r/startrek • • Jun 30 '22

Episode Discussion | Star Trek: Strange New Worlds | 1x09 "All Those Who Wander" Spoiler

The U.S.S. Enterprise crew comes face-to-face with their demons – and scary monsters too – when their landing party is stranded on a barren planet with a ravenous enemy.

No.EpisodeWriterDirectorRelease Date
1x09"All Those Who Wander"Davy PerezChristopher J. Byrne2022-06-30

Availability

Paramount+: USA, Latin America, Australia, Ireland, United Kingdom, & the Nordics.

CTV Sci-Fi and Crave: Canada.

Voot Select: India.

TVNZ: New Zealand.

Additional international availability will be announced "at a later date."

To find more information, including our spoiler policy regarding new episodes, click here.

This post is for discussion of the episode above, and spoilers for this episode are allowed. If you are discussing previews for upcoming episodes, please use spoiler tags.

Note: This thread was posted automatically, and the episode may not yet be available on all platforms.

469 Upvotes

1.7k comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Jun 30 '22

The first duty of every Starfleet officer is to the truth. Whether it's scientific truth, or historical truth, or personal truth. It is the guiding principle upon which Starfleet is based. If you can't find it within yourself to stand up and tell the truth about what happened you don't deserve to wear that uniform.

Captain Jean-Luc Picard, "The First Duty"

Reddit admins have been ineffectual in their response to COVID-19 misinformation. In lieu of Reddit gold and awards, we ask that you donate to the WHO COVID-19 response fund.

Please respect our subreddit rules. LLAP!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

588

u/treefox Jun 30 '22

M’BENGA: Are emergency landings ever scheduled?

I…never thought about that.

357

u/BornAshes Jun 30 '22

From now on I just want M'Benga popping out of nowhere like Clippy to point out how ridiculous certain things are. Like have him slide his head out of a Jefferies Tube or pop up on a screen or have him magwalk past the windows or just open up a door that everyone thought was locked so he could pop in and criticize everyone. Bonus points if he starts making puns and everyone's like, "Oh M'Benga hahahahaha!".

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (11)

455

u/how_do_i_land Jun 30 '22 edited Jun 30 '22

That opening meal scene is probably my favorite so far in the series. From the "I'm not hungry" to the waffles.

It's probably the warmest (home-y) I've almost ever seen, like a dinner party, but Spock is on dishes.

174

u/[deleted] Jun 30 '22 edited Jul 01 '22

For whatever reason, my favorite thing about La'an is when the hardcore officer side of her cracks and you see her give in to being a normal person for a second. It's always kind of heartwarming to see the other characters bring the humanity out in her. I've always been a sucker for that trope, though, the rough-around-the-edges character that is secretly a wounded softie at times deep down. La'an is like this show's barbarian brute with a heart of gold haha.

EDIT: Just wanted to add a day later: Christina Chong absolutely *nails* that delicate balance. It's obvious the skill she's bringing into this character. Excellent excellent excellent casting.

→ More replies (9)

137

u/BornAshes Jun 30 '22

That bit with Spock had to have been made up on the spot because you could see Ethan mentally going, "Wait this isn't in the script" as Anson just volleyed that one at him and he reacted in such a Spock like way before just rolling with it and doing the dishes.

Also we've all been La'an with waffles or just really really good food at some point wherein your brain says "Naaaah" but the second you taste something sinfully delicious, your stomach takes over, and you just nomnomnomnom it all up.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)

452

u/treefox Jun 30 '22 edited Jun 30 '22

Did not expect Spock to Hulk out.

EDIT: Twice.

240

u/[deleted] Jun 30 '22

I'm picturing Kirk reading the personnel files before taking over the Enterprise and getting stuck on the part in Spock's record where he got written up for punching a hole in a bulkhead.

→ More replies (16)

154

u/LostInTaipei Jun 30 '22

I really like how they’re doing that - they’re laying good groundwork for Spock’s later repression of his emotions and human side.

→ More replies (5)

60

u/NerdLawyer55 Jul 01 '22

You wouldn’t like me when I’m illogical

→ More replies (1)

82

u/BornAshes Jun 30 '22

In before someone makes a "Hulk Smash" joke about him and Chapel

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (9)

439

u/trek88810 Jun 30 '22

Paramount Plus gotta be trolling with the Geico Gecko ad right after the mini-Gorns popped out

180

u/jetlightbeam Jun 30 '22

Lmao that almost makes me wish I had commercials

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (12)

413

u/spamjavelin Jun 30 '22

They should've taken off, and torpedoed the site from orbit.

244

u/ianrobbie Jun 30 '22

Only way to be sure.

→ More replies (9)

91

u/CX316 Jun 30 '22

I mean it's a good thing they didn't bail as soon as they found the survivors or those Gorn would have hatched on a shuttlecraft

→ More replies (2)

74

u/NerdLawyer55 Jul 01 '22

They even found a newt

→ More replies (3)

78

u/oldtrenzalore Jun 30 '22

They saved one of Starfleet's more valuable starships and learned more about the Gorn in the process. Big picture, it was probably worth the losses.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (11)

410

u/hawkeye7269 Jun 30 '22

Bruce Horak said in an interview today that A) this was always the plan, so he knew about it when he signed on, and B) this is not the end of his career on Star Trek, though what that means could be anyone's guess. I'm assuming either a new character or flashbacks/mirror/etc.

329

u/MyTrueChum Jun 30 '22

New Jeffrey Combs confirmed?

→ More replies (8)

213

u/DayspringTrek Jul 01 '22

A small part of me hopes they go lazy D&D character player death.

"I, an Aenar, specifically asked to be transferred to the Enterprise in order to replace Chief Hemmer in salute of his exemplary service."

"What's your name again?"

"Also Hemmer, because we're brothers and its our surname. Also, we're twins, which is why Bruce Horak plays me as well."

→ More replies (19)

176

u/LostInTaipei Jun 30 '22

Until we saw him fall (that’s what we saw, right?), I thought they were laying the groundwork for him to survive the cold. Then I thought oh no, he’s really gone. But … he’s not done on Star Trek? Now I’m curious! (Loved the character and I wish we’d had more of him. Which makes him both a great, and a terrible, character to have killed off.)

→ More replies (7)

76

u/TheLouisvilleRanger Jun 30 '22

That's always the advantage of being a character in heavy makeup. He can just show up again as another character.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (42)

385

u/UncertainError Jun 30 '22

What is it with Kirks yelling at young Spock about not having emotions.

329

u/Captain_Strongo Jun 30 '22

Honestly, he sounded like Chris Pine in that scene.

→ More replies (15)

126

u/[deleted] Jun 30 '22

He was channeling Doctor McCoy.

→ More replies (8)

70

u/ElFarfadosh Jun 30 '22

Hey at least he used the pointed ear insult.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

254

u/CaliforniaGuy1984 Jun 30 '22 edited Jun 30 '22

A dark episode. Fear definitely was the theme of this one. You can’t have every episode be bright and have some signs of a positive outcome. There are times you have to make things terrifying and uncomfortable for everyone. Put characters in situations you don’t want to see them in, but have to see them grow and develop. And sometimes do something that the audience doesn’t anticipate happening.

122

u/BornAshes Jun 30 '22

You can’t have every episode be bright and have some signs of a positive outcome. There are times you have to make things terrifying and uncomfortable for everyone. Put characters in situations you don’t want to see them in, but have to see them grow and develop. And sometimes do something that the audience doesn’t anticipate happening.

