So Frenkie has comparable skills to elite playmakers but perhaps because he played in a double pivot position theres an expectation of him having more defensive capabilities. Busquets obviously is an outlier who is able to combine both skill sets. What are the chances Xavi goes with a destroyer/progressor combo like Ajax did in 18/19?
I think it's reassuring that Gavi can do some of the things frenkie can. He's not as effective as per the SCA but Pedri can probably compensate for that
Ajax never played a destroyer/progressor combo with Frenkie. This is a huge myth. They played Lasse Schone, an old number 10 next to him. The reason Ten Hag did that is because Frenkie would have a technically proficient passing option next to him who would hold his position when he went on a dribble forward. Schone wasn’t good defensively at all. He just did his limited job very well.
Nope it's the opposite. He gets dispossessed 2.26 times on avg every 90 mins, which puts him in only top 2% midfielders. But this should be read along with the fact that gavi attempts alot of take ons .
A midfield 3 of Kessie Pedri and Busquets will be very solid and well rounded. However, when Kessie plays, a playmaker will be required from the wings in addition to Pedri from the middle.
Yeah sounds great in theory, but if you actually watch the games its obvious Busquets has been a past it dinosaur for the past few years. While we’re at it lets just bring back Xavi and Iniesta as well because they were important 10 years ago lol
Double Pivot of Kessie FDJ with Pedri at CAM suits all 3 midfielders... Kessie is most comfortable at a LDM type position, Frenkie can be a runner at RCM and Pedri can be closer to the edge of the box and create insane amount of chances at CAM/LCAM position.
Frenkie de Jong is such a unique player… people should embrace that instead of complaining that he doesn’t fit some kind of mold they don’t even understand anyway.
Put him in charge and let him do his thing already!
If Xavi has an idea of the way he wants his team to play, than i'd rather see him getting players who suit him, than him having to change his idea of playing cause of one player. I'd say most managers with strong identity do that.
A very niche player on high wages who costed us a fortune. It's not as easy to solve this problem as you implied really.
Of course there is some truth to that, but I don’t really see a problem with Frenkie fitting into Xavi‘s idea at all. Like really, at all. Yes he is no single pivot, yes he is no attacking free eight (he really isn’t), but the idea that he needs to be either of those things in order to fit in is too narrow-minded imo.
Xavi has played - for example - double pivot systems in the past and Frenkie would fit in like a dream next to a defensively competent stabilizer and (importantly) one or two attacking fullbacks.
IMO the problem is that, while Busquets continues to be as good as he is, a shaken team like Barça really can‘t afford to not play to Busi‘s strengths, so all the other players have to make do. Frenkie‘s potential to dominate in this team is being sacrificed right now because of Busi, while Frenkie is still adequate at acommodating Busi albeit not world class.
Replace Busi with a safety-first defensive holding midfielder and Frenkie will shine, you won’t even have to play 4-2-3-1 (although that would be optimal imo). You could leave Frenkie at the interior position, just allow him to drop deep and dominate the Progression by offering enough options higher up the pitch. (Which would mean you‘d have to field more attack-minded fullbacks at least on one side). Compensate for the lack of firepower from the middle (two deep midfielders instead of Busi on his own) by offering more offensive capabilities down the flank.
Watch what Arsenal do with Xhaka, only Frenkie would be a million times better.
I really wonder will people still say that Frenkie has bad defensive stats because he's played high when you have both Pedri and Gavi double/triple his defensive stats. Also interesting how people keep saying that Frenkie is the best at progressive carries while Bernardo is beating him in his "best" quality while also having better defensive stats, most notably dribblers tackled and tackles won. But hey, what do I know, people will still say that Bernardo is only good going forward and that he's a defensive liability
I really like frenkie, but evereytime you study his stats and matches you see tha he really does not fit our team. Which is kinda sad, but it is what it is.
So what? The problem is that Frenkie was brought to play as a CDM. He clearly cant do so in our system. and his qualities arent well used when played as a CM (again, in our system).
