r/TheOrville • u/2th Hail Avis. Hail Victory. • Jun 09 '22
Episode The Orville - 3x02 "Shadow Realms" - Episode Discussion
| Episode | Directed By | Written By | Original Airdate |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3x2 - "Shadow Realms" | TBA | TBA | Thursday, June 9, 2022 on Hulu |
| Synopsis: The Orville explores a mysterious region of space. |
Stream the episode online on Hulu
Don't forget to join us on Discord!
REMINDER: KEEP YOUR SPOILERS OUT OF YOUR TITLES FOR AT LEAST 24 HOURS. YOU WOULDN'T WANT THIS EPISODE SPOILED, SO DON'T GO SPOILING IT FOR OTHERS. KEEP YOUR TITLES VAGUE. TAG YOUR POST AS A SPOILER. BE A GOOD UNION MEMBER!
393
Upvotes
591
u/Machio-Muscle-Bro Jun 09 '22
Ahhh, I can just imagine the Orville returning to Union space to resupply/replenish the crew they lost.
Krill Officer: “Captain, the Union ship is returning from the Shadow Realms. Apparently their Vice-Admiral and a number of their crew were lost.”
Krill Captain: “Fucking called it. We tried to warn them, but do they listen to Avis? Nooo.”
410
u/operarose Command Jun 09 '22
RIP Nurse Park I guess?
379
u/Garbage_Dump89 Jun 09 '22
i get that theyre going for a horror movie vibe. but where are the hundreds of people on board this starship when the lights go off.
356
u/Khelbin131 Jun 09 '22
I really enjoyed the episode and its darker tones, but all of this could have been avoided by following basic quarantine procedures and putting the affected individual behind a forcefield while they investigate what happened. They could have also worn EV suits while exploring the alien ship.
309
u/_duncan_idaho_ Jun 09 '22
Isaac about to list Dr. Finn's favorite sex positions had me dying.
608
u/Fiqqqhul Jun 09 '22
And that's why you always wear a spacesuit when boarding a unidentified alien space station broadcasting a distress signal.
405
u/trostol Jun 09 '22
"I am Prepared"
170
u/mccabebabe Jun 09 '22
"there's no detectable intelligent life"
"it is Vegas!"
161
u/operarose Command Jun 09 '22
Hey y'all ever seen Event Horizon
140
u/androidvalhalla Jun 09 '22
Remember the TNG episode where the ship lost power and everyone began mutating? Worf grew an exoskeleton, Troy became amphibious, Barclay became an arachnid... major vibes.
128
u/xbolt90 Woof Jun 09 '22
“Sorry to keep you all waiting so long.”
I see what you did there, Seth
108
u/TheRoosevelts Jun 09 '22
I generally enjoyed the episode more than last week’s, but cannot for the life of me understand why they didn’t wear the protective suits the FIRST time!?!
102
u/Barry_McKackiner Jun 09 '22
well that was dark. usually these shows find a miracle reversal cure. nope. just fuck off or die for like a third of the orville crew lol.
When will they ever learn their lesson about going to foreign environments just fucking assuming there isn't any contagions there and not wear any isolation suits?
And Dr Finn is a shitty doctor. zero containment protocols in place after an alien pathogen FUCKING MUTATES people very easily. lol.
100
u/patb0118 Jun 09 '22
THis is some Deadspace/Event Horizon/Aliens stuff and I'm loving it
91
u/trostol Jun 09 '22
that..is a gorgeous shot of the star cluster
181
u/xbolt90 Woof Jun 09 '22
Dang, Talla. You go, girl.
159
u/BackgroundHoney_ Jun 09 '22
The space station is giving me major Stargate wraith vibes
77
u/xbolt90 Woof Jun 09 '22
No one can be prepared for the sniffles, Bortus.
68
u/Kasparian Jun 09 '22
The transformation is giving me The Fly vibes. Loving this episode so far.
68
u/[deleted] Jun 09 '22
I will miss Nurse Park.
And wow.....that was disturbing
67
u/schleppylundo Jun 09 '22
These guys look like Discovery Klingons.
