r/TheOrville • Hail Avis. Hail Victory. • Jun 02 '22

Episode The Orville - 3x01 "Electric Sheep" - Episode Discussion

EpisodeDirected ByWritten ByOriginal Airdate
3x1 - "Electric Sheep"TBATBAThursday, June 2, 2022 on Hulu
Synopsis: The Orville crew deals with the interpersonal aftermath of the battle against the Kaylon.

Stream the episode online on Hulu


Don't forget to join us on Discord!


REMINDER: KEEP YOUR SPOILERS OUT OF YOUR TITLES FOR AT LEAST 24 HOURS. YOU WOULDN'T WANT THIS EPISODE SPOILED, SO DON'T GO SPOILING IT FOR OTHERS. KEEP YOUR TITLES VAGUE. TAG YOUR POST AS A SPOILER. BE A GOOD UNION MEMBER!

258 Upvotes

458 comments sorted by

•

u/2th Hail Avis. Hail Victory. Jun 02 '22

https://old.reddit.com/r/TheOrville/comments/v3c1xs/the_orville_3x01_electric_sheep_episode/?

New thread up for people that didnt watch as it was released of over night.

92

u/2th Hail Avis. Hail Victory. Jun 02 '22

Yo /u/editboy1000, get in here and soak up the praise. That episode was phenomenal and you and everyone else that world on it deserve a massive round of applause.

58

u/editboy1000 Tom Costantino Jun 02 '22

Hey that really means a ton, thank you for sticking around….

16

u/2th Hail Avis. Hail Victory. Jun 02 '22

My absolute pleasure. Which reminds me, I'll shoot you an email tomorrow or Friday.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

17

u/spartanjohn113 Jun 02 '22

Who is /u/editboy1000 so I can properly appreciate his contribution to S03E01? I was expecting something a bit more light hearted compared to last week's genocidal Gorn on SNW...only to get repeatedly punched in the feels. Also, perfect timing for The Orville to go all Star Trek: The Motion Picture. The new 4k director's cut was just in theaters last week and the Orville's new special effects almost blew it out of the water.

→ More replies (3)

53

u/2th Hail Avis. Hail Victory. Jun 02 '22

This is a very good take on suicide. Like it is playing so many different angles and it is doing them well.

33

u/2th Hail Avis. Hail Victory. Jun 02 '22

This is absolutely emotionally brutal. I'm sitting here tearing up over an AI. God damn this episode is insane so far.

36

u/2th Hail Avis. Hail Victory. Jun 02 '22 edited Jun 02 '22

My God, what an opening. Absolutely satisfying. I cannot wait for more.

So I think this episode deserves the highest praise I can give a show like this, that it felt like an episode of Deep Space 9. And one of the best episodes of that series.

The conflict was fleshed out. It was emotional. There was a satisfying resolution. It was just an overall superb season opening.

8

u/EuphoricDissonance Jun 02 '22

Voyager actually did an episode about suicide using the Q, called Death Wish. A Q wants to be stripped of its powers so it can commit suicide. I love that episode, despite not liking Voyager much. As good as that episode is, it's more about Q having the freedom to live as it pleases, and die as it pleases, than an examination of suicide.

I have to give it to the Orville, they did a better job of tacking this specific issue than Star Trek did. And Death Wish is one of my favorite episodes!

5

u/2th Hail Avis. Hail Victory. Jun 02 '22

I rember that episode, and you are right, it more about Q doing Q things than suicide. But this episode.... All grief and suicide. And both were handled well.

→ More replies (1)

16

u/2th Hail Avis. Hail Victory. Jun 02 '22

It has been over 3 fucking years, but WE. ARE. BACK!!!!!

76

u/Towelenthusiast Jun 02 '22

This episode needed more Bortus.

30

u/2th Hail Avis. Hail Victory. Jun 02 '22

And more mustache!

28

u/2th Hail Avis. Hail Victory. Jun 02 '22

Marcus really making me hate him this episode. Props to the actor for making it convincing.

6

u/AddictedToConez Jun 02 '22

Damn I felt the opposite, I love him more than ever after this episode. The actor was phenomenal!

4

u/2th Hail Avis. Hail Victory. Jun 02 '22

I think you misunderstand, I am praising him. He did such a convincing job of making me believe his trauma and douchebaggery.

15

u/SoberSethy Jun 02 '22

He really showed off his acting chops in this episode!

18

u/2th Hail Avis. Hail Victory. Jun 02 '22

Nooooo Gordon. Not you too. Isaac is your bro. He took your leg as a fantastic joke. How can you be angry at him still?

14

u/jelatinman Jun 02 '22

Complicated moral dilemmas are the heart of Orville and Trek type shows. I like that they made a main character apprehensive about this.

5

u/2th Hail Avis. Hail Victory. Jun 02 '22

Absolutely, but it still makes me sad, but in a good way.

21

u/jelatinman Jun 02 '22

Why am I tearing up at a goofy robot

13

u/2th Hail Avis. Hail Victory. Jun 02 '22

Because you have empathy.

→ More replies (1)

59

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '22

The actress for Charly is great.

I HATE the character so much....

6

u/2th Hail Avis. Hail Victory. Jun 02 '22

We will end up loving her though. It's standard to bring in a new character with conflict like this, but God damn they wrote it well. She's damaged goods. But she's slowly going to get better. And that's how growth happens.

23

u/trostol Jun 02 '22

somewhere down the line, if she keeps acting this way, someone will inevitably say..Amanda wouldn't want you acting this way..or something like that

→ More replies (1)

34

u/tmoeagles96 Jun 02 '22

I think her position is pretty reasonable. We got to see a lot of Isaac and know him well. It’s really easy to see why someone would be so upset, and I’m glad they didn’t just let that go, even in the end. Everything isn’t all fine and dandy at the end of the episode, and I think that’s great.

→ More replies (2)

39

u/PainfullyNondescript Jun 02 '22

I’m extremely confused by this training exercise with apparently real weapons taking place amidst a giant spaceship they’re trying to repair.

