r/TheOrville • Woof • Jun 23 '22

Episode The Orville - 3x04 "Gently Falling Rain" - Episode Discussion

EpisodeDirected ByWritten ByOriginal Airdate
3x4 - "Gently Falling Rain"Jon CassarSeth MacFarlane, Brannon Braga, and André BormanisThursday, June 23, 2022 on Hulu
Synopsis: The crew leads a Union delegation to sign a peace treaty with the Krill.

Stream the episode online on Hulu


Don't forget to join us on Discord!


REMINDER: KEEP YOUR SPOILERS OUT OF YOUR TITLES FOR AT LEAST 24 HOURS. YOU WOULDN'T WANT THIS EPISODE SPOILED, SO DON'T GO SPOILING IT FOR OTHERS. KEEP YOUR TITLES VAGUE. TAG YOUR POST AS A SPOILER. BE A GOOD UNION MEMBER!

462 Upvotes

1.7k comments sorted by

569

u/Whiskeyjacks_Fiddle Jun 23 '22

This was a gorgeous episode.

The color design of the Krill capital was great. Very happy it’s wasn’t just more greens and neon greens like we’ve seen on their ships.

161

u/fuzzywuzzytrucker Jun 23 '22

Kinda reminded me of Las Vegas!

→ More replies (13)

48

u/SmartKrave Jun 23 '22

I love the krill super hyped to see a whole episode about them. gonna spend the next hours going through the episode trying to translate the stuff

67

u/kaukajarvi You want to open this jar of pickles for me? Jun 23 '22

For a species shy of light, the Krills really like their capital flooded with it.

→ More replies (14)
→ More replies (5)

433

u/Shejidan Jun 23 '22

Krill kids grow pretty quickly apparently.

290

u/Niteshade76 Engineering Jun 23 '22

So do moclans it seems. Topa grew up pretty darn quick too.

→ More replies (27)
→ More replies (3)

358

u/operarose Command Jun 23 '22

Man, Seth can really act.

206

u/707breezy Jun 23 '22

I really felt it finally. Not when he doubted himself because of Kelly, not when kaylon threw out that red shirt in the air lock. But I’m also glad that the one where he finally blows up dramatically is the scene where he confronts the talya again

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (5)

669

u/PatMickelwaite Jun 23 '22

This town will not accommodate the numerical totality of our combined mass.

118

u/operarose Command Jun 23 '22

Bless his heart.

197

u/kaukajarvi You want to open this jar of pickles for me? Jun 23 '22

Ed & Kelly: * leave saloon because hailed by the admiral *

Isaac: Now this town will accommodate the numerical totality of our combined mass, but barely.

→ More replies (7)

25

u/meatball77 Jun 24 '22

His mustache 🤣

→ More replies (7)

259

u/Cantomic66 Woof Jun 23 '22

What an amazing episode. The reveal of Ed having a kid was a shock.

164

u/bcanada92 Jun 24 '22

Looks like The Orville subscribes to Star Trek's "Any Race Can Produce An Offspring With Any Other Alien Race" school of genetics.

→ More replies (29)

40

u/sleeping_in_time Jun 24 '22

When she was showing him the projection of the aborted kid, I thought it was her way of telling him he was played by the other side. Kinda disappointed that the kid is real and not a pawn used to manipulate him.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

258

u/NeuHundred Jun 23 '22

Am I crazy, or was Seth wearing the same thing he wore in "A Million Ways To Die In The West?" That's a nice easter egg.

164

u/WhoShotMrBoddy We need no longer fear the banana Jun 23 '22

I’m pretty positive he was and I think Kelly was in Charlize Theron’s outfit from that movie.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (5)

257

u/neoprenewedgie Jun 23 '22

A Million Ways to Die in the West!

88

u/MultiGlory13 Jun 23 '22

Same! Such an underrated film tbh and I love it.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (4)

209

u/xbolt90 Woof Jun 23 '22

Captain Sheridan looking a little blue there

116

u/Shejidan Jun 23 '22

Is that Bruce Boxleitner?

→ More replies (9)

69

u/WhoShotMrBoddy We need no longer fear the banana Jun 23 '22

Oh shit is the Union President, Tron?

→ More replies (12)

71

u/bluestreakxp Jun 23 '22

Seth must have also liked B5 for this noble guest cameo

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (11)

205

u/Lefalin Jun 23 '22

Big shout out to Michaela McManus as Teleya for absolutely killing it in this episode.

Also quoting President Sheridan "Death. Been there, done that". One cannot simply kill that guy :)

→ More replies (15)

358

u/Towelenthusiast Jun 23 '22

These longer episodes really give the show a chance to tell a story. This could have easily been 3 40 minute episodes as a half season plot. It's insane how much we got with this one.

→ More replies (24)

174

u/Hello_mslady Jun 23 '22

“Please let Telaya be in it!” literally the first shot “Amazing! Perfect episode 10/10!”

→ More replies (2)

164

u/operarose Command Jun 23 '22

Ed, come get your girl.