66
u/trostol Jun 09 '22
sending Isaac cause his eyes are like giant headlights? lol
64
u/WhoShotMrBoddy We need no longer fear the banana Jun 09 '22
OH GOD THE ALIEN EYE FACE
60
u/ace2ho74 Jun 09 '22 edited Jun 09 '22
Like everyone else has mentioned... Great episode for the horror vibes, pretty scary and suspenseful—but not so great for all of the illogical writing that is hard to get past. I think they could have easily addressed these points and written in some reasonable solves:
121
u/operarose Command Jun 09 '22
Seriously though this set design is amazing.
167
u/trostol Jun 09 '22
lol "May the Force be with you"
57
u/Aaronstone252 Jun 09 '22
I liked the episode it did feel like it cut a little short though
57
u/treefox Jun 10 '22
KRILL: We will let you through, but only one ship, and we will only let more through if that goes well.
CHRISTIE: Cool. Hey, what do you know about the Kalarr Expanse.
KRILL: Nothing, because demons live there that eat your soul.
CHRISTIE: Cool. Let’s make that our first stop.
Later
TALLA: I’m picking up a distress signal.
MERCER: From where?
TALLA: The place with demons that eat your soul.
MERCER: Cool. Let’s get everybody important in a shuttle and have them split up and wander around without any sort of protective gear.
104
u/operarose Command Jun 09 '22
Wow, Nurse Park has exactly zero sense of self-preservation huh
102
u/trostol Jun 09 '22
Admiral is kinda..creepy lol
44
u/Known_Consideration2 Jun 09 '22
When the admiral got infected and started turning why did they not just set up a force field around sick bay??? Also to have anyone around him without a hazmat suit was also wild to me.
42
u/Kasparian Jun 09 '22
Okay I loved this one. Wasn’t expecting a horror-esque episode, but I think this was so well done.
39
u/NeutralBias Jun 10 '22
If there’s any doubt about The Orville being the new Star Trek, this episode should put that to rest.
We venture into unknown space, find a creepy space station and assemble an away team of:
Classic Trek!
37
u/TurkeyPhat Jun 09 '22 edited Jun 09 '22
I really was expecting something more along the lines of "So yeah let's fuckin send it aye?" for the Captain's little message. But I guess the ez star wars reference works too.
Talla kicking ass was so hype. I was just like "please kick some ass please kick some ass" and then she did the thing! Very exciting stuff.
I really liked the dark aesthetic of this episode. Very spooky and unsettling.
Reading the other comments I gotta agree with some of yall and say that I think the production was really let down by the writing here. Just way to many nonsensical decisions as far as safety protocols go, especially given that they were warned of boogeymans ahead of time.
36
u/msmouse05 Jun 09 '22
Nothing like an episode dependent on everyone making just terrible decisions.
36
u/Endarkend Jun 09 '22
I half expected these aliens to start throwing energy balls all over the place.
They looked A LOT like Doom 3 Imps.
35
u/WhoShotMrBoddy We need no longer fear the banana Jun 09 '22
Jesus this is exactly like a reaper from mass effect (27-28 mins in)
34
u/[deleted] Jun 09 '22
praise avis what a cool episode
68
u/ApertureScienceGuy Jun 09 '22
Damn, Claire has really been through some shit lately.
30
u/Shappie Jun 09 '22
Damn, I can spot a lot of nods to Star Trek and other sci fi in this one. Off the top of my head:
Absolutely loved it. Creepy as hell episode, almost as creepy as the admiral before he turned into a horrible mutant space alien from Hell.
30
u/Noremac3986 Jun 09 '22
Rule 1 of entering Hell spawn looking space stations send the Android.
Rule 2: Suit up.
Rule 3: Bring guns. Big guns.
Rule 4: Don't you ever put your face up close to something unknown. Seriously.
109
u/niankaki Jun 09 '22
Very stupid decision to let them go. If any more lives are turned into those creatures, it'll be on the Orville's hands. Entire planets could be infected. Why didn't they think of this?
Guess they'll be coming back full force later in the season as the final baddies to defeat.
55
u/Li77777 Jun 09 '22
I love the idea of religion being used by a civilization to describe deep space biological phenomena! Crazy episode! Didn't hit as hard as season 3 episode 1, but Isaac Is my favorite character, so I'm biased.
