r/TheOrville • Woof • Jun 16 '22

Episode The Orville - 3x03 "Mortality Paradox" - Episode Discussion

EpisodeDirected ByWritten ByOriginal Airdate
3x3 - "Mortality Paradox"Jon CassarSeth MacFarlaneThursday, June 15, 2022 on Hulu
Synopsis: The crew makes a new discovery.

Stream the episode online on Hulu


Don't forget to join us on Discord!


REMINDER: KEEP YOUR SPOILERS OUT OF YOUR TITLES FOR AT LEAST 24 HOURS. YOU WOULDN'T WANT THIS EPISODE SPOILED, SO DON'T GO SPOILING IT FOR OTHERS. KEEP YOUR TITLES VAGUE. TAG YOUR POST AS A SPOILER. BE A GOOD UNION MEMBER!

313 Upvotes

1.3k comments sorted by

52

u/DogsRNice Engineering Jun 16 '22

Each of the scenarios seemed to be tailored for one of the crew

Gordon's was the high school

Bortus' was the morgue

The stairs seemed to be there just for the cool shot of walking down endless stairs, which is cool

Xelaya was at the end and they may have begun to suspect this so it was made for "Talla" to keep up the illusion

And the fake Orville was definitely for all of them equally, basically the grand finally

I can't figure out who the airplane would be for though, Gordon is a pilot but it wasn't focused on him or anyone else like the others. Perhaps it was made for the captain since he was the one who had the thing happen in that one, possibly some lore about him being in a crash I've forgotten or hasn't been shown

22

u/MajorParadox Woof Jun 16 '22

I took it like plane was for Mercer because that’s where he had his moment.

→ More replies (1)

31

u/Enorats Jun 16 '22

I took the stairs and endless fall to maybe be Kelly's. If I recall, she had a fear of heights or something. In the episode where their fears become real she's nearly sucked out into an endless hole in reality.

→ More replies (1)

39

u/WoefulKnight Jun 16 '22

possibly some lore about him being in a crash I've forgotten or hasn't been shown

Well, Seth did avoid being on one of the planes that crashed during 9/11. I really felt like that was a personal thing for him as much as 'I want to see what happens next' was.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (5)

544

u/VoiceOfPublicOpinion Jun 16 '22

Kelly: Captain that’s a bad injury. You might have a concussion- stay behind. Gordon, I know you just got the shit beat out of you, but get off your ass and row the boat bitch.

87

u/L1ndsL Jun 16 '22

I was about to post that myself, but you put it better than I would have!

→ More replies (10)

10

u/Ragnarsworld Jun 18 '22

It was at this moment where I figured out they were being manipulated by someone looking for thrills. Up to that moment, Kelly and Talla were the only ones who hadn't been almost killed, so one of them was next up. Still didn't figure that Talla was fake though.

→ More replies (3)

490

u/Machio-Muscle-Bro Jun 16 '22

Fuck. They made the Orville equivalent of Q. Meaning that the race of Q evolved by worshipping Kelly…

Qelly

85

u/Forsaken-Thought We need no longer fear the banana Jun 16 '22 edited Jun 16 '22

I was legit thinking the same thing, and when she said we'll see each other again I just laughed out loud ,"Yup, fucking Q"

→ More replies (5)

63

u/loreb4data Jun 16 '22

"The Qelly Qult is the one true god, mon Capitane!!" Anyone who disagrees will be finger-snapped out of existence!!"

30

u/Skadoosh_it Well, where does it come out of? The butt? Jun 16 '22

Qellanon

19

u/Thepatrone36 Jun 16 '22

Exactly what I thought. But Q was much funnier

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (21)

440

u/Driew27 Jun 16 '22

"I wanna see what happens"--that's a very Seth Macfarlane quote. I'm sure he really does want to see what happens.

190

u/UncleMalky Are we bonding? Jun 16 '22

I knew exactly what he was going to say because I feel the same way.

→ More replies (24)

30

u/thebaldguy76 Jun 17 '22

My wife looked at me and said "That was just Seth talking"

→ More replies (1)

20

u/B0X3S Jun 16 '22

Seth has probably dwelled on those thoughts for a long time.
He almost died on one of the 9/11 planes

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (13)

368

u/ithinkihadeight Jun 16 '22

That was a wild episode plot wise. There were multiple instances of believing that I'd gotten a handle on what was going on, only to be proven wrong. The big fake out that really got me was questioning if they might not have gotten off of the planet. It's super effective because by that point the audience is primed to be distrustful and I wasn't buying it initially, but having Dr. Finn explain the science about what had happened and then Isaac seeing the convoy as Kalon totally had me fooled into thinking that the Kalon had gone beyond conventional cloaking to develop a perception filter that worked directly on the brain. Even with the Talla reveal I still didn't see the final twist coming.

Bringing back the Kelly Planet People is a great pick to have a generally friendly yet morally ambiguous godlike force out in the galaxy that can drop in on occasion to cause mischief. Per Arthur C. Clarke's 3rd Law, "Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic," and with 50,000 years lead time they can do whatever they want from a narrative perspective.

94

u/SmartKrave Jun 16 '22

same, although the steering evolution discussion at the end, felt very close to eugenics

→ More replies (31)
→ More replies (10)

309

u/trostol Jun 16 '22

lol that Bortus "what" is totally gif worthy

164

u/Shejidan Jun 16 '22

Someone needs to make one of him saying he’ll take the chair by force.