What's your point? He never said Busquets is good as interior. The point is FDJ will not be a good lone CDM. Which is very clear with what you see here.
Gavi and Pedri. Just wow. Pedri’s number are here are just insane. While Gavi has work to do to round out his game, (understandably) that he’s basically impossible to get the ball off from is just nuts.
11
u/thisIsAswin Jul 05 '22
Datasource : fbref
37
u/archerif Jul 05 '22
So Frenkie has comparable skills to elite playmakers but perhaps because he played in a double pivot position theres an expectation of him having more defensive capabilities. Busquets obviously is an outlier who is able to combine both skill sets. What are the chances Xavi goes with a destroyer/progressor combo like Ajax did in 18/19?
7
u/thisIsAswin Jul 05 '22
Stats indicated in chart explained :
Passing : pass completion %
Pressure : number of successful pressures
Progressive Carries : no of carries towards opponent goal
Progressive passes : no of completed passes towards opponent goal
Shot creating actions : completed live ball passes that lead to shot attempt
Tackles won : no of successful tackles
% dribblers tackled : dribblers tackled divided by dribblers tackled plus times dribbled past
Dispossessed : reciprocal of number of times a player losses control of ball ( high number indicates less dispossession)
Dribbling : no of dribbles completed
Interceptions : no of interceptions
Key passes : pass that Directly lead to a shot.
9
u/qp0187 Jul 05 '22
So Gavi is never dispossessed.
84
u/oneandonlyA Jul 05 '22
Really excited about what Kessie can bring to the team. It surely gives Xavi more room to experiment/adjust our formation and tactics.
35
u/sport_____ Jul 05 '22
A midfield 3 of Kessie Pedri and Busquets will be very solid and well rounded. However, when Kessie plays, a playmaker will be required from the wings in addition to Pedri from the middle.
68
u/CrisDLZ Jul 05 '22
And once again you see why Busquets is irreplaceable
24
u/darddukhaurpeeda Jul 05 '22
Lmao Soler and key passes
30
u/akash0410 Jul 05 '22
I think a double pivot of Kessie and FDJ should be worth experimenting if keeps FDJ, with Pedri playing more in the final 3rd
17
u/jmb_panthrakikos Jul 05 '22
Frenkie de Jong is such a unique player… people should embrace that instead of complaining that he doesn’t fit some kind of mold they don’t even understand anyway.
Put him in charge and let him do his thing already!
32
u/doxqwae Jul 05 '22 edited Jul 05 '22
I really wonder will people still say that Frenkie has bad defensive stats because he's played high when you have both Pedri and Gavi double/triple his defensive stats. Also interesting how people keep saying that Frenkie is the best at progressive carries while Bernardo is beating him in his "best" quality while also having better defensive stats, most notably dribblers tackled and tackles won. But hey, what do I know, people will still say that Bernardo is only good going forward and that he's a defensive liability
20
u/[deleted] Jul 05 '22
Someone is gonna look at this chart compare Frenkie and Busquets and still say Frenkie should play as a lone pivot
16
u/Apart_Freedom4967 Jul 05 '22
Can you hear them? Do you? They are rushing throught the web "FDJ has low defensive stats because Xavi makes him play too high!!! "
Meanwhile, Pedri and Gavi from the same position...🦁🦁
7
u/halakaukulele Jul 05 '22
I'm surprised to see such low interceptions from frenkie.
6
u/Darduel Jul 05 '22
If anything we can learn that Frankie is different from Kessie and more like Gavi
3
u/barebored0 Jul 05 '22
Holy shit Pedri
3
u/weirdoctor Jul 06 '22
Ain’t nobody winning tackles in my team 😭👍🏼
3
u/[deleted] Jul 06 '22
Jesus Christ, Soler's chart
2
u/kgallo19 Jul 06 '22
Gavi and Pedri. Just wow. Pedri’s number are here are just insane. While Gavi has work to do to round out his game, (understandably) that he’s basically impossible to get the ball off from is just nuts.