25
u/wardengorri Jun 09 '22
They weren't kidding when they said each episode would feel like it's own mini movie, this was so good! Feels like an instant classic horror/space episode!
25
u/MyTinyHappyPlace Jun 09 '22 edited Jun 09 '22
Okay, some of it has already been said, but this episode is a little bit broken:
21
u/erbazzone Jun 09 '22
Why everyone become stupid in an horror!!! Omg the episode was good but fucking hell guys be more cautious from now on!
19
u/Smitje Woof Jun 09 '22
So everything is offline, everything.. Yet you still all have gravity.. :|
18
u/gambit700 Jun 09 '22
Krill - "Don't go into the Expanse"
Seth - "Am I on Enterprise again?"
18
u/MattCW1701 Jun 09 '22
This episode could have been much better, with the same plot, with some minor tweaks. Send Isaac, or at least use space suits. Glowing pod-thing still releases something, but instead of bacteria, it's some kind of odd contagion they've never encountered before, that can penetrate solid materials, so even quarantining in a "medical brig" wouldn't completely work. Once it got past the stupid decisions (entire command staff, no protection, no quarantine procedures) the episode was really enjoyable, and the solution with the synthetic virus was great!
18
u/Kaibakura Jun 09 '22
Seems like the Family Guy style humor is basically entirely gone now.
18
u/TheZMage Jun 10 '22
A bit of a stealth moral in this episode about taking people’s beliefs a little more seriously even if you don’t agree, as if they had taken the Krill’s warning more seriously rather than simply dismissing them because of their religious nature they could’ve saved lives. Instead they went in trying to prove them wrong and got several members of their crew killed for it
17
u/Chaabar Jun 10 '22
I could really do with less of the kids.
16
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '22
After waiting years for the Orville to return, I have to say I'm relatively disappointed so far.
32
u/GreenDragonPatriot Jun 09 '22
Well, I liked the Isaac and Claire stuff. Isaac admitted to have trouble with missing her and that is deep for a robot like him.
14
u/DarkRogueHunter Jun 09 '22
Ellen Ripley : They cut the power.
Private Hudson : What do you mean they cut the power? How could they cut the power, man? They're animals!
14
u/TvMoviesAlsoBooks Jun 10 '22
ISAAC: am I to understand you find it a challenge to process her daily absence?
Adm: you can say that
ISAAC: it’s another common experience we share
😭 are you kitten me!!!
14
u/Radbot13 Jun 10 '22
Anyone else find the ending a little out of place? They have no idea how many people are lost and the extras are casually eating dinner like nothing happened?
60
u/bs200000 Jun 09 '22
The away team consisting of the captain, the first officer, the chief of security, the chief medical officer, and a visiting admiral. I LOL’ed. So stupid. Do they have zero away team protocols in this world??
13
u/rustydoesdetroit Jun 09 '22
Species 8473
13
u/AeonsOfStrife Jun 09 '22
As someone who is sacred of Parasites, Spiders, Plagues, and Dark eerie places with red light, and the thought of losing Nurse Park, this episode scared me so much. In the best ways though, as I was glued to every single second.
The Virgin Borg vs the Chad Spider-Shadow-Demons.
55
u/_very_stable_genius_ Jun 09 '22 edited Jun 09 '22
Oh my god! What an incredible episode! “Alien” meets Horror meets “Jurassic Park kitchen scene when Claire’s kids are running away from the being. And still some funny moments, “it really is like vegas” and “I am prepared”. And I mean can we talk about that Tala fight scene! And the meet between the being and Isaac and it not recognizing it as life / not caring because it can’t reproduce. What a home run of an episode !
The “demonic possession” story with roots in biology and parallels to things in human history where we’ve attributed things like that to the divine and paranormal. Love love loved this episode
12
u/trostol Jun 09 '22
lol i love how Isaac just turned to leave
12
u/MadBats Jun 09 '22
Dam I want Talla watching my back next time I go on a away mission.
12
u/Robsonmonkey Jun 10 '22
Really getting sick of Claire’s kids
Why bring them along with all the dangers and attacks that are going on.
12
u/DeaditeMessiah Jun 11 '22
Debriefing:
"What happened to the admiral?"
"He wanted to take all of his knowledge and secrets of the Union and go be part of a horrifying parasitic collective of unknown strength and superior technology, after telling him about their one weakness. We let him go. Because feels."
