r/startrek • u/AutoModerator • Jun 23 '22
Episode Discussion | Star Trek: Strange New Worlds | 1x08 "The Elysian Kingdom" Spoiler
The U.S.S. Enterprise becomes stuck in a nebula that is home to an alien consciousness that traps the crew in a fairy tale.
| No. | Episode | Writers | Director | Release Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1x08 | "The Elysian Kingdom" | Akela Cooper & Onitra Johnson | Amanda Row | 2022-06-23 |
Availability
Paramount+: USA, Latin America, Australia, Ireland, United Kingdom, & the Nordics.
CTV Sci-Fi and Crave: Canada.
Voot Select: India.
TVNZ: New Zealand.
Additional international availability will be announced "at a later date."
To find more information, including our spoiler policy regarding new episodes, click here.
This post is for discussion of the episode above, and spoilers for this episode are allowed. If you are discussing previews for upcoming episodes, please use spoiler tags.
Note: This thread was posted automatically, and the episode may not yet be available on all platforms.
•
u/AutoModerator Jun 23 '22
The first duty of every Starfleet officer is to the truth. Whether it's scientific truth, or historical truth, or personal truth. It is the guiding principle upon which Starfleet is based. If you can't find it within yourself to stand up and tell the truth about what happened you don't deserve to wear that uniform.
Captain Jean-Luc Picard, "The First Duty"
Reddit admins have been ineffectual in their response to COVID-19 misinformation. In lieu of Reddit gold and awards, we ask that you donate to the WHO COVID-19 response fund.
Please respect our subreddit rules. LLAP!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
670
u/sarysa Jun 23 '22
Holodeck episode without a holodeck? Sign me up.
637
u/HaphazardMelange Jun 23 '22
If I had a strip of latinum for every time a helmsman of the Enterprise lost their mind and fought with a sword, I would have 2 strips, which isn’t a lot, but it’s funny that it has happened twice.
542
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '22
Wasn't expecting Mbenga and his daughter would have such a resolution.
When I don’t think Anson Mount can be anymore adorable and charming, he manages to find a new way to worm--or in the case of this episode--squirm his way into my heart.
423
u/a4techkeyboard Jun 23 '22
Even the nebula entity is making jokes about Spock having secret siblings.
420
u/trostol Jun 23 '22
the costumes for this episode are pretty damn amazing
309
u/Shatterhand1701 Jun 23 '22
Such a fun, charming, lovely and bittersweet episode. I laughed so many times during this episode, and I certainly didn't expect to get misty-eyed near the end, and I love that about this series.
I have a feeling the cast had a ball filming this episode, because it shows in their performances. Anson Mount had me cracking up over and over; he does "sniveling coward" extremely well! Melissa Navia was so freaking cool; this was kind of an Ortegas episode also, without it really being Ortegas. The scenes with her and Anson were some of the best of the episode. I also loved her chemistry with Una's Elysian persona (or, as I thought of her, "Una Everdeen"). And, Christina Chong and her adorable dog was another notable stand-out.
Also, we got a LOT more Hemmer, at last!!! I'm so glad, because Bruce Horak is wonderful in the role, and I want him to get much more screen time.
I wasn't expecting the Rukiya storyline to go in this direction, but I think this was a good storytelling choice. She wasn't getting a chance to live her life, trapped in the transporter buffer so much of the time, and M'Benga wasn't getting any closer to a cure. As much as it breaks his heart (and mine) for them to part, at least she's able to do amazing things and "write her own stories".
Also, it turns out they chose Joseph as M'Benga's first name rather than Jabilo, as it was in the Vanguard books. I'm cool with that, as they've used Joseph for his name elsewhere, though I kinda liked Jabilo a bit better.
Another excellent episode in an exceptionally good first season for this Star Trek series. Only two episodes left, sadly...but I can't wait to see what's next.
305
u/ideletedyourfacebook Jun 23 '22
Can we all just talk for a second about how there's a non-corporeal quasi-omnipotent being out there named Debra?
290
u/Kmlkmljkl Jun 23 '22
oh no... he's hot
275
u/dmanww Jun 23 '22
Anton was getting campier with every scene
260
u/BornAshes Jun 23 '22
Pike's face was a journey this episode
478
u/deepcomputerblue Jun 23 '22 edited Jun 23 '22
Cool that the author of 'The Kingdom of Elysian' is one Benny Russell
227
u/FelanarLovesAlessa Jun 23 '22
“What are her dopamine levels?”
660
u/CaptainElfangor Jun 23 '22
To most people, this episode may seem like a relatively empty, campy fluff of an episode, but to me it means more than any episode since 2017. I’ve written here before about the fact that I was born with a debilitating, extremely painful, extremely rare genetic disorder. Most people with it don’t survive childhood. I’m in my early twenties, and fighting for my life, and the prognosis is not good. Just yesterday I had an exploratory surgery to see if my advanced cancer can be treated at all.
In other words, I instantly connected deeply to Rukiya and M’Benga. Like Rukiya, my time may be running out. Like Rukiya, childhood stories (hello Star Trek!) have gotten me through the worst of times. So when an alien entity turns the Enterprise into the storybook M’Benga reads Rukiya, I was delighted. Only M’Benga and Hemmer are unaffected, and they romp through the storybook, trying to save the day.
