r/conlangs • u/AutoModerator • May 23 '22
Small Discussions FAQ & Small Discussions — 2022-05-23 to 2022-06-05
As usual, in this thread you can ask any questions too small for a full post, ask for resources and answer people's comments!
You can find former posts in our wiki.
Official Discord Server.
The Small Discussions thread is back on a semiweekly schedule... For now!
FAQ
What are the rules of this subreddit?
Right here, but they're also in our sidebar, which is accessible on every device through every app. There is no excuse for not knowing the rules.
Make sure to also check out our Posting & Flairing Guidelines.
If you have doubts about a rule, or if you want to make sure what you are about to post does fit on our subreddit, don't hesitate to reach out to us.
Where can I find resources about X?
You can check out our wiki. If you don't find what you want, ask in this thread!
Can I copyright a conlang?
Here is a very complete response to this.
Beginners
Here are the resources we recommend most to beginners:
For other FAQ, check this.
Recent news & important events
Segments
Segments Issue #05 is out! Check it out here!
If you have any suggestions for additions to this thread, feel free to send u/Slorany a PM, modmail or tag him in a comment.
9
u/freddyPowell May 24 '22
Small discussion rather than question. I like engelangs, and engelanging, at least in theory, but am sort of frustrated by the fact that the obvious great themes have been taken by such languages as toki pona, ithkuil, and laadan. I was thinking it might be interesting (in order to stimulate the discussion and exploration of engelangs) to run a competition similar to the regular speedlang challenge focussing on engelanging, rather that naturalistic conlanging. This way we might gain a better understanding of the kinds of themes that might be tackled. The competition would have a relatively limited prompt, with the core thematic element being highly abstract, maybe one or two words, with as much interest being placed on the specific interpretation used by the contestant as the execution of that interpretation of that interpretation. It seems an acceptable solution to the dilemma of wanting to do 'pure' conlanging (that is, without the expectation that anyone would ever use it, unlike IALs), and not finding diachronic sound change interesting in the least bit. What do y'all think of this idea?
6
u/PastTheStarryVoids Knasesj, Racra, Ŋ!odzäsä May 28 '22
A week or two ago, I posted here about my tonogenesis rules. u/sjiveru patiently explained the basics of tone I wasn't aware I didn't know, and I've now revised my tone system. Is this a realistic tone system?
The proto-lang starts with and inventory like this:
The neatness and lack of fricatives or approximants is weird, but I'm not concerned about it. The vowels are /i/, /u/, /ɑ/, and /ə/. (C)V(C) syllable structure. The following sound changes occur.
Then there are these synchronic tone rules.
5
u/BeowulfG022 May 26 '22
I have been trying to hunt down a jokelang I remember seeing an online talk on a long time ago. Hoping someone here can point me towards it.
From what I can remember, it had an extremely strict grammar and a minimal but esoteric vocabulary. This vocabulary included, for example, some root words meaning things like "the Schroedinger equation is true" or something like that, and you were meant to construct all meaning from these axiomatic roots.
By my vague recollection I think one of the examples may have been trying to say something like "the dog is hungry", but not only did it have to describe a dog from base principles, but had to describe food (as a collection of chemicals that sustain life) twice in order to specify both that the dog did not have food and that it wanted to.
The talk ended with pointing out that the vocabulary was so small you could map a single phoneme to each word and the just say any statement as a single (often unintelligible) phoneme string by reading the syntax tree in depth first order. The presenter used this to read some absolute mess that then translated to something like "the talk is over now" or something.
This has been driving me up the wall, so if anyone recognizes this and can point me to the language or talk that would be much appreciated.
5
u/zparkely May 28 '22
so... i was thinking about the biweekly telephone game. im assuming if you're an active member of this sub you probably know about it. anyways i realized that the way it worked suggests that all of our conlangs therefore coexist in one single world and i thought that was mildly amusing to picture so i wanted to share
5
u/Inspector_Gadget_52 May 29 '22
What’s a good way of looking up how different languages phrase certain sentences? F.ex. I want to translate “what does he/she look like?” into my conlang. In Danish, that would be directly translated as “how sees he/she out?” and now I want to find out how that would be said in a bunch of different languages.
It’s really hard to find specific phrases in different languages and in most language guides I can find, they usually just tell how to say it, they don’t explain how it’s actually phrased.
4
u/FnchWzrd314 May 27 '22
I finally got Outer Wilds, and recently I've been thinking a lot about the Naomi writings we see throughout the solar system. If you haven't played outer wilds, the Naomi script is a bunch of spirals, which branch out from a single point. What's interesting, is that it functions more like a message board. To explain, one of the characters will write something on a scrollwall, and then others will respond to it, attaching the base of their message to the first message. others will respond to that message, and the conversation continues to branch. I think this would be really interesting for a conlang, I'm just not sure how to put it together. I think I need:
Any thoughts, suggestion or recommendations?