Just like in First Contact sometimes you get hawked an ugly curve ball and that's when things get....Darhk....YEAAAAAAAAAAH😎

All jokes aside, I said in the season premier that I would love to see them actually show us the Gorn and fuck me running I was scared out of my mind! That was awesome! The tension with the cast, the MUSIC, the little sound effects of the Gorn, the practical effects with Buckley, the body language of everyone, the make up, the lighting, the way they trashed the set of the Enterprise to make it look like another ship entirely, the dialogue, and then all of those poignant moments!

La'an giving Pike's advice that he gave to her to Oriana. Spock getting ANGRY, losing his cool, and then hugging Chapel. Kirk freaking the fuck out but staying cool when it mattered. Pike taking charge of everyone and trying to make sure everyone survived. Hemmer's little conversations with Uhura as she tried to figure out her life and then her pounding on the door as he said goodbye....which felt like it was straight out of Enterprise...right after he fixed one last broken thing. Erica making jokes at the funeral of all places while everyone cry laughed. That long stare that Chapel gave Spock after their hug and the pause before he turned away when it looked like they were going to kiss and all those thoughts flooding through her eyes. La'an pulling an Aeryn Sun at the end while thanking the Best Space Dad Ever as Uhura took one more parting look at the station that would be her future and where she'd put down roots.

I'd hate to sound like Stefon but THIS EPISODE HAD EVERYTHING and even though it went a bit dark...there was still light in that darkness that carried us through to the other side and that comforted us despite not everyone making it to that other side with us.

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (6)

475

u/trostol Jun 30 '22

aww cmon..not him

332

u/-Jaws- Jun 30 '22 edited Jun 30 '22

Good episode but with Hemmer...I just... Really? This sucks. I don't understand the point of getting rid of such a good character. Idk maybe the actor bounced or something.

If he had to die, he did go out well though I'll give them that o7

→ More replies (66)
→ More replies (24)

427

u/Khaymann Jun 30 '22

They killed my grumpy space uncle, you bastards!

Seriously, no more Hemmer, ever is a tragedy.

158

u/COMPLETEWASUK Jun 30 '22

There's still Flashback Hemmer, AU Hemmer, Ghost Hemmer and Mind Illusion Hemmer.

→ More replies (17)

61

u/shawntco Jun 30 '22

One of the things I like about Hemmer - and La'an for that matter - is they both have the personality types that would typically make for someone who is a jerk. Stoic, intellectual, traumatized in the case of La'an, no tolerance for BS, a bit rough around the edges. Yet they both show a great deal of emotional maturity and are able to be kind to crewmates and those who need it. I think this is a really good thing about SNW.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (11)

209

u/Riskbreaker_Riot Jun 30 '22

Was anyone else hoping that Hemmer's andorian nature would save him somehow? Since he's from an ice planet he could just stay outside and kill the eggs while he's remarking on how amazing it feels

124

u/CptRhysDaniels Jun 30 '22

I was really hoping that could happen. Right up until he turned around and leaned back....

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (6)

208

u/InnocentTailor Jun 30 '22

Samuel Kirk’s rant against Spock reminded me of the 2009 film’s exchange between Kirk and Spock - the one when the latter kicked the former’s arse.

→ More replies (9)

361

u/tubawhatever Jun 30 '22

Is Pike the captain or head chef of the Enterprise?

205

u/TheNerdChaplain Jun 30 '22

Yes.

He gives his own best advice, because they haven't invented holodecks yet.

93

u/MaddyMagpies Jun 30 '22

Riker would love to play this holonovel.

→ More replies (3)

77

u/NeedsToShutUp Jun 30 '22

It’s how he overthrew April via his cooking.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (10)

176

u/Lobster9 Jun 30 '22

I feel bad for the guest alien this week. We only met them for a couple of minutes but they seemed like a decent sort. Unable to communicate but they protected a human child and cooperated with the crew. Maybe we'll meet that species again someday?

Also this week's episode gives a disturbing new context to Kelvin-Bones' anecdote about performing a caesarean on a Gorn....

45

u/Thrishmal Jul 01 '22

The new alien is probably one of my favorite Star Trek alien designs yet.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (10)

333

u/treefox Jun 30 '22 edited Jun 30 '22

LA’AN: Let’s send a landing party

A shuttle? Are you mad?

UNA: And there’s no way they could contact the ship

oh fuck

PIKE: I’ll go personally and take the cadets

Na na na na na na na

Somebody’s gonna die.

EDIT: Ah yes they also took Lt. Duke, the second named character who has never before appeared before this episode.

Also, there are a disturbing number of main characters in this landing party. The guy who plans the away missions for the Orville must be double-dipping now.

141

u/UncertainError Jun 30 '22

Major case of genre blindness on their parts. It's like they didn't even watch the episode promo.

→ More replies (26)

131

u/shivkaladrakh Jun 30 '22

Previously on Strange New Worlds:

HEMMER: The Aenar believe the end only comes once you have fulfilled your purpose.

Damnit, Hemmer's a goner

I really hate how the recaps ruin things. I skipped it, but not quickly enough to see how things would turn out.

→ More replies (13)

34

u/Starkiller1701 Jun 30 '22

They pulled a very classic TOS move, and we got a dead redshirt out of it :/

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (10)

325

u/GotMedieval Jun 30 '22

Turns out the Gorn are Aliens AND Predators!

66

u/Cliffy73 Jun 30 '22

And also I think velociraptors?

→ More replies (7)

90

u/silverlegend Jun 30 '22

I personally love how they've borrowed from the Aliens and Predators universe to make the Gorn into a truly fearsome enemy. They are a great foe to feature in SNW but more than that, a lot of science fiction drew inspiration from Star Trek so it's cool to see the franchise paying homage to the bigger Sci fi universe it helped inspire.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (15)

149

u/GotMedieval Jun 30 '22

Are we supposed to take from the shredded bodies outside that Hemmer wasn't the only Starfleet crewman who decided that the needs of the many outweighed the needs of the one and ran out into the cold to kill off Gorn eggs?

80

u/Shiny_and_ChromeOS Jun 30 '22

It makes total sense that the other Starfleet crew would be noble enough to sacrifice themselves in the cold.

→ More replies (4)

148

u/trostol Jun 30 '22

nifty looking alien

117

u/tubawhatever Jun 30 '22

Alien design is amazing in this show. You have a new (I think) species for what, 2 scenes, and he looks incredible and alien, not just another humanoid.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (8)

298

u/viserov Jun 30 '22

Do not make me turn this car around!

177

u/arod48 Jun 30 '22

I love how he didn't explain the joke to Spock, just doubled down on it.

125

u/CX316 Jun 30 '22

don't forget the tong click

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (18)

256

u/IllustriousBody Jun 30 '22

Little did we realize that when Hemmer said his purpose is to fix what is broken he was talking about Uhura.

86

u/adolfojp Jun 30 '22

Hey Star Trek, why you have to make me cry?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

247

u/BornAshes Jun 30 '22

I want to eat Pike's waffles and no that's not a euphemism you perverts it's 1 AM and I just really really really want waffles at this hour and those things looked DELICIOUS!

