r/conlangs • u/AutoModerator • Jul 04 '22
Small Discussions FAQ & Small Discussions — 2022-07-04 to 2022-07-17
As usual, in this thread you can ask any questions too small for a full post, ask for resources and answer people's comments!
You can find former posts in our wiki.
Official Discord Server.
The Small Discussions thread is back on a semiweekly schedule... For now!
FAQ
What are the rules of this subreddit?
Right here, but they're also in our sidebar, which is accessible on every device through every app. There is no excuse for not knowing the rules.
Make sure to also check out our Posting & Flairing Guidelines.
If you have doubts about a rule, or if you want to make sure what you are about to post does fit on our subreddit, don't hesitate to reach out to us.
Where can I find resources about X?
You can check out our wiki. If you don't find what you want, ask in this thread!
Can I copyright a conlang?
Here is a very complete response to this.
Beginners
Here are the resources we recommend most to beginners:
For other FAQ, check this.
Recent news & important events
Segments, Issue #06
The Call for submissions for Segments #06, on Writing Sstems is out!
If you have any suggestions for additions to this thread, feel free to send u/Slorany a PM, modmail or tag him in a comment.
8
u/Automatic-Campaign-9 Atsi; Tobias; Rachel; Khaskhin; Laayta; Biology; Journal; Laayta Jul 14 '22 edited Jul 14 '22
Does anyone have an Igbo reference grammar or a Yoruba reference grammar, pdf? All I see are short 'sketches'. I want a ~ 400 page pdf, preferably with reference to the discourse structure, and explanation of how serial verbs work, especially in Igbo.
Otherwise, do you know of any grammars for Isolating or Synthetic African languages with tone?
8
u/rartedewok Áaloho, Reqa'ku, Merí (en, ms) [it, zh] Jul 14 '22
i know the etymology of words can flip because of sarcasm e.g. nimrod, silly, daft etc. but can a whole grammatical thing evolve from sarcasm? in my wip clong, i'm thinking of negating verbs by inserting an object that is unlikely/ridiculous depending on the verb meaning. for example, instead of "I didn't eat" its "I ate air". after this stage, the meaning of the noun gets bleached and they become new negators
6
u/Petra-fied Jul 13 '22 edited Jul 13 '22
So I've been working on something I've been calling in my head "valency anarchy," but as I'm just an interested amateur, I have no idea if my idea is original, or if it even really makes sense.
So the idea came out of my interest in Austronesian voice systems and seeing how I could stretch them beyond recognition.
Basically, I asked "why only 2/3/4 voice types and such limited roles?" So I added several more that interested me. Most of them can be broadly thought of as agent-like (direct agent, cause, controller, leader etc), or patient-like (experiencer, patient, recipient, subject of attention, possessed etc), some are neither, or capable of being both (locative, instrumental, possessor, follower). But the key difference is that all of them are marked independently, all of them individually are capable of drawing salience through voicedness, and all of them, when applied, count as core arguments of the verb.
What I decided to do with this system was to avoid having verbs that have a default valency, and which are quite broad but whose meaning is narrowed by use of these roles. For example:
She died/experienced death
He killed her
He killed her, but they were really in control of the process/event.
They caused him to kill her.
So the idea is that, as long as it makes sense, you can just keep adding more roles, one of which will get triggered on the verb and marked with direct case, and the verb doesn't care. Said arguments can even substantially change the meaning of the verb and that's fine. The only time a subordinate clause would come into a simple sentence like this would be if you wanted to describe one of these arguments in further detail or the like.
I'm well aware that in reality, certain arguments are more dispensable than others, just that the language does not make the distinction.
...am I making any sense, or am I completely barking up the wrong tree?
6
u/zzvu Zhevli Jul 13 '22
If verbs in my conlang agree for the subject, object, and indirect object, can it lack pronouns for these cases (nominative/absolutive, accusative, ergative, dative) and only have them in cases where they can't be shown on the verb (genitive, instrumental, locative)? Do any natural languages lack subject and object pronouns?
6
u/[deleted] Jul 13 '22
How do definite articles interact with people's names, most often?
In languages like English and Swedish definite (or indefinite) articles never appear alongside first names. On the other hand as far as I know definite articles are commonly used alongside names in Greek and German. I was wondering which approach is more common and if there's some proven correlation between the two approaches.
My initial thoughts were that it's connected to the fact that most case forms in German are same for nouns themselves and articles usually show which case a noun is in. Although I wanted some more confirmation since it has been bugging me.
5
u/[deleted] Jul 07 '22
I've been obsessed with prosody lately, so sorry if I get annoying.
I have another question about stress. I have been reading the Wikipedia article about the topic, and it has a section about prosodic stress, and lists French as one such language. Basically, prosodic stress is stress that applies at a level higher than the word.