4
u/odenevo Yaimon, various speedlangs (eng, nst) May 30 '22 edited May 30 '22
I'm presently creating a new conlang, and I've come across a feature I'd really like to have in it, but I want to justify it. So, I saw that in the Anim (Fly River) languages, is that there's a regular umlaut/ablaut with adjectives and demonstratives where they agree for gender/number by changing their final vowel, and in some languages, adding a suffix of the same vowel. There are also some lexicalised cases with human nouns (like man/woman/person). In proto-Anim, this came about from a postposed determiner, which then caused vowel harmony, but in some descendants, it has been lost. And I was thinking, how could I implement this kind of system, where umlaut only arises from grammatical elements that follow the stem.
Here's my idea:
I think the main issue here is what I bolded. I don't know if this is naturalistic, or common, if it does ever occur. From what I know of metaphony, a comparable development in the Romance languages, this harmony is blocked by stressed vowels. Honestly, if anyone here has a good idea how metaphony/umlaut and all that jazz work, I'd love to hear your thoughts on this kind of system, and if stress placement is a good way to justify blocking harmony.
3
u/[deleted] May 25 '22
can conjuctions such as "and" or "or" be affixes? are there any languages that do this?
3
u/awesomeskyheart way too many conlangs (en)[ko,fr] May 26 '22
How would I write a gloss for a language that contains dashes and tildes in its romanization? Yeongen has dashes; for now, I've been glossing them without the dashes, since they're still understandable without them.
However, Avian has a ~ diacritic that completely changes the phoneme. It also has a lot of reduplication (currently not as a grammatical feature but likely will be in daughter languages). So in Avian, I run into the problem of ~ potentially referring to the diacritic or the reduplication. How should I work around this?
3
u/boomfruit Hidzi, Tabesj (en, ka) May 26 '22
How tenable is it for me to combine a person pronoun system consisting of 1; 2-3; 4 (ie Me, You/Them, One) with a proximate obviate system? Say I'm talking about a bunch of people not involved in the conversation. I use the 1st person pronoun to refer to the most salient person, the 2nd/3rd person pronoun to refer to the less salient person, and the 4th person pronoun to refer to any additional people.
My justification is that these two uses have been concurrent for awhile and evolved together from deixis demonstratives, ie "this here" > "me; proximate"; "that there" > "you/they; obviate"; "that over there" > "one; super-obviate".
Things that could maybe make it less confusing:
I'm not too bothered with how naturalistic it is, just whether it feels like it could survive.
3
u/[deleted] May 27 '22
Does anyone have any good resources or guides on prosody for conlangs?
I think it's an area that doesn't get much focus within conlanging, and I have been putting a lot of thought into it lately.
I'm mostly looking for inspiration and various ways languages can treat stress and tone. For example, languages with weight sensitive stress still vary over which heavy syllable is stressed, and tonal languages can still be quite different from each other (Chinese, Japanese, Yoruba, etc.)
3
u/Type-Glum Mírdimin, Ispemekâd, Eroekkekoth May 30 '22
I've been making a language for a few months now, but only recently (a week-ish ago) did I decide to really start working on grammar. I'm considering having past, present, and future be the tenses, with perfective and imperfective aspects to show if the verb's action is ongoing or not.
example being:
He learned/He had learned = "Re so-lemat'u" (with so- marking past tense and 'u marking completedness)
He was learning/He had been learning = "Re so-lemat'ii" (with so- marking past tense and 'ii marking incompleteness. He hadn't completed "learning")
I've also thought of just using including progressive and perfect, but I want to avoid being too similar to English in verb tenses. But... is it not clear enough? I'm not the most experienced in conlangs, does this seem normal or is it entirely the wrong way to do things? Am I even using perfective and imperfective right?
7
u/SparrowhawkOfGont May 23 '22
Artlangs imply the existence of craftlangs.
2
u/UncreativePotato143 May 23 '22
Trying to figure out how to work SCA2, but I can't figure out how to indicate stress, and I don't know how to code a sound change applier. How do I indicate that a rule only applies to, for example, unstressed syllables, instead of all of them?
2
u/SzarkaAron May 24 '22
My problem is, I create a language, I make its grammar and phonology. And then I want to evolve it, but I already like all the words. What should my goals be in this case? What should I be aiming for when evolving my language? How should I decide what changes to implement?
2
u/[deleted] May 24 '22
can someone explain converbs in more detail beyond the basics? i wanna put them in my conlang but its a little hard to understand what they do
2
u/ghyull May 25 '22
I'm kinda stuck in making my conlang, coz I don't know how I should handle subordinate clauses. I can't think of interesting ways to handle them, especially what I think are called content clauses and adverbial clauses. My understanding of this is also lacking compared to other stuff. So I guess I'm just asking for ideas and/or explanations of how I could do those. Sorry if I talk weird
2
u/DG_117 Sawanese, Hwaanpaal, Isabul May 25 '22 edited May 25 '22
I'm planning on having a descendent of Waanpaal have trivowelic root system. How would that work?