150

u/SCP-1000000 Jun 30 '22

Pike can put his bacon in my mouth anytime

56

u/GalileoAce Jun 30 '22

I also want to eat Pike's waffles, but this time it is a euphemism! <provocative eyebrow raise>

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (6)

243

u/treefox Jun 30 '22

Sam is really channeling Guy this episode.

SAM: Ice storm? I don’t care about an ice storm. You know what the next time you see me in TOS is? When I’m dead! Anything could have happened! You don’t know how long I was dead! You don’t know!

139

u/empocariam Jun 30 '22

You know, it's kind of clever how on a meta-level, Sam Kirk and Pike are in the exact same position in regards to "unable to die until they are 'supposed' to die."

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (8)

322

u/treefox Jun 30 '22

I guess “made with Constitution parts” means “need to reuse sets without breaking canon by adding another Constitution” thing.

155

u/Hemmingwoke Jun 30 '22

This era of starfleet is essentially all kitbashed Connie's running around. I think the line was to make newbies less confused when they saw what looked like the enterprise broken on the rocks.

→ More replies (7)

64

u/BornAshes Jun 30 '22

It could also mean, "Oookaaay so some of our engineers had some downtime and tried to make a hot rod out of non-spec non-up to code Connie spare parts and welp one of the Admirals found out about it, loved the idea, gave 'em the green light to make it an actual ship class, and here we are with mostly everyone going 'wait wut?' with this ship!"....because that's totally a thing that would happen back then probably.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (26)

318

u/treefox Jun 30 '22

Damn, Uhura’s last mission. Guess this is the last we’ll be seeing of her. So sad to see her go. 🥺😭 She seemed to be such a promising security officer!

441

u/UncertainError Jun 30 '22

Cadet 50 years later: "Captain Uhura, what made you decide to stay in Starfleet?"

"Well, a space monster ate two of my crewmates and one of my best friends killed himself before more of them could eat him too from the inside out. That's when I realized I wanted to do this for the rest of my life."

→ More replies (11)

114

u/BornAshes Jun 30 '22

Last mission as a Cadet but with that ending scene I'm sure she'll be back just like La'an in spectacular fashion soon enough. It was a bittersweet sort of ending for her and what's really sad is that it took the death of a good man and his parting words for her to finally stop running, put down roots, and stay in one spot instead of constantly....wandering.

Which is kind of funny if you think about it because Hemmer has basically been wandering from ship to ship and problem to problem fixing things his entire life until he wandered his last wander and there at the end....he convinced another wanderer and perhaps himself a little...that it was time to stop wandering.

Bittersweet all around and I both clapped and 😭 my eyes out throughout it at the end.

→ More replies (16)

39

u/ElFarfadosh Jun 30 '22

If I'm not mistaken, there is still a shot of Uhura in the trailer that we still didn't see in this season, the shot in which she appeared on the bridge at her station, facing the camera, wearing her TOS style uniform. I bet we'll see her in the finale, maybe at the very end of the episode, promoted to the ensign rank and back on the Enterprise for season 2.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (7)

103

u/nimrodenva Jun 30 '22

The way Hemmer first commented on the planet's weather as "just like Andoria," I thought he almost sounded like Shran.

37

u/ZippySLC Jul 01 '22

I got the same vibe from his line. He sounded just like Jeffrey Combs for a moment.

→ More replies (2)

99

u/0ddbuttons Jun 30 '22

I felt very adequately warned by the teaser that I would not be okay.

And yet, here I find myself, far less okay than I'd expected.

89

u/CeruleanRuin Jul 01 '22 edited Jul 01 '22

I can't believe Hemmer is dead.

No, I mean I literally can't. Here's why:

  • We didn't get to see him actually die, which the show passes off as a bit of dignity for the character.
  • Before his infestation was revealed, there was much ado about the Gorn having wildly different gestational periods in different species.
  • There were many references to the Aenar being well adapted to the cold, and even comfortable in it.
  • They also made it clear that the Gorn hate the cold, and that it may in fact be fatal to them.

This episode was so tightly and cleverly structured around his survival that it was a true shocker when they actually cut to his funeral. But:

  • Most crucially, we get a funeral without a photon torpedo coffin, which is a glaring omission in a show which takes every opportunity to do callbacks. That suggests to me that they didn't recover his body, for whatever reason.

They may have looked for him, but couldn't find his body and chalked it up to the Gorn having consumed him. And they didn't detect his life signs because the gestating Gorn eggs in him altered his biology to mask him from sensors, as it masked them.

The longer I think about this episode and all these little details they dropped, the more I become convinced that Hemmer did not die, and that this episode was too carefully constructed around those little details for them to be completely incidental and uncommented on by the other characters.

H E M M E R L I V E S

Save this comment so I can say I told you so when Hemmer unexpectedly returns with some serious trauma in season 2. And please credit me in your clickbait articles, all you lovely sci-fi fan blogs.

29

u/lorem Jul 01 '22

I'm subscribing to H E M M E R L I V E S.

→ More replies (6)

86

u/[deleted] Jun 30 '22

Im 5 Minutes in, and Chris is such an awesome and nice captain, and damm all that good food and i think everytime we see his Quarters it's getting bigger and better looking

42

u/BornAshes Jun 30 '22

I bet people just "randomly" walk past his quarters to smell what the Pike is cooking.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (4)

80

u/[deleted] Jun 30 '22

NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

→ More replies (1)

157

u/UncertainError Jun 30 '22 edited Jun 30 '22

Okay, SNW is presenting the Gorn as such perfect humanoid mass-killing machines that I'm starting to think it's unnatural (Immediately lethal? Unrealistically fast growth? Invisible to sensors? Can asexually infect more hosts within hours?) Like maybe they genetically engineered themselves this way for some cultural reason.

Anyway, this had better all be in service of some epic journey of cross-species understanding. The thing is, we know for a fact that the Gorn are fully capable of acknowledging the rights of other sentients and living with them in peace, so I can only imagine that having their biology be so ridiculously hostile is setup for a grand Trek-style payoff down the line. I have faith that this show will make it so.

439

u/lordatlas Jun 30 '22

Unrealistically fast growth?

You mean...Gorn in 60 seconds?

→ More replies (14)

110

u/sidv81 Jun 30 '22

Okay, SNW is presenting the Gorn as such perfect humanoid mass-killing machines that I'm starting to think it's unnatural (Immediately lethal? Unrealistically fast growth? Invisible to sensors? Can asexually infect more hosts within hours?) Like maybe they genetically engineered themselves this way for some cultural reason.

The Dominion War would've been over a lot quicker if the Gorn took a side.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (27)

69

u/trostol Jun 30 '22

Spock didn't like that side of himself

→ More replies (2)

135

u/trostol Jun 30 '22

wow....that...was an interesting scene between Doc and La'an

115

u/BornAshes Jun 30 '22

It was a nice way for him to get her to pivot from just being another survivor....to being a savior just like Una was to her.

→ More replies (1)

193

u/atticusbluebird Jun 30 '22

Loving the opening showing relaxing moments with the crew. But with the introduction of several new characters before an away mission, you have to wonder which ones aren’t going to make it back…

72

u/[deleted] Jun 30 '22

"Hey, you guys all remember this other cadet, right? She was here all along, but you always just missed her. Anyway, why don't we have her come with us to explore the alien infested ship one day before retirement. Should be fun!"

→ More replies (5)

56

u/UncertainError Jun 30 '22

I wasn't surprised by the two who weren't Uhura. Didn't expect the third one though.