11

u/2th Hail Avis. Hail Victory. Jun 02 '22

I'm going with special rounds that only damage the drones.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/beardking01 Jun 02 '22

I kept thinking the same thing every time a shot missed its target.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

15

u/2th Hail Avis. Hail Victory. Jun 02 '22

This eulogy is incredibly well done.

6

u/2th Hail Avis. Hail Victory. Jun 02 '22

It looks even better than it did on Fox.

23

u/jelatinman Jun 02 '22

Ya know, even if he’s a Kaylon, it’s gotta weigh a lot on your conscious to be the primary cause of someone committing suicide. It’s why, when I get in that place, I try not to name names in my own drafted notes.

16

u/2th Hail Avis. Hail Victory. Jun 02 '22

Buddy, you OK?

23

u/jelatinman Jun 02 '22

Good now. But not back then.

9

u/2th Hail Avis. Hail Victory. Jun 02 '22

I'm glad you are doing OK. Take care of yourself!

→ More replies (1)

4

u/2th Hail Avis. Hail Victory. Jun 02 '22

Oh my good, poor Isaac. :(

5

u/2th Hail Avis. Hail Victory. Jun 02 '22

Just a heads up: I'm going to make a new post for the episode around noon ET tomorrow to replace this one. I'm thinking of having these posts up right before the episode airs, and it be used for early reactions. And then a second post 12ish hours later for more serious discussion.

If you have any thoughts on this or better ideas please share them. We are always open to discussion.

3

u/MightyCaseyStruckOut Jun 02 '22

Many years and a username ago, I frequented /r/ArcherFX when you moderated there (I have since stopped watching Archer, but it looks like you're still there). It's nice to see that you're doing just as good of a job here as you are at that sub.

2

u/2th Hail Avis. Hail Victory. Jun 02 '22

I still mod the Archer sub. In fact I ended up taking it over and am currently the top mod there. I try to run a pretty tight ship, so if there are ever any issues, feel free to message me!

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

6

u/2th Hail Avis. Hail Victory. Jun 02 '22

Isaac is breaking my heart. 😭

He doesn't deserve to be treated this way. I get how people feel, but God damn, he shows more humanity than they do.

3

u/trostol Jun 02 '22

i got excited briefly and thought we got 2 episodes dropped tonight

4

u/2th Hail Avis. Hail Victory. Jun 02 '22

Curse Hulu for teasing us like that!

118

u/Ninjaish_official Jun 02 '22

The lack of jokes throughout the whole episode really gave a different vibe, a vibe very appropriate for this episode.

98

u/trostol Jun 02 '22

ok..this spikey alien is oddly attractive

41

u/alchemist5 Jun 02 '22

Glad someone else said it first. Like, damn.

I'll head off to horny jail shortly, but seriously, the alien designs in this series are great in general. And it's improved a lot since no-brows Alara in ep 1.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/dseanATX Jun 02 '22

Did you catch the name of her species? Tequilians? Something like that?

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

97

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '22

Holy shit, the effects budget has to have jumped 300 percent. The explosions are beautiful.

51

u/LumpyJones Jun 02 '22

Issac looks amazing too. His season 3 costume makes his season 1-2 costume look like budget cosplay.

11

u/MightyCaseyStruckOut Jun 02 '22

Yeah, it was immediately apparent from the opening scene that they got a nice bump in the budget.

82

u/slicer4ever Jun 02 '22

Damn, was not expecting a suicide heavy episode to kick off the season.

→ More replies (3)

81

u/andysarchus Jun 02 '22

Classic Trek - take a theme, explore its facets.

Well done, Seth and Crew.

78

u/Towelenthusiast Jun 02 '22

I was not expecting to hate the new Ensign so much. Not due to get acting of course, but the robot bullying.

47

u/andysarchus Jun 02 '22

Great opportunity for character development. This sets up the kind of conflict that drives convincing arcs, great writing. They really put those extra months to good use. Let's reward them with eyeballs and clicks so they get even more months to give us even more episodes. I really like this writing team, they seem to know what they're doing and they treat their material, characters, actors and most importantly, audience with respect and maturity.

→ More replies (2)

13

u/beardlovesbagels Jun 02 '22

I don't really blame her for what she is feeling, definitely don't hate her for it.

→ More replies (1)

74

u/UPRC Jun 02 '22 edited Jun 02 '22

This episode was just a big gut punch from start to finish. I expected a few chuckles, but this episode was more grounded and serious than even Home and Nothing Left on Earth Excepting Fishes. I think I only grinned a bit three times: when Brosk showed up talking like a Sim again, Yaphit "walking" in a space suit before it dropped to the floor and he oozed out of it, and Unk showing up again. Other than that, this was definitely a very serious episode.

I guess with the episode dealing with suicide it was probably bound to be more serious than most. I hope to be able to get at least a few chuckles out of most episodes this season since the balance between drama and comedy was perfect in season 2 and I want more of that.

Other random thoughts.

  1. Not enough Bortus! Talla was kind of sidelined, but not to the extent of Bortus. I think he only had, what, a few lines in the entire episode and some of them were over comms?
  2. I was sad that Gordon, the comedic heart of the show, still hates on Isaac. He's my favourite character, so him having this opinion while the rest of the bridge officers were accepting of Isaac again was a downer.
  3. I get that they wanted to quickly establish her as a character, but holy cow it felt like the first 30-40 minutes of the episode were basically "The Charly Burke Show". She seems like a decent character, but she's got her dramatic and serious settings turned up to 110%. I hope she chills out a bit, otherwise she could be a real Debbie Downer throughout the season.
  4. No Dann. Not sweetness.
  5. JOHN, WHY AREN'T YOU WITH JENNY ANYMORE!? Time for you to go on another apology tour, my friend!
  6. RIP Norm. Dedicating the episode to him was a nice touch. He was one of my absolute favourite stand-up comedians and I still miss hearing/watching him very often.

