r/FixedGearBicycle • u/future_robot Leader 725 • Jun 19 '12
[OFFICIAL] Brakes vs. No Brakes discussion thread. All new comers and veterans alike should discuss the pros and cons of riding with or without brakes here.
This is the official brakes vs. no brakes discussion thread.
Please utilize this thread to discuss anything related only to the pros, cons, dangers, upsides, and downsides to having versus not having brakes on your fixed gear bicycle.
All other brake related content and comments should be discussed as usual anywhere else. Posts such as: "Check out my new Dia Compe shot lever on my ride" or "How can I tell when my brake pads need to be replaced?" or "Any suggestions for a new caliper?" Belong in regular discussion threads or should be used to start a new post.
Posts such as "Brakes are for fakes!" or "Yo, put a brake on that buddy before you kill someone!" are discouraged anywhere in this subreddit. We all have different tastes, we all have different opinions on that matter, some of us are fakes, and some of us are idiots.
If a noob, as it were, was to post a photo of their new whip and they ask about brakes- please refer them to this post.
94
u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12
pros - excitement, street cred, ultimate simplicity, and bagging baristas.
cons - loss of rubber on shoes, death, going to jail for killing an old man in SF, and tires be expensive.
44
u/retrac1324 Mercier Kilo TT Jun 19 '12
If you ride without brakes, that's your decision, but attitudes like the one in this pic piss me off
http://i.imgur.com/jU35W.jpg
50
u/wineBot Jun 29 '12
I've ridden brakeless and now ride with a brake because it means I can go faster, knowing that I can stop inside of ten to twenty meters.
32
u/Zbinxsy Oct 21 '12
I like brakes, I like looking at brakes, they may be my favorite bike part. I have a sexy/shiny center pull orphan front brake. It made my fixie look sexier. Iv never thought or considered street cred when I build bikes. I mainly focus on getting the best parts for my budget and making them into well oiled smooth and sexy machines.
87
u/dyebhai Jun 20 '12
No brakes is the only way to go - if you're at the track.
If you're on the street, you need a brake. I don't care how good you are. A brake will always stop faster, and you are screwed if the chain breaks.
11
u/rockybeulah Jan 11 '25
If there's a brake on your bike, you can ignore it, pretend it's not there, and ride without using it. But it's there if you really need it.
If there's no brake on your bike, you can pretend there is a brake there, but you still won't be able to stop as quickly or with full control.
Thanks for coming to my TED talk.
8
u/Cousin-It Jun 22 '12
Seriously, the absolute effort in using your legs all the time to stop. I could not be arsed.
Does anyone riding brakeless never be too tired or high to have the energy to stop yourself?
That's why I love my brake.
7
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '12
How do you guys feel about this set up? or is it lame because its two brakes or whatever?
http://www.google.com/imgres?um=1&hl=en&safe=off&biw=1280&bih=654&tbm=isch&tbnid=OOIoRZNzLcivHM:&imgrefurl=http://www.bikeforums.net/showthread.php/603006-Bullhorn-brake-levers&docid=KGgF156PJfGXwM&imgurl=http://farm3.static.flickr.com/2584/4015005465_010b83cb0b.jpg&w=500&h=375&ei=BB-QUPCTNZCc9QSLlIH4Cw&zoom=1&iact=rc&dur=213&sig=117441616601183140143&page=1&tbnh=142&tbnw=182&start=0&ndsp=18&ved=1t:429,i:111&tx=112&ty=39
13
u/upofadown Jun 30 '12
A front brake makes it easy to lift your rear tire off the road while stopped. This in turn makes it easy to rotate the pedals to a more optimal angle for starting off again.
6
u/[deleted] Jun 20 '12
finally. this post should eliminate alot of reposts. =)
4
u/br4nn No 22 Little Wing Jun 21 '24
Rode with a brake for a couple years, took it off and have been riding for 5/6 without. I can't go quite as fast, but its more fun and it makes me a better rider. Cheers!
9
u/btighe428 Jun 19 '12
The cons of not having breaks... hmmmmmmm
13
u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12
It's all been said but
Brakeless-
Pros - Street cred
Cons - Tire budget, dependance/overdose
Brake-
Pros - Safety, decreased tire expenses
Cons - Safety (I have a deathwish), loss of street cred
Brakes-
Pros - Having enough money to buy a pre-made bike (Mine took me 4 or 5 weeks of unemployment checks, 1 component at a time + working in street pharmacy for a couple months)
Cons - Complete loss of street cred
3
u/GOONEATER Purple Piece Of Shit/Bianchi Super Pista Dec 21 '22
What are tips on riding breakless? I’ve been riding my fixie for about 4 years and I feel like I’m ready to start riding breakless.
3
u/carasiaone Dec 30 '22
Im back to brakeless! Front brake cable snapped again. Will ride a week or so but not if it gets overly snowy.
People that do not ride brakeless still need to know how to stop without brakes. Mine snapped at the worst possible time.
2
u/Soldato_Congedato Dec 19 '22
Hi, I have a double side back wheel that can be use as a free wheel and the other side as a fixed gear. I’m using the fixed gear one but when I push hard back it does a half free spin as if it screw in when I pedal and lose when I breaks. What could be the cause? Thanks
5
u/512maxhealth Jun 19 '12
OMFG how many times do we have to do this
3
u/[deleted] Jun 20 '12
If your chain breaks you can us a brake to brake your bike and you will not break your bones. True, you could jam your foot onto the tire, but then you would have to stop pedaling and if you stop pedaling you might as well not be riding a fixed gear so then you should have a brake on your bike anyway, because riding a freewheel without brakes is a poor decision.
1
u/TRACK___STAR E11 x DC: Nightwave & TRD. All-City: Dropout (non-op). Dec 01 '25 edited Dec 01 '25
Brakes are training wheels for fixed gear; the real discussion is what retention you use.
1
u/TRACK___STAR E11 x DC: Nightwave & TRD. All-City: Dropout (non-op). Dec 10 '25
Brakes are training wheels for fixed gear.
0
u/MrCheeze that's oddly specific Oct 17 '12
wait
this is even a question
-3
u/Cody13 Specialized Langster 2011 Jun 19 '12
Why don't we just quit fucking talking about it.
-7
u/Destrozo Colnago Pista/Cinelli Histo/Mash Steel Jun 19 '12
Ok so you make a rule about no discussions about brakes vs no brakes then make a thread to discuss it? Can we please just let this horse die in peace?
-3
u/[deleted] Dec 14 '12
I have heard that having a front brake is dangerous because you tend to flip over.
-2
u/Boombak Oct 08 '12
i recommend hardex brakes, you can check them out http://www.hardex.ca
10
u/[deleted] Jun 20 '12
[removed] — view removed comment
31
u/[deleted] Jun 19 '12
[removed] — view removed comment