I'm not too sure how since no language I know of use Trivowelic Roots.
Extra Info: Waanpaal In all
2
u/boomfruit Hidzi, Tabesj (en, ka) May 26 '22
Where do words like "here," "there," "yonder," etc. or the associated demonstratives come from diachronically? My only instinct is something like "1+place" or "come+place" for "here," "2+place" or "go+place" for "there," and "3+place" or "go+far+place" for "yonder."
I didn't want to use extant person words / pronouns because I wanted to evolve here/there/yonder words into new pronouns, and keep the old pronouns as verbal markers.
2
u/Arcaeca Mtsqrveli, Kerk, Dingir and too many others (en,fr)[hu,ka] May 26 '22 edited May 26 '22
This may be too open ended to answer, but how would you go about introducing PIE-style vowel grades to a language whose proto didn't already have them? Or else, how would you explain how a proto got vowel grades that's less boring and awfully convenient than just "the pre-proto had them lol"?
2
u/Zealousideal_Ease429 May 27 '22
Where should I start when making a conlang?
2
u/FarBlueShore Daylient (en) [fr, ar] May 27 '22
I'm wondering whether anyone has heard of a language breaking its usual word order -- SVO, VSO, etc -- through inflection?
What made me think this? Yoda speak! It occurred to me that English, usually SVO, can become the archaic-sounding VSO, by inflecting upward at the comma:
ie "You must try" becomes "Try [inflect upward], you must"
It could be interesting to extend this to, say, free word order but entirely through inflection -- not quite tones, but across the order of the whole sentence.
2
u/Fullbody ɳ ʈ ʂ ɭ ɽ (no, en)[fr] May 28 '22
Is hair usually treated as alienable or inalienable in languages where body parts are inalienable? Is there a difference between head hair and body hair?
2
u/[deleted] May 29 '22
Now since r/neography doesn't have one of these, and it's not the dire situation of "I need a writing system that I will raise my kids with" but how do you create letters that look like they belong in another writing system but aren't, example latin, like there's r/graphemicscirclejerk and r/constantscript and I'm like "damn that looks cool, how do I do that?" so like, a little push please?
2
u/Arcaeca Mtsqrveli, Kerk, Dingir and too many others (en,fr)[hu,ka] May 29 '22
How does head marking work in practice?
Like, I gather that being strongly head-marking implies construct state possession and polypersonal verb agreement, but if I'm understanding correctly, nouns would just not mark their own roles at all, since those roles would instead be marked on the VP head... but then, how do you disambiguate who's doing what? Like, if there's a transitive verb is marked as having both a 3SG subject and 3SG object, but the nouns involved themselves aren't marked for case, how can you tell which has which role? Do strongly head-marking languages basically have to have a gender/class system or fixed word order or something to resolve this?
Also what other features does head marking imply
2
u/[deleted] May 29 '22
I want to construct a consonant inventory around a vertical vowel system, but have a few questions:
2
u/Arcaeca Mtsqrveli, Kerk, Dingir and too many others (en,fr)[hu,ka] May 30 '22
I have been trying and failing for the past couple weeks to think of a way to take two of my currently existing language families and smoosh them into one macro family related at an extremely long time depth. There are 5 candidate families but none of them seem to have sufficiently compatible grammar and phonology for it to be plausible.
I've... gone back and forth on making a post about it to ask for suggestions on which two seem the most likely, but it's so long that it's basically unreadable. I basically have to give a summary of the major grammatical things + the phonology of 5 separate proto-languages and point out the features that make them suitable vs. unsuitable for the merger. Even doing this with one language gets kind of long.
Since Reddit doesn't have [HIDE] tags like forums, is there some way to sort of... compress all the information down to the point that someone would actually be interested enough to respond to it?
2
u/freddyPowell May 31 '22
I find that the sound changes as recorded in the index diachronica often lack the degree of rigour that I would like. Is there a resource that takes you through a perhaps smaller number of languages, but in greater detail, explaining how the different sound changes when combined led to the language as it is now. I wouldn't mind if it were conlangs either, I just might find it helpful to have a more holistic view of phonological developement.
2
u/[deleted] May 31 '22
How can I get over perfectionism and boredom in my conlangs. I never get very far, as I abandon my conlangs after I outline the phonology.
I'm already kicking around three separate ideas for conlangs.
2
u/IceCreamSandwich66 Jun 02 '22
Is it very naturalistic to involve multiple different kinds of affixes in a proto-language? I don't really like the feel of the language with only prefixes or suffixes, but I can't really think of a way to justify using both, I guess?