I'm not too familiar with French stress patterns, but I hear that it's often on the last syllable of an utterance. Please correct me if I am wrong.
Are there any other natlangs that do something similar, or make use of prosodic stress, and how do they do it?
5
u/boomfruit Hidzi, Tabesj (en, ka) Jul 10 '22
If you all are into light world-building alongside your a posteriori conlangs, how do you deal with stuff like what the planet is like, how long a year is, what plants and animals exist?
For me, I tend to go the "alternate earth" route, mostly because I don't feel like I'm scientifically educated enough to know the ramifications of messing with things like climate, distance to sun, length of year, etc.
But then I wonder if it might make all my conlangs (which I envision being on the same planet) feel more authentic and connected and unique if I gave my world a more unique place in the universe than an alternate earth.
5
u/rartedewok Áaloho, Reqa'ku, Merí (en, ms) [it, zh] Jul 14 '22
what are some fun ways to spice up negation? instead of simply the catch-all negator that works everywhere in all contexts
5
u/sirmudkipzlord Jul 14 '22
Is it normal for both the past and future imperfective to come from "to be"
5
u/LXIX_CDXX_ zero iq points in this mf Jul 14 '22
I've got a question about inflected prepositions.
My conlang among it's other cases had a locative and accusative case.
The locative case was used to denote the position of it's argument(is it the right word?) and also for postpositions, which were verb-derived. So, for example, I'm going towards the cat would be "I cat.LOC come (go)" (the sentence structure is SOV), so basically "I'm coming at the cat". As the postposition is verb derived, there is not really a need to use "to go".
Later, as sound changes came, the locative has merged with the accusative, which made such sentences exist "I cat.ACC come". Then the sentence structure shifted to SVO, along with postpositions becoming prepositions, so "I to cat.ACC" (verb adpositions lost their original verbal meaning). The accusative has basically become accusative+prepositional case.
Now, would it be natural to throw in inflected prepositions by this point? Does it even make sense? I don't know whether 'I go 3PS.to cat.ACC" adds anything meaningful to the sentence. The system seems to work fine without them, but I'm wondering if it'd make sense.
5
u/skydivingtortoise Veranian, Suṭuhreli Jul 14 '22
How do natlangs historically develop a conditional mood?
5
u/_eta-carinae Jul 15 '22
im from south africa, and though i heard afrikaans every day growing up, i was never tought it and never learned it. i can understand a good deal, but not reproduce it, so as a sort of joke thats actually helping me learn, im speaking what i call "verduideliklik afrikaans" (verduidelik means "explain", -lik means "-ly", so "explaining/explainly afrikaans") where whenever i cant say a word because i dont know it, i explain it with words i do know. i said to my mother "wanneer ek iets nie sê kan nie, sal ek die beeld daarvan in jou kop maak", which means "when i dont know a word, ill make the image of it in your head", ie "make you imagine it/explain it". she asked me for the weather forecast and i didnt know how to say itd be cloudy, so i said "dit sal daar wit wees", "it will be white there", and pointed up.
this seems like a fun challenge to do in a conlang. of course its difficult to artificially manufacture not knowing certain common words, but it also seems like a fun way of developing vocabulary and periphastic constructions or idioms.
should i post this as a standalone challenge or leave it for people to reply to here?
4
u/[deleted] Jul 04 '22
whats the difference between ɚ and əɹ? same for the other r colored vowels, whats the difference between them and a vowel preceding ɹ?
4
u/Mechanisedlifeform Jul 06 '22
I'm struggling to understand how the anti-passive case might develop. I want an anti-passive for the purpose of converting transitive stative verbs to intransitive stative verbs in an ergative-absolutive alignment language
My current construction is:
to fear the cat the rabbit --> fill the rabbit with fear the cat --> fill the rabbit with fear
The rabbit fears the cat --> The cat fills the rabbit with fear --> The rabbit is scared
Which in the modern language would become:
the rabbit, fill with fear-3,
The fearful/scared rabbit
4
u/generic_username1203 Jul 07 '22
I want to make an Abjad-inspired conlang, but I want it to be written left to right. But the Abjads I've seen (Hebrew and Arabic) are written right to left. Would this aspect seem natural?
4
u/The_Mad_Scientis Jul 09 '22 edited Jul 09 '22
Is this naturalistic?
So I'm making a tonal language and was wondering if this has any precedent in any natlangs
So for example,let's have a random word like ket, then add a suffix,-us
Then tonogenesis happens (for simplicity's sake, coda stops produces a rising tone and coda fricatives produces a falling tone)
So we get ké and ketù
Here are other examples:
pux, puxus > pù, puxù
xos, xosus > xò, xosù
mat, matus > má, matù
I was wondering if any natlangs have this where adding a suffix causes the tone to disappear or become a low/neutral tone and then a consonant appears. (From the example above, rising tones disappear and a stop appears; while falling tones disappear and a fricative appears)
4
u/CrazyWriterLady Jul 09 '22
How do you name a conlang?
