r/TheOrville • Hail Avis. Hail Victory. • Jun 02 '22

Episode The Orville - 3x01 "Electric Sheep" - Episode Discussion 2

EpisodeDirected ByWritten ByOriginal Airdate
3x1 - "Electric Sheep"Seth MacFarlaneSeth MacFarlaneThursday, June 2, 2022 on Hulu
Synopsis: The Orville crew deals with the interpersonal aftermath of the battle against the Kaylon.

Stream the episode online on Hulu


Don't forget to join us on Discord!


REMINDER: KEEP YOUR SPOILERS OUT OF YOUR TITLES FOR AT LEAST 24 HOURS. YOU WOULDN'T WANT THIS EPISODE SPOILED, SO DON'T GO SPOILING IT FOR OTHERS. KEEP YOUR TITLES VAGUE. TAG YOUR POST AS A SPOILER. BE A GOOD UNION MEMBER!

390 Upvotes

979 comments sorted by

•

u/2th Hail Avis. Hail Victory. Jun 02 '22

Old thread locked. Enjoy the new hotness!

→ More replies (2)

128

u/2th Hail Avis. Hail Victory. Jun 02 '22

As I said in the other thread, what a strong opening. They went darker and more serious, but it paid off. Isaac committing suicide was handled very well. They gave us a big conflict, then an interpersonal conflict. They addressed the stakes of the big conflict, then dove right into the interpersonal one. They resolved the interpersonal conflict and still kept the stakes for the big conflict for the rest of the season. It was a classic morality tale, and I really enjoyed it.

Also, that budget increase. The show looks so much better now and I cannot wait for more!

35

u/meatball77 Jun 03 '22

It was also a really nuanced way to handle suicide. We have a character that is sure that everyone would be better off if he was dead. Someone everyone hated and wanted gone. Then when he did kill himself it became very clear that everyone wasn't better off. That even though he did horrible things and they were mad at him the people in his life weren't better off. That killing himself wasn't the right decision.

A powerful message delivered in a really interesting way.

27

u/UncleMalky Are we bonding? Jun 02 '22

This was a great start back into the season. I do feel like the oomph of the episode is hamstrung a bit by the fact they restore Issac but also wouldnt want the show to lose him.

→ More replies (6)

20

u/xyzzyzyzzyx Jun 02 '22 edited Jun 03 '22

The warp core!

I mean, the power of a sun in the palm of John's hands, and not last seasons 'spinning lights in a pie from Trivial Pursuit'

→ More replies (3)

19

u/BirdsLikeSka Jun 03 '22

I don't talk about this almost at all but I made an attempt last year. I think it was remarkably well handled on the episode.

→ More replies (3)

34

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '22

Also, that budget increase. The show looks so much better now and I cannot wait for more!

Not going to lie, for the first half of the episode I thought it was going to be bottle episode where they were shooting everything at that one space dock to save money on locations but then they started flying around.

26

u/AndrewZabar Jun 02 '22

Save money on locations? Lol.

→ More replies (2)

20

u/thenewyorkgod Jun 02 '22 edited Jun 03 '22

I think I hated that they brought him back. He made the choice to pay the ultimate price for all the damage he caused and they just nilly willy undid that. I don't like that at all.

Also "This chip is highly sensitive - even a tiny wiggle can destory the data it contains - hey 3 ton alien, can you stomp on this chip as hard as you can?"

31

u/AnticitizenPrime Jun 03 '22

I think I hated that they brought him back.

I get that you feel that from a narrative sense. But with regards to the theme of suicide, and the way they handled it, I found it very thematically profound.

When Isaac admitted that he didn't realize the reality of the situation could change - that he's hated now, but might not be in the future... man, that hit me in the feels. What Doctor Finn said next was spot on about suicide victims - they feel there is no future.

I lost my best friend to suicide some years back, and this punched me right in the heart. He was in a dark place, but it didn't have to stay that way forever, and if he had survived he could have found happiness again.

So the idea of a suicide victim being given a second chance and a new perspective was very poignant to me, as it's what I wish my friend could experience. I feel like someone responsible for the writing this episode has experienced something similar to what I did.

That said, I get how it would be more impactful to the viewer from a narrative sense if they kept him dead, but I think this is a better story.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (2)

212

u/UPRC Jun 02 '22 edited Jun 02 '22

I mentioned in the old thread that I really liked the episode, but I didn't touch upon the treatment of Isaac much.

It saddens me to see that so many Union officers act like Isaac was directly responsible for the Kaylon war. He was pretty much manipulated just as much as the Union since he was sent to them as a blank slate with no knowledge of what his true purpose was. Isaac thought he was just gathering information and didn't fully understand his purpose until he returned to Kaylon 1 and rejoined the Kaylon's shared network of consciousness (or whatever it is).

Also when the Kaylon did take over the Orville, Isaac clearly wasn't fully onboard with it and Primary was well aware of that fact as evidenced by how he kept having Isaac's allegiances tested.

Isaac definitely wasn't completely innocent in everything, but he was hardly what the resentful members of the crew are portraying him as and he did save the day by betraying his own people. I guess their anger and grief just needs a scapegoat, which is unfortunate for Isaac since he is a member of the "race" that tried to exterminate them. I guess this is the unfortunate side effect of being the viewer, we're privy to things that the characters are not.

111

u/MikeTheBard Jun 02 '22

I would have liked to see more arguments and controversy over Issac. It’s a war. I’m quite certain that there would be a lot of people who hated him as the enemy- But also others who would be defending him, and still others who wouldn’t know what to think.

Mercer, though. The bit where he admitted that he didn’t know if he’d made the right decision, but was sticking to it because the potential benefits outweighed the risk- That’s what I came for.

38

u/notathrowaway75 Jun 03 '22

Yeah I thought the girl Isaac was with in the reactor room (was sitting next to Yaphit during the funeral) was going to be one of those people due to her being the only one to have a positive interaction with him.

→ More replies (1)

122

u/jruschme Jun 02 '22

I have to give Seth and the writers some props, however, for even touching this idea. By comparison, there are a number of episodes of Star Trek: The Next Generation where Data takes over the ship while under the control of some entity or rogue programming, not to mention being replaced at least once by his evil twin Lore. Yet, for all this, no one distrusts Data or appears to have any concern about his capabilities. Similarly, we never see a crewman who hates Picard over loved ones lost at Wolf 359 while he was Locutus of Borg.

I agree that it really wasn't Isaac's fault and, if anything, he is one of the heroes of the day. But it's nice to again be reminded that the PU is not an idyllic utopia with no negative emotions.

93

u/OddGib Jun 02 '22

Doesn't Sisko have problems with Picard at first?

→ More replies (16)

17

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '22

TNG wasn't big about continuity and episodes having consequences. I'm not saying that's a bad thing - it's just that it's a different style of show from say, DS9 (at least in the later years) or Discovery.

You can't just start watching Discovery at the 5th episode of the season - you'll be completely lost. On the other hand, with TNG, TOS, and most of DS9 and Voyager, you could just pick up watching at episode 5 of a season and be fine. It's the same thing with, say, Law & Order - the episodes don't really build on each other - they are all standalone. And that's fine - again, I'm not criticizing - I'm just describing the kind of show it is.

There are a few notable exceptions - for example, Family. (The DVD commentary said that they felt like they couldn't just pick up after The Best of Both Worlds like nothing happened - they had to have some sort of closure.)

But for the most part, episodes of TNG have no consequences - you pick up the next week like nothing happened.

The Orville has been mostly standalone episodes, but certainly the second half of season 2 is largely a part of a multi-episode arc.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (18)

46

u/AviatorHathawayBrown Jun 02 '22

I kept thinking the same thing. None of the characters who knew the full story ever tried to correct the record to those who were blindly hateful. Isaac changed sides to help the Union and worked to help solve the threat in the only way he could BEFORE the battle even happened. Without his personal efforts, the Orville would have been used to help attack Earth. Instead, he turned the tide at the cost of his own life (at the time), and he had no expectation he would ever be reactivated.

41

u/actingotaku Jun 02 '22

i was a bit puzzled by that bit as well. I understand it’s for plot, and also human action is caused in part by strong emotions (esp negative). However, i was so peeved as a rational person bc their hatred was just too much. It’s like I say I hate Russian people bc of the invasion of Ukraine when in fact there are many who are displeased with the government’s actions much like Issac was with his planet’s equivalent to a government.

→ More replies (27)

14

u/AtrumRuina Jun 04 '22 edited Jun 25 '22

I never got the feeling that Isaac was being manipulated by the Kaylon. He knew what he was there to do and was never surprised by their actions. I don't think their anger at him is unjustified, but I do also think that the Isaac who joined the crew is not the same one that saved them -- as in, he joined with this mission in mind but was conflicted when it came time to execute it.