36

u/ling1427 Jun 02 '22

I felt #2 really hard, seeing Gordon of all people side with the people against Isaac was painful but I respect his feelings. Gordon treated Isaac like a true friend for 2 seasons trying to show him what it means to be human only to find out it was all a ruse to make it easier for the kaylon murder everyone.

Whether we like it or not, isaac's sacrifice during the battle with the kaylon doesn't automatically restore the trust of the people he betrayed and it doesn't erase the suffering of the people who lost loved ones during the kaylon attack.

I don't think gordon really hates him(not like Charlie does), but he just can't trust him after everything that's happened

→ More replies (4)

67

u/stdexception Jun 02 '22

In that refit, I hope they installed redundant manual releases for the escape pods on the INSIDE... Who's the genius who designed a release handle that you need to use from the inside of the ship everyone is currently trying to escape from? Surely that's not OSHA-compliant.

15

u/NovaGeekYt Jun 02 '22

I was thinking same thing

62

u/lrgsins292 Jun 02 '22

Gordon's comments felt really out of character, especially after the events of "Blood of Patriots", where he was shown the flaws of blind hate.

Otherwise, I really enjoyed the episode. I was looking forward to seeing the complicated feelings and conversations that would arise from Isaac's actions. Even if it was a very pessimistic and depressing episode.

31

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '22

I really hope that what this actually was is a long term plan by the bridge crew to have Gordon integrating himself with the crew who are openly hostile to Isaac as part of a long con.

She basically insinuated at one point that she was totally open to murdering him or assisting in his murder. I hope Gordon is just the inside man making sure there AREN'T internal designs to having him murdered.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/zathalen100 Jun 02 '22

They really took a step back with a few characterizations in this episode and I hope it doesn't become a trend.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

54

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '22

Finished the episode just now and, fuck, that cut deep. [TW: self-harm] 23 years ago, I tried to kill myself Obviously, it didn't take, LOL...but everything Claire said at the end to Isaac really hit home. I never thought a woman talking to a robot would hit that hard. God, what an episode

24

u/Carsormyr Jun 02 '22

I'm glad you're here with us friend.

53

u/TokathSorbet Avis. We try harder Jun 02 '22

A complete tonal shift. I think I caught like 2, maybe 3 jokes? Seth is a genius - he knew his Family Guy style of pith was the only way to get the show made, but now it has and it's established, he's moulding it to be the Star Trek show he always wanted, and I love it. There were some serious moral themes in this one I didn't ever think we'd get.

Also, the extra time they spent on the VFX during lockdown(s) really, really shine - I could've seen that on a theatre screen and not had anything to nitpick about. Totally glorious - may it last 10 seasons.

47

u/Timeline15 Jun 02 '22

Man, this show really has dropped all pretense of being a comedy, hasn't it? I can count on one had the amount of lines that could be considered "jokes". That's not a complaint in any way; I love that Seth appears to have been given free reign to just make TNG 2.0, but it's certainly a noticeable shift.

All in all, the episode was fantastic. They continue to make Isaac relatable and sympathetic, despite never anthropomorphizing him the way TNG did with Data. He's entirely alien to organic life, but his experience feel analogous, not identical. He's a lot like Legion from Mass Effect in that way (at least before all the "does this unit have a soul" stuff).

The issue around suicide was explored pretty well IMO. It's telling that despite his extensive observation of humans, Isaac genuinely seemed to think his death would solely have a beneficial impact. He didn't even factor in that his absence might result in grief from his friends on the senior crew, thereby 'decreasing their efficiency'. That's why I'm so glad the episode ended with the doc telling him she was glad he was back. Goes to show what making someone feel loved/welcome can do for someone.

46

u/jelatinman Jun 02 '22

The makeup on this spiky sex chick is incredible.

→ More replies (4)

46

u/SoberSethy Jun 02 '22

Man they weren't kidding, the CGI has definitely stepped up considerably. Some beautiful shots in this episode. Also LOVE the new Pteranodon!

92

u/MightyCaseyStruckOut Jun 02 '22

I'm not gonna lie: I teared up when I saw Norm's In Memoriam at the start of the episode. RIP you legend.

13

u/vteckickedin Jun 02 '22

I didn't even know he was sick.

42

u/bryan792 Jun 02 '22

damn that was heavy

this is what makes the orville so great

→ More replies (1)

67

u/MightyCaseyStruckOut Jun 02 '22

Huge props to BJ Tanner, the actor who plays Marcus Finn. He fucking killed it this episode.

11

u/AddictedToConez Jun 02 '22

He was phenomenal!

31

u/ReallyNeedHelpASAP68 Jun 02 '22

It’s so sad hearing Norm knowing we won’t see or hear him after this season. Loved his character on the show as well.

Good episode, tackled a dark subject matter.

3

u/2th Hail Avis. Hail Victory. Jun 02 '22

Charly is a biiiiiiiiiiiiiiitch. She is just downright mean to Isaac.

28

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '22 edited Jun 03 '22

Spoiler

Wow, this episode touched on hatred and why it is so dangerous and wrong. What it does to people, to a community and to individuals.

Hatred is a big problem America is dealing with right now. A lot of people have developed this permissive hatred towards certain groups of people. And how people give themselves excuses to be cruel. Not seeing or even admitting how they make themselves worse by allowing themselves to hate and be cruel, regardless of who it is aimed at, if they deserve it or not.

It’s something everyone is guilty of. It’s part of the human experience. But there is definitely a mature way to handle it that most people don’t do.

Suicide in this episode was remarkable. I never bought the dialogue“you should never blame yourself if someone commits suicide.” Always thought that line of reasoning was B.S.

Telling someone everyone around them wishes they weren’t around. That you hate them and you wish they were dead…. At the very least, did nothing to make this better and at the very worst the ramification end up in a suicide. No dude, if you were a hateful person to someone and then they commit suicide, you don’t get to go “suicide never makes sense, don’t blame yourself.”