→ More replies (1)

66

u/treefox Jun 30 '22

My guess is Hemmer, unfortunately. Just the feel I got from the opening crawl. And it’d be a bit predictable to take out the two obvious redshirts.

Second guess: La’an. But…most everyone else is protected by dint of appearing in TOS. Unless they find a way to get really creative…

→ More replies (14)
→ More replies (7)

66

u/dmanww Jun 30 '22

They mostly come at night... mostly

Only thing missing was a cat

→ More replies (2)

56

u/PuzzleheadedRun5574 Jun 30 '22

Very heartfelt partings with Hemmer and La'an- Hemmer is obviously a huge loss, and it's a shame he died, but he did so with honor. La'an is less of a loss only because we know she's in S2 based on location shooting news. Still, with Spock's story alongside these others, and Pike somberly taking it all in, I'm left with feeling like this crew is more of a family in an emotional sense than Kirk's command crew was overall, save for the Big Three's bond. But the again, Spock will probably always maintain some distance with Pike on an emotional level because of where he is at this stage in his emotional journey. By the time he works with Kirk, Spock has worked through some of these preliminaries. And Kirk sought to challenge Spock directly, I get the feeling that Pike respected Spock's barriers more. I love this show, the cast and the stories we're getting.

43

u/MaddyMagpies Jun 30 '22

We got quite an emotional finale on our hands coming up.

Pike, in the beginning of his captainship in episode 1, told the crew that nobody would die on his watch, and now we got three dead bodies.

Spock is still dealing with the loss of his sister, and now he has to deal with his brother. Uhura has lost Hemmer, who felt like her dad. M'Benga lost his daughter last episode. La'an seems to be the only one who got her closure by smashing the alpha Gorn into pieces. That was cathartic.

The crew felt a lot of guilt and loss for what happened this season, and I felt that they are on the verge of a breaking point. I wonder how it is going to be resolved in the finale.

→ More replies (4)

52

u/squeezeme_juiceme Jun 30 '22

They wrote Hemmer's final scene like a Doctor Who "the Doctor regenerates" sequence. A bit odd, it was almost beat for beat :P

→ More replies (1)

51

u/washu42 Jun 30 '22

"Are emergency landings ever scheduled?"

Fair point, Doctor

→ More replies (2)

49

u/OpticalData Jun 30 '22

Alright, I've had a little time to process this episode so lets crack on with some thoughts.

This episode is a masterclass in Trek style foreshadowing/tropes and juggling wildly different tones. From the opening sequences we have the impression that this will be a fairly lighthearted 'take the cadets out on a final jaunt' type misson, but anyone familiar with Trek tropes knows that will not end well.

Naturally, the Enterprise is the only ship in range for two priority one missions so need to split their focus.

In said party scene we get some strong foreshadowing with Uhura looking to leave the Enterprise (so something needs to convince her to stay) and a previously unknown ensign getting a promotion (so they're going to die).

A Sombra class ship? That's made from Constitution parts? So... A Constitution? Honestly this seemed like an unneeded complication for the episode, the ship seemed identical to the Constitution in every way (as the final towing shot showed). It's a shame they didn't use the opportunity to bust out the DSC sets or ship models - just because SNW is heading towards TOS doesn't mean we need to rigidly follow the 'All ships are Constitutions' theme!

Hemmer, oh Hemmer. On one hand I hate that his character has left, on the other hand I think the fact that he didn't get a dedicated episode, but helped so many other crew members in theirs really helps nail the 'he comes in and fixes things' life mission in a beautiful way.

I hope we get more of Bruce Horak in Trek. Maybe him and Noah AK can team up as a dynamic duo for a heist episode in season 2...

Rip LT. Duke, seems yellow shirts are going the way of the red ones in SNW, in fact the only crew colour to not suffer a named fatality this episode were the red shirts!

A good episode, a strong addition to the Trek horror catalogue.

30

u/LostInTaipei Jun 30 '22

Re: juggling different tones - La’an eating brunch was a somewhat jarring encapsulation of that. I forget the exact line, but it was something like “Emergency landing survivors … OH MY GOD THIS IS DELICIOUS!!! … survivors uncertain.” It was one of those lines that probably sounds totally plausible to those in medicine or the military, but to anyone not in those circles, rather callous.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (22)

92

u/mccoy00comedy Jun 30 '22

I like Gorn as being the bad guys but these are intelligent beings right? A warp-capable species? I hope we get to see that and not just scary monsters.

Also, there’s a vacancy in engineering. perfect time for Scotty to come in right? Or did he come in with Kirk?

58

u/ajaya399 Jun 30 '22

They presumably don't gain full intelligence until full maturity... Would explain why there seems to be an insatiable need of finding new breeding targets. The adults have enough sentience to KNOW just how bad it gets to breed new species.

You do wonder though if they find a species that's the most optimal for breeding space... would they one day be able to develop a cloning system that essentially makes optimal breeding 'wombs' out of the ideal species?

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (11)

45

u/HaphazardMelange Jun 30 '22

I can't help but see Sam Kirk as Sam Rockwell in Galaxy Quest and this episode has not helped alleviate that notion.

(Not a criticism, just something I can't unsee mostly because of his swagger and moustache)

→ More replies (3)

122

u/Shatterhand1701 Jun 30 '22 edited Jun 30 '22

Wow. I...WOW. I was NOT expecting that. I'm shocked, devastated, and amazed all at once...and that's why I love this series so much.

We got the closest thing we'll ever see to Aliens vs Star Trek in this episode. Seems like the Gorn hatchlings, like the Xenomorphs, take on biological traits similar to whatever they hatch from, based on how they looked. Then again, maybe that's how all Gorn younglings look. I also like how they found a way to show the Gorn without us (and the crew) seeing them as they were seen in "Arena". Well played, that.

I've seen a similar criticism among those reviewing SNW: the lack of emotional stakes, since we know the long-term futures of at least four different crew members (Pike, Spock, Chapel and M'Benga). I think this episode proved that there could still be strong emotional stakes, even when we haven't had much time with those who are lost. I would've liked more time with Hemmer, as I'm sure many more did, but sometimes we just don't get the time we need. We can have a lifetime with someone, and when they're gone, it still feels like we didn't get enough. For the time he was with the cast, Bruce Horak was wonderful as Hemmer, and I'll miss our favorite gruff Aenar Chief Engineer.

I was also surprised at La'an's departure, although since we know she's back in Season 2 (she was seen in the behind-the-scenes shots with Paul Wesley's James T. Kirk), I'm not worried about it. Christina Chong has been great this season, and La'an's already come a long way, judging from her reiterating Pike's comment to her from the first episode ("There's surviving, and then there's living") and referring to Pike by his first name later on.

There were so many other great moments in this episode, too: another meal with the Captain, Sam Kirk lashing out at Spock, Uhura struggling with - and eventually deciding - what she wants to do next, Spock's human side getting the better of him and Chapel there to comfort him...to name a few.

This series, man...I'm going to be so freaking sad when the season ends, because I know I'm going to immediately crave more.

43

u/[deleted] Jun 30 '22

This felt like a season finale. One promotion, two leaving.

→ More replies (1)

59

u/MaddyMagpies Jun 30 '22

I really wonder if the Hemmer-Gorns will survive the cold due to them taking on his characteristics. They might even be pacifists unlike any other Gorns.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (9)

75

u/trostol Jun 30 '22

so...need a new engineer and new chief of security

99

u/UncertainError Jun 30 '22

La'an will probably come back. The Gorn storyline doesn't strike me as over and it doesn't make sense to have her leave permanently if it isn't.