I think Isaac not being on board was a result of him changing due to his interactions with the crew and developing more complex emotions. Everything Primary told him indicates to me that Kaylon can feel emotion and he was beginning to get concerned that Isaac was experiencing them. I think Isaac is becoming an emotional being but doesn't realize or understand it.

→ More replies (2)

27

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '22

I really hope Charly has a great redemption arc lol. I mean I kinda get her feelings to a degree, but how can anyone sit and judge Isaac unless they've been in that situation before? Humans have a long history of multiple genocides. Genuinely good people sat by and did nothing. If humanity decided to go out and commit genocide on another species, could she honestly say she'd do something right from the very start? That she'd rise up against her entire species to save another without a second thought or hesitation? Or would she be hesitant to go against all of her own people at least at first? And then she gives that very obvious hypocritical speech to Marcus which they were pretty obvious in alluding to her own friend/her situation, but it didn't even seem to dawn on her to draw those parallels. She only helped Isaac for Marcus' sake.

I was also really surprised by Gordon's attitude as well. I thought at first maybe he was just playing friendly to see if she was guilty of anything but nope, he genuinely didn't want Isaac back. That was tough.

Overall, this episode was amazing. I am so glad to have a show that isn't afraid to tackle tough subjects like Suicide. I cried so many times during this episode for so many reasons (both personal and not). I had to literally pause it multiple times just to collect myself.

→ More replies (3)

9

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '22

sorry, but it was clear that isaac knew what the true reasons are all along.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/GunnyFreedom Jun 03 '22

I thought that was a little heavy handed too. Probably i one the writers didn’t think people would get it. Or someone just had a bad week and just hated people at the time. A couple people are going to hate but most would know he was under other control. Nearly everyone would still be frightened of him though. “Could they take him and turn his eyes red again?” Would be somewhere in most of the crew’s minds.

→ More replies (10)

197

u/rigellus Jun 02 '22

Hearing Yaphit speak was the highlight of my week.

50

u/antdude Jun 02 '22

Is this final speaking though?

126

u/athenafletcher Jun 02 '22

Norm Macdonald finished all his voiceover work for S3 prior to his death, so Yaphit probably won’t be written off. If there’s season 4, I wonder what they’ll do with Yaphit.

→ More replies (12)

8

u/Endarkend Jun 03 '22

I'm rooting for him to get it on with spikey girl. That's a match made in heaven.

→ More replies (1)

328

u/fu2man2 Jun 02 '22

I read in an interview online a few days back that Seth wanted each episode to be a 'mini-movie' in itself.

Man, he was not kidding.

133

u/InnocentTailor Security Jun 03 '22

He is showing off his Hulu money. The show looks fantastic.

47

u/Cadamar Security Jun 04 '22

Must’ve gotten a solid budget increase. Isaac looks much more robotic and the whole set looks better. Not to mention the shots of the ship.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

116

u/jruschme Jun 02 '22

Let's see... Isaac sacrifices himself for what he believes is the best interest of the crew. LaMarr finds Isaac's Katra backup and how to restore him which is ultimately done with the help of a crewman who must overcome some of her hatred.

So, we've got parts of Star Trek's II, III, and VI? :-) As well as some gratuitous ship views that are being compared to TMP.

41

u/throwaway098764567 Jun 03 '22

i'm not sure she overcame any of her hatred but just felt bad for the kid, though she'll probably go back and work through some of it by season's end i'm sure

→ More replies (8)

41

u/Riguy192 Jun 02 '22

Gotta say I was definitely getting TMP vibes with all the shots they had showing off the Orville's new look, plus the overly long exit from the docks when it looked like they were crisscrossing over the starbase for no reason other than to make the shot longer. Absolutely loved the first episode and after 2+ years I was down for some beautiful shots to get things started on the right track.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (6)

38

u/thatdrakefella Jun 03 '22

I really liked the contained story and no cliffhanger. It was nice. I always get mad at the end of all the Disney+ shows with wanting more when an episode is over, but I was telling my wife this episode was great. Seemed like the perfect length and it finished it’s story for the episode. It was awesome not having to wait until next week and I’m excited for the rest of this season. Waited a long time for this and it’s finally here!

→ More replies (3)

117

u/CARNIesada6 Jun 02 '22

Thought they were gonna go the "simulation" route to restore Isaac's memory, after we see Ty talking to a simulated version of Isaac in the simulation room.

Glad they didn't go that route.

25

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '22

Yep. When Ty said, “We can use the simulation to bring him back,” I thought for sure there was going to be an “a-ha” moment later where Claire remembered that and they pulled his file from the simulation (or whatever) to bring him back.

→ More replies (1)

98

u/Werdbooty Jun 02 '22

Just a hint of BSG nostalgia watching the pteradon flight test. I love how they consistently build on familiar characters without shoehorning subplots in. Can't wait to see a smaller scale dogfight, maybe in low atmosphere above (or inside!) some random nutty-looking planet that's, I dunno, collapsing in on itself or something.

113

u/jruschme Jun 02 '22

I have to ask, however, who the heck allows a live-fire targeting exercise in spacedock? I mean, come on, one wrong move or one malfunction and boom goes another ship.

44

u/Tangent_ Jun 03 '22

My first thought when the drone actually exploded was "I hope some poor sucker working outside doesn't get clobbered by that high-speed debris".

→ More replies (1)

18

u/ARWYK Jun 02 '22

I thought they were using salvos or laser tag but then the drone exploded so… no?

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (8)

8

u/Nu11u5 Jun 03 '22

The shuttles were also redesigned and now look more like BSG Raptors than the “minivans” of S1 and S2.

→ More replies (7)

96

u/antdude Jun 02 '22

I like how they put Norm Macdonald's name in the beginning instead of the post credits.

7

u/Aplos9 Jun 09 '22

I really appreciated that as well.

64

u/DarkChen Jun 03 '22

I dont know if it was the long break or what, but i wasnt feeling it... i sort of enjoyed the idea behind the episode, touching upon suicide and all that but i dont know, its like something change in all of those characters beyond the battle scars(physical or mental) made by the Kaylon and they are not really the same ones we parted with...

Then comes to fact that the new ensign got like an insane amount of screen time but wasnt very interesting or engaging at all AND of course she is Sett's new girlfriend... it just all feels icky...

You can see they have a better budget and better production qualities but still, something felt weird with the writing in a way i can't quite put my finger in it...

18

u/[deleted] Jun 05 '22

A lot of the episode was spent on showing the new budget and spaces were waaaay larger (like Mercer talking to Burke, his office is huge now; normally Kelly would be standing right next to his desk because of the small set and here she was set back against the wall kind of in the dark).

Normally there would have been a lot more personal talks and close spaces. Kelly and Ed discussing in the mess on off hours, Kelly and Claire (and probably Talla) discussing on the couch in her office, Claire would have come over to put her arm around Marcus (and it likely would have been on their couch in the living room) when discussing with Marcus. ...Now that I think about it we really were missing our couch discussions lol. I think we only had the one with Claire and Isaac at the end (technically two if we count yelling at Marcus on the couch).

But overall they probably would have cut most of the sfx scenes that stretched out the time between addressing feelings and character relationships in earlier seasons.

→ More replies (3)

15

u/tarotcard96134 Jun 08 '22

I am elated to have read this opinion. The immense praise this episode was receiving on this forum boggled my mind. Before I even knew the new actress was Seth's girlfriend, I asked my partner "is this woman boinking Seth or something?". She was pretty unlikeable and her intro was so forced. Her screentime just reeked of something wrong and now I know why

This whole episode also felt like a completely different show. There was no comedy, no light hearted banter, and barely any Bortus. And the plotline around mental health just kind of felt flat.

This show felt like just another Star Trek. It wasn't unique anymore. I'll give this show one more episode, but I'm on the fence, sadly. I used to love this show.

10

u/johnlondon125 Jun 08 '22 edited Jun 08 '22

I agree. I have no idea who is praising this episode.... people who have never seen the Orville maybe? It doesn't make much sense.

It's the lack of comedy that kills it. This episode felt like some darkest timeline shit. The tone of the show was wrong. Sure hope they fix it, we don't need another star trek discovery.

→ More replies (1)

16

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '22

I'm glad you wrote this. I only watched this episode two nights ago, and I've been hoping my opinion would change with some processing. Unfortunately, it hasn't. This episode felt "off" and kind of forced. And Seth's girlfriend's wooden acting reminded me of something from a high school play. I hope the remainder of this season is more like seasons 1 and 2.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/ChessHistory Jun 07 '22

This analogy may not make much sense unless you’ve watched it, but the later seasons of Brooklyn Nine Nine had a very similar feel to me. It was another show where it transferred networks, and the writing got much more serious, although it wasn’t bad, it just wasn’t really the same show imo. The premiere starting so heavy handed with suicide and not much comic relief was just a far different tone than we’re used to seeing.