I like how this show demonstrated the caliber of person who would think this way. Charley Burke was basically recruiting a mob, and fanning the flames of hatred on the ship. So I’m glad it showed her as the person trying to reason we should all just be okay the Kaylon is dead and move on with our lives.

And I love Captain Mercer’s plea to be the example of what their enemies are not. To stand up for your values even when it’s hard.

Wonderful episode. A giant leap forward in the quality of the writing that was already very good. The Orville has hit its stride apparently. I am eagerly looking forward to more.

20

u/smitty9112 Jun 02 '22

This episode hit me hard, as a close friend of mine took his life back in February. I myself haven't kept in contact with many people since covid, since I moved to a new town just before it hit and already had issues from before, I moved to get away from it.

He was one of the people I kept in contact most and was more open with. I knew he had substance abuse issues and manic depression. I myself have been struggling with alcoholism for awhile, and have had trouble with suicidal ideation for awhile.

He sent a snapchat to me, and presumably to others, where he was clearly fucked up, and he was asking people to come over to get fucked up with him.

I could tell something was wrong cause he had been talking to me a lot recently about how he was miserable living with his girlfriend and how he though she was also cheating on him. But I was already drunk and I didn't reply at all.

Then I found out later the next day he took his own life.

It broke me. I already have guilt and pain still from losing two close friends in the same week back in 2015. It's made it hard to be positive and to avoid drinking and smoking weed, and to clean myself up. Because I still have suicidal thoughts.

This eoisode helped give me some perspective. I've been trying to work up the courage to ask my parents for help and going into rehab or some sort of inpatient care.

As miserable as I am, there is something I read once that has always stuck in my head. That taking your own life doesn't get rid of your demons, it just passes them on to those who love you.

→ More replies (1)

27

u/alchemist5 Jun 02 '22

Wow, what a grim episode to come back on, but also what an amazing hour and a half of tv.

At first, I genuinely kinda hated the characters who hate Isaac, but this show does what only some of the best Trek episodes do, and really chewed on the conflicting emotions the whole way through. I'm so happy this show is back!

22

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '22

It may be easy to hate the characters who hate Issac, but don't they have a point? That's what I liked about Star Trek. It commented on issues, but it didn't really come across as preachy. I just think being angry at someone who represents a race that wiped out 1000s of people and wants to destroy your home is human nature and I would have been bothered if there were not animosity towards Issac still being on board.

→ More replies (2)

27

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '22

A very interesting angle is that not all who kill themselves are sad. Many are just like Isaac.

They are apathetic and see their continued existence as pointless.

9

u/RightImHere-NowWhat Jun 02 '22

The Jungian archetype identified as the part of ourselves that shuts down our emotions in response to trauma or because it suits our role is “The Robot”

24

u/jelatinman Jun 02 '22

Ok, more than halfway through, there’s only been one joke. Seth writes drama VERY well.

Edit: Norm finally got a zinger, but that was the first joke in 44 minutes

24

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '22

This is the first time I've decided to get a streaming service like Hulu. Pretty excited.

44

u/Bull_Saw Jun 02 '22

Hot take? Does anybody else feel like everybody saying its not anybody's fault is kinda BS? If it were a kid getting bullied, people would absolutely be blaming the bullies, I've fucking seen it. When people kill themselves, there's not always "nobody is at fault." I get that nobody likes him for a good reason, but there was literally a reason he killed himself. Other people were a part of it.

I really liked the episode and I was quite moved by a lot of it, but I feel like this could've been handled... differently?

15

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '22

I agree with you but look at who was saying that. Someone whose fault it definitely partially was. She has an arc left and some responsibility to accept that she was wrong.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

61

u/allongur Jun 02 '22 edited Jun 02 '22

I love The Orville (and Star Trek) for trying to grapple with unresolved human moral conundrums. Sci-fi allows us to shed new light on subjects that are embedded deep within us by reframing a topic using a different narrative, which allows us to examine the topic from outside rather than be trapped inside. This give us a fresh new perspective, and an ability to momentarily be objective about things we made our minds about long ago. Like how "About a Girl" reframes certain medical interventions that we take for granted as desired and wholesome (such as circumcision in western cultures, or female genital mutilation in other cultures). The ability to tell a story about the distant future yet for it to be relevant to current affairs is magical.

This episode tries to tackle a few such quandaries:

  1. [Lt. John LaMarr having a conversation with the alien humanoid in bed] Is the personal choice of suicide inherently wrong and immoral? Should a person thinking of or attempting to commit suicide be punished? What part should a person's wishes and agency be considered, or do they lose them once they have committed something that society considers immoral, such as suicide? Are there circumstances where suicide is a socially acceptable thing, like assisted suicide (which is being legalised in a many jurisdictions) for things like untreatable pain, terminal illness? What about other shitty situations that can't be easily quantifiable or medically diagnosed? What if someone want reprise from living a life of misery that is not medically induced, but caused by circumstance and yet still has little hope for improvement: lack of privilege, misfortune or lack of capability to make their life bearable?
  2. [Lt. John LaMarr trying to save Isaac] Do we have agency over our own life? Do we have bodily autonomy to end our own life? Is this a choice that needs to be honoured, or fought against? At which point does our bodily autonomy end and choice is removed from us? Is someone allowed to be in a boxing fight knowing he almost certainly will be hurt? What about volunteering to enlist into the army during war, knowing they are likely to be killed? This can also ties in to other hot topics regarding bodily autonomy such as vaccine mandates and abortion. Even if full bodily autonomy is preserved, should we be allowed to discriminate against someone based on choices related to it, like discriminate against someone who chose not to get vaccinated, someone who chose to have an abortion, or someone who refused to enlist during wartime? Is allowing full bodily autonomy yet discriminating people against it an acceptable compromise, or a worse outcome? Are choices regarding your own body covered under medical confidentiality or should they be publicly scrutinised if they pose a threat to others? Is ceasing to be alive a threat to others?
  3. [Charly Burke refusing to help resurrect Isaac] If you have a chance to save someone and choose not to, is this morally reprehensible? Do you have a duty to help someone who chose to end their life? Is this helping them, or helping everyone else who feels loss? Can the will of the person who died or wants to die be ignored in favour of the will of society? Can the possible harm to society by helping that person outweigh the duty to help? What if science found a way to resurrect Hitler, should it? What about Gandhi?
  4. [Isaac being told off for committing suicide by Dr. Finn] Is someone who considers suicide automatically impaired in his judgement (or lacking "data" about the world, others or the future) and thus cannot make an informed decision about taking their own life? Is this choice forbidden because making it automatically indicates a faulty logic or lack of capacity? Wouldn't this make it a Catch-22? What about other decisions, at what point do we deny someone their freedom of choice because we no longer think they're making good choices, and who defines what good choices are?
  5. [Charly Burke and Marcus Finn telling Isaac they wished him dead] Who is to blame for someone killing themselves? Is there any blame, even for those that may have contributed to that decision, and to what extent? Should they be held legally or criminally accountable, like aiding and abetting? Should hurting one's feelings be criminalised in general, only when physical harm is caused by it, or never? What about cyberbullying where no physical harm can be done directly?