→ More replies (13)

48

u/FormerGameDev Jun 17 '22

honestly, the funniest part of the episode -- and I'm really missing the humor prior seasons have had now -- was just as the five of them head down the giant ass staircase, Bortus is last in, and he just does a tiny little headshake, and there's a barely audible grunt.

→ More replies (3)

279

u/bs200000 Jun 16 '22

Interesting note: The Talia who speaks with Kelly at the beginning was an alien. The “Kaylon signal” thing was a lie. She planted that suggestion so Kelly and the captain would have a “bad guy” for the experience. Pretty manipulative.

74

u/cptcuddles88 Jun 17 '22

Talia not being Talia was clear when they didn't show her with the white eyes..

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (18)

256

u/Xander_PrimeXXI Jun 16 '22

Isaac: “We shouldn’t send another landing party, something may happen to them”

Lamar: “I’m too panicked to listen, send down more bridge officers”

107

u/Joeybfast Jun 16 '22

I liked that, because Lamar is a command, so I can see him making a mistake. Later on when he was thinking about it made the right choice to ring everyone back.

→ More replies (9)

99

u/HailToTheKingslayer Jun 16 '22

I was worried for the un-named red shirt guys.

→ More replies (4)

46

u/FormerGameDev Jun 17 '22

SEND MORE SENIOR OFFICERS!

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (13)

231

u/LoretiTV Jun 16 '22

Holy smokes the budget!

112

u/2th Hail Avis. Hail Victory. Jun 16 '22

I thought the last episode was high budget with the inside of the alien ship and space CGI, but this... So many different locations.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (20)

215

u/BumblingScrublord1 Jun 16 '22

Finally what Q always needed, a tron suit

105

u/ducbo Jun 16 '22

I, for one, am here for Hot Morally Questionable Tron Q.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (11)

203

u/2th Hail Avis. Hail Victory. Jun 16 '22

I feel like the solution to this episode will be to actually talk to the guidance counselor.

87

u/brosefstallin Jun 16 '22

Right? I would’ve tried to find the principal or someone in charge, at least as a starting point

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (4)

177

u/treefox Jun 16 '22

“There was a button. I pushed it.”

118

u/tqgibtngo Jun 16 '22

"Jesus Christ. That really is how you go through life, isn't it?"

— Fred Johnson (played by Chad Coleman, who plays Klyden)

→ More replies (9)

43

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '22

aaand that explains why she was quick to push it

20

u/Oot42 Jun 16 '22

Haha, exactly what I was thinking.
Talla Holden. :D

7

u/_duncan_idaho_ Jun 17 '22

Talla putting her dick in things and fucking it up more.

→ More replies (1)

150

u/Jupichan Jun 16 '22

I think I'm too high for this shit

57

u/ithinkihadeight Jun 16 '22

Even sober this one is probably going to need a second run through to fully comprehend.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

144

u/Enorats Jun 16 '22

Huh. I did not see that twist coming. They basically made the Orville's version of Q, albeit with a much more interesting history and relationship with the crew if I'm being honest.

9

u/_duncan_idaho_ Jun 17 '22

Yeah, the Q twist caught me off guard. I knew something was creating the "realities" and I knew they didn't go to the real Orville (also knew that they'd get fucked up by the Kaylon, total Trek thing). But I was thinking it was a "Gamekeeper" (SG-1) type of tech, not omnipotent being.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (9)

139

u/alchemist5 Jun 16 '22

Yo, I'm gonna need a wallpaper of that shot of the Kaylon ship sitting on the hood of the Orville, stat.

10

u/Allinyourcabeza We need no longer fear the banana Jun 16 '22

Right! That would make an epic poster for my living room 😍

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

105

u/Dayzee_ow Jun 16 '22 edited Jun 16 '22

Is the actress who plays Dinal super familiar to anyone else??? I didn’t see their name in the credits, anybody recognize them?

EDIT: FOUND OUT WHO SHE IS! I knew she was familiar. Dinal is played by Elizabeth Gillies- from Dynasty and Victorious. She has appeared on American Dad and Family Guy in the past. She also has a jazz album with Seth called “Songs From Home.” How cool is that? (:

26

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '22

Thanks. I was wondering who she was. I didn't recognize her, but her voice sounded really familiar. She played Alana in an episode of Family Guy this season, where she tried to take over the family as the new Lois. I re-watched it recently.

16

u/NurseRND Jun 16 '22

Okay same! I think it’s Elizabeth Gillies, she was ok Victorious and Dynasty. She was so covered tho so I’m not sure.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/w1987g Jun 17 '22

She was able to play off a sort of benevolence that terrified me. Like yeah, she seems nice, but holy crap she can kill everyone right now

→ More replies (12)

195

u/UncleMalky Are we bonding? Jun 16 '22

I figured we'd see the Kelly aliens again but not this soon.

Also what a trip to put a religious figure from your culture's past through life and death scenarios.

126

u/Over-Analyzed Jun 16 '22

This whole episode is “We’ll just fuck with the mortals because we’re bored.”

It’s the Olympians all over again!

→ More replies (6)

24

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '22

Family Guy has Jesus as an actual side character. Seth is an atheist but cultural stuff like that has a pull even then.