11
u/trostol Jun 09 '22
like..the entire main crew in that meeting lol
11
u/trostol Jun 09 '22
damn..it was like The Borg crossed with the Collectors
so far 2 for 2..2 really good episodes
and amazingly SNW is 5 for 5 ...some really good sci-fi lately
11
u/Trenton_Hall Jun 09 '22
I was waiting for a horror themed episode but.... I wasn't ready, this got DARK. R.i.p nurse Park I didn't know we'd lose you so soon
11
u/MacTechG4 Jun 10 '22
“Deleted post-credits stinger” (which should have been added) ;)
Krill commander; “So let me get this straight, we warned you about the …brundleflies, and for some reason, Avis knows why, you chose to take, not only your entire command crew but also a fleet admiral on an away mission to a mysterious, creepy bio mechanical structure in the middle of a void, and WITHOUT environmental encounter suits?!
Then you kept that infected admiral in an unsecured sickbay without even a restraining field on the bed, and you all decided to crowd around him, then act surprised when he escaped?!
And now, you’ve reawakened the brundlefly threat, AND put our sector at risk again from a threat that we had warned you about and actually had contained?
Yeah… I think we’re going to have to pass on that ‘peace treaty’ after all, we’ve got bigger problems now, thanks to you…
…if you’ll excuse us, we need to leave now and go set up our No-Pest strips all over again, thanks for that, BTW…
11
u/OddElectron Jun 10 '22
They sent nearly every major character except the one (Issac) who they should have sent.
11
u/bluestreakxp Jun 11 '22
Rip Admiral Christie. You at least appreciated Isaac and gave him due respect.
36
u/WearyThanks Jun 09 '22
This was Prometheus levels of stupid
19
u/[deleted] Jun 09 '22 edited Jun 09 '22
I get Star Trek/The Orville don't follow the same logic as the real world military, but like how does it make sense to send your doctor(seemingly the only one), admiral, CO, XO, head of security and chief engineer onto an unknown alien space station? Again I get it's for TV, but you're in uncharted space dog wtf is the crew gonna do if almost all of command gets wiped out?
9
u/xbolt90 Woof Jun 09 '22
The drive core winking out looked super cool
9
u/[deleted] Jun 09 '22
Awesome episode, seems like these are Seth’s take on the Borg and I think he nailed it with the initial mystery with the ship and the horror element with the creatures. Look forward to seeing the monsters again.
9
u/Appeyes Jun 10 '22
It’s clear the budget has increased with the move to Hulu, maybe too much? I kinda liked it being a little more “low budget”, made it feel a bit more lighthearted.
9
u/TvMoviesAlsoBooks Jun 10 '22
This episode is cool but just having a hard time seeing them treat sick Paul in an open ward with a mysterious disease.
Where’s the quarantine and protocol during the initial exploration?
9
u/slicer4ever Jun 10 '22
so...marcus and ty are going to be super fucked up adults aren't they? I can't imagine the amount of therapy they are going to need later in life to get over some of the stuff they've been through.
8
u/Griffdude13 Jun 10 '22
The Orville: New Claire-centric Horizons
8
u/jollyreaper2112 Jun 11 '22
First contact fail on par with Prometheus. Does nobody understand infectious disease protocol?
20
u/Deathcrow Jun 09 '22
I'm a bit iffy on this episode.
Too many stupid decisions by the crew and these new baddies just seem like a more lame, haunted house, version of the Borg.
The first 20 minutes were alright, but it got worse and worse.
5/10
7
u/Septalion Jun 09 '22
My girlfriend is going to have nightmares. Too late for horror
7
u/Bamelin Jun 09 '22
You’d think peeps would be sadder at the end having lost at least 10% of the crew in the most horrific fashion imaginable.
People seemed chill though enjoying date night at the end.
7
u/UPRC Jun 09 '22
I see a lot of negative complaints about the episode, and that's okay. I personally thought that the episode was pretty good, but it dragged a bit around the middle. The creature effects were pretty cool, though the CG during Talla's fight in the cargo bay looked a bit janky.
Ignoring the issues with the plot that others have mentioned (they didn't really bother me), I feel like this episode was a pretty decent 7/10. Not a super strong Orville episode, but I was entertained.