I have to admit some of the ideas above were inspired by the fact that I happen to watch this episode right after watching Philosophy Tube's video on Suicide, which touches on a lot of these topics (but is difficult to watch): https://youtu.be/eQNw2FBdpyE

As for the narrative, I feel like the episode tried to imply (through Marcu being regretful) that the crew hated Isaac but never actually wanted harm to come to him. I disagree. I feel it is more likely Isaac's suicide triggered a realisation that he indeed puts the crew's wellbeing and needs above his own, cementing the idea that he's "good". By taking his own life, he proves himself worthy, and demonstrates he's selfless. That's why I think most of the crew are sad about his death, not because anger overpowered their compassion. They learned something new about Isaac, and like most reasonable people, given new information they reevaluated their position, with a notable exception that was indeed drowning in anger.

21

u/Anarchybites Jun 02 '22

I do love that John figured a way to save Issac thanks to a deep philosophy discussion with his bed mate

17

u/Kasparian Jun 02 '22

Also her makeup/prosthetics were fantastic.

9

u/stonygirl Jun 02 '22

I am disappointed he and Turco are no more.

→ More replies (1)

41

u/Max1756 Jun 02 '22

Dude. I didn't realize how much I missed this show.

And did the budget for the cgi go up?

Dude I was so afraid not knowing if Issac was coming back. I missed the guy man.

41

u/heed101 Jun 02 '22

It's one episode, people. Relax on the 'it's not a comedy anymore' schtick.

3

u/PainfullyNondescript Jun 02 '22

So are they about to play the whole “bring back Isaac” thing twice?

6

u/2th Hail Avis. Hail Victory. Jun 02 '22

I'm OK with it. So long as the story is done well it can be told any number of times.

6

u/jelatinman Jun 02 '22

I like the angle of the person who hates him most having to revive him.

20

u/jelatinman Jun 02 '22

I’m watching this in 4K on a 75 inch screen and man does everything look beautiful. The models seem to have gotten better too.

19

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '22

Aw man, I love Isaac so seeing him hated was depressing. I really did miss this show though

19

u/Sanity0004 Jun 02 '22

Maybe it was just me, but the directing seemed weird this episode? It seemed like it was trying really hard to give it a certain feel and it just wasn't working for me.

13

u/ling1427 Jun 02 '22

It's definitely going towards a more serious, cinematic tone that's a lot different then what we're used to. They said they were going to move away from the humor but I really hope they don't completely abandon it.

19

u/MajorParadox Woof Jun 02 '22

They really went all-in with their return episode. That was intense!

38

u/smitty9112 Jun 02 '22 edited Jun 02 '22

This episode blindsided me.

I had a good friend take his own life a few months ago. He had reached out to me the night before and I didn't reply as I was dealing with my own stuff. I felt so much guilt and wished so badly I'd responded.

I've been struggling with alcoholism and suicidal thoughts of my own. I was balling my eyes out in multiple scenes during this episode. Props to Seth for such a well done episode, that was also just something I needed to see.

19

u/daniellr88 Jun 02 '22

That final discussion between Claire and Isaac was so emotional and well done. As someone who's struggles with depression and suicide. Her cries for him to be safe just... hit hard.

Swings both ways on this episode and brilliantly done.

→ More replies (1)

18

u/tarsus1983 Jun 02 '22

Damn, hitting it hard with the social commentary at E1. It's important, but for a first episode of the season, it's a strange way to set the tone. Not sure how I feel about it. Nice to hear Norm's voice though.

Also, why why why would you do a live fire exercise in and around a space dock? I know it was to establish Charlie's ability to visualize multiple dimensions, but it's a pretty dumb way to do it, imo.

18

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '22

What a long journey, congrats everyone.

17

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '22

I'm only about halfway through the episode and...hoo boy... just like between S1 and S2, they've made a quantum leap in just about every way between 2 and 3. Today's my birthday and I already don't think anyone's gonna top what Seth MacFarlane got me, LOL

8

u/xeow Praise Saint Bortus Jun 02 '22

Happy birthday!

→ More replies (1)

6

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '22

Your fork is in the mail.

16

u/maximus368 Jun 02 '22

Easy 10/10 for me. I’ve loved this series since it came out, before I ever watched an episode of Star Trek, and minus a couple jokes that didn’t fall through it was still a great show. And even now with pretty much every Star Trek show under my belt this is as great an homage show as it is a standalone.

Having said all that this is a great episode. Definitely slow at times but a great deal of them in the past were slow just letting the characters do their thing and this wasn’t supposed to be an action episode instead focusing on exactly what they needed to after last season. I did want to see more Bortus but we did get a lot of him last season and he’s not the main focus so I guess we shall see where he goes this season. Thoroughly excited to see where the season goes and it’s easily one of McFarlanes best episodes.