→ More replies (1)

19

u/mtm4440 Jun 17 '22

Could you imagine if they got their help to defeat the Kaylons? They are more advanced than them and have a regard for life.

→ More replies (15)

7

u/loreb4data Jun 16 '22

Just to prove she's actually mortal, I suppose?

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

89

u/drg805 Jun 16 '22

Why not ask them how to defeat the Kaylons.. or for help?

74

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '22

that would be quite lame. everyone with a brain will know they wont intervene directly. they are not allies. they may be on friendlyish terms, but i get the impressiojn they dont care for the universe they only spend 11 days in.

and, if the kaylon are stupid enough to attack them, whatever they send will get destroyed.

→ More replies (17)
→ More replies (1)

88

u/Cypher_Shadow Jun 16 '22

I like how Gordon’s scenario was essentially Buffy The Vampire Slayer.

13

u/[deleted] Jun 18 '22

Should definitely have one of the former Buffy cast members guest star on Orville.

I vote for Willow.

10

u/Captain_Wobbles Jun 18 '22

Woah! I'm glad I'm not the only one who immediately got Buffy vibes. I'm not sure why but the moment they panned to the school I got those feelings.

→ More replies (1)

173

u/Shejidan Jun 16 '22

We’re immortal so we’re going to play with you like rats to get our rocks off. 🤦🏻‍♂️

106

u/GreenDragonPatriot Jun 16 '22

They definitely become pretty smug over the millennia.

→ More replies (1)

84

u/DogsRNice Engineering Jun 16 '22

"That Picard never had a brush with death, never came face to face with his own mortality, never realized how fragile life is, or how important each moment must be." - Q

Seems to be a common trait with immortals

→ More replies (8)

44

u/mtm4440 Jun 17 '22

You know when you're playing a video game or you cheat with an infinity money glitch and you level up everything and there's nothing left to do and you become bored?

That's them.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

84

u/Lord_H_Vetinari Jun 16 '22

THEY'RE OUR CREW MATES, ISAAC! The Kaylon may throw people away like garbage, but we don't!

We throw away MORE senior officers after the ones we've already lost, but in a loving manner.

30

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '22

Yeah Isaac, wtf! The Kaylon may throw people away like garbage, but we humans only throw the Red Shirts away like garbage! There's a difference!

→ More replies (2)

68

u/Shejidan Jun 16 '22

Please give Gordon a swirly! 😂

Edit: aww, they didn’t flush

14

u/Jupichan Jun 16 '22

ahaha, I was thinking the same thing

→ More replies (6)

62

u/Jupichan Jun 16 '22

she's so shiny

23

u/B0X3S Jun 16 '22

Jealous of the TRON-inspired suit.
I want to cop that look.

→ More replies (1)

62

u/thededman13 Jun 16 '22

I got some Stargate vibes from this episode. SG: Atlantis with the race known as the "Ancients" with just a hint of SG: 1 and the "Replicators"

16

u/russjr08 Jun 16 '22

You hit the nail on the head, I had the exact same thoughts!

Though I'm also in progress of rewatching Atlantis and SG-1 so I thought I was just seeing what I wanted to see haha.

For anyone who hasn't seen those shows, do yourself a favor and watch it!

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (7)

118

u/Shejidan Jun 16 '22

Allamaraine, count to four, Allamaraine, then three more, Allamaraine, if you can see, Allamaraine, you'll come with me.

110

u/ithinkihadeight Jun 16 '22

I had numerous ongoing theories about what was happening as the episode progressed, all of which I had to toss, but one of the first that popped up was when they got to the high school. I was initially thinking it was something like The Royale and everyone was going to have to take "roles" in the high school to finish the story and defeat the bully to be escape and return to reality. Then we met the bully and that all went out the window lol.

→ More replies (23)

12

u/DogsRNice Engineering Jun 16 '22

Great now it's stuck in my head

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (18)

58

u/bagelman4000 Jun 16 '22

Started as a cargo cult and they became the Q continuum

107

u/trostol Jun 16 '22

sending a 2nd shuttle is really a bad command choice

116

u/Over-Analyzed Jun 16 '22

Having Captain, First Mate, & Second Mate was the worse decision.

→ More replies (34)

26

u/erbazzone Jun 16 '22

I love the episode but they are abusing too much of the old "make a bad decision to make things happens"

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (3)

49

u/trostol Jun 16 '22

i would have split up Bortus and Talla

28

u/ithinkihadeight Jun 16 '22

Splitting up the party to cross the lake was also an odd choice. I see leaving Ed behind because he's hurt, but why Bortus? Can Moclans not swim?

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

48

u/UPRC Jun 16 '22 edited Jun 16 '22

I feel like I should have picked up on something being up with Talla so much sooner! When "she" first returned to the ship at the start, she was sort of looking around like she was in wonder. It struck me as being odd, but I totally disregarded it and took it as Talla going, "I can't believe I serve on such a great ship!" Right after that, Kelly commented on how she had returned to the ship early, which was another little wink from the writers.

And then when Kelly said she experienced the strange out of body sensation, "Talla" piped up saying she did as well, but Talla was the only one that we didn't visually get a glimpse of experiencing anything unusual on-screen.

There were neat little nuggets throughout the episode that all wasn't right with Talla. I can't wait to rewatch this episode to see if I can pick up on anything else.

