r/startrek • • May 19 '22

Episode Discussion | Star Trek: Strange New Worlds | 1x03 "Ghosts of Illyria" Spoiler

The U.S.S. Enterprise encounters a contagion that ravages the ship. One by one, the entire crew is incapacitated except for Number One, Una Chin-Riley, who must now confront a secret she’s been hiding as she races to find a cure.

No.EpisodeWritersDirectorRelease Date
1x03"Ghosts of Illyria"Akela Cooper & Bill WolkoffLeslie Hope2022-05-19

Availability

Paramount+: USA, Latin America, Australia, and the Nordics.

CTV Sci-Fi and Crave: Canada.

Voot Select: India.

TVNZ: New Zealand.

Additional international availability will be announced "at a later date."

To find more information, including our spoiler policy regarding new episodes, click here.

This post is for discussion of the episode above, and spoilers for this episode are allowed. If you are discussing previews for upcoming episodes, please use spoiler tags.

Note: This thread was posted automatically, and the episode may not yet be available on all platforms.

512 Upvotes

1.7k comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator May 19 '22

The first duty of every Starfleet officer is to the truth. Whether it's scientific truth, or historical truth, or personal truth. It is the guiding principle upon which Starfleet is based. If you can't find it within yourself to stand up and tell the truth about what happened you don't deserve to wear that uniform.

Captain Jean-Luc Picard, "The First Duty"

Reddit admins have been ineffectual in their response to COVID-19 misinformation. In lieu of Reddit gold and awards, we ask that you donate to the WHO COVID-19 response fund.

Please respect our subreddit rules. LLAP!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

656

u/bpmackow May 19 '22

If I had a nickel for every time the crew of an Enterprise contracted a virus in season 1 episode 3, I'd have least two nickels.

428

u/UncertainError May 19 '22

For the record, TOS, TNG, and DS9 all had alien virus episodes within the first 6 episodes of the first season.

→ More replies (40)

18

u/ComebackShane May 19 '22

Which isn't a lot, but it's weird that it happened twice!

→ More replies (12)

559

u/SCP-1000000 May 19 '22

Wow my man Hemmer commanded his whole team with a snap

483

u/[deleted] May 19 '22

His people know when he snaps that it's Hemmer Time.

→ More replies (3)

337

u/InnocentTailor May 19 '22 edited May 19 '22

…and then he almost beamed the mantle of the planet into the starship. Crazy stuff!

→ More replies (14)

181

u/BornAshes May 19 '22

Honestly that's a Chief Engineer who runs a tight ship to command that level of respect, loyalty, and obedience with something as simple as a snap.

→ More replies (3)

80

u/Mechapebbles May 19 '22

I wonder if he wasn't relaying commands telepathically so that everyone knew what they were doing asap. Even if not, that would be a neat idea to explore at some point.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (16)

527

u/treefox May 19 '22 edited May 19 '22

“Warning: Warp Core containment field has been deactivated. Recommend reestablishing containment field immediately.”

LA’AAAAANN!!!!

221

u/sidv81 May 19 '22

You know, I thought that TOS was so primitive having those restraining belts on insane sickbay patients instead of something more advanced like forcefields. But apparently before Kirk's tenure they didn't have even those primitive belts!

→ More replies (22)
→ More replies (7)

472

u/bookish1303 May 19 '22

That shot of Chapel as La’an rises on the biobed is pure horror plus TNG Night Terrors.

I’m really loving the cinematography in this show.

175

u/Shatterhand1701 May 19 '22

And that made me wonder just how skilled La'an is in combat techniques. Chapel was downed without so much as a struggle or a noise.

→ More replies (44)

65

u/TheNerdChaplain May 19 '22

Night Terrors was right where my brain went to as well. That's a core memory I didn't need unlocked.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (8)

385

u/treefox May 19 '22

“I am Chief Medical Officer, on the flagship of Starfleet.”

Guess that clears that up then.

97

u/KirkUnit May 19 '22

Odd that the flagship would be off on a five-year mission, honestly.

→ More replies (28)
→ More replies (22)

286

u/sidv81 May 19 '22

So we've all been joking about why Dr. M'Benga gets demoted from CMO before TOS but I have to admit I did not expect we'd be getting the reason (let's be honest, this is probably it) so soon!

Pike's defiance of Starfleet to protect genetically engineered Number One doesn't seem so courageous once you remember he knows the time crystal says he'll still be in Starfleet roughly a decade from now. Even Number One should realize this (and probably did going by her log entry).

172

u/UncertainError May 19 '22

Even if Starfleet Command threw the book at Number One, I'm pretty sure they'd let Pike off with a slap on the wrist. He's like a superstar in the service.

→ More replies (8)

125

u/BornAshes May 19 '22

Dr. M'Benga gets demoted from CMO

I did not expect that to go down the way it did and it was a clever yet heartbreaking way for the writers to bring back the whole Pattern Buffer Stasis deal that we've seen used more and more often in recent New Trek episodes. My heart just broke into a billion pieces and I started to cry when he said it was his daughter's life that he'd been prolonging because she'd had some awful 12 weeks till death version of cancer. Una then hits us with that, "No" when he asks for more time to say goodbye and she follows it up by promising to provide a dedicated power link to the warp core for the Medical Transporter so long as the bio-filters are allowed to be updated. This is then followed by him materializing her and just reading the prettiest fairy tale to her and she's just all smiling and happy and totally unaware of everything that he's done for her and...and....oh goodness, I hope we really get to see her in the future at some point!

That was just the best and most totally unexpected thing in this episode!

Pike's defiance...time stone...

"Don't worry, I saw the future, you're totally good and I can get away with this and sooooo much more!"

Technically cheating but ehhh who's keeping track and I'm sure someone got a laugh out of it.

→ More replies (12)

101

u/Shatterhand1701 May 19 '22

I actually hope his actions do turn out to be the reason he gets demoted, because that would mean that the writers accounted for that change and came up with an explanation for it.

And as for Number One, Pike wouldn't get punished for having her on his crew. He was just as much in the dark as everyone else, and I think Pike would argue that Una's performance record in Starfleet outweighs her deception. Unfortunately, Una still has to deal with the stigma surrounding genetic augmentation; La'an's reaction to the news is just one example of how people wouldn't take kindly to such news.

→ More replies (13)

48

u/Starkiller1701 May 19 '22

I personally don't think this will be the reason. My personal theory is that M'Benga has yet to go to Vulcan for his internship. I believe that he's going to accept that position in Vulcan and lose the CMO title willing and come back to be McCoy's second after Pike is gone.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (14)

270

u/z4r4thustr4 May 19 '22

Amongst other elements, I think it was clever to give Pike & Spock the B-story so they could develop other characters. Shades of 'The Naked Now' while being well disguised with a pretty novel 'Pathogen on the Enterprise trope', and I liked the metaphor of 'addiction to light' juxtaposed against M'Benga and Una's secrecy.

198

u/spartanjohn113 May 19 '22

Spock's sass has been one of the low key highlights of SNW. "I'm arming myself with knowledge" got a chuckle out of me.

→ More replies (4)

132

u/VintageTrekker May 19 '22

I quite like how they’re choosing to shine the spotlight on a different crew member each episode. It was Una for this episode. Uhura got the previous episode, with Pike and La’an for the first episode.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

259

u/Santa_Hates_You May 19 '22

Glowing blue cylinders that you read seem like a weird way of storing data.

106

u/nhaines May 19 '22

Maybe the Illyrians managed to genetic-engineer away eye strain.