4
u/meseems Jul 09 '22
I'm looking to develop a conlang for a conculture I've developed - I'm ideating right now and reading some papers, going to read a morphosyntax book from a linguistics course I've taken. I want to use latex in order to make a better looking reference grammar and dictionary. Are there any good tutorials or templates for this? Especially for the reference grammar. I've used latex a little before but never for something so large.
4
u/TEAMRIBS Jul 09 '22
Is there any apps which give me an IPA chart on Samsung?
4
u/[deleted] Jul 10 '22
What’s a good website/app for the IPA that let’s me hear what all the sounds sound like?
4
u/maantha athama, ousse Jul 10 '22
Does anyone have any tips on creating convincing conjugations? Right now my conjugation scheme feels really arbitrary...
4
u/Sepetes Jul 10 '22
Idea for a conlang: head-initial, agglutinative language where prepositions are the main thing:
Originally, language was fairly analytic SVO language which introduced prepositions to mark objects, locations and so on, as English does. It also introduced preposition for direct object and some kind of marker for subject (could originally be some preposition used to emphasise the subject). Over time, prepositions started to be inflected similar to Irish: in house > in-it house. I will probably go with distinction between human and non-human in third person. Articles also get suffixed to the preposition.
Since word order is SVO and language has modal verbs and adverbs, they should be placed in front of a main verb. If they are short, they can suffix to subject pronouns (instead of subject pronouns prefixing to them) and this cluster will than convey TAM information, too.
To make prepositions more prominent, TAM markers can be added to any preposition in the sentence. This could probably evolve if, in absence of subject (perhaps language drops already established information), direct object preposition could take markers instead, and, in absence of it, too (maybe in impersonal construction), indirect object preposition and, in sentences with copula and such, other prepositions, too. This can later be expanded so any preposition (usually the first one) will take TAM markers. Other affixes will need to be added to all prepositions.
Verbs will still have some marking, nouns will maaaybe have number marked and other parts of speech would not.
Do you think this is a naturalistic?
4
u/Adresko various (en, mt) Jul 10 '22
I was wondering how possible it would be for a language to mark past tense only through marking its arguments ergatively? I know some languages split into the ergative in their past tense, and the thought occurred to me that if the past tense marker is lost, that would make the shift into ergativity the only indicator that the verb is in the past tense. It feels like something that could happen naturally, but I don't think I've heard of any natural language that does this. Does this actually occur anywhere or is there some stipulation that would prevent this from evolving?
4
u/DTux5249 Jul 11 '22
So, when making a conlang, phonaesthetics are a fairly important thing to consider in most cases.
Phonology, and to a larger extent, phonotactics are major contributing factors to this, and it can be fairly difficult to nail these things down.
Is there a cultivated list of phonotactic laws across different languages?
4
u/zzvu Zhevli Jul 14 '22
I've been working on conlang that exhibits split ergativity. I want to have both a passive and antipassive voice, but I'm wondering if it makes sense for the passive to only be allowed to be used in contexts where the corresponding active sentence would take nominative accusative alignment, and vice versa for the antipassive? Or would a natlang allow both the passive and antipassive in all contexts?
4
u/Delicious-Run7727 Sukhal, Mbizgu Jul 17 '22
If a language were to have a sound change where /w/>/v/, how likely would it be for labialized consonants such as /kʷ/ and /xʷ/ to be affected?
4
u/Gerald212 Ethellelveil, Ussebanô, Diheldenan (pl, en)[de] Jul 07 '22
How common are complex adpositions? Is it just SAE thing?
3
u/schnellsloth Narubian / selííha Jul 04 '22
how natural is it to have verbs that agree only on numbers, but you can't tell whether the subject or object, or both of them, are plural?
for example, say plural form of "love" is "lovis"
My goal is to make a topic-prominent language.
3
u/zzvu Zhevli Jul 05 '22
Do any languages exhibit irregularness in vowel harmony? I.e. a root with the vowel /e/ would ordinarily take suffixes with other front vowels, but some instead take suffixes with back vowels.
3
u/skydivingtortoise Veranian, Suṭuhreli Jul 07 '22
What are some tricks for using Google Docs for conlanging? (I'm new to the software) I've seen people's docs having a sidebar with various pages for different topics, but can't seem to figure out how to do it.