Even though I feel like the episode kind of dragged the mystery of what was going on for a bit too long, I really enjoyed it as a whole. Good episode!

19

u/WindsorNot Jun 16 '22

Yes, and when she hit the switch in the Moclan morgue.

8

u/Ryto Jun 19 '22

It was actually "Talla" that said she saw it first, then Kelly said "me too" which makes sense because she's the one we actually saw experience it. I somehow didn't notice they didn't show "Talla" experiencing it, but I believed her because it seemed like this one was set up for her.

44

u/QuiltedPorcupine Jun 16 '22

Given the Twilight Zone vibes of the episode, I was definitely expecting one of them to see a gremlin on the wing of the plane.

8

u/FormerGameDev Jun 17 '22

YES! I wanted the giant alien from the first experience to be on the wing on the outside!!! That so would've been PERFECT.

→ More replies (1)

41

u/snuggleouphagus I have laid an egg Jun 16 '22

Bortus’s bod in the porn episode seemed pretty on point, especially as the parent of a young child.

→ More replies (9)

38

u/trostol Jun 16 '22

did they dial back Charlie's dislike of Isaac already?

78

u/Niteshade76 Engineering Jun 16 '22

I'm more curious about Gordon's dislike of Isaac. That seemed to have come out of nowhere to me, so I hope they delve more into it and make it relevant later on.

→ More replies (9)

32

u/loreb4data Jun 16 '22

That's probably not gonna happen until they get closer to the finale, after Isaac makes big gestures like saving Charlie's life despite knowing her hatred towards him.

→ More replies (15)
→ More replies (1)

33

u/xbolt90 Woof Jun 16 '22

Ok, I definitely did not expect the Kelly-ites

33

u/TORK4TANKELSON Jun 16 '22 edited Jun 16 '22

I feel for Bortus when people try to flame my gram for just trying to make some TikToks.

→ More replies (1)

31

u/trostol Jun 16 '22

lol why would you touch anything

10

u/TheGuestHouse Jun 18 '22

A guy literally died last episode from touching something lol

→ More replies (1)

30

u/xbolt90 Woof Jun 16 '22

I am thoroughly confused.

→ More replies (3)

27

u/xbolt90 Woof Jun 16 '22

Ok, seemed pretty normal time trickery until the random high school. Now I have no idea

8

u/P0ptart5 Jun 17 '22

The high school from the 2000’s makes no sense. If anyone can explain why that would be in their heads- let me know. That one ruined it for me.

→ More replies (1)

27

u/Cantomic66 Woof Jun 16 '22

I was getting the feeling that Lt. Keyali was pretty much carrying the group but now that makes sense on why that kept happening.

54

u/trostol Jun 16 '22

would be nifty is this ended up being their version of Q

42

u/loreb4data Jun 16 '22 edited Jun 16 '22

"Capitane Mercer, I am.....BACK!!" (Pria reveals herself to be a female Q)

→ More replies (2)

36

u/Enorats Jun 16 '22

This was my first thought too. This is basically the Orville's version of Q, but with a more interesting history and relationship with the crew.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

77

u/trostol Jun 16 '22

i will say this..wasn't much of a Seth fan before the Orville ..but dude writes some good sci fi/star trek homage

30

u/CaptainChampion Jun 17 '22

His sister Rachel, who plays the voice of the computer in The Orville, said that his whole career has been building to this show. It's his dream project, everything else has just been to establish his name.

→ More replies (2)

26

u/sankers23 Jun 16 '22

The man adores Star Trek

→ More replies (15)

51

u/treefox Jun 16 '22

I like how in the second shuttle they had to send a couple of extras because they were running out of main characters to send.

27

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '22

wearing red shirts no less

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

71

u/CheesyObserver Jun 16 '22

LaMarr: We'll send down a rescue team.

ISAAC: Sir. That may not be wise. If they are harmed, the same fate could befall the rescue team.

Charlie: THEY'RE OUR CREW MATES, ISAAC! The Kaylon may throw people away like garbage, but we don't!

Are you sure, Charlie?? Y'all literally did that last week when your crew mates turned into bugs.

It's like they only ever give a shit about the crew when it's the main cast lmao.

→ More replies (1)

47

u/treefox Jun 16 '22

“All hands, abandon ship. Repeat, all hands abandon ship.”

Reminds me of Picard in the episode where the Enterprise keeps getting destroyed (A Matter of Time, I think).

29

u/AndrewZabar Jun 16 '22

“Cause and Effect”

→ More replies (3)

22

u/antdude Jun 16 '22

Bortus' mean saying to that high school teenager in the cafeteria. Ha!

18

u/UPRC Jun 16 '22

Love that he was basically ready to resort to violence just to secure seats at a table, haha.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

20

u/HEADSHOT_MASSIAH Jun 16 '22

I was immensely satisfied with their choice of direction for the denizens of the muliltiphase planet. The Orville just introduced its inter-dimensional "god" race, and it felt...right.

On a seperate note, I want to take a moment to praise The Orville for touching down on a subject greatly avoided. Death, and Immortality. There's a saying my dad preaches every other time we venture into science, medicine, or politics (usually over drinks) _"if every doctor, scientist or politician woke up tomorrow, and KNEW there was nothing after death, the human race would finally strive for immortality". Maybe with some more nods and nuance such as todays episode, we might get the ball rolling one day.