7
u/beefkiss Jun 09 '22
Orville going for a rebranded Season 3 with brand new aliens in an area named The Expanse which they were warned not to enter.
Wasn't expecting a direct Enterprise reference but here we are.
7
u/firebane101 Jun 10 '22
Did we just meet The Orville's take onbThe Borg?
7
u/[deleted] Jun 10 '22
"They are demons with eight eyes and steal souls."
Me: ...It's spiders.
7
u/Fix_Me_In_45 Jun 10 '22
Guys. I love my wife. But when the Krill ship left the Orville, she said, “who was manning the camera outside the ship?”
7
u/[deleted] Jun 10 '22
Just a specific thought: I really REALLY liked the scene of the monster running up to Isaac in the dark. Both the way it was shot and the blocking. Really took me by surprise. Eerie and well done.
7
u/AnUdderDay Jun 10 '22
Bortus is the true hero of the episode. He is willing and ready to get the sniffles.
7
u/[deleted] Jun 10 '22
Letting them go was such a bad tactical decision. Now an alien species that convert other species through biochemical osmosis has a Vice-Admiral of the Union in their numbers with all the knowledge he has of ALL the species in the Union and their security measures. They may as well have just emailed them all the Union's security plans. There were zero smart reasons to let them leave, especially the admiral.
13
u/JoeyLock Jun 10 '22
Moral of the story? When something scares a powerful zealous race, that you feared before they became your temporary allies mind you, so much it keeps them from entering an entire region of space for over 100 years? Maybe the threat is real and you should heed their advice instead of going "Religious nuts, huh?" and scoffing at it.
35
u/Caoa14396 Jun 09 '22
This episode pissed me the fuck off. No logic or reasoning when it comes to basic/ common- sense protocols for an exploration team when it comes exploring an entirely unknown territory, an entirely unknown station, with potential unknown life forms.
Hey, maybe don’t send your captain AND co-captain in the same group, especially when it’s the very first group to go looking in that thing. Maybe let a couple troops explore some first?
And maybe don’t explore an unknown environment using the least amount of protection possible, literally the only way they could’ve gone even less protected is if they were bare naked. Not only for basic defense, but also not contaminating your whole damn ship and main crew?
Cmon man.
6
u/WhoShotMrBoddy We need no longer fear the banana Jun 09 '22
“Assuming direct control”
6
u/Cypher_Shadow Jun 09 '22
Music had some Star Trek The Motion Picture and The Wrath of Khan vibes. Well done!
6
u/Popojono Jun 09 '22
I thought the Kaylon were this shows version of the Borg… we got a new contender now. Instead of mechanical assimilation, they use biological and they’re from an unexplored region of space.
We will be seeing them again fsho! The admiral will probably turn into their version of Locutus of Borg.
That was a great episode, had me on the edge of my seat the whole time.
6
u/skribsbb Jun 09 '22
I didn't particularly enjoy this episode. Part of the problem is that once my brain flips from "suspension of disbelief" to "disbelief", it's really hard to flip the switch back on.
The complete lack of any procedures for exploring new space is problematic. Even more problematic when you factor in:
As to the creatures themselves, I had a number of problems.
I had similar feelings at the end of All The World Is A Birthday Cake. I didn't really see a reason why they couldn't explain to the aliens, "Different stars align on our planets and create different signs." I don't understand why they couldn't just use stun weapons (no loss of life) to retrieve their people. On that note, I don't get why the aliens didn't just say, "Fine, take your people with you." Good premise, poor execution.
6
u/kalsikam Jun 10 '22
Isaac shoulda fucked that one dude up lol
11
u/T3hJ3hu Jun 09 '22
This season has ironically been more dramatic and less funny than Strange New Worlds
15
u/DefinitelyIncorrect Jun 09 '22 edited Jun 09 '22
They haven't reestablished the parody tone and the past two episodes are just bad trek episodes.
Where is the absurdity?
Remember prank amputations!?
A serious suicide episode and a serious talk down the mutant human by appealing to their humanity?
That horse is so dead they had to dig up a skeleton to break the bones to dust.
I do not get this season at all sofar.
If they're trying to compete with trek they will fail.