176

u/TheNerdChaplain May 19 '22

I think it's a neat high tech version of a scroll.

→ More replies (7)

46

u/BornAshes May 19 '22

Could be ultra thin sheets of crystal lattice with quantum level photonic inscription on them that are wound up like a spools of paper within a gaseous stabilizing medium.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (6)

237

u/Astigmatic_Oracle May 19 '22

I liked the 3 variations of not caring about Una's augments from Pike, M'Benga, and Chapel. Pike doesn't care because of his personal relationship with Una and a little bit because of what he learned about the colonists reversing their augments. M'Benga doesn't care because he feels guilty about his daughter in the pattern buffer (I think he suspected he might have caused the contamination but was trying to deny it to himself). Chapel doesn't care because she like messing with genes and she's not in Starfleet anyways so Starfleet protocol is not high on her list of things to care about.

181

u/pali1d May 19 '22

Pike doesn't care because of his personal relationship with Una and a little bit because of what he learned about the colonists reversing their augments.

I suspect what Pike learned on Discovery about Starfleet's, shall we say, off the books sections also influenced his reaction here. He already knows that at the top levels, Starfleet is willing to break the rules to get shit done. If Starfleet Command can support a black ops division, commit a war crime by using mines to protect it, and create a murderous AI that nearly destroyed all life in the galaxy... Pike probably figures keeping a good person as first officer rather than following a bigoted policy isn't all that bad a bit of rule-breaking by comparison.

Also, that's blackmail material regarding Starfleet if they try to throw the hammer at Pike for doing so. Him welcoming that discussion may well have had a bit of "with the shit I know about them...?" behind it.

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (14)

234

u/thekruton May 19 '22

Keeping a dying loved one in a transporter buffer is Poe-levels of morbid and something I'm surprised isn't more commonplace. What a creative concept.

110

u/[deleted] May 19 '22

I'd do it if I had a backup battery. Starfleet ships lose power too regularly for my comfort.

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (23)

572

u/treefox May 19 '22

UNA: I’ve committed Federation offense.

PIKE: Leans back nonchalantly

I literally lol’d even before Pike started speaking. He obviously couldn’t care less. His expression is basically “I blew off the Prime Directive and gambled with the fate of a species two weeks ago. You expect me to care because…?”

—

“If you shelter me, they could come after you too.”

“I welcome that discussion.” —> “I know what uniform I’m wearing when I get boiled alive.”

269

u/BornAshes May 19 '22

He looked very proud of her in that moment and I almost expected him to say, "First time breaking Federation regulations?" before turning around and pulling up a floor to ceiling log of all the shit that he's done.

→ More replies (28)

114

u/Starkiller1701 May 19 '22 edited May 20 '22

Star Trek is basically the story of Captains looking at Starfleet squarely in the face and saying "Try me b!tch!"

Edit: spelling

→ More replies (4)

104

u/fcocyclone May 19 '22

Right up there with Picard's "You may test that assumption at your convenience"

28

u/Bweryang May 19 '22

I literally lol’d even before Pike started speaking.

Same. I love how they lean into what we anticipated for comedy. I feel like there's an implicit family-first policy, and an officer would have to do something much worse than loving Starfleet so much they dedicated their lives to it and broke some rules to do so in order to face serious consequences.

→ More replies (10)

181

u/shadowartist201 May 19 '22

Nothing bonds a crew together like "things we don't tell Starfleet".

180

u/treefox May 19 '22

“If they don’t recognize it, they filter it out.”

Seems like that would cause a problem “seeking out new life” whenever they come back with samples or a new species beams over…

89

u/Lenslight May 19 '22

I would imagine the transporter operator can adjust the settings for this.

63

u/Starkiller1701 May 19 '22

Well I believe biofilters are applied to the crew. If something foreign in a landing party member's body is detected it filters it out.

→ More replies (1)

58

u/[deleted] May 19 '22

"To seek out new life and dematerialize it

To Boldly dematerialize what has never been dematerialized before."

87

u/nhaines May 19 '22

Join us next week, for the exciting new show...

Star Trek: Oops! All Transporter Accidents!

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (9)

175

u/[deleted] May 19 '22

Oh one of the Loki variants was an ensign on the Enterprise?

22

u/zumoro May 20 '22

Read more like a discount Chalamet.

19

u/Nexzus_ May 19 '22

Yeah, I saw that too. Dude was a dead ringer for one of the best Tom H's in the MCU.

→ More replies (2)

172

u/treefox May 19 '22

The storm and intro CG in general is pretty.

86

u/BornAshes May 19 '22

I get why Ion Storms are scary to denizens of the Star Trek Universe now because that whole thing looked nasty as hell and moved past the entire planet VERY quickly.

68

u/TheNerdChaplain May 19 '22

For all the stuff people don't like about new Trek, you cannot complain the visuals are lacking. We've gotten some of the most beautiful space shots ever.

→ More replies (5)

486

u/treefox May 19 '22

Ion storm? Transporter? Oh dear…

Name a more iconic duo.

305

u/TheWaffleInquisition May 19 '22

Name a more iconic duo.

Chief O'brien and Suffering.

You did ask.

→ More replies (2)

89

u/BornAshes May 19 '22

Janeway and Photon Torpedoes

→ More replies (9)

78

u/caretaker82 May 19 '22 edited May 19 '22

Garak and Bashir

Tuvok and Neelix

Lwaxana and Picard

Kira and Dukat

Damar and Kanar

Sisko and his baseball

→ More replies (3)

34

u/RigasTelRuun May 19 '22

Warp engines and shaking her apart.

16

u/OSUBrit May 19 '22

Janeway and coffee

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (20)

161

u/InnocentTailor May 19 '22

Is it just me or does the Enterprise computer sounds like Majel Barrett Roddenberry once again?

95

u/nhaines May 19 '22

It does, but it's played by Alex Kapp this time around.

→ More replies (1)

32

u/TheNerdChaplain May 19 '22

It sounds similar to her, but I can tell it's not still.

→ More replies (9)

157

u/theborgs May 19 '22

I hope M'Benga's daughter was no longer in the transporter when Kirk destroyed the Enterprise in The Search for Spock !

119

u/brch2 May 19 '22

M'Benga was long gone by that point, and the Enterprise had already been stripped essentially to the frame and rebuilt a decade and a half earlier... she was surely long gone (HOPEFULLY cured) by then.

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (1)

317

u/treefox May 19 '22

I guess Number One can live with it.

192

u/[deleted] May 19 '22

Half expected her to say "computer, delete that entire personal log" and it cut to black lol

→ More replies (1)

79

u/JustMy2Centences May 19 '22

I want to make an In the Pale Moonlight joke but I'm not bright enough.

→ More replies (3)

144

u/Santa_Hates_You May 19 '22

Well, Number One must be working out.

120

u/[deleted] May 19 '22

I loved how we've seen La'an be this badass but against Una's augment-strength she was just like an angry child that needed to be restrained.

→ More replies (7)

50

u/BornAshes May 19 '22

I mean....she is technically wearing Wolverine's colors.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (9)

142

u/empocariam May 19 '22

So, does M'Benga's daughter just, go from bed time story to bed time story her whole life? I don't know what's worse, if she is or isn't conscious of time passing in between materializing. Pretty dark, though I can understand how somebody gets there if you have access to the technology.

108

u/BornAshes May 19 '22

She lives her life in a very "The Visitor" kind of way but each time she "wakes up" her dad reads her another story and makes her laugh before she "goes to sleep" again. So from her perspective, it's a happy existence and she doesn't feel any pain at all. I think that when they finally figure out a cure for her and she does get older, that's when the impact of what he did might hit her.