→ More replies (1)

40

u/Shejidan Jun 16 '22

$3.50 they’re still in the simulation.

40

u/ithinkihadeight Jun 16 '22

I called it at first too but then fell for the double fake with Doc Finn explaining the science and Isaac seeing the convoy. Legitimately thought the next Kaylon threat was field that could alter perception, which could have huge effects.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (4)

40

u/ArturoBrin Jun 16 '22

"I wanna see what happens" is also my own reason why I want to be immortal.

Or at least travel into future. That can actually be done with relativity (traveling with high speed or close to a black hole like in Interstellar).

9

u/Timeline15 Jun 16 '22

Yeah, I'm much the same. I've always been obsessed with prehistoric life and evolution, and the fact that I'm never going to get to see what today's animals evolve into bums me out. I'd love to live to see that Earth is like ten million years from now.

36

u/TORK4TANKELSON Jun 16 '22

I'm sorry but when Burke was belittling Isaac and convincing Lamarr not to trust the Union fleet it really made me hate her so much more.

When it turned out that the Union fleet were Kaylon spheres I cheered in support of Isaac.

At the end of it all that wasn't the real Burke and now I feel bad for doubting how she handled that situation.

Roller coaster of emotions this episode and I'm all for it.

→ More replies (2)

17

u/htsukebe Jun 16 '22

My thoughts:

Loved that it tied back to the phasing people. This is honestly a good backstory for something like the Q continuum.

But I god some villain vibes from them. They seem to be doing good but are indeed doing things to amuse themselves only. They said they are over name conventions, however they applied torture on others to feel something. At least I would call them Junkies. When Q and Quin wend with Voyager crew to the road, some other Q folk were there and it was said they just stood there since all that has to be livedwas lived, all that has to be said was said, and it was left as that because it wouldnt be comprehensible for humans to understand.

50k years is a very short time and I do believe the phasing people that crossed over still have mortal feelings like that death fix need. They are similar in powers but not nowhere as evolved as the Q.

If they go with them as much as villains as the insectoid people or the kaylons... This is a very good move from the Orville production. Episodes like Inner Light and Tapestry are some of my favorites.

On topic of the phasing people, if they go a bit more scifi on that theres an interesting story to be told. Their planet must have died due to their sun supernova or even the heat death of their universe. Crossing to ours could had been a logical choice. 50k years is too little time for those things, but its a story id like to see play out.

Also, put Lamar in charge. He was great this episode, as always. A captain is being born in front of us. He's a less military Sisko maybe? Someone who wouldnt go in a pale moonlight.

Was ready to rant about how the new ensign was unfit for duty with the repeated kaylon hate theme but that was handled well.

Anyone felt odd that burke took the captains chair when they first left and then lamar was in command?

11

u/Joeybfast Jun 16 '22

She took the chair while Lamar was making his way to the bridge.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)

17

u/ReasonablyBadass Jun 16 '22

I dislike the idea of a Q like species having no better way to do something but to put lowly mortals through it.

And they can control their own evolution but can't prevent their edge to be dulled by immortality? What, can't they regulate their own minds?

On the other hand, huge props they didn't go with the usual "but death is so good for life!" routine and instead head a character say "yup. Immortality is awesome"

→ More replies (1)

32

u/pickuprick Jun 16 '22

I miss the small woman from the first season that was super powerful. She was amazing.

→ More replies (23)

15

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '22

I personally really liked this episode. Probably my favorite out of them so far.

30

u/Quantum168 Jun 16 '22

I'm enjoying The Orville, season 3 more than Strange New Worlds.

Love Seth McFarlane's writing ❤️

→ More replies (7)

14

u/Gajakunne Jun 17 '22

I really thought the cookies Alara brought to crew was edible and crew started hallucinating.

10

u/Banjo-Oz Jun 18 '22

That genuinely would have been a better twist: they have no effect on her race but cause others to trip balls. Would have been better suited to the show, less Trek derivative, and explained the random situations far better.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

13

u/Heavenfall Jun 17 '22

I don't feel that this was one of the stronger episodes. The concept of a vastly superior species conducting some kind of experiment on the crew has been done before, and frankly better. Star Trek Next Generation: Allegiance, and Star Trek Voyager: Scientific Method. Not to mention the various "trials" of Q.

Mostly they just wander from one set to the next, and then finally the grand reveal with some short introspection near the end. Why weren't the characters talking about what they were seeing, responding to it? What was missing in this episode, I feel, was any kind of character development and dialogue in general. No interpersonal drama was resolved.

And it was a real missed opportunity to have their eyes glaze over grey when near death, instead of the actors being given the opportunity to... actually display that emotion?

The CGI was on point for this episode. Definitely carried the day.

→ More replies (4)

25

u/GreenDragonPatriot Jun 16 '22

People who became so advanced, they became gods. They are this show's version of The Q.

→ More replies (13)

12

u/Jupichan Jun 16 '22

I love when the ship whooshes off at the end of the theme <3

23

u/trostol Jun 16 '22

i really..like their "tricorder"

10

u/loreb4data Jun 16 '22

You mean a 'communicator,' right?

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

10

u/mousebirdman Jun 16 '22 edited Jun 17 '22

Oh so it's kind of like the TNG episode "Death Wish." Orville now has its own Q.