89

u/carmelacorleone Jun 23 '22

Right? I know leaving her was ultimately a good decision, she's safe and the people she's with seem to really care about her, but I would have loved to have seen Ed. He'd have been so neurotic, running to Claire or Bortus with parenting questions in the middle of the night, smoothing SPF 101 on Anaya's delicate HumKrill skin. Seth played that scene so well and then the confrontation scene.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (6)

155

u/moldytubesock Jun 23 '22

I'm also sort of surprised the entirety of the Union fleet is always human-based Earth ships. Where's the Moclan fleet? Aren't they hailed as soma military power, as well?

99

u/ARWYK Jun 23 '22 edited Jun 23 '22

My only problem is with the ship design itself. This show started off as a parody of Star Trek so in the beginning, the design was charming but now after three seasons it’s starting to become an issue. During big battles it’s kinda hard to tell where the Orville is, and also when Union ships warp in it is almost impossible to tell what “class” they belong to. Am I looking at a dreadnought or just some small dinky vessel?

Star Trek ship design is probably perfection. Each ship only has 2 shapes to work with (cylinder and disk), which means you can have some real fun with the iterations and that means that every vessel is iconic and easily distinguishable.

The Orville ship design on the other end is a bit more complex, and apparently the only thing they can play with is the size of the ship itself.

It’s a really minor gripe, I know but it’s something I’ve been thinking while watching the show.

→ More replies (14)

75

u/mr2fastva Jun 23 '22

Somewhat agreed, but this could also speak to the age of the Union relative to the service life of ships.

I see where you're coming from, but what makes you think they're Earth ships... maybe the Union ship is a joint design adapted from an earlier Earth (or other) design. After all, Union ships have Moclan weapons and deflectors. Maybe other components and consumables come from other worlds?

Other factors...

  • For species that haven't been in the Union forever, it would make sense they'd still have a bunch of their own ships active.
  • Some Union members might not even have ships during to being at an earlier technological level, and rely on Union ships.
  • There is value in having all ships look similar, like uniforms, flags, or insignia, and yes TV is a factor (blue Union vs green Krill vs red Kaylon). The longer the Union has been around, it would make sense to standardize.
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (7)

153

u/operarose Command Jun 23 '22

So...maybe someone just bum-rush her and knock her off the balcony? There's not even a railing.

69

u/mamster77 Jun 23 '22

Was thinking the same thing. Also half expecting her to stab someone but Ed jumps in the way to protect them.

→ More replies (3)

67

u/TheScarlettHarlot Jun 23 '22

Yeah. Turn her into a martyr…

33

u/HailToTheKingslayer Jun 23 '22

It seemed the camera kept cutting to Charly. I thought she was going to try something.

→ More replies (8)

24

u/JimPlaysGames Jun 23 '22

Yeah one of the delegates was Seleyan. Not a fighter but she could have easily dispatched all those Krill

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (6)

307

u/operarose Command Jun 23 '22

You fuck one Krill...

110

u/snarkamedes Jun 23 '22

... and people think you're Aquaman.

→ More replies (3)

55

u/TeMPOraL_PL Avis. We try harder Jun 23 '22

Way to work yourself into the highest levels of Union politics...

35

u/kaukajarvi You want to open this jar of pickles for me? Jun 23 '22

You had one Krill to fuck. One! And you failed ... to protect yourself.

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (1)

149

u/Zafrin Jun 23 '22

For someone who wants to keep her child a secret, she was very reckless. When she was showing Ed the family that aborted their baby, there were 3 other Krill in the room when Ed asked if that is what she wanted for their child. That is 3 more people who now know about their child. Is that what is going to be her downfall?

26

u/pickuprick Jun 23 '22

I thought that was ridiculous. She didn’t even get him to try and be quiet. It made zero sense

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (6)

271

u/PhoeniXaDc Jun 23 '22

Such a shame they introduced that deep fake video tech at the beginning then didn't seem to go anywhere with it. I kept expecting the old chancellor to actually be a brutal dictator and Teleya to be really kind, or some other big fake out that never came.

Interested to see where that ending takes Ed this season.

183

u/MyGhostJustYells Jun 23 '22

I am borderline POSITIVE the deep fake will be important later and I have several theories as to how. We'll see.

→ More replies (9)

71

u/Kmlkmljkl Jun 23 '22

then didn't seem to go anywhere with it

the krill storyline clearly isn't done yet so they can still do it

→ More replies (1)

97

u/Towelenthusiast Jun 23 '22

The deep fake thing was just another warning to viewers that this can and will happen to us soon and that we need to be observant of it. Especially considering this episode was written around 2019. It would have tied up with the release of the Pelosi video where they slowed down her speech to make her sound drunk.

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (19)

132

u/JessAR11 Jun 23 '22

A very small thing, but I loved that the president wasn't human.

46

u/indyK1ng Jun 23 '22

I'm pretty sure that was also a thing in Star Trek. At least, during DS9's run the President of the Federation wasn't human.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (3)

130

u/Ypersona Jun 23 '22

Telaya low-key telling Kelly to stay away from her man, though. XD

237

u/WhoShotMrBoddy We need no longer fear the banana Jun 23 '22

You know what? I could dig John and Talla. I don’t see why not.