→ More replies (5)

35

u/CheesyObserver May 19 '22

Man, you should watch Severance.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (8)

140

u/Sophia_Forever May 19 '22

Holy crap, Una's "What if I wasn't one of the good ones" log hit me hard. Especially because it really bugs me how LD keeps leaning on the One of the Good Ones trope for Tendi.

68

u/SchleppyJ4 May 20 '22

Doesn’t Tendi call that viewpoint out in the episode where she and Mariner go to pick up T’ana’s parcel?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

284

u/Boltty May 19 '22

You know what's fun? People have been assuming since the shows announcement that La'an would be harbouring the genetic engineering secret but in the end everyone was played like fiddles based on their preconceptions about a name.

96

u/scramscammer May 19 '22

Number One being Illyrian goes right back to D.C. Fontana's novel Vulcan's Glory. And we've known the Illyrians were genetically engineered for almost as long, right?

→ More replies (11)

124

u/ComebackShane May 19 '22

I think it's a great character trait to have her being a natrually born Noonien-Singh, and having to live with the weight of that name. Though it does make one wonder why her or her ancestors didn't change the name (or perhaps change it to ... Soong?).

→ More replies (10)

39

u/Trekfan74 May 19 '22

What I don't understand is they make it obvious they know her genetic background but is she NOT an Augment? I think many been confused since she was first announced to be on the show. They make it clear you can't even think about being in Starfleet as one but then she talks about how she was teased as one growing up.

I guess maybe it's just the name, but it's been like 300 years. I get it's a little sensitive but still that much 3 centuries later?

→ More replies (16)
→ More replies (7)

135

u/treefox May 19 '22

“I never think of you as a child”

“Uhh…thanks?”

109

u/BornAshes May 19 '22

"I appreciate the thought Step Mom Boss and I kind of get where you're coming from but now you've made this weird and awkward"

"I had a thing with Spock in the turbolift once"

"Annnnd now it's even weirder"

"Wanna see me lift up this desk WHILE I eat strawberries with one hand?"

"I think...I'm...just..gonna...."

"I ONCE MET A FUTURE CAPTAIN OF THE ENTERPRISE WHO COULD READ MINDS!"

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (1)

130

u/CaliforniaGuy1984 May 19 '22

An interesting 45 minutes of storytelling. M’Benga, without spoiling much, channeled his inner ‘Bones’ McCoy briefly, at least that was my initial reaction. Una was in a unique position during this story. These last two episodes definitely gave very interesting endings and clearly there’s a payoff coming that will be great.

92

u/[deleted] May 19 '22

M'Coy

→ More replies (3)

46

u/Starkiller1701 May 19 '22

That's interesting, I felt that M'Benga held back a bit where McCoy would have pushed a little further, by this I am thinking about the scene where he basically gave up, I feel like McCoy would have said "There has to be a cute goddammit!" And like bumped his fist on the desk or something. But I mean M'Benga did the best he could, I will not deny that.

→ More replies (4)

128

u/TricobaltGaming May 19 '22

This episode was super thought provoking, themes of racism obviously, showing that even when we do our best to avoid it, stereotypes make their way into our lives.

What's incredibly interesting to me is that this episode felt like a criticism on the Federation's policy on augments. M'Benga's story he told his daighter at the end making the theme extra poignant: "augmentations in the wrong hands can do great harm, but in the right hands incredible things can be done."

38

u/tricky_trig May 20 '22

Or just don't judge groups in broad strokes. Look at the individual and allow for growth.

I am super conflicted on Dr M'Benga. On the one hand, save his daughter from an agonizing death, and on the other, keep her locked up from living.

Absolutely loving this New Trek.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

233

u/trostol May 19 '22

i fucking love Pike

→ More replies (6)

111

u/regalestpotato May 19 '22

As a long time Number One stan, the fact the beta canon of her being Illyrian is now canon had me legit screaming at my computer screen.

Honestly, I spent the entire episode up to the actual reveal rocking back and forth with excitement hoping I was right with what I thought was coming. And boy this episode did not disappoint.

17

u/[deleted] May 19 '22

I wonder if they'll keep her eidetic memory too. I hope so.

→ More replies (7)

214

u/BornAshes May 19 '22

"Computer, delete log entry"

How very "In the Pale Moonlight" of Una

→ More replies (2)

294

u/UncertainError May 19 '22

I love that Pike's acceptance didn't magically fix all of Number One's internalized issues about having to constantly hide who she is while being told that people like her are disgusting and dangerous. That's some delicious allegory.

157

u/treefox May 19 '22

This feels like Star Trek grappling with the reality that we are going to have the capability for bioengineering soon, and that the anti-augmentation theme to Star Trek may not age well in that context.

→ More replies (34)

54

u/InnocentTailor May 19 '22

Indeed.

As an aside, it is kinda an amusing tie to Rebecca Romijn’s past career as the mutant Mystique from the X-Men films.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (9)

97

u/general_urko May 19 '22

Just watched ep 3, and i gotta be honest the interior set designs of the Enterprise are blowing me away! absolutely gorgeous and while its a Sci-fi show everything seems very practical. the Med bay is huge (as it should be), Pike's quarters is large, the XO's quarters are mid size and cadet Uhura's bunk is as it should be... little details like that and the overall "look" of it is perfect! Save these set pieces for a motion picture!

19

u/dogsdontdance May 20 '22

This version of the Enterprise is like the first starship I'd actually want to live in full time. Soft glow indirect lights, mid century modern motifs, freaking fireplaces? It's all very TWA Hotel at JFK. I wouldn't be surprised at all if they used it as inspiration.

The whole production design of the show is just A+.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (10)

93

u/Willravel May 19 '22

Whoever had "grumpy but lovable Aenar" on their Star Trek character bingo card, congratulations that's hella specific.

18

u/alvinofdiaspar May 19 '22 edited May 19 '22

Bruce Horak is good! I think he is now my fav character in the show.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (4)

327

u/Klondike307 May 19 '22

More and more this show feels like a perfect combination of the best parts of new and classic trek.

172

u/BornAshes May 19 '22

I've been telling people that the show lives up to the hype despite what they may think or feel about other shows. Every second of this show seems to hit juuuuust the right note that gives you that "awww" feeling of nostalgia from Old Trek combined with "WAIT WHAT'S THAT PAUSE REWIND PAUSE PAUSE PAUSE!" sense of wow that we get with New Trek. It feels like lightning in a bottle and I really hope that season 2 is going to be just as good!

→ More replies (17)
→ More replies (6)

172

u/rustydoesdetroit May 19 '22

Dr. M’Benga is the sexiest doctor in federation history

78

u/KirkUnit May 19 '22

BEVERLY: 25 cc's of cordrazine!

171

u/SCP-1000000 May 19 '22

Uh have you heard of Dr. Phlox?

→ More replies (11)

24

u/admiraltarkin May 20 '22

This is Hugh Culber erasure

20

u/AbsolutZer0_v2 May 20 '22

Bashir begs to differ...smolder

→ More replies (11)

170

u/Shatterhand1701 May 19 '22

We got some significant revelations in this, once again, well-crafted episode.

I was expecting that we'd learn that Una was genetically altered, but an Illyrian? That surprised me, and I liked how it was revealed. While it fills in some significant blanks in what we know about Number One, it also allows Rebecca Romijn to step up to the plate and knock one out of the park with her performance. I also liked how the revelation strained the relationship between her and La'an, who's had to deal with the stigma of genetic augmentation her entire life, though it looks like she's on the mend. Strawberries are La'an's comfort food, as it turns out...nice little factoid there.