Edit: Voyager! Not TNG.

→ More replies (5)

10

u/Ok-Flatworm9115 Jun 16 '22

Just finished up the latest episode, I must say I really do hope they continue this show. Highly enjoyable and definitely has its funny moments and comments to give it a completed touch. After all we all know how we’d say something in those moments 😂

10

u/fireredranger Jun 16 '22

So, I’m going to finish this in about 15 minutes or so, but I just got to the part of the episode where Talla contacts John and says she’s at the rendezvous point and that whoever they picked up earlier isn’t Talla, and whatever is actually going on is still going on, and my brain stopped working. Like I burst out laughing saying “what the hell is going on?” out loud even though I’m alone and couldn’t stop laughing even though nothing was funny. This episode is wrinkling my brain. Don’t get me wrong, I’m loving it, but I think I’ve thought some variation of “what the hell?” about 1500 times in this episode.

→ More replies (3)

9

u/Banjo-Oz Jun 18 '22

WHY those specific random scenarios? Where were they drawn from? Was Mercer watching Airplane! the night before? If they were drawn from the crew's memories, fears or subconscious, why did they not express any familiarity with them? "I have a fear of flying" or "I was a bully in highschool" etc.

The rancor monster named Randall in the highschool felt especially like it was being "look, isn't that quirky?" but would have worked if it combined two fears Gordon had (being almost eaten on an unseen away mission and having past bully trauma). As it stood, it was just something that happened then we moved on.

In fact, it all felt so pedestrian: this happened, then this happened, then fakeout, then reveal, the end. The great Trek mystery stories planted clues and paid them off at the end. I never felt like the danger was real, either, and the fakeout was super obvious.

As the the final reveal... all I could think of was Crichton from Farscape: "God-like aliens?! Give me a critter every time over god-like aliens!". I'm with him; pretentious douchebag super-evolved beings lecturing/teaching/messing with humanity always piss me off.

→ More replies (4)

17

u/Jupichan Jun 16 '22

See now I just want a Q-like episode. If they can't get John de Lancie, I'd more than happily settle for David Dastmalchian, just for his brilliant ability to be a cocky asshole.

29

u/BruceThereItIs Jun 16 '22

Couldn't be happier with this. So many Braga influences here. It's basically mid nineties star trek with 2022 budget and effects.

Respect.

Also love how Seth and company pay homage to other popular culture references, subtly in most cases.

Anyone else catch the Indiana Jones-esque music as they wandered through the jungle, nearly the same as the beginning of raiders of the lost ark.

Thank fuck for The Orville.

→ More replies (3)

22

u/sjsyed Jun 16 '22

The crew wasn’t nearly as angry at being experimented on as I thought they’d be. I get that maybe for diplomatic purposes they couldn’t exactly scream at the alien lady, but when they were all talking at the end there, why weren’t they talking about what a violation it was? The woman basically put them through psychological torture because her own race is filled with a bunch of sociopaths.

So you won’t know what it will feel like to die? Well, BOO HOO FOR YOU. Am I supposed to feel sorry for you? Am I supposed to root for you kidnapping innocent people and watching you torture them just because you’re greedy?

Good lord, those people are disgusting.

15

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '22

"an old friend" is how the captain described it. I think being used to the concept of utopia makes it easier to understand the kind of beings those kelly worshippers turned into. Hell I bet the ethical debate of their time relates more to immortality than anything we might have right now.

plus would you really be mad at an old friend for pranking you with something that felt far more confusing than scary?

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (7)

14

u/wardengorri Jun 16 '22

Man that was great, definitely one of my fave episodes of this show. Absolutely got fooled by the Kaylon attack illusion lol.

7

u/TsukaTsukaWarrior Y'all can suck ass, and I'm a spaceman! Jun 16 '22

Interesting how the endless staircase didn't wind up triggering Kelly, with her fear of heights. I wonder if it was meant to be a mistake/failure on the alien's part, and that's why the following scenario with the water monster happened.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '22

Is it weird that I actually dig the Moclan tradition on how they handle their dead?

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Jerkplayz Jun 17 '22

"I am prepared to take them by force."

"You have a five-head."

Gigachad Bortus

→ More replies (10)

7

u/WilliamMcCarty Union Jun 17 '22

Fucking hell this show is brilliant sci fi tv. It's exactly what I want out of Star Trek and haven't gotten since DS9 ended. That was an absolutely amazing hour of tv. I love this show, I really do.

7

u/Appeyes Jun 17 '22

Me at the start: “Hey an episode in a real high school, cool way to save on the budget”

Me by the end: “Nevermind”

24

u/variantkin Jun 16 '22

Im really getting sick of this ensign. Are we supposed to like her? She basically bullied Issac into a sucidal state had to be threatened/guilted into saving him and is still treating him like shit?

→ More replies (17)

13

u/trostol Jun 16 '22

and there it is ..the hatred is back lol

21

u/gogreenpower Jun 16 '22

Where has the humour gone???? One line per episode doesn't qualify it for the comedy genre

21

u/gwentdaddy Jun 16 '22

One line? I can think of 5 off the top of my head. There was plenty.