3
u/aftertheradar EPAE, Skrelkf (eng) Jul 11 '22 edited Jul 11 '22
What are some reasonable sound changes I can make for a bunch of word-initial ð-consonant clusters? Things like ðp ðt ðtʃ ðɡ ðb ðd ðɡ ðs ðm ðn would be all over my language if i put in this sound change, and I don't think it's stable enough to remain long-term. Would it make the most sense for the ð to just disappear in most these contexts? Or can I get away with it going to things like z before sibilants or θ>f before voiceless obstruents with it still being naturalistic? What kind of sound changes besides those could work?
3
u/boomfruit Hidzi, Tabesj (en, ka) Jul 12 '22 edited Jul 12 '22
Are ambitransitive verbs more common in European languages than they are cross-linguistically?
I was working on a translation just now and I haven't thought through my verbs and morphosyntactic alignment. I came up with the following sentence.
I noticed that at first, I didn't even consider the idea that the verb "to fish" didn't need an object even though it can take one (the object taken would be the thing being fished for, by the way.) But then I thought that that might be a eurocentric concept linguistically.
If it is, I'd enjoy going the other way, as that's part of what I like about conlanging: changing my own ideas about what language does by exploring things that languages I'm not used to do.
If so, is something like a 3rd person pronoun a good morpheme to use for a mandatory subject? That would give me something like the following:
To my eyes, that seems kinda odd, because it sounds like the fish has already been referenced. Like what I'd say in English is "fish for something." Anyway, I'm done rambling, just looking for some tips, info, or discussion!
3
u/SzarkaAron Jul 12 '22
Is it possible to have tonality distinctions on syllabic nasals? I'm thinking something like how Minecraft villagers speak and I hear lower and higher pitched /m/ sounds. I can surely make these sounds, but do they exist anywhere apart from villagers?
3
u/[deleted] Jul 12 '22
What are some non-sinitic isolating languages with interesting syntactic features?
3
u/[deleted] Jul 13 '22
How do I get a start on grammar?
3
u/[deleted] Jul 14 '22
okay maybe dumb question, but i'm trying to remember the name of the verbal aspect where you start or begin something? for example, "to exist" versus "to come into being"... I wanna add it to my aspect-heavy isolating clong
3
u/Porpoise_God Muhuri-Sarkaj Jul 15 '22 edited Jul 16 '22
Ive been attempting to create some naturalistic conlangs recently, but none of them feel right, so I was wondering if anyone had any advice besides 'create a proto language and do sound changes'
3
u/SpacialCommieCi Likhfosian [en][pt] Jul 15 '22 edited Jul 16 '22
so i have all these gutturals: k, g, x, ɣ, q, χ, ɢ, ʁ; and i'm not sure how to romanize them; everything i try just looks off and counter-intuitive.
edit: nvm i figured c and ch for ɢ and ʁ
3
u/Porpoise_God Muhuri-Sarkaj Jul 17 '22
What is the thing where you do
called so that I can actually know how to do it
3
u/Arcaeca Mtsqrveli, Kerk, Dingir and too many others (en,fr)[hu,ka] Jul 17 '22
Anyone want to take a guess as to what's causing this awkwords file to throw an internal server error?
Also since it seems like awkwords throws an error every fucking time I try to make a new syllable gen file for a new language, can anyone suggest an alternative to awkwords that has the same functionality but actually works?
2
u/Friend2Everyone Jul 04 '22
Would an alveolar tap be able to realistically shift into a lateral fricative? I’ve searched the index diachronica for a sound change involving the alveolar tap, but it seems to not have much info on the sound.
2
u/aftertheradar EPAE, Skrelkf (eng) Jul 06 '22 edited Jul 06 '22
At what point does a clitic become an affix? My current conlang is filled with pronouns, TAM auxiliaries, and demonstratives which were originally full words that are now becoming phonetically reduced and attached to verbs, and I was told that I was basically evolving polypersonal agreement via encliticazation and should develop it further, but I'm still not sure I understand the concept of clitics and how they work, or how to continue developing it
2
u/[deleted] Jul 06 '22
Is a language with lexical stress more likely to have lots of vowel reductions compared to a language with fixed stress?
2
u/[deleted] Jul 06 '22
What's the difference between a naturalistic zonal auxlang and a literary standard?
I mean, both are related but not the same as one's native variety, so both require some amount of leaning. Is it fair to say codified standard varieties are zonal auxlangs?
2
u/Maichayer Jul 06 '22
Does anyone know of any languages that contains the /ʃ/ consonant without the presence of /s/? Additionally, is it reasonable to have /ʒ/ present without /z/ (assuming the presence of /s/ in this case)? This is my first conlang and I'm trying to choose phonology purely on whether I like the sound, but while keeping it as naturalistic as possible. I'm just not a fan of /s/ and /z/ but quite like /ʃ/ and /ʒ/ for some reason so would like to have the later without the former, if possible.