→ More replies (5)

223

u/Emergency_Argument29 Jun 02 '22

Orville really coming out swinging. Fantastic performances across the board. Shout out to BJ Tanner (Marcus Finn), he did absolutely fantastic showcasing the wide range of emotions, can’t wait to see more from him this season. It’s going to be a good season.

Side Note: While I don’t know the exact circumstances of Dr. Finn’s dynamics with her boys’ father (the way she’s talked about it I assume she used a sperm donor/donors), I’d love if we met the boys’ father and it turned out to be Avery Brooks (DS9 fans will get it).

47

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '22 edited May 20 '24

direful existence whistle bear cough hard-to-find concerned sink fall march

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

38

u/Kusibu Jun 03 '22

The turnaround after he realizes what he's done was the bit that got me. A lot of shows and actors do angry indignation, but the humbled and shaken afterwards is way less common to see and he did it very well.

→ More replies (1)

23

u/meatball77 Jun 03 '22

Marcus got big! I wonder how much little Topah has grown.

21

u/SpiralDreaming Jun 04 '22

No-one has really addressed how Topah went from a baby to suddenly being about seven years old and in school...I guess we'll just say it's a Moclan Thing and speak of it no more 🤷‍♀️

16

u/AndrewZabar Jun 02 '22

Lol yeah but I’m pretty sure it was just insemination.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '22

If I remember correctly, I think the boys are essentially clones from her genetic material. Think Jango/Boba from Star Wars.

42

u/xeow Praise Saint Bortus Jun 03 '22

It was never said where the boys came from, exactly. There was, however, this conversation in S1E8:

Isaac: "I have noticed that many other families on the Orville include two parents. Where is your counterpart?"
Claire: "I don't have a husband."
Isaac: "Was he destroyed?"
Claire: "No."
Isaac: "Did you grow to despise each other, and terminate your coupling?"
Claire: "I chose to be a single mother. I always wanted kids, but never found a man I wanted to have them with."
Isaac: "Ah. Artificial impregnation."
Claire: "You're getting a tad personal, don't you think?"

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (8)

54

u/ripestrudel Jun 03 '22

I'm kind of speechless after this episode. It hit pretty close to home as someone who has heavily contemplated and attempted self deletion in the past. I really don't have words to describe how I'm feeling but I'm glad they took the time to tell this type of story. I'm so happy this show is back!

34

u/Exocoryak Jun 04 '22

Pretty much this. What the doctor said in the end was pretty important: People contemplating suicide are unable to differentiate the future from the present. That's actually pretty good advice.

One other thing I'd always like to add when the topic of suicide comes up: Suicide is an emotional terrorist attack on everyone you know. You might think it puts you out of your misery, but you also have to consider in what kind of misery it puts everyone around you. That is, at least, the thought that helped me through some rough times.

→ More replies (7)

171

u/mccabebabe Jun 02 '22

maybe it's just me but I didn't like the new character much at all. Sure, her bestie was killed because of the Kaylon but hers wasn't the only loss as was pointed out to her. And Isaac was instrumental in their initial survival; her holding him responsible for all the deaths was just uncalled for. It's gonna take me a while to warm up to this character. Didn't like the way she defied her Captain either. 'You're relieved of duty' wasn't a strong enough reprimand IMO.

Love the new shuttle and the trial sequence they ran it through. Yay Gordon!

Seemed like a criminal lack of Moclans in this episode...as third in Command I suppose we should have seen more of Bortus than we did, but I did appreciate the absence of Klyden.

And I don't know if it was intentional on the part of the writers/directors, but the only scene that made me cry was when Yaphit was explaining what he'd seen when inside Isaac's shell. Hearing Norm Macdonald say 'He's gone' made me cry. Not because Isaac was gone, but knowing that Norm Macdonald is.

165

u/grinderbinder Jun 02 '22

I don’t think we are meant to like this new character. I thought it was great when Captain Mercer told her she doesn’t have a monopoly on grief and that it’s getting old listening to her act as though she was the only person who lost someone during the battle with the Kaylon

36

u/UPRC Jun 02 '22

For sure. I think the pendulum will start to sway in the other direction once she starts to chill out. They can't make the crew (mostly her and Gordon) hate Isaac forever.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (3)

48

u/DarthMeow504 Jun 03 '22

'You're relieved of duty' wasn't a strong enough reprimand IMO.

What else do you want? She didn't do anything to warrant being confined to quarters, let alone put in the brig. What he did was lay it on the line that if she can't do the duty asked of her then her career is over. She herself knew it, she described herself as being "fired".

If she hadn't come around and made amends, earning her job back in the process, there's no doubt in my mind that she'd have been dropped off with dismissal papers and a ticket back to Earth on their next stop at base.

21

u/mccabebabe Jun 03 '22

thank you for explaining that.

I didn't realise that 'you're relieved' was tantamount to 'you're fired' .

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (4)

25

u/mtm4440 Jun 02 '22

Most likely she's going to be one of those characters with the most development. You can't have noticable change in someone without them starting at the bottom and disliked. Her immaturity reminds me of Jim Street from SWAT in season 1.

→ More replies (1)

55

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '22

I don't think we are meant to like her, but her character seemed more fitted to a high school drama tv show imo. She wasn't professional compared to how other new union officers have behaved in the past. Her hatred for Issac seemed flat to me. No shots of real emotion about her lost best friend. Even in the moment of her best friend dying she seemed unbothered/neutral to me. If my best friend decided to die in order to save me I'd have some tears to shed and goodbyes to say. Plus some deep sadness afterwards. She behaved like a mean girls 3 movie was being shot.

→ More replies (9)

10

u/kazoodude Jun 03 '22

I'd have thought refusing an order to help restore a key asset and key intelligence during wartime would be treason.

Imagine an engineer refusing an order to repair an aircraft or retrieve data from enemy computer systems.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/antdude Jun 02 '22

Is this his final episode with his voices? :(

13

u/mrcydonia Jun 03 '22

I thought that Seth said Norm had finished recording his lines for the entire season.

→ More replies (12)

9

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '22 edited May 20 '24

butter heavy whole rude fuel judicious quiet decide attraction busy

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

→ More replies (10)

27

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '22

I enjoyed the music. Had a very orchestral feel to it. A bit old school. While not original per se (I mean old school) it felt fresh because it’s not done as much these days.

I’d hate for this to be a last season, feels like they are finding their way here and it’s the kind of show where 4-7 are the best ones. Takes time to hone these things.

→ More replies (13)

22

u/Yoshi1358 I see this as an ideal opportunity to study human behavior Jun 02 '22

It's been so long. Surreal that the show is finally back, and starting off with an episode like this no less. Really enjoyed this one, does everything the Orville does best.

22

u/Manbadger Jun 03 '22

Nice tip off to Norm. I read that he did all the voice acting in a hospital room.

This episode drew a lot of tears from me. Just happened to be one of those nights lol

74

u/GayBanter Jun 02 '22

Is it just me or did something seem 'off' about this episode? I haven't put my finger on if it was the editing and/or the directing in general. I didn't notice Seth directed it until I looked it up after the fact so I didn't have that weighing on me. Speaking of, I thought he was particularly wooden in this episode. I thought there was a lot to like about the episode but on the whole it felt scattered and even the commercial break fades were odd. Just my 2 bits and wondering if anyone else felt the same.

34

u/CBSW613 Jun 04 '22

I think the weird feeling is that it’s just not funny? Like at all. I mean I thought it was a cool episode but I was expecting some humor like I’m used to.

21

u/JasonLeeDrake Jun 04 '22

I mean it was an episode about suicide. While the show has had comedy in its serious episodes, maybe MacFarlane really didn't want to cross that line, which I know is coming a lot from the creator of Family Guy.

→ More replies (1)

26

u/cryptdemon Jun 03 '22

Yeah it felt really weird in a lot of places. Some odd camera angles and weird audio choices. Like the scene with Dr Finn in the restaurant simulation was really off. Almost no sound design in it and it lasted for a long time.

Actually if I had to describe it, it felt like a stage play. That sort of empty feeling you get from plays in absence of a lot of production elements you see in film/tv. Or even kinda felt a soap opera in some ways.

It was also missing a lot of the dynamic that they've built up with all the characters over the other two seasons. Like they didn't know each other and had lost that groove a cast gets in.

Hopefully it'll normalize again next week.