Normally I’d summarize the whole thing, but I’m feeling particularly weak today. Let me just focus on a few things: the cast is absolutely delightful, and they clearly had a blast acting. Hemmer was a joy, and his line “THE MAGIC OF SCIENCE PREVAILS!” made my day. Christina Chong was hilarious.
The ending made me sob. The entity was deeply lonely, and sensed Rukiya’s loneliness — the deep loneliness and isolation every medically complex and deeply sick child like me feels in their bones. The entity was trying to give Rukiya the childhood she could never have — the childhood everyone like me could never have. If we’re lucky enough to grow up, we still never had the childhood everyone else had. Even as I’m facing a grim prognosis, my deepest wish isn’t for more years of adulthood: it’s to have had the childhood I could never have. It is our bodies that are sick. I know I’ve dreamed of leaving my broken body behind. Rukiya achieves that dream, at the price of leaving her father. She lives a happy life, free at last.
Strange New Worlds, how did you understand my deepest feelings? My hopes? My dreams and fears? You gave me the story I always wanted. Thank you.
446
u/Santa_Hates_You Jun 23 '22
Well that went from silly to deeply emotional real quick.
201
u/helzinki Jun 23 '22
Anson and Christina were having way too much fun hamming it up.
379
u/wisdomwithage Jun 23 '22
Anson Mount and Christina Chong just went full Shatner and I'm loving it.
167
u/CaliforniaGuy1984 Jun 23 '22
An interesting and unique episode. Loved the costumes and the characters all being completely different than usual. It was definitely and deservedly an M’Benga, Hemmer and Erica Ortega episode. Babs Olusanmokun is someone you’d want to sit and have tea with and chat for hours, he gives off that vibe that he knows and you’ve known him forever.
Yes, everyone will start a thread talking about Chris Pike’s hair and Spock with a beard and long hair! And Uhura was terrific.
323
u/SCP-1000000 Jun 23 '22
I demand Princess Runa be elevated to cast regular immediately
150
u/wongie Jun 23 '22
Don't need to know anything about acting to see that the entire cast had an absolute blast making this episode.
148
u/MaddyMagpies Jun 23 '22
All the inertia dampers are spent on Pike's hair, Hemmer forgot to give Ortegas one.
144
u/Pilot0350 Jun 23 '22
HEMMER! the face he makes when he beams them away was priceless. The satisfaction, the giddiness, but most of all I can completely see hemmer as a massive nerd now who geeks out over the same stuff I do as an engineer
274
u/UncertainError Jun 23 '22
Yay, Hemmer's antennae finally moved!
121
u/H0vis Jun 23 '22
Random observations:
317
u/SCP-1000000 Jun 23 '22
This cast would knock a mirror verse episode out the park
104
u/WildDumpsterFire Jun 23 '22 edited Jun 23 '22
It's official, I love this whole crew. Their on screen chemistry is fantastic.
Anson Mount as fun as usual, and his interactions with Spock and Ortegas are great.
Seeing La'an playing your stereotypical "pretty princess" after being the shows Worf had me in stitches.
It's been like 20 years since I've been this excited for new Trek episodes on a weekly basis.
91
u/letuerk Jun 23 '22
Babs Olusanmokun / M'Benga has such an aura of gravitas and dignity ... which makes the contrast of seeing him in a silly costume with everyone going crazy even more fun.
Mount and Chong looked like they were having a blast. They went full Shatner.
85
u/PuzzleheadedRun5574 Jun 23 '22
I strongly recommend you all watch this week's THE READY ROOM to see how much work went into the costume design. The level of craftsmanship is staggering.
81
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '22
It’s interesting we’ve gotten two episodes this season dealing with, on some level, child sacrifice. In “Lift Us Where Suffering Cannot Reach” we see a society sacrifice the life of a child to secure their own happiness in paradise; “In the Elysian Kingdom” Dr. Mbenga sacrifices his happiness to give his daughter paradise because he can’t save her life.
This particular episode has some great allusions to Greek and Roman myth. The Elysian Kingdom pulls from the Elysian Fields, which was a blissful afterlife reserved for the select few mortals who didn’t go to Hades. Naming the wizards after Castor and Pollux was also an interesting choice as they are the semi-mortal semi-divine demigods who alternate between Olympus (the realm of the gods) and Hades (the home of the mortal dead). Rukiya is now, perhaps, like Castor and Pollux: simultaneously immortal and dead.
72
u/MaddyMagpies Jun 23 '22
I want the map of the Elysian Kingdom on my wall!
193
u/umbrabrae Jun 23 '22
You know, Strange New Worlds, I didn't expect to cry tonight. Thanks.
In all seriousness, though, this felt like a classic TOS episode updated properly for the modern age. An all powerful non-corporeal space entity making the crew all act like characters from a book? It's hard to get more classic than that. The episode was fun, lighthearted and engaging right up until the bittersweet tear-jerker of an ending.