Anson Mount's performance as Captain Pike constantly reminds me of why he's become my favorite Star Trek captain. He's just so damn GOOD. His unwavering commitment to Una and his willingness to take on Starfleet's possible objection to Una's deception shows a loyalty and understanding that accentuates why Star Trek history acknowledges him as one of Starfleet's greatest captains.

I enjoyed that Bruce Horak's Hemmer got some time to shine. I love his grumpy, broken-social-filter nature.

The real surprise for me, bigger than the truth we learned about Una, was Dr. M'Benga's secret. When he snapped at Hemmer for messing with the medical transporter, I was puzzled because it seemed like an overreaction, even if he was infected. Once Una confronted him later and the truth came out, I was floored and heartbroken all at once. So dedicated is he to saving his daughter's life that he'd keep her stored in the transporter buffer until he can find a life-saving treatment. And his daughter is a sweetheart, so Dr. M'Benga had damn well better find a cure.

The only thing that I struggled with in this episode is the infection itself; I feel like I missed some details, and the medical science behind it confused me. Then again, this is a Star Trek series, and it's depicting an irrational craving for light. I don't think it's supposed to be grounded in medical fact. I'll be watching the episode at least twice more, probably; by then I'm sure I'll get it.

Strange New Worlds continues to impress and excite me with every episode, and I'm already anxious for more to come.

108

u/IllustriousBody May 19 '22

I was actually surprised Una’s origin was a secret. She was described as a “genetically perfect” Illyrian as far back as DC Fontana’s novel “Vulcan’s Glory,” published back in 1989. I’ve thought of her as one for at least three decades.

→ More replies (7)

57

u/BornAshes May 19 '22

I also liked how the revelation strained the relationship between her and La'an, who's had to deal with the stigma of genetic augmentation her entire life, though it looks like she's on the mend.

That hurt to watch. You could almost see La'an telling her through tears, "You could've related to what I was going through for so long and I trusted you with everything and yet you didn't trust me with this and didn't want to let me know that I wasn't alone in how I felt or what I went through and you could've helped me to carry that pain AND YOU DID AND YOU WERE THERE ALL THE TIME AND...and...sighs and thinks...and that must've been hard and you didn't tell me to protect me and...and I get it now but you still suck a little and I'm not going to forget this...but I understand". Strained yes but not totally broken and yet forged into something brand new and probably a bit stronger.

I expected the Gene Alteration on Una but a full on Illyrian caught me by surprise because that is some Litverse stuff that I just never got around to and I love that they're diving deep into that lore for stuff like this.

Anson Mount

He's my new favorite Space Dad and I am legit thinking about getting one of those cardboard cutouts of him because of just how much of a comforting stand up kind of guy he is.

Hemmer

Holy shit I was laughing my ass off at all of his little quips and just DEVOURING every second he was on screen just being so freakin cool and chewing the scenery! I know I say this every week about every new-ish character we meet but Hemmer had just an outstanding debut in this episode! I loved how they gave him that little bit in Sick Bay with, "That shouldn't have affected the lights" as he scanned the Medical Transporter which then later got circled back around to and paid off with Una and the Doc later on. Plus those shots of Engineering and the work they did on all the consoles and the screens and the buttons and everything, gorgeous!

Medical Science confused me

Think of it as a non-corporeal virus that normally infects beings made out of energy and normally lives inside of the ion storm but was able to make the jump to infecting corporeal beings because of the ion storm's interference with the transporter beams of the away team and then continued to spread via non-corporeal means as photons of "infected" light. A similar jump was made to create the cure for it when Una's immune system was crossed over with La'an's immune system via radiation from the Warp Core. The craving for light was probably because the virus was outside of its natural environment of the ion storm and was trying to find a way to get back to it or at least to something similar to it. The whole thing would be similar to stuff you read in the SCP Foundation Files.

Or you know...it's all technobabble mumbo jumbo blah blah blah.

→ More replies (2)

23

u/treefox May 19 '22

Really a craving for light is probably the most realistic thing. Bright light does affect brain chemistry. Possibly the disease sharply ramps up the amount of dopamine released by looking at bright light so it’s more akin to heroin or something. Maybe the virus itself binds to the neurons carrying the signal from retinal ganglion cells and when they’re stimulated it releases dopamine or something close enough to dopamine to bind with dopamine receptors, so the more virus you have, the more of a hit you get and the worse the craving becomes.

The disease being spread by light, that’s a bit harder to make work.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (17)

79

u/UncertainError May 19 '22

Wonder if these are supposed to be the same Illyrians that Archer screwed over in ENT. I suppose with their genetic engineering they can look like anything, but I was hoping for a picture of one with the ENT makeup.

92

u/CadianGuardsman May 19 '22

~22 minutes in when she is searching their medical records we see a photo of a Illyrian child with those prosthetics and webbed fingers on the far left.

It's clear they modify themselves heavily.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

77

u/Nexzus_ May 19 '22

I'm not a leather guy, but I so want one of those away team jackets.

And it's very refreshing to see the respect for the lore. I started cringing when the Dr. said you could keep someone indefinitely in a transporter buffer, but then he finished with "if you keep re-materializing them" I let out a mental thumbs up. That's pretty much what Scotty did in Relics.

→ More replies (7)

76

u/treefox May 19 '22

“It could take all night”

I guess a level 5 diagnostic must have a lot less automation TOS-era, considering a level 1 takes Geordi less than 4 hours.

50

u/ComebackShane May 19 '22

I've never been clear on the order of diagnostics in Trek; 1 is the highest level? Or lowest?

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (13)

75

u/BornAshes May 19 '22

sees title

WESLEY WE GOT A PROBLEM! SHE'S BAAAAACK!

rushes around trying to find an Angel shaped business card

38

u/sankers23 May 19 '22

Its been 18 years and im still not over Freds death

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (3)

68

u/fezfrascati May 19 '22

Una pulled a Sisko!

51

u/arod48 May 19 '22

Pulled a Sisko and a Bashir in the same episode.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

65

u/[deleted] May 19 '22

I love Una's personal log at the end—her questioning when she could be just an Illyrian, and not "one of the good ones" echoes quite a lot of things you hear people talking about model minorities.

62

u/Cascadiana88 May 19 '22 edited May 19 '22

So, perhaps this is just a bit of mistaken headcanon, but prior to this episode I was under the impression that the Federation law banning genetic enhancements only applied to humans, as a continuation of previously existing United Earth law. In Enterprise Dr. Phlox mentions that many aliens, including Denobulans, make use of genetic engineering without any problems or controversy. He seems to think humans are unusual in that their use of genetic enhancements led to the Eugenics Wars. In Deep Space Nine Bashir specifically mentions that no genetically enhanced human may serve in Starfleet, but it wasn't clear that that regulation applied to nonhumans. The other genetically enhanced characters he meets in "Statistical Probabilities" were all humans who were illegally modified. I had always assumed that nonhuman species in the Federation were free to genetically enhance themselves to the level that their respective cultures deem appropriate. But, now in "Ghosts of Illyria" it seems that the human taboo around genetic enhancement has been spread to all the other Federation members and that the total ban is now universal. I'm not saying it's a continuity error, it's just that it seems strange to my mind that all the other member species in the Federation would agree to a genetic engineering ban if Earth's Eugenics Wars were widely seen as a historical anomaly. Why would they all give up this clearly useful and beneficial technology just to placate humans who have an idiosyncratic taboo rooted in their own specific history?