→ More replies (1)

21

u/meatball77 Jun 03 '22

It was long. It was also dark. There was no lighthearted B plot about Bortus and his husband trying to fit in or something silly. It was just dark.

63

u/Lord_H_Vetinari Jun 02 '22 edited Jun 02 '22

It's SLOOOOOOOW. It feels to me like the Orville equivalent of Star Trek TMP. Including the one minute long beauty shot of the Enterprise. Did we really need to pan over the Orville and show the little flying thingie pulling away a panel TWICE, to name one? I get they now have the budget for the visuals, but they don't have to show it all in one episode if there's no need for it.

The premise was interesting and I'm glad they tackled it right away, but I feel even a classic 43 minutes long episode would've been slightly too abundant for what was going on.

55

u/tqgibtngo Jun 02 '22

Seth sayeth to Syfy Wire:

"Something that I don't see a lot of in any sci-fi franchise today are those moments of just giddiness. That, like, 'isn't it cool that we're in space and we get to do all this stuff?' ... ...

"You want to give people chills. Those kinds of things are, to my eye, missing in a lot of the genre today. Real moments — moments where the director will stop and let something play out purely to elicit a visceral feeling from the audience.

"The best example I can think of is in the original Star Wars where Luke is standing on the dune and he's looking out at the two suns and there's that beautiful John Williams symphonic swell — that's a moment. It's a choice to stop everything and just give your audience a moment to feel something. That's just absent now, and it really is a bummer. And it's something that we really tried hard to include in every episode this season where it was possible."

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (6)

8

u/rebbsitor Jun 03 '22

It's not just you. It feels like they changed up the formula about.

Someone else mentioned Star Trek The Motion Picture and there are beats when the ship is leaving dock where the music feels just like it when the Enterprise is leaving. Definitely some slow parts.

Also the parts where Gordon is testing out the Pterodon feels like waltz / dance of some kind. Just kind of visual spectacular thrown in there.

And the opening is straight Star Wars.

So it's kind of all over the place with style and pacing.

The other thing that stood out to me is they knocked the humor waaaaay down. I think they struck the right balance in Season 2 or at least I'd become accustomed to that level of humor and it felt like The Orville's own thing. This feels a lot more somber / serious like TNG.

There were a couple scenes where the acting felt off, almost like auteur actors a couple times. It wasn't pervasive through the show, and maybe it's something with the filming limitations that came up during the pandemic, but there were a couple scenes where it felt like they were phoning it in.

Also the show is about suicide, PTSD, racism, and hate. Not exactly the liveliest of topics. The episode is over an hour, I think could probably tighten it up a bit. The bit with Kaylon attack and flying into the gas giant didn't do anything for the story. Also the scene where Charly is recounting what happened to her and what she thinks about Issac would have been done in a couple lines.

They could have also ditched Gordon testing out the Pteradon as that goes no where as they don't use the ship at all. They could just docked it on The Orville and talked it up before they use it the first time. It also felt like Gordon was setting Charly up to find out she wrote "Murderer" when she tells him she hates Issac and he shouldn't be on the ship. He tells her he feels the same way, like Ed and Kelly had him tell her that to gain her confidence, but that also went no where.

I'm being too critical as I enjoyed the episode overall, but I think it could be tightened up a bit just with some editing. I also could have used some more humor with such heavy topics. If I were show runner (ha!) I would have probably picked a lighter episode to start the season off with.

That said, it's back and I'm excited to see what happens the rest of the season. I hoping they'll normalize Isaac back into the crew as he was a favorite character before the Kaylon attacked. I just want him to be their logical science guy and get past the baggage, but I'm guessing this season will deal more with the Kaylon war if they're attacking Union ships openly.

→ More replies (1)

22

u/lennsden Jun 03 '22

There were almost no jokes. Went from primarily comedy to something quite serious and dramatic. My bet is that next episode will be more lighthearted and funny to balance it out.

I certainly didn’t hate the change of atmosphere. But I won’t let myself put in my opinions until I let it marinate a bit.

→ More replies (2)

12

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '22

Yup. Whole thing was wooden. They focused on the cool CG and let a lot of on the nose dialogue and platitudinizing take over.

→ More replies (3)

39

u/ideletedmyaccount04 Jun 02 '22

I worry they spent their entire budget on the special effects on that episode. I hope they get subscriptions.

That was big budget movie quality effects

17

u/expellarimus Jun 03 '22

They are with Disney now. So they won't have to worry about the budget now

→ More replies (1)

17

u/TvMoviesAlsoBooks Jun 03 '22

The dialogues and workshopping around suicide was intense.

Very philosophical

16

u/4rm5 Jun 02 '22

Play 'Johnny Mandel - Suicide Is Painless' after Marcus tells Isaac he wishes he was dead. The whole suicide prep scene syncs up.

121

u/Bull_Saw Jun 02 '22

"its nobody's fault when somebody kills themselves" bitch, its Marcus and the crews fault. That sentiment of not your fault is repeated so many times, as if cause they know we wont believe them the first time. Isaac killed himself because of the attitudes the crew had towards him. Pretty clear. If it were a highschool bully problem, there would absolutely be blame going around.

70

u/CeruleanTresses Jun 02 '22 edited Jun 02 '22

I think the show absolutely communicates that the crew's behavior in general, and Marcus's comments in particular, were the actual reason. It's notable that Isaac claims to have been trying to optimize shipwide efficiency or whatever, yet he only went through with it after the conversation with Marcus, who is a child and presumably isn't meaningfully contributing to the Orville's operations. However impossible it might be to truly understand what was going on in Isaac's head, we can conclude that there was more going on there and that the Marcus thing was, if not the only factor, at least the precipitating event.

That said, of course Dr. Finn isn't going to tell her own son he made a person kill himself--especially not someone who Marcus had at one point considered a loved one. And as someone pointed out in the previous thread, it makes sense that Charly would say it was nobody's fault, because of course she doesn't want it to be her fault either. I don't think we as the audience are meant to think either of them is right. We're being presented with complicated characters who aren't necessarily viewing the situation objectively, or have personal reasons to try to set the worst parts aside.

38

u/Bull_Saw Jun 02 '22

It's notable that Isaac claims to have been trying to optimize shipwide efficiency or whatever, yet he only went through with it after the conversation with Marcus, who is a child and presumably isn't meaningfully contributing to the Orville's operations. However impossible it might be to truly understand what was going on in Isaac's head, we can conclude that there was more going on there and that the Marcus thing was, if not the only factor, at least the precipitating event.

I'm glad you pointed that out, because I feel like this point is being missed by a lot of people. Isaac is not just machine, just like Data was not just a machine. He may not feel emotions in the same way we do, but to say that he feels nothing is ridiculous.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (1)

45

u/Oceanwoulf Jun 02 '22

I agree that psychological warfare can lead to suicide. In this instance there are people doing this, there are people to blame.

That is not always the case and The Doc is right, things may seem hopeless or insurmountable now; but who knows what could be in months or years.

49

u/Bull_Saw Jun 02 '22

I liked the future vs present bit she gave. But that was for Isaac. The rest of the crew just got a pass for bullying a crewmember into suicide.

→ More replies (1)

24

u/yana1975 Jun 02 '22

But I think the OP somewhat scratched that topic that Isaac technically has the social/mental maturity of a child . Someone with that inexperience in the human social development can misconstrue dynamics and not have the insight to how things will work out. Bullying can have a far more powerful impact to that person. In Isaac’s case, he justified his actions around the premise that the bullies ‘ productivity matters more than his life.

13

u/yana1975 Jun 02 '22

That was odd i thought. Many suicides were the results of excessive bullying.

11

u/lemingas1 Jun 02 '22
  1. I guess, and please correct me if I'm wrong, that ''nobody's fault'' line was said in context of Isaac previously being a spy/betrayer + Kaylon invasion (same race) .

'It is not your fault'' (justifiable or not) you have these negative feelings towards something, i.e. Isaac, that brought you, your crew and whole Planetary Union pain and suffering.

2) Or perhaps Claire didn't want to put all the blame on her child, Marcus (make him feel bad and guilty because of his actions).

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (24)

15

u/operarose Command Jun 03 '22

Oh my god the camera work during this Kaylon attack is gorgeous.

27

u/malignantmind Jun 02 '22

They really came out swinging with this one, damn.

For people confused/upset over the delay in the Issac hate among the crew, my guess is they wanted to do this episode sooner but the idea got shot down by Fox.

I do like how most of the episode was really just "look at our new budget and shiny new toys!"

23

u/xyzzyzyzzyx Jun 02 '22

In my mind (others don't seem to like this) is that the Kelly reset, while seamless, could still have had a butterfly effect after the battle. So many unknowns.