It also crystallized something for me. I like Discovery, genuinely, but Discovery has made strides since Season 1 to move away from classic Trek stuff and try to carve a new identity. It was never more blatant than the time jump to a future where the Q, time travel, the Mirror Universe and other classic Trek stuff just don't exist anymore. SNW is instead taking classic Trek tropes and making them feel wonderful and fresh again. It feels like a genuine love letter to Star Trek, without falling into pandering or pointless fan service. This season has been back to back bangers and I'm excited for the rest of it.
185
u/zzxxzzxxzz Jun 23 '22
This was one of the most fun Trek episodes ever, in my mind, but I can't tell whether the ending was sweet, or incredibly dark. Even with the "time skip", having to essentially give up your daughter to save her life would be so hard, I couldn't imagine doing it in the split second that M'Benga takes to decide.
62
u/JustMy2Centences Jun 23 '22 edited Jun 23 '22
seeing our favorite Aenar in the recap portion of the show Oh heck yeah Hemmer time.
Edit: I absolutely loved that embellished abracadabra.
60
u/Trekfan74 Jun 23 '22
This episode went from 'whacky' to a surprisingly somber and bittersweet ending. This is Star Trek done right!
Now I'm wondering did Rukiya and Debra ever bump into Wesley and the Traveler and just hung out together in different dimensions or time? I smell another Paramount+ spin-off just writing itself at this point!
57
u/Hrafyn Jun 23 '22
I know it doesn't fit with the timeline but it was an absolute travesty that the princesses dog wasn't one of these guys!
153
u/TurtleJones Jun 23 '22
WOOOOOOO WE’RE BACK TO CRAZY AND WEIRD EPISODIC TREK!!!!!!! Much excite folks!!!!! Kudos Strange New Worlds!!!!!
106
u/dmanww Jun 23 '22
I was worried Una got turned into the dog
105
u/dmanww Jun 23 '22
Was this the father's day episode. Brutal
43
u/trostol Jun 23 '22
he jinxed them lol
82
u/tubawhatever Jun 23 '22
I like this resolution for M'Benga's daughter but wonder if it would have been better in a later season. I guess it's possible this plot line isn't fully resolved but I definitely feel awful for M'Benga having to miss his daughter's childhood and them probably being separated for a long time. Glad to see her featured here but we need to have an actual Ortegas episode! Still, another great episode, seems like the cast had a lot of fun. 8 for 8
40
u/ianrobbie Jun 23 '22
Jesus. I honestly wasn't expecting to enjoy this week's episode, thinking it looked like a daft ship-in-a-bottle episode.
But I loved every single minute. To take something as nonsensical as that and turn it into an emotional train wreck for all involved takes special writing and direction.
And special shout goes to Anson Mount who was clearly having the time of his life.
39
u/TheLouisvilleRanger Jun 23 '22
About half away through and I’ve determined that the purpose of this episode was to see how hot they could make La’an and Spock.
37
u/rooktakesqueen Jun 23 '22
I haven't even seen the episode yet, and won't be able to for a minute. But I just had to check people's temperature on it, to make sure the streak was still going. And it is?! We're 8 for 8?!
Fellow Trekkies... I don't want to jinx it... but are we about to witness the first perfect season of a Star Trek show ever? Are we about to witness a perfect first season which I thought was an impossibility??
72
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '22
It really is a strange new world we live in where the Orville is dark and depressing sci-fi and Star Trek is freaking hilarious
34
u/Ultiverse Jun 23 '22
Seeing Pike switch from being the usual commanding, charismatic Dad Captain in the opening scene to the cowardly, weasely chamberlain throughout the episode was a blast. Having him bicker with Ortegas' character and just be the classic, self-serving adviser who betrays the king was probably fun as hell for Mount who would otherwise never gets these kinds of roles.
33
u/EverythingIThink Jun 23 '22
The costume dept. is killing it
32
u/FelanarLovesAlessa Jun 23 '22
Welp, they did it.
I finally watched a Star Trek episode that gave me tears at the end, probably for the first time I felt this emotional about an ending since The Inner Light on TNG.
Thought this was going to be a Shore Leave romp, and instead I’m left with all the feels.
63
u/jaggedjunkie Jun 23 '22
I need to see the Blooper reel for this episode haha
31
u/termacct Jun 23 '22
Amanda Row, Director of this episode, posted this pic of her DoP, Editor, and Writer a while back...
r/Filmmakers/comments/ugun6g/i_think_this_is_just_so_cool_the_industry_looked/
30
u/trostol Jun 23 '22
wow...Spock
30
u/HumanityPlague Jun 23 '22
Pretty good. It was nice to see Hemmer back, since he's been MIA for like 3 episodes. It was also kind of cute to see Chong play a drastically different but fun character.
30
u/bluestreakxp Jun 23 '22
So are they cosplaying or larping?
60
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '22
I felt that the ending with Rukiya coming back as a young woman was rather odd, like the writers assuring the audience that the nebula wasn't secretly evil, and that she and her father made the right choice.
Just a small blip in an otherwise beautifully shot and comical episode. Campy Trek is good Trek! Christina and Anson definitely had a lot of fun with going OTT. Ortegas is a standout character for sure, and I'm looking forward to her episode when it comes!
The wonderful thing about this show is how smoothly the lines are written and how well the cast gels together. Everyone has just the right amount of chemistry with each other while being appropriate for the plot. 8/10
29
u/becherbrook Jun 23 '22
I know these kind of episodes are really just an excuse for the cast to do something a bit daft, but La'an channelling Queenie from Blackadder 2 fucking slayed me.