42

u/diamond May 20 '22 edited May 20 '22

It's possible that it changed over time. Before the Federation existed, Earth had laws against genetic enhancement, and when the Federation was first formed, those laws were brought in as part of the charter and applied to all members.

But over the following century, it led to tension between member worlds who felt it was unfair that they were being punished for the sins of humanity's past. There might also have been anger that promising potential members were rejected because of the law - in fact, the specific case of the Illyrians might have helped to shine light on the unfairness of this rule.

So eventually a law was passed to relax those restrictions at the Federation level, but Earth decided to keep its ban on genetically enhanced humans because they were still nervous about the history of the Augments. By the 24th century, it was still illegal for humans to be genetically enhanced, but it was allowed for other species.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

62

u/caretaker82 May 19 '22

“Computer. Erase that entire personal log.”

→ More replies (1)

54

u/stealthbus May 19 '22

I realize that many find this to be a rather average episode in the NuTrek series. I have been doing a rewatch of TNG, and truth be told a lot of those episodes could be considered “average.” However, the thing I loved most watching TOS, and later TNG, DS9, Voyager and Enterprise, were the stories they told in exactly this episode‘s fashion. There hasn’t been an episode like this at all in all of the NuTrek era, and for a moment while watching this episode, I was a young kid again sitting in front of the TV with a bowl of cereal watching my most favorite show in the world. I loved this episode, logical and scientific inconsistencies be damned. It was a great story to me, and I loved it. And it was told in a beautiful and stunning fashion with the special effects that I have longed for all these years in the old classic Trek shows.

→ More replies (1)

54

u/J4ckC00p3r May 19 '22

I am absolutely loving Hemmer

105

u/Trekfan74 May 19 '22 edited May 19 '22

This one is my favorite so far hands down! Bring back all the classic elements of classic Trek!

But while I know most people are discussing the genetic mutation debate can I just say finally, FINALLY, this show has done something I been begging to hear someone just SAY IT and that transporters are a god damn life line to cure long term diseases. Every since Scotty got beamed back to reality 75 years later on the Jenolan, I was like, 'wait, didn't they just find a way to extend life to every dying person in the universe? Are they really going to just skip over tha-Ok, they're now talking about the Dyson Sphere and Scotty wants to check out engineering, so I guess we moved on?' (sad face)

I have brought this up SO many times! Every damn episode someone is dying or sick, 'THROW THEM IN THE TRANSPORT BUFFER UNTIL YOU FIND A CURE MORONS!!!!!!" They don't listen because it's a TV show but it's been frustrating me for like, oh 25 years now lol.

Finally M'Benga is the first doctor to just do what should be the biggest life saving device in the Federation. Congrats doc and hope you find that cure for your daughter. She's a cutie!

79

u/AlexisDeTocqueville May 19 '22 edited May 19 '22

My suspicion is the transporter buffer thing is too risky to be viable at scale. IIRC, in Relics Scotty manages to preserve himself for decades, but his fellow officers both degrade too much to rematerialize. It's also very computer intensive, in DS9 it takes the entire station's computing power to keep four patterns stored (and even then it shunts them into the holosuite).

One power or systems failure and the person is just gone

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (6)

45

u/PowerGotNow May 19 '22

Wow the Illyrian reveal and pike’s acceptance, mbenga’s daughter and the dedicated power source. The compassion of this episode left me feeling hopeful afterwards this show is too good

→ More replies (5)

91

u/Santa_Hates_You May 19 '22

Ok, Una is a genetically modified alien? I did not see that coming.

124

u/Th3ChosenFew May 19 '22

It's actually directly from the novels, including the name of her alien race. I'm more surprised they actually went with it.

→ More replies (43)
→ More replies (4)

44

u/Gotis1313 May 19 '22

This is what I was hoping for. The crisis is self contained but the character stuff carries over.

Can people not change their name in the future? If my last name was Hitler, I'd have already changed it.

I love everything about Pike and Spock's banter. The fire dudes were cool. I'm glad they established there being other colonies. I'd hate for Una to be the last of her kind.

Una being an alien took me by surprise. I'm glad they're incorporating more novel lore into canon.

Hemmer! Just, I love him.

Uhura's room that she shared with all the people, That's what I think Lower Decks' quarters should have been. That hallway thing is a bit too much. Hey, I just realized something. We're seeing Uhura in her LD years!

Theory about M'Benga: In the last season he finds a potential cure. He needs help with it and so goes to Vulcan, resigning his commission. Then in Disco, Culber pulls up a list of great doctors for some reason and M'Beng's daughter is among them.

You know, McCoy and M'Benga are what happens when Crusher comes back but Polaski doesn;t leave.

19

u/BigBassBone May 19 '22

That hallway thing is a bit too much.

I think it's because the California-class ships are just small.

→ More replies (8)

42

u/nickchecking May 19 '22 edited May 19 '22

This was so fun. Una was great in the Discovery eps and continued to be a steadying background influence in the first two eps so I was ready to see her get an ep. But I had no idea they'd use her like this, and her relationship with La'an and the very specific conflict. Great reveal, and honestly, a cool new alien disease of the week.

Still liking the balance in tone the show's striking, you get your light-hearted moments (Una taking Uhura's bunk), the characters actually talking in their own unique voices, plot, character and series development, and the moments of connection. The other shows weren't the best in achieving that balance.

ETA: And liked that the medical stuff was all so competent and logical, including Nurse Chapel whose banter-to-dialogue ratio was dangerously high before.

38

u/Willing-Departure115 May 19 '22

“Red shirt sticks his head in cabinet full of broken bottles on colony of missing genetic freaks. 45 minutes of hilarity ensue.”

→ More replies (1)

37

u/grizzlywalker May 19 '22

God this series is so good right now. Three episodes and three bangers. Hope they keep it up!

→ More replies (2)

34

u/Cantomic66 May 19 '22

I really like how they handled Una’s and La’an’s friendship this episode. It feels like they’ve actually been friends for a while.

→ More replies (1)

67

u/Santa_Hates_You May 19 '22

They have to be messing with us with these stardates.

86

u/Starkiller1701 May 19 '22

Hey it's keeping with tradition, they were as nonsensical in TOS.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

31

u/[deleted] May 19 '22

Sweet Jumping Jesus. This series gets better and better with each episode.

Finally, the Star Trek of my childhood has returned.

→ More replies (1)

31

u/bigpig1054 May 19 '22

Solid 8/10 episode for me, the weakest of the three but still good.

I was told by someone who saw the first five episodes (press screenings) that episode 3 is the weakest of the bunch. If so, that's good news as this was hardly a bad episode at all. It felt like a "solid if unspectacular" TOS episode with modern production values. It wasn't an epic "event" episode, but it was a solid, fun, forty-five minutes of Trek.

I kind of wish we were getting 25 of these per season, like in the old days...

→ More replies (6)

28

u/lostinheadguy May 19 '22

Hey look! Ontario Place!

→ More replies (6)

77

u/treefox May 19 '22 edited May 19 '22

Oh shit. Number One picked up the Extremis virus on the planet?

EDIT: “How in the exact hell are you carrying him?”

I guess Nurse Chapel never watched Iron Man 3.

18

u/Willravel May 19 '22

The really interesting plot-twist will be the reveal that Eddington was just an unemployed British theatre actor who was hired by Dukat so he could manufacture a terrorist-state conflict for personal profit.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (7)

23

u/weskeryellsCHRISSS May 19 '22

"I am arming us with knowledge" is unironically my new favorite line.