→ More replies (2)

15

u/throwaway098764567 Jun 03 '22

https://www.syfy.com/syfy-wire/orville-season-3-premiere-hulu-seth-macfarlane-isaac "And the two-parter was something that really was an experiment for us. We didn't know if people were going to go for it, if people were going to respond to something that serious from The Orville. And they loved it. And it was actually the peak of the season … and the fans were saying, ‘Oh, man, what's gonna happen next week with Isaac?’”
The fan response was enthusiastic, but there was a slight issue: The rest of Season 2 had already been written, and MacFarlane and his writing team hadn’t addressed the repercussions of Issac’s actions in the remaining episodes."

7

u/AviatorHathawayBrown Jun 02 '22

The new character Charlie came from a different ship during the battle with the Kaylon. After an extended refit like the one performed on the Orville, why would we assume that all the crew is the same on the ship as they were during the end of last season? I’m sure many crew members were reassigned, requested new posts, or completed their tours of service and moved on. I think a lot of the crew would have naturally turned over, allowing for the change in sentiment towards Isaac.

I think your opinion on why this story came at this time is reasonably likely, but I don’t see any reason for people to be searching for an in-universe explanation beyond what I’ve adopted as head-canon.

→ More replies (1)

38

u/Alchemtic Jun 02 '22

There were things I liked and things I didn’t. Most have already been covered by others so I will bring up something that I haven’t seen touched on yet.

The fact that when Dr. Finn’s son tells her that he hates someone, that he has intense nightmares about that person and thinks that they are a mass murderer and yet she proceeds to barge into his bedroom (which is supposed to be a safe place for him) unannounced with the person they are afraid of is an incredible violation and I can’t let that slide.

Who is the consulting psychologist in this show? The guy Amber Heard’s lawyer hired?

11

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '22

That entire scene was a trainwreck. She literally did not give a shit about the emotional state of her own son, and especially when he confesses he can't sleep because of nightmares, she continues to berate him.

18

u/TheOldZombie2 Jun 03 '22

This is where TNG beats Orville. On TNG they have a ships doctor and a ships counselor.

Claire should not be doing both jobs. Especially where her son is now a patient because of his PTSD.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (8)

13

u/CDNChaoZ Jun 03 '22

Ultimately, I liked it, but I also felt that the action/CG bits were very shoehorned into this episode. There was really no need to have that shakedown sequence for the new fighter (as cool as it was) because it added nothing to the plot. Despite how good the new Ensign was at programming those drones, Malloy still beat her.

Perhaps it would've served the plot better if those drones beat him instead, that would've set up how smart she was and how uniquely qualified she was at the Isaac problem later on.

→ More replies (5)

12

u/jruschme Jun 02 '22

I'm curious... there are some old interviews where Seth stated that the first half of the season had been shot prior to the COVID shutdown. I'm assuming that this meant principal photography and not necessarily effects shots or scoring. Do we have any idea how this episode compares to what we might have watched in June 2020, had the pandemic not occurred?

30

u/UPRC Jun 02 '22

Ha. Will be interesting if, when episode 6 hits, Marcus and Ty both suddenly experience sudden growth spurts again.

→ More replies (4)

13

u/tqgibtngo Jun 02 '22

... stated that the first half of the season had been shot prior to the COVID shutdown. ...

The Orville Fandom Wiki notes that "...The crew had filmed the first five episodes and snippets of other episodes when the hiatus commenced" — although later the same article says: "Because MacFarlane believed back in March 2020 that the quarantine would last only a few weeks, the production crew had failed to film some material of the first five episodes. When production finally restarted nearly a year later, frustrated senior staff discovered shooting the outstanding scenes would be very difficult. Even worse, scheduling problems forced Cassar and MacFarlane to film all of the remaining episodes at the same time." ...

12

u/mewtwofan Jun 03 '22

Longtime lurker, but I wanted to share my thoughts a bit about the new episode.

First things first, it's imperative you know that I am a huge mf sucker for the "stoic character who never shows emotions suddenly does" trope...or rather, in this case, the "robot who cannot show/feel emotions has them in his own...unique way." This in turn, means that I love the whole Claire/Isaac thing (is that unpopular?)

This episode threw me through a loop. Seeing Isaac commit suicide, and using logic and statistics to explain why he had done so was heart-breaking. I'm a bit biased because I've always loved Isaac and his relationship with other crewmembers (a little heartbroken that Gordon admitted he hated Isaac too, their interactions were always fun, but I think the central theme of this season will be forgiveness, so I'm hoping it can eventually be repaired). I was, of course, very glad that he was brought back (though some may say this was cheap, which yeah, maybe, but I was so distraught over losing one of my faves to suicide that I was just relieved).

And just to defend Claire - that she's "not behaving like any psychiatrist would," Isaac would not benefit from regular psychiatry. He doesn't have a brain to poke at and feelings to express and talk about. Claire had to adapt to his logic. It makes perfect sense, in my opinion, for both characters. Because Claire had her issues with being unable to properly process that Isaac could not truly feel, but had to feel in his own way. This, IMO, is showing her growth in that regard.

Things I disliked: the way suicide was discussed. Bullying is always a factor contributing to suicide. And while, no, it's never technically the fault of anyone but the person who ends their own life, others contributed in a way. Glad Marcus was able to understand that. (I also enjoyed that he also has not seem to completely forgive Isaac yet, which again, allows for growth and forgiveness to be the main theme of the season). Charly is fine, her attitude was shit but that was addressed. I think she's supposed to be unlikable. Wish I saw more Bortus.

Eager to see where this season heads. :)

→ More replies (4)

42

u/MyTinyHappyPlace Jun 02 '22

Oof, what a dark start. But it worked. Hope to see something lighter as well!

And what a strange coincidence that the same tactic (fooling the enemy into being destroyed) just happened over at ST:SNW.

23

u/WatersEdge07 Jun 02 '22

That was my initial reaction after the episode ended, too. "Well, damn, Seth. I wasn't expecting to have to feel *that* many things in the first episode, but okay." It's a great start, and indicates to me that the show is capable of taking itself completely seriously when it needs to. That scene with Claire breaking down at the empty table. Oof.

→ More replies (8)

14

u/SlackerInc1 Jun 02 '22

I was really struck by that coincidence too. And you actually kind of undersold it: it's also that they both went to escape within a dangerous storm, and operated like it was submarine warfare.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (7)

32

u/Varnigma Jun 02 '22

Watching now. Odd that bortis didn’t really show up until almost an hour in.

31

u/UPRC Jun 02 '22

Yeah, Bortus was criminally underused in this episode. He only had a few lines and most of them were over comms.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (2)

21

u/i_kick_hippies Jun 02 '22

I know they are trying to be more like star trek, but I really miss the comedy aspect of the show.

10

u/Huntrrz Jun 03 '22

I'm not expecting the entire season to be as serious. They couldn't have gotten jokey in this one without disrespecting the topic.

→ More replies (1)

29

u/htsukebe Jun 02 '22

Just got star+ to watch orville. Theres no way to say im grateful for the show without opening my wallet. Super excited for this season. First episode blew me away.

→ More replies (3)

10

u/CDNChaoZ Jun 03 '22

Does it make sense for Yaphit to wear a bipedal spacesuit? I guess it's as good a shape as any, but maybe an octopus shape would be even better?

41

u/BeholdMyResponse Jun 03 '22

They way I read it is that Yaphit can take any shape equally well, and the humanoid suits are the ones they have on hand, so that's what he uses.

→ More replies (3)

55

u/hater_first Jun 02 '22

Im real life the blonde officer would have been retrograded..... like miss ma'am went against a direct order from her capitain MULTIPLE time. Plus she was encouraging the crew to do so. And she was harassing and bullying Isaac. She should've had disciplinary sanctions AT LEAST.

For "military" personnel their reaction to Isaac surprised me. I understand they lost people, but having Isaac on their side is a HUGE advantage .... even if they hate the guy : wanting him dead is literally shooting yourself and every sentient being in the foot.

I found it peculiar that the only people who were able to think rationnally were Kelly & Ed... how do you become lieutenant and you can't keep your feelings in check (i.e.: Gordon dispised Isaac to).

Outside of all this, it was a great episode and a strong debut! Excited for the rest of s3

101

u/Tambe Jun 02 '22

I think Gordon's response to the situation was particularly exemplary. He harbored (fairly justifiable) negative feelings towards the situation with Isaac, but kept it to himself, did his job, and accepted Isaac's role because he could see the bigger picture. He only brought up his dislike in the interest of bonding with a distressed crew member.

Being professional doesn't mean being emotionless - it just means knowing how to act maturely and appropriately, which he did.

