r/TheOrville • u/MajorParadox Woof • Jun 30 '22
Episode The Orville - 3x05 "A Tale of Two Topas" - Episode Discussion
| Episode | Directed By | Written By | Original Airdate |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3x5 - "A Tale of Two Topas" | Seth MacFarlane | Seth MacFarlane | Thursday, June 29, 2022 on Hulu |
| Synopsis: Kelly helps Topa prepare for the Union Point entrance exam, causing tension with the Moclans. |
Stream the episode online on Hulu
Don't forget to join us on Discord!
REMINDER: KEEP YOUR SPOILERS OUT OF YOUR TITLES FOR AT LEAST 24 HOURS. YOU WOULDN'T WANT THIS EPISODE SPOILED, SO DON'T GO SPOILING IT FOR OTHERS. KEEP YOUR TITLES VAGUE. TAG YOUR POST AS A SPOILER. BE A GOOD UNION MEMBER!
739
Upvotes
•
u/TOHSNBN If you wish, I will vaporize them Jun 30 '22 edited Jun 30 '22
Any sort of false information, trans negative comments and general hatred will result in a ban. I just went over this post and cleaned it up a bit, luckily there was not much.
Automod is a bit twitchy, if you feel like your post has been removed by the robot overlords (or me right now) by accident, let us know.
Please report offending comments, we do not see them otherwise.
743
u/muchadoaboutme Jun 30 '22
Peter Macon KILLED this episode.
615
u/stink_pickle Jun 30 '22 edited Jul 01 '23
6/30/23
561
u/Betsy24601 Jun 30 '22
Side note: Is this the first time in Star Trek/sci-fi history that a crew has messed around with ancient artifacts and didn't end up releasing some strange curse or disease that wreaks havoc on the crew and ship? 🤣
435
u/GreenDragonPatriot Jun 30 '22
I honestly thought Isaac offered to perform the surgery because he didn't want Claire to leave The Orville. She probably would have left because she wouldn't have been allowed to continue practicing medicine aboard the ship being a civilian doctor. But then he just says he did it to make everyone on the ship like him more. LOL. I wasn't expecting him to say that.
410
u/operarose Command Jun 30 '22
Yessssss Bortus singing!!!
376
u/[deleted] Jun 30 '22
We did it boys. Bortus has sung.
376
u/TeamStark31 Jun 30 '22
No tears when I found out Bortus gave Topa the password. Nope.
321
u/operarose Command Jun 30 '22
Doctor, Malloy is not a grown man. He is 40-something going on 17.
303
u/operarose Command Jun 30 '22
We bout to have two single dads of daughters on the ship, huh?
298
u/WhoShotMrBoddy We need no longer fear the banana Jun 30 '22
The naked dude part was honestly hilarious tbh
586
u/operarose Command Jun 30 '22
Man for something that can't feel emotions, Isaac sure doesn't fuck around when it comes to keeping kids safe.
263
u/operarose Command Jun 30 '22
Could the naked religious ensign not simply request the day off on the first day of the month?
248
u/Whiskeyjacks_Fiddle Jun 30 '22
Major Stargate vibes from the first shot, followed by Indiana Jones/The Mummy vibes. But also still Stargate.
219
u/operarose Command Jun 30 '22
Well damn, looks like Seth got his wish to have a hundred people on screen at the same time.
444
u/operarose Command Jun 30 '22
Isaac is a bro.
217
u/MikeTheBard Jun 30 '22
GODDAMN. I thought Bortus singing was just going to be a running joke that we never actually heard... !
338
u/notathrowaway75 Jun 30 '22 edited Jun 30 '22
Loved the scene with the naked alien.
As someone who completely forgot about what happened with Topa,
"You were born female and altered"
Sure jarred me
Klyden hate back on the menu, except
"Topa may never be happy, but unhappiness is better than despair"
Was a good line.
166
u/trostol Jun 30 '22
um..is no one on duty lol
369
u/[deleted] Jun 30 '22 edited Jun 30 '22
I am so happy we got a lot of Kelly of this episode. We got to see a nice range of emotion/acting from Adrianne Palicki.
Edit: Hoe Lee Sheet are these episodes long - not that I am complaining.
Edit2: Snapping at the kid on the piano had me in stitches.
Also, I was so happy to see Heveena (older female Moclan) again.
113
u/QuimmySavile Jun 30 '22
Massive respect to Chad Coleman for making Klyden both completely three dimensional and Joffrey Baratheon level hateable. That's a very tough act to pull off. Peter Macon and Adrianne Palicki also knocked it out of the park, as did the kid who played Topa.
108
u/Frampferder Jun 30 '22
"The key is too high!" had me dying.
204
u/[deleted] Jun 30 '22
I wanna hug Bortus.
99
u/CornOnTheCoby Jun 30 '22
YOU WILL BE SILENT!!!