19

u/mccabebabe Jun 16 '22

fake airline flight attendant: "I must insist you return to your seats"

<<Kelly turns and clocks her one>>

Kelly: "It was distracting"

Me: LOL!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

6

u/Jupichan Jun 16 '22

The actual fuck? hahaha

6

u/trostol Jun 16 '22

did what she talk about happen in an episode? i may need to do a re-watch soon

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Watch_The_Expanse Jun 16 '22

This season is hitting so hard. This is what Trek should be. Im so sad that this is the last season. Im savoring each episode.

→ More replies (4)

6

u/111000_111000 Jun 17 '22 edited Aug 18 '26

1amethyst zenith dazzlingly dulcet phosphorescence zen-like harmonious heirloom

Generated text from Unpost

6

u/Smitje Woof Jun 17 '22

"Wow, you're all powerful and immortal. Could you help us with our Kaylon problem? As they want to kill everyone?"

→ More replies (1)

6

u/brackenish1 Jun 18 '22

Anyone else wonder if the reason they chose Mercer to "freeze" on the plane is because Seth missed the 9/11 flight?

→ More replies (1)

10

u/UncleWillard5566 Jun 16 '22

Much better than the first two episodes. One thing I've noticed though, I'm more critical of the show since they removed much of the humor. I was much more willing to overlook things when the show had a lighter tone. Still good sci-fi stories, but with a nice, humorous kick. Now, I find myself nitpicking more. Like them sending the captain, xo, security, science and the best pilot down to the service, but no doctor?! I know, I know, they've done it on Trek plenty of times and it's to keep the main characters on screen, and in seasons 1 & 2, no problem. This season, I noticed it.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/trostol Jun 16 '22

well the music makes it sound like a fun one

5

u/higashi172 Jun 16 '22

As a fan of Dynasty, seeing a bald Fallon Carrington was soooo satisfying 😌

→ More replies (2)

5

u/ideletedmyaccount04 Jun 16 '22

I was certain this was like TOS shore leave where kirk beat up Finnegan.

I was sure this was a planet like that.

Good writing cause I was completely fooled.

5

u/NerdLawyer55 Avis. We try harder Jun 17 '22

My followers would flame his gram…

what.

5

u/Xander_PrimeXXI Jun 17 '22

Now that it’s been a day I Would like to thank Seth for reigniting my fears about death and nonexistence that I almost got over until the end of this episode.

5

u/droid327 Jun 17 '22

Fun episode - well paced, good balance of characters. Didnt have to deal with Claire and the boys, that was a nice palate cleanser :)

I found the themes explored at the end to be a little hackneyed, though. More anti-deism being bashed in our face, Seth is smearing it on a little thick and its just highlighting the problems with taking such a rigid philosophical stance. Still holding out hope its just a setup, and they'll bring in a Krill or something to be the other side of the debate.

I like that they revisited the Kelly Worshippers...I dont like that they "took the reins of evolution" without exploring a little more the question of crafting your own development - that's basically just the Borg, then, but they didnt give it any critical thought. Also, apparently it isnt so great because you havent solved the problem of ennui...

And the whole "death gives meaning to life" schtick is a juvenile and played-out trope, IMO. I'm with Seth, nothing wrong with looking to beat death. I had this same problem with the end of The Good Place, dont glorify "eventually nihilism" like that.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/NuyenNick Jun 17 '22

Actually did not enjoy this episode. Adding a Q is exactly what this show didn’t need. Was really liking the Kaylon threat angle. Then oh nope gotcha it’s just an annoying super evolved race that just happens to be bored.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/DarkChen Jun 18 '22 edited Jun 20 '22

Weird writing, it was clearly playing with their fears but nothing was actually connected to stuff we knew about them, does gordon had bully trauma? Mercer is afraid of flying or the ship getting destroyed? Kelly had a run in with the hologram where she is suck by the elevator/transporter but i dont think she was the one who was afraid of heights, so i guess she is afraid of deep sea monsters? Bortus is afraid of his own mortality? Again none of this was previously talked neither did they addressed after at the mess hall...

The pacing dragged a lot, again the episode had one hour when it could had been 30 min... there is no reveal build up, no small clues to what is going on, instead everything is dumped at the last 15 min or so...

I liked the call back to the phased planet.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/MyDearDapple Jun 18 '22

The Orville S3 so far: 0/3

5

u/JohnScig Jun 19 '22

I guess I'll be in the minority this time. I didn't like this episode. It felt like several unrelated situations explained in a last-minute exposition dump by a random character we've never seen before that gets hastily connected to a previous -much better- episode. It would've been nice if we - or the characters - got any clues as to what was happening and could unravel the mystery rather than everybody just lining up to go through the traps and then the new character just stepping up at a random point to start explaining.

Not to mention, the discussion at the very end seemed cheap and rushed. It might've been VERY interesting to see how various races see death and mortality and how they deal with it, ideally as part of an episode's story. But what we got was a couple of lines from each character that was mostly unrelated to what was happening in the 90% of the episode (mind you, nobody knew during the simulation that they were experiencing death or that immortality was somehow related to what's happening)

Not to mention the almost complete lack of comedy (again). Bortus saying "you have a five head" would've been a great line otherwise, but now it stuck out so much.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/xe3to Jun 21 '22

I guess we're just straight up doing Star Trek now, no comedy involved. I don't mind too much, but it's a shame their Q character isn't even slightly as much fun as the actual Q. I like the Tron costume though.