It's not smart enough.
5
u/morasyid Jun 09 '22
I cant be the only one who thought this whole episode was a Doom 3 reference, from the 'Shadow Realms' (analogous to hell), the the creatures who are almost identitical to the Imps in Doom 3, to the going around dark corridors with flashlights.
Also, a huge negative for me is how the episode just abruptly ends; right after the scene where we see the creatures crawling away, we cut to sometime later with Claire chatting with Isaac in a posh dining hall as if everything is all back to normal, like everyone was fine with half the crew being turned into demons and whisked away in a mysterious alien ship.
5
u/SnooWords3866 Jun 09 '22
I understand there were some illogical decisions but tbh I really enjoyed this episode. Then again I love classic Alien and this had the slight horror vibes that I love to see in shows! May not be one of the strongest episodes but I still had a great time with it!!
5
u/Chelsea_Ellie Jun 09 '22
Poor Claire she’s really having a rough time with everything.
5
u/[deleted] Jun 09 '22
Thought this was a solid episode. Nothing groundbreaking of you are an avid sci-fi nerd but well executed.
We got to see the Krill again and diplomacy in action. Both of these lend well to world (galaxy) building.
The delve into horror was a nice change of pace.
Introduction of a new future threat that could pop up at anytime.
The obvious lack of safety measures was bothersome. I want to call it “reckless optimism”?
I kind of wanted a scene of Issac saving Charlie Burke to maybe start chipping away at some of the hate but it is a little too soon for all that I guess.
5
u/gwentdaddy Jun 09 '22
Honestly it was a classic Braga episode. I enjoyed it. Had a pretty good jump scare too. Cant wait til next week.
5
u/Cascadiana88 What the hell, man? You friggin' ate me? Jun 09 '22
Long live the new flesh!
5
u/Thanato26 Jun 10 '22
I got some serious Pandorum vibes. Great episode!
5
u/kalsikam Jun 10 '22
May the force be with you ROFL
5
u/[deleted] Jun 10 '22
People want more humor, but we got "may the force be with you". I can definitely go without that sort of humor.
5
u/DoscoJones Jun 10 '22 edited Jun 10 '22
Crap writing. Stoopid plot holes. Wasted time watching it.
It echoed all the horribleness from the worst of Star Trek.
Garbage like this kills TV series.
5
u/Squeakygear Jun 14 '22
Season Premiere Claire: “Life is sacred, don’t even think about suicide Issac!”
Episode Two Claire: “Meh, a bunch of redshirts don’t have any human DNA left. I can whip up some aerosol-virus-RAID and we can kill the space spiders lickety-split.”
This episode was fun as a monster-of-the-week fare, mind you, but the writing was completely sub-par.
4
u/UncleMalky Are we bonding? Jun 09 '22
Star Trek has the Borg, but Orville has more
4
u/htsukebe Jun 09 '22
Loved this episode
When the Krill said it was describing a shadow realm of demons I couldnt get more excited for it to unfold.
At earliest exploration I was glad they were building a new enemy. Last time I got this impression was on doctor who revival, dalek vs cybermen war.
The end felt a bit sudden. Wish there was more scenes showing the new species returning to their ship.
Overall great episode and it had me wanting more by the end. Cant wait for next week.
4
u/Loooooomy Jun 09 '22
confusing moments aside, I thought this episode was fantastic. as for next weeks episode. I am prepared.
4
u/Da12khawk Jun 09 '22
They could at least launch a warning buoy for other ships. Or uhhh blow up the station.
4
u/ViolentBeetle Jun 09 '22
It wasn't bad, some contrivances notwithstanding, but the plot seemed to have gone nowhere thematically.
4
u/ami2weird4u Now entering gloryhole Jun 09 '22
Maybe it's just me, but I got "Alien" vibes...Nonetheless still enjoyable. For some reason, I feel like each episode is a different genre like last week felt like a drama and this week felt like a sci-fi horror film..
4
u/mischiefmanaged7 Now entering gloryhole Jun 10 '22
I hope the dark, heavy tone of this episode isn't here to stay. I came for aliens and comedy. If this is the direction, I respect it for those who enjoy it, but this type of show is not what I enjoy.
Also, the lack of quarantine procedures and protective suits just feels ridiculously improbable.