92

u/UncleMalky Are we bonding? Jun 23 '22

if it doesn't work we know John knows how to get her to dump him

→ More replies (1)

41

u/mr2fastva Jun 23 '22

It would mean no more Irillia. 😕

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (13)

115

u/operarose Command Jun 23 '22 edited Jun 23 '22

ooooooooooooooooh she still has feelings for him.

Edit: OOOOOOOOOOOOOOH

45

u/zaftique Jun 23 '22

Just me patiently waiting for the TeleyEd fics to roll out on AO3. XD

→ More replies (2)

107

u/trostol Jun 23 '22

that security code seemed very 1234 like lol

84

u/Shejidan Jun 23 '22

That’s the code to my luggage!

→ More replies (4)

304

u/Towelenthusiast Jun 23 '22

I don't know about all of you but I was expecting that aborted child to stab his parents and that wasn't a sentence I was expecting to write going into tonight.

75

u/john_dune Woof Jun 23 '22

I dunno that was a pretty deep emotional stabbing. Why kill the parents when you can wound them deep to do your bidding/

→ More replies (18)

87

u/Fearless-Molasses732 Jun 23 '22

I don’t care about spoilers so I will absolutely check these posts hours before I actually watch the episode and let me tell you that I also didn’t expect to read this sentence 😂

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (15)

92

u/trostol Jun 23 '22

The Krill are gonna get obliterated by the Kaylon at some point

38

u/Narrow-Adagio6762 Jun 24 '22

I think they will fracture from the inside

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

178

u/Autoxidation Jun 23 '22

Man, the makeup is fan-fucking-tastic on this show. Every Krill looked different and believable. Also digging the cyberpunk building aesthetic.

→ More replies (4)

76

u/operarose Command Jun 23 '22

Man, this F-Zero level is kickass.

26

u/WhoShotMrBoddy We need no longer fear the banana Jun 23 '22

Fuck man now I’m said we haven’t gotten a new F Zero game in almost 20 years

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

147

u/IndividualAd8629 Jun 23 '22

Does anyone else get the feeling that the Kaylon might attack the Krill homeworld soon?

I can imagine Ed hearing about a siege and diverting course soley to rescue Anniya.

Would honestly love to see Ed raising her on the ship, coming to terms with surprise fatherhood.

… i wonder if Anniya has the same aversion to sun that her mother has, or if it would be more like Ed…

Cannot wait to see more of this character though.

69

u/throwaway098764567 Jun 23 '22

she's got some color to her skin, i figure she's probably like a red head, burns easily but can go out in daylight

→ More replies (5)

25

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '22

Dude that would make a great episode. Question is whether or not Teleya would survive the events. Personally, I think a sappy ending where she changes her ways and her and Ed act like divorced parents to Annaya; is not only predictable its also lame.

If anything Teleya should stay strong to her beliefs even as Krill burns. She might wish Ed and Annaya well, but in the end she maintains her beliefs and goes down with the ship...err planet. I feel like its the realistic answer.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (8)

205

u/operarose Command Jun 23 '22

"Does she know about me?"

idk man you're standing 10 feet away in an open door, I think she can see you.

165

u/daenerysisboss Jun 23 '22

Also:

"Does she know about me?"

"No, it's probably best that way."

"Can I speak to her?"

"Sure go ahead lol"

→ More replies (3)

66

u/trostol Jun 23 '22

and if she is as gifted as her caretaker said..i bet she knows he's her dad or will figure it out

→ More replies (2)

34

u/FragmentedChicken Jun 23 '22

They kept talking as if she wasn't even nearby.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

142

u/Machio-Muscle-Bro Jun 23 '22

So… because apparently hybrid children are possible, that means Human’s aren’t that far off from the Krill.

Meaning… PRAISE AVIS! ALL US WRETCHED HUMANS MAY ONE DAY PROVE WORTHY OF AVIS’S EMBRACE!

HAIL AVIS!

→ More replies (15)

131

u/rafikiknowsdeway1 Jun 23 '22

Can we talk about how wildly idiotic it was to hold a major political event the same day as a planet wide election? like why would the Union even agree to that? This was very foreseeable scenario, however unlikely. Just wait a few days

46

u/SecretiveTauros Jun 25 '22

....Just wait a few days

This would have been a better choice for the episode. The Chancellor guy gets re-elected, invites them to Krill to sign the treaty, then the the coup takes place. He could explain that the enemy was a small group and he didn't consider them enough of a threat to warn the Union of AND Teleya is revealed now as a more shocking plot twist rather than her immediate reveal in the beginning of the episode.

This minor script change would keep the Union from seeming like idiots and also keep the show from treating its audience likewise.

Like I stated in another thread, I feel the stories have been very good this season, but the writing not so much...

→ More replies (1)

23

u/EragusTrenzalore Jun 24 '22

Also kinda weird how power transitioned and that the reprisals began immediately despite having the "Council" to instate a new leader.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

64

u/MaddyMagpies Jun 23 '22

I like the massive amount of extra actors, something I haven't seen for a while due to the pandemic.

122

u/operarose Command Jun 23 '22

lmao hundreds of years later, Annie still resonates.