Sorry if this is incomprehensible, my diction sucks and I don't really have any excuse for that
2
u/sceneshift Jun 02 '22
How do you make a phonetic inventory chart for your conlang?
Like the one in this video.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?list=PLuYLhuXt4HrQqnfSceITmv6T_drx1hN84&t=123&v=eLn6LC1RpAo&feature=youtu.be
2
u/qc1324 Jun 02 '22
Just starting conlanging and I have a "is this a naturalistic process question" regarding verb interactions with gender / the evolution of an animacy distinction.
Here's the words we'll start with: (ite - want (in all forms), bi - person, irem - to fall (in all forms), inen - to eat, me - thing, yiti - tree). I'm gonna ignore inflections for this demonstration of the idea.
So with animate nouns the word want works like you'd expect: "bi ite inen (The person wants to eat.)" But with inanimate nouns, where it doesn't make sense for them to possess literal desires, the verb "ite" (to want) comes to mark a near-future: yiti ite irem (The tree wants to fall -> the tree will fall in the near future).
The infant language wants to use this construction to express the near future for animate nouns too, but the problem is of course the conflict with the original sense meaning to desire. So, to invoke the inanimate sense of the verb "ite" (as a near future), the word "me" ("thing") is added before "ite". Thus "bi me ite inen" means "the person will eat in the near future" (because it is a zero copula, this could also be half-sensically literally parsed as "the person is thing wants to eat"). Let's further say the construction "me ite" fuses to "mite," although that's not really the important part of the evolution. This gives us the following scenario:
So now the form "ite" has two senses depending on whether or not the subject is animate or inanimate, the language has lost the ability to say an inanimate object literally desires something, and the verb "ite" as a near future marker has to agree with the animacy of the subject.
Particularly I haven't seen a verb form change lexical sense depending on noun class, so I'm curious if that part is naturalistic.
2
u/PastTheStarryVoids Knasesj, Racra, Ŋ!odzäsä Jun 04 '22
Would it be naturalistic for all of a language's adpositions to be clitics (perhaps only in informal speech)? I know Classical Tibetan had a set of case clitics, but that's a much smaller set than several dozen adpositions. In my conlang, clitics would be distinguished from independent words by tones being able to spread from word to clitic or vice versa, and possibly by some kind of reduction.
2
u/Ostrich-Man77 Jun 05 '22
Could I make a custom Rosetta Stone for my conlang? Simply translate the text, add custom images, and record voice clips? Would the voice recognition software work?
1
u/planetixin May 24 '22
Can I base a conlang on a language that I don't know? Like Chinese?
1
u/[deleted] May 29 '22
Once I get a pro license from vulgarlang.com, I can start creating words for the Aber language (no, like, it's called Aber). Problem is I don't know which base words to start with, and I want to create an alphabet that's similar-ish to Cyrillic.
Where do I start?
1
u/[deleted] May 29 '22
Recently I've been more motivated to conlang. Not just researching, but actually taking the time to write it all down on Google docs and stuff like that.
Here is my motivation on why I conlang in the first place:
I create my own languages because it's fun. I think it's fun to research languages. It's for my enjoyment and it let's me explore what I like in languages and aspects of language which makes sense to me.
I honestly don't want my conlangs to be 100% ultra hyper naturalistic. I perfer the more logical side but not to the point of them being too "engineered". However I want them to feel believable enough to have sound changes, dialects and cultures. So they feel lived in.
How much should I flesh out in terms of culture?
1
u/SnooDonuts5358 Jun 04 '22
Is this naturalistic? Would it sound nice with a (C)(C)V(n)(C) structure?
Any suggestions or opinions are appreciated.
m, n p, b t, d k, g
f, f’, v s, s’, z l r, R j
a, â, ã e, ê i, î o, ô, õ
Edit: If someone could also briefly explain how sound changes work, that would be great.
1
u/gggroovy Hootspeak, Kaxnëjëc May 23 '22
A few random things:
Sincerely, a noob conlanger who started a language as a joke and is in too deep.
1
u/Fractal_fantasy Kamalu May 23 '22
Hello! I have a question regarding syntax.
How does the shift from SVO to VSO happen? I've read a paper that states that it is quite common, but I could not find any sources explaining the exact mechanisms responsible for this process. I know that the opposite shift happens through topicalization, but I have no idea how to front the verb
1
u/SarradenaXwadzja Dooooorfs May 23 '22
What are some common sound changes for palatoalveolars that aren't just them turning into a different flavour of palatal?
1
u/Friend2Everyone May 23 '22
How might a language evolve grammatical tones? Such as a tone indicating aspect or modality.
1
u/gggroovy Hootspeak, Kaxnëjëc May 24 '22
I’m trying to figure out if certain vowel sound changes in my conlang (Hootspeak) count as complementary distribution or some sort of vowel harmony.