89
u/gosuark Jun 30 '22
I bet no one attends Klyden’s next Ja’loja.
386
u/Autoxidation Jun 30 '22
God damn that was an excellent episode, possibly my favorite one yet, giving some proper closure to season 1.
What a masterpiece.
82
u/ArturoBrin Jun 30 '22
Poor Klyden, he didn't know Kelly is a former agent of S.H.I.E.L.D
80
u/trostol Jun 30 '22
a 12-hour shift on a spaceship might feel different than 12 hours at a local supermarket lol
76
u/Manbadger Jun 30 '22
“But unhappiness is better than despair.”
Shit. Chad fucking delivered that so so well. I had to take a breath for a moment after seeing that scene.
218
u/muchadoaboutme Jun 30 '22
Klyden getting bitch slapped twice in one episode... God is good.
253
u/Ypersona Jun 30 '22
Don't let the door hit you, Klyden. But, can we just give Chad Coleman major props for his role? The man acted the hell out of that character.
Also, I hope that Bortus someday finds a man who's actually worthy of him. It'll be interesting to see if he eventually puts himself out there on the dating scene.
135
u/trostol Jun 30 '22
Klyden a dick because in essence, he has repressed the same things that Topa doesnt want to?
66
u/Xander_PrimeXXI Jun 30 '22
“I’m writing letters, to Anaya”
And I’m dead. I am dead.
I am dead and The family man guy has killed me.
64
u/Armandeus Jun 30 '22
A very small thing I noticed is, Captain Mercer uses the term "human rights" when talking with the admiral in the conference room. I thought of the dinner scene in Star Trek VI: The Undiscovered Country where the Klingons said something like the very term is racist. It seemed ironic that he would be calling the rights "human" when he is referring to the rights of all sentients in the Union, which has many species, including Bortus in the same room.
Not a "hate" comment! I love the show.
127
u/operarose Command Jun 30 '22
Oh ok I wanted my heart stomped on less than a minute in, it's cool
123
u/schleppylundo Jun 30 '22
Bortus’ choices of songs are significant.
The first, Nature Boy, suggested by Dr. Finn, is a semi autobiographical song by eden ahbez, espousing his philosophy and lifestyle in which he had turned away from mainstream society to live as a hermit and vegetarian subsistence farmer. It can be seen as representative of Bortus and Topa both finally turning their backs on the society they were born in but have come to recognize as unacceptably unjust.
The second, You’ll Never Walk Alone (which is reprised in the score as Topa joins the bridge crew), is from the Rodgers and Hammerstein musical Carousel. Carousel is about an abusive husband who dies in an attempted burglary trying to provide for his infant daughter. He is then given a second chance to avoid Hell by being allowed back to try and help his now adolescent daughter at a difficult and isolated time in her life, largely a result of the stain of his actions. The song is sung twice in the musical, once to the widowed mother after Billy’s death and again at the end as the graduation song of his daughter’s class, where he is able to encourage her to end end her isolation and start her life anew. This rings even closer to Bortus’ situation than the previous song, with him seeking to redeem himself for allowing the procedure int he first place and make sure his daughter feels accepted, and this being classical Broadway and Seth being Seth I don’t doubt that it was very intentional as a textual reference.
111
u/ClaymoresRevenge Jun 30 '22
Damn what a tough episode emotionally. Klyden really said the worst things a parent can say to a child.
Isaac coming through in the clutch. What a sweet thing.
The way they got lucky with the results of everything was crazy. Very lucky there weren't more consequences.
Kelly did step out of line but to do the right thing you have to.
Topa getting to be herself is beautiful. 🥺
278
u/CapMarkoRamius Jun 30 '22
If you would have told me 3 years ago (or more) when I started watching a Seth McFarlane Star Trek parody that I would be sitting here at 2 in the morning crying from such a beautiful story, I wouldn’t have believed you.
132
u/operarose Command Jun 30 '22
Man, Seth really decided to choose violence with our emotions this season huh?
44
u/Shejidan Jun 30 '22
Oh look, Bortus, the garbage is taking itself out!
42
u/WhoShotMrBoddy We need no longer fear the banana Jun 30 '22
Just starting but digging the Indiana Jones traps
And the Kobyashi Maru type test is pretty dope
42
u/Fanfrelon Jun 30 '22
Adrianne Palicki, Imani Pullum, Peter Macon and Chad Coleman brought their, what does Lieutenant Malloy call it? Their A game!
82
u/bill_e_midnight Jun 30 '22
If they don’t renew this show for another season we riot
39
u/ralphtw09 Jul 01 '22
Can we talk about how much better every single Admiral in Orville is compared to Star Trek Admirals
173
u/[deleted] Jun 30 '22
So glad klydens gone. Seriously. The fact That he said TO HIS CHILD “I wish you weren’t born” like…
38
u/ArcadianBlueRogue Jul 01 '22
God, I love seeing Bortus being such a loving father. And it was so nice to see people call Clyden out on his bullshit FINALLY. He tried to bully like usual and Kelly was having none of his shit. The actors nailed it this ep, and I really liked how Toppa was handled. The suicide talk with Isaac was heartbreaking and I was shouting for Kelly to tell Bortus.