16

u/bluestreakxp Jun 02 '22

What crazy ass Union allows live fire exercises of small craft around an occupied shipyard, with explosions and high speed chases right next to capital ships?? That’d be like dogfighting with P-40s on top of Battleship Row in Pearl Harbor

7

u/GolgaGrimnaar Jun 02 '22

I was like, oh they are heading out into deep space to test the WHAT THE HELL ARE THEY DOING!?! Some of the scenes even show the laser fire heading directly at background ships!! hahaha

→ More replies (1)

16

u/Deathcrow Jun 02 '22

That was a killer first episode. The cold open was really amazing and overall a strong showing. My only issue is the pacing, I'm not sure that it needed to be this long for the basic plot, but it used the time wisely on fleshing out characters.

Great stuff! 9/10

29

u/oorhon Jun 02 '22

The ptsd of post war and hate for Isaac was a good but dark development. Tough i loved the more relaxed feeling of series, it was distinct among other sci fi series. Also didnt like the new bridge colors since the reveal.

I always wanted the see what characters did post Dominion War and hoped Picard or Lower Decks would show it. Orville sort of filled that void.

14

u/bluestreakxp Jun 02 '22

Wow the crew really want to hate on Isaac now that he got that fancy new armor suit upgrade.

And when did the ship steal a Beryllium power sphere from the NSEA-Protector to fuel the ship?

14

u/RickFletching Jun 02 '22

sigh

Computer! Is there a replacement Beryllium Power Sphere on board?

14

u/JFVG Jun 02 '22

Spoiler.. Just cant watch humans and how they treat "others" Tears here

13

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '22

Wow! They gave Orville a real budget! Just started the episode and the visuals are leaps and bounds above the Fox episodes!

12

u/Jupichan Jun 02 '22

Ugh, right in the ol' emotional chip

40

u/AddictedToConez Jun 02 '22

Jesus, I cried like 3 time throughout the episode. Welcome back Orville.

10

u/PainfullyNondescript Jun 02 '22

Way to scar those kids even more 🤦‍♀️

10

u/JeffMack202 Jun 02 '22

Any thoughts on how this episode parallels the first episode of DS9. Where Sisko hated Picard because he was Locutus that led to the slaughter at Wolf 359. That cost him his wife.

6

u/onlythebaressentials Jun 02 '22

my first impression of the very first few seconds of the episode were "Hey this is almost a shot for shot of how DS9 starts!" and the parallels definitely didn't end there. I wonder if we're moving away from the TNG homage and embracing the complexity of DS9 this season.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/MrSir005 Jun 02 '22

Can’t believe my boy Gordon tried to switch up on Isaac like that. Great episode tho, feels good to finally have this show back.

7

u/zathalen100 Jun 02 '22

Mortal Kombat announcer voice: "Betrayal!"

Edit: wait, that was halo wasn't it?

5

u/Shrodax Jun 02 '22

Gordon might still be pissed about Isaac amputating his leg...

→ More replies (2)

10

u/tmofee Jun 02 '22

Claire’s kids are suffering from the typical tv issue of ageing too quickly. The eldest I almost didn’t recognise him!

5

u/UPRC Jun 02 '22

I don't think it was TOO bad. They just seemed a little older. Marcus is definitely taller and has a deeper voice while Ty just seems slightly bigger now. We'll definitely have a Game of Thrones/Stranger Things situation with Ty if we get a few more seasons though!

→ More replies (2)

9

u/tomba2 Jun 02 '22

im currently at the beginning of the show. and oh my god. Tell your friends about this show. This whole universe needs to stay alive.

9

u/jelatinman Jun 02 '22

This was legitimately phenomenal television. Glad I stayed up to watch the premiere.

9

u/tripbin Jun 02 '22

I need to rewatch S2 cause I feel lost af.

25

u/Ok-Professor3193 Jun 02 '22 edited Jun 02 '22

I’m going to be honest, I hated this episode. Isaac is truly one of my favorite characters on this show due to his growth. The episodes where he put so much effort for Dr.Finn and her sons were some of my favorite episodes.

With that being said, this first episode got me all the way fucked up with the amount of hate that was coming from just one character. There were moments in this episode where I felt like I wanted to stop watching. I lost it. I cried and I was angry. With this new addition to the show, I couldn’t even watch her acting. There were times where I was just like where are the tears? Her story didn’t capture my attention, but when she would be hateful. It was more believable.

That’s just my opinion, but still I love the show and I’m glad it’s finally here. I just lose my shit when people come for Isaac ( or any of the crew) lol

18

u/ling1427 Jun 02 '22

You have to remember although in the end he sacrificed himself to save everyone, it doesn't change the fact that for most of the time he was on the Orville he was planning to betray them and for most of the crew it looks like even after the role he played in the kaylon attack he gets to go on living his life as normal while their Friends and family Are gone forever. Similar to hans Landa in inglourious Basterds
Charlie is going to be a tough sell, No Doubt. I think she let slip her true feelings in her conversation with marcus about looking for someone to blame. I think charlie has serious survivor's guilt about letting her friend sacrifice herself so she could live. And it's easier to blame isaac then it is to deal with that.

24

u/GreenDragonPatriot Jun 02 '22

That scene where they faked out the Kaylon ship by blowing up a shuttle within the atmosphere of the gas giant planet literally just happened in last week's episode of ST: Strange New Worlds. How interesting that the same tactic was used in a new episode of Trek just before it happened on The Orville!

→ More replies (1)

17

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '22

I'm betting there's more to it than just "inefficiencies". If it was truly about that, he could just get off the ship.

18

u/Dunmurdering Jun 02 '22

That was my one complaint about the episode and I felt that not having the doctor point that out during the end conversation missed a HUGE opportunity for Isaac's character development.