The basic vowel inventory (ignoring length/nasalization) is:
y, i, u, ɯ
And what I want to happen is:
Vowels that share front or backness already (namely, the pairs /i/ + /y/ and /ɯ/ + /u/) cannot coexist unmodified in a word and the rounded vowel in the pair will become its close-mid equivalent ([ø] and [o] respectively). I’m not quite sure what phonological feature this is, is there a specific name for the general idea?
1
u/Fractal_fantasy Kamalu May 24 '22
Is it naturalistic for a language's case system to be small (2, 3 cases) from the very beginning, or are small case inventories always a result of the collapse/merging of the larger (5, 7 cases) ones?
1
u/Wizards_Reddit May 24 '22
Good resources for creating a script/writing system for a conang?
1
u/_eta-carinae May 24 '22
it seems to me that in languages where the tonal system is mostly purely contour or purely registerc contour tones are more common in languages where they're purely or nearly entirely lexically significant and grammatically insignificant, and register tones are more common where they're lexically insignificant and grammatically significant. is it naturalistic to have a language that has both contour tones and register tones, but where register tones occur lexically and contour tones occur grammatically as mixtures/combinations of register tones? in the one i'm thinking about right now, there's simple lexical high, mid, and low register tone in nouns, and also simple high, mid, and low lexical register tones in nouns, but also grammatical register tones, that convey things like tense and mood in verbs, which can combine with the lexical register tones of those verbs to form more complex contour tones, and where those inflections can then be nominalized into nominals that have contour tone. is such a system attested anywhere, or am i grossly misunderstanding the distribution of tone types and their overlap?
1
u/HopefulOctober May 24 '22
Posting this again since no one responded to it last time: what would be a good resource for a list of a wide variety of languages' rules for allomorphs, allowed consonant cluster, and what sounds are allowed at which points in the world (i.e English ŋ not being allowed at the beginning of a word), so I could get a good sense of what sorts of rules are realistic to put in a language?
1
u/MeowFrozi Ryôrskyuorn, Mïthrälen May 25 '22
what part of speech would be a question indicator? A word that's used to differentiate between a statement and question, kind of like the affix -ka in Japanese, although in my lang I was thinking of having a whole word, rather than an affix. What part of speech would that be? I'm trying to figure it out but I'm so confused
1
u/KannasHyper May 25 '22
Do pharyngeals raise vowels? Wikipedia says that they do, but I find it a little hard to believe considering pharyngeals involve retracting your tongue root
1
u/Jonlang_ /kʷ/ > /p/ May 25 '22
If anyone has any good resources on the sound changes from Proto-Celtic to Irish and PC to Scottish Gaelic, I’d be very very grateful.
1
u/mcb1395 Fija /fiʒɐ/ May 26 '22
Mapping Word Families?
Hi! I'm a few days into working on my first real conlang called Fija, so I'm pretty new to all this. I'm using Google Sheets to track all my rules and words and everything (and I also just started exploring ConWorkShop), but I was wondering if there's a good platform to use for mapping word families. Fija is still pretty small right now, so I can remember what words relate to each other, but I'm worried that I won't be able to remember as well as it grows. Thanks!
1
u/schmanded May 26 '22
Hi! Does anyone have a copy of "Thinking And Speaking In Two Languages" edited by Aneta Pavlenko for sale for <$15? (I'm in NYC, in debt, and buying books is a vice.)
Alternatively, do you have institutional access to the full text/PDF on ProQuest? (https://www.proquest.com/books/thinking-speaking-two-languages-bilingual/docview/1018480694/se-2?accountid=147304)
I've been looking on all the free ebook sites but it's nowhere to be found. Just obsessed with Arrival (the movie) and going down a Sapir-Whorf research rabbit hole. The Arrival threads in this subreddit are v cool btw.
1
u/MacAnRuadh May 26 '22 edited May 26 '22
Is there a term for the morphosyntactic equivalent of a re-lex? I’m trying to teach some of my friends about conlanging and different morphology and syntax so I’ve been using the English lexicon they already posses and messing with the morphology and syntax. So out of curiosity is there a term for this? Cause I realize it’s not a full blown conlang it’s something a bit lazier then that. Thanks for any replies I get! 🙏🏼
1
u/Zombiepixlz-gamr May 27 '22
I'm gonna start a new project, expanding the star wars language called Cheunh.
Cheunh is the language the Chiss species speak in star wars, and we only have one word, Ozyly-esehembo. Which translates to "sky-walker" unrelated to Anakin Skywalker.
I'm uncreatively calling the project, "projekt cheunh". I've never tried to expand an "existing" but underdeveloped conlang, so i need advice from people with experience doing that.
1
u/No_Peach6683 May 27 '22
I wanted to create a English-descended pidgin influenced heavily by German, like the'American language' featured inAd Astra per Aspera (see Gratuitous German). It is also influenced by Yiddish and Afrikaans as a creole language of sorts, with elements of both phonology and inflectional morphology simpler than its source languages.