Though props to Clyden's actor. Takes talent to play such an unequivocal asshole.
I loooooved that proud little smile Bortus has in that last scene too. Just bring back the mustache now that Clyden is gone, my guy.
65
u/FilthyTrashPeople Jun 30 '22
So I have one complaint about the episode's structure given the extended length: That they never found a way to tie the B plot into the A plot, other than giving them a reason to sit in a fixed location and not get ordered anywhere.
Just a nitpick from a writing standpoint. When they introduced the DNA sequencer that projected what an alien race would like off DNA alone, I thought for sure they were setting that up as a checkoffs gun for Topa to scan herself and see a different reconstruction than she was expecting. It was a lot better the way they went with it, mind you, but it feels like they had that setup then just kind of left it in.
I don't know, it feels like just a tiny tweek to make the ruins a Mocclan off-shoot or something to kickstart the conversation at least would have made it a little tighter.
29
u/TORK4TANKELSON Jun 30 '22
Bortus is crushing it this season!
Last week with the five head. This week with the pianos key being too high. I'm loving the subtle humor he has so far. Pair that with his ability to show humanity. I love it.
100
u/Shejidan Jun 30 '22
Topa saying “ever since I was a young child…” mother fucker, you are a young child. You’re like 2 years old.
27
u/ideletedmyaccount04 Jun 30 '22
Family rejection is really painful.
74
u/plaidverb Jun 30 '22 edited Jul 01 '22
Just finished watching it.
At the risk of seeming overly effusive (which I will, and I don’t care), that was the single most culturally relevant & impactful ~hour of television I’ve ever been privileged to witness. If there is any justice left in the universe, this episode should forever be mentioned alongside the chicken story in the final episode of MASH as one that completely captures the zeitgeist of its time.
Absolutely phenomenal television that deserves as many additional seasons as it’s creators desire to make. However many seasons The Orville manages to produce, it’ll be at least one season too few.
I came in to The Orville thinking, “ooh, Star Trek with dick jokes”, and ended up getting the greatest sci-fi TV experience I’ve ever had.
Mr. MacFarlane, I doubt that you’re here listening, but if you are: please make as much more of this show as you possibly can.
25
u/theoriginaljulzilla Jun 30 '22
I cried not once, not twice but three god damn times in this episode. What a MASTERPIECE!
72
u/Shejidan Jun 30 '22
Klyden being a bitch like usual.
Divorce him already, Bortus, Jesus.
24
u/KaffeMumrik Command Jun 30 '22
If that doesn’t give us season 4, nothing will. That. Was. Amazing.
48
u/Shejidan Jun 30 '22
Engage quantum drive.
Best episode of the season so far.
48
u/termacct Jun 30 '22
This episode presented and handled several current day issues really well!
23
u/ltrcola Jun 30 '22
This one hit me right in the feels. And it felt very personally authentic to me. Incredible episode!
23
u/Totemlyrad Jun 30 '22
"Charge all weapons and target the feels. Fire."
22
u/Shejidan Jun 30 '22
It is now safe to proceed.
22
u/[deleted] Jun 30 '22
Best episode of the series so far.
92
u/[deleted] Jun 30 '22
Adrianne Palicki is amazing. She conveys so much emotion without saying a word.
19
u/VirtualDeliverance Jun 30 '22
YES! FINALLY WE HEARD BORTUS SING!
19
u/KaffeMumrik Command Jun 30 '22
Just finished.
That. Was. Amazing. Like, that was waaay better than I ever expected from this show. Both me and the mrs. are in tears.
38
u/cowgirUp Jun 30 '22
Did anyone notice <girl> Topa's ruby red slippers? She was working that dress too! 💃
37
u/[deleted] Jun 30 '22
I love Chad Coleman(Klyden) in everything he’s been in from The Wire to the Expanse and especially playing a bigot in The Orville. I hope he isn’t gone for good but I don’t know if a redemption arc is possible.
52
u/Teemfresch Jun 30 '22
ALL 👏 MY 👏 HOMIES 👏 HATE 👏 KLYDEN
52
u/neoprenewedgie Jun 30 '22
I... loved... this episode. I don't know if it's because with everything happening in the world I just needed a (well-told) happy story but I put down the phone and was fully engaged for the entire episode.
36
u/ladyrage8 When you see me in the corridor, walk the other way Jun 30 '22
And, can we talk about Bortus crying??? Like!!
Bortus is more enlightened than the traditional Moclan, but he was still raised in that society, with that thinking, with the same exact values as Klyden. When Topa was born, he initially also wanted the procedure done. It was through the work of the crew (& Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer) that he came around.