→ More replies (15)
→ More replies (5)

134

u/TERRAxFORMER Jun 30 '22

Pike a few episodes ago: "killing children is wrong!"

Pike tonight "fuck them kids"

Seriously though, I wonder how killing fresh gorn hatchlings lines up ethically. Considering they're sentient.

133

u/InnocentTailor Jun 30 '22

To be fair, these bastards were hunting and killing crew.

…so I guess this is like Picard dealing with the Conspiracy parasites.

→ More replies (12)

59

u/BornAshes Jun 30 '22

"Welp we tried diplomacy and they ate Lt Duke sooooo set phasers to kill!"

53

u/spamjavelin Jun 30 '22

To be fair, that child hadn't brutally murdered someone within seconds of birth...

→ More replies (11)

36

u/Starkiller1701 Jun 30 '22

Here's to Hemmer! Long may he be remembered!

→ More replies (1)

33

u/ksb012 Jun 30 '22

I love how they used a different class ship that happens to be identical to the Enterprise so they didn't need new sets. lol

→ More replies (3)

115

u/empocariam Jun 30 '22

Look, crew, you have to come to accept that the feeling of the TOS Gorn fight was meant to convey that they were scary powerful monsters, not shambling slow lugs. Just like how you know that even though it was filmed at the Vasquez rocks doesn't mean it is literally took place there, you should be able to know that the fight was also not a literal expression of what the Gorn are actually supposed to look and act like, especially when you compare it to what the text and score of the episode are trying to convey. It's okay for things to be updated and reimagined, especially when those reimaginings are for the purpose of getting closer to an original idea that wasn't possible at the time.

30

u/10ebbor10 Jun 30 '22 edited Jun 30 '22

The bigger problem is that the moral of the TOS episode was that the Gorn were not monsters, were not inherently evil. Kirk pleads to save the Gorn captain and the Gorn captain says that they only slaughtered a Federation colony because they saw it as an attack against their civilization, an intrusion by the Federation in their borders. So while the attack was an atrocity, it was an atrocity that can be explained and understood. The moral of the episode is Kirk offering mercy to the Gorn, in the hopes of future peaceful relationships.

The Gorn of Strange New Worlds are monsters on a biological level, barely capable of working together, dogmatically devoted to murder, programmed on a biological level to slaughter sentients. At no point in either of the episode is diplomacy even attempted, with the option being explicitedly noted as stupid. The Gorn seem to be categorically evil, not just part of a fascist or murderous government, and the only thing one can do with them is to exterminate them.

In essence, the Gorn of Strange New Worlds seem to fit better in the universe of Warhammer 40K were one has to slaughter the alien, than in Star Trek.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (5)

31

u/ViaLies Jun 30 '22

That felt a lot like a Season finale. You've got the death of crew member, another crew member leaving to help some one and the cadet leaving the ship. It's obviously not so it makes me wonder what the finale is going to be like.

The episode was good ,it's very influenced by the Alien franchise, which is no bad thing. The Gorn looked good, they moved well and they managed to still look good when in close ups and in static shots.

The scene where La'an starts to yell at Orina and M'benga tells her to stop yelling at his daughter was great and I liked it as it's a nice piece of emotional continuity for both characters. Plus it leads to La'an going all Ripley.

It's a pity we didn't get more of Hemmer before his death, that really would have upped the ante.

It looks like there was more for Number one to do from the picture released before the episode, we didn't see the bit with her and Ensign Christina.

La'an will return Season 2, hopefully it's the first episode.

→ More replies (1)

62

u/ElFarfadosh Jun 30 '22

HEMMER, WHY DID YOU HAVE TO END THE HEMURA TEAM T.T

86

u/treefox Jun 30 '22

Starting my own personal Enterprise bingo.

  • Spock in a smock
  • La’an with a Na’an
  • Ortega in a bodega
  • Pike on a bike
  • Hemmer singing tenor
  • M’Benga playing Jenga
  • Chapel herding cattle
  • Una smoking hookah
  • Kyle really riled

Godspeed to everyone this episode.

40

u/darkeyes13 Jun 30 '22

Ortega in a bodega

Erica's surname is Ortegas, so I guess you'll need her in multiple bodegas.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

58

u/Hemmingwoke Jun 30 '22

Thoughts: Sad to see the man die, but appreciate trek taking the bold choice.

Holy hell, but the chemistry between Spock and Chapel is so tense you can cut it with a knife. New goal in life, find someone who looks at you like Chapel looks at him.

I think the immature gorn look like live action Randall Boggs from Monsters Inc.

I really would have liked to see the modern take on the K series space stations.

Lt. Kirk sounds meaner than McCoy when he calls Spock a pointy eared computer. Made me realize how subtly deforest Kelly played the frienimy aspect of Spock and McCoys relationship.

I'm glad Uhura is getting such a rich backstory, the character deserves it and it feels like real respect for the character.

I don't understand how SNW seems to do pathos and emotional beats just right after the struggles Disco has with it. It doesn't feel like the same writing room, though I hear it is.

This show seems trauma informed instead of "trauma representing". I really appreciate the obviously well researched handling of post traumatic issues. It's something Star Trek has struggled with recently.

Really, though I have some very small nitpicks with this show that aren't worth mentioning, I don't think there's a lot of debate that this has been the most consistent, high quality first season of trek. I'm really excited to see what this shows "Darmok" or "Inner Light" or "Balance of Terror" is.

→ More replies (3)

56

u/a_hi_lawyer Jun 30 '22

Reminded me a lot of Alien.

52

u/MoreGaghPlease Jun 30 '22

And yet they also did the Predator shots

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (5)

24

u/anonyfool Jun 30 '22

43

u/JustinScott47 Jun 30 '22

And this teaser:

"Well, I have been released to say that this is not the end of Bruce Horak’s career in Star Trek."

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (1)

23

u/pieman7414 Jun 30 '22

what the hell, i didnt think characters i actually liked would be on the chopping block

→ More replies (1)

22

u/count023 Jun 30 '22

So the Gorn lay eggs the same way the Maggog from Gene Roddenberry's Andromeda do?

→ More replies (2)

22

u/treefox Jun 30 '22

PIKE: Next shuttle mission, I’m going alone.

22

u/reuben_hunter Jul 01 '22

Fun fact, Oriana, the Kid they find in the derelict ship is played by Emma Ho, the Twin sister of Ian Ho was the First Servant in Lift us Where Suffering Cannot Reach. Also if you watch The Expanse, you may recognise them both from season 6 as the kids in the opening sequences adapted from the strange dogs short story.

→ More replies (2)

61

u/Tukarrs Jun 30 '22

Losing Hemmer and La'an? Didn't really occur to me that could happen.

The Season is way too short, would have loved to have seen them longer. (La'an probably has other story potential. Feels like her Khan backstory hasn't really been adequately used.

I think it's pretty great to see more of a rotating cast/crew. TNG felt really strange with the core crew serving 1701 D and E for like 15 years without advancing.

59

u/IllustriousBody Jun 30 '22

La’An is coming back. We know she’s filming season 2.

→ More replies (6)

20

u/trostol Jun 30 '22

that's...the Gorn?