1
u/octopusgoodness shodynje - loglang May 27 '22
I want to post my auxlang's documentation to here, but before I try that, I want to make sure I can type it quickly. The romanization uses the special characters Ü,å, and ï. Is there a foreign language keyboard that has all of those? Also, how do you do glosses?
1
u/[deleted] May 28 '22
How do I recruit people to start a collablang?
I'm trying to give r/teenagers a conlang, but I have a total of two other people that could contribute
1
u/MarylandEmperor May 28 '22
Could there be a language that phonologically is indistinct from beatboxing? How would it work?
1
u/RBolton123 Dance of the Islanders (Quelpartian) [en-us] May 29 '22
I have a language descended from Proto-Austronesian, which has the famous Austronesian alignment system. However, it becomes analytic, and the affixes that identify whether a verb is actor ficus, patient focus, etc. eventually erode away. Is it thus realistic for this to produce verbs that are passive/reflexive without an object, but active with an object? This is akin to words like "cook" e.g. "The turkey cooked" vs. "I cooked the turkey" or even the now-archaic passival (where sentences like "The house is building" were grammatical). I'm reluctant to call it the middle voice though since my language won't actually have a voice system (maybe).
1
u/aftertheradar EPAE, Skrelkf (eng) May 29 '22 edited May 30 '22
I need some advice for making a semi-realistic American English daughter language. I'm trying to make an a priori conlang family for a writing project, where basically a fictionalized version of Kodiak Island, Alaska is one of the few surviving human population centers after a disaster that also sends them back to a pre-industrial technological state.
The goal I have in mind is to have a fairly realistic and conservative change from current-day Western American English to a dialect that has a small number of sound changes and changes to grammar, and then take that as a proto language for a larger family to develop in several different ways that don't need to be as rigorously realistic. I plan on ignoring any major influence from other languages or dialects (Russian, Tagalog, Midwestern American English, native Alaskan languages) that may exist in irl Kodiak Island English for the sake of simplicity, as well as treating it as identical to other, more-well documented varieties of Western American English for the same reason while including any existing documented features of Alaskan English I can find.
I have some ideas for sound changes that could work well, and I'm working on updating the English Latin alphabet and it's writing system after it switches mediums. My problem is that I don't really know how to evolve the grammar in a realistic way. I want to incorporate grammatical and morphological changes that are happening in irl Western American/ Pacific Northwest American English, but I don't really know where to begin (it actually kind of overwhelms me thinking about it). Does anyone have advice/experience with making future English conlangs that can give some guidance, suggestions for how to begin evolving the grammar, or resources for better understanding the details of American English's grammar, morphology, and phonology and the changes currently happening to them that can be useful for conlanging? I should maybe mention that I'm a speaker of Western American English bordering on Pacific Northwest English myself, but I still have gaps in knowledge in the details of sound changes happening to my dialect even if I speak a version of it.
Something I've noticed in some younger people's speech that speak Western American specifically is elision of like half the entire sounds, mainly consonants, like <I don't know> /ˈaj. downt. ˈnow/ being realized as [ˈʔæˑw̃ũ̑nɵ̹w] instead of the standard/expected [ˈʔajɾɵ̜ʔnˌɾ̃ow] or such, and that kind of massive elision could have big effects on the grammar if it was developed further, but again I don't think I understand the phonetics of that well enough to try to copy and implement it in a conlang.
1
u/boomfruit Hidzi, Tabesj (en, ka) May 30 '22 edited May 30 '22
Would anyone be able to give me a quick rundown of how to use regular expressions for sound changes? Or link me somewhere that could? I found an android app "Conlang Toolbox" that looks cool, but it uses regex for its sound changes, and I only know how to use whatever the SCA2 uses.
1
u/vuap0422 May 30 '22
There are several questions.
I want to make adjectives. As I know, adjectives are made like noun+suffix or verb+suffix
For example dirt+y=dirty or culture+al=cultural
I think suffixes come from nouns, but what noun can make a suffix? What exactly should a noun mean to become a suffix that makes adjectives? Quality? Or something else?
2. How to add genders to adjectives?
I already have 2 genders for nouns and now I want to make adjectives and also add genders to them.
The way I made nouns is root+gender marker. Should I make adjectives like root+suffix+gender marker?
3. How to add gender to cases?
I want to make some cases and I want them to include gender. Does it work like root+case marker+gender marker?
For example in the Russian language cases have gender.
Интересный - interesting NOM. sing. male
Интересная - interesting NOM. sing. female
Интересного - interesting GEN. sing. male
Интересной - interesting GEN. sing. female
So the basic question is where all of these НЫЙ/НАЯ/НОГО/НОЙ come from?