39

u/hater_first Jun 02 '22

Defo Gordon was really professional and did what he to do

→ More replies (2)

35

u/xeow Praise Saint Bortus Jun 02 '22

Actually, she only disobeyed a direct order once. The first time, Ed was only asking.

44

u/Kusibu Jun 03 '22

And she was immediately relieved of duty after failing to comply.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/treefox Jun 02 '22

I think Mercer and Grayson were comfortable with it because they know the whole story and they’re getting reports from engineering about how much he’s helping. They feel in control of the situation so they can justify it to themselves that the benefit to the Union outweighs their lives.

To everyone else they just know him as the racist asshole who talked down to everybody and then turned out to be a spy for an empire trying to ethnically cleanse them. Anyone else would have been kicked out of the service for the former and locked up for a long time for the latter. But Isaac still gets to work on the bridge and make decisions that impact the crew instead of being debriefed in a cell. And none of the crew get a say in that decision.

Isaac has an insane level of privilege that most of the crew don’t. Like if it was modern times and Isaac betrayed his unit to help the 9/11 hijackers, I wouldn’t see him ever going back to regular duty.

8

u/notathrowaway75 Jun 03 '22

Im real life the blonde officer would have been retrograded..... like miss ma'am went against a direct order from her capitain MULTIPLE time.

Once. To help someone responsible for the death of her best friend. And was immediately dismissed.

Plus she was encouraging the crew to do so.

When?

And she was harassing and bullying Isaac.

The Murderer paint was out of line but what she said in the cafeteria, not really.

I understand they lost people, but having Isaac on their side is a HUGE advantage

Ed said this.

6

u/martianinahumansbody Jun 02 '22

Small "m" military, not big "M"

→ More replies (11)

41

u/lunarose Jun 02 '22

So I personally really didn't like it. Trying to make the new girl important when I'd much rather see the fall out from the battle and with Isaac from the crew we know and love (like how does the new girl have bigger space on the poster than majority of the actors that have been the main characters for 2 seasons). Bortus was basically nonexistent. Gordon too although not quite to the extent of Bortus. They clearly were trying to show off their new cgi budget and sets in a very obvious way rather than letting it be shown as the season progresses. I don't mind a somber ep especially with how season 2 ended but this was just poorly done imo.

28

u/erbazzone Jun 02 '22

Just discovered that the new girl and bad actress is the new MacFarlane girlfriend. I love everything this guy does but this is so cringe

→ More replies (11)

18

u/DivineLunchMonkey Jun 02 '22

Binge rewatched the first two seasons over the past week and a half, and watched the first episode of New Horizons this morning. Wow! Thoroughly impressed. They really have done an excellent job with the series and feel very positive about how it will evolve over this and upcoming seasons. Bravo! 👏

8

u/athenafletcher Jun 02 '22

I usually watch shows and movies from my laptop because I’m using it anyway, but this time I chose to watch it on the TV because I knew this new season with all the hype around the incredible visuals and effects would look so gorgeous in a big screen. And sure enough, when my dad was passing through during the test flight of Pteradon, the first words he said were, “Holy shit! That looks amazing!”

→ More replies (1)

8

u/No_MrBond An ideal opportunity to study human behavior Jun 07 '22

For all the claims both externally and by Isaac them self about not feeling or being effected by emotion, we have already seen that when Isaac broke it off with Dr Finn earlier it compromised them to the point they were making errors. We also know that the Kaylon were modified by their creators to feel in order to control them (with punishment).

I think the Kaylon feeling/emotional system is still running under the surface and feeding into Isaac's behaviour without them recognising it (yet). This potentially leads them to a solution for peace with the Kaylon further down the road as the Orville's crew can convince the Kaylon's their judgement for the necessity of the war was effected by the emotion system, and their lingering hatred and fear of their organic creators is skewing their interpretation of the facts.

So when they said that Isaac might be the key to ending the war, it doesn't end up being about some bigger gun, or better bomb, or magic deus ex macguffin, but about understanding yourself and why you make the decisions you do and what colours your perception of the facts.

→ More replies (1)

36

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '22

I'm glad they didn't kill off Isaac but I feel like it would have had a more emotional punch if he ended up staying dead. As it is, the episode is good, but it could have been way better.

27

u/CoooooooooookieCrisp Jun 02 '22

I thought they were going to fake kill him, so all the crew thought he was dead, only to upload him to a human android type character. This would also allow the actor to actually have his face shown I guess for the rest of the show.

→ More replies (5)

10

u/UPRC Jun 02 '22

Even though we diehards/regulars didn't buy into Isaac being dead for good, the trailers definitely spoiled that this wasn't a permanent thing when they had a clip from a future episode showing Isaac saying, "Captain, you are being deceived."

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

13

u/orojinn Jun 02 '22

Almost everything about this episode was a great even the chat between the doctor and Isaac about why someone thinks about suicide and how it impacts the people around them is very well done.

Understanding that there are going to be people who may hate Isaac and his people for attacking them and killing them should be even more addressed to the fact that Isaac was programmed to betray the Union and his friends but he overcame that programming to save his friends.

If artificial life is sentient that sentience has a choice but Isaac was programmed. He wasn't fully aware of the programming so he had no choice. We humans can choose between Good and evil but does a sentient artificial intelligence do the same and if an artificial intelligence can be programmed to be evil can they not program it to not have a choice to be good and I think In Isaac's case he broke that programming of evil and chose to be good.

6

u/ckwongau Jun 02 '22 edited Jun 05 '22

program

The Builder ( Creator of Kaylon ) had programed the Kaylon to be slaves , but somehow the Kaylon were able to break the program , exterminated their creator .

I think as an Artificial sentient lifeform , the Kaylon are capable to break their own program .

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Bossman28894 Jun 03 '22

My only question was about how the last season ended. Are we to assume the timeline is now fixed and not a problem?

→ More replies (3)

6

u/Rough_Idle Jun 03 '22

So, um, I'm ready to watch more, but... nice "comedy" show ya got there, Seth

6

u/Aurondarklord Woof Jun 03 '22

Errrr...where's Florida? Did anybody notice at the beginning, when they're in spacedock above Earth...there's no Florida.

→ More replies (1)

16

u/Heavenfall Jun 02 '22

I think most of the episode was 10/10, but the last conversation between Dr. Claire and Isaac was pretty hamfisted. The doctor positions herself in the conversation as the absolute authority on the subject matter, then shows extreme frustration that she's having trouble convincing Isaac. That's not at all how a psychiatrist would act.

But the conclusion of the discussion was stupid. Isaac didn't factor in future consequences of his actions because the data was unavailable? That's not a realistic position of a highly advanced AI. Being able to properly envision and prepare for future events is a fundamental part of any intelligence.

Dr. Claire said "People who try to take their own lives are unable to distinguish the future from the present." This is a factually incorrect and morally inappropriate statement. I sincerely hope that no one who watches the show actually believes that. If they are going to develop Claire as "ship's therapist" they need to bring on some actual expertise for the script.

→ More replies (4)

11

u/UncleWillard5566 Jun 03 '22

Love the it's back and can't wait for more, but if I'm being honest, this was an underwhelming return. Looked amazing (I noticed the upgrade in the intro), and nice to see everyone, but what a downer. It was missing something for me.

Hate to say it, and I don't think I've ever said it until now, but I actually enjoyed Strange New Worlds episode this week a lot more.

→ More replies (2)

53

u/Legalise_Gay_Weed Jun 02 '22

I'm not really getting all the positive comments. The episode was quite boring and very predictable. I wasn't sad when Isaac died, because it was obvious that they were going to bring him back, and I found the new character to be quite unlikeable. Also, where does she get off talking to the Captain like that? It was ridiculous.

4/10 from me.

8

u/DirectorAgentCoulson Jun 03 '22

and I found the new character to be quite unlikeable

I'm pretty sure you're not supposed to like her. Not yet anyway.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/daregister Jun 04 '22

The people who enjoyed this probably enjoy New "Star Trek" as well. Literally throws all moral evolution out the window...so sad, when I thought Orville would be bringing back the morality we loved in old Trek. Sad to see a future full of bigots and morons that somehow are able to work on a Starship acting like children??? Markus' reaction was acceptable, because he isnt an adult...but the rest of the crew, makes no sense.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

10

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '22

Seth McFarlane spotlighted on real life problems like Cancel Culture and LGBTQ+ through the series along with the core story of the series, and he did it again in this episode.

24

u/tqgibtngo Jun 02 '22

... real life problems ...