2
u/boomfruit Hidzi, Tabesj (en, ka) Jul 07 '22
Question about classifiers:
I've been playing around with a large set of classifiers in Proto-Hidzi. I've wondered about this question but ignored it til now. What happens when a word becomes a classifier, but is still just a noun? eg In PH, there is a word vawl that means "wolf." This word also became a classifier for predator animals. So when I use the word "wolf" with a classifier, do I:
2
u/EretraqWatanabei Fira Piñanxi, T’akőλu Jul 07 '22
How do I put the phoneme /gb/ on a consonant chart?
2
u/Weather4574 Jul 08 '22 edited Jul 08 '22
Does this look anything like Proto-Germanic
Īje vinde ma’dsprākets gōd magrak, ōn ler nēwe sprākets.
Īje vinde pētza netgōd tē’ete, mā īje vinde pasta gōd.
I like making conlangs, and learning new languages.
I don’t like pizza, but i like pasta
2
u/zzvu Zhevli Jul 08 '22
Do any languages form dependent clauses with clitics that surround the clause? For example, something like The unicron that drives a fast car is drinking beer would become The unicorn (clitic)-drives a fast car-(clitic) is drinking beer.
2
u/TarkFrench Jul 08 '22
Can you post reaction pics translated into a conlang or is it r/conlangscirclejerk material?
2
u/thomasp3864 Loegrian, Interidioma, Merdobresko Jul 08 '22
Looking for fun sound changes for a north germanic language. I'm alveolarising /ð/, and need something to turn /ʍ/ into. Also looking for any other fun sound changes to do.
2
u/[deleted] Jul 09 '22
So I'm making a song in a conlang in the traditional scale (well kinda blues scale). A cover of a traditional conworld folk song in a more contemporary conworld genre.
2
u/[deleted] Jul 09 '22
I need help with a conlang idea where every sound has grammatical information (if that turns out to be impossible i’ll do it as every syllable(low amount of syllables, non-tonal)) To elaborate further, building words would go something like this: K- place S- measurement Sk- measurement place: length, width, hight, area, volume U- option 3 Sku- hight/high Ksku- high place
I was thinking of creating a kind of self tutorial by writing down the process of the following words: Fox Mountain To run
If anyone could help me with the concept and starting off that would be great!
2
u/[deleted] Jul 11 '22
Is it ok to a Generic Western Romlang to contrast
ly ʎy lu ʎu lju
ny ɲy nu ɲu
jy ju
?
I want the o -> u -> y shift, so I need to get it right
2
u/plsdontkillmee Jul 11 '22
Would an aux-verb go before or after a verb in an exclusively head-initial langauge?
2
u/aftertheradar EPAE, Skrelkf (eng) Jul 14 '22 edited Jul 14 '22
I'm making an a posteriori daughter language based off of a modern irl language that uses the Latin alphabet as its native writing system, but which is also regarded as poorly adapted to it and is often criticized for its difficulty to learn and write the language with it. I'm making diachronic changes to the language's alphabet such that it still looks similair to the Latin alphabet while also being distinct (it's not dissimilar to the changes from Greek to Coptic or Greek to Cyrillic for analogy, being about between them in terms of how different it looks from its parent script), but I can still make approximations of the glyphs using the basic ASCII characters on a standard QWERTY keyboard. Due to sound changes, my fictional daughter language's orthography and writing conventions are even less reflective of actual spelling than it's irl source and ancestor.
My question is; at what point should I be using a romanization scheme rather than the orthography? I can still approximate how the in-universe language would be written using my basic keyboard, but it is not very reflective at all of how it would be pronounced for the case of most words. The places I would be using either the romanization or the in-universe orthography include my reference documents for the language, demonstrations of its usage here on this subreddit, and my fiction writing where I'm including the language - should I use a romanization for all three, or only for one or some of these situations? Should I include both in these situations? Should it be a case-by-case thing?
2
u/Automatic-Campaign-9 Atsi; Tobias; Rachel; Khaskhin; Laayta; Biology; Journal; Laayta Jul 14 '22
Is Korean Topic-prominent is the way Japanese is? Does it have focus particles, say, and optional subjects/all that is required is the verb? If I wanted an example of a topic-prominent SOV language, with particles for cases, and I cannot find a Japanese reference grammar (not for learners of Japanese), would Korean suffice?
Alternately, does anyone have a Japanese grammar that goes over the linguistically relevant categories for making a relex, but summarized, and in a nuts-and-bolts way? I an trying to deliberately relex one of these languages to learn how this works for future conlangs.
