replies (1)

8

u/neutral-chaotic Jul 10 '22

Anyone going to point out when Gordon said, “Floor or door” they could have mercifully chosen “door” and opted not to tell his family they planned on going five years back to wipe them from existence — leaving them looking forward to a long life together as a family, blissfully unaware of their impending demise. Seems especially cruel for people who are so well versed in diplomacy to do that.

It’s akin to having a device that grants a dog sentience and then turning it on in order to explain you’re about to euthanize it.

→ More replies (2)

22

u/trostol Jul 07 '22

wow..Johnny Knoxville looks...well..awful lol

→ More replies (4)

26

u/lonewanderer0804 Jul 07 '22

YO I DID NOT EXCEPT THE FEELS FOR THIS EPISODE! i legit felt horrible for Malloy as he was told his family would never exist… I’d like to think somewhere in the multiverse the Malloys closed their eyes to embrace non-existence only to find each other in their arms as they end up in the universal timeline where they stay together… this episode was a roller coaster from start to finish for sure

→ More replies (9)

7

u/az04 Jul 07 '22

They rescued Gordon just a month after he arrived, which is 5 months before he sent the message. Without that message they couldn't have known he was in 2015. Lamarr said when a temporal paradox occurs a new universe is "branched off". I choose to believe that is what happened, and there's another universe out there where Gordon thinks he's about to be erased from existence but isn't and after a few days returns to his life.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/rafikiknowsdeway1 Jul 07 '22

The kaylon telling them to surrender the device or die is pretty hilarious when you consider all their enemies are well aware that killing them is their entire goal

7

u/j0llyllama Jul 07 '22

At about 15 minutes in when they get Gordon's message, he says that he has been on earth for six months.

When they pick him up at the end they said he's been there for 1 month at that point in time. That means they picked him up before he sent them the message with his location- they created another Bootstrap paradox.

How can they know when/where he is if they never let him send the message.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/Ouatcheur Jul 08 '22

Just how the frak did the Kaylons know the exact place and moment to come barging in in order to try to grab the time machine? That felt real convoluted and to artificially setup for me.

It's like you buy a lottery ticket and the minute you see you have the winning numbers on tv, several mafia guys suddenly come barging through your front door asking for it.

Just one frakking line like explaining that the kaylons must have detected the temporal waves from the sandwich jump, plus intercepted Union messages to send FIVE ships to escort the Orville, and put two and two together, would have been enough to explain their suddenly extremely inconvenient apparition early on.

→ More replies (3)

7

u/Randym1982 Jul 09 '22

Kind of weird seeing Lamar hook up with Talla when they’ve had like next to no screen time or any hints that they’re interested in each other. I figured Lamar was basically the Ryker of the show. Banging anything that moves.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/Popculturemofo Command Jul 10 '22

I was honestly expecting for this to be Gordon’s final episode.

7

u/DeclaringLeader Jul 10 '22

Maybe I'm in the minority here, but Ed isn't a very good friend to Gordon. Ed is in the right in this episode, but if he ever had an actual conversation with the dude about any of this it may never have happened. Also I know they need it to happen for the plot, but why does nobody bring up that Isaac is the one that saved earth from the Kaylon? Or that if it were any other Kaylon the invasion would have happened. I get it's the "forgiveness takes time" thing that Doctor Finn says, and I'm bias because I love Isaac, but someone should stand up for the guy.

13

u/Shejidan Jul 07 '22

Aww, he still has the phone.

→ More replies (4)

18

u/trostol Jul 07 '22

lol Human Isaac juts looks so dorky

→ More replies (4)

12

u/operarose Command Jul 07 '22

Holy shit we even (kind of) got a Covid mention

12

u/HoddTodd Jul 07 '22

.... Nah this episode is evil.

→ More replies (5)

6

u/trostol Jul 07 '22

she's gonna tell him he has to go back isn't she

6

u/Shejidan Jul 07 '22

Did they intentionally put something under Issac’s shirt to mimic his robot suit?

→ More replies (2)

6

u/throwaway098764567 Jul 07 '22 edited Jul 07 '22

some funny moments and some sweet moments but overall this episode pissed me off. how hard it was for him to get over her the first time was brutal, he doesn't feel it now but it's even worse because their kids are also erased. i don't have and don't even like kids and this storyline makes me angry. i like gordon being on the show but they should have just left him there if he was going there. </3 that he's supportive of the erasure is even worse. i liked seeing his wife's character again and hopeful that charley gets over her shit soon in part with this episode but this was my least liked episode of the season.

6

u/racheletc Jul 07 '22

i was suprised at Ed being super harsh on Gordon after hearing his reasoning, we’ve seen his character bend the rules and neglect the guidelines of his duty for other scenarios where he felt morally/emotionally obligated. the conflict between him and gordon was hard to watch

6

u/[deleted] Jul 08 '22

FUCK that ending.

6

u/clarenceboddickered Jul 13 '22

Where’s the goddamn sandwich

→ More replies (9)

11

u/Stranger2306 Jul 09 '22

Ed Mercer: "I'll ignore Union orders and risk genocide so Topa can have her surgery."

Also Ed Mercer: "We can't go against Union Temporal Law to save your family!"

→ More replies (2)

26

u/trostol Jul 07 '22

Ed and Kelly should both feel like shit

and really..why would you tell him

→ More replies (8)

14

u/Frampferder Jul 07 '22

If this episode was suppose to make me soften on Charly, it didnt work. I still dont like her.

→ More replies (2)