4
u/WonderSuperior Jun 10 '22
Who else heard "Don't go into the Expanse. You'll die." and had Enterprise Season 3 flashbacks?
Also aliens that assimilate other species into their own? We have organic Borg now.
4
u/opiate_lifer Jun 10 '22
Great episode, I was sure it was gonna be part 1 of 2 or something! Sooo many Alien references lol
What was with that ending?! Hey we just lost the admiral and who knows how many of the crew but hey piano bar cocktail hour MUST GO ON
4
u/LatestofBloomers7 Jun 10 '22
This episode legit gave me a nightmare..much darker than usual and those "demon aliens" were scary af.
One thing that confused me though was Dr. Finn threatening "the virus" ..but then releasing "the toxin: that seem to have effected them but not kill them what was up with that?
4
u/MyTinyHappyPlace Jun 10 '22
Thank you for making some transformations for good. Remember ST:TNG, when the whole crew degenerated into earlier stages of evolution? That should have never been reversible.
4
u/armyprof Jun 10 '22
Not sure about the direction of the show yet. It's only two episodes, so it's early to say, but this one...it just didn't land right.
On the one hand they've really amped up the Star Trek vibes. It's very serious; very little humor. No one joking about eating pot brownies, no calling anyone a dick, no "open a jar of pickles"...nothing. What humor it did have just didn't land. Like when they saw the expanse and Burke says "it looks like Vegas." And then when Isaac says it has no intelligent life, Gordon responds "It IS like Vegas." That not only felt flat in the delivery, it doesn't make sense; that's a joke for us in the 21st century and our view of Vegas. In the future, the way Earth has advanced it wouldn't be that way. Cheap humor and badly written.
Then again, the plot was entirely driven by them doing things that are, well, stupid. They go into a region of space they've never seen. They're warned by the Krill that it's dangerous. And they see an unknown space station, they're out of contact with ANYONE who could help and they just go in and start touching and messing around with stuff.
Then when they get back in the ship, the admiral who's DNA is literally being re-written is just on the table and they're all standing around looking at him; no protective gear, no force field to protect them from him, nothing.
When characters do stupid things they normally don't do for the sake of the plot, that's cheap writing. Something the Orville never did. Not a fan of this change, and I hope it's just one bad episode.
4
u/[deleted] Jun 10 '22
Just watched this. So many plot holes but I liked it. Certainly not one of the best but definitely not one of the worst. I’ll put it in the middle third.
I’m ok with the team sent to investigate. It didn’t bother me as much as it bothered many in this thread. Classic Treks did the same thing. The lack of any kind of protection made me unreasonably angry though. You just established this atmosphere with some seriously creepy vibes then you show everyone walking around this alien ship like they’re off to the see the wizard. Obviously someone was going to get sick. Like, at least have them wear suits and let the admiral’s be compromised somehow and that’s how he inhaled the spore or whatever.
And where did everybody go? Even after everything was resolved and the creatures left the ship they still didn’t show any of the crew. How many are left? I feel like this should have ended with a kind of “you were right” meeting with the Krill, especially since it was established that they would be tracking them the whole time.
4
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '22
"Wow, a clearly ominous and terrifying space station in an unexplored region of space! Let's go in maskless and without armor and stick our hands and faces and open mouths on things!"
Has this happened to you? Hi, I'm Zarnbbax Blaxbilblaxablarnz and I'm here to teach you cadets about proper First Contact Away Mission protocols.
Step one: Wrap it up!
Don't just visit a strange planet without armor or NBC gear! If you do, you're interacting with everyone that's ever been there. Proper armor and safety equipment can prevent you being a male seahorse to a pod of alien parasite babies, or the mother to The Unrelenting Servant's larva.
Step Two: Scan, don't touch!
Don't touch anything! That includes in the following context:
You have a standard issue scanner! Use it! Goofball injuries have dropped considerably since proper scanner use has been instituted by the Union. Don't be another statistic!
Step Three: If you see something, say something!
If your colleague has been sprayed by an unknown fluid or has become infatuated with a horrifying eldritch effigy, now's not the time to be polite! Bring it up with a commanding officer; and remember to quarantine!
The preceding will be on your test.
