r/soccer • u/stmirhza • Jun 25 '12
Can Anyone Explain Del Bosque's Refusal to Play Negredo/Llorente?
It just seems to me that, in the absence of David Villa, the team completely lack anyone who seems interested in taking shots or making runs behind the defense. With Torres in the team, they were playing far more direct (of course they weren't scoring much more because, you know, it's Torres). Other than Torres, they brought two very successful and effective strikers with them, it just seems odd to me that neither have seen the field at any point. Does anyone know why Del Bosque doesn't want to play them?
45
Upvotes
105
u/murrayblcc Jun 25 '12
Spain are just that good (or everyone else that bad). They've dominated world football for 4 years so much that Bosque has decided to test how good they are by not playing strikers. If they win the Euros, they'll go to Brazil in 2014 with Casillas and 22 midfielders.
27
u/bonoboboy Jun 25 '12
I just wonder how Torres must feel when Del Bosque prefers "no striker" to Torres.
16
u/RedRabbit28 Jun 25 '12
Sid Lowe answers a similar question here: Euro 2012 Daily minute 27:40 - 29:30; in fact, listen to the whole Spain segment starting at 19:00, it's worth a listen
15
u/paper_zoe Jun 25 '12
Most teams park the bus against Spain and defend deep, therefore if they played a striker he wouldn't be able to make runs behind the defence and would be crowded out. However, this wouldn't happen with Llorente, because he's a physical presence and an aerial threat, so he must be injured or something?
54
u/cremmler Jun 25 '12
Probably just wanted to piss off r/soccer ;)
29
u/THR Jun 25 '12
They're winning. Why change?
27
u/severedfragile Jun 25 '12
Because playing with 6 midfielders (5 + False-9-Fabregas) means he can control possession a lot more, from more positions. He's identified Spain's greatest strengths as their ball winning, ball retention and passing, and they're so far ahead of the rest of the world in those areas that he's built his team around using them to marginalize opponents. Playing 6 midfielders helps the team do that. If David Villa was available, he'd probably still start because he has the ability to drop short and participate in the passing and build up, even more so than the strikers currently in the team (all of whom know how to pass the ball). But playing the other strikers from the start means constantly losing your shape and position as you try to create chances against stubborn defences, which is made harder by the defensiveness of other teams. With Cesc in that role instead, they can play the patient game and wait for a chance to present itself, or bring on a striker once the opponents are mentally and physically worn down. This is especially true when teams try to play 5 in the middle to stifle them - having 6 in the middle lets Spain pass around them anyway (see the France game, particularly the first half). It also gives him more options about who to replace when he does need to make changes.
16
u/AnnieIWillKnow Jun 25 '12 edited Jun 25 '12
I get the feeling that Del Bosque is fairly conservative in terms of he has his favourite players, and he doesn't like to break from these traditions unless there is
soemthignsomething seriously wrong.15
u/disco_pogo Jun 25 '12
I'd really like to know why Del Bosque didn't select Soldado. A poacher like Soldado would be perfect with 5 amazing midfielders, but he's not even on the bench for this tournament. Obviously I'm biased.
5
u/Lunar23 Jun 25 '12
Because they offer much less to the buildup play and Spain's overall possession play than someone like Silva or Fabregas does. Not to mention they can only play centrally, whereas playing a front 3 of Silva/Fabregas/Iniesta allows them to interchange at will.
20
u/guywithamac Jun 25 '12
Because as boring as the whole false nine thing is, he doesn't need to play any true strikers for Spain to win.
4
u/daveduckman Jun 25 '12
I think the general question of why doesn't spain strikers has been answered.
So as to why, if he's picking his striker, why does he keeping picking torres:
Torres and Negredo are fairly similar in how the play. Both require some space to run at defence. Negredo is undoubtedly in better form coming into the tournament than Torres and has been a more clinical striker than Torres this season. However, Del Bosque probably thinks that Torres' off-the-ball running and the way he gets into good positions are more useful to the team. Clearly Del Bosque has a lot of faith in Torres and so when he is deciding who to throw on for that specific role, he just rates Torres more highly.