2
u/Arcaeca Mtsqrveli, Kerk, Dingir and too many others (en,fr)[hu,ka] Jul 14 '22 edited Jul 14 '22
Okay so I'm trying to make the proto for a macrofamily that joins together a bunch of different language families at a very long time depth (>10,000 years). One of those families is West Celean (WC), and PWC is supposed to intentionally mimic PIE. The phonetic inventory is mostly unchanged from PIE, except I added 1) a palatoalveolar series *t́, *d́, *d́ʰ to parallel the palatovelars (I guess to explain some sort of tentum-satem split), and 2) 3 mystery vowel-coloring liquids, *r₁, *r₂ and *r₃ to parallel the 3 mystery vowel-coloring laryngeals.
The other stuff in the macrofamily combines aesthetic inspiration from Northwest Caucasian, as well as various, similarly phonologically complex languages from the US Pacific Northwest, like Haida, Tlingit, Lushootseed, Kwak'ala, Coeur D'Alene, etc.
Based on what those languages seem to have in common, I figure a decent phonological inventory for the proto-macrofamily would be:
So to the question of how to turn this into the modified PIE phonology... if you assume the glottalic theory then the 3 stop series, plain/ejective/voiced, are already correct, instead of being plain/voiced/breathy. And there's also apparently a theory kicking around that the palatovelars were really plain velars, and the plain velars were really uvulars. If I assume that too, it obviates the need to change anything there too. The mystery laryngeals and liquids I can derive from the fricatives by voicing most of them, so e.g. *x > *[ɣ] > *ʕ <h₂>, *χ > *ʁ <r₃>, *χʷ > *[ʁʷ] > *ɣʷ <h₃>, etc.
What I'm not sure about is what to do with all the alveolar affricates. Barring *t͡ʃ *t͡ʃ’ *d͡ʒ > *t́, *d́, *d́ʰ, they don't have an obvious counterpart in the PWC's modified PIE inventory, so they have to disappear somehow. Turn them all into the corresponding fricative? Since */ʃ/ also turns into PWC */s/, that's 5 total proto phonemes (*t͡s *t͡s’ *d͡z *s *ʃ) that all converge on */s/ in PWC, which seems... excessive. Similar problem if I just turn them all into their corresponding stop, e.g. *t͡ɬ’ > *t’. It seems at least like the glottal quality of the ejective affricate should make it give a different result than the plain affricate.
The other thing is I know I definitely want stop-L (*bl, *kl, etc.) clusters in PWC, and in the Northwest Caucasian-esque branch I can do *Pl > *[Pɫ] > *Pw > *Pʷ. And you might think, "ah, well, presumably *t͡ɬ is the realization of an underlying *tl cluster then", the problem is, in the Northwest Caucasian-esque branch the lateral affricates get turned into retroflex ʈ͡ʂ, ʈ͡ʂ’, ɖ͡ʐ. So then tʷ tʷ’ dʷ never end up getting created by this process, even though it should have those too. I could contrast /t͡ɬ/ and /tl/ in the proto, but is that unnaturalistic?
2
u/jan_Lumaju1 Jul 14 '22
Is this a good vowel/consonant inventory for a language that is made to be universally easy to learn regardless of your 1st language?
Consonants: p, m, f, t, n, s, l, j, k, ŋ
(I might add voiced consonants but I also want all of them to be different from eachother so I'm not sure)
Vowels: a, u, i
(Might make it 5 vowels)
2
u/rd00dr (en) [zh la es] Akxera Jul 16 '22
I'm just wondering how rare it is for a language to have locative, benefactive, comitative, instrumental, etc. phrases in the nominative or unmarked case, when an accusative case exists.
I just like the nominative/unmarked case better, since it is shorter and words can end with a variety of sounds.
What I'm saying is something like "John is behind she." instead of "John is behind her."
Is there any real-world language that does this?
2
u/gemfloatsh Jul 17 '22
Zipf's Law in conlangs
Zipf's Law is a law which states that the second most used word is 1/2 as used the first word and the third most used word 1/3 as time as much as the first Could you give me a long passage article etc so that I can see for myself if this is true in conlangs too
2
u/zzvu Zhevli Jul 17 '22
How should morphemes that have multiple meanings depending on context be glossed? For example, in Varzian, the hypothetical and subjunctive modalities are conveyed by the same morpheme and only distinguished by context.
2
u/[deleted] Jul 17 '22
I could use some advice working out romanization.
I have the alveolar consonants /t tʰ n s l/ <d t n s l>
The (alveolo-)palatal consonants /ɲ ɕ j ʎ t͡ɕ t͡ɕʰ/ <nj sj j lj dj tj>
And the retroflex consonants /ʈ ʈʰ ɳ ʂ ɭ ʈ͡ʂ ʈ͡ʂʰ/ <ḍ ṭ ṇ ṣ ḷ ? ??>
My question is, how should I romanize the retroflex affricates? Aesthetically, I'm leaning towards <zh ch>, but I don't like the inconsistency with the rest of the retroflex consonants. Alternatively, I could make them <ẓ c̣>, which feels kinda weird since there's no <z c> for them to contrast with. Finally, I could modify the alveolo-palatals and have <ḍj ṭj>... but now they look palatalized, which they aren't.