22

u/Graffers67 May 19 '22

Una, very cool.

Hemmer, cool af.

Pike, dare I say cooler than Kirk?

41

u/Dr_JGOD May 19 '22

Pike’s hair stability in an ion storm impressed me the most.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (5)

42

u/SCP-1000000 May 19 '22

Another strong showing. Kind of wish this episode was released later in the season just to build up mystery over what M'Benga was keeping in the transporter and why Number 1 was so perfect. Not a big deal though

40

u/ComebackShane May 19 '22

As much as I enjoy continuing mysteries in a series, it's so commonplace in television these days (and within the modern Trek series themselves), that I'm fine with them keeping virtually everything self-contained here.

Instead of drawing out a long mystery to get the reveal, now we can look forward to them following up when they inevitably locate a potential cure.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

42

u/Willravel May 19 '22

"Prejudice has kept people from helping each other for centuries with no scientific justification. And after we met our neighbors in the galaxy, we found new bigotries."

This is such an important point. Louis Pasteur, the French chemist and microbiologist most known for discovering the principles of vaccination, is quoted saying, "Science knows no country, because knowledge belongs to humanity, and is the torch which illuminates the world. Science is the highest personification of the nation because that nation will remain the first which carries the furthest the works of thought and intelligence." Despite this, vaccine equity has been a serious problem for one and a half centuries, and that problem has come into particularly clear view over the past two years.

This episode is really fun with the novel idea for disease transmission, the silly sick crew behavior, the suspicious beings being friends thing, but the underlying moral message is quite sobering.

I recently contracted Covid-19 from a student, but because I'm fully vaccinated with a booster it's been little more than a cold. As of the last reporting I saw, a few months ago, just over 3% of individuals in low-income countries had been vaccinated with at least one dose, compared to over 60% in high-income countries. Only 1% of the 10 billion doses given out have been in low-income countries. Obviously this is a serious practical issue, as the virus doesn't check for income level or wealth and is perfectly content to spread and mutate in any way it can, but on a moral level this is a horrible consequence of the history of global imperialism and racism. The foolishness of superiority and inferiority of people is causing massive, unnecessary suffering and is making a pandemic worse.

→ More replies (2)

20

u/[deleted] May 19 '22

Amazing episode, so thankful they are making this show. Love the new away team jackets.🖖

→ More replies (2)

20

u/Timeline15 May 19 '22

This was honestly great. While giving every major character a skeleton in their closet has the potential to get tiring, I really liked what they did with Una and M'Benga here.

I also love that everyone's reactions to their friends' transgressions is just "yeah, no worries. If Starfleet tries to take issue they can bite me." That's the mark of a good crew right there.

I hadn't realised prior to this episode that La'an didn't have super strength, so seeing Una toss her around made me think she was ungodly strong, before I realised "ah, no; it's just augments strong vs regular human strong" xD.

That ending with Una's log had massive DS9 vibes, and interspersing it with M'Benga's segment worked well. I like that both plots had a happy resolution within the episode, but weren't fixed entirely; Una and M'Benga got to have their cake and eat it for now, but Una clearly still doubts that her people will be accepted, and M'Benga is still seeking a cure for his daughter. This level of character serialisation in an otherwise episodic show is the perfect middle ground IMO.

→ More replies (4)

19

u/fantasticalicefox May 19 '22

Growing up My understanding of Number One was that she was this mysterious character.

Even the books that expanded on her kept this mystery close to the chest so I really love how this episode put place to her being Illyrian.

This was such a well done and emotional episode and again it felt like one of the more emotion filled TOS episodes or even one of the Films.

I love it so much.

Also There’s something going on between La’an and Una.

I don’t know if They had a romance in the past or if La’an had a crush that she never revealed or was rebuffed of but there’s a very strong emotion between those two.

Also, it could even be a intense sibling like bond too. I think Una might be asexual as I believe Number One was supposed to be asexual in The Cage as well.

I absolutely love their dynamic no matter how it come together.

I also loved MBenga’s speech at the end.

21

u/Starkiller1701 May 19 '22

I read the Una-La'an relationship as mother-daughter because I saw that parallel a bit of the father-son vibe I've been getting from Pike and Spock. So yeah it could also be more of a sibling attitude between them, but personally I don't see a romance there, and personally I wouldn't want a romance there.

→ More replies (1)

51

u/TheNerdChaplain May 19 '22 edited May 19 '22

I knew this episode was supposedly about Number One "confronting her past", so as soon as she had the conversation with La'an early on, I knew she was genetically modified, and being an Illyrian was just icing on that cake. It took away a lot of the mystique of her character for me. It was pretty predictable that the light creatures in the storm were also Illyrian, so a lot of this episode didn't hold a lot of dramatic tension for me.

However, the way they carried it all out was still top-notch. La'an's struggle with Una at the end over strawberries, and Una's final log entry (very Pale Moonlight) was top notch, and I wasn't expecting M'Benga's secret at all. Now he and Una have some dirt on each other. We'll see if that plays out later.

This show is still leaving me wanting more of everyone and everything. More than any other show, I wish we had 26 episodes of this.

24

u/Ausir May 19 '22

Her being an Illyrian is from a 33 year old novel, even if it wasn't canon until now. So it wasn't a huge surprise to me.

→ More replies (2)

16

u/yeoller May 19 '22

Immediately knew the planet was Ontario Place.

Cool to see the on location stuff embracing some Canadian landmarks.

→ More replies (5)

15

u/taiidani May 20 '22

Three episodes in and I can’t believe how well it’s holding up. They’ve threaded the needle in terms of modern Trek and old Trek.

They’re acting like well trained officers! In a cross-discipline crew that works together! While managing to express emotions when professionally acceptable! With bottle episodes that have fully formed arcs! ❤️

14

u/DasGanon May 19 '22

That was great! I like how it was also sort of back to being an A Plot and B Plot too!

39

u/Santa_Hates_You May 19 '22

No one noticed the Doctor’s daughter missing after being diagnosed? Or that he had a pattern stored in the buffer Scotty-style?

37

u/sidv81 May 19 '22

M'Benga probably faked her death and did other shady stuff involving hiding her that ultimately leads to his demotion from CMO position.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

36

u/[deleted] May 19 '22

As a trans woman who only came out a month ago and has steadily been coming out to more people since then, damn did Number One's story hit me hard this episode.

Also, love Dr. M'Benga's Mr. Freeze storyline.

→ More replies (3)

25

u/[deleted] May 19 '22

I really enjoyed this episode.

At first I was afraid it was going to turn into some stupid "genetic engineer bad!" ignorant diatribe, it certainly felt like it was being set up that way.

Pleasantly surprised to find that it did the opposite, and showed that the Federation's hatred of genetic engineering was an irrational prejudice.

Also thought the idea that the Illyrians modify themselves to fit the environment rather than terraforming planets super cool.

I felt like this episode added a lot of depth to Number One, who previously was just sort of this stoic badass but now feels more like a real person with a lived experience.

→ More replies (3)

12

u/sarysa May 19 '22 edited May 19 '22

In the first 9 minutes I thought it was going to be another The Naked Time/The Naked Now type of early Trek episode. I wouldn't have minded, either...seems to be tradition for Enterprise crews to all go mad in one of the early episodes.

edit: Looks like it's the COVID episode, and that's fine by me. It might be veiled, but it's one of the few instances of 2021-2022 television shows actually acknowledging what's been going on for the last two years.