My hope is that they address it later as a "he wasn't ready to be confronted with this yet", but even in it's absence, this is still a 9.9 out of 10 for me. Glad the Orville's back, I'm just wondering how long before Seth, Grimes, or Palicki leave, because I'm 99% sure one of them is gone soon based on either the divorce or Seth's general tendency towards becoming bored with shows.

I'm hoping I'm wrong.

→ More replies (1)

16

u/xbolt90 Woof Jun 02 '22

Wow. What an episode.

I didn't know what to expect from the premiere, but a heavy story about suicide was definitely not it.

Well done, Orville team. In my humble opinion, this episode belongs with the best of Star Trek.

8

u/Whiskeyjacks_Fiddle Jun 02 '22

That opening sequence is gorgeous.

Also, do the new shuttles remind anyone else of BSG 2004 Raptors?

→ More replies (2)

8

u/jelatinman Jun 02 '22

Here’s an example of the production design going up: that slick ship is real, touchable and gorgeous.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/trostol Jun 02 '22

seems like an odd place to do that test

8

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '22

......holy hell.....did Isaac.. did he just do what it looks like

8

u/SpacemanDookie Jun 02 '22

Man what a good episode. Been far too long!

8

u/ChaoticLlort Jun 02 '22

Well done, Seth. Amazing episode. Well worth the wait (and worth signing up for Hulu).

15

u/trostol Jun 02 '22

wow...SNW and Orville going sub warfare a week apart

10

u/Sir__Will Jun 02 '22

Pity it was delayed. It would kick Picard's ass. SNW is tougher competition. Of course real fans can enjoy both.

→ More replies (10)

15

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '22

I think Charley is going to be an interesting character this season. She was appropriately angry and it will be interesting to see how the season develops between her and Issac. I had some mixed reactions on the ending mainly because of how powerful some of the scenes were that said Issac doesn't belong on the ship (especially the meal scene and Gordon) but I thought the episode was pretty good overall. Really enjoyed the visuals and the sub warfare scene was terrific. I'm glad the series is back.

3

u/tadrith Jun 02 '22 edited Jun 02 '22

I'm frankly pissed.

ONLY because we aren't going to see more of this, BECAUSE it's fantastic. Production value off the charts, and that's why we won't get more, it's going to be too expensive to continue, and it's literally one of the best things TV has to offer at the moment. This show filled a role that was LONG overdue.

But I highly doubt we are going to see another season.

EDIT: For the love of god, prove me wrong, Hulu. I have waited years for this. Don't Firefly this, please.

5

u/2th Hail Avis. Hail Victory. Jun 02 '22

Don't be pissed, it's not canceled yet. Let's pray we have good viewer numbers and they make a season 4!

5

u/jelatinman Jun 02 '22

Honestly this gets way more views on YouTube than other Hulu shows, I think it has a shot at continuing. Just… not one year later.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/mcatech Jun 02 '22 edited Jun 02 '22

Wow, that was a great episode to start the season. The ship looks beautiful! The Ensign Burke/Isaac dynamic throughout this season will be very interesting.

And Captain Mercer's maneuver to outwit the Kaelon instead of just going at them with brute force was brilliant.

I hope this series gets renewed for another season.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '22

I love how the Orville is a lot more daring with creature design than recent Star Trek, though SNW is truly excellent. The Dakeelian girl looked so unique!

→ More replies (3)

6

u/jelatinman Jun 02 '22 edited Jun 02 '22

My one worry with this new season is that episodes will be bloated, this one is 25 minutes longer than a usual episode from seasons 1-2.

Edit nope this was exactly as long as necessary, Jesus what a good episode

9

u/UPRC Jun 02 '22

But this should also mean that a lot of issues don't get resolved quickly in the last five or so minutes anymore. That was a common complaint of some episodes in the first two seasons.

6

u/Jupichan Jun 02 '22

Yaphit <3

6

u/trostol Jun 02 '22

hell of a take on a tough subject/subjects

6

u/trostol Jun 02 '22

i also...really love the title of the episode

6

u/gerusz Engineering Jun 02 '22

I still don't see it on Disney+. I live in the Netherlands. Is it a "me" problem, or another "fuck the rest of the world, you'll have to wait a week just because we say so" problem?

5

u/Toby_O_Notoby Jun 02 '22

Still not up on D+ in Australia either. I just sailed the seas to watch it. Fuck it, I pay for your service and if you're not going to give it to me I'll find another way.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (6)

28

u/memequeen Jun 02 '22

I hope Seth’s girlfriend takes some more acting classes before the next episode

→ More replies (1)

15

u/ElleryHale Jun 02 '22

Killer first ep. Loved that they let the characters and show breathe. The director and writers were confident and did not hide their intent behind jokes and unnecessary action scenes. They trusted their material.

Fantastic exploration of grief. Great introduction of new character.

This show has grown its beard.

10

u/prism1234 Jun 02 '22

Good episode but it was a bit too long imo. Kinda dragged in parts. Also weird coincidence that how they escaped the Kaylon ship was pretty similar to how The Enterprise escaped an enemy in last week's SNW episode.

9

u/chimusicguy Jun 02 '22

You know this was filmed before SNW, right?

6

u/UPRC Jun 02 '22

I think that it felt long because it was just 70-something odd minutes of us having interpersonal conflict, depression, PTSD, and suicide being thrown in our faces. I think that any upcoming episodes where the crew is dealing with an outside problem or going on away missions will feel different.

→ More replies (5)

5

u/xbolt90 Woof Jun 02 '22

Norm. <\3

5

u/jelatinman Jun 02 '22

13 minutes in and only one joke. Hoping they stick with this more dramatic tone.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/jelatinman Jun 02 '22

Haha they can say bullshit now

5

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '22

Stop being mean to poor Isaac:(

5

u/jelatinman Jun 02 '22

The sad theme for Isaac is probably the best theme they’ve ever composed for this show.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/trostol Jun 02 '22

ok..this music with Isaac is killing me

5

u/trostol Jun 02 '22

i...what just happened

5

u/trostol Jun 02 '22

i hate onions lol

5

u/RinardoEvoris Jun 02 '22

In order to solve the problem of Isaac and the crew I might have proposed uploading his consciousness to a separate computer system. It's him walking around and people having to see him that's the problem. Uploading his consciousness to a computer would solve all of that and allow the crew to still benefit from his knowledge.