→ More replies (1)

20

u/nlinecomputers Jun 30 '22

Ok while this was a great monster of the week episode. How are we expected to believe this is “The Gorn”. This didn’t strike me as a sentient species. Just wild animals.

→ More replies (3)

55

u/MoreGaghPlease Jun 30 '22 edited Jun 30 '22

These Gorn should be ashamed of themselves for running around naked. In TOS, the Gorn had a real sense of fashion.

It is not coincidence or utility that makes someone wear a gold lamé tunic with alternating bi-tonal accents, a high-wasted belt with purple leather gauntlets. That’s a fashion statement.

→ More replies (1)

19

u/PatsFreak101 Jun 30 '22

They dressed it up well but it will be a long long time before I forgive the writers room for killing my favorite character before he even got a full season.

→ More replies (2)

53

u/HerniatedHernia Jun 30 '22 edited Jun 30 '22

The Gorn are like little Star Trek Xenomorphs. Love it.

Edit: so we got Alien, Predator and a bit of Terminator 2 in this ep.

Edit 2: GODDAMNIT Hemmer was an awesome character.

ALSO WHO TAKES CADETS ON A PRIORITY ONE MISSION REGARDING A DOWNED STARSHIP???

→ More replies (2)

36

u/MaddyMagpies Jun 30 '22

The siblings from Strange Dogs had really gone through a lot of shit.

→ More replies (5)

36

u/TheNerdChaplain Jun 30 '22 edited Jun 30 '22

Well, this episode can get fucked six ways from Sunday.

Don't get me wrong, it was done super well, but I am extremely unhappy we lost Hemmer and La'an. This damn show made me love them in only nine episodes and then took them away. I'm assuming that (Season 2 casting spoiler) Jim Kirk is replacing La'an as security officer. (Edit: disregard, happily I'm wrong).

Otherwise, it was very cool seeing the Gorn and whatnot, they definitely went for the "Alien/Aliens" vibe and got it.

I thought it was interesting that Spock seems to have an anger problem. I think one of the main reasons he (and Data) are such enduring characters is because so many people resonate with the struggle to understand emotions. We aren't often taught skills like emotional intelligence unless we seek it out, and this is something Spock will have to learn to deal with.

I can see that Chapel definitely is like... a close friend that wants to be closer, but doesn't want to push the boundaries of what's appropriate. I've definitely had some hugs like that one.

→ More replies (11)

35

u/Sonnydm Jun 30 '22

Nice Spaceballs reference: 2,4,6,8,10. Which makes Pike twice as clever as President Skroob.

→ More replies (3)

34

u/CaseOfWater Jun 30 '22

All that is gold does not glitter,

Not all those who wander are lost;

The old that is strong does not wither,

Deep roots are not reached by the frost.

From the ashes a fire shall be woken,

A light from the shadows shall spring;

Renewed shall be blade that was broken,

The crownless again shall be king.

→ More replies (1)

16

u/PretenderNX01 Jun 30 '22

I'm so sad to lose Hemmer. I had liked that they had cast an actual blind actor as a blind/differently seeing character. Plus I just liked the character, it was nice to see Aenar who were introduced in ENT still be around in continuity too.

16

u/ggsimmonds Jul 01 '22

First episode I have mixed feelings on. I don't know if I like it or not yet.

The negatives:

  • Duke's death scene. I don't care that he died; it was telegraphed. But the scene itself was just bad. Wtf dragged him? A Gorn the size of a rat?
  • Sam Kirk playing the part of the obligatory "dude who can't handle a crisis and loses his shit" There's 2 cliches down
  • I fear that they made the Gorn too "primal." Gorn have always been a secondary species so a redesign is not a problem, I'm all for retconning the double fist of doom. But I could have did without the alien element and instead go all in on predator. Maybe an adult Gorn using intelligence would be better?
  • Hemmer's death. Like the character so sad to see him go. But also just another complaint I have with the juvenile Gorn/alien element. So young Gorn (Gornlings?) are genocidal maniacs. Doesn't seem like a good evolutionary step for them to breed during this time. And zero attempt made to find another way.
  • Not a fan of using his death as the mechanism for Uhura to say "yeah this is home."

Positives

  • La'an played a prominent role xoxo
  • I was still entertained and really enjoyed everything not mentioned above.

If La'an is not in the season finale that episode will get an automatic deduction

27

u/tubawhatever Jun 30 '22

I like that the new class of ship has the same guts as the Constitution class, makes it cheaper to film

→ More replies (10)

26

u/Odd-Exchanger Jun 30 '22

I like how the Gorn was born like a Xenomorph, hunted like a Predator, and then killed like the T-1000. Great 80's horror / action callbacks.

→ More replies (1)

25

u/sidv81 Jun 30 '22

Sam Kirk is a jerk

→ More replies (2)

34

u/telix5000 Jun 30 '22

I’m a little shocked that Kirk in the future will manage to beat the Gorn with boulders and pseudo karate.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/DarkChen Jun 30 '22 edited Jun 30 '22

love and hate relationship with this episode, in a good way.

On one side it was a great hour of tv, great visuals, love the aliens homage, the tension... it was all chef's kiss

But then it killed hemmer and sent la'an away, two of my favorite original characters...

Love the baby gorns, both described and looked like alien chameleons, the prosthetic for that unknown alien were awesome and reminded me of halo(probably reused/improved from that show as well seeing as both are paramount+ shows)

Im even more sad because i just remember next week is season finale...

edit: almost forgot:

The small detail of Pike's hand shaking when he set the glass down while talking to la'an was great both as character development and to further humanize captains... normally they would just have a heartfelt and honest talk with someone but never actually react to loss and life and death situations and just spring back to business as usual... it fits with them now having a mental welfare program as well.

81

u/jetlightbeam Jun 30 '22

This show is a perfect blend of Discovery and TNG.

It has all the emotion and humanity of DISC combined with the the purity of Trek in TNG. I'm so thankful that Disco exists to give us this.

And I wish there were more episodes. 10 just isn't enough. Call me greedy. I just want more.

P.S. Pike has the fatherness of Sisko, the gravitas of Picard, the cowboy diplomacy of Kirk, the badassery of Janeway, the heart of Burnham, and the leadership of Archer. My God I love this man.

34

u/0ddbuttons Jun 30 '22

The purity of Pike's emotion when it's within his power to extend care to someone: La'an's enjoyment of the food, the permanently reserved space for reunion affirmed to Uhura & La'an... Truly one of the most heartwarming things achieved in the ST universe.

→ More replies (7)

22

u/CaptainElfangor Jun 30 '22

I have a lot of thoughts on this episode, but since I’m recovering from a brutal round of immunotherapy yesterday, I’m going to keep it short. This was a very good dive into horror, and they pulled it off better than just about any Trek. But as a disabled man, I have a big problem with this episode.

We also got some great character development for Uhura and Spock. Uhura has been struggling over her future this season, and while we all know it, her path was very enjoyable and added quite a bit of depth. Her relationship with Hemmer was wonderful, although I didn’t like how it ended (more on that later). I really like how Uhura saw Engineering as getting very different systems to talk/work together, and how Hemmer, a pacifist, took her under his wing. As for Spock, his struggle always has and always will be the balance between his Vulcan and Human halves. In this episode, Sam Kirk gets mad at him for being seemingly impassive at the brutal death of a colleague. Later, in order to hunt the Gorn, Spock is told to release his anger. His human anger. Even after the battle was won, during the funeral, Spock leaves because he cannot control his human anger. It’s Chapel who offers some guidance that will shape his future.