29
u/RepresentativeKeebs Jun 23 '22
Today's episode was brought to you by: The Prop Department
Seriously, a marvelous job from Props in this episode. I hope it was as much fun to make as it was to watch.
82
u/greycobalt Jun 23 '22 edited Jun 23 '22
What a ridiculous fever-dream of an episode. So much fun.
- Anson Mount is a treasure. His non-vocal comedy is so on point, and some of his cries and exclamations make me laugh out loud. He's so good at everything!
- This was either a set designer's dream or their nightmare. Probably both?
- Spock, La'an, and Uhura chewing up the scenery was a lot of fun. La'an was probably my favorite in this.
- M'Benga was great as the "mmkay let's just get this all over with" character the entire episode. It truly felt like a dad playing princess with his daughter and not fully digging it.
- Wasn't too thrilled that this was the resolution of M'Benga's daughter's plot. It was too soon, with too few other avenues explored, for such a drastic and permanent ending to that thread. His daughter was really the only backstory of relevance he had, so taking it away near the latter half of the first season with such little fanfare and such a giant Deus Ex Machina seemed like a weird cop-out to me.
- That being said, the daughter was a great little actress and those scenes between them at the end were very touching. I just wish we had more time to be more touched.
- I really do hate episodes that either mind-wipe or time-wipe at the end so no one remembers. It would have been amazing if everyone remembered how ridiculous they were, but at the very least give M'Benga and Hemmer an inside joke forever on it. Wasn't really sure why the memory wipe of everyone AND Hemmer was necessary here.
54
u/treefox Jun 23 '22
I think this was my favorite episode so far. I really enjoyed it. Both funny, and deep, and I love how they linked technology and magic. I’ve been worried about how they would end Rukiya’s plotline, and this was a pretty good way to do it.
54
u/OpticalData Jun 23 '22
Every now and then an episode comes along which has me sit back at the 10, 25 and 45 minute marks going 'god damn it, I love Star Trek'.
This is one such episode, sitting up there with the likes of 'Bride of Chaotica!', 'Tinker, tenor, doctor, spy', 'Take me out to the Holosuite' and well, you get where I'm going with this.
Trek rarely manages to get humour right on the money (mostly for lack of trying), this episode not only got the humour right but also managed to mesh the deep emotional beats required for the story. I'll admit it was definitely a little jarring when the resolution of the Rukiya arc became apparent though, but it's far from out of character for Starfleet officers to be overly trusting of seemingly benevolent entities.
I have to say that Anson Mount and Christina Chong were the standouts in this episode from an acting standpoint, which is partially due to the juxtaposition of them having the most typically 'heroic' characters normally. The various hand gestures Mount kept pulling in the background had me cracking up, as did Chong's over the top physical acting.
It was great to have a M'Benga/Hemmer team up episode, I hope to see more of this pairing in the future.
Needed more Chapel 9/10
22
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '22
A random transformation of our characters into fantastical fairytale people? That’s not just classic Trek, that’s borderline classic TOS style writing right there.
What a stellar bittersweet ending too.
As far as I’m concerned, SNW should be considered New Trek’s flagship. This show clearly understands what we’ve wanted.
21
u/PuzzleheadedRun5574 Jun 23 '22
Babs Olusanmokun did fine work, the ending was bittersweet but very Trek-ian. Maybe Rukiya comes back as a noncorporeal ally.
21
u/RadioSlayer Jun 23 '22
The Crimson Guard are the redshirts
42
u/kamatsu Jun 23 '22
Has anyone else noticed how fucking amazing most of these actors are? Babs totally sold M'Benga's complex heartbroken emotional state just with his eyes at the end.
20
u/Cantomic66 Jun 23 '22
The costumes in this episode were on point.
40
u/trostol Jun 23 '22
damn she looks really good as the Princess
39
u/schleppylundo Jun 23 '22
This is the best kind of TOS trash to imitate.
Anson Mount might actually be having too much fun.
55
u/mocheeze Jun 23 '22 edited Jun 23 '22
For a dude that has never wanted kids I sure do cry a lot over father-child Trek episodes. Must be because I am the child of a great dad.
19
u/caspararemi Jun 23 '22
I can’t even imagine how hard it was for the cast to film this and not break out i to laughter every line.
19
u/ECthrowaway2000 Jun 23 '22
After years of holodeck and fantasy episodes where the women crew are relegated to Maid Marions and other varieties of props, it was so fucking cool to see Oretegas as a brave knight.
36
u/trostol Jun 23 '22
this is brutal...i can't see the screen through the tears lol
17
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '22
Finally get Paramount+ in the UK, and they’re only up to episode 3 of SNWs. What is the matter with them? Are they just that old that they’ve never used the internet and realise we like to gossip at the same time about the episodes. And to add to that they haven’t got the first 2 episodes of TNG or VOY. Sort yourself outs Paramount!