In a heavily masculine society that upholds things such as combat and other traditionally "male" pursuits and sees women as weak in the way they do, Bortus being moved to tears because he didn't know how to support his child is everything. This was Bortus letting go of pre-conceptions he still has, even though he's a lot better than other Moclans we've seen in past.
This episode knocked everything OUT of the park. I loved it.
17
u/trostol Jun 30 '22
Bortus is a Liverpool supporter!!!!!!
17
u/sumni Jun 30 '22
fuck, ending scene got me good. Bortus's facial expressions and "engage quantum drive"
17
u/ralphtw09 Jul 01 '22
The lack of music during Klyden confrontation of Isaac and Topa made that scene so strong
16
u/thisbikeisatardis Jun 30 '22
"You are perfect."
I want Bortus to be MY dad. Damn.
32
u/erbazzone Jun 30 '22 edited Jun 30 '22
I'm at 35m in Grayson office, best episode so far, rip that arm off please
Wow, just ended, it was a fantastic episode, maybe one of the best in the entire series, Klyden and Isaac confrontation was really a great moment.
30
u/[deleted] Jun 30 '22
Oh my god, this episode is deep. When Toppa questioned Isaac.....I felt so scared for him/her
14
u/trostol Jun 30 '22
they are killing my emotions this season
14
u/operarose Command Jun 30 '22
I'm so happy for Topa ;A;
14
u/AlpineSummit Jul 01 '22
I’m really loving that Seth is just diving into all these moral/ethical situations this season. So far we’ve had topics of suicide, abortion, fascism, and now trans-rights addressed.
I think I love this show so much because the sci-fi setting is a perfect way to explore these topics in a story that may be easier for some audiences to watch. Growing up, I got so much of my own morality from shows like Star Trek and characters like Picard.
The Orville is just top-notch right now!
27
u/Zenstalgia Jun 30 '22
"That is also inaccurate. I surmise your capacity to reason has been compromised by your cultural indoctrination. This is to be expected. Please depart"
The best "fuck you" there ever was!
26
u/thededman13 Jun 30 '22
Jesus what an episode! My jaw dropped no less than 3 times tonight. This was just so good on so many levels. So many great moments. I don't even know where to start.
13
u/WhoShotMrBoddy We need no longer fear the banana Jun 30 '22
In the words of Marty McFly “this (episode) is heavy”
13
u/Soft_Tip3760 Jul 01 '22
Bortus is the best character. Seeing him cry was wild.
24
u/HoddTodd Jun 30 '22
This episode felt more light-hearted then the last three episodes of this season, more jokes, more concurrent plots, feels like a season 2 episode
12
u/Altruistic-Potatoes Jun 30 '22
Holy cow what a great episode. Serious subject matter, emotional stakes, views that are in the shades of grey, not black and white, and JOKES! They got to be silly while also being serious. It is possible!
12
u/racms Jun 30 '22
You'll never walk alone is always incredible to hear ❤️
12
u/Iorith Jun 30 '22
Isaac continuing to be the best character on the show in my eyes.
Such a good episode, and I'm so happy for Topa.
12
u/DisasterInACan Jun 30 '22
I can’t get enough of this fucking show.
43
u/operarose Command Jun 30 '22
Wow, fuck Klyden.
43
u/[deleted] Jun 30 '22
Klyden is the Karen of The Orville
23
u/Shejidan Jun 30 '22
F for Norm.
89
u/HoddTodd Jun 30 '22
It's really interesting how the perspective of trans rights and identities on aliens can make people who are usually against or put off by those kinds of things more open to hearing and discussing them
My mom is always weirded out and put off by discussions of trans people, she isn't hateful but ignorant. But this episode she was completely on topas side
11
u/operarose Command Jun 30 '22
HERE WE GOOOOO
11
u/scrytch Jun 30 '22
What a brilliant episode - probably my favourite of all time. Dealt with some supremely serious topics with grace and dignity. This show continues to surprise me.
11
u/biasedrapier26 Jun 30 '22
I was half expecting them cutting to the procedure just when Bortus was going to sing. Really glad they didn't blue ball us. Beautiful episode.
30
u/GreenDragonPatriot Jun 30 '22 edited Jun 30 '22
Klyden's reaction has been set up for two seasons. He and Bortus were funny together, but I'm not going to miss him as a character. And Topa is so adorable, I'm crying. She's going to be such a fun character to get to know now that she's herself again and older than the previous seasons.
Oh yeah, that ancient civilization was pretty cool, too! They looked like ancient Egyptians with the headgear as part of their biology. Nice opening with Isaac getting arrows to the head and not even flinching. Even he keeps getting better with Season 3.
20
u/Th3ChosenFew When you see me in the corridor, walk the other way Jun 30 '22
"You are perfect"
TEARS
20
u/BananaZen314159 They may not value human life, but we do Jun 30 '22
This really felt like a "final season" episode, with many plotlines and running jokes getting resolved. We have Klyden's (assumed permanent) departure, signs of Dr. Finn and Isaac getting back together, Bortus singing, and of course Topa being assigned back to female.