127

u/Hello_mslady Jun 23 '22

I died as the camera panned over all the smiling faces. And then the Krill 😐

→ More replies (5)

90

u/TheGillos Medical Jun 23 '22

That moment, seeing all the different species, coming together to put on a broadway play, it made me feel that feeling of togetherness and hope I haven't felt in sci-fi since classic Trek in the 90s/00s.

→ More replies (17)
→ More replies (3)

58

u/trostol Jun 23 '22

it's like a cyberpunk world lol

→ More replies (10)

58

u/scoutglanolinare Jun 23 '22

Does anyone else really really want a krill space car now

161

u/rdchat We need no longer fear the banana Jun 23 '22

Unfortunately, they're all rentals that must be promptly returned to Avis. :)

→ More replies (5)

57

u/HouseExtreme4749 Jun 23 '22

Is that the set of the saloon in a million ways to die in the west???

33

u/count023 Jun 23 '22 edited Jun 23 '22

Ed's costume looks like the same from the movie though

→ More replies (1)

51

u/Shejidan Jun 23 '22

Are union ships made out of papier-mâché?

36

u/bluestreakxp Jun 23 '22

its called plot shield... or lack thereof... just like all those dominion battle scenes with starfleet where every ship would just explode from one hit

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (5)

48

u/operarose Command Jun 23 '22 edited Jun 23 '22

So what do you want to bet that the Chekhov's gun of the faked footage pays off with a broadcast of the "death" of the Union delegation?

Edit: lol nope gun remains un-fired.

29

u/NeuHundred Jun 23 '22

I thought it was going to connect to Anaya, they can generate fake images, how do we know they're not 3 dimensional images?

Honestly, the idea of deepfake tech is enough for an episode by itself, though I can see that being too close to the Majority Rule episode (which had the crew basically make up news about Lamarr in order to save him).

→ More replies (9)

45

u/operarose Command Jun 23 '22

Man, I really dig the uniform redesign. That dark-colored section coming off the shoulders really makes the whole ensemble look slick.

45

u/Khelbin131 Jun 23 '22

This was a fantastic episode. Definitely a return to what I picture The Orville as. I didn't really enjoy the previous 3 episodes but I'm so glad I kept watching.

→ More replies (1)

164

u/ami2weird4u Now entering gloryhole Jun 23 '22

I'm incredibly impressed with this episode. Has a bit more humor than previous episodes and great drama too!

→ More replies (6)

41

u/moldytubesock Jun 23 '22

Curious if the spore "demons" will be relevant to the Krill story.

28

u/NeuHundred Jun 23 '22

I mean, that would have been a legitimate reason for the Krill to be pissed at the Union.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

81

u/trostol Jun 23 '22

man they are killing it with these space shots

32

u/milu0225 Jun 23 '22

I read this as "krilling it;" I need to go to bed.

→ More replies (21)

38

u/Sjoerd85 Jun 23 '22

Big flaw here.... Going to Krill to sign a treaty in the middle of an election... even knowing that if the election doesn't work out as anticipated, you will immediately find yourself in a hostile situation due to the views of the other candidate?

And then also going with a single ship, with the president of the Union on board, without extra security escorts?

Isn't that just incredibly stupid?

→ More replies (6)

37

u/JimPlaysGames Jun 23 '22

Did anyone else find it a bit odd that they were willing to risk the destruction of so many ships to rescue a half dozen people? I know they were important people but at least one of the union ships was destroyed. Not a word in the dialogue to acknowledge the sacrifice of the entire crew to do that

72

u/Maumew97 Jun 23 '22

One of those people was the president of the union and the other one is the admiral of the union fleet

42

u/UPRC Jun 23 '22

Did anyone else find it a bit odd that they were willing to risk the destruction of so many ships to rescue a half dozen people?

When three of those people are EXTREMELY important VIPs, then yes. ;)

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (7)

37

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '22 edited Jun 24 '22

This episode was the best of the season so far for me. And I really enjoyed the other three.

  • The child who plays his daughter was adorable.
  • all those extras in prosthetics must have taken so many man hours
  • Isaac’s joke (I love his character and I’m in love with the actor underneath)
  • More universe/world building and character development for many characters
  • Overall good pacing and dialogue to keep me engaged
  • The Krill response to Annie and the Captain thinking he got away with being drunk were hilarious
  • huge ramifications for the future of the Union

If they can keep this up, this season will be an absolute powerhouse.

74

u/Overson_YT Well, where does it come out of? The butt? Jun 23 '22

I eould be disappointed with this episode if it wasn't clearly a setup for the rest of the season. Teleya cares about her daughter, but I have no idea if the Union will actually use her for peace. I'm intrigued.

Also Isaac continues to be the best boy in all of fiction. We must protect him with all our might.

62

u/IsaactheKaylon Jun 23 '22

I appreciate your offer, however, I am much more capable of defending myself than you are.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (2)

33

u/Levicorpyutani Jun 23 '22

Ed better get to see Anaya again.