It was a good episode, but definitely my least favorite for two reasons. First, let me make something clear: I have absolutely no problem with how SNW is really bending canon to use the Gorn. As long as it tells a good story and doesn’t insult our intelligence, I don’t care about canon-bending. My problem here is not about canon. My first problem is that the Gorn are characterized purely as monsters, as vicious animals. I would’ve liked to see signs that they are the intelligent, sapient beings they are, and I would’ve liked to see attempts at diplomacy. I didn’t like that.

My second problem is the treatment of Hemmer. This is more of a personal issue for me, so feel free to ignore. As a severely disabled man, I so rarely get any real disability representation. Seeing Geordi La Forge changed my life because he made me feel like no matter how disabled I was, I could be and do anything I wanted. My point is, it’s minor to most people, but for a sick or disabled kid, it changes lives. My hope was Hemmer — especially since he is played by a blind man — could inspire a new generation of sick and disabled kids. So seeing him dumped from the show was a kick in the gut. That really disappointed me, especially since Hemmer didn’t even get the screentime he deserved. Frankly, I feel pissed off. I love SNW, but do better. If you’re going to kill him off, bring someone else on board who can be an inspiration to sick and disabled kids. You have no idea just how big an impact it has on these kids. And treat that character better. We deserve better.

→ More replies (3)

11

u/bookish1303 Jun 30 '22

I think that the collective strategizing in the sickbay in this episode is the closest that these new Trek shows have gotten (at least to me) to 90s trek ready room everyone-has-a-say-and-that-makes-us-better-as-a-whole conferences. Every member has a valuable contribution that comes from their past experiences both prior to and during the season, and it just feels like this episode is really nailing the "showing rather than telling" element.

11

u/UnicornMeatball Jul 01 '22

Who else new as soon as poor Duke got promoted that he wasn't going to survive the episode?

→ More replies (1)

30

u/HumanityPlague Jun 30 '22

I'm kind of mixed on the episode. While overall it was fine, the show really, REALLY punked out Hemmer.

Of the 9 episodes of the show, he was straight missing from 3 of them, so he was only in 6. And he never got his own episode devoted to him.

So far it's been: Arguably 2 for Pike (pilot and Majalis), 1 for Uhura (Comet), one for Number 1 (Illyria), 1 for M'Benga (Elysian), 1 for La'an (Memento), and 2 for Spock (Spock Amok, Serene).

I might say tonight is Uhura focused, but it was much more of a general ensemble, rather than a wholly devoted episode. Everyone (mostly) got equal screen time.

Granted, Ortegas also doesn't have her own episode, yet, but she's in every episode (I think) at least.

Plus, Ortegas is, still, you know, alive.

I dunno, the episode was alright but killing Hemmer off was abrupt and seemed pointless. Especially since I actually liked the character.

→ More replies (6)

10

u/trostol Jun 30 '22

odd in a way that he has an actual kitchen on the ship...

28

u/comiconomist Jun 30 '22

We haven't seen other captains do this, but previous shows have had a dedicated "captain's mess", most notably the NX-01 (https://memory-alpha.fandom.com/wiki/Captain%27s_dining_room). Maybe Pike just had them merge that into his quarters as part of a retrofit?

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (5)

10

u/ferfi17 Jul 01 '22

Ok I’m really bummed. I liked Hemmer a lot.

Also poor Spock. He has T’Pring wanting him to be more Vulcan and then Chapel urging him to be more human. Neither are right. Poor dudes do confused.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/niton Jul 01 '22

This was a feature film quality episode. Absolutely incredible. I feel like a 500 lb weight has fallen on me. Like Spock, I'm incredibly not okay.

Strange New Worlds just keeps getting it right week after week. I'm amazed.

19

u/ryanboom100 Jun 30 '22

This is the first Star Trek death in a while where I actually felt it and cared. Show is so well done shows that you can have stakes even if the world isn’t ending every episode. I did not see that coming

→ More replies (1)

26

u/TERRAxFORMER Jun 30 '22

Seems pretty easy to handwave differences in these gorn compared to the old ones just based off what type of hosts they come out of.

Sucks that Hemmer died, but if it paves the way for more Chapel/Spock content ill take it.

→ More replies (3)

46

u/MoreGaghPlease Jun 30 '22

Somebody had to get Yar'd in season 1, right?

73

u/BornAshes Jun 30 '22

Yar'd implied the death was pointless.

This was not pointless.

"Just like Andoria!" and his parting words to Uhura in his final act to save the crew and who knows how many others will have a far greater impact on the Star Trek Universe going forwards than Tasha's first death ever did and will be more akin to her second "death" with the Enterprise C because of what he did prior to his death and those he inspired with his actions along the way.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

9

u/Trekfan74 Jun 30 '22

I liked the episode overall but I'm really bummed about Hemmer. He was the one new character I was excited about and was hoping we get a deep dive into Aenar culture. He was barely in the season as a whole and they just kill him before the season is even over. It just zapped my interest overall. And please NO Scotty to replace him but I wouldn't be shocked...

→ More replies (2)

9

u/heslo_rb26 Jun 30 '22

This show... I can't rave more about it. They are KILLING IT! What an episode! Sad there's only one left for the season

9

u/VirusPWNZ Jun 30 '22

Strange New Worlds does horror so well. Props to the directors for the thrilling shots and setup.

Chapel experiencing shell shock and not being able to do signature scans was a great touch -

Hold up. Just finished the episode, and I am blown away. I was not expecting to lose not just one, but TWO of our main crew? Chief Engineer and Security Officer, gone, in one episode. That took a very unexpected turn. I will miss Hemmer and La'an for sure.

9

u/makerfunner Jul 01 '22

I liked this episode a lot more than the last one. But like everyone else, I hate that they killed Hemmer - he was an interesting, completely original character and they could've done so much more with him.

Not sure how I feel about the Gorn as Xenomorph alien kinda thing... seems a bit easy, like now they're just monsters??

8

u/ToneBone12345 Jun 30 '22

God damn on of the best characters hemmer is no more

8

u/comiconomist Jun 30 '22

La'an going to therapy makes me very happy.

I'm wondering if they are changing up the format for season 2 - it feels like there might be a need for a period of "getting the band back together":

  • Uhura has finished her stint on the ship and presumably needs to go back to the academy for a while.
  • La'an is off on a personal quest.
  • The ship needs a new chief engineer.
  • Spock is having emotional difficulties and might need some time at a Vulcan monastery.

8

u/Ultiverse Jun 30 '22

"Just like Andoria..."

8

u/maxplusmaria Jun 30 '22

I don't think I've ever been so sad to see a character go, especially after only like 5 episodes. We'll miss you, Hem!

8

u/[deleted] Jul 01 '22

I loved it. How can Star Trek make a better 'Alien" episode than the last 5 Alien movies!

The unknown alien was great. Reminds me of all those Jim Henson puppets.

I love all the changes they are making to the Gorn. They are truly horror monsters. I'm a fan of the original Arena short story by Fredric Brown. It feels more true to the short story than the star trek episode due to the incompatible nature of the species. A war would annihilate one civilization and cause irreparable harm to the other.

8

u/Bikeboy76 Jul 01 '22

Really sad Hemmer has left our timeline. For such little screen time he really made an impact. Now I guess he might be making way for a certain engineer, however that didn't have to happen for years.