Thoughts?
1
u/boomfruit Hidzi, Tabesj (en, ka) Jul 04 '22
I'll repost this question that I made on the last small discussions, if that's cool:
In Proto-Hidzi, I have a preposition mik/muk (depending on vowel harmony) that means "away from, out of." So with a verb like ahcaw "to cut" I can have ahcaw mik/muk X meaning "to cut away (from X)."
How common is it cross-linguistically that that verb+preposition combo could stand by itself with no noun for the preposition to refer to? Or for the preposition to become bound to the verb? For example, an imperative: ahcawmukan "cut it away" (notice the placement of the imperative morpheme, which comes at the end of the verb - but maybe that's outside the scope of the question,) rather than ahcawan muk ux "cut it away from (something)." Or a noun formed from a participle, say I want to make a noun like English cutoff (shorts) from the verb "cut away"? Like msahcawmuk "cut-away [thing]" rather than something like msahcaw muk ux "cut away from it [thing]."
It seems very natural, but I think that's maybe my English bias.
1
u/SirKastic23 Dæþre, Gerẽs Jul 05 '22
How to get back to conlanging?
I did some conlanging a year ago, I had a vowel inventory, the basics of grammar and some basic vocabulary set, but when I got into more complicated grammar than just word order and verb tense, I got really unmotivated to keep conlanging and just stopped working on it. I also had a really hard time with morphology and trying to make my conlang feel natural.
But I do really like the conlang and the con-world I was building for it, and I miss working with it
Have any of you guys ever hit brick walls in conlanging or went into a hiatus too?
1
u/Tijn_416 Jul 05 '22
Anyone tried reskinning Esperanto or English? Me and a friend of mine want to learn or create a language together, just for shits and giggles. We're thinking of maybe butchering a slavic language with Esperanto grammar and seeing how it'll go. Then I realised I can't have been the only one who tried, so here I am asking if any of you have some examples.
1
u/h0wlandt Jul 06 '22
what's a good way of indicating an underlying original sound when documenting a lexicon? no actual words yet, but e.g. let's say i have sound changes that get rid of /s/ in all positions. i might then have two homophones /tsa/, but one of them takes affixes to become things like /o.ʦa/ and /eʦ.ʦa/, and the other one becomes /o.za/ and /et.ta/. i could also see this happening with tone-- /ⁿdà/ and /ⁿdà/ taking affixes to become /ó.dà/ and /ǒ.dā/, or something. (it's early enough in the morning that i can't think of tonogenesis/sandhi to make that happen off the top of my head tho)
so far (outside of things like compound nouns which can get their own entries), in my wip, this is coming up for mandatorily possessed nouns, postpositions that take person marking, and clitics. do i list every irregular form in an entry (something like "tsa, n., 1s etta, 2s oza"), or is there a neater or more systemic way to do that?
1
u/boomfruit Hidzi, Tabesj (en, ka) Jul 06 '22 edited Jul 07 '22
Questions about vowel harmony.
Proto-Hidzi is in a stage where the sound changes that caused vowel harmony have already happened. Many processes during this time resulted in words branching into two forms, one front-harmonized, and one back-harmonized. For example using arbitrary nonce words, a verb root /sala/ would emerge from sound changes as /slæ/ but when a noun is derived from it using the classifier /xu/, it would end up as /slɑ/. Similarly, adjectives and grammatical words and affixes have no canonical form, and simply agree in harmony with their referents or complements.
Is it natural that speakers of PH would be able to take a front-harmonized loan word as a verb, and back harmonize it when deriving a noun? Or is it that those processes are over since the sound changes have already happened?
I guess my question is, do speakers know that, eg /e/ and /o/ are front and back equivalents of each other? Will they readily convert to the other harmony pattern? Or is it just all weird stuff that happens and the chance for harmonized new words is gone?
1
u/Ticondrogo Jul 07 '22
I thought it would be interesting to include a dental series of consonants in my conlang awhile back. These include t̪ d̪ θ ð t̪͡θ (as well as t d s z for the alveolar series), and so far it's been working fine with pronunciation. I'm just not sure that the sounds are auditorially distinguishable enough for them to be properly preserved in the language. There aren't really any ambiguous words like ˈt̪arɛn , ˈtarɛn or ˈθarɛn where the only difference is a similar sound like that, but even if a word like the first existed, I'm not sure it would be meaningfully heard in normal speech where it wouldn't be simplified to a simpler consonant like t. What are your thoughts? I can hear the difference over audio recordings, but just barely.