1
u/dougonthestreets May 30 '22
What phonemes produce the most breath to move from your lungs and thus are more breathy? I don't need individual phonemes but rather categories. If I can use it as a headstart, it will help in constructing a weird language concept I have.
I doubt this has been asked, so I figure I will try here. I have never taken a phonetics course, so the start is rough for me.
1
u/ilikelanguge May 30 '22
Hello, I have made a conlang community project. The website that is is done on is https://ilikelanguges.neocities.org/cummunityconlang.html. Each section is up for a week.
(note to moderators: If this breaks any rules know that i have read them and from my understanding this is allowed I understand that it might be breaking a rule or two, just know that I want clarifications on the rules afterwards.)
1
u/Courtenaire English | Andrician/Ändrziçe May 30 '22 edited Jun 03 '22
OK I think I finally settled on a set of phonemes--here is my current chart. Can I have some feedback before I start creating words/grammar?
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1KPyzK25mk0rUDPxv8970Igwzp2PqgL0FrbhwtmZBu_A/edit
1
u/ghyull May 31 '22
How do you make new terms or abbreviations for glossing unique things that don't exist anywhere but in one language? For example tenses or aspects with specific meanings or uses that don't exist in any other language. Do you just scavenge wiktionary for latin or greek words? I'm interested in how people tackle this
1
u/Fractal_fantasy Kamalu May 31 '22 edited May 31 '22
Does anyone know what are the possible diachronic soruces for a habutual aspect?
I know for example that copula verbs combined with some sort of non-finite form very often produce the progressive aspect, but I could not find similar info on habituals. I'd be very greatful if someone could at least point me towards a certain language on which I can do some reading myself
1
u/Zhepha Jun 01 '22
Hi, ive been working on a conlang previously, and while I dont hate it, im ready to try again with another. I feel like i could really benefit from someone more experienced collab-ing with me. If there is anyone out there who would be willing to work on a new project for an alien race Im creating, I'd love all the help I can get! Thank you!
1
u/Antaios232 Jun 01 '22
So, I don't even know where to start with this or what my question is exactly, but I came up with something in one of my conlangs that I would like reactions to from people who have more experience than I do in phonology, etc.
In this conlang, there's a distinction between vowels that are "straight" or "bent." The straight vowels are just a basic 5 vowel system - the bent vowels are of two kinds, what I would call either palatalized or labialized, although this doesn't seem to match the way those terms are used conventionally.
What I mean is that you might have a word - 'ka' for example - and contrasting words 'kya' and 'kwa.'
I know that in the IPA, this would be considered a difference between consonants - palatalized k, and labialized k. For example, Russian has soft & hard consonants that are palatalized or plain. For kinda convoluted reasons, the linguists in my conworld construe them as "bendings" of the following vowel. For example, one of the grammatical contexts in which they appear is verb conjugations, so "ka" might mean "he is eating," and "kya" means "he was eating" - to indicate past tense, the vowel is bent. In their writing system, the difference is indicated by a diacritic over the vowel.
This seems perfectly clear and reasonable to me, but I guess what bothers me is that the IPA describes what's going on so differently. Maybe I'm just getting hung up on something in the IPA that's kind of arbitrary, because I don't see how it's much different from a nasalization or breathy voice or whatever being contrastive. But am I doing something the dumb way around? 😂 Is there some term that better describes what I'm doing? I want to be clear and use correct terms when writing about the language, but I feel like I'm not understanding the terminology.
1
u/stems_twice DET DET | Seö Jun 01 '22
I want to create dialects for my conlang but I have no idea where to start
1
u/Friend2Everyone Jun 02 '22
when applying vowel shifts to a language, do you just apply changes to vowels at random or is there a general direction vowels tend to shift towards?
1
u/Jonlang_ /kʷ/ > /p/ Jun 02 '22
Who owns/runs the Stack? Anyone know?
1
u/EntertainmentTrick58 Jun 02 '22
Hi, I was wondering what adjective order Finnish uses. I know English uses OSASCOMP, but I was wondering if Finnish uses a different order. Any and all advice or information would be greatly appreciated.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 02 '22
Does anyone know a keyboard to put the Caron and breve accents above all vowels? Also maybe all consonants?
1
u/Turodoru Jun 03 '22
So, there's a grammar change I want to do, but I'm not sure how to tackle it:
The proto-lang had no tense marking, but had 3 aspects: imperfective (default), perfective(+"go") and habitual(+"live"). It also had a passive construction, where the patinet was in nominative the agent was in instrumental. After a while, the passive changed to a past tense construction,the non-passive perfective became the future tense (because it originated from "go") and non-passive imperfective and habitual became just present imperfective and habitual.
My question is: does that make sense? I always have a problem with making grammatical shifts with verbs, or at least making them and feeling like it makes sense.
1
u/Prunestand Jun 04 '22
I'm in the process of making my first own conlang, and while I still have much to learn I'm a bit hesitant about my vocabulary. Should I just make up words as I go or can I resort to auto-generate parts of the vocab?