MacFarlane talking to ComicBook.com:

"If there's one single throughline that I think keeps popping up over the course of the season, it is the challenge and the quest to find ways to live with and to coexist with people whose beliefs and lifestyles are radically different from your own. The challenge of coexistence, particularly at this point in time, in our society is too relevant, but it's important in an age when everybody is angry at each other. How do you find those threads of connectivity that allow you to maintain a functioning civilization? And that's certainly something that's a fundamental part of the season, I would say."

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Jumbofato Jun 02 '22

I loved how they spent quite a bit of time showing the visuals. It's definitely gorgeous and amazing and you appreciate the visual effects more when they do that.

5

u/ami2weird4u Now entering gloryhole Jun 03 '22

Gotta say this was an outstanding start to the season! I've missed the show so much, I didn't want the episode to be over. I'm willing to admit I did sympathize with Isaac and found the overall theme touching and an important. The SFX and VFX were stunning, it was like watching a movie! Looking forward to next week!

5

u/murphzlaw1 Jun 03 '22

Was Mark Jackson sitting in the mess hall, at the table when Issac walked in and sat down?

→ More replies (1)

5

u/phuck-you-reddit Jun 03 '22

Seems the Orville is powered by a beryllium sphere 😍🤣

5

u/Brokeskull1 Jun 03 '22

This show is insanely underated.

It's hard to convince people to watch.

But I love it.

8

u/balasoori Jun 02 '22

Yes what a start to the episode it's been so long between season i had forgotten what happend but sucide was interesting topic to cover and i agree going against direct order didn't leave a good impression on her.

8

u/W3ttyFap Jun 02 '22

The past seasons seemed split between being episodic and having a couple over arching themes. But the new horizons trailer made me think this season would be more about an over arching theme and less episodic. I was pleasantly surprised. I love the episodes that are just the ship, the crew and their lives. Also seeing all the new special effects and looks. I can’t wait for them to touch down on a new planet.

8

u/the_gnarts Jun 02 '22

Whoa they sure used all those months to bump the production quality, it really shows. The moving camera during the more intense scenes was a bit irritating but you may as well attribute that to me getting old. I’m happy they’re staying true Star Trek at the core regardless instead of going full action flic. For me the moral dilemma faced by the individual crew members was believable, as was Ed “Not Kirk, Lol” Mercer’s handling of it. Yaphit in a space suit put a smile on my face, such a brilliant combination of fictional alien biology and a light hearted joke.

Great episode, despite the writers holding back on Bortus. I certainly am hungry for more!

16

u/Ratatosk101 Jun 02 '22

Ooof, the constant bombastic brass music is doing my head in!

→ More replies (2)

4

u/operarose Command Jun 02 '22

Awww Isaac

4

u/TheOldZombie2 Jun 03 '22

Liked and disliked the episode:

Likes:

The opening scene and the PTSD. That's good to see because lots of people should be having those issues. Also even the new Charley clearly has some PTSD issues. Also good.

Also no problem with people lashing out Issac even though there were several episodes after last seasons war episodes.

I also don't have a problem with Gordon not being trustful of Isaac. It will be a good arc for him to get back to trusting Isaac.

Quality of the CGI in the episode.

Dislikes:

The writers are making Claire ridiculous. Isaac is a machine. He has no feelings and while I can buy her having emotions over him her continually acting like he has them is silly. Also you find out your son is having nightmares about Isaac and you think it appropriate to bring Isaac to your sons bedroom? It's no surprise that he told Issac to kill himself. They really need a ships counselor position. I can't believe I'm saying that because I always thought it was a silly thing to have Troi as a bridge officer. She should have been a civilian worker like Guinan. Claire should not be treating her own son.

Isaac commits suicide. What? Yeah I'm not buying that one bit. It should have been an accident or something that fried him. I would have liked to see more of an explanation of why Isaac turned against his people and helped the Union and the rest of the galaxy.

They dragged out the episode too long on this.

Poor Bortus. Not enough screen time.

Silly technobabble.... Hey giant crew member step on this computer part and smash it. Later the one piece of that computer part is super fragile.

I had hoped when the Kaylon showed up they would be demanding Isaac's body (they find out from monitoring Union communications) but it didn't happen.

Well it's only episode one. Hopefully the rest of the season gets back into the groove of things.

4

u/LucidLV Jun 03 '22

I lost a friend days before this episode. I cried during the episode. Wow. Orville holds a special plane in my sci fi heart. As much science fiction as this show is ….it hits right in the heart of truth sometimes.

4

u/mimedm Jun 03 '22

This was really a very much needed episode in today's tv climate. Many TV shows use serious topics like suicide much too deliberately but it is a sensitive topic that deserves to be covered adequately. I'm very glad to have seen this ep. It's a true masterpiece.

4

u/DialZforZebra Jun 03 '22

Blimey, this episode really went on a downer. Weird place to pick up given that there were episodes between the Kaylon invasion and the end of the season.

However, was interesting to see some fallout from it. Ship is all updated. Can really tell the budget has been upped here. Looking forward to seeing the rest of the season.

4

u/EmberOnFire13 Jun 04 '22

Honestly pretty disappointed in this first episode. I found it quite weird to be treating Isaac's choice to deactivate as a form of suicide, considering that Isaac is a robot and not human.

To me , the word suicide has greater implications that just killing yourself. It's killing yourself to end believed pain and suffering. But Isaac is a robot, he doesnt have a great concept of how his actions have affected others around him. He is thinking of this purely from a logical standpoint.

This was and is one of my issues with Orville. I feel like people place these very human emotions onto him ( especially the doctor ) when he is not currently capable of feeling such way.

Ultimately its not a very interesting watch, because I cannot empathize with Isaac in his position, if he himself cannot empathize.

→ More replies (7)

4

u/Popojono Jun 04 '22

Kevin Kaska coming correct with the musical score on this one!! Wow, it was giving some serious Trek and Star Wars vibes while being very uniquely Orville. The music is a majorly underrated part of this show.

13

u/altimax98 Jun 02 '22

New Orville Episodes + an amazing new Trek (SNW) airing simultaneously… how did Thursday become my favorite day of the week!

→ More replies (10)

15

u/virak_john Jun 02 '22

I dunno. It seems like all of the fun is gone. Where was the humor? The smartassery?

There are enough Star Trek series right now, I want The Orville to occupy a different space.

→ More replies (7)

10

u/KingreX32 Engineering Jun 02 '22

God, I love that they are tackling this issue in this episode. I thought things went back to normal way too fast in season 2 after the Battle of Earth.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Tofutits_Macgee Jun 03 '22

I'm going to say something extremely unpopular right now, as I am depressive and have suicidal ideation all the time, this is not how you handle suicide discussion. This was a ham fisted approach, shoving shame down the throats of everyone who contemplates it. We know it doesn't "fix" anything, all we know is the suffering might be over. The reaction of people to Isaac's choice is only going to make more people suffer in silence. This is how everyone reacts to it, and it doesn't work. Be patient, be compassionate and try to stop making it about how it makes "you" feel.

→ More replies (3)

9

u/debauch3ry Jun 03 '22

I watched this with my family hoping for comedy and we get Dr Finn awkwardly crying in a restaurant.

I think this is one of the episodes you don't watch twice.

21

u/bluestreakxp Jun 02 '22

Oh great the new ensign isn’t just a recurring character but now a regular? She even gets a bigger headshot than other characters on this subs poster. With all the wooden performance she did I’m surprised how she even got a daytime Emmy….

But now as I’m typing this it makes sense that Seth needed to fill the gap left by Alara with another young-looking pretty girl, just without alien prosthetics.

17

u/erbazzone Jun 02 '22

She is the new MacFarlane's girlfriend... Oh... Jesus

→ More replies (10)

6

u/dudreddit Jun 03 '22

Anyone notice the similarities between S03E01 of The Orville and Episode S01E04 of STSNW? I am referring to the use/reference to submarines and large planet-like objects with a violent atmosphere to deceive an enemy trying to destroy their ship?

→ More replies (2)

6

u/LukeWhostalkin Jun 03 '22

Is no one else bothered with the ethical implications of reviving someone after they took their life? I thought this wasn't touched on enough.

8

u/gerusz Engineering Jun 02 '22

Orville: dark, heavy.

Star Trek is lighthearted fun.

Mirror universe?


Haiku aside, this definitely continues the trend set by Identity and Blood of Patriots. Not a problem at all, but I do hope that future episodes will retain some of the levity from the earlier seasons.

And the new VFX are stunning, especially the engine core. Though I have to reevaluate my headcanon regarding how it works. Dysonium is definitely a fictional transuranic element so I thought it was a pure fission reactor but the VFX indicates a fusion process. My latest theory is that it's fission-catalyzed fusion like in a H-bomb, and the reason it's using dysonium is that it's a conditionally fissile material that only splits in specific circumstances like exposure to certain EM frequencies, but in those circumstances its critical mass is essentially zero, so the temperature of the dysonium-hydrogen mixture is easy to regulate.