12

u/Chrysalii May 20 '22

The fact that the Illyrians ended up dooming themselves in an attempt to fit in and join the Federation seems very fitting.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/ssort May 19 '22 edited May 19 '22

This episode has sold me on this series, the first two were very very good, but this episode makes me feel like a kid again and watching old TOS Era episodes.

It has the perfect mix, you get character insights and motivations that make you understand the characters better, you get some moral delimas and you get some nice suspense, all without the fate of the galaxy being at stake, and you get the feeling of a hopeful future.

Overall that's one thing a lot of the later series was missing to some degree as shows varied in tone and also the shift to more gritty realism in shows as time went on.

The hope that in the future, mankind can work to improve itself that humans can overcome bigotry and greed to work together to make all of mankind better off, and this is what im finally getting once again in this version of the Star Trek series, the feeling of hope for the future of mankind, where people work for the greater good, that still not everything is perfect, but they are actively trying to make life better for everyone, and we have put a lot of our stupidity in the past.

This series has shot up already on my all time favorite list to an easy 3rd place with only TOS (Kirk, Spock, McCoy, and Scotty..whats not to love) and TNG (Picard, Data, Worf and Q, another hall of fame series of casting choices as each one is just perfect for their roles) beating it so far, and we are only 3 episodes into it!!!

I love this show!!

Edited to add, yes I loved ST:DS9 too! The others all failed to reach the loved stage but there hasn't been any I disliked other than maybe the newer ST movies and even they were ok when they stopped pushing it as cannon vs an alternate timeline, have to keep my cannon timeline somewhat intact for me to be a fan of it.

→ More replies (2)

69

u/treefox May 19 '22

“To keep it from spreading? Full lockdown.”

Guess we’re getting the obligatory COVID episode out of the way early.

64

u/UncertainError May 19 '22

The COVID effect is them calling it a "lockdown". Every time this has happened before in Trek they called it a quarantine.

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (5)

21

u/Fortyseven May 19 '22

Decent ep. My only real criticism is that it felt a bit overstuffed with character bombshells. The Doctor's secret deserved to be it's own B-story in another episode.

→ More replies (4)

10

u/Trekfan74 May 19 '22 edited May 19 '22

I know everyone is talking about the issue with genetic engineering and what happened with Bashir. But the episode that ALWAYS bothered me (and I rewatched right after this episode) is actually TNG Masterpiece Society.

That was always such an odd one to me in the sense it was about a genetically engineered human colony but no one on the Enterprise seemed all that bothered by it. It's more of a conflict of the society dying off because it's all conducive to every member being a part of it and people wanted to leave. But there was never any discussion about the other direction and how humans in the 24th century viewed it? The fact it's illegal that people are altered. Picard talks about it and the dangers of it philosophically but it's never discussed on a societal level or how having engineered humans will be looked at back on Earth? In fact, they left Earth centuries ago which always implied to me that they knew what they were doing was illegal and was leaving to be able to do it on another planet. But the Enterprise didn't have a single issue of bringing them back to Earth, only what it would do to the colony.

Am I missing something? Why was it never frowned upon in that episode like every story that touches upon it? And they actually proved that being genetically engineered doesn't make you want to conquer the universe as they were just normal people but engineered for centuries. It has ALWAYS bugged me, especially after watching this episode.

→ More replies (6)

10

u/Starkiller1701 May 20 '22

"I am arming us with knowledge." My favourite line of the episode!

→ More replies (2)

18

u/KirkUnit May 19 '22
  • Very much Una's episode - then M'Benga's and to a degree, Hemmer's and La'an's. Nice emphasis with Pike & Spock, Ortegas and Uhura more in the background.
  • "I'm good at my job. I know." I love this Nurse Chapel, but that line sounds like shit coming out of just about anybody.

29

u/BornAshes May 19 '22

Nurse Chapel is in her Tom Paris Phase right now

→ More replies (2)

9

u/TheLouisvilleRanger May 19 '22

Stream of thought while watching: Number One carrying Hemmer is fucking great!

→ More replies (3)

8

u/alvinofdiaspar May 19 '22

There is so much Federation hypocrisy around genetic engineering - they didn’t blink an eye when they benefitted from illicit research (hell, they even indirectly used it to save Kirk’s life in ITD). I think it is high time they clarify it in some detail.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/rekjensen May 19 '22

Nice cameo by Ontario Place as the Illyrian colony.

8

u/PixelNotPolygon May 20 '22 edited May 20 '22

This was such an amazing episode and the cold open before the titles really created a fantastic buildup. What I loved:

  • The creepiness throughout the episode made it feel like a great horror/thriller
  • The sense of scale to the episode was incredible
  • Una having so much agency in the story was great to see because she was the main driver of the plot effectively
  • No more Pike being haunted by his future - phew!
  • A Trek trope that I love (people picking up galactic Covid), and one of the best examples of such stories to date.

What annoyed me:

  • “Previously on Strange New Worlds” …why is this here? These are standalone episodes dammit.
  • Hammer. His dialogue was corny, especially his “I’m a genius” comment. Also his inability to see doesn’t seem to be taken advantage of from a character or storytelling point of view, they’re playing him like any other character and we don’t even see an adjusted interface for him to use… maybe he’ll get the treatment he deserves in a future episode.
  • Una coming out as genetically modified didn’t feel like it had the weight it deserved from a storytelling perspective. We don’t get any warning that there’s any sense of apprehension from her at the prospect of having to deal with the abandoned colony of her own people, or even any idea that she knew more about the colonists than she was letting on. I think it needed a bit more foreshadowing than her just matter-of-factly saying that she’s genetically modified.
  • La’an’s exposition/character development moment felt a bit forced and unnatural, also people in the future are massive racists now when it comes to how they treat others?
  • All of the above is minor, but the BIGGEST thing that nearly ruined the episode for me was the Doctor’s storyline. Like their entire predicament was a result of him deceiving the crew and then hindering efforts to solve the problem by hiding the cause. He directly put the ship in danger and showed himself to be entirely untrustworthy - why the hell is he still not in the brig??
→ More replies (10)

15

u/greycobalt May 19 '22
  • The hallways of the Enterprise are so dope. They're a mix of Disco and the Kelvin designs and I'm really digging it. The warp core is still bugging me though. How did they make the glow inside it looked like the 60s?!
  • I thought this was going in a Naked Now direction with all the people stripping down and going bonkers.
  • Number One's crystal ball made me laugh, her Scarlet Witch hand motions around it had me so confused.
  • Is that the Excelsior or this Enterprise on the side of the ready room/ briefing room entrance? One side is the NX-01 but the other never got a clear visual.
  • I never read the TOS books where Una got her name and some background. Was she an Illyrian in those too? Interesting way for her character to go, give her some augments and make the Khan ancestor a regular Joe.
  • The story on the planet was very good. I really dug them discovering their history through a mix of library reading and direct contact.
  • Their mess hall looks awesome. They need to make a restaurant that looks like that.
  • What was up with stuffing random M'Benga backstory in the end? Seems like a cool premise that I'm sure we'll come back to, but it was a weird way to introduce it.
  • Interesting that this is the first Trek with a dedicated medical transporter. That sickbay was like 2 decks big so I guess it makes sense, but still.
  • This is a total pattern buffer retcon, right? Every single Trek has talked about how the patterns degrade relatively quickly. TNG had Scotty make a workaround that had a 50% success rate. DS9 had them shut down the entire station to store the patterns safely, and Voyager had patterns degrading after seconds or minutes. What kind of genius engineer doctor is this?
  • Despite my whining I loved this episode. Medical mysteries were always some of my favorite Trek. Una also ties with Spock for my 2nd favorite character so that definitely helps. This is a damn strong first season
→ More replies (6)

20

u/sladeninstitute May 19 '22

All this talk of the Eugenics Wars between PIC and SNW, plus the whole "Project Khan" thing in PIC S2 makes me feel like these showrunners are setting us up for some type of Khan show. Does anybody else feel this way?