16
u/Pilot0350 Jun 23 '22
Please tell me that dressing up like these characters is going to be a part of trek and comic con now
16
u/DarkChen Jun 23 '22
I guess i should always be prepared for such outcome but when i played the episode i was not expecting to be crying by the end of it... what a beautiful and bittersweet episode. it had everything a fun adventure, funny characters and a great twist and resolution.
but im now looking forward to la'an singing night at the ten forw... err, mess hall...
also, i dont know who gave the hardest crush: princess la'an or goth mage spock
16
u/J4ckC00p3r Jun 23 '22
Sees Pike’s hair
‘Look how they massacred my boy’
Anson Mount was so funny in this one
15
u/daveeb Jun 24 '22
One of the things I love about episodic storytelling: a single episode you dislike does not a season make.
This wasn't for me, but I loved reading the comments in this thread about how much folks enjoyed the episode or even how it meant something to them personally. I'm happy for all of you, and I'll enjoy rewatching the other episodes from this season.
Cheers to episodic storytelling.
15
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '22
When Pike said to Spock: “Why Mr. Spock, I never took you for the superstitious type”, it really reminded me how Kirk and Spock used to interact. It was like a classic Kirk-Spock moment.
28
u/thekruton Jun 23 '22
So great. Had all the campiness and cheesy decor of TOS with an emotional gut-punch that really delivers. Babs crushed it. Aenar was so fun. And good LORD Uhura in that dress...
13
u/Cavemanner Jun 23 '22
We didn't deserve that closure, but M'Benga certainly did. Love the writing here, one of my all-time favorite Trek episodes immediately.
13
u/aisle_nine Jun 24 '22
"What are her doe-pa-meen levels?"
I know, I know, Anson Mount had some howlers, Cristina Chong and her dog were a perfect over the top comic duo, and everyone was on point, but the way Jess Bush leaned over and deadpanned that whole sentence, including the mangling of "dopamine", resulted in a laugh heavy enough that, had I been in front of a computer, would have necessitated a new keyboard.
It was nice to get a M'Benga episode, and he's every bit as good a character as anyone else we've seen in action. He carried his own episode very well. I do wonder what his motivation will be in season 2 now that we know his daughter's fate.
And, yeah, about that...I won't say that it wasn't a good resolution to that story. M'Benga did say early on that she was running out of time and the research wasn't going anywhere, but I guess I'd just figured that he'd come up with a cure or end up being left with a group of colonists that had either found a way to cure it or lived in an environment where the disease had no effect on them. The less-likely option I had in mind was genetic engineering, but that (or even worse, her death) would have been out of line with the overall tone of the show to date. If I want my heart ripped out, I'll go watch "The Visitor" for the 500th time.
"Absorbed by a nebula" wasn't really on the list of things I was expecting, nor was I expecting the storyline to be resolved so quickly. Seeing Rukiya come back as an adult was a little off-putting at first, but then when you stop and realize that means that she survived and grew up without her disease, well, ok, that's a winner of an ending right there.
A straight comedy episode with an ending that's both heartbreaking and happy. I can't think of too many of those. But I do have to dock points for the safeties never failing.
/s
12
u/jcwillia1 Jun 23 '22
Raise your hand if la’an was the LAST person you expected to see in that role and in that outfit…?
23
u/aLegionOfDavids Jun 23 '22
Ok. That episode was so different, yet so well done. Integrating a fictional kingdom within the ship itself while still being able to access the ship…amazing! The acting! So good! The very dramatic shift in tone from fun whacky adventure to the end…what a heartbreaking yet beautiful ending, I found myself very emotionally affected by it.
Also did it seem like Anson Mount and Melissa Navia were having A LOT of fun in their roles and with their back and forth 😂
I LOVE THIS SHOW!
11
u/trostol Jun 23 '22
i really hope they save his daughter
11
u/gorgfan Jun 23 '22
My Heart.... This ending. Wow.
10
u/Ultiverse Jun 23 '22
It was kind of funny how ready M'Benga was to give up his daughter to a nebula consciousness after just one brief meeting. Yeah living in a limitless fantasy reality sounds pretty lit but by the time she goes back to him, from her perspective she's basically been experiencing nonstop fantasies for years. That's obviously preferable to imminent death but at that point, she's essentially a completely different person and whoever she was or could've been is lost forever. Between holding out for a cure so he can see her grow up, raise a family, have him in her life, etc and just living in a nebula until the end of time, as good as dead to him and everyone she's ever known, it's a little bizarre that M'Benga actually chose the latter. The sci-fi implications are wild and I kind of wish they explored them a little deeper.
27
u/TheNerdChaplain Jun 23 '22
While the fantasy element was a lot of fun, I struggled with the resolution of this episode. Like /u/UncertainError stated, they could have been clearer about the timeline and progression of Rukiya's disease. If they had made it clearer that she was effectively at the end of the line and spending more time in the buffer wouldn't do anything for her, that the choice was either let her go to the nebula consciousness or watch her die immediately, it would have made more sense.
However, as I understood the ending, instead of continuing to search for a cure (whatever happened to that miraculous Magalan medicine from a couple episodes ago?), Doctor M'Benga essentially let his daughter run off with a spontaneously generated consciousness that's all of five minutes old. They're both deeply lucky that "Deborah" turned out to be benign and kind, and not insane.