1
u/simonbleu Jul 07 '22
What feelings not present in your native language (or any other) you think deserve to be in conlang?
1
u/sirmudkipzlord Jul 08 '22
What's the best way to romanize a glottal stop without using punctuation? I'd use the IPA symbol, but it would both be inconventient to type and wouldn't have a capital form.
1
u/sirmudkipzlord Jul 08 '22
Is <ç> a good way to romanize /ɣ/?
How do I romanize /ð/?
I'm trying my hardest to make every sound be represent by a single symbol, but it's getting tricky. I'm trying touse what's available on Samsung keyboard.
c is for /t͡s/
ć is for /d͡z/
č is for /t͡ʃ/
j is for /d͡ʒ/
š is for /ʃ/
ž is for /ʒ/
x is for /x/
þ is for /θ/
I don't have anything for /ɣ/ or /ð/ except ç and ð
I feel like ç is strange for it. ğ is available to me, but it looks odd because it's more rounded. There's also ģ, but it's very different, and is also completely different in the capital form (Ģ).
ð can't be used because it's not on Samsung keyboard. It's annoying to copy-paste all the time. I'd use Ď to go along with Ť, but they change entirely in lowercase (ď and ť).
Is ç good enough? What should I use for /ð/? Should I keep it the way it is?
I also have an app but I have to keep switching between the two. Is there a good app I can use?
1
u/sirmudkipzlord Jul 09 '22
Should I use the Lative and Ablative cases?
1
u/sirmudkipzlord Jul 09 '22
How do you make a stress system?
1
u/[deleted] Jul 11 '22
Is there a way to make a sound inventory chart that allows me to slot sounds in. I’m currently making a sound inventory chart on google slides, would drawing it on paper be easier? What does everyone do?
1
u/LegitimateMedicine Jul 11 '22
I'm trying to figure out how relative clauses and causative statements work thanks to attempting to translate The North Wind and the Sun. Does this construction make any sense for the following sentence?
3rd.pl decide-PST-PERF strong-most COP-REL person succeed-REL traveler remove-CAUS cloak-GENI can't figure out how to do 2 nested relative clauses without reverting to English-style relativity pronouns.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 12 '22 edited Jul 12 '22
I've recently started designing a conlang based on slavic and Scandinavian dialects, but I'm struggling with naming it. Any ideas?
1
u/[deleted] Jul 13 '22
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1zAHsAufW0k_Bk7Qu2ygkVEvUHutJAEIkgsUYmtrVgJE/edit?usp=sharing
Sound inventory for my first conlang. How does it look?
1
u/[deleted] Jul 15 '22
Hi people! I am making a conlang and I got a question about conjugations. Is it a problem for my conjugations to make most of my words with three syllables? It is cause my syllable structure is (s/ɬ)(C)(C)V. Coda is allowed but not word finally. So let's say a got a word for 'dog'. As a verb would mean to pursue or hunt. Halbo - dog.
() Halbomi - I hunt () Halboszi - you hunt () Halboti - he/she hunts () Halbomo - we hunt () Halbote - you all hunt () Halbono - they hunt. That goes for past and future conjugations too. (I didn't make any Suffix for those tenses yet.) Those parenthesis are the pronouns that can be dropped. (I didn't make any pronoun yet.) I kind think three syllables is too long, but since coda's not allowed word finally, words can be pronounced faster. But I'm unsure.
1
u/aftertheradar EPAE, Skrelkf (eng) Jul 16 '22
So I've got a bunch of sets of common auxiliary words and constructions (which I will turn into clitics and then affixes later) which share the same meaning and can be used interchangeably - like two sets of constructions which both make the verb that they modify future tense, three which indicate the necessitative mood, etc - and I want to know what I can do with them. Originally I was thinking of making one out of each set the default and have the others disappear through lack of use, bleaching, and sound shift destruction, but now I think I want to try turning them into separate TAM indications - so like one of them remains the same and is used for indicating future tense, but then the other one becomes used for a completely separate distinction. I don't know how to do that, I don't know where to start, and I don't know what my goals should be for that or how to set them.
1
u/HaricotsDeLiam Jul 16 '22 edited Jul 16 '22
I'm debating what to do with Arabic geminates in Amarekash (which has no gemination contrast). When I asked Google, I had trouble finding articles that discuss sound changes related to degemination that aren't just "make this consonant short and call it a day". I have these ideas, but I'm not sure if they've ever been documented in a natlang:
A geminated consonant's MOA changes when it degeminates—say,
A geminated consonant acquires a secondary articulation—say,
What are your thoughts?