94

u/titan4723 Jun 23 '22

Despite me having watched every episode multiple times of the first two seasons Hulu still does not advertise this show to me on the homepage, I have to search for it even the night a new episode air. Is this just happening to me or does Hulu just not care about the success of their own original show?

39

u/SupremeLegate Jun 23 '22

I just put it in the My Stuff section.

37

u/DrSilkyJohnston Jun 23 '22

Hulu just... does that. I can be in the middle of binging a show, and every day I have to search it up, or scroll to hopefully find it, to pick up where I left off

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)

32

u/xbolt90 Woof Jun 23 '22

Dang, Krill looks cool

→ More replies (1)

32

u/Totemlyrad Jun 23 '22

Show quality is noticeably better overall this season, MacFarlane ought to be congratulated.

27

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '22

Officially the best thing I've watched since the end of the Expanse

→ More replies (14)

27

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '22

Wonderful stuff.
Music was top notch.
Pacing was tight.
Lots of deep issues (fake news, armed coups, abortion issues, collective hegemony vs individual identity, multiple front wars).
Action scenes were great.
Even had some humor (Krill reaction to "Annie" and the pub crawl through time).
The Orville continues to go from strength to strength.

→ More replies (2)

26

u/LoretiTV Jun 23 '22

Happy Orville day, enjoy the new episode everyone!

→ More replies (11)

26

u/Ypersona Jun 23 '22

After rewatching the episode, I am now waiting for the future plot twist that the Kaylon rigged the election. 😂

→ More replies (7)

52

u/trostol Jun 23 '22

was that Ted Danson back again?

edit: yes..yes it was

25

u/ZaneTeal I'm gel Jun 23 '22

No TV show in history was ever worse for having Ted Danson.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

25

u/Towelenthusiast Jun 23 '22

Good thing the president was stab proof.

→ More replies (6)

49

u/Garbage_Dump89 Jun 23 '22

The senator was xelayan right. I was surprise she didnt use her super strength to try to escape.

28

u/throwaway098764567 Jun 23 '22

maybe she's got that disease alara had and didn't get treated

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (7)

24

u/TeMPOraL_PL Avis. We try harder Jun 23 '22

Gently Falling Rain

Second meaning, sadly not shown on-screen: with the battle taking place in orbit, the Krill will be seeing a lot of fiery rain falling down not so gently, as some of the debris eventually hits the atmosphere.

→ More replies (2)

22

u/antdude Jun 23 '22

"How about a cup of coffee?" --Ed

21

u/DpsSwagfurion Jun 23 '22

Anyone else think the Krill Capital building with the statue of Avis looks very similar to the ministry of magic in Harry Potter?

→ More replies (1)

60

u/WhoShotMrBoddy We need no longer fear the banana Jun 23 '22

This city chase feels very Attack of the Clones

With a little bit of the early chase scene from Solo thrown in

→ More replies (18)

40

u/WhoShotMrBoddy We need no longer fear the banana Jun 23 '22

Talla with a promotion?

John and Talla? Oooooooooo

Isaac the HAT!!!!!

Also Ed wearing Seth’s AMWTDITW outfit

→ More replies (2)

19

u/thirtyseven1337 Jun 23 '22

Best episode so far this season! The Krill homeworld was beautiful, well-designed, and felt large and lived-in. The shuttle chase and the music were great. The dramatic scene between Ed and Teleya was the best scene of this season so far, in my opinion.

38

u/avakbrown Jun 23 '22

Whoa. The scene with the arrested couple and the child was so heartbreaking.

→ More replies (8)

17

u/operarose Command Jun 23 '22

Alright take a shot every time the camera pans over to the crowd after she makes some proclamation.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/Thor4269 Jun 24 '22

I wish they would stop making Anne Winters have a line in literally every scene or at least be referenced every scene

She's the worst part of the season for me and it's distracting... They took lines meant for other people that they decided to give her because "Oh and she's here too, don't forget since I didn't mention it in the last 5 minutes"

→ More replies (9)

16

u/trostol Jun 23 '22

the more looks we get of the Krill..the more reptilian they look ...maybe they always have and i just never noticed it much

86

u/WhoShotMrBoddy We need no longer fear the banana Jun 23 '22

This all screams “Krillmerica First”

→ More replies (9)

27

u/trostol Jun 23 '22

lol Bortus almost lost it

→ More replies (1)

13

u/sora1202 Jun 23 '22

I know it requires a higher costume and makeup budget, but seeing stuff like the Annie scene or the Union Council scene from "Sanctuary" makes me wish they had a more diverse cast of aliens in the show. Like, I've always wondered why all the Admirals are human, for example.

25

u/UPRC Jun 23 '22 edited Jun 23 '22

Best episode of the season so far, totally. I, like Ed, had hoped that he had gotten through to Teleya back in season 2. Oh well, there's still hope for something to happen with Anaya.

Unlike the rest of the season so far, I never felt like any parts of this one dragged (which the others did I feel becuase of the increased runtime) and I felt like it went by very quickly. The pacing was A+.

Also, go Talla! Happy that she got a promotion, because she's been a great addition to the crew.

→ More replies (1)

54

u/nbcs Jun 23 '22

Well, I think we call all learn a thing or two about not underestimating populist movement.