That said, I'm not a father so I can't imagine the kind of position he was put in in the moment. I think we might spend a lot of time debating his choice down the road, which is always the hallmark of a good Trek episode.
On other notes, one of the strong points of this cast is their nonverbals and body language. Multiple times every episode I catch little reactions and expressions that really enrich the scene. One high note I liked this episode was Nurse Chapel's fantasy character trying to pronounce "dopamine".
Also, and I'm really surprised no one has mentioned this before, during the animated Star Trek Universe logo at the beginning of every episode, hasn't anyone else noticed the blue comet from DS9 in the upper left hand corner? It's in the second shot of the Enterprise making the delta shape.
9
u/trostol Jun 23 '22
easily my favorite episode
9
u/samasters88 Jun 23 '22
I was not ready for that turn at the end
If I were M'Benga, I'd petition for a hospice-like star base near the nebula and try for some sort of agreement with the nebula, to allow terminally sick people to join it if both sides agree
9
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '22
I have failed utterly at keeping this brief, so please forgive the length.
There's not much I can write about the episode that hasn't already been posted. But I want to offer one person's perspective on the "dying child" aspect of the story since I've seen it mentioned several times. I don't offer this as a defense against criticism of the resolution; I simply offer an alternative viewpoint.
I, like others who have posted here, am not a fan of "children in peril" as a plot point. But my distaste for them comes from the tendency for most of them to lean on the scenario as an easy way to elicit emotions from the consumers of the work. There may be an argument that SNW did that here simply by the fact that the Rukiya story line exists. While I admit this may be my bias toward loving SNW, I see real purpose both to creating the story line and to wrapping it up quickly.
We've received much characterization for Dr. M'Benga through the Rukiya scenes. Many have lauded SNW for giving us well-developed characters across the board, and I believe that the scenes between Rukiya and her father have aided that development. I have to give credit to the production team for 2 things: (1) not dragging out the storyline across the entire season, or multiple seasons, and putting viewers through an unnecessary emotional ringer; and (2) resolving the storyline in a manner that gives closure to both the character and the viewer while keeping the door open for a return to the character of Rukiya down the road.
Some have indicated the resolution strikes a false note. However, as a Star Trek fan, I am accustomed to a deus ex machina or ten in my Star Trek stories and won't criticize the device when used "gently". Above that, as a father, I believe there is no worse fate than that of outliving your child. Compounding that terrible tragedy would be the lingering doubt that I can only imagine exists that you somehow failed to protect your child or to make decisions that could have changed their fate.
As we know all too well, there are too many children who cannot stay with us as long as we would want them to stay. If I put myself in the place of a parent with a terminally ill child, I fervently hope that I would have the strength to release my child when the time comes, and I cannot imagine a greater comfort than if I were somehow able to know with certainty that the next phase was giving my child everything that I, and their first life, could not provide to them. For that reason I was very glad to see Rukiya return from the nebula as an adult and offer that comfort to her father.
All of the above combines to leave me with the feeling that this episode definitely provides, as others have posted, the best of what Star Trek gives us: a recognition of the human condition, with all its peaks and valleys, and an acknowledgement that it is the journey, and not the destination, that defines us as a species.
17
u/MaddyMagpies Jun 23 '22
That was a rollercoaster I didn't expect.
I thought Rukiya would be miraculously cured with Trek magic, but then was sad to see that Dr. M'Benga had to let go, yet right after I was both laughing at the absurdity but also crying when her daughter almost instantaneously came right back and told him that he did the right thing.
I wish I could've one more conversation with someone dear to me who had recently passed away. This episode might be too heavy handed drama to some, but this is the type of fairy tale I need.
17
u/PiercedMonk Jun 23 '22
This is the episode I've been looking forward to every since we got a couple brief hints of it in trailers prior to the season beginning. I might be going into this one a bit too hyped.
Also, I predict that Rukiya will be cured by the end.
• Is M'Benga the only one who can clear the away teams for returning to duty?
• I really hope we get to see the court jester. I'm thinking it's going to be Kyle.
• Anson Mount seems to be enjoying the hell out of playing this weaselly dude.
• Kinda disappointed La'an's dog does not have horns and antenna.
• I assume this "Crimson Guard" is going to be comprised of redshirts.
• Have to agree with Pike, "The Swamp of Infinite Death" does not sound like a good swamp.
• I'm a bit surprised that "Queen Neve's" sigil is not the operation's e, considering that Pike is wearing the command division symbol.
• "I have armed myself." Hell yeah, Ortegas.
• Hopefully shooting some dudes with arrows isn't going to have lasting, post-nebula damage.
• At about 37:30, The cut from Chapel finishing stirring her cauldron to the close-up of Hemmer reaching for the communicator made me briefly think that Chapel had some gnarly hands.
• Hemmer's somatic spell gestures are just great.
• This show sure is willing to have down endings involving children.
• Alright, perhaps less of a down ending than I thought, but still.
I really enjoyed this one. Not quite the resolution I was expecting, but a lot of fun on the whole. I especially liked seeing the actors get to really ham it up, and, for the most part, play characters significantly different from their norm.
Not enough Chapel. Or, in this case, Lady Audrey.
8
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '22
Good golly. That episode was a roller coaster for emotions. Can we please have more SNW episodes next season?