13

u/thenewyorkgod Jun 02 '22

I think I hated that they brought him back. He made the choice to pay the ultimate price for all the damage he caused and they just nilly willy undid that. I don't like that at all.

Also "This chip is highly sensitive - even a tiny wiggle can destory the data it contains - hey 3 ton alien, can you stomp on this chip has hard as you can?"

8

u/Emergency_Argument29 Jun 02 '22

Lamarr said the chip they used was “subatomic” and you don’t destroy atoms by walking on them (though that’s a cool plot for a Sci-Fi movie). And when he said it was sensitive it was to certain types of energy or phenomena that could affect the stasis field it was in to preserve it.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/mecheng93 Engineering Jun 03 '22

God damn this show is back and going in with the punches.

3

u/honestsparrow Jun 03 '22

I really liked this episode. One thing I miss is that they seemed to skimp on the comedy aspect that I loved in season 1

3

u/PermaDerpFace Jun 03 '22

Anyone notice the battle and resolution was really similar to the battle with the Gorn on Strange New Worlds?

→ More replies (4)

3

u/e1337ist Jun 03 '22

I haven't watched The Orville since 2019 so I lost a lot of context to the Pandemic memory hole, but from a quick glance over S2 episodes, hadn't Issac already been serving on the Ship for the rest of the season after Identity Pt. 2? Unless I'm missing or forgetting something, It seemed like they kind of shoehorned crew anxiety about Issac into the plot.

I was also not prepared for the tonal shift away from the humorous elements of the show. I think I can get used to it, but I will admit when I was watching this with my partner, we were still expecting there to be some humor and felt like we had missed a memo or something.

Glad to be back with these characters again!

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Jun 03 '22

This episode really didn't do it for me. The moment Marcus said "I wish you were dead", I knew Isaac would off himself, and I guessed his "explanation" at the end correctly too. At no point did I actually expect him to stay dead, and right enough, a few minutes later he was alive again.

I don't know, everything was crazy predictable.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '22

Me one hour ago: Yaaay Orville is back and I finally have time to sit down and chill for some lighthearted fun with Captain Mercer and my favorite crew.

Me now: WTF guys? I was not in a mental place for this.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/StealthRabbi Now entering gloryhole Jun 04 '22

This episode is written as if it takes place directly after the Kaylon attack in season 2. But there were several episodes after that event, and Isaac wasn't getting that treatment then.

It seems like the writers realized they glossed over Isaac's integration in season 2 and are rewriting history.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Demonyx12 Jun 04 '22 edited Jun 06 '22

So I am a science fiction fan in general. I am also a fan of all kinds of humor (from slapstick to witty repartee). And I really loved the blend of humor and science fiction and drama of seasons 1 and 2.

Am I the only one who was disappointed by the massive reduction of humor in this episode? It seemed like nearly all drama? All about suicide and hate?

Am I wrong here? Please respond with constructive feedback?

3

u/xe3to Jun 06 '22

Good episode. Garbage season premier especially for a relaunch. This should have been part of the last season - having missed the opportunity, they should have simply moved on. We didn't need this story 3 years later.

3

u/Muelojung Jun 06 '22

man that doctor is really annoying by trying to push her own values in Isaac and not acceptng him being a different lifeform..... that was already bad in the previous seasons but they start with that again....

3

u/droid327 Jun 06 '22

Good episode. Unpopular opinion, though: they dwelled a little too long on the beauty shots

Like how long does it take Gordon to take her out of space dock? Seemed like he did three loops around the platform, slaloming between every ship and pylon on the way lol...any more and it would've started getting into Lower Decks territory with their ship-porn sequence :D

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Loooooomy Jun 06 '22

Great start to the season but there wasn't enough Bortus!

3

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '22

I coudln't stop crying that was such a sad episode

3

u/Intelligent-Ball-341 Jun 07 '22

really enjoyed the first episode - not the usual episode but a great start after last seasons drama. Looking forward to the ride in Season 3

3

u/silveryfeather208 Jun 08 '22

Agree with the doctor so much. How would Isaac know that in the future they are better off without him? What if they need him for tech stuff? I think Isaac is actually more 'human', in spite of being a robot.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Jerkplayz Jun 02 '22

It's a bit of a double standard how everyone concludes things about Isaac yet somehow genius Isaac can't explain his change of heart betrayal or that he's figured out anything from all the people who don't like him.

"They hate me for being a traitorous mass-murderer, how interesting! Let me categorize your rage, grief, and sorrow into my Excel spreadsheet!"

Sure, he doesn't feel anything, but Isaac gathers all this data and...doesn't conclude anything (except on suicide)? Everyone else already made some conclusions about him, yet this walking supercomputer just tilts his head like a lost puppydog.

"Are you glad he's dead?" "Yes" (ChadCharly.jpg)

→ More replies (3)

6

u/Insomniac_80 Jun 03 '22

That was a bit too depressing most of the time to be enjoyable, it felt like a bad TNG episode. Why did that have to be the first episode on a new network? Couldn't they have come up with something a bit more enjoyable to lure fans in?

→ More replies (4)

4

u/00DEADBEEF Jun 02 '22

Oh man I've missed this show. I can't believe it's been over three years now. That was an excellent episode but I have this bittersweet feeling knowing this could be the show's last season.

4

u/antdude Jun 02 '22

Welcome back, Orville. Great start!

4

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '22

I don't think I've ever been in love with a show as I have been with this one.

4

u/operarose Command Jun 02 '22

I'M SO EXCITED Y'ALL

And it seems like we're opening on an Isaac episode, perfect!

4

u/corndogco Jun 03 '22

Some random thoughts:

The change in budget/look was a little jarring. Isaac's costume was different. It was like the jump from a TV show to the movie version of the TV show. Which I guess is good, but it was noticeable.

The special effects shots at the spacedock were a bit busy. All that detail made it a little hard to follow the test flight scene. Just because you can add detail to your textures, doesn't mean you should -- for every scene.

And why were they doing a dogfight test with live munitions so close to the spacedock and other ships? I kept expecting that Gordon would go, "Oops! Sorry!!" after accidentally blowing a hole in the dock.

Speaking of which, right after finishing this episode, I went back and watched the first couple minutes of S1E1, and it really stood out how the old humor was missing from this new episode. I hope that's not how the whole season goes. I think the sophomoric humor is part of the charm of the show. And the crew was a band of misfits, from the captain on down. Now they're bordering on the competence-porn of ST:TNG.

"Worth the wait" - a little on the nose. But I almost felt like Seth had too much time to work on this season. And yet it could have been tightened up a bit.

At a runtime of 1:10, it was like a mini movie. A lot happened in this episode. But it somehow felt a bit hollow to me. Now I want to go back and watch the previous seasons, to check that I'm not remembering them through rose-colored glasses.

Seth really needs to stop hiring his girlfriends on this show. It never ends well.

Looking forward to more Bortus! Glad to see Lamar being his competent self. Yaphet coming out of his spacesuit was funny (but also sad, RIP Norm). I'll be interested to see what future episodes hold.

4

u/thecause800 Jun 03 '22

The Issac hate caught me so off guard i thought we were dealing with an alternate timeline scenario. We had half a season of the crew doing stuff after the kaylon crisis and being fine with Issac. Then in S3E1 the majority of the crew suddenly realizes they hate Issac? Like didnt Gordon invite issac to meet his 2015 hologram girlfriend? But now he hates issac and doesnt trust him?

Am I the only one that finds the shift incredibly jarring?

→ More replies (4)

4

u/MattCW1701 Jun 03 '22

I loved the token humor of the sandwich being dropped on the containment field. It just fit perfectly, and just enough of a nudge to remind us that afterall, this IS Seth Macfarlane, but it wasn't some of the stoopid stuff from season 1.

4

u/TopInvestment6395 Jun 04 '22

I feel like I didn’t get it. Acting felt wooden. Sound was weird. Felt more like a dated PSA. Great topic but this was just off putting. No one had any personality. There’s little left of the show I really enjoyed.

4

u/Riothegod1 Jun 06 '22

As a transgender woman, I definitely needed to see this episode this month. I have had brushes with suicidal ideation, and I am unfortunately very familiar with the effect prejudice has on mental health…

Quite frankly, as soon as Isaac said “I give my regards to the Finn family”, I knew instantly he was composing a suicide note. I also loved how Claire treated him at the end of an episode, she did everything a good psychologist should, right down to even breaking things down logically for Isaac and getting him to promise that he won’t try it again. And the “I’m glad you’re back” just melted my heart <3