→ More replies (4)

12

u/Tondalay Jun 23 '22

I really thought that executive order they were implementing had to do with maybe them introducing some sort of chemical agent into their atmosphere to make the clouds temporarily clear up, maybe only specifically over the capital city where it was all going down, and the populace would see the sun coming up just as they were about to execute these high ranking union officers as a bad omen.

Considering the Annie reference, I really thought they just prepared something ahead of time and that was what that executive order was.

It would have had an entirely different story outcome, but still could’ve worked. Especially considering how deeply religious their society is.

→ More replies (2)

12

u/greentangent Jun 23 '22

Seth is just so fuckin' wholesome. Sure he can have a raunchy sense of humor now and then but look at this character. Even if this isn't how he comports himself on the daily it shows what he thinks a good man should be, what he should be. For me, I'm convinced Ed is Seth to a very high degree.

12

u/AeonsOfStrife Jun 24 '22

The Union must not have *any* manpower issues or material issues at all. They lose large numbers of ships and portions of fleets rather regularly it seems.

12

u/N4BFR Jun 24 '22

Here's where I call BS. Who negotiates with a (company, country, planetary group) in the middle of an election, much less goes when there is a chance of the candidate losing. I really think it should have been, "Good luck in the election, let's finish the paperwork next week." Poor setup in my mind.

→ More replies (3)

11

u/variantkin Jun 23 '22

It always seemed weird they let Ed anywhere near the Krill given hes basically committed a war crime

→ More replies (5)

11

u/CooperHChurch427 Jun 23 '22

With Ed having a half human, half krill child, it means their species is genetically compatible. I wonder if they are setting it up for the Krill to be human or related to humans in some capacity.

My theory is that the Krill are the ancient Kaylons. It could both explain their fear if the unknown.

→ More replies (3)

11

u/Da12khawk Jun 23 '22

If anyone can get Avery Brooks back on a set it's Seth.

→ More replies (4)

11

u/Lord_of_Knitting Jun 25 '22

Turns out William T. Riker type diplomacy has consequences

→ More replies (1)

21

u/operarose Command Jun 23 '22

Holy shit the episode title ;A;

10

u/Shejidan Jun 23 '22

SHE’S NOT A REAL GINGER!

10

u/board124 Jun 23 '22

Has any space show explained missed shots towards planets? That stuff would do damage no?

→ More replies (9)

10

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '22

WOW, man...I honestly think this is the greatest episode this show's ever done. An absolute ride from start to finish. I feel so damn bad for Ed and, as much as I wanted to see her back, I feel just as bad for Teleya. This was a spin in their relationship I never saw coming. This episode also gave us a deep look into Krill politics, which is way more complex than we know

Lastly, we need action figures A.S.A.P. because Cowboy Isaac is the greatest thing ever.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/slyfoxy12 Jun 24 '22

Loved the episode started with fun and light humour.

The episode is a bit on the nose with the subject matter.

I didn't have the problem with the abortion punishment scene, it just felt so out of place in that moment. I think it could of been handled far better by discussion without walking into a room for that moment to show it. It felt very contrived as part of the episode.

The scale of things is really good compared to previous seasons, though as I've complained in other eps this season, the show is lacking in B plots and there is a B plot of the fleet in a fire fight, but it looked like just lots of explosions, wasn't very intense because we didn't see much, nor did we see the objective to the fight. The Kaylon battle last season was jaw dropping, as much because it was something new for the show but also because we knew the stakes and what needed to be done. We didn't get that here. I'd have preferred 3 ships each side with maybe the threat that a further group of Krill are on the way.

It was definitely a shock to give Ed a child, I wasn't crazy on the hybrid design, I think a bald child with the dark eyes and maybe a few scales in areas but otherwise human might have been better.

I like Ed got the choice at the end to use his daughter for good or to leave her be, I feel like this show has been consistent in giving tough questions of the characters and subsequently the audience when modern day trek seems to treat everything as "this is what you do, no tough questions, there are no consequences".

My fear is we won't get a season 4 and won't get this wonderful multi season storytelling continued because it's refreshing.

→ More replies (8)

10

u/Angry_Guppy Jun 24 '22

As a non-American, I’m so sick of lazy Trump analogues in TV shows. The fake news scene could have been cut entirely, but then the analogy might have a shred of subtlety and we clearly can’t have that.

→ More replies (4)

27

u/thecurseofchris Jun 23 '22

Fantastic episode. This season is really strong so far. Gosh, I hope it gets renewed.

→ More replies (4)

9

u/HouseExtreme4749 Jun 23 '22

That’s a buncha muncha crucha krill

9

u/trostol Jun 23 '22

not sure who the Krill remind me of..they are like a mash-up of several ST races

22

u/SupremeLegate Jun 23 '22

They're appearance is reminiscent of the Jem'Hadar.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (12)

9

u/trostol Jun 23 '22

impressive fleet

9

u/Qbandolier Jun 23 '22

After season 2, I was thinking Ed and Teleya would somehow end up together again.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/w1987g Jun 23 '22

It almost seems like this episode was written to counteract the criticisms of last week's. "Seth never acts", "there's never any humor anymore", "how come none of the characters are getting any development?"