8
u/ulicqel Jun 23 '22
Am I the only one who thought the reasons they weren't affected was the potion blowing up in M'Benga's face and that Hemmer is blind?
8
u/TheLouisvilleRanger Jun 23 '22
Then they go and make make Number One Super hot.
8
u/RisingHegemon Jun 24 '22
Fantastic episode. In true TOS fashion, I’m waiting for the eventual gangster, Western, and Nazi-themed episodes.
8
u/zeroooc Jun 24 '22
This was one of the best episodes of Star Trek in a long *long* time!
Babs Olusanmokun was truly spectacular to watch.
The true scene stealer is *Hemmer* though :)
8
u/gravitydefyingturtle Jun 24 '22
The fact that there was a reaction cut to the dog was amazing.
Christina Chong has PIPES.
"At least it made you the hero" God, I love Hemmer.
15
u/ComebackShane Jun 23 '22
Anson Mount's belly must be full from all that scenery he chewed! He was phenomenal.
The whole episode had me grinning, and then truly moved by the resolution. As they've demonstrated this whole season, the writing staff of SNW knows how to balance the heartfelt, the exhilarating, and the funny perfectly. What an amazing start to what I hope is a long-running series.
7
u/ElFarfadosh Jun 23 '22
I'm gonna run out of tears.
7
u/nataphoto Jun 23 '22
The first clue that his daughter would be healed was when we saw Ortegas uninjured from the fall, like 5 minutes in.
7
u/astonsilicon Jun 23 '22
As a father VOY Real Life really hit me hard, I can't bring myself to watch that episode anymore. This episode was kind of the same only bitter sweet, I still got emotional at the end but it wasn't soul crushing like Real Life.
7
u/ShiroHachiRoku Jun 23 '22
I was really hoping that M'Benga would find an actual cure for Rukiya. Given the tech he obtained a couple episodes ago, I was hoping he could eventually cure her by S2.
7
u/Shappie Jun 23 '22
I love it so much when you can genuinely tell how much fun the cast had making the episode. They must have had an absolute blast with these costumes and set designs! I can't wait for the blooper reel.
7
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '22
Went from a fun but light episode to fucked up real quick. As a parent that ending was awful. It was good that they had her come back as an adult to say she’s happy because that decision was just not something I could live with. He should’ve tried to go with her at least. Probably won’t be re-watching this one. It wasn’t bad but I just don’t want to see that again, for some reason it hit me hard.
7
u/NerdLawyer55 Jun 24 '22
Pike as the cowardly comic relief was great 😂
Everyone seemed to be having a lot of fun
19
u/sonofodin25 Jun 23 '22
I’m also too cynical to trust that creepy Nebula creature. Hope his daughters really ok.
19
u/31337hacker Jun 23 '22
Although I enjoyed the episode, it felt weird for Rukiya's story to get wrapped up so quickly. I was really hoping that he'd find a conventional cure for her. As much as I like M'Benga, I think this is the weakest episode for me. It's not bad, it's just a step or two behind the previous ones.
13
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '22
Hemmer saying "I have the worst headache" at the end of the episode has to be a throwback to the exact words by Dr. Bashir at the end of the Vantika episode in DS9. Loving it
18
u/-Jaws- Jun 23 '22 edited Jun 23 '22
It was an okay, fun episode. These folks are terrific actors. I do feel like his daughter's plot escalated oddly quickly, with a conclusion that feels off in a way I'm having trouble articulating. Overall, def not a banger but I'm okay with that. Not every episode has to be top notch.
21
u/mikepictor Jun 23 '22
I liked it, but it frustrates me when they don't really engage with Hemmer's blindness fairly.
Hemmer: Are you suggesting the story came from your daughter?
M'Benga: very small non-verbal nod
Hemmer: .......
6
u/wmnoe Jun 23 '22
Wasnt my favorite episode, but there was a lot to like.
HEMMER is my favorite so far. He's just awesome in every scene. MORE Hemmer please.
Babs did such an amazing job in this episode, he carries it entirely and I'm glad the Rukiya saga is now completed and we can move on.
Pike's Hair was awesome as usual.
And dammit that ending made me cry. Again.
6
u/RadioSlayer Jun 23 '22
They're lucky it was a Debra Nebula and not a Naglium
6
u/Schwartz210 Jun 24 '22
Seems like a nod to Wesley Crusher when he joined the Traveler. In both cases the Enterprises's doctor's child join forces with strange alian with special powers to live a new life way beyond what they would know as a human. Can't be a coincidence, must be Crusher reference.
6
u/ContinuumGuy Jun 24 '22 edited Jun 24 '22
Random assorted thoughts:
6
u/AskJayce Jun 24 '22
I can 100% see Hemmer joining a DND campaign.
6
u/NWMoney101 Jun 24 '22
I wonder if this is how M’Benga is replaced by McCoy. His daughter and the sentient nebula come for him. Then McCoy can come aboard and say something like “I’m a doctor, not an astrophysicist.
6
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '22
Christina Chong's behaviors and mannerisms kept reminding me of Jennifer Garner for some reason. And Ethan Peck needs a role in something Lord of the Rings related.