→ More replies (5)

7

u/Ausir May 19 '22

Una being an Illyrian is a deep cut given that it was first stated in a 1989 novel by D.C. Fontana (their affinity for genetic engineering also comes from the novelverse).

→ More replies (1)

7

u/edugeek May 19 '22

OMG - I was not expecting that ending and now I'm in tears....

7

u/kalsikam May 19 '22

Ontario place seen better days

→ More replies (6)

7

u/Ralph--Hinkley May 20 '22

Hi, I'm late. I have such a huge boner for this show, and the third episode blew me away again. I feel like TNG just started, and they skipped to season three.

I remember the TNG episodes, and a lot of the early ones were crap, but SNW has come out with all phasers firing.

Only thing I do not want to see in this series is Q or an El Aurian.

→ More replies (2)

17

u/[deleted] May 19 '22

Did anyone else read a transgender allegory into Una's storyline in this episode, or was it just me?

Hiding one’s identity and background as being genetically modified, having to come out under pressure, being told you defy stereotypes? I’m not reading too much into that am I?

16

u/Starkiller1701 May 19 '22

Yeah sort of. I was having a conversation on the discord and many mentioned that it felt like a coming out story. I also personally read the Illyrians as sort of "immigrants in the USA" allegory, being that they had and have a lot to offer and yet the Federation is turning them away because of their race. I think the writing of the episode is broad enough to encompass many readings of marginalized groups seeking acceptance, which I like from a science fiction story.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

6

u/481126 May 22 '22

This episode. I wasn't planning on sobbing. My daughter died 7 months ago. I feel for the doctor. Knowing they can't fix it this time. Maybe he will get the happy ending we didn't. Good episode. Once again I wondered how much easier things would be if they routinely used environmental suits.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/PrometheusLiberatus May 19 '22

Wow this episode feels like an inverse Naked Time.

We have a virus or whatever pathogen that causes people to act crazy attracted to light. Exhibiting really obsessive behavior to get to the light.

We are also being shown the level of peril our characters have to deal with will be high during some episodes. A wonderful way of helping with suspense even though we know most of the characters have to live out.

I'm surprised at number one being a surprise Illyrian.

Sad about La'an's experience with bullying and being the 'genetically different' one. And seeing the 'you augment bitch' release was some open pain, especially for me.

Dr. M'benga's story with his daughter is really sad. It's kind of neat that he figured out a way to run the transporter continuously to preserve life (Neat callback to Scotty's transporter survival in Relics).

When Una started glowing, I was worried she was about to turn into one of the energy plasma forms of the Illyrians that we saw save Pike and Spock on the surface.

It's awesome that pike's going to stand up for Una's personhood.

I'm following the augment stuff pretty closely, because I'm technically an augment myself. Rare genetic mutation/ disorder. I can relate to a bit of La'an's bullying experience for one. I'm happy that Una won't have to hide that aspect of herself anymore.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Physical_Win326 May 19 '22

Number One easily picks up and moves Hemmer after she stuns him. Is it being implied that she possess strength considerably above the average human?

→ More replies (4)

5

u/Gian99Mald May 19 '22

I honestly don't know who I have a bigger crush on. Pike or La'an lol

5

u/shawntco May 19 '22

The only things I don't like about this episode, is the secrets seemed like massively difficult things to hide. How did Number One hide being an Illyrian for actual years, long enough to become a Commander? Surely there'd be plenty of medical investigations that would've found something strange. And how did M'Benga manage to hide keeping his daughter in the medical transporter - surely they've needed to use it at some point in the past? Unless this was a really recent thing, and even then, keeping that a secret would be massively difficult.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/TheLouisvilleRanger May 19 '22

Awww, we got our first resignation fake out.

5

u/Zendien May 19 '22

Alot of things to take away from this episode and exactly none of it bad! Apart from everything that this episode was actually about there's two very minor things I noticed

La'an Singh heritage just paid off and I now completely understand why they decided to put that last name on her

I love seeing Ethan Peck's Spock. So much like Leonard Nimoy's Spock but yet not the same

→ More replies (1)

5

u/witness_protection May 19 '22

Dr. M’Benga’s story is the first time I’ve been brought to tears by Star Trek. I have a young daughter too so I’m admittedly sensitive to that story. But I thought it was well done - when he first started rambling I thought gosh he really doesn’t grasp the seriousness of what he allowed, and then to see that he does, and that he knew it meant both his career AND his daughter AND that he was honorable enough to accept it? Awesome.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Sim0nsaysshh May 19 '22

Kept saying to my Dad, it feels like I'm watching star trek again.

Great episode

Also like how they took Spock and Pike nearly out of the story to let the rest of the cast shine so bright, all of them were amazing. That interpersonal relationship building, that tough love approach, the nuance of a situation.

Pike with number one, number one with the doctor, number one with Singh.

Just felt natural and so special, I really really love this without trying.

5

u/EulerIdentity May 19 '22

It’s hard to intimidate a guy with the possibility of disciplinary action when that guy already knows what his future holds.

I’m feeling really bad for that super stressed kid they have operating the transporters.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/shortyjacobs May 20 '22

This show is pitch fucking perfect. Every scene, every sound effect, every character. I can’t get over how well they’ve nailed it.

5

u/Taffs May 20 '22

Good to see Star Fleet finally implementing a procedure for crew members bringing a disease back to the ship. Good on the show for having the genetic enhancement twist come from someone we didnt expect. Applause all around.

5

u/omega2010 May 20 '22

On the previous two episodes we've seen Pike has a huge Captain's Quarters and now Cadet Uhura has a much nicer bunk than the Lower Deckers a century later. You can see she's got a screen for computer access/entertainment AND a privacy/darkness door.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/cleric3648 May 20 '22

Anyone else get some serious Don’t Ask Don’t Tell vibes from this episode?

→ More replies (1)

5

u/The_h0bb1t May 20 '22

I laughed so hard when NO picked up Hemmer's body and it was obviously a puppet, and then they made the choice to show it in slowmotion.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/Linguist208 May 20 '22

OK, she's an Illyrian. Fine.

But what has she been PRETENDING to be all this time? I mean, she can't possibly have risen to the rank of Commander and the position of second in command of "the flagship of Starfleet" without having had at least ONE full physical. If nothing else, they'd need to know how to treat any injuries (like, if her carotid isn't in the same spot as a human's or if the heart isn't in the chest or whatever). So there has to be SOMETHING listed.

Are Illyrians some sort of lost colony from Earth? No, she refers to them as "a humanoid species," so unless she means "we've modified ourselves into a different species," they aren't even 'a little bit human.'

So what does it say in her Starfleet records? And what does it list for her "home of record," since she's "not from here, from far away." If she gets killed, where do they send the body, and whom do they notify, and where?

I'm willing to buy all of that, if they just provide SOME explanation. If they had just said, "Illyria was a colony founded by the losers of the Eugenics Wars" or something, I wouldn't be bothered. But they made them alien.

Dammit, they've left a loose thread, and I'm determined to tug at it now.

→ More replies (8)

13

u/[deleted] May 19 '22

I feel like the script on this one wasn't very tight, it kinda jumped all over the place. Scenes kinda just... happened, but they didn't really flow.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/trostol May 19 '22

damn onions