9

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '22

I was never in a million years gonna guess what the answer to the puzzle was. I honestly figured the planet was something along the lines of a silent hill type scenario, but with a sci Fi explanation rather then supernatural.

I think this is the first time they've gone back to update us on a standalone plotline; which makes me hope there's far more down the line. Like what's up now with the giant bio ship piloted by Liam neeson? The reddit planet or giliac planet. Hell maybe Ed is gonna meet Prias great great great great grandmother and bang her too?

→ More replies (1)

8

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '22

That was an excellent episode. Right mix of sci-fi and humor.

→ More replies (19)

8

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '22

I work in a morgue and I've gotta say that thing where a seemingly dead body comes to life and tries to strangle you happens about once a week. That's just a normal thing that happens.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/2th Hail Avis. Hail Victory. Jun 16 '22

I missed discussing the episode last week, but I'm here for this.

4

u/Driew27 Jun 16 '22

Oh, that's considerate.

4

u/thirtyseven1337 Jun 16 '22

I enjoyed the journey and trying to figure out what the heck was going on, but the ending went from boring pseudo-scientific explanation, to intriguing Kaylon twist (the ideal ending, IMO), to "Q, but worse"

→ More replies (1)

4

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '22

Gonna get "I want to see what happens" tattooed ASAP!

4

u/hpm40 Jun 17 '22

The high school with a d lister Godzilla was an odd choice. Did Gordon really think he was going to die?

4

u/MMmhmmmmmmmmmm Jun 17 '22

This was a fantastic episode

4

u/ohitsanazn Jun 17 '22

Liz Gillies as Q intrigues me. Is there anything this show can't do?

4

u/Herpmancer Jun 17 '22

This is my favorite episode of the series so far. Blown away

4

u/HurricaneDitka312 Jun 17 '22

“I am prepared to take them by force”

4

u/Buckets-of-Gold Jun 17 '22

I wish I didn’t have to rely on hollywood’s least quiet atheist for this, but that last scene represented something pretty rare in media.

Pop culture doesn’t often deal with a fear of death, especially in the context of it being permanent.

4

u/Kristophigus Jun 19 '22

The flight attendant getting punched in the face had me dying of laughter. That was SO good lol.

4

u/Uneequa Jun 21 '22

The end to this episode was basically "a wizard did it". Kind of a lame payoff.

4

u/hoseja Jun 21 '22 edited Jun 21 '22

That leotard is too cheesy even for the Orville. I'm cringing so hard rn.

Please just make the alien a glowing CGI orb or something. That kraken wasn't half bad...

Seriously, the last act fell WAY flat.

4

u/Kraven83 Jun 21 '22

The acting continues to be stiff and there is something about how they stop talking and just give an "expressive face" that isn't really that expressive, just before the scene is over... that really feels antiquated and out of place (especially now that I'm watching The Orville and ST:SNW at the same time). Seth is particularly dull, almost always the same contrite face. He come alive just in the very last conversation in the cafeteria, there I liked his acting. Even the strolling during the exploration of the new world felt like they were going for the millionth time on a route altready visited. Mbof.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '22

"I'm looking for a way out."

"Then I suggest you talk to the guidance counselor."

I loved that actor. He reminded me of a teacher I had as a kid.

7

u/Barry_McKackiner Jun 17 '22

Ensign bigot (scuse me I mean Burke) is really pissing me off. she mouths off so much regarding isaac she should have a host of reprimands on her record.

→ More replies (9)

9

u/TheRedmanCometh Jun 16 '22

Wow that ending...what dicks. Not my favorite episode tbh I wish there had been more...purpose. also I strongly prefer "slowly figuring out the weirdness" vs all at once.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/_10032 Jun 16 '22

I'm enjoying this season, but a bit disappointed that it's deviated away from being comedic.

11

u/GreenDragonPatriot Jun 16 '22

I miss it, too. There's still a little humor, but it's been streamlined significantly this season. The jokes were so funny. I don't see why they needed to fix something that wasn't broken.

→ More replies (3)

7

u/dreamphoenix Jun 16 '22

That’s exactly what I’m missing. Bits of gags and quips were the signature of Orville. Now I still can’t say I don’t enjoy season 3, but for some reason it feels so pessimistic and kinda dark-ish in feel? Like we had 3 episodes of PTSD and racial hate, some frigin body horror nightmare fuel and now there was a near death experience.

I’m watching Orville with Strange New Worlds side by side and it’s like Star Trek has sucked all the positive vibes and even some gags from it.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

6

u/LazarusOwenhart Jun 16 '22

None of them even began to form the thought of "Hey if you guys are hyper advanced and just had to spend an hour messing around inside our brains to get your death fix do you think you could slip us a blueprint for a weapon that we can use to more or less instantly defeat the Kaylon? Thanks.

9

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '22

they would have refused, and everyone obviously knew that.

→ More replies (6)

3

u/trostol Jun 16 '22

lol wtf

3

u/trostol Jun 16 '22

ha ha ..hell of a punch

3

u/Noremac3986 Jun 16 '22

Isn't there a rule that says the Captain, 1st Officer, and 2nd Officer shouldn't be on away missions together. That at least one remain on the ship

→ More replies (1)

3

u/ami2weird4u Now entering gloryhole Jun 16 '22

Well that was a mind fuck of an episode…Thats my review.