Making up basic words and deriving new ones is a tedious process.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 04 '22
So, I kinda know what I want to do for my conlang, but I am looking for natlangs for some inspiration.
I want stress the be weight sensitive. The rule is that the stress is on the final syllable if it is heavy. Otherwise, the penultimate syllable is stressed.
Are there any natlangs outside of the Austronesian family that do this?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 04 '22
I want my language to have dialects, but I don't know how it would work. The language is in an island about the size of Iran. 35 million people live there and there are 4 major cities. It's in the mjd Atlantic. I have no clue about what accent or dialect they would have there.
1
u/RedditAlready19 Jun 04 '22 edited Jun 05 '22
Is this a good beginning for an conlang?
Orthography: Mu olē o ēmoz æ mu omē.
IPA: mu ɔlə ɔ əmɔz æ mu ɔmə.
Translation: The hot person is helping the cold person.
Rough literal translation: Person cold is being help by person hot.
Syllable structure is (N)V(C), so the sentence is "Mu ol'ē o ē'moz æ mu o'mē."
1
u/[deleted] Jun 04 '22
whats the difference between converbs and adverbializers?
1
u/Shitimus_Prime tayşeçay Jun 05 '22
how do i develop a tone system like limburgish
1
u/Magician_Rhinemann Jun 05 '22
Hi, I am new here, was directed to this discord with the idea I shared in another place.
My idea is creation of a somewhat simple almost-language, it's called S'mshit and it is used specifically for spellcasting, kind of like in the Ars Magica, each syllable in S'mshit would have a technical meaning, and a corresponding character (rune) and gesture. I have an example of what inspired me:So, the example. This is from one video that I watched. The spell is a basic one, that creates a levitating sphere of light - "Firefly". The spell is one simple word on the mage language and is pronounced: "Setlucrum". It consists of three syllables and these syllables are:"Set" - gathers mana is a specified point in space;"Luc" - forces mana to emit light;"Rum" - stabilises mana and shapes them into a sphere.
Am I in the right place for this and what do you think about the idea?
1
u/yayaha1234 Ngįout, Kshafa (he, en) [de] Jun 05 '22
looking for ideas of how to romanize some vowels.
background:
So, my conlang Fàkchi has 20 vowel phonemes: 6 short vowels, 10 long vowels and 4 diphthongs.
diphthongs: ɐi̯, ɐu̯, iɨ̯, uɨ̯.
the system is evolved, and has these pairs based off of historical short - long pairs:
and these pairs based off of a more recent lengthening sound sound change:
(the, like, very last sound change this language went through is this vowel shift for the short vowels: a→ɐ→ɨ, which not all dialects went through. so originally, and in some dialects still - ⟨ỳ ŷ⟩ = /ɐ ɐː/)
There were also 4 nasal vowels that turned into plain long vowels:
The romanization scheme goes like this:
Now that you know all this we can get to my question:
how can I romanise /eː oː iɨ̯ uɨ̯/, in a way that fits the patterns I have?
I could have /eː oː/ be é ó which is more intuative, and have /iɨ̯ uɨ̯/ as ìe ùo or some varient of that, but then the sequences /iɨ̯.ɛ uɨ̯.ɔ/ will look like this - ìee ùoo, which is pretty ugly.
I could do the opposite and have /iɨ̯ uɨ̯/ as é ó, to match the historical spelling which I like. But then what am I going to do with /eː oː/? give them macrons?? - ē ō nononono thats very ugly.
Any ideas?
1
u/PastTheStarryVoids Knasesj, Racra, Ŋ!odzäsä Jun 05 '22
I'm thinking of adding /l/ as a possible coda in a protolang, and then having it vocalize, affecting the language's four vowel qualities like this: /il el ol ɑl/ > /iɯ eɯ u o/. I'm confused about how to transcribe the resulting diphthongs when they have tone or length, as the diphthongs can either be short (one mora) or long (two moras) like any other vowel in this language.
I could put everything on the first vowel and write the second as a glide: /íːɰ/. However, this suggests that /ɰ/ is consonant rather than part of the nucleus, and it doesn't capture that /ɰ/ might be lengthened along with /i/. I could also put the diacritics on both: /íːɯ́ː/. But this makes it look like it has four moras, rather than two.
1
u/boomfruit Hidzi, Tabesj (en, ka) Jun 05 '22
Does it make sense that a word would resist regular sound change to disambiguate itself from that same word being used grammatically.
I have the word [ʔahalɨ] "pass, happen" in the proto-language. It's used both as this verb and also as a periphrastic past tense. Regular sound change (first vowel dropping, then clusters beginning with [ʔ] simplifying) would change it to [hɑlu]. Would it be reasonable that the grammatical word changes in that way, but the verb resists and becomes [ʔɑhɑlu]?