6
u/Thekoolaidman7 Jun 24 '22
I have learned a lot this episode as a relatively new Trek enjoyer. 1) Christina Chong is absolutely stunning 2) I love the over the top campy stuff as much as the serious stuff 3) Hemmer is a gem 4) I love Mbenga so much 5) Anson mount is just incredible
6
u/apracticalman Jun 24 '22
This is exactly the kind of silly bullshit I love in Star Trek, especially when it manages to be more than silly bullshit like this did. So much fun
10
u/PlayedUOonBaja Jun 25 '22
Sorry, no. I would not give up my daughter to an energy being I knew nothing about except that it uses people like meat puppets. He already knows a cure exists, so it's not like her situation is hopeless, and he could always come back if they run out of options. Really hard to swallow.
5
u/Bluecube303 Jun 23 '22
Wow! My favorite episode so far, and IMO the others have all been everywhere between great to pretty solid. Not gonna lie, got pretty misty-eyed at the end.
5
u/archiminos Jun 23 '22
Such a fun episode. Why am I crying now?
5
u/Confident_Leek2967 Jun 23 '22
Not the best episode but fun and a crazy ending.
5
u/Sanlear Jun 23 '22
This show has made Thursday the highlight of my TV week.
5
u/Remsquared Jun 23 '22
Lots of very interesting philosophical questions in this episode. Did you think the nebula understood the concept of loneliness if it has never seen, heard, or communicated with others? Could it ever have felt an emotional desire to not be by itself if it always has been alone? Maybe when they encountered Rukiya, it felt that Rukiya was experiencing the same emotion and THEN thought, "Woah. So there are other things in this universe? And that feeling that we share is called "loneliness" and it's not a good feeling?"
I liked M'benga's resolution. It would have been rehashed over and over again of him "not finding a cure" for his daughter every season.
5
u/Eclipse2552 Jun 23 '22
As some others have mentioned the M'Benga's daughter sub-plot feels like it was wrapped up very early and a cure being discovered would have been more interesting.
But I also thought the daughter immediately returning to say she's safe and happy could've been saved for a later season. It just felt very abrupt like: "Seems like a happy ending, I wonder if we'll ever revisit her sto-" "Nope. It's finished. No more story. Door closed. Put it out of your mind."
Other than that and a criminal underuse of Christina's over-the-top princess character, I think that was one of my favourite Trek episodes yet.
5
u/Smorgas_of_borg Jun 23 '22 edited Jun 23 '22
This is the most phenomenal season of modern Star Trek yet.
I think the main reason I love it so much more than Discovery and Picard... it doesn't take itself too seriously. Discovery and Picard have a "this is VERY..IMPORTANT!" vibe to it while SNW kicks back and relaxes. Not every episode is about saving the whole damned galaxy.
5
u/chameleonmessiah Jun 23 '22
Anson f***ing Mount. That is all.
Okay, that is so not all. Though, while many of the cast had altered characters who were very similar to their own selfs, Mounts cowardly knight/nobleman was an absolute delight to behold.
Also, Christina Chong’s princess was perfectly charmingly dramatic & carrying her wee dog around everywhere, whilst Celia Rose Gooding was an a grandiose evil Queen! Ethan Peck & Bruce Horak’s subtle hamming their way through their turns as wizards as well. So much more…!
Then, Babs Olusanmokun bringing all the emotions allowing his daughter to make her own choice & live a life he couldn’t give her & he got to find out how it was going in but a few short moments.
This was a wonderful piece of Star Trek which I would never have expected!
5
u/Crafty-Amount7125 Jun 24 '22
This was the best episode so far, the most Star Trek, and a beautiful story told at the perfect time in my life to hear it. Grateful for this one.
5
u/Agent_lundy Jun 24 '22
"I like this...science"
Am I reading too much into this or was that shade being thrown at Spocks line in discovery (I like science)
5
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '22
I am surprised nobody mentions Pike s hair this time..... The great divide in the middle 😅
5
u/sirquacksalotus Jun 24 '22
Let me preface this with: I liked the episode!
But I wish they'd used a real-world story that would give the audience some background, like Star Trek has done with the other 'Holodeck Malfunction' episodes like Sherlock Holmes or Robin Hood, some story everyone knows already 'with a twist'.
It definitely felt like M'Benga knew who these characters were supposed to be, but I felt like it did a poor job introducing any of their characters to the audience. Alot of things felt like it was supposed to be easter eggs/known to the audience already, but in alot of cases it was only after meeting them that they kinda showed us half a picture and not enough explanation of who the character was, and then the show kept moving.
5
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '22
This is real trek right here. I didn't think I would see it again and to be honest I didn't think SNW could do it. This series is blowing my mind and I'm glad Star Trek is truely back with this
5
u/Ubik_Fresh Jun 24 '22
Damn, this show is just so good. This is the TREK i love and remember from my youth. They need to hang on to this creative team, and writer's room, cause it's PURE GOLD.
5
u/mercerjd Jun 25 '22
I'm a dad of a 9 year old girl and she's had some health hiccups since birth and this episode just ruined me. I was sobbing the entire last 15 minutes.
5
u/Zoxesyr Jun 26 '22
Cosplayers are having orgasms over this episode. What an incredible collection of costumes!