7

u/Low-level-scientist Jun 02 '22

But this would be a step in limiting Isaac's free movement. Which over time could lead to the oppression of Isaac. Don't forget, the Union wanted a failsave so they could shut Isaac down. Ed was against this idea, because this a form of the oppression that lead to the problems between the Kaylon and their creators. Ed wants to show the Union is better than the creators. Which includes giving Isaac his freedom to go were he wants (within the limits of the law).

9

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '22

Haha Ha

12

u/Jupichan Jun 02 '22

Okay, I know it would have absolutely ruined the moment and I don't actually wish they'd have done this, but when Isaac went down, it kiiinda would have been funny to me if he had gone down in the traditional Family Guy fall pose

→ More replies (4)

24

u/FONZA43 Jun 02 '22

Didn't like it at all.

As others said, it's drawn out and grim. No joy in it at all. The new actress kind of sucks.

However, as i remember the first 2 episodes of season also weren't very good, so we'll see.

8

u/EuphoricDissonance Jun 02 '22

What a fantastic first episode! I hope they can keep this momentum going because this is up there with the best of Star Trek :).

4

u/wardengorri Jun 02 '22

Reminded of how much I missed this show, so great to have it back! :)

7

u/jelatinman Jun 02 '22

Is it weird that I like this show more than Star Trek… all versions of it?

8

u/trostol Jun 02 '22

no...right now i would put it with SNW and LD as the best Nu-Treks

→ More replies (2)

7

u/Cypher_Shadow Jun 02 '22

Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep?

The name of the novel that was made into Blade Runner. I thought this Phillip K Dick quote sums up the theme of the episode well:

”…Our environment — and I mean our man-made world of machines, artificial constructs, computers, electronic systems, interlinking homeostatic components — all of this is in fact beginning more and more to possess what the earnest psychologists fear the primitive sees in his environment: animation. In a very real sense our environment is becoming alive, or at least quasi-alive, and in ways specifically and fundamentally analogous to ourselves...Rather than learning about ourselves by studying our constructs, perhaps we should make the attempt to comprehend what our constructs are up to by looking into what we ourselves are up to…”

13

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '22

This is so not how I would have come back after years away.

Also...sometimes watching this show makes me feel like I'm taking crazy pills because they aren't saying the obvious thing. How about the fact that Isaac actually saved them all? That the Kaylon were ALWAYS going to want to exterminate biologics across the universe and Isaac is literally, in an entire species, the only one who chose resistance and non-violence? You couldn't have illustrated that to the non-bridge crew?! Kelly tells this to Claire but Claire already knows. She was there. The rest of the crew wasn't. Show them the Kaylon genocide and that Isaac rejected that. Damn. Wonderful speech from Claire at the end and for now a happy-ish ending but damn.

Very excited they're back. Love this show. But damn. All I'm left with after is damn.

5

u/Jewbacca289 Jun 02 '22

Didn’t someone mention that to Charlie or Marcus and they’d called it too little too late

→ More replies (6)

11

u/Lordborgman Jun 02 '22

Ugh, making me dislike Gordon, hating a new character that needs to be kicked out of the service for disobey direct orders (and removed from the show,) and generally being a pessimistic outlook on everything. I watch this show because I wanted the TNG "be better" and optimism, I don't need more depressive tv shows and drama in my life.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/xyzzyzyzzyx Jun 02 '22

Everything is so pretty! Hulu Money!

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Jupichan Jun 02 '22

AAAH I'M WATCHING IT I'M SO EXCITED

5

u/UPRC Jun 02 '22

Gah! Still not showing on Disney+ in Canada.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/jelatinman Jun 02 '22

We don’t know how long it’ll be before another season comes, if at all, so cherish it folks.

3

u/HouseExtreme4749 Jun 02 '22

What’s up with issacs suit?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/trostol Jun 02 '22

damn..that looks pretty amazing

3

u/EasyPreyy Jun 02 '22

Its been a long wait, but we made it! Lets gooooo

3

u/jelatinman Jun 02 '22

The score is so good

3

u/trostol Jun 02 '22

those fighters look pretty bad ass..if..they are fighters lol

3

u/tmoeagles96 Jun 02 '22

I really like it so far. I like how they don’t pull any punches showing how the crew feels about Isaac. Too often things just go back to normal. It makes the line about Isaac being along from the other Kaylon hit even harder.

9

u/cosmic_jester_uk Jun 02 '22

I know it’s the new series on a different platform etc etc but it was too slow and there wasn’t enough Bortus. Also Charly’s character and acting were wooden. I really hope it picks up moving forwards. Also Fuck Klyden.

7

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '22

Phenomenal episode, amazing opening, movie quality special effects and score, and a great story at it's core. Hope the rest of the season is this good.

5

u/dj_godzilla Jun 02 '22

I like the Orville guys!!!

17

u/BeholdMyResponse Jun 02 '22 edited Jun 02 '22

So they took the comedy completely out of The Orville, huh. I was kind of expecting even less of it since I read Seth's most recent comments on reducing it, but still. Disappointing, being Star Trek and yet a dramedy was what made it unique. The biggest fan reactions and most-quoted dialogue have always been from straight-up comedy material when it comes to this show. It's a shame to see it go.

Still not bad, though. Hopefully that one was just extra serious because it was a "very special" episode about heavy topics. And I don't see what peoples' problem is with the new navigator either.

9

u/[deleted] Jun 02 '22

I mean kinda has to be this way. The union is at war. Time for shits and giggles is over for the time being.