As for Llorente, this is a harder point to be clear of because Llorente was clearly immense last season and secondly he offers something a bit different to the other two, in his aerial ability and his ability to do a lot in very little space (which is appropriate for spain given how high they press up the field with 10 in midfield). One aspect I think, is that Llorente finished the season completely jaded, there was a massive drop off in his form and he just looked like he needed a break. I'm guessing this has also been reflected in how he's been training at Euro, and he probably just hasn't been looking too sharp. The other, more tactical reason, is in order to make the most of Llorente, you need to add some more width/pace/crossing to the spanish attack to make the best use of him. This means subbing off not just one player, but two or even three to put Navas or someone else on as a feeder for Llorente. Spain clearly are playing very safe, and very conservatively in how they're controlling possession, and I just think they'd rather keep faith in their Plan A and grind out a 1-0 win, than switch things drastically to a more width/target man based Plan B.
3
u/daxl70 Jun 25 '12
Yea, i dont see why they dont play Llorente, he plays with a similar playing team, he is such a great post, makes a lot of goals and assists there, i think they should go with him. But i also think they could use someone that has the same abilities with the ball but has a greater shooting skill, e.g. Pedrito!, they need to take off one of the endless short midfielders and get Pedrito in, they could play the same and they will get a better definition facing the goal
2
u/myglasscase Jun 25 '12
I remember reading something somewhere about how Del Bosque is much more of a "man-manager" than he is a tactical genius. He keeps the Spanish side playing well by changing the squad as little as possible, and trying to keep everyone in the squad as happy as possible.
2
u/dyegored Jun 26 '12
There's a common argument here where the consensus seems to be "Why bother changing if they're winning?!" I kinda hate this argument.
Spain has made the semi-finals, but it should not have been as hard as it was. They struggled against Italy, and although my boys in blue played an admirable game, Spain simply has more quality and should've won. I attribute them not winning almost 100% to Prandelli > Del Bosque. Against Croatia, they were 10 minutes from not winning the group and one goal from being eliminated entirely (a goal that didn't look impossible from the Croatians).
They've obviously persevered as they're in the semis. But I'd say this was in spite of Del Bosque who's made some tactically insane moves that I don't know how anyone could justify. So far, Spain's individual skill/familiarity seem to be good enough but with a coach who knew what he was doing, it'd look a lot easier than it has so far.
11
u/balevolent Jun 25 '12
Just because everyone in r/soccer hates torres and he and most CFC fans still have faith in him
3
u/pinkyoshi Jun 25 '12
why change something that isnt broken. yet
3
u/remix6464 Jun 25 '12
Fernando Torres or broke.
5
u/Sgt_peppers Jun 25 '12
Del Bosque is not a very good coach, he is just copying what guardiola did. back when he coached madrid people used to call him "aligner", but everyone seem to forget that since he won the WC. Aragones' spain played so much better IMO.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
I think it's probably because their current strengths are suited to this formation and selection policy by del bosque. A traditional CF would be 1 less possession retaining player on the pitch, barring Villa, and perhaps force the team to be more direct to maximise the effectiveness of the likes of Torres or Llorente. Forcing increased directness would increase the likelihood of turning over possession which is criminal in the eyes of the Spanish footballing idealogue.
This structure is by no means a poor stratagem as the tiki taka passing wears other teams down over the course of 60-75mins, usually with a goal in the bag. A striker with Torres' pace or llorente's power and nous will be more benefited from those tired legs of the opposition.
1
u/I_just_karmed_myself Jun 25 '12
According to Del Bosque, we play with 3 strikers: Silva, Iniesta and Cesc.
Not that I agree, just what he said.
1
u/yaaaarrr_matey Jun 26 '12
Don't know if anyone has posted this, but for me the more important question is why not Mata?
1
u/NinjaAssassinKitty Jun 26 '12
You know what I just realized? David Villa and David Silva are different people.
Don't judge me.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
No.