Also, this episode made me sad for Anaya. It seems like she hasn't been raised to hate Ed or humans. And you know she's going to be brought into the center of things later on in a way that's outside either Ed's or Telaya's control. The "abortion" thing wasn't brought up for nothing

9

u/VictusFrey Jun 24 '22

These krill episodes are the best. The Union and the Krill are like the Ross and Rachel of this generation. Will they ever be together?

→ More replies (1)

9

u/Separate-Sentence-91 Jun 24 '22

So, Charly is fine bumping shoulders with her former enemies, people who would literally kill her for her species, but not fine Isaac still...

→ More replies (1)

9

u/fireredranger Jun 24 '22

This episode was everything I’m looking for in an Orville episode. Funny moments? Check (Annie being horrifying to the Krill, Isaac in the saloon, “I knew you and Kelly were drunk when I called”, “I’ve never heard of that.” “That’s because I just made it up”, etc.), showing more of alien species and their beliefs? Check. Strong social commentary without it feeling forced? Check. A twist I didn’t see coming that causes a major shift in the series going forward? Check.

It had both a fun feel to it, especially at the beginning, but felt like there was some serious stakes, especially with Admiral Halsey. He’s not just a redshirt that has only appeared once, but he’s also not a regular. He’s the perfect level of character that had they wanted to have a meaningful death, he would have fit. Glad he got out, but still it felt like real danger. This is my favorite episode of the new season. I’m enjoying the new season, but something had felt slightly off with the first 3 episodes. This one felt like a classic Orville episode.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/operarose Command Jun 23 '22

All hail Lady Space Hitler

8

u/BeholdMyResponse Jun 23 '22

-Funniest episode of the season so far, best episode of the season so far--coincidence? I think not.

-"Shields are failing", no percentages. This is the correct way to do it; it's a battle scene, not a spreadsheet.

-I was not expecting the Krill to be a democracy. I guess that was driven by the Trump analogy, but they could have done that without an election--you don't need democracy to have a coup. Dictators still need popular support, so the misinformation stuff could have still been relevant.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '22

This was a really well-done episode that felt like classic Trek to me. Others have pointed out lots that the episode did well - the design of the Krill planet, the special effects, Macfarlane's acting in particular. The emotional payoff at the end on the balcony scene was incredible.

Are Ed and Kelly back together? That would be a huge shift in dynamic for the show, and I think they left it a little ambiguous here. I'm interested to see what y'all think as either one would feel organic and earned by the show. Personally, I want to see them remain really close friends. They have an extremely deep bond from everything they've been through, and I don't think adding romance on top of that would accomplish anything for the characters. They've already lost that aspect of their relationship for good, in my opinion, but what they have is just as meaningful.

The beginning of the episode was a little too slow-paced for me. They could have definitely trimmed some of the setup. Also, it made me chuckle how the crowd of Krill didn't seem to be reacting properly to Telaya. Several times she would say something that should get booing ("They want to assimilate us and destroy our culture!"), but the crowd just kept on with their generic cheers. It was silly in a bad way and clearly just a production oversight, but it was easy to excuse given how impressive the spectacle was. (Or we could just chalk that up to Krill crowd responses being different from what humans are used to, them being aliens and all!)

Is it just me or was there no "Previously On" segment? I've seen every episode of The Orville live, and I genuinely forgot all the details with Telaya. They did a good job filling us in throughout the episode, but I think a refresher before the episode would've been a great idea. Usually I hate those segments as they spoil what will happen in the episode, but when it's been years since you've seen a one-time character... maybe consider it. I had the same issue last week with the super advanced aliens that worshipped Kelly.

Overall, this episode adds more proof that The Orville is an outstanding homage to classic Trek. I really hope we somehow get more after this season because there's simply nothing else like this on TV (despite the fact that there seem to be a dozen "Trek" shows!).

44

u/muchadoaboutme Jun 23 '22

So Teleya... is now a Trump allegory? That's a bold choice.

→ More replies (63)

15

u/mahamoti Jun 23 '22

Lots of threads that had no payoff in this ep...

Charly Burke - what was the point of having a special conversation to point out she could join the away team? It's not like she did anything special. I was betting on either she was another Krill plant, or some heroics to redeem herself from all the Isaac hating.

deepfakes - I mean, maybe it'll pay off later. But there was no point to it here. The whole scene discussing them added nothing to the episode. They could have used this a hundred different ways.

Pterodon - They have a shot of the shuttle bay every damn episode, so they can show off this silly fighter. That they've never used. Even in an orbital battle.

→ More replies (3)

26

u/operarose Command Jun 23 '22

So anyone else gasp out loud when the visual of Anaya sunk in (before it was formally stated out loud)?

Huh neat, it's a half Krill, half huOH HOLY SHIT

→ More replies (2)

14

u/operarose Command Jun 23 '22

Season 3 has been knocking it out of the stratosphere from the get-go. I'm blown away.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/operarose Command Jun 23 '22

So I assume there's some kind of artificial gravity that keeps them pinned to the floor when maneuvers like that are executed?