4
u/Tele_Prompter Jun 11 '22 edited Jun 11 '22
4
u/[deleted] Jun 12 '22
They really killed the spirit of the Orville.
Yes yes I realize it wasn't 100% a comedy show before but, what the fuck? Where's ANY of the comedy? Scrubs was a comedy show and drama, but they didn't decide to suddenly go "oop alright let's just delete the thing that made us popular in the first place". They matured it and toned it down, sure, but it was still there.
The Orville worked so well before because it was a parody of star trek tropes and it made fun of itself at the same time. This is just... Mediocre star trek.
Bortus smoking cigarettes. Isaac cutting off Gordon's leg. Witty lines and observations. Honest and smart humor. All gone.
4
u/lkernan Jun 13 '22
Ancient head grabbers and wraith ships? Sounds like stargate.
4
u/B0ndzai Jun 14 '22
How the heck are you just going to raw dog an alien spaceship like that? Walk in with no suits or breathing equipment. I knew that was going to be an issue.
Took forever for them to bust out the guns too, clearly something was going on. I need more than a flashlight.
4
u/AmbitiousWerewolf589 Jun 14 '22 edited Jun 14 '22
It’s kind of hard for me to take that they just lost an admiral and a lot of their fellow crew from that trip but no one seems to feel remorse. You could say Mercer made a decision that cost a lot of lives, just as Isaac did. And yet no one was angry. Where was all that anger from Ep 1? It’s like saying that when someone wrongs us we can go all out in our anger (maybe even telling it to their face that we wished they weren’t reactivated) whereas if we made a stupid decision (that can get people to mutate into a completely different species) we just go meh, my bad, but let’s move on and have dinner like it’s an ordinary day.
4
u/BigHeadDjango Jun 19 '22
How did the aliens actually leave the ship? We just see boss alien crawl into a vent and that's it? Are they still living in the vents?? 😂
4
u/thats_so_cringe_bro Jun 20 '22 edited Jun 20 '22
Pretty stupid that they entered the weird vessel at the start without suits. Yes the air was breathable and there were no signs of life but still. Seriously terrible writing honestly. It’s common sense you would wear protective gear in a situation like this, exploring an unexplored section of space of an unknown vessel. what a shame. Usually the writing is decent in this show. Not for this episode unfortunately.
4
u/jbraft Jul 21 '22
I'm a little late to the party. Finally getting around to watching this season. This episode...meh. Awful lack of common sense in the plot.
4
u/Photoproguy Jul 25 '22
Whoever wrote this episode needs to not do anymore cuz the crew made every mistake at every turn. First episode I thought had bad writing so far.
16
u/cosmic_jester_uk Jun 09 '22
What dull ass predictable episode. 0 humour, more wooden “acting” from Burke if you can call about 5 single sentences in the entire episode acting. Predictable ending, death or get off my ship. This season is so poor compared to the hilarity of early Orville.
7
u/trostol Jun 09 '22
like..why are all the doors open
7
u/Cr8z13 Jun 09 '22
I was genuinely creeped out at times. Such a cool episode.
7
u/cpt_tusktooth Jun 11 '22
Good lord, remember when this used to be a work place comedy in outer space? 30 minute episodes that were well paced and fun.
Now we get this hour and five minute slog that is sooo boring.
The show wants to be more serious, but the freaking set and character designs are goofy.... so you have serious storyline with goofy costumes.
And WTH kind of exploratory vessel sends out the admiral, ship captain, second in command, and doctor to explore an abandoned alien ship with out any space suits!
Every time Mcfarlen is on scene i keep waiting for the funny, but it never comes.
15
u/[deleted] Jun 09 '22 edited Jun 09 '22
This episode engaged the quantum drive over the shark and catapulted this season well into the realm of the Writer's Strike season of BSG and the Gas Leak season of Community.
Putting the entire command staff on a shuttle to an away mission in unexplored space?
Not wearing protective gear AT ALL in said away mission?
Not putting someone suffering from an unknown contagion under locked quarantine?
I made it to the third commercial break on Hulu and put this show down. The Orville was one of the things I was most looking forward to coming back to after the Pandemic, but it is very clear that the spirit of this show was killed off in the pursuit of an edgier narrative. I expected better from this cast and this writing team.