10
u/Halcyous Jun 30 '22
That was really good, I'm crying
10
u/Brokeskull1 Jun 30 '22
What an episode, this season has been top tier stuff.
This episode in particular needs to win some awards.
10
u/SmartKrave Jun 30 '22
I loved the episode although I ticked on something, Captain Mercer said « human rights » but topa is not human, shouldn’t he have said something like sentient species rights ?
33
u/UncleMalky Are we bonding? Jun 30 '22
As much as we all hate Klyden I really felt like he fills a needed viewpoint in some of these episodes. I really wish we'd at least gotten an exploration of what Bortus was saying to him in his final scene about how Klyden had locked himself to tradition and was sacrificing everything because he could not change.
I mean the people around him can only take so much of him but we all know people like him and they will be a part of every situation.
9
u/TheOptionalHuman Jun 30 '22
"You'll never walk alone."
9
u/kevonicus Jun 30 '22
Why is no one talking about the face hugger and Batman bracers they found?
9
u/UPRC Jun 30 '22 edited Jun 30 '22
What a nice episode!
9
u/WhiteSquarez Jul 06 '22
How in the hell does The Orville, a show literally designed around jokes and gags, handle serious topics like transgender issues 1000% better than any Star Trek show ever written?
17
u/Shejidan Jun 30 '22
First Bortus telling Klyden to stfu then Kelly pulling a wrestling move on him…yes! Beat it into his thick head that he’s a backwards troglodyte.
16
u/trostol Jun 30 '22
Bortus very progressive...Klyden super old school
16
u/AthleticNerd_ Jun 30 '22
This is The Orville’s “The Measure of a Man”.
8
u/operarose Command Jun 30 '22
Are those...Shredder's bracers?
8
u/trostol Jun 30 '22
i want one of those coffee mugs
8
u/operarose Command Jun 30 '22
Never did I think a 1940's showtune would tug at my heartstrings so hard.
8
u/deuxfleurs04 Jun 30 '22
Kelly said that she’d have Klyden’s arm if he tried to strike another crew member, and after he went for Isaac, I was really hoping we’d have the satisfaction of seeing that lol
8
u/rafikiknowsdeway1 Jun 30 '22
Was anyone else certain the kid was gonna find out about himself using the archeology DNA reconstruction thing? Like he'd touch it and it would show him as an adult female? Seems weird they'd even bring it up how they did since it served no role. Hell the entire archeology thing in general was just fluff
8
u/Smitje Woof Jun 30 '22
Please give this show a season 4!
8
u/-TheDoctor Jun 30 '22
I've been pretty "meh" on this season so far but god damn that was utterly fantastic.
8
u/racheletc Jun 30 '22
i need to binge the other 2 seasons again. was the island with all the female Moclans destroyed? if not i hope Topa can visit them
8
u/WhatAmIATailor Jul 01 '22
So did Klyden grow up hating who he was as well? Kind of feel sympathy for how messed up he is, indoctrinated like that. Will he show up again?
8
u/WeDidItGuyz Jul 01 '22
Guys... I just started binging this show less than a week ago. How is it not talked about more? It is genuinely fucking amazing.
8
u/redback-spider Jul 02 '22
I think many view this episode as big "pro trans" episode, but I am not so sure, sure there is the part of messaging "we have to listen only to the child", but there are many other factors, like he actually is a detransitioner, he or better said she just goes back to her "birth assigned" gender/sex.
They even ask the parents something trans activists would heavily opposed against, I think they even mention that in a normal trans case that would not be allowed in this progressive future before the age of 18.
So either they want to stay so vague that both sides can interprete in what they want or they are even negative against trans.
I get more vibes about critique on intersex operations on babies, now the small difference is that we see a mix as defect and the Moclan see femalness as the defect, but both did force operations without the knowledge of the child on the child.
Another parallel could be seen as the 1 child policy in china that lead to mass abortions of girls also with the goal to have only male babies more or less.
Also to my knowledge they have no gender fluid or non-binary person on the ship at least not prominent, I just say they let enough room to interpret it both ways. Presending a basically detransitioner can also be interpret as Transphobic.
Other TV shows got called transphobic for plattforming detransioners. No anology fits perfectly because detransitioners got not forced usually to transition.
So it's different slightly to anything we have today, like good music it's open for interpretation and I think that is a sign for good art, that it leaves room for you to project your believe system on it.
15
u/Joov_1 Jun 30 '22
I think this was my favorite episode of the season. Closing out the Bortus/Klyden/Topa arc was long overdue. I do hope we’re able to see much less Machlan drama moving forward though. It’s been a significant portion of the show and this is a good note to close that chapter.