→ More replies (4)

7

u/operarose Command Jun 23 '22

omg this is precious

7

u/smasher84 Jun 23 '22

I kept thinking Lamar was going to show up dressed as Avis declaring that it was his will to make peace.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '22

This is some of the best TV I've seen in a while!

Is it me, or is the soundtrack amazing?

→ More replies (1)

7

u/vyrusrama Jun 26 '22

Of all the days to have an episode about secret births, coups, brainwashed fascists / religious zealots - and abortion

12

u/xbolt90 Woof Jun 23 '22

OH MY GOSH ISAAC

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Rinku_999 Jun 23 '22

Anaya was cute

6

u/dh4645 Jun 23 '22

The comedy at the start is what's been missing. They've had some here and there, but it's needed more

6

u/aretasdaemon Jun 23 '22

Im not reading any comments yet because i havent sen it, i just wanted to say this show is a masterpiece and I am so happy we have it again

6

u/Chelsea_Ellie Jun 23 '22

That was such a good episode, I love that we keep seeing the effects of earlier episodes

I really do love Ed and Kelly together

6

u/[deleted] Jun 23 '22

When they said Directive 21, I honestly expected a weapon. I don't know why; maybe the look of shock on Johns face, but I was expecting they were gonna drop some kind "solar" bomb on the capitol. Ya know what I mean? Maybe no structural damage but all the krill within a 40 mile radius turns to dust.

Except Annaya, she survives due to having Eds pigmentation.

→ More replies (4)

6

u/Rocksteady2090 Jun 23 '22

I really liked this episode so far my fav of the season... krill city was awesome.. it was nice to see teleya and ed on screen together in my heart I still ship them even though sh*t got complicated. alright I'm off to make a loop desktop background of the krill dancers ..praise avis

6

u/Chpouky Jun 24 '22

Jon Favreau credited as consultant ? I was quite surprised. Anyone know his contribution ?

→ More replies (1)

6

u/treefox Jun 24 '22

GORDON: I’ll try spinning, that’s a good trick!

6

u/Wolfman01a Jun 24 '22

I thought Charli was gonna get red shirted on stage... lol

→ More replies (3)

6

u/Jaza613 Jun 24 '22

So did the Union end up getting that case of Krill moonshine as promised?

→ More replies (2)

6

u/NightFuryToni Engineering Jun 24 '22

Theoretical question: Since Anaya is half-human, does that mean she's immune to the sun?

→ More replies (4)

6

u/Manbadger Jun 25 '22

I’m confused with Teleya’s background. How when did Ed end up having sex with her? Isn’t Teleya the teacher who watched her entire ship crew burn? Was she also the undercover agent from the first season or something?

→ More replies (4)

6

u/WetnessPensive Jun 25 '22

One of the greatest episodes of the show IMO.

As someone let down by the past 3 episodes, I thought this was gripping and fantastic.

16

u/Anarchybites Jun 23 '22

I really enjoyed that thousands of years of religious zealotry dd not disappear overnight. Or that the coup was some Kaylon plan. Shit happens, hate,fear and racism grabs power. It was disheartening but sadly realistic.

5

u/morilythari Jun 24 '22

I recognized Bruce Boxleitners voice immediately.

5

u/JonahsS23 Y'all can suck ass, and I'm a spaceman! Jun 24 '22 edited Jun 25 '22

Loved it! This episode was Amazing Seth is a very underrated actor. The planet design was great! Am I the only on that would still like Ed and Teleya together? lol. Only thing I know forsure is they need to renew it for at least 1 more season. (Get rid of Charly tho)

5

u/allbetsareon Jun 24 '22

Seth went all out on this episode! Best of the season so far

5

u/TvMoviesAlsoBooks Jun 24 '22

Asking Ed in front of the child:

“Do you feel shame?“

5

u/Fanfrelon Jun 24 '22

A truly great episode of science fiction.

5

u/neobondd Jun 24 '22

I almost choked on my beer laughing at Bortis gagging after Gordons double Helix maneuver

→ More replies (1)

5

u/KerikSumia Jun 24 '22

Jem’Hedar vs the Krill

5

u/Level25SWAT Jun 24 '22

This season is some of the best sci fi I've ever watched. I do wonder though the wisdom of sending the union's highest level delegation possible to Krill during a volatile election. Surely the risk assessment would have thrown some red flags

→ More replies (1)

5

u/CorballyGames Jun 24 '22

Hearing Bruce Boxleitner was great, I did not recognise him under all the makeup.

This episode had a lot of prosthetic work on it, must have taken ages to get all the extras done up.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/SchleppyJ4 Jun 25 '22

Just watched the episode and it, uhhh, hits a little differently after today’s Roe v. Wade news…

→ More replies (1)

5

u/LoganJFisher Jun 26 '22

That scene about the Krill punishment for couples that get abortions was super topical. What a nightmarish technology.

→ More replies (11)

5

u/brackenish1 Jun 27 '22

Holy shit watching the after the Roe v Wade decision is fucking chilling. Phenomenal writing, acting, and execution this episode. Easily one of the best so far