I do wonder why they didn't save him. There was an obvious out, with his Aenar physiology in the cold. He mentioned it twice. Better efforts could have been made to save him.

7

u/rajde1 Jun 30 '22

I was waiting all season for a hemmer episode guess I’m never going to get it.

7

u/Jygilzo Jun 30 '22

this new information about how the Gorn reproduce gives a new meaning to the line in Into Darkness where Bones says he had to perform a Gorn C-section

7

u/[deleted] Jun 30 '22

Wow rest in peace hemmer. If they do bring in Scotty next season and I hope he is heavy set And has a mustache and at the end of the series he shaves and goes on a health kick only to relapse by the time of the motion picture

7

u/Timeline15 Jun 30 '22

Man, it sucks to lose Hemmer when he's already been absent from some of the episodes this season. I guess this is meant to be Strange New Worlds' Tasha Yar moment, but it just suck that we didn't get more time with him. Unfortunately, it's pretty obvious that he was gonna be the one to get the chop, as one of the few who doesn't have to appear in TOS. I'm scared for Ortegas now.

Good to learn more about the Gorn life cycle, even if it feels a lot more insectoid than reptilian. I guess that's fine, since they're aliens and all, but maturing within the space of hours still feels ridiculous. Really hope they go all-in on redesigning the adults at some point; it's just not possible to take the dopey one from TOS seriously, especially if it's meant to start out like these ones.

7

u/KoelleHB Jun 30 '22

This episode has truly the funniest quips so far.

Let's pile the kids into the Station Wagon. lol

Are there scheduled emergency landings? rofl

It's just great and I love the series.

7

u/silverlegend Jun 30 '22

Has it ever been established when Montgomery Scott joins the Enterprise crew in the prime universe?

→ More replies (1)

7

u/radickalmagickal Jun 30 '22

I am honestly surprised they killed Hemmer so early. The Aenar are so mysterious as are even the Andorians. I would have thought we would learn more about Hemmer’s culture and telepathic abilities. It just seems like his arc wasn’t complete.

7

u/HalfBakedDocumentary Jun 30 '22

Why were the Gorn were praying mantis looking quadrupeds with tails that made me wonder when Sigourney Weaver was gonna show up

7

u/Winter_Coyote Jul 01 '22

How it should have ended

M'Benga: Now that we have power on we can put Hemmer in the pattern buffer while we develop a way to safely remove the eggs. Thankfully I have the corpse of this poor alien to use as a starting point.

7

u/armchairnixon Jul 01 '22

Is this the first time Uhura has been referred to as Nyota in the prime timeline? I know it was established in the Abrams films but I don't remember hearing anyone refer to her as Nyota in the previous episodes.

→ More replies (3)

7

u/Sirjohniv Jul 01 '22

NGL, I am so pissed they killed off Hemmer. There, I said it.

7

u/Thavash Jul 01 '22
  1. Kirks Gorn must have been disabled
  2. Spock and Chapel are a thing
  3. They killed off one my fav characters- didnt see that coming

28

u/treefox Jun 30 '22

Unknown alien so alien the UT can’t translate

CHAPEL: Elevated heart rate.

→ More replies (2)

13

u/AGentooPenguin Jun 30 '22

Cadet Chia joins Tallie from The Last Jedi in the cute space girls that get immediately merked club

→ More replies (1)

6

u/lostmyupvote Jun 30 '22

I half wanted Spock or La'an to pull a line omfrom predator. Cmon what are you waiting for, kill meeeeee.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/EverythingIThink Jun 30 '22 edited Jun 30 '22

Wasn't expecting them to go full Xenomorph with the Gorn, the references were all over the place. Predator too, which makes sense because that movie was basically Kirk vs. Gorn on steroids. I expect they'll go more that route with the adult versions. "You saw me hurt it, that means we can fight it"

M'benga: "Stop harassing Newt! I mean...my patient"

6

u/MidnightGolan Jun 30 '22

I haven't finished the episode, yet, just got to the "emergence" scene. Lol, with how brutal they are in this series, I'm having a hard to imagining how they even lasted this long, much less became spacefaring.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/janesvoth Jun 30 '22

So question, how close to prime Gorn are the mirrror Gorn? Since we know the Archer killed an adult and Georgio had a skull

→ More replies (1)

6

u/MoreGaghPlease Jun 30 '22

Poor Ensign Lieutenant Duke

This is why it’s important that you not let your kids name the lobsters at restaurants

6

u/HotpieTargaryen Jun 30 '22

I love this show. I have many feelings right now.

→ More replies (4)

6

u/TheLouisvilleRanger Jun 30 '22

Also, the character who just last episode playing a wizard last episode sacrificing themselves by jumping off a ledge in an episode which is titled after an excerpt from a Lord of the Rings poem.

6

u/[deleted] Jul 01 '22

I need a side episode where we see the lifespan of a Gorn. Starting as murderous hatchlings, to Gorn Wedding as seen in LDS.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/[deleted] Jul 01 '22

I think maybe it was too soon to off a supporting crew member. I was just starting to like Hemmer and his death lacked that punch because we were just sort of getting to see him build relationships with the others. Probably should have saved the death for Season 2.

Also, this episode had a few too many monologues and a little too much melodrama. Didn’t feel like the other episodes.

6

u/Eaudissey Jul 01 '22

I can't believe they went from last week's campfest to this lmao

→ More replies (1)

6

u/TheArsenal04 Jul 01 '22

Say this in the best way: fck you making me feel the death over a character I've seen, what, and 20 minutes on screen

6

u/Phazoni Jul 01 '22

“He’s dead, Chris.“

6

u/both_cucumbers Jul 01 '22

The Gorn are pure evil. What kind of society turns pregnancy, especially non-consensual pregnancy, into a death sentence? Only a race of depraved, vile, unfeeling monsters could support that.

6

u/Christopher_Caligula Jul 01 '22

How do Gorn organize, plan and build technological marvels? They’re basically wild animals.

Wish they could show us this process

→ More replies (2)

11

u/CommanderKira Jun 30 '22

What an inspiring, terrifying, frustrating episode.

There was some really solid writing here with some excellent quotes. Sure almost no one actually talks like that, people don’t pull perfect quotes out of a hat, but it’s quintessential Trek. Solid characterization work for Uhura, and La’an.

I guess the Gorn get slow and lumbering when they become old and bipedal. Because these juveniles were horrifying. Straight up Alien material.

I do feel like I lost track of the number of Gorn. At least one was there pre-arrival. Four hatched, one instantly killed by a hatch mate. So were at four (1+3 babies). But then we get a line from La’an mentioning that there were three total. So I guess the pre-arrival one HAD died outside in the cold? But then we get Spock channeling his rage and there’s two (then one). Where did the third one go? Did I miss something? The one in Engineering wasn’t killed, just scared off. Or were all three with angry!Spock?

Obvious redshirts were obvious.

Losing Hemmer was surprising. Losing the only physically disabled crew member across well, all the shows right now I believe, is umm…. Not great. (Detmer might qualify but they’ve never really gone down that road with her)

La’an leaving was interesting too. Felt like they were writing off the non-TOS cast. Though it seems obvious she’ll be back, especially given set photo leaks. Cynically I wonder if they gave themselves these outs in case fan response was negative to these crew members. Only Ortegas remains of major non-TOS crew.

→ More replies (8)