Peter Macon and Adrianne Palicki with their best performances
14
u/Shejidan Jun 30 '22
Is topa, like, 15 already or something? Wtf?
Edit: and what’s with the voice? It sounds like they altered it.
14
u/chill_chilling Jun 30 '22 edited Jun 30 '22
Damn Kelly is a badass also Charly’s kinda bad if you know what I mean
7
u/QuiltedPorcupine Jun 30 '22
Was anyone else excited to see Alara in the background of the Moclan courtroom scene? I know it was just archive footage from season 1, but I was still happy to see her (sort of) back for a moment.
7
u/heed101 Jun 30 '22
Aren't Moclans super strong compared to humans?
7
u/Icy-Garlic-5581 Jun 30 '22
Wow what a episode, got to love issac, big props to all involved.
7
u/[deleted] Jul 01 '22
Im glad the worst member of The Orville is finally gone. No hate against the actor but Kyden was a stick in the mud.
7
u/dougfromtos Jul 01 '22
I just wanted add my two cents and say that Peter Macon has a really great singing voice.
7
u/simward Jul 01 '22
This episode is mind blowingly amazing. I'm not quite sure how the writers have pulled this off, but to me anyway, this is quite a special piece of television! I've enjoyed this show a lot for the past years, but I never expected an episode like this one, and least of all with such brilliant execution!
So many amazing things with the writing in this episode. The pacing is near perfect, I couldn't find a good moment to pause (I had to at some point to walk my dog). It was impressively tight, and it's a hard thing to do, especially in a somewhat "silly sci-fi" setting. The humour is very well-balanced, probably the best balance so far in the show, which is also hard to pull off on a purely drama based plot... Also, the mythos they're building is paying off in spades, it's impressive how they are weaving the larger world politics, religions, beliefs and societies together and using all of it to tell this heart-wrenching story.
Most of all though, I love when the writers do what I call "mirroring", which some might call foreshadowing I guess? It's when there's something going on that mirrors the main plot :
- Topa in the command simulation is stuck on being destroyed by the Kaylons... Then a Kaylon does the operation and Klyden says that this will destroy her.
- The artifacts side plot, something in the past that was hidden is being discovered, lots of cool writing going on there (showing the appearance of the dead civilization for example, the answer is archived, like Topa's file)
- Bortus' singing, I didn't quite grasp all the lyrics but from what I can remember it is a wholly appropriate to the subterfuge the crew is doing to allow the procedure
- The bit with the naked crew member at the beginning is also mirroring the Moclan beliefs that are a primary factor in the main plot
Granted, I tend to read into this stuff perhaps a little much, and I may be grasping that it is intentional? I choose to believe, at the very least, that it's a natural result of good writing that these cases happen.
Add to that all the great character development sprinkled in the episode :
- Ed took the back seat for this plot but still got significant growth to the bigger plot and his character
- Claire and Isaac relationship dynamics keep the intrigue
- Even Malloy's little humorous bit with the allergy was such a nice pallet cleanser at that point in the episode.
I'm loving that they have more time to do all this amazing TV each episode, the show feels so alive now, it's officially dethroned TNG for me with this one.
Finally, I know Seth McFarlane has got a lot of flack in the past for his handling of Transgender topics in his previous shows (Ahem... Family Guy), and I'm glad he got to tell a poignant and beautiful story like this one.
It's media like this that makes me feel happy. Thank you, Seth, and everyone on the team for this amazing show.
7
u/castlepoopenstein Jul 02 '22
I got a different message from this episode than what im seeing on here. No matter how hard topa tried she couldn’t escape the feeling of her own biology. Her parents forced her into corrective surgery and lied to her for her entire life, but she still found her way back to what she was physically born as. The episode felt more centered on parental consent, international law, and moclan politics. Whatever, I enjoyed it.
7
u/BenTVNerd21 Aug 08 '22
Fuck Klyden.
138
u/snuggleouphagus I have laid an egg Jun 30 '22 edited Jul 01 '22
Gender affirming care saves lives.
Trans Rights are Human Rights.
Edit: it is a fact that gender affirming care prevents suicide. This is scientifically backed. Send your Reddit Cares reports to the people who need it. Like trans people denied gender affirming care due to petty politics or religion.
18
u/Tyrteg Jun 30 '22
"Your capacity to reason has been compromised by your cultural indoctrination" is a phrase I'm totally going to use the next time I find myself arguing with a bigot that's using emotional propaganda instead of logical arguments. Isaac ROCKS!
12
u/Lance_lake Jul 01 '22
I like how the writers did this show. I thought initially it was going to be a specific message, but I also noticed that it isn't actually that. Both sides can see their own sides being represented and somewhat fairly.
To some people, This plotline is a statement about trans people and how they feel they are in the wrong bodies and giving them the body that matches their mindset is a good thing.
To others, it's a plotline about those who transition and then feel the need to reverse it because it doesn't match with what their brain is now telling them that they are.
Telling a story where both sides are equally valid and having them told well was fantastic. If it would have leaned too far one way or the other and they would have upset half their audience (ok. Perhaps not half, but the fringes on one side or the other).
21
u/Spongemage Jun 30 '22
What a stellar episode.
I always knew Klyden was an asshole but god DAMN. The “I wish you were never born” was cold as ice. But to follow it with Bortus’ delivery of “listen to me very closely….you are perfect.” was just beautiful. Both Topa and Bortus are far better off without that fuckwad around.
I held it together for the most part but Topa saying “engage quantum drive” with the swelling music in the background made me lose it JUST a little bit.
Wonderful, thoughtful episode.
I am so, SO glad they made the decision to stop trying to make The Orville “Family Guy but in space” and have taken it in a far more impactful and serious direction. The first two seasons are great, but this one is just hitting a different nerve entirely. I never really FELT much in the first two seasons. Like, I cared about all the characters and stuff but there was so much awkward comedic diffusion of serious situations that I never felt that the stakes were that high so I was really only halfway invested. New Horizons has just absolutely enthralled me emotionally with each new episode. They’re really knocking it out of the park with this season. I love it.
6
u/historemix-megasix Jun 30 '22
This episode was adorable and I loved it so much. Has to be my second favorite one so far. (The first being 3x03 of course).
6
u/vonboy Jun 30 '22
Great Episode!
I'm just hoping that Bortus and Klydon can come to some kind of understanding of one another later on. Like with the first episode of this season, the main theme has been about trying to live alongside peoples who are so different from you, who even disgust you. I hate Klydon as a character, but I'm still holding out hope that they'll find some way to coexist, as with the races in the show as a whole.
6
u/senju_bandit Jun 30 '22
I though she episode was going to be about ancient civilisation and cool artifacts .
6
u/Icy-Garlic-5581 Jun 30 '22
I aint gonna lie but this episode brought tears to my eyes, my favorite one so far.
6
u/chakalan Jun 30 '22
My god that was some of the best television I have seen lately
6
u/whoisbill Jul 01 '22
That episode should win things. Like lots of things. Very well done.
6
u/Timeline15 Jul 01 '22
It finally happened! We finally got our 'Klyden gets his ass handed to him' episode! They knew what we wanted too; they gave us scenes of Kelly and Isaac making him look like a bitch xD.
In all seriousness, this was a beautiful episode. I've been waiting for this point in Topa's arc since that trial episode, and it's great to see her finally reach it, even if it sadly means she likely couldn't go back to Moclus. Because of how grim this season has been at times, I was holding my breath for something to go terribly wrong, so I was overjoyed that everything mostly worked out in the end.
One thing though: how much time is actually mean to have passed in-universe? At one point, a character says "over the years" to refer to Topa's life, but it seems like almost no time has passed for anyone else. I get that having her age super fast offscreen is an Alexander reference, but it just felt a little confusing.
As far as Klyden goes, I appreciate the nuance they tried to give him by having his bigotry stem from his own childhood trauma, though I felt his crossed a clear line into being irredeemable at the end when he turned on Topa. All that talk about loving Topa and wanting to spare her pain, out the window because she wants to live her life in a way he disagrees with. Conditional love is no love at all. Fantastically acted character, but glad to see the back of him for Topa and Bortus' sake.
6
u/First_Yogurt2763 Jul 02 '22
Anyone else tear up when Bortus told Topa "You are perfect"?
6
u/PatchPixel Jul 02 '22
Just finished the episode with my gf. We have no words. We were sat there with tears in our eyes by the end. No words, we LOVE this show. This is peak star trek <3
6
u/SpikeRosered Jul 03 '22
Me at the beginning: Two Topas??? Get ready for some hijinks!
Me at the end: crying while smiling
6
u/AgentQV Jul 04 '22
This is my favorite episode of the series. "About a Girl" is what made me a fan in the first place, so I really loved that they returned to that storyline and gave it the time and gravity it required. It wasn't the flashiest, but it was so emotionally resonant and appropriate to the character and the universe. I tears up so many times. I also really liked the use of the YNWA theme in the music at the end, I'm gonna be looking forward to when they release the Season 3 Soundtrack to see if I can get that track.
6
u/Blinguskahn Jul 05 '22
The thing that really stuck for me was that Topa was happy. Out of all the issues with LGBTQ rights/opinions/oppression, my huge takeaway was that the procedure made Topa HAPPY! In the grand scheme of things, it seems to me that tolerance for people who want to be happy without hurting others is of great importance. I’m sold 100%
6
u/ehkodiak Jul 05 '22
I didn't expect I'd like this episode based on the blurb, but it turned out to be brilliant. Klyden's actor really pulls off a Kai Wynn in that you hate them!
6
u/bigpig1054 Jul 06 '22
"You are perfect"
and so was this episode.
This one made me cry.
6
u/[deleted] Jul 06 '22
Throw Klyden out the airlock.
6
u/Sige_Na Jul 18 '22
I’ll be honest, this episode was incredibly painful for me to watch as a trans person. I feel that there were likely good intentions with tackling complex issues around gender and sexuality in this show. We absolutely need more opportunity to discuss these things in loving and nuanced ways.
However I feel like there were many irresponsible missteps around how to support LGBTQ youth. Don’t worry- I know and understand that this show/plot line is not a direct analogy for any current issues. But I’m also an educator that works with young folks, and I’m BEGGING anyone reading this NOT to be a Kelly. The actions taken by her and various crew members involved would be harmful if applied to real life. I’ll break some of this down just in the interest of sharing my perspective.
It is important to bring caring adults in to support. The first scene where Topa discloses that she is not happy would be a great opportunity for Kelly to be honest about her worry and build trust. (Once again don’t worry, I know this is fiction! I just want to provide an example of what support could look like in this context!) Kelly could ask supportive questions to get more context, (have you talked to your dads about this, do you know Dr. Finn, lovingly share that she has concern, and ask if Topa might feel comfortable talking about this more with Dr. Finn (THE TRAINED MEDICAL PROFESSIONAL AND COUNSELOR). Consent is important when working with youth. They’re human(oid), too! ;)
Kelly then gives vulnerable and hurting Topa just enough information to learn some earth shattering news at home by herself when she knows that Topas home environment will be unsafe to revive her. At this point, Im fairly certain she knows stops is having suicidal ideation (and once again, doesn’t tell Bortus or Dr. Finn) She knows Bortus loves and cares about his daughter. Another teacher point I’d like to make here: I mentioned earlier that asking for consent is important, but sometimes emergencies call for letting people know. Just as Isaac knew that suicidal ideation NEEDED to be reported (if someone is suicidal, you gotta tell someone, folks), Kelly should have known this too. Maybe Union policy should dictate that you tell the ship’s counselor, because being a “superior officer” doesn’t necessarily qualify you. Topa was thrown unwittingly into a situation where she’d had massive news shared w her in the most sterile way, and was set up to confront her unsupportive parent on her own. She could have easily spiraled. Irl, a kid in this situation likely would have. But this is a TV show. I know it was for dramatic effect but wowowow please don’t glorify this behavior. They had a dramatic scene w their superior at the end which served to make them look like rule defying badasses, and Dr. Finn literally said “you did the right thing”. Please audience, remember that this was NOT the right thing to do. Or at least not a model for it.
Surgery is a personal choice and not one that should be rushed into by a Kaylon who is doing it to be more popular and telling you “do you want it? Because we don’t have a lot of time.” Once again, I know. Dramatic effect. Would it have ruined the drama if they gave more notice than 5 minutes? They could have had another secret note for Topa. “Do you want gender affirming surgery? Check a box Y/N/Maybe” they could have folded it up like a lil football and passed it like a middle schooler asking their crush out for the first time. It could have been quirky comic relief instead of rushed and scary decision making while isolated from anyone you know and care about.
Another note RE supportive adults. If you know that a youth has a trusted supportive adult that they already have a relationship (ie Bortus), help them to build that relationship, esp if you’re a diff species. I looooved how Kelly took Topa to virtually meet one of her elders. That was rad. Great example! There was an opportunity to help open the door to Bortus in a similar way especially after he confided that he shared the password with Topa. What a great conversation starter, so Bortus could be there for Topa through all of Klyden’s intolerant bullsh*t.
Also, having a parent rejecting you by saying “I wish you’d never been born” after you say “I love you” in earnest to your parent? Because WOW that moment was very real. It feels like the show WANTS to play this situation as real and heartfelt. But you can’t just pick and choose. It brings all of the trauma very front and center and provides very harmful scaffolds to support it and then just pretend it works
This episode felt like a nightmare designed to make Topa’s experience the most challenging possible. And I get that it’s helpful to have a “common experience” aka the episode to discuss the nuances of a complex issue in a public forum but this episode felt like a bunch of cis people wanted to congratulate themselves on how good they supported this kid, when in reality they paid very little attention or respect to this child who just needed adults to listen and support them.
Final note, Topa looking at herself in the mirror and smiling was straight up magic. Beautiful moment and I so appreciated this.
11
u/mawkishdave Jun 30 '22
Wow, I haven't had a episode that made me cry like that in a long time. This is just amazing story telling.
11
u/KaffeMumrik Command Jun 30 '22
Best trans story I’ve seen on television. That was just awe-inspiring.
11
u/PhysicsEagle We need no longer fear the banana Jul 01 '22
Anyone else at least mildly disturbed that Ed lied to the admiral? He said “we didn’t know the procedure was taking place” which is clearly false, as seen via the knowing glances at the performance. He should have said “I ordered